Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

The Hellenistic & Roman World

300 BC – 300 AD

Yohanan ben Zakkai of Yavneh fl. c. 30 – c. 80 AD

(●) The Pharisee sage who, by the famous story, escaped besieged Jerusalem in a coffin and rebuilt Judaism around Torah, prayer and kindness once the temple was gone. + Imagine waking one morning to find that the one building your whole religion was organized around has been burned to the ground, and that it will never be rebuilt. That is what happened to the Jewish people in the summer of AD 70, when the Roman army took Jerusalem and the temple went up in flames. The sacrifices stopped. The priesthood lost its work. The center of Israel’s worship for a thousand years was a ruin. Yohanan ben Zakkai is the man Jewish memory credits with seeing his people through that morning. He was a Pharisee, a member of the lay movement within Judaism that held the written Law of Moses together with an oral tradition of how to keep it. He was also a rabbi, a teacher of that Law, and the rabbis who came after him remembered him as the one who carried their tradition out of the dying city and planted it again in the coastal town of Yavneh (Jamnia, in Greek and Latin). Almost everything known about him comes from their writings: the Mishnah (the first written collection of Jewish oral law, finished around AD 200), the Tosefta (a companion collection), the Talmud (the vast commentary on the Mishnah), and the midrash (rabbinic commentary on Scripture). They were written down generations after his death, and they mix memory with legend, so each story is marked as one or the other wherever the difference can be told. Christians have two good reasons to know him. He is the clearest living picture we have of the Pharisees of the Gospels, the men Jesus ate with, argued with and warned; and the Judaism he rebuilt at Yavneh is the Judaism the church has been talking with ever since. His dates are a convention. No source gives the year he was born or the year he died. His teaching career is worked out from a tradition that he led Israel for forty years and from the fact that he outlived the temple by a few years; on that reckoning he was active from roughly AD 30 to about AD 80. Every date in his life is an estimate, and each is marked as one.

(●) Early 1st century AD: By his own people’s reckoning he came to the Law late, after a first career in trade, and sat at the feet of Hillel. + The rabbis liked to tell great lives in three equal parts, the way Moses’ life falls into forty years in Egypt, forty in Midian and forty in the wilderness. They told Yohanan’s the same way: forty years in business, forty years learning, forty years teaching, a hundred and twenty in all (Sifre on Deuteronomy 357; Babylonian Talmud, Rosh Hashanah 31b and Sanhedrin 41a). The pattern is a tribute rather than a birth certificate, since the same three forties are given to Hillel and to Akiva, and no one should build a chronology on it. What it does preserve is a memory worth keeping: that he did not start out as a scholar, and that he came to study as a grown man. His teacher, the rabbis agreed, was Hillel, the gentle Babylonian sage who had led the Pharisees a generation earlier. The Mishnah says Yohanan "received" the tradition from Hillel and Shammai, Hillel’s stricter rival (Avot 2:8), and the Talmud tells of Hillel’s eighty disciples, the greatest of them Jonathan ben Uzziel and the least of them Yohanan ben Zakkai (Sukkah 28a). The least, the story goes on, still knew everything: Scripture, the oral law, the fine points of interpretation, even the speech of palm trees and angels. A later tradition says that Hillel, on his sickbed, called the least of his pupils "the father of wisdom" and "the father of coming generations" (Jerusalem Talmud, Nedarim 5:6).

(●) c. AD 20s–40s: He taught for eighteen years in the Galilean village of Arav, and found few who wanted to learn. + Before he was famous, Yohanan lived in Arav, a village in the hills of lower Galilee, not far from Nazareth. The Mishnah preserves exactly two questions that were brought to him there, both about the Sabbath: a man who had covered a scorpion with a dish so it would not sting, and a man who had smeared wax over a hole in a jar. Both times his answer was the same cautious sentence: he was afraid the man had made himself liable for a sin offering, the sacrifice the Law required for an unintentional sin (Shabbat 16:7; 22:3). Two questions in eighteen years is not much of a congregation, and the Jerusalem Talmud draws the conclusion. It says he sat in Arav eighteen years and only those two cases came before him, and that at the end he cried out: "O Galilee, Galilee, thou hatest the Torah; hence wilt thou fall into the hands of robbers!" (Jerusalem Talmud, Shabbat 16:8, as the Jewish Encyclopedia of 1906 renders it). Torah is the Hebrew word for the Law of Moses, and more broadly for all of God’s teaching. On the conventional reckoning these were roughly the same decades in which a carpenter’s son from Nazareth was teaching in the synagogues of the same hills. Neither record mentions the other, and nothing should be made of the silence. But it is worth picturing the two of them a few hours’ walk apart.

(●) c. AD 40s–60s: In Jerusalem he became the leading Pharisee teacher, sparring with the Sadducees in the shadow of the temple. + In Jerusalem his school became famous. One tradition says he sat in the shadow of the temple and taught all day long (Pesachim 26a). Another remembers him as the man who never spoke an idle word, never walked four cubits (about six feet) without thinking about the Law, was always the first into the house of study and the last to leave it (Sukkah 28a). The Pharisees’ great rivals were the Sadducees, the party of the leading priestly families, who accepted the written Law but rejected the Pharisees’ oral tradition and denied the resurrection of the dead. The book of Acts shows Paul splitting a council down the middle on exactly that question (Acts 23:6–8). Yohanan spent much of his Jerusalem career arguing with them, and the Mishnah records one of those exchanges with something like a grin. It helps to know a strange-sounding rule first. The Pharisees taught that the holy Scriptures "make the hands unclean": anyone who handled a sacred scroll had to wash his hands afterward. The rule sounds backwards, but it worked like a fence: a man who knew that touching a scroll would cost him a washing would not pick one up idly or leave it lying about, and the point of the rule was exactly that, to keep people from handling a scroll carelessly. To the Sadducees it looked absurd. Why should the holy books make a man unclean, they mocked, while the books of Homer do not? Yohanan answered with a joke. By that logic, he said, they should also complain that the bones of a donkey are clean and the bones of a high priest unclean. The Sadducees replied that bones are counted unclean because people love them, so that no one turns his parents’ bones into spoons. And he turned their answer back on them: so it is with the Scriptures, because the more precious a thing is, the more protection the law throws around it (Yadayim 4:6). The Tosefta adds that he once stopped a Sadducean high priest from burning the red heifer, the cow whose ashes were used to purify people who had touched a corpse (Numbers 19), in the Sadducean way, for the two parties disagreed over how pure the priest had to be before he performed the rite (Tosefta Parah 3:8). He also brought an ancient rite to an end. The Law prescribed a test of "bitter water" for a wife her husband suspected of adultery (Numbers 5:11–31). When adulterers multiplied, the Mishnah says, Yohanan stopped the bitter water, judging that the rite could not be used against wives when the husbands were no better (Sotah 9:9).

(●) c. AD 68–70: When Jerusalem refused to make peace with Rome, his students, by the famous story, smuggled him out of the besieged city in a coffin. + The Jewish revolt against Rome broke out in AD 66. By the time the Romans closed in on Jerusalem, the city was held by rival bands of rebels who were as ready to kill moderates inside the walls as Romans outside them. Yohanan was one of the moderates, and the rabbis remembered him pleading with the rebel leaders to send the Romans a token of surrender and save the city and the temple. They refused. What happened next is the most famous story told about him, and it is told in more than one version (Avot de-Rabbi Natan, version A, chapter 4; Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 56a–b; Lamentations Rabbah 1:5). In what is probably the oldest, he sent for two of his students, Eliezer and Joshua, and told them to make him a coffin. They carried him to the city gate at sunset, one at each end, and told the guards they were carrying a corpse, which by law could not stay in Jerusalem overnight. Outside the walls they opened the coffin, and the old man climbed out and asked to see the Roman general Vespasian. He greeted the general as a king, saying it was Israel’s tradition that the temple would fall to a king and not a commoner, and he quoted Isaiah: "Lebanon will fall by the Majestic One" (Isaiah 10:34). That verse sounds like geography, but the rabbis often read "Lebanon" in the prophets as a name for the temple, and they took "the Majestic One" here to mean a king. Read that way, Isaiah was saying the temple would fall to a ruler, and the old man was telling a Roman general to his face that he would be one. Vespasian granted him one request. He asked for Yavneh, a town near the coast, and the freedom to teach his students there. The Talmud’s version adds two further requests, for the family of Rabban Gamaliel and for a physician to heal the aged Rabbi Zadok. (Rabban, "our master," was a higher title than rabbi, given to the heads of the sages; Yohanan himself is remembered by it.) In the story, word soon came from Rome that Vespasian had been proclaimed emperor, just as the old man had said. How much of it happened? The story has a historical kernel, but it also has a problem of dates. Vespasian left Judea in AD 69 to become emperor, and his son Titus led the final siege of AD 70, so either Yohanan escaped earlier than the story suggests or the story has folded several events into one. Its claim that Vespasian was hailed emperor soon afterward is true. And the historian Josephus, a Jewish commander in the revolt who surrendered to Vespasian in AD 67, says he made the same prediction himself (Jewish War 3.8.9). The legend may have borrowed from the historian, or the two may simply have read the same signs. Either way, the core is credible: Yohanan left the doomed city with Roman permission and settled at Yavneh, where Vespasian had already settled Jews who had come over to the Romans (Jewish War 4.8.1).

(●) AD 70: At Yavneh he heard that the temple had burned, and set about teaching Israel to live without it. + The news came to Yavneh in the late summer of AD 70. According to Avot de-Rabbi Natan, Yohanan and his students tore their clothes, wept and mourned as people mourn for the dead (version A, chapter 4). Then he went to work. The work was practical, and the Mishnah lists it piece by piece. Again and again a ruling took something that had happened only at the temple and found a way for Israel to keep doing it without one. Before the destruction, when the New Year fell on a Sabbath, the ram’s horn (the shofar) was blown only in the temple; Yohanan ruled that it should be blown wherever there was a court of sages, beginning at Yavneh (Rosh Hashanah 4:1). The palm branch of the Feast of Tabernacles had been carried for seven days only in the temple; he ruled that it be carried for seven days everywhere, "in commemoration of the Temple" (Rosh Hashanah 4:3, in Rodkinson’s translation). He settled how witnesses who had seen the new moon should be received, since the whole calendar of feasts hung on it (Rosh Hashanah 4:4). The Talmud keeps a sharp little scene from the first of those rulings. When the New Year fell on a Sabbath, the leaders of a rival scholarly family, the sons of Bathyra, wanted to debate the change first. "Let us sound it," Yohanan said, "and then we will discuss." After the horn had sounded they asked to debate, and he told them the horn had been heard in Yavneh already, and a thing done could not be undone (Babylonian Talmud, Rosh Hashanah 29b, in Rodkinson’s translation). Behind the rulings stood a larger change. The court of sages at Yavneh took up the work of the great council of Jerusalem (the Sanhedrin, the high court that had sat beside the temple), and the house of study took the place the temple had held at the center of Jewish life. The priests lost their altar; the teachers of the Law inherited Israel.

(●) c. AD 80: He died weeping before his students, unsure which road lay ahead of him, and asking for a throne to be set for Hezekiah. + At some point, while Yohanan was still alive, the leadership at Yavneh passed to Rabban Gamaliel II, the grandson of the Gamaliel who had taught Paul. Yohanan spent his last years at a nearby place called Berur Hayil, where he still headed a court. He knew grief before his own end came. He had buried a son; his students had come to comfort him then, one after another, each with a story from Scripture, until Eleazar ben Arach found the words that consoled him (Avot de-Rabbi Natan, version A, chapter 14). His own death is told with unusual honesty. When his students came in they found him weeping. They called him a lofty pillar, the light of the world, a strong hammer, and asked why he cried. He answered that he was not going before a human king, whose anger lasts only for this world and who can be talked round or bribed, but before the King of kings, whose anger reaches into the world to come. Two roads lay before him, one to paradise and one to Gehenna (the place of punishment), and he did not know which he would be led down (Avot de-Rabbi Natan, version A, chapter 25; Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 28b). His last words were an instruction to "clean the house of all defilement, and put in a chair for Hezekiah, King of Judah" (Avot de-Rabbi Natan, version A, chapter 25, in Rodkinson’s translation); the Talmud’s telling adds that Hezekiah is on his way (Berakhot 28b). Hezekiah was the faithful king of Judah in Isaiah’s day, and the old man seems to have been thinking, at the end, of the Messiah, the anointed king God had promised to send. The Mishnah’s epitaph is short: when Rabban Yohanan ben Zakkai died, the splendor of wisdom ceased (Sotah 9:15). The tomb shown to pilgrims at Tiberias is a medieval tradition.

