Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
Matthew the Apostle fl. c. 28 – c. 60 AD
(●) Matthew was the tax collector Jesus called away from his booth, and the church has always credited him with the Gospel that opens the New Testament. Picture the most disliked man in a small lakeside town: the one who sits by the road with a ledger, stops every cart and fishing catch that comes through, and takes a cut for a ruler nobody loves. That was Matthew’s job when Jesus walked past his booth in Capernaum and said two words to him. He got up and left it, and within a few years he was one of the twelve men Jesus chose to carry his message to the world. He matters to a Christian apologetics site for one reason above all. From the early second century on, every ancient writer who names the author of the first Gospel names Matthew, and no rival was ever put forward. That Gospel gave the church the Sermon on the Mount, the Lord’s Prayer in the form Christians still pray it, the great commission to "make disciples of all nations," and a steady chain of Old Testament prophecies that it shows coming true in Jesus. It became the most quoted Gospel in the early church, and it still stands first in every Bible. One small detail is worth carrying away. All four lists of the twelve apostles in the New Testament include Matthew, but only one of them calls him "Matthew the tax collector" (Matthew 10:3), keeping the old, embarrassing job title beside his name. That list is in the Gospel that bears his name. If the man himself wrote it, he chose to remind every reader where he had come from. His dates are conventions, not records. No ancient source gives the year of his birth or his death. The opening date, c. 28 AD, is the conventional year of his call, reckoned from the start of Jesus’ ministry. The closing date, c. 60 AD, comes from a report by Irenaeus, a bishop in Gaul in the late second century, that Matthew wrote his Gospel while Peter and Paul were preaching in Rome. After that, the record simply goes quiet.
(●) Before c. 28 AD: He sat at a toll booth in Capernaum, a Jew collecting money for Herod’s son, and his neighbors counted him among the sinners. Matthew’s life before Jesus survives in a single scene, but it is a vivid one. Capernaum was a fishing town on the northern shore of the Sea of Galilee, the place Matthew’s Gospel calls Jesus’ "own city" (Matthew 9:1). Galilee was then ruled by Herod Antipas, a son of Herod the Great, and the Jordan, flowing into the lake just to the east, marked the border with the territory of his brother Philip. Most scholars think the booth in Capernaum took tolls on goods moving along the road and across that border. Someone had to sit there and collect them. Matthew was that someone. Mark and Luke tell the same story about a man they call Levi, and Mark adds that he was "the son of Alphaeus" (Mark 2:14). Nearly every Christian reader since has taken Levi and Matthew to be the same man with two names, the way Simon was also called Peter, though a few early writers, Origen among them, kept the two apart. The job paid, and it was despised. Tolls were farmed out: a contractor paid the ruler for the right to collect them, and he and the men at his booths lived on whatever they could take above the agreed sum, so the trade drew men who were willing to be hated. A Jew who did it handled money for a ruler most of his neighbors resented, and spent his days with Gentile traders, that is, non-Jews. The Gospels show what people thought of the whole trade by the company it keeps: the Pharisees asked Jesus’ disciples "Why does your teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?" (Matthew 9:11), and Jesus himself told the religious leaders that "the tax collectors and the prostitutes go into the kingdom of God before you" (Matthew 21:31). Matthew was, in his neighbors’ eyes, in that company.
(●) c. 28 AD: Jesus said "Follow me," and he got up from his booth, left it, and threw a dinner for his old friends. His own Gospel tells the call in one breath: "he saw a man called Matthew sitting at the tax booth, and he said to him, Follow me. And he rose and followed him" (Matthew 9:9). Luke adds two words that show what it cost: "leaving everything, he rose and followed him" (Luke 5:28). Think about what that meant. A fisherman who followed Jesus could still go back to his boat, and after the resurrection Peter did exactly that for a night (John 21:3). A toll collector who walked away from his post could not walk back to it; someone else would be sitting there by the afternoon. Matthew’s decision was the least reversible of any disciple’s we know about. The first thing he did as a follower was to throw a party. Luke says "Levi made him a great feast in his house" (Luke 5:29), and the guests were the only friends a man in his trade had: other tax collectors and people the religious would not eat with. When the Pharisees, the most careful keepers of God’s Law, complained, Jesus answered with a doctor’s logic, "Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick" (Matthew 9:12), and with a line from the prophet Hosea that only Matthew’s Gospel records at that table (T2).
(●) c. 28 to 30 AD: He was named one of the Twelve, and served alongside a man called the Zealot. Not long after the call, Jesus chose twelve men from among his followers to be his apostles, the ones he would send out with his message. The word "apostle" simply means "one who is sent," like an envoy carrying a king’s letter. Matthew is on all four lists (Matthew 10:3; Mark 3:18; Luke 6:15; Acts 1:13). The company he joined was an odd one. Four were fishermen from the same lakeshore. Another was "Simon the Zealot" (Matthew 10:4). A zealot is someone burning with zeal, and among Jews of that day the word usually meant zeal for God’s Law against anything that compromised it; a generation later it became the name of one of the parties that took up arms against Rome. So Simon may well have hated exactly the kind of foreign-backed rule Matthew had been collecting money for. It is hard to imagine two men less likely to share a table, and for the better part of three years they shared everything. Beyond the lists, the Gospels never give Matthew a speaking line of his own. He was there for the teaching on the hillsides, the healings, the storm on the lake, and the long road south to Jerusalem, but he never steps forward in the story. He is a witness, not a character, and that is how he seems to have wanted it.
(●) c. 30 AD: He saw the risen Jesus on a mountain in Galilee, and waited with the others in the upper room. After the crucifixion and the empty tomb, Matthew’s Gospel takes the eleven remaining apostles back north, to "the mountain to which Jesus had directed them" (Matthew 28:16). There they saw him, and Matthew records the scene with a frankness no inventor would choose: "And when they saw him they worshiped him, but some doubted" (Matthew 28:17). It was there, by his Gospel’s account, that Jesus sent them to make disciples of every nation (T4). The last time Scripture names Matthew is in Jerusalem a few weeks later. Acts lists him among the apostles gathered in the upper room, the upstairs room where they were staying, after the ascension, the day Jesus was taken up from their sight into heaven. They were waiting and praying for the Holy Spirit Jesus had promised (Acts 1:13). From that day on, the Bible says nothing more about him.
(●) c. 30s to 60 AD: He preached first to his own people, and the early church remembered that he left them a written Gospel. For the next part of his life we depend on the early church’s memory, and it agrees on the main lines. Papias, a bishop in Asia Minor (modern Turkey) writing early in the second century who had collected what the apostles’ followers remembered, said that Matthew wrote down the Lord’s sayings "in the Hebrew language." Irenaeus, writing around 180, placed the Gospel "among the Hebrews" while Peter and Paul were preaching in Rome, which puts it in the early 60s. Eusebius, the church’s first great historian, added a human touch: Matthew had preached to his own people first, and when he was about to leave for other nations, he wrote his Gospel for them so that they would not lose what he had taught. That fits the book we have. It is the most Jewish of the Gospels: it opens with a family tree running back to David and Abraham, it assumes its readers know the Law and the Prophets (the Jewish Scriptures, which Christians call the Old Testament), and it argues again and again that Jesus is the Messiah, the anointed king Israel had been promised (T1). A former toll collector would also have been used to writing things down carefully, and the Gospel arranges Jesus’ teaching in orderly blocks a careful note-keeper would recognize (T3). The Gospel that has come down to us is in Greek. How it relates to the Hebrew writing Papias mentions, we simply do not know, and the ancient writers who reported it did not explain. What they did agree on, without exception, was the name of the man who wrote it.
(●) After c. 60 AD: Where he went and how he died are not known, and the traditions disagree. Here honesty means admitting how little survives. Later traditions send Matthew in several directions. The church historian Socrates of Constantinople, writing in the fifth century, reported that when the apostles divided the nations by lot, "Matthew was allotted Ethiopia," and other traditions point to Parthia (the great empire on Rome’s eastern border, centered on what is now Iran) or Persia. Eusebius passes on a report that when the teacher Pantaenus travelled east in the late second century, he found believers already holding a copy of Matthew’s Gospel in Hebrew, left there by the apostle Bartholomew. Even the manner of his death is disputed. Later legends make him a martyr, someone put to death for refusing to deny Christ, but the earliest relevant witness points the other way. Around 200, Clement of Alexandria quotes a teacher named Heracleon, a follower of Valentinus, whose Gnostic school taught that salvation came through secret knowledge. Heracleon listed Matthew among the apostles who did not die by public confession, that is, who never stood before the authorities, confessed Christ, and were executed for it. Clement, quoting him, does not contradict him. Clement also passes on a homely detail, that "the apostle Matthew partook of seeds, and nuts, and vegetables, without flesh." The cathedral of Salerno in southern Italy has claimed his relics, the bones honored as his, since the tenth century. Western churches keep his feast day on 21 September and Eastern churches on 16 November. These are traditions, and they deserve to be held as traditions. What is not a tradition is the book.
What His Gospel Taught
(T1) Jesus is the one the Law and the Prophets were pointing toward, and his life fulfills them. Imagine finding a key that had been cut centuries before anyone made the lock, and then watching it turn. That is the experience Matthew wants his readers to have. His Gospel opens with "The book of the genealogy of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham" (Matthew 1:1), tying Jesus at once to the two great promises of Israel’s Scriptures: the blessing promised through Abraham to every nation, and the everlasting throne promised to David. Then, about ten times through the book, he pauses the story to point at an Old Testament passage with a set phrase, something like "All this took place to fulfill what the Lord had spoken by the prophet" (Matthew 1:22). Scholars call these the fulfillment formulas: a formula is just a fixed form of words, repeated so the reader learns to listen for it. When the infant Jesus is carried into Egypt for safety, Matthew hears in it "Out of Egypt I called my son" (Matthew 2:15). When Jesus rides into Jerusalem on a donkey, the scene Christians call the triumphal entry, Matthew stops to point at a prophecy. And when the thirty pieces of silver Judas threw back into the temple are spent on a potter’s field, he points at another. Matthew does not mean that Jesus throws the Law away. He means that Jesus is what it was for, the way a promise is fulfilled by being kept rather than by being torn up. That is the point of Jesus’ own saying about the Law and the Prophets in the Sermon on the Mount, and it is why his Gospel has always been the natural doorway from the Old Testament into the New.
(Q) "Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them." Source: Matthew 5:17 (English Standard Version). Jesus says it early in the Sermon on the Mount, just before he begins to show what the commandments look like when they are kept from the heart (T3). Matthew records the saying; only his Gospel has it.
(T2) God wants mercy more than ritual, and Jesus came for sinners rather than for the respectable. Go back to Matthew’s dinner party (the call, c. 28 AD). The Pharisees were members of a devout movement that took great care over the purity laws, and to them a meal with tax collectors was a meal with the unclean, people whose company left a careful Jew unfit for worship until he had been made clean again. Jesus answered them with the doctor’s line that Mark and Luke also record. But Matthew alone adds a second sentence, sending the critics back to their Bibles: "Go and learn what this means, I desire mercy, and not sacrifice" (Matthew 9:13). The line comes from the prophet Hosea, where God says through him, "For I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice" (Hosea 6:6). Hosea was not abolishing the temple offerings; he was saying that worship offered by people who have no love for others is not what God is after. Jesus applies it to a dinner table: the religious were keeping themselves clean, and missing the point of being clean. Matthew cared enough about this to record Jesus quoting the same verse a second time, when the Pharisees accused his hungry disciples of breaking the Sabbath by picking grain (Matthew 12:7). It is not hard to guess why the line stayed with him. He had been the sinner at the table, and he was the one the physician came for.
(Q) "Go and learn what this means, I desire mercy, and not sacrifice. For I came not to call the righteous, but sinners." Source: Matthew 9:13 (English Standard Version). Jesus’ answer to the Pharisees at the meal in Matthew’s house, quoting Hosea 6:6. Mark 2:17 and Luke 5:32 give the second sentence; only Matthew gives the first.
(T3) The kingdom of heaven asks for a righteousness that goes all the way down to the heart. Where Mark and Luke usually write "the kingdom of God," Matthew usually writes "the kingdom of heaven," thirty-two times in all, and nowhere else in the New Testament is the phrase used. It means the same thing. Devout Jews of his day often said "heaven" instead of naming God directly, out of reverence, much as someone today might say "the good Lord" or "the man upstairs." The kingdom of heaven is God’s rule, breaking into the world in Jesus. Matthew gathers Jesus’ teaching about that kingdom into five long speeches, each ending with a version of the same sentence, "when Jesus finished these sayings" (Matthew 7:28; 11:1; 13:53; 19:1; 26:1). The first and most famous is the Sermon on the Mount (chapters 5 to 7). There Jesus takes the commandments everyone knew and follows them inward. The law says do not murder; Jesus says that anger and contempt for a brother already stand under judgment (Matthew 5:21–22). The law says do not commit adultery; Jesus says that lust already commits it in the heart (Matthew 5:27–28). The old saying allowed you to hate your enemy; "But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you" (Matthew 5:44). It sounds impossible, and it is meant to. The righteousness Jesus asks for is more than any careful rule-keeper can manufacture. In Matthew’s Gospel the same Jesus who sets that standard also says "Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest" (Matthew 11:28).
(Q) "For I tell you, unless your righteousness exceeds that of the scribes and Pharisees, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven." Source: Matthew 5:20 (English Standard Version). It follows straight after the saying on fulfilling the Law (T1). The scribes were the experts in the Law, and the Pharisees its most careful keepers, so the first hearers would have taken the sentence as a shock: if they are not righteous enough, who is?
(T4) In Jesus, God himself has come to be with his people, and he stays with them to the end. Some books are built like a pair of bookends, with the first page and the last page holding up everything between. Matthew’s is one of them. In the first chapter the angel’s message to Joseph is tied to Isaiah’s promise of a child called "Immanuel (which means, God with us)" (Matthew 1:23). In the last verse the risen Jesus tells his followers, "I am with you always, to the end of the age" (Matthew 28:20). In between, he promises that "where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them" (Matthew 18:20). That is a staggering claim for a Jewish writer to make about a man he had eaten with. God’s presence with Israel had once filled the tabernacle, the great tent Israel carried through the wilderness, and later the temple in Jerusalem. Matthew says it now walks around Galilee, and that it will go with a handful of fishermen and a former toll collector to every nation on earth. The last scene also gives the church its marching orders, and one of its clearest early statements of the Trinity, the Christian teaching that the one God is Father, Son and Holy Spirit. The disciples are to baptize "in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit" (Matthew 28:19), one name, three persons. A story that began with a family tree for Israel ends by sending Israel’s Messiah to the world.
(Q) "Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you. And behold, I am with you always, to the end of the age." Source: Matthew 28:19–20 (English Standard Version). The last words of the Gospel, spoken on the mountain in Galilee (c. 30 AD). Christians call them the Great Commission.
(Q) "Therefore every scribe who has been trained for the kingdom of heaven is like a master of a house, who brings out of his treasure what is new and what is old." Source: Matthew 13:52 (English Standard Version). Jesus says it at the close of his parables of the kingdom. Many readers, ancient and modern, have heard in it a quiet self-portrait of the evangelist (the old word for a Gospel writer): a man trained to keep careful records, who brought out of Israel’s old treasure the new thing God had done in Jesus. That is a reading of the verse, not a claim the verse makes, but it fits him.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) The church put his Gospel first, and for centuries read and quoted it more than any other. If you had walked into a Christian gathering in the second century, the Gospel you were most likely to hear quoted was Matthew’s. The Didache, an early church manual on prayer, baptism and the Lord’s Supper, tells believers to pray the Lord’s Prayer three times a day in very nearly the wording Matthew records (Didache 8). Ignatius of Antioch, writing on his way to martyrdom in Rome, echoes Matthew’s account of Jesus’ baptism "to fulfill all righteousness" (Matthew 3:15) in his letter to the Smyrnaeans, the church at Smyrna on the Aegean coast (chapter 1). A large modern study by the Belgian scholar Édouard Massaux traced how much of the earliest Christian writing leans on Matthew, and found it was the Gospel those writers used most. When the four Gