Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

Alister McGrath of Belfast b. 1953 AD

(●) The Belfast atheist who became a Christian while reading chemistry at Oxford, earned a doctorate in molecular biophysics, and has spent his working life arguing that science and faith are two ways of seeing one world. + When Richard Dawkins published The God Delusion in 2006, one of the most prominent Christian replies came from a man who had stood exactly where Dawkins stood. Alister McGrath had been a teenage atheist in Northern Ireland, convinced that the sciences he loved had made God unnecessary. He went up to Oxford to read chemistry (the British way of saying he went there to study it), became a Christian in his first term, and then did something unusual: he kept both. He finished a doctorate in molecular biophysics, took a first-class degree in theology on top of it, and became one of the most prolific Christian writers of his generation. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for three reasons. He wrote the textbooks from which a generation of seminary students, Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox, learned the history of Christian doctrine. He answered the New Atheism, the movement of popular writers around Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens and Sam Harris who argued after 2001 that religious belief is not merely mistaken but harmful, from inside the scientific world it claimed to speak for. And he wrote one of the standard modern lives of C. S. Lewis. One fact a reader tends to remember: the boy who lay awake in a school dormitory reading the stars as symbols of his own pointlessness grew up to hold Oxford’s chair in science and religion.

(●) 1953 AD: Born in Belfast and raised in Downpatrick, he was a boy in love with science who saw no room in it for God. + Alister Edgar McGrath was born in Belfast on 23 January 1953 and grew up in Downpatrick, a small county town in County Down. He went to Down High School there and, from 1966, to Methodist College Belfast, where he specialised in mathematics, physics and chemistry. By his own account he began to love science at about the age of eight, and soon was reading books far too hard for him. At thirteen he asked one of his teachers to explain Einstein’s theory of relativity. The teacher lent him a book, met him a week later for half an hour, and sent him away kindly: "Your brain needs to grow before you’ll be able to take it in. We’ll talk again in five years’ time." They never had the second conversation, McGrath later said, partly because he worked the theory out for himself about two years later. The same boy was an atheist. He remembered lying awake in his school dormitory, tracing the patterns of the stars through the window, and finding it a melancholy business: he believed he was alone in a vast, meaningless universe, and the stars seemed to him symbols of how brief and pointless his own life was.

(●) 1971 AD: He went up to Oxford to read chemistry and, in his first term, became a Christian. + In the autumn of 1971 McGrath arrived at Wadham College, Oxford, to read chemistry. He came a confident atheist, though his reading in the history and philosophy of science had already sown a few doubts. By the end of that first term, as he later recalled in an essay on the theologian T. F. Torrance, he had concluded "that Christianity was far more intellectually robust and spiritually relevant than I had given it credit for," and he became a Christian. He has described it not as a flash of feeling but as "a purely intellectual conversion," the exchange of one set of convictions for another, and in several of his books he puts it in one line: "I turned my back on one faith and embraced another." The word "faith" in that sentence is deliberate. Part of what changed was his view of atheism itself. He had taken it to be simply what the evidence showed; he came to see it as a belief about the whole of reality that went beyond what any laboratory could test, held on trust like any other. That thought would shape everything he later wrote about science and God.

(●) 1975 AD: After a first in chemistry he took a doctorate in molecular biophysics, and a first in theology alongside it. + McGrath took first-class honours in chemistry in 1975, "a first" in Oxford shorthand and the highest grade a British degree can carry, and moved straight into research in molecular biophysics, the study of the physical behaviour of the large molecules that make up living things, working in the Oxford laboratory of the biochemist George Radda. He held research scholarships at Linacre College and then at Merton College, and was awarded his doctorate (the Oxford DPhil) in 1977. He was not content with one subject. While still in the laboratory he began to study theology, and in June 1978 he took a second first-class degree, this time in theology. Picture a student who spends his days with spectrometers and enzyme samples and his evenings with Augustine and Calvin: that double life is the whole shape of his later work in miniature.

(●) 1980 AD: He married Joanna Collicutt and was ordained in the Church of England. + In 1978 McGrath went to Cambridge to train for ordination at Westcott House, and there he turned to the Reformation, the sixteenth-century upheaval in which Martin Luther, John Calvin and others broke with Rome over how a sinner is put right with God. His study of Luther became his first book, Luther’s Theology of the Cross (1985). In 1980 he married Joanna Collicutt, a psychologist who would herself later be ordained, and with whom he would write one of his best-known books. That September he was ordained deacon, the first of the two steps into the Anglican ministry, and in 1981 priest, the second, in the Diocese of Southwell, serving his curacy (the apprentice years of an Anglican clergyman) at St Leonard’s Church, Wollaton, on the edge of Nottingham, from 1980 to 1983. The Oxford scholar spent three years doing what parish clergy do: preaching on Sundays, visiting the sick, and burying the dead.

(●) 1983 AD: Back in Oxford he became a historian of doctrine, and his textbooks went into seminaries across the world. + In 1983 McGrath returned to Oxford to teach Christian doctrine and ethics at Wycliffe Hall, an evangelical Anglican college that trains clergy (evangelical meaning the wing of the church that puts special weight on the Bible, personal conversion and the cross), and served as chaplain of St Hilda’s College. The books came quickly. Iustitia Dei (1986), Latin for "the justice of God," traced the doctrine of justification, how God declares a sinner righteous, from the early church to the present, and remains a standard reference. The Intellectual Origins of the European Reformation (1987) and Reformation Thought (1988) followed, then a life of Calvin, and in 1990 he gave the Bampton Lectures, one of Oxford’s oldest theological lecture series, published as The Genesis of Doctrine. The book that carried his name furthest was a textbook. Christian Theology: An Introduction (1994) set out the whole of Christian belief, its history and its live disagreements, in plain language, and went through edition after edition in seminaries of every tradition. In 1995 he was elected Principal of Wycliffe Hall, leading it until 2005, and in 1999 Oxford gave him a personal chair as Professor of Historical Theology, a professorship created to honour one scholar’s work rather than an established post waiting to be filled.

(●) 2004 AD: When the New Atheism arrived, he answered it as a former atheist and a trained scientist. + McGrath had long wanted to bring his two disciplines together, and between 2001 and 2003 he published A Scientific Theology in three volumes. But it was Richard Dawkins who made him a public figure. In 2004 he published Dawkins’ God, a careful reading of Dawkins’s whole body of work, and that same year The Twilight of Atheism, a history of modern unbelief. When The God Delusion became a best-seller, he and Joanna replied with The Dawkins Delusion? (2007), short enough to read in an evening. The books brought invitations to debate in public, including one with Christopher Hitchens at Georgetown University in October 2007. In 2008 he moved to King’s College London as professor of theology, ministry and education, and in 2009 he gave the Gifford Lectures at Aberdeen, the best known of all lecture series on natural theology, which is the attempt to learn something about God from the natural world (T1). They were published as A Fine-Tuned Universe, a title that points to the way the basic settings of physics seem balanced within the narrow range that life needs, like a radio dial that has to sit on exactly the right spot for any music to come through. He also wrote children’s fantasy novels, the Aedyn Chronicles, as a man who had learned from Lewis that a story can reach places an argument cannot.

(●) 2014 AD: He returned to Oxford as its professor of science and religion. + In 2014 Oxford made McGrath its third Andreas Idreos Professor of Science and Religion and director of the Ian Ramsey Centre for Science and Religion. From 2015 to 2018 he was also Gresham Professor of Divinity in London, a post founded in 1597, giving free public lectures to anyone who walked in off the street; the transcripts are still free to read, and much of what he believes is set out there in his own unhurried words. He retired from the Oxford chair in 2022 and kept writing. Somewhere past his fiftieth book the habit was simply part of him: a man who once lay awake miserable under the stars now spends his evenings explaining why they are worth looking at.

What He Taught

(T1) Christian faith is a lens that brings the world into focus. + Anyone who has put on a pair of glasses for the first time knows the feeling. The tree across the road was there all along; now it has leaves. Nothing new was added to the world. What changed was the eye. That is McGrath’s picture of what Christian belief does. He does not think nature, taken on its own, forces anyone to God. Nature is ambiguous: there are sunsets, and there is the bloodshed of the food chain. Read without help, it could suggest a good God, a cruel one, or none. What faith supplies is a way of seeing, and the test of a way of seeing is how much it brings into focus. Christianity, he argues, makes sense of the order science finds, the beauty we cannot help noticing, and the moral sense we cannot shake off, more naturally than its rivals. This shapes his version of natural theology, the old project of learning about God from the created world. Older writers such as William Paley tried to argue from nature up to God, step by step, as a proof. McGrath, in The Open Secret (2008) and his Gifford Lectures, proposes something humbler: look at nature through the lens of Christian faith and notice how well it fits. Christians who prefer the older proofs think he concedes too much here; he thinks the fit is itself a kind of evidence, the way a theory in science earns trust by how much it explains.

(Q) "After discovering Christianity, I looked at those same stars, but now through a different lens. What I had once seen as symbols of transience and pointlessness took on a new meaning. They became signs of God’s love and presence." + Source: Alister McGrath, "Cosmology and Creation: How Do They Relate to One Another?", Gresham College lecture, 26 January 2016 (published transcript). He is describing the same night sky he had watched from his school dormitory as an atheist (T1). The stars had not changed; the lens had.

(T2) Science tells us how things work, but it cannot by itself tell us what they mean. + A chemist can tell you exactly what is in the ink on a love letter. What the chemist cannot tell you, from the ink, is whether the letter is sincere. Both are true things to know, and they are known in different ways. McGrath loved science and never stopped defending it, but he insisted on its limits. It answers questions of how; it cannot, by its own methods, answer questions of why, of purpose, value and meaning. He borrowed a picture from the philosopher Mary Midgley: reality is too rich for one map, so we need "many maps, many windows," each true to its own territory. A geologist’s map and a road map of the same county are both accurate, and nobody thinks they are at war. That is also why he rejected the "warfare" story, the popular idea that science and religion have always been enemies. Historians of science such as Peter Harrison have shown how recent and selective that story is, mostly a product of the later nineteenth century. Behind his position stands a view called critical realism: the world is really there and can really be known (realism), but every way of knowing it, scientific or theological, has to be fitted to what it studies and is open to correction (critical). Think of a doctor reading an X-ray. The broken bone is really there, and the film really shows it, but she has had to learn which shadows to trust, and a second opinion might still correct her. His A Scientific Theology argued that theology is a discipline of the same honest kind, studying a real God by methods suited to its object.

(Q) "Science helped me to understand how things worked. But what did they mean? Science gave me a neat answer to the question of how I came to be in this world. Yet it seemed unable to answer a deeper question. Why was I here? What was the point of life?" + Source: Alister McGrath, "Are Science and Faith at War?", Gresham College lecture, 3 October 2017 (published transcript). He is looking back on himself as a young man, when he loved science but sensed it was not complete (T2).

(T3) Human beings are made with a natural longing for God. + Augustine opened his Confessions with a prayer that McGrath returned to again and again: "You have made us for yourself, and our hearts are restless until they find their rest in you." Pascal spoke of an abyss in human nature too deep to be filled by anything less than God; C. S. Lewis of a longing that no earthly thing satisfies. McGrath set that old Christian theme beside a new field, the cognitive science of religion, which studies why religious belief comes so easily to human minds. Its researchers have found that belief in unseen agents and purposes arises from ordinary ways of thinking, in every culture, without being drilled in. An earlier rationalism, the confidence that reason alone could settle every serious question, had treated religion as a failure of reason, something imposed on people from outside. The newer finding turns that around: religion, it turns out, comes naturally. He was careful about what that proves. A natural tendency does not show that God exists, and he said plainly that the naturalness of belief does not make it right or wrong. But he thought it fits the Christian story better than the atheist one: if we were made for God, a restless reaching toward him is exactly what we should expect to find.

(Q) "The Christian narrative tells us about a natural desire for God; a scientific narrative tells us about a desire for God that is natural." + Source: Alister McGrath, "Why God Won’t Go Away", Gresham College lecture, 10 May 2016 (published transcript). The sentence is worth reading slowly, because it turns on swapping the order of two words. Theology speaks of a natural desire for God: a longing aimed at God. Science speaks of a desire for God that is natural: one that springs up on its own in ordinary human minds. The two accounts look at the same longing from different sides, and he argues they can be woven together (T3).

(T4) Human nature is broken, and we cannot mend ourselves without help. + Every New Year’s Day millions of people resolve to be kinder, more patient, more honest, and by February most of the resolutions are gone. Paul described the same experience long before: "I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing" (Romans 7:19). McGrath pressed this point against Richard Dawkins. In The Selfish Gene Dawkins had pictured our genes as "selfish" in a metaphorical sense, bits of DNA that build bodies as a way of getting themselves copied into the next generation, and he had argued that humans, alone among living things, can rebel against the genes that built them. McGrath agreed with the diagnosis that something in us pulls the wrong way, and disagreed about the cure. Dawkins believes we can overcome it by ourselves; McGrath, with the whole Christian tradition, believes we need help from outside us, which is what the gospel calls grace: God’s help, given freely to people who have not earned it. The old word for the problem is sin, and he thought the record of human history, from the Terror of the French Revolution (the months in 1793 and 1794 when a government that claimed to rule by reason and virtue sent thousands to the guillotine) onward, made it impossible to do without.

(Q) "If the word ‘sin’ didn’t exist, I think we would need to invent it." + Source: Alister McGrath, "Is Humanity Naturally Good? Richard Dawkins’s Selfish Gene", Gresham College lecture, 4 April 2017 (published transcript). In the same lecture he puts the disagreement in one line: "Dawkins believes that we can overcome this by ourselves; I think we need help if we are to do this, and transcend our natural limits and boundaries" (T4).

(Q) "The idea of some perennial or essential ‘warfare of science and religion’ narrative has had its day, and it is time to move on." + Source: Alister McGrath, "Are Science and Faith at War?", Gresham College lecture, 3 October 2017 (published transcript). A summary of the conviction behind most of his public work (T2): science is neither for nor against religion, any more than it is for or against politics.

What the Church Made of Him

(†) His textbooks taught a generation of students across every Christian tradition. + Ask a seminary graduate of the last thirty years which book first walked them through the doctrine of the Trinity, the two natures of Christ and the Reformation debates, and a good many will name Christian Theology: An Introduction. With its companions, Historical Theology, Reformation Thought and The Christian Theology Reader, it became a standard teaching text in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox classrooms alike. Part of the reason is fairness. McGrath is an evangelical Anglican and does not hide it, but his textbooks set out each tradition’s view the way its own best teachers would, and leave the student to weigh them. That is close to what C. S. Lewis called mere Christianity, the faith held in common across the churches, and it made McGrath a teacher whom readers of very different churches could trust. His scholarly work, above all Iustitia Dei on the doctrine of justification, is cited by Catholic and Protestant historians alike.

(†) He gave Christians a scientist’s answer to the New Atheism. + When the New Atheism was at its height, many believers had no idea how to answer the claim that science had disproved God. McGrath could say, from his own doctorate, that science had proved no such thing, and from his own conversion, that atheism was a faith commitment of its own. Dawkins’ God and The Dawkins Delusion? were read widely in churches and student groups, and he and his Oxford colleague John Lennox became two of the voices British Christians heard most often in those debates. Not everyone was persuaded, of course. Dawkins and his allies thought the replies missed the force of their case, and some Christians thought McGrath’s acceptance of evolutionary biology, or his modest version of natural theology (T1), gave away too much. But he changed the tone of the conversation: the believer in the room was no longer cast as the one who feared science.

(†) His life of C. S. Lewis reset the date of Lewis’s conversion. + For more than half a century readers and biographers dated Lewis’s turn from atheism to belief in God to 1929, because Lewis himself did in Surprised by Joy. Writing C. S. Lewis: A Life (2013) for the fiftieth anniversary of Lewis’s death, McGrath went back to the letters and found that the evidence points to 1930 instead: Lewis, writing decades later, had misremembered his own year. The biography and its companion volume, The Intellectual World of C. S. Lewis, renewed interest in Lewis among scholars and ordinary readers, and they show what McGrath had been doing all along. Like Lewis, he was a convert from atheism who tried to show that Christianity is a way of seeing everything else clearly; Lewis put it in a sentence McGrath quoted often: "I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen: not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else."

McGrath is still writing, and his bibliography runs past fifty books, many in several editions. The works below are his principal books, grouped by subject; reissues, edited readers beyond the main one, and short devotional titles are not all listed. His Gresham College lectures (2015 to 2018) are published free as transcripts on the college’s website and are the source of every quotation in the teaching rows. Reformation and historical theology: - Luther’s Theology of the Cross (1985): His first book, from his Cambridge research: how Luther’s breakthrough on justification grew out of his reading of the cross, where God is found in weakness rather than glory. - Iustitia Dei: A History of the Christian Doctrine of Justification (1986; later editions): The standard history of how Christians have understood God’s declaring the sinner righteous, from Augustine through the Reformation to modern ecumenical talks. - The Making of Modern German Christology (1986): How German theologians from the Enlightenment to the twentieth century rethought the person of Christ. - The Intellectual Origins of the European Reformation (1987): Traces the ideas behind the Reformers in late medieval theology and Renaissance humanism. - Reformation Thought: An Introduction (1988; later editions): A clear student introduction to the Reformers’ ideas and why they mattered so much to the people who fought over them. - A Life of John Calvin (1990): Calvin as a man and as a shaper of Western culture, written for a general reader. - The Genesis of Doctrine (1990): His Bampton Lectures, asking what doctrine is for and how it grows out of the church’s reading of Scripture. - In the Beginning: The Story of the King James Bible (2001): The making of the 1611 English Bible and its effect on language and culture. - Christianity’s Dangerous Idea (2007): The Protestant Reformation’s radical claim that every believer may read and interpret the Bible, and what followed from it. - Heresy: A History of Defending the Truth (2009): Why the early church drew lines around the faith, and what heresy actually was. - The Nature of Christian Doctrine: Its Origins, Development, and Function (2024): A late scholarly return to the question of The Genesis of Doctrine: how and why the early church formed its doctrines, and what they are for. Textbooks and introductions: - Christian Theology: An Introduction (1994; many editions): The most widely used introduction to Christian doctrine of its generation (reception). - Historical Theology: An Introduction to the History of Christian Thought (1998): The development of doctrine period by period. - The Christian Theology Reader (1995; later editions): Primary texts from the whole history of the church, the companion to Christian Theology. - Science and Religion: An Introduction (1999; later editions as Science and Religion: A New Introduction): A balanced survey of the field for students. - Christian Spirituality: An Introduction (1999): The main traditions of Christian prayer and devotion, and the theology behind them, for students. - Theology: The Basics (2004): The core of Christian belief in short chapters for beginners. Science and theology: - The Foundations of Dialogue in Science and Religion (1998): Groundwork for his later critical realist approach (T2). - A Scientific Theology, 3 volumes: Nature (2001), Reality (2002), Theory (2003): His major work, arguing that theology, like the sciences, studies a real object by methods fitted to it (T2). - The Science of God (2004): A shorter, more readable version of A Scientific Theology for students and general readers (T2). - The Open Secret: A New Vision for Natural Theology (2008): Natural theology as seeing nature through Christian eyes, rather than proving God from nature (T1). - A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology (2009): His Gifford Lectures, on how the finely balanced laws of physics fit a Christian view of the world. - Darwinism and the Divine (2011): Evolution and natural theology, from his Hulsean Lectures at Cambridge. - Surprised by Meaning (2011): How science, faith and the human search for meaning fit together (T2). - Enriching Our Vision of Reality (2016): Theology and the natural sciences in conversation. - The Territories of Human Reason (2019): How science and theology each reason, and where their territories meet. Apologetics and the New Atheism: - The Twilight of Atheism (2004): A history of modern unbelief from the French Revolution to the fall of Soviet communism, arguing that its great age was ending. - Dawkins’ God: Genes, Memes, and the Meaning of Life (2004; second edition 2015): A careful reading of Dawkins’s whole work and its leap from biology to atheism (T4). - The Dawkins Delusion? Atheist Fundamentalism and the Denial of the Divine (2007, with Joanna Collicutt McGrath): The short, widely read reply to The God Delusion. - Why God Won’t Go Away (2011): An assessment of the New Atheism and why belief has outlasted it. - Mere Apologetics (2012): A practical guide to explaining the faith to seekers and skeptics. - The Big Question (2015): Why science and faith keep being talked about together. - Inventing the Universe (2015): Why science and faith need each other to tell the whole story of how the universe came to be and what it means. - Narrative Apologetics (2019): Commending the faith by telling its story, in the way Lewis and Tolkien did. Biographies: - J. I. Packer: A Biography (1997): The life of the English evangelical theologian. - T. F. Torrance: An Intellectual Biography (1999): The Scottish theologian whose work on theology and science shaped McGrath’s own. - Emil Brunner: A Reappraisal (2014): A fresh assessment of the Swiss theologian long overshadowed by Karl Barth. - C. S. Lewis: A Life (2013): One of the standard modern biographies, which redated Lewis’s conversion to 1930 (reception). - The Intellectual World of C. S. Lewis (2013): Essays on Lewis’s thought, the scholarly companion to the biography. Spirituality and fiction: - Mere Theology (2010; in North America The Passionate Intellect): Essays on faith and the life of the mind, including his account of his own conversion. - Through a Glass Darkly: Journeys through Science, Faith and Doubt (2020): His memoir, the fullest account he has given of his move from atheism to faith and of the doubts that came after. - The Aedyn Chronicles (2010 to 2011): Three fantasy novels for younger readers, Chosen Ones, Flight of the Outcasts and Darkness Shall Fall. Lectures: the Gresham College lectures (2015 to 2018), including "Cosmology and Creation" (26 January 2016), "Why God Won’t Go Away" (10 May 2016), "Is Humanity Naturally Good?" (4 April 2017) and "Are Science and Faith at War?" (3 October 2017), are free on the college’s website.
Playlist
Justified True Belief