Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

The Hellenistic & Roman World

300 BC – 300 AD

Apollonius of Tyana c. 15 – c. 100 AD

(●) A wandering Pythagorean holy man of the first century, whose legend a pagan governor later set up as a rival to Jesus. + Imagine a barefoot man in a plain linen robe walking into a Greek city some time in the reign of Nero. He eats no meat, drinks no wine, lets his hair grow long, and talks with priests about how the gods ought to be honored. Crowds follow him; magistrates ask his advice; some people whisper that he is a sorcerer. That is Apollonius of Tyana, a teacher in the tradition of Pythagoras (the sixth-century BC philosopher who taught that the soul is immortal and that a disciplined life purifies it), and he was walking the same roads of Asia Minor in the same decades as the apostle Paul. He matters on a Christian apologetics site for one reason above all. Around AD 303, as the last great persecution of the church began, a Roman governor named Sossianus Hierocles wrote a book arguing that Apollonius had worked wonders as great as Christ’s, and that pagans were sensible enough to call him only a man favored by the gods, while Christians made a god of Jesus on the strength of a few miracles. "Apollonius did the same things" has been an objection to the Gospels ever since, and anyone weighing the evidence for Jesus will meet it. Almost everything known about him comes from one book, the Life of Apollonius by the sophist Philostratus, written around AD 220, more than a century after Apollonius died. (A sophist, in Philostratus’ day, was a celebrated professional speaker and teacher of rhetoric, something like a star lecturer who could fill a hall in any city of the empire.) So we are seeing Apollonius through another man’s eyes, at a long distance, and even the dates are conventions. Philostratus gives no year of birth and says that reports of his age at death ranged from eighty to over a hundred; the usual round figures, born around AD 15 and dying around AD 100, are back-reckoned from the emperors his story moves through, from Nero to Nerva.

(●) c. 15 AD: Born into a wealthy Greek family at Tyana in Cappadocia, and surrounded from birth with legends. + Tyana was a Greek city set among the Cappadocian people of central Asia Minor, in what is now south-central Turkey. Philostratus says the family was old, descended from the city’s first settlers, and richer than its neighbors, and that the boy was named Apollonius after his father. The birth stories came later and grew in the telling. Philostratus reports that before the child was born, the sea-god Proteus appeared to his mother in the guise of an Egyptian spirit, and when she asked what sort of child she would bear, answered, "Myself." He adds that she gave birth in a meadow, startled by a chorus of swans, and that the local people spoke of a thunderbolt that seemed to fall and then rose back into the sky. These are traditions recorded some two centuries after the fact; Philostratus tells the meadow birth as something "said," and the thunderbolt as what "the people of the country say." At fourteen the boy was sent to study rhetoric at Tarsus, the university city where Saul of Tarsus had grown up a generation earlier. He found it frivolous and soon moved to nearby Aegae, where there was a temple of Asclepius, the Greek god of healing, and teachers from every school of philosophy.

(●) c. 31 AD: At sixteen he took up the Pythagorean life, and later kept five years of silence. + His teacher at Aegae, a man named Euxenus, could recite the sayings of Pythagoras the way a trained bird says "good day," Philostratus remarks, without living any of them. At sixteen Apollonius decided to live them. He gave up meat as unclean, gave up wine as something that clouds the mind, went barefoot, wore linen instead of wool (wool comes from an animal), let his hair grow, and lived in the temple precinct. A few years later, after his father’s death, came the hardest discipline of all. When Euxenus asked why so gifted a speaker did not write a book, Apollonius answered, "I have not yet kept silence," and for five years he said nothing at all, conversing with his eyes, his hands, and nods of the head. He later called it the most uphill work of his life: he often had something to say and could not say it, and had to let insults pass unanswered. Anyone who has bitten back a reply in a heated meeting knows a little of what five years of that would cost. As for the year itself, it is only a convention, counted forward sixteen years from a birth date that is a convention too.

(●) c. 40s AD: He journeyed east to Babylon and, by Philostratus’ account, as far as the sages of India. + Philostratus sends him east to learn from the Magi of Babylon (the Persian priestly sages, the same Greek word Matthew’s Gospel uses for the wise men who came to Bethlehem) and the Brahmans of India (the priestly, learned class of Indian society). At the ancient city of Nineveh he picks up a companion, Damis, who becomes his disciple and, Philostratus claims, his chronicler. In Babylon he is received by the Parthian king Vardanes. The Parthians, a people from what is now Iran, ruled Mesopotamia in those years and were Rome’s great rival in the east, and Vardanes’ short reign (roughly AD 40 to 47) is the main anchor for dating this part of the story. In India he sits with the wise man Iarchas, who tells him that in an earlier life he had been the pilot of an Egyptian ship, an idea Apollonius accepts, because Pythagoreans held that souls pass from body to body. How much of the journey happened is one of the open questions about him. The Indian chapters are full of marvels (self-moving tripods, sages who float in the air) that read more like a traveler’s romance than a diary, and many scholars doubt that Damis’ memoir ever existed outside Philostratus’ book. It is safest to say that Apollonius was remembered as a far traveler, and that Philostratus filled in the map.

(●) c. 60s AD: Back in the Greek world, he advised cities, reformed temple worship, and gathered a reputation for wonders. + Most of his public life was spent moving between the cities of Asia Minor and Greece, talking with priests about the right way to honor the gods and with citizens about their quarrels. He also visited Rome under Nero, where the authorities watched philosophers closely, and later Egypt, where Philostratus has him advise Vespasian as he made his bid for the throne in AD 69. The wonder stories cluster in these years. When plague struck Ephesus, Philostratus says, Apollonius led the people to the theater, pointed out a ragged old beggar, and urged them to stone him; when the stones were cleared away, the body was that of a huge dog, and the plague ended. In Rome he met the funeral procession of a young bride from a consular family (one whose men had held the consulship, the highest yearly office in Rome), touched her, whispered something over her, and she woke. Philostratus is candid that even those present could not tell whether "some spark of life" had remained in her that her nurses had missed. It is worth noticing, as the stories go by, that Paul had preached in Ephesus only a few years before, in the mid-fifties, and that Luke records a bonfire of magic books there, worth fifty thousand pieces of silver (Acts 19:19). The city knew both kinds of holy man.

(●) c. 93 AD: Accused before the emperor Domitian, he stood trial in Rome. + Domitian, the last of the Flavian emperors (the dynasty his father Vespasian had founded), grew suspicious and cruel in his final years, and philosophers who spoke freely were among his targets. Philostratus says Apollonius was accused of sorcery, of letting people call him a god, and of plotting with Nerva, the senator who would one day replace Domitian. Rather than hide, he sailed to Rome to face the charges. The trial scene is the climax of the Life. Philostratus has Apollonius imprisoned, his long hair cut off, his legs chained, and then brought before the emperor, where he answers each charge briefly and with dry wit. Domitian acquits him but orders him to remain for a private interview, and that is when Apollonius stops being careful. He tells the emperor to his face that informers have ruined his cities, filled the islands with exiles, and the mainland with lamentation. Then he quotes Homer ("thou shalt not slay me, since I tell thee I am not mortal") and vanishes from the courtroom. That same day, the story goes, he appeared to his friends at Puteoli, near Naples, more than a hundred miles away. Nobody knows the exact date of the trial; the early nineties are a convention.

(●) 96 AD: Lecturing in Ephesus, he was reported to have seen Domitian’s murder in Rome as it happened. + Domitian was stabbed to death in his palace on 18 September AD 96 by a freedman (a former slave) named Stephanus. According to Philostratus, at that hour Apollonius was speaking in a colonnade at Ephesus, hundreds of miles away. He faltered, fell silent, stared at the ground, stepped forward, and cried out, "Smite the tyrant, smite him." Then he told the stunned crowd to take heart, because the tyrant had been slain that very day. Here, for once, Philostratus is not alone. Of all the wonders, this is the one that another writer of the period also reports. The Roman historian Cassius Dio, writing his own history of Rome in the same years as Philostratus, tells the same story (67.18). Whatever happened in that colonnade, then, the story was not Philostratus’ invention. After that, the trail goes cold. Philostratus says Nerva wrote inviting him to Rome as an adviser, and that Apollonius sent Damis off with a letter so that no one would witness his end. No one knew where he died: some said Ephesus, some Lindus on Rhodes, some Crete, where he was said to have entered a temple at night and been heard no more. Philostratus adds that he never found a tomb.

(●) c. 220 AD: A century after his death, Philostratus wrote the Life that made him famous. + For a hundred years after his death, Apollonius was a local saint at Tyana and a name with a mixed reputation elsewhere. An earlier writer, Moeragenes, had described him as a magician as well as a philosopher, and the satirist Lucian, poking fun at a notorious fraud, mentioned in passing that the fraud’s own teacher had been a follower of Apollonius. It was not the kind of fame a holy man would want. Then the empress Julia Domna, wife of Septimius Severus and a patron of philosophers and rhetoricians, asked Philostratus, a member of her circle, to turn a set of notes into a proper book. Philostratus says the notes were the memoirs of Damis, brought to the empress by one of Damis’ relatives, and that he also used a short account by Maximus of Aegae and the sage’s own letters. Julia Domna died in AD 217, and the eight books of the Life were finished after that, probably around 220. The book made Apollonius a celebrity of the third century. Philostratus reports that a shrine at Tyana was honored by the emperors; Dio says the emperor Caracalla built a hero’s shrine to him (the kind of sanctuary Greeks raised to a great man honored after death as something more than mortal); and a later Roman source claims the emperor Severus Alexander kept his image in his private chapel. It was this Apollonius, the Apollonius of Philostratus’ book, that Hierocles would set against Jesus eighty years later.

What He Taught

(T1) Wisdom begins by purifying the body, and the sage lives by strict discipline. + Think of an athlete in training: no late nights, no rich food, a body kept lean so that it does what it is told. Apollonius treated the whole of life that way, except that the contest was for the soul. Following Pythagoras, he held that what goes into the body affects the clarity of the mind, so he ate only vegetables and dried fruit, refused wine because it "darkened, as with mud, the ether which is in the soul," and stayed unmarried. Philostratus says he would not even wear leather or wool, because they came from animals. This was asceticism, the practice of training oneself by self-denial, from the Greek askesis, an athlete’s exercise. Christians knew the word too: Paul wrote, "I discipline my body and keep it under control" (1 Corinthians 9:27), in a passage full of runners and boxers, and the desert monks of later centuries kept fasts as hard as any Pythagorean’s. The difference lay in what the discipline was for. For Apollonius it purified the soul and raised the sage toward the gods; for the Christian it was a response to a grace already given, never the price of admission.

(Q) "At the point at which physicians begin, for they, by purging the bowels of their patients prevent some from being ill at all, and heal others." + Source: Philostratus, Life of Apollonius I.8 (Conybeare translation, 1912). The sixteen-year-old Apollonius has just told his teacher Euxenus that he intends to live the life of Pythagoras, and Euxenus asks where he will begin. This is his answer, and Philostratus adds that he immediately gave up eating meat.

(T2) The highest God needs no sacrifice, and is honored by the mind alone. + Every Greek city of his day smelled of the altar: the smoke of burning fat, the blood of oxen and sheep, the incense heaped on coals. Apollonius spent much of his life in temples, and what he told the priests was surprising. The gods, he said in the Life, already know what every worshiper deserves, so the only fitting prayer is, "O ye gods, grant unto me that which I deserve." He went further in a book called On Sacrifices, which Philostratus says he found in many temples. Only a fragment survives, quoted by the church historian Eusebius. In it he distinguishes the First God, one and separate from all the rest, from the lesser gods beneath him, and says that the First God should receive no sacrifice at all, no fire and nothing that the senses can touch, because he needs nothing and every earthly gift carries some defilement. He should be honored only with the silent speech of the mind. Christian readers recognized something here. Paul told the philosophers of Athens that God "is not served by human hands, as though he needed anything" (Acts 17:25), and Eusebius quoted the fragment precisely because it sounded so close to the truth. Yet Apollonius kept the lesser gods and their offerings in their place below the First God, which is where the gospel would part ways with him (see the final row).

(Q) "He should sacrifice nothing at all, neither kindle fire, nor dedicate anything whatever that is an object of sense... but should ever employ towards Him only that better speech, I mean the speech which passes not through the lips, and should ask good things from the noblest of beings by what is noblest in ourselves, and this is the mind, which needs no instrument." + Source: Apollonius, On Sacrifices, as quoted by Eusebius, Preparation for the Gospel IV.13 (Gifford translation, 1903). The passage is the only surviving fragment of the treatise. Eusebius introduces it carefully, as words "said to be written by" Apollonius, and the attribution, though widely accepted, cannot be proved.

(T3) The wise man is free before tyrants, because no one can take his soul. + Most of us have known someone who simply would not be bullied: the employee who quietly tells the boss the truth, knowing what it may cost. The philosophers of the Roman empire turned that kind of courage into a teaching. If the soul is what matters, and no emperor can touch the soul, then the sage has nothing to fear from an emperor. Apollonius, as Philostratus draws him, lives this out. He rebukes Nero’s officials, lectures Vespasian on how to rule, and walks into Domitian’s court of his own accord. The defense speech Philostratus gives in full in Book VIII (one he says Apollonius prepared but never delivered, and which most scholars take to be Philostratus’ own work) argues that the philosopher who has done no wrong should face a tyrant with the same calm he brings to anything else. Christians would honor that courage and give it a different root. Peter and the apostles told the Jerusalem council, "We must obey God rather than men" (Acts 5:29), and Jesus told his disciples not to fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul (Matthew 10:28). The difference is that the apostles expected to die, and many did. Apollonius, in the story, escaped by vanishing.

(Q) "Send some one to take my body, for my soul you cannot take. Nay, you cannot take even my body." + Source: Philostratus, Life of Apollonius VIII.5 (Conybeare translation, 1912). Apollonius speaks to Domitian immediately after being acquitted. He goes on to quote Homer’s Apollo, "For thou shalt not slay me, since I tell thee I am not mortal" (Iliad 22.13), and then vanishes from the court.

(T4) The soul is immortal, and at death it leaps free of the body like a horse from its harness. + Picture a horse that has pulled a heavy cart all day. The traces are unbuckled, and it bolts off across the field, light and free. That is the image Apollonius used for death: the body is the cart, and the soul is glad to be rid of it. Like Pythagoras and Plato before him, he taught that the soul existed before the body and survives it, and that it had lived in other bodies before (the Indian sage’s talk of a former life as a ship’s pilot is the example in the Life). Philostratus closes his book with a story that sums up the teaching. A young man at Tyana, who refused to believe in the soul’s immortality, prayed to the dead Apollonius for more than nine months for a sign. Then one day he fell asleep among his friends, woke drenched in sweat, and cried out, "I believe thee," reporting that Apollonius had appeared to him and recited verses about the soul. Christians agreed that the soul outlives the body. What they did not share was the relief at shedding it. The Christian hope is not a soul running free of its harness but the body itself raised and made new (1 Corinthians 15:42–44).

(Q) "The soul is immortal, and ’tis no possession of thine own, but of Providence, and after the body is wasted away, like a swift horse freed from its traces, it lightly leaps forward and mingles itself with the light air, loathing the spell of harsh and painful servitude which it has endured." + Source: Philostratus, Life of Apollonius VIII.31 (Conybeare translation, 1912). The verses are the ones the young man at Tyana said Apollonius recited to him in his dream. They are Philostratus’ report of a posthumous appearance, not a text Apollonius is known to have written, and they end by telling the doubter not to pry into such mysteries while he is still alive.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) Hierocles set him up as a rival to Christ, and Eusebius and Lactantius answered. + Around AD 303, as Diocletian’s Great Persecution began (the last and fiercest attempt by the Roman state to stamp out the church, with churches pulled down and Scriptures burned), Sossianus Hierocles, a provincial governor and one of its organizers, published a book against the Christians called The Lover of Truth (Philalethes). Its one original move was to set Apollonius beside Jesus. Pagans, he argued, had a better-attested wonder-worker than Christians did, and the sense to call him merely a friend of the gods. The stories of Jesus, he claimed, were the work of uneducated liars like Peter and Paul, while the life of Apollonius had been written by educated men who loved the truth. Two Christian replies survive. The first is a short treatise Against Hierocles, traditionally ascribed to Eusebius of Caesarea, the church historian (some scholars assign it to another Eusebius). Its approach is striking for its fairness. The author says he is happy to count Apollonius a sage, humanly speaking, and refuses to abuse him; his quarrel is with Philostratus’ book, which he takes apart chapter by chapter, showing its contradictions and asking why a philosopher needed so many marvels. The second reply is in the Divine Institutes of Lactantius (V.3), who asks Hierocles the obvious question: if Apollonius did equal or greater things, why does no one worship him in place of God?

(Q) "For whereas we reckon him who wrought such feats not a god, but only a man pleasing to the gods, they on the strength of a few miracles proclaim their Jesus a god." + Source: Hierocles, The Lover of Truth, as quoted in Eusebius, Against Hierocles 2 (Conybeare translation, 1912). Hierocles’ own book is lost; his words survive only because his opponent quoted them. Three chapters later the reply sets its terms: "I, however, my friend, used to regard the man of Tyana as having been, humanly speaking, a kind of sage, and I am still freely disposed to adhere to this opinion" (Against Hierocles 5).

(†) Weighed side by side, the parallel with Jesus falls apart on the evidence. + The comparison still turns up, so it is worth seeing why the church fathers were unimpressed, and why historians today mostly agree with them. - Distance from the events. Philostratus wrote around AD 220, a century and more after Apollonius died and about a hundred and fifty years after the events he describes. Paul’s letters were written within about twenty-five years of the crucifixion, and the Gospels within living memory; Paul could tell his readers that most of the more than five hundred witnesses of the risen Jesus were "still alive" (1 Corinthians 15:6). - The sources. Philostratus’ main source, the memoir of Damis, appears nowhere before his book, and many scholars doubt it existed. Moeragenes, the earlier biographer whom another ancient writer also knew, called Apollonius a magician, and Philostratus waves him aside as ignorant of much of the life. - The author’s own hedging. Philostratus admits that no one could tell whether the girl in Rome was dead, says he never found a tomb, and reports three different deaths. The Gospel writers name a tomb, its owner, and the people who found it empty. - No resurrection. The nearest thing in the Life is a young man’s dream of hearing the dead sage recite verses. Nothing in it resembles a public claim, made in the city where it happened, that a crucified man had been raised bodily and seen by hundreds. - No rival intended. Philostratus never mentions Jesus or the Christians. It was Hierocles, eighty years later, who turned his romance into an anti-gospel. Later Christian writers drew the line in the same place. Augustine, asked about Apollonius around AD 412, granted that he was a far worthier character than Jupiter, and called the attempt to rank him with Christ ridiculous (Letter 138.18).

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: the many gods, the ascent by discipline, the soul set free of the body, and a stoning at Ephesus. + For all his austere goodness, what Apollonius taught and did, as his own biographer records it, parts from the gospel at four points. - The lesser gods. Apollonius kept the First God above all sacrifice but spent his life tending the shrines of the lesser gods and teaching the right offerings for each. Scripture knows one God and no ranks of deities beneath him, and it settles the question of sacrifice not by abolishing it but by fulfilling it: Christ "offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins" (Hebrews 10:12). - The way up. For Apollonius the sage climbs toward the divine by diet, silence, and self-mastery, and the reward of the climb is that people begin to call him divine. The gospel runs the other way: God comes down, and those who come to him do so by grace through faith, not by aptitude for self-denial (Ephesians 2:8–9). - The body. Apollonius taught that souls pass from body to body and that death frees the soul from a painful servitude (T4). Scripture teaches one life, "appointed for man to die once, and after that comes judgment" (Hebrews 9:27), and a resurrection in which the body is not shed but raised. - The stoning at Ephesus. The most troubling story in the Life is one Philostratus tells as a triumph: Apollonius urging a crowd to stone a ragged beggar, apparently blind, who was pleading for mercy, before anything showed him to be a demon. Whatever happened at Ephesus, it is the opposite of the way Jesus met the outcast and the possessed, with a touch and a word. Apollonius sought God earnestly by the light he had, and even his Christian opponent was willing to call him a sage. The trouble was never the man; it was the attempt to make him a second Christ.

Almost nothing Apollonius wrote survives intact. Philostratus names several works and quotes letters, a later collection of about a hundred letters circulated under his name, and one fragment of a treatise survives in Eusebius. The man is known chiefly through what others wrote about him, so the catalog lists both. Works attributed to Apollonius: - On Sacrifices: A treatise on how each god should be honored, which Philostratus says he found in temples, cities, and the houses of learned men, written, he says, in Apollonius’ own words (Conybeare took this to mean his native Cappadocian, though the surviving fragment is Greek). One fragment survives, quoted by Eusebius (Preparation for the Gospel IV.13), arguing that the First God should receive no sacrifice at all (T2). - Letters: A collection of roughly a hundred short letters to cities, rulers, and philosophers, many addressed to his rival, the Stoic Euphrates (a philosopher of the school that taught calm acceptance of whatever fate brings). Philostratus quotes several and says Hadrian kept a collection; the surviving set mixes possibly genuine letters with later forgeries, and scholars disagree about which is which. - Testament: A statement of his teaching which Philostratus says he used as a source and calls proof of how "rapturous and inspired a sage he really was." Lost. - Hymn to Memory: A hymn Philostratus says he chanted, teaching that time withers everything, yet time itself never ages but stays immortal because of memory. Lost. - On Divination by the Stars: Four books on astrology, which Philostratus says Damis and Moeragenes mention but which he had never seen and did not know anyone to own. Lost, and its existence uncertain. - Oracles: A collection listed among his works by the Suda, the tenth-century Byzantine encyclopedia, beside the Testament, the Letters, and the Life of Pythagoras. Nothing of it survives, and no earlier writer names it. - Life of Pythagoras: A biography of the founder of his school, cited by the Neoplatonists (the later followers of Plato in the third and fourth centuries) Porphyry and Iamblichus under the name of an Apollonius. Whether it is this Apollonius is debated. Lost except for their borrowings. Ancient sources about him: - Philostratus, Life of Apollonius of Tyana (c. AD 220): Eight books begun at the request of the empress Julia Domna and finished after her death, part biography, part travel romance, part philosophical dialogue. The source for nearly every story told of him (all the life rows, T1, T3, T4). - Moeragenes, Memoirs of Apollonius: An earlier four-book account, now lost, which Origen says presented him as "magician and philosopher" (Against Celsus VI.41) and which Philostratus dismissed. - Maximus of Aegae: A short account of his youth at Aegae, used by Philostratus and now lost. - Lucian, Alexander the False Prophet 5: The satirist’s passing mention that the fraudulent oracle-monger Alexander was taught by a follower of Apollonius. - Cassius Dio, Roman History 67.18 and 78.18: A contemporary historian’s separate report of his vision of Domitian’s murder, and of Caracalla’s shrine to him. - Hierocles, The Lover of Truth (c. AD 303): The anti-Christian book that set him beside Jesus, lost except for what its Christian critics quote. - Eusebius, Against Hierocles: The chapter-by-chapter reply to Philostratus’ book, traditionally ascribed to Eusebius of Caesarea. Printed with Conybeare’s translation of the Life. - Lactantius, Divine Institutes V.3: The second Christian answer to Hierocles. Spurious: Medieval Greek and Arabic works on talismans, magic, and alchemy circulated under his name (in Arabic he is "Balinus"), among them the Book of the Secret of Creation. None is his. Standard English edition: Philostratus, The Life of Apollonius of Tyana, edited and translated by Christopher P. Jones (Loeb Classical Library, 3 vols., 2005–2006; the third volume holds the letters, the ancient testimonies, and Eusebius’ reply to Hierocles). F. C. Conybeare’s 1912 Loeb translation, with the letters and the treatise against Hierocles, is in the public domain and free online.

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief