Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
Stephen Hawking of Oxford 1942 – 2018 AD
(●) The physicist who showed that black holes glow, and who spent his public life arguing that the universe needs no Creator. For the last thirty years of his life Stephen Hawking was the most recognized scientist on earth. People who had never read a page of physics knew the picture: a man folded into a wheelchair, nearly unable to move, speaking through a computer in a flat electronic voice about the beginning of time. His book A Brief History of Time sat on more coffee tables than perhaps any science book ever written. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons that pull in opposite directions. His early mathematical work, done between 1965 and 1970 and crowned by a theorem with Roger Penrose, became one of the strongest scientific supports for the claim that the universe had a beginning, which is exactly what Genesis and the argument from a first cause both say. Yet he spent the rest of his career trying to take that beginning away, or at least to take the Beginner out of it, and in his last books he said plainly that physics leaves no room for God. The signature fact is the one everyone remembers. At twenty-one he was told he had about two years to live. He lived another fifty-five, and did nearly all of his famous work after the diagnosis.
(●) 1942 AD: Born in wartime Oxford to a family that prized learning over comfort. Stephen William Hawking was born in Oxford on 8 January 1942. His parents lived in London, but Oxford was not being bombed, and so his mother went there to have her baby in safety. He liked to point out that the date fell three hundred years, to the day, after the death of Galileo. His father, Frank, was a medical researcher who worked on tropical diseases; his mother, Isobel, had studied at Oxford at a time when few women did. The family moved to St Albans, north of London, when he was eight, and the neighbors thought them odd: they drove an old London taxi, read books at the dinner table, and kept bees in the cellar. Stephen was a middling student who took clocks and radios apart and could not always put them back together. His schoolfriends nicknamed him "Einstein," half in fun, long before anyone else had reason to. In 1959 he went up to University College, Oxford, to read physics. By his own account he found the work easy and did very little of it, coxing a rowing boat instead. He finished in 1962 on the border between a first-class and a second-class degree, and in the oral examination that decided it he told the examiners that if they gave him a first he would go to Cambridge, and if a second he would stay at Oxford. They gave him a first.
(●) 1963 AD: At twenty-one, a new Cambridge student, he was told he had about two years to live. He arrived at Cambridge in the autumn of 1962 to work on cosmology, the study of the universe as a whole, under the physicist Dennis Sciama. He had already noticed he was getting clumsy; he fell down a flight of stairs in his last year at Oxford. Early in 1963, shortly after his twenty-first birthday, the doctors gave the clumsiness a name: motor neurone disease, known in America as ALS, a disease that kills the nerves that drive the muscles while leaving the mind untouched. He was told to expect about two years. He sank, for a while, into gloom. What pulled him out, by his own telling, was two things. One was a young woman named Jane Wilde, a languages student he had met at a New Year’s party just before the diagnosis. The other was the discovery that the disease was progressing more slowly than predicted, which meant there might be time to finish a doctorate after all, and a doctorate was required if he was going to get a job, and a job was required if he was going to marry.
(●) 1965 AD: He married Jane Wilde, and with Roger Penrose proved that, if Einstein’s gravity holds, the universe began in a singularity. Stephen and Jane married in July 1965. She was a practicing Anglican, and her faith carried her through the long years in which she was wife, mother, and nurse together; he was not a believer, and the difference was there in the marriage from the start. They had three children: Robert in 1967, Lucy in 1970, and Timothy in 1979. The physics came in the same years. The mathematician Roger Penrose had just shown that a collapsing star must end in a singularity, a point where matter is crushed to infinite density and the equations of Einstein’s general relativity break down. (General relativity is Einstein’s theory of gravity: it says that heavy things bend space and time around them, the way a bowling ball sags the middle of a trampoline, and that everything else rolls along the curves.) Hawking saw that the same mathematics could be run backward in time, to an expanding universe like ours. His doctoral thesis of 1966 did that, and in 1970 he and Penrose together published the theorem that bears both their names: if general relativity is right and the universe contains about as much matter as we see, then its history began in a singularity. Time itself, on that picture, has a first moment (T1).
(●) 1974 AD: He showed that black holes give off heat, and Cambridge gave him Newton’s chair. A black hole is a region where gravity is so strong that nothing, not even light, can climb out. Everyone, Hawking included, assumed that meant a black hole could only swallow, never give back. Then in 1973 and 1974, trying to add the rules of quantum theory (the physics of the very small) to the physics of black holes, he got an answer he did not believe: black holes should glow faintly, as if they had a temperature, and very slowly lose their mass. He checked it for weeks before announcing it, in a short paper in Nature in March 1974 titled "Black hole explosions?" The glow is now called Hawking radiation (T2). Within weeks of that paper he was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society, Britain’s senior scientific academy, at thirty-two. In 1979 Cambridge made him Lucasian Professor of Mathematics, the chair Isaac Newton had held three centuries before. He held it for thirty years. By then he could no longer walk, and could write only with great difficulty. He did his mathematics in his head, holding whole equations in memory and thinking in pictures, and dictated the results to students and colleagues. One of those students, the American physicist Don Page, lived in the Hawking household from 1976 to 1979 as a research assistant and helper; Page was an evangelical Christian, and the two men argued about God at the breakfast table for years with obvious affection.
(●) 1985 AD: Pneumonia took his voice, and a computer gave him the one the world remembers. In the summer of 1985, on a visit to the CERN laboratory in Geneva, he caught pneumonia and was put on a ventilator. By Jane’s account, the doctors asked her whether to switch it off. She refused. To save his life the surgeons performed a tracheotomy, cutting an opening in the windpipe to help him breathe, and it took away what was left of his speech for good. A Californian programmer, Walt Woltosz, sent him a program that let him choose words from a screen with a hand-held switch, and a speech synthesizer turned them into sound. With it, he wrote, he could manage up to fifteen words a minute. The voice had an American accent, which amused him, and when better voices became available years later he refused to change it: by then, he said, it was his.
(●) 1988 AD: A Brief History of Time made him the most famous scientist in the world, and his marriage did not survive the fame. He wrote the book partly to pay for his care and his daughter’s schooling, and he wanted it sold in airport bookstalls. An editor warned him that every equation in a popular book halves its sales, so he kept only one, E = mc². Published in 1988, it stayed on the London Sunday Times best-seller list for 237 weeks and sold millions of copies around the world. It became a running joke as the most-bought, least-finished book of its day, and he took the joke well. Fame changed the household. In 1990 he left Jane for Elaine Mason, one of his nurses, whom he married in 1995; that marriage ended in divorce in 2006. Jane wrote of their years together in Music to Move the Stars (1999), later revised as Travelling to Infinity (2007), the book behind the 2014 film The Theory of Everything. In his later years the family drew close again. He went on working and talking for another thirty years: more books, cameo appearances on The Simpsons and Star Trek, a weightless flight on a reduced-gravity aircraft in 2007, and a long string of public bets with other physicists, some of which he cheerfully lost.
(●) 2018 AD: He died in Cambridge at seventy-six, and his ashes lie in Westminster Abbey near Newton and Darwin. Stephen Hawking died at his home in Cambridge on 14 March 2018, aged seventy-six. His funeral was held on 31 March at Great St Mary’s, the university church in Cambridge, and on 15 June his ashes were interred in Westminster Abbey, in the nave not far from the graves of Isaac Newton and Charles Darwin. One of his last scientific papers, written with the Belgian physicist Thomas Hertog, appeared a few weeks after his death, and a final book of essays, Brief Answers to the Big Questions, that October. There is a quiet irony in the setting. A man who said there is no God was laid to rest in one of the great churches of Christendom, beside Newton, who believed the ordered heavens displayed their Maker, and with the Abbey’s prayers read over him.
What He Taught
(T1) General relativity says the universe began in a singularity, though he later argued that quantum theory removes it. Imagine running a film of the expanding universe backward. The galaxies, which are now rushing apart, crowd closer together; everything grows hotter and denser. Physicists call that crowded, blazing opening stretch of history the big bang. The question is whether the film simply keeps running backward forever, or whether it comes to a first frame. The Hawking-Penrose theorem of 1970 answered: a first frame. A singularity is the name for that frame, a state of infinite density where the laws of physics as we know them stop working, a little like a road map that ends at the edge of the paper. If Einstein’s general relativity (his theory of gravity as the bending of space and time) holds all the way back, the universe has a finite past. Christians noticed at once that this was what they had always said. But Hawking himself came to doubt the conclusion, and his reason is worth understanding. General relativity is a theory of the very large, and it leaves out quantum theory, the physics of the very small. For stars and galaxies that does no harm. Near the beginning, though, everything we can see today was packed into a space smaller than an atom, and there the physics of the very small must have had its say. In the 1980s he began to argue that once quantum effects are included, the singularity may disappear (T3). He was candid about the turnaround, and even a little amused by it.
(Q) "So in the end our work became generally accepted and nowadays nearly everyone assumes that the universe started with a big bang singularity. It is perhaps ironic that, having changed my mind, I am now trying to convince other physicists that there was in fact no singularity at the beginning of the universe." Source: Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, chapter 3, "The Expanding Universe" (Bantam, 1988). Hawking is recounting how the singularity theorems won over a skeptical physics community. The sentence continues past the point quoted, promising that the singularity "can disappear once quantum effects are taken into account."
(T2) Black holes are not entirely black: they glow, lose mass, and may in the end evaporate. Think of a hot coal taken out of the fire. It glows because it is hot, and as it glows it gives its heat away. Hawking found that a black hole behaves like that coal, which nobody had expected. The reason lies in quantum theory, which says that even empty space is never perfectly still. It seethes with pairs of particles that flicker into existence and vanish again almost at once, like sparks that wink out before you can point at them. At the edge of a black hole, its event horizon (the boundary past which nothing can return), one member of a pair can fall in while the other escapes, and to an outside observer the black hole appears to be radiating. The effect is tiny for a black hole the mass of a star, far colder than the empty space around it. But it means a black hole has a temperature, and anything with a temperature eventually cools away. It also raised a puzzle that occupied him for the rest of his life. Burn a letter, and in principle the smoke, ash and heat still carry every word, scrambled but not erased; physicists had long held that nature never truly deletes a record of what happened. So if a black hole evaporates completely, what happens to the information about everything that fell in? In 1976 he argued it is destroyed. In 2004 he publicly conceded a bet that it is not, and paid off the winner, the physicist John Preskill, with an encyclopedia of baseball. Hawking radiation has never been observed directly, because the glow from real black holes is far too faint to detect. It is nevertheless the result most physicists would name first when they think of him. It is also why he was so often spoken of as a Nobel candidate, and why he never won: in practice the physics prize has gone to theoretical work only once experiment has confirmed it, and his prediction is still waiting.
(Q) "Black Holes Ain’t So Black" Source: Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, title of chapter 7 (Bantam, 1988). The chapter tells the story of the discovery in his own words, including how long he resisted his own result before announcing it. The playful title is typical of the book.
(T3) The universe may have no edge in time, and a universe with no edge leaves nothing for a Creator to do. Picture the surface of the earth. Walk south, and eventually you reach the South Pole. But the South Pole is not an edge; the surface does not stop there, it simply has no further south. Nobody asks what lies south of the South Pole. In 1983, with the American physicist James Hartle, Hawking proposed that the beginning of time might be like that. Their "no-boundary proposal" describes the earliest universe using what physicists call imaginary time. The name sounds like make-believe, but it is borrowed from mathematics, where "imaginary" numbers (the square root of minus one is the famous example) are simply a different kind of number that turns out to be useful in calculation. Measure time in those numbers, and something odd happens in the equations: time stops behaving like time and starts behaving like one more direction in space, like north or east. On that description the history of the universe is finite in the past, yet rounded off smoothly like the bottom of a globe, with no first moment and no singularity at which the laws break down. Hawking stressed that it was a proposal, not a result, and that it describes the universe in imaginary rather than ordinary time. He drew the theological conclusion himself, in the most quoted lines of A Brief History of Time. Much of the force of the old argument for God, as he understood it, was that someone had to set the universe going. Take away the starting point, and you seem to take away the need for the starter.
(Q) "So long as the universe had a beginning, we could suppose it had a creator. But if the universe is really completely self-contained, having no boundary or edge, it would have neither beginning nor end: it would simply be. What place, then, for a creator?" Source: Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, chapter 8, "The Origin and Fate of the Universe" (Bantam, 1988). The same chapter tells of a 1981 conference on cosmology at the Vatican. By Hawking’s account, Pope John Paul II told the scientists that they could study the universe’s development after the big bang but should not inquire into the big bang itself, since that was the moment of creation and the work of God; Hawking was glad the pope did not know he had just given a paper suggesting there was no such moment.
(T4) The laws of physics alone explain why there is something rather than nothing, so God is not needed, and philosophy is dead. For most of his career Hawking left the door to God slightly ajar. A Brief History of Time famously closes by saying that if we found a complete theory of physics, and understood why it is that we and the universe exist, "then we would know the mind of God." Readers took the line in very different ways, and he later said he had meant it figuratively. By The Grand Design (2010), written with the physicist and writer Leonard Mlodinow, the door was shut. The book opens by declaring that the great questions, why there is a universe and why these laws, used to belong to philosophy, but "philosophy is dead," because philosophers had not kept up with physics. It closes with the claim that the laws themselves, gravity in particular, are enough to bring a universe into being from nothing. A universe, on this view, is something like a bubble that forms spontaneously in boiling water: no one blows it. The book is also where he described his method as "model-dependent realism," the view that a scientific theory is a model that is good if it predicts well, and that it makes no sense to ask whether the model is "really" true beyond that. A subway map works the same way: it is a good map if it gets you to your stop, and nobody asks whether the tracks truly run in straight colored lines. Critics, Christian and otherwise, pointed out that a claim about what science can and cannot tell us is itself a piece of philosophy (see the parting-ways row).
(Q) "Because there is a law like gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing in the manner described in Chapter 6. Spontaneous creation is the reason there is something rather than nothing, why the universe exists, why we exist. It is not necessary to invoke God to light the blue touch paper and set the universe going." Source: Stephen Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow, The Grand Design, chapter 8, "The Grand Design," p. 180 (Bantam, 2010). The "blue touch paper" is the fuse on a British firework, and Chapter 6, "Choosing Our Universe," is where the book describes universes appearing like bubbles in boiling water. The lines were excerpted in The Times of London ahead of publication, which printed the first sentence as "a law such as gravity," and they made headlines around the world.
(T5) The mind is what the brain does, and when the brain stops there is nothing more. Hawking spent most of his life with a body that worked less every year and a mind that did not, which is the very picture many people have of a soul outlasting its body. He drew the opposite lesson. A person, for him, was a physical system, as an ordinary laptop is, and a mind was what that system does while it runs. He said so most plainly in a 2011 interview with The Guardian, given at sixty-nine, after nearly half a century of living, as he put it, with the prospect of an early death. The view behind it is called physicalism: the belief that everything that exists, minds included, is physical, so that there is no soul to survive the body. In his final book he put the same conclusion in more general terms, that there is no God, no one created the universe or directs our fate, and there is probably no heaven and no life after death. He did not think this made life meaningless. In the same interview he said we should seek the greatest value of our actions, and he spoke often of the wonder of understanding the universe as the thing that made his own life worth living.
(Q) "I regard the brain as a computer which will stop working when its components fail. There is no heaven or afterlife for broken down computers; that is a fairy story for people afraid of the dark." Source: Stephen Hawking, interviewed by Ian Sample, "Stephen Hawking: ‘There is no heaven; it’s a fairy story’," The Guardian, 15 May 2011. The interview came days before he spoke at Google’s Zeitgeist meeting in London on why we are here. It is among the bluntest statements he ever made about death.
(Q) "Even if there is only one possible unified theory, it is just a set of rules and equations. What is it that breathes fire into the equations and makes a universe for them to describe?" Source: Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, chapter 11, "Conclusion" (Bantam, 1988). The question he asked here and never answered to his own satisfaction is the one Christian thinkers kept handing back to him: equations describe a world, but they do not make one.
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Christian philosophers took his singularity theorem as evidence that the universe began, and answered his no-boundary proposal on its own terms. The kalam cosmological argument is the old argument that whatever begins to exist has a cause, that the universe began to exist, and that the universe therefore has a cause. (Its name comes from kalam, the Arabic word for the reasoned theology of the medieval Islamic thinkers who developed the argument most fully; its first full statement came earlier, from the sixth-century Christian philosopher John Philoponus.) It was revived in the late twentieth century by the philosopher William Lane Craig, and the Hawking-Penrose theorem became one of its standard pieces of evidence. Here was mathematics, from a scientist with no theological stake, pointing to a first moment of time. When Hawking turned to the no-boundary proposal, Craig answered him in a 1990 article in the British Journal for the Philosophy of Science whose title borrowed Hawking’s own question, "What Place, Then, for a Creator?" The reply made three points that Christian writers have repeated since. First, the proposal still gives the universe a finite past; it rounds off the beginning but does not remove it. Second, it works only in imaginary time, which Craig argued is a mathematical device rather than a physical reality. Hawking himself wavered here, sometimes calling his models mere mathematics and sometimes suggesting that imaginary time might be the more basic kind. Either way, translated back into real time, the singularity returns. Third, creation was never only about a first moment: Christian theology holds that God keeps the universe in being at every moment, so a universe with no edge would still owe its existence to him. The Vatican, for its part, kept him close despite the 1981 audience: Hawking was appointed to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences, the Vatican’s own body of leading scientists, believers and unbelievers alike, in 1986, under John Paul II, and spoke at its meetings for decades.
(†) John Lennox and others answered The Grand Design: laws describe what happens, but they create nothing. The Oxford mathematician John Lennox answered The Grand Design within a year in a short book, God and Stephen Hawking: Whose Design Is It Anyway? (2011). His central point is easy to see with an everyday example. Newton’s laws tell you exactly how a billiard ball will move once it is struck, but the laws never strike a ball; somebody has to pick up a cue. In the same way, the law of gravity describes how matter behaves, but it is not a thing that can act, still less a thing that can make a universe. And a "nothing" that already contains a law of gravity is not nothing. Lennox also seized on "philosophy is dead," since the sentence that announces the death is itself a philosophical claim about what kinds of knowledge there are. Other Christian voices answered within weeks. Rowan Williams, then Archbishop of Canterbury, wrote in The Times that physics on its own will not settle why there is something rather than nothing, and the Cambridge physicist-priest John Polkinghorne took up the book in a radio debate that October, including what physicists mean by a universe from "nothing." The reception was not only argument. Don Page, Hawking’s former student and lodger, went on to a career in cosmology at the University of Alberta, and remained both a Christian and his friend; the two published together for years. He is a reminder that the physics Hawking did is not the property of any one worldview.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: on what makes a universe, what a person is, and what follows death. Christians owe Hawking real gratitude. He made a whole generation curious about the beginning of the universe, he did it with courage few people have been asked to show, and his best physics belongs to everyone. But at three points his teaching and the Christian faith cannot both be right. - What makes a universe. Hawking held that the laws of physics are enough to explain why anything exists (T4). Scripture says the universe owes its existence to God, who made it by his word: "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth" (Genesis 1:1), and "By faith we understand that the universe was created by the word of God, so that what is seen was not made out of things that are visible" (Hebrews 11:3). A law describes what things do once they exist; it does not supply the things. Hawking’s own question, what breathes fire into the equations, is the place where Christians say the answer is not a further equation but the God in whom "all things hold together" (Colossians 1:17). - Philosophy. The claim that philosophy is dead is not a finding of physics but a philosophical thesis, and a self-defeating one, which means it saws off the branch it sits on. No experiment could ever show it, so if physics were the only road to knowledge, nobody could know the claim was true. Christians have never been asked to choose between careful science and careful reasoning about God, and Paul expects that what can be known of God is "clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made" (Romans 1:20). - The person and death. Hawking regarded the mind as a computer that stops when its parts fail (T5). The Christian hope is not a fairy story for those afraid of the dark but a promise grounded in a historical event, the resurrection of Jesus, and it is a promise for the body, not only the soul: "What is sown is perishable; what is raised is imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:42). None of this requires denying a single equation he wrote. The disagreement is about what the equations mean, and that, as he might have admitted on a better day, was always a question for philosophy.