What He Taught

(T1) Studying God’s Law is what a person was made for, so learning it is nothing to boast about. + Think of a bird that has learned to fly and wants a medal for it. Flying is simply what a bird is for. Yohanan thought about Torah study the same way. A scholar who had mastered a great deal of the Law had done nothing extraordinary; he had only become what a human being was created to be. That is the saying the Mishnah chose to remember him by, set in Avot (often called Pirke Avot, "Chapters of the Fathers"), a small collection of the sayings of the sages arranged as an unbroken chain of teachers from Moses to the rabbis. Yohanan stands at the hinge of that chain: he received from Hillel and Shammai, and handed on to the students who would shape the Mishnah. The saying carries two ideas at once. It is the highest possible view of study, as the purpose of human life; and it is a warning against the pride that study breeds in those who are good at it. Christian readers will recognize the warning. Jesus aimed some of his hardest words at learned men who loved the best seats and the respectful greetings in the marketplace (Matthew 23:6–7), and Paul warned that knowledge puffs up while love builds up (1 Corinthians 8:1). Yohanan, a Pharisee, was saying something very like it to Pharisees.

(Q) "If thou hast learned much, do not boast of it, for it is for that that thou wast created." + Source: Mishnah, Avot 2:8 (Rodkinson translation, New Edition of the Babylonian Talmud, Tract Aboth, p. 61). The Mishnah introduces it as the saying "he was wont to say," his motto, immediately after recording that he received the tradition from Hillel and Shammai (T1).

(T2) The best road through life is a good heart, because every other virtue grows from it. + Every good teacher has a favorite way of making students think for themselves. Yohanan’s was to send them out with a question. The Mishnah names his five chief disciples and gives his verdict on each: Eliezer ben Hyrcanus was "a plastered cistern, which loseth not a drop," because he never forgot a thing he was taught; Joshua ben Hananiah, "happy is she that bare him"; Jose the priest was pious; Simeon ben Nathanael feared sin; and Eleazar ben Arach was "a welling spring," always bringing up something new (Avot 2:8). Then he sent them out: go and see which is the good way a man should hold to. They came back with five answers. A generous eye, said one. A good friend, said the second. A good neighbor, said the third. Foresight, the ability to see what an action will lead to, said the fourth. A good heart, said Eleazar. And the teacher chose Eleazar’s answer, because it included all the others. He sent them out a second time, to find the evil way a man should shun, and again chose Eleazar’s answer: an evil heart (Avot 2:9). The point is the one Moses and the prophets made long before: what matters is not a list of good habits but the source they come from. A generous eye, a loyal friendship and a neighborly life all flow out of a heart that is right. Christians hear in it the voice of Proverbs, "Keep your heart with all vigilance, for from it flow the springs of life" (Proverbs 4:23), and of Jesus, who said that what defiles a person comes from within, out of the heart (Mark 7:21–23).

(Q) "Go out and find what is the best thing to cultivate." ... "I consider R. Elazar b. Arach’s judgment the best, for in his all of yours are included." + Source: Mishnah, Avot 2:9 (Rodkinson translation, Tract Aboth, pp. 61–62). Rodkinson spells the disciple’s name Elazar b. Arach, the "b." standing for ben, "son of." The omitted middle is the list of the five students’ answers, ending with Eleazar’s "a good heart" (T2).

(T3) With the altar gone, God still forgives, and deeds of loving-kindness carry the weight the sacrifices once carried. + Avot de-Rabbi Natan, an old commentary on Avot that expands its sayings with stories, tells of a walk. Yohanan was leaving Jerusalem with his student Joshua, and they passed the ruins of the temple. Joshua cried out in grief: woe to us, for this place where Israel’s sins were atoned for is destroyed. Atonement means the covering or wiping away of sin, so that the sinner is reconciled to God, and for Israel the great means of atonement had been the sacrifices at the temple, above all on the Day of Atonement. Joshua’s fear was simple and terrible: if the altar is gone, how can sin be forgiven? Yohanan told him not to grieve. Israel had another atonement as effective as the sacrifices, he said, and it was deeds of loving-kindness. His proof text was Hosea 6:6, which the ESV renders: "For I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice, the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings." The Hebrew word behind "steadfast love" is hesed: covenant loyalty, mercy, kindness that goes beyond what is owed. He pointed to Daniel, who lived in Babylon far from any altar and still served God by rejoicing with people in their joy, weeping with them in their sorrow, helping poor brides, burying the dead, giving to the needy and praying three times a day. It is hard to overstate what that answer did. It gave a grieving people a way to go on being faithful when the center of their worship had been taken from them. And Christians notice the verse he reached for. Jesus quoted the same line from Hosea twice, against critics who cared more for ritual than for mercy: "I desire mercy, and not sacrifice" (Matthew 9:13; 12:7). The two men agreed that God has always wanted the heart behind the offering. Where they parted is the question of what, in the end, takes away sin, and that is the first place the gospel parts company with him.

(Q) "My son, do not grieve over it. We have other means of atonement as effective ... bestowal of favors, as it is written [Hosea, vi. 6]: 'For kindness I desired, and not sacrifice.'" + Source: Avot de-Rabbi Natan, version A, chapter 4 (Rodkinson translation, Tract Aboth, p. 24). The ellipsis stands for the word "namely." "Bestowal of favors" is Rodkinson’s rendering of the Hebrew phrase usually translated "deeds of loving-kindness." Yohanan is answering Joshua ben Hananiah among the temple ruins (T3). Rodkinson’s rendering of Hosea is his own, made from the Hebrew; the ESV reads "steadfast love" where he reads "kindness."

(T4) God’s commandments are the decrees of a King, to be obeyed even where he has not given the reason. + A child who asks why she has to hold her father’s hand to cross the road will usually get a reason. But sometimes the answer is "because I said so," and a child who trusts her father will take his hand anyway. Yohanan thought some of God’s laws were like that. The test case was the red heifer of Numbers 19: a perfect red cow was burned, and its ashes, mixed with water, purified anyone who had touched a dead body. A Gentile once challenged Yohanan that it looked like sorcery. The midrash says he answered the man in his own terms: had he never seen a person possessed by an evil spirit treated with smoke from burning roots until the spirit fled? Purification works like that, Yohanan said, quoting the prophet’s promise that God would remove "the spirit of uncleanness" from the land (Zechariah 13:2). The man went away satisfied. But his students were not, and pressed him for the real answer. He told them that a dead body does not, in itself, make anyone unclean, and water does not, in itself, make anyone clean. The red heifer is a decree of the Holy One, and it is not for us to question it (Pesikta de-Rav Kahana 4:7). There is something bracing in that answer. Yohanan refused to pretend that he understood everything in the Law, and he refused to make obedience wait until he did. Christians know the same posture from Abraham, who set out "not knowing where he was going" (Hebrews 11:8). And they believe the red heifer did have a meaning, one the letter to the Hebrews would draw out (Hebrews 9:13–14).

(Q) "By your lives, death does not make impure, nor water clean; but it is a decree of the All Holy, whose reasons we must not question." + Source: Pesikta de-Rav Kahana 4:7 (Buber edition, 40a–b), as rendered by Solomon Schechter and Wilhelm Bacher in the Jewish Encyclopedia (1906), article "Johanan b. Zakkai." The article’s bracketed gloss on "it" (the law concerning the red heifer) is left out of the title row. Yohanan is speaking to his students after a Gentile has gone away content with a simpler answer (T4).

(Q) "There are two ways before me: one leads to the garden of Eden and the other to Gehenna, and I do not know whether I will be condemned to Gehenna, or I will enter the Garden of Eden." + Source: Avot de-Rabbi Natan, version A, chapter 25 (Rodkinson translation, Tract Aboth, p. 90); the same deathbed scene is told in the Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 28b. His students have just called him the light of the world and asked why he weeps. The greatest teacher of his generation, at the end of a life given to God’s Law, did not know whether he would be saved, and he said so.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) Christian scholars have read him as a living picture of the Pharisees the Gospels describe. + The Gospels mention the Pharisees again and again, but they never stop to explain them, because their first readers already knew who they were. For later readers Yohanan helps fill the gap. Here is a Pharisee of exactly Jesus’ generation: a student of Hillel, a teacher who sat in the shadow of the temple, a man arguing with Sadducees about purity and Scripture, careful to the point of worry about the Sabbath (Shabbat 16:7), and devoted with his whole life to the Law. When Jesus says that the scribes and the Pharisees "sit on Moses’ seat" (Matthew 23:2), Yohanan is the kind of man he means, at his best. The German New Testament scholar Adolf Schlatter, one of the great evangelical scholars of his day, saw this clearly enough to write a book about him in 1899, and called it Jochanan ben Zakkai, der Zeitgenosse der Apostel: "Yohanan ben Zakkai, the contemporary of the apostles." Read beside the Gospels, the rabbinic memories of him show what was admirable in the Pharisees (their seriousness about God, their love of the Law, their humility before it, T1) as well as why Jesus’ quarrels with them were quarrels within the family, over how Israel should be faithful to the God they both served.

(†) His rebuke to the temple doors sits beside Jesus’ own warning that the temple would fall. + The Talmud records a strange set of omens. To follow them, picture the Day of Atonement, the one day a year when the high priest made atonement for the whole nation. Two goats were brought before him and lots were drawn: one goat for the Lord, to be sacrificed, and one to be sent away into the wilderness carrying the people’s sins (Leviticus 16:7–10, 21–22). Tradition also said that a crimson thread tied at the temple door turned white that day, as a sign that Israel’s sins were forgiven. Forty years before the temple was destroyed, the Talmud says, things began to go wrong. The lot for the Lord never came up in the high priest’s right hand. The crimson thread no longer turned white. The westernmost lamp of the great lampstand would not stay lit. And the doors of the sanctuary swung open by themselves. Then it adds Yohanan’s rebuke to the temple itself (Yoma 39b). The prophecy he quotes comes from Zechariah, and "Lebanon" once again stands for the temple: "Open your doors, O Lebanon, that the fire may devour your cedars!" (Zechariah 11:1). Christian readers have long noticed two things. The first is the date: forty years before AD 70 is about AD 30, the years in which Jesus was crucified. The second is the prophecy: Jesus, standing in the same temple courts, told his disciples that not one stone would be left upon another (Matthew 24:2), and wept over a city that "did not know the time of your visitation" (Luke 19:44). The nineteenth-century scholar Alfred Edersheim, a Hebrew Christian (a Jew by birth who came to faith in Jesus), drew attention to the forty-year tradition in his study of the temple’s services, noting in his chapter on the Day of Atonement that the scarlet thread stopped turning white for forty years before the destruction. The Talmud’s round "forty years" should not be pressed for an exact year, and the omens are told, not proved. But it is a striking thing to find the rabbis themselves remembering that the temple’s signs of forgiveness failed in the very generation of the cross.

(Q) "Temple, Temple, why alarmest thou us? We know that thou art destined to be destroyed. For of thee hath prophesied Zechariah ben Iddo [Zech. xi. 1]: 'Open thy doors, O Lebanon, and the fire shall eat thy cedars.'" + Source: Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 39b (Rodkinson translation, New Edition of the Babylonian Talmud, Tract Yomah, p. 60); a parallel appears in the Jerusalem Talmud, Yoma 6:3. The rebuke closes the Talmud’s list of omens from the last forty years of the temple. Rodkinson’s rendering of Zechariah is his own, made from the Hebrew, and its wording differs from the ESV’s (Zechariah 11:1).

(†) The Judaism he rebuilt at Yavneh is the Judaism the church has been talking with ever since. + Before AD 70 there were many ways of being Jewish: priests and Sadducees, Pharisees, Essenes (a strict, separatist brotherhood, some of whom lived apart in the desert), rebels, and the followers of Jesus, who still worshiped in the temple (Acts 2:46; 21:26). After AD 70, two of those ways went on. The rabbis, led first by Yohanan and his students, rebuilt Judaism around the study of the Law, prayer and deeds of kindness (T3). The church read the same catastrophe as the fulfillment of Jesus’ warning, and believed the sacrifices had already found their end in the one sacrifice of Christ, the high priest who "offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins" (Hebrews 10:12). That is the fork in the road. When the Christian apologist Justin Martyr sat down around AD 155 to write his long Dialogue with Trypho, an imagined (or remembered) conversation with a learned Jew about whether Jesus is the Messiah, the Judaism he argued with was already a Judaism without a temple, guided by the teachers who came after Yohanan. Christians and Jews have been reading the same Scriptures across that fork ever since, and much of what the church knows about the Jewish world of the New Testament it has learned from the rabbis who remembered him. He did not set out to oppose the gospel, and his recorded words never mention it. What he did was keep alive, through one of the worst disasters in its history, the people from whom the Messiah came.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: what takes away sin, and whether a dying man can know he is forgiven. + Christians can honor Yohanan sincerely, and they have to disagree with him plainly at three points. - Atonement. Yohanan taught that deeds of loving-kindness atone as the sacrifices did (T3). The gospel agrees that God desires mercy (Matthew 9:13) and disagrees about what takes sin away. The sacrifices were not replaced by human kindness but fulfilled in a death: the Son of Man came "to give his life as a ransom for many" (Mark 10:45), and Christ "offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins" (Hebrews 10:12). Kindness is the fruit of forgiveness, not its price. - The red heifer. Yohanan held that the red heifer was a decree without a reason we may know (T4). The letter to the Hebrews, written to Jewish believers in the same century, gives it a meaning: if the ashes of a heifer purified the body, "how much more will the blood of Christ, who through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish to God, purify our conscience from dead works to serve the living God" (Hebrews 9:13–14). The rite pointed beyond itself. - Assurance. Yohanan died not knowing which road he was on, and his honesty deserves respect: he would not pretend to a confidence he did not have. The gospel answers his tears with a promise rather than a rebuke: "I write these things to you who believe in the name of the Son of God that you may know that you have eternal life" (1 John 5:13). That confidence does not rest on a life well lived, which Yohanan’s certainly was, but on a righteousness given as a gift (Romans 3:24). The old man’s last thought was of a king who was coming. Christians believe he was right that a King was coming, and that the King had already come.

Yohanan ben Zakkai wrote nothing that survives, and no book was ever attributed to him. Everything known about him comes from the rabbinic literature compiled between about AD 200 and AD 600, where his rulings, sayings and stories are scattered across dozens of passages. Josephus, the one Jewish historian of his own day whose work survives, never mentions him. What follows gathers the principal passages instead, each annotated the way a book would be. The Mishnah’s reports are the earliest and soberest; the stories in the Talmud and the midrash grew in the telling and are marked as later. The Mishnah (compiled c. AD 200): - Avot 2:8–9: His place in the chain of tradition from Hillel and Shammai, his motto on learning without boasting, his verdicts on his five disciples, and the two questions about the good way and the evil way (T1, T2). - Shabbat 16:7 and 22:3: The two Sabbath questions brought to him at Arav, both answered with his cautious "I fear for him a sin offering." - Sotah 9:9: He ended the ordeal of the bitter water when adulterers multiplied. - Sotah 9:15: The epitaph: when he died, the splendor of wisdom ceased. - Sotah 5:5: His student Joshua reports his teaching that Job served God from fear rather than love. - Rosh Hashanah 4:1, 4:3–4: The rulings after the destruction: the shofar blown at Yavneh on a Sabbath New Year, the palm branch carried seven days everywhere in memory of the temple, and the reception of witnesses to the new moon. - Yadayim 4:6: His joke against the Sadducees about the bones of a donkey and the bones of the high priest. - Sanhedrin 5:2: A cross-examination of witnesses down to the stems of the figs, remembered as a model of careful judging. The Mishnah names only "Ben Zakkai," and the Talmud (Sanhedrin 41a) debates whether he is meant. - Eduyot 8:7: Rabbi Joshua hands on a tradition from him, received as going back to Moses at Sinai, that Elijah will come not to declare families clean or unclean but to bring near those pushed away by force and put away those brought near by force. - Kelim 17:16: His lament, woe to me if I speak of them and woe to me if I do not, over the purity rules for tools a cheat could use; the Talmud explains that he feared teaching swindlers their tricks, or letting them think the sages ignorant of them (Bava Batra 89b). The Tosefta (compiled c. AD 250): - Parah 3:8: He stops a Sadducean high priest from burning the red heifer the Sadducean way. - Bava Kamma 7:3–7: Five of his symbolic interpretations of the Law, among them why the ear of a slave who refuses freedom is pierced (Exodus 21:6) and why no iron tool may touch the stones of the altar (Exodus 20:25). Avot de-Rabbi Natan (an expanded commentary on Avot, in two versions, compiled perhaps AD 300–700): - Version A, chapter 4: The walk among the temple ruins and the saying on loving-kindness (T3), the plea to the rebels, the escape in the coffin, the meeting with Vespasian, and the mourning at Yavneh. Probably the oldest full telling of the escape. - Version A, chapter 14: His verdicts on his disciples and the visit of comfort after his son’s death. - Version A, chapter 25: The deathbed: the two roads, and the throne for Hezekiah (the closing quotation of What He Taught). The Babylonian Talmud (compiled c. AD 500–600): - Gittin 56a–b: The fullest and latest version of the escape, with his nephew Abba Sikra, a rebel leader, helping smuggle him out, and the three requests: Yavneh and its sages, the family of Gamaliel, and a physician for Rabbi Zadok. - Berakhot 28b: The deathbed scene, with his blessing that his students might fear heaven as much as they fear flesh and blood. - Berakhot 34b: His student Hanina ben Dosa prays his sick son back to health when his own prayers could not; asked by his wife whether Hanina is greater, he answers that Hanina is like a servant who goes in and out before the king, while he is like a nobleman who must wait. - Yoma 39b: The omens of the temple’s last forty years and his rebuke to the temple doors. - Sukkah 28a: Hillel’s eighty disciples, Yohanan the least of them, and the description of his tireless devotion to study. - Rosh Hashanah 29b and 31b: The debate with the sons of Bathyra over the shofar, and the count of nine ordinances credited to him, most of them made after the destruction. - Sanhedrin 41a: The tradition of his hundred and twenty years, forty in trade, forty in study and forty in teaching, told also at Rosh Hashanah 31b. - Pesachim 26a: He taught all day in the shadow of the temple. - Bava Batra 10b, 115b–116a; Menahot 65a: His reading of Proverbs 14:34, that kindness shown by a nation atones like a sin offering, and his disputes with the Boethusians, a party close to the Sadducees. - Hagigah 14b: His study of the mystical passages of Ezekiel’s chariot with his student Eleazar ben Arach. The Jerusalem Talmud (compiled c. AD 400): - Shabbat 16:8: The eighteen years in Arav and his cry, "O Galilee, Galilee, thou hatest the Torah." - Yoma 6:3: A parallel to the rebuke to the temple doors. - Nedarim 5:6: Hillel’s sickbed tribute to the least of his pupils as "the father of wisdom." The midrash: - Lamentations Rabbah 1:5: Another telling of the escape and the meeting with Vespasian. - Pesikta de-Rav Kahana 4:7: The red heifer, the Gentile questioner, and the answer to his students (T4). - Mekhilta of Rabbi Ishmael, Bahodesh 1: After the destruction he sees a starving Jewish girl picking grains of barley from the dung of an Arab’s horse, and reads in it the curse of Deuteronomy 28. - Sifre on Deuteronomy 357: The three forties of his life, matched to those of Moses, Hillel and Akiva. Not a source for him: the "Council of Jamnia" that closed the canon of the Hebrew Bible appears in no ancient text. It was a modern scholarly hypothesis about the Yavneh academy, and it has been largely abandoned; the ancient sources show discussion at Yavneh about whether particular books (Ecclesiastes and the Song of Songs) "make the hands unclean," not a council that decided the canon. Standard English editions and studies: Herbert Danby, The Mishnah (Oxford, 1933); Judah Goldin, The Fathers According to Rabbi Nathan (Yale, 1955); Jacob Neusner, A Life of Yohanan ben Zakkai (Brill, 1962; second edition 1970) and Development of a Legend (Brill, 1970), which sorts the traditions about him by age. Michael L. Rodkinson’s New Edition of the Babylonian Talmud (1896–1903), which includes Tract Aboth with Avot de-Rabbi Natan, is in the public domain and free online, as is the Jewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906).

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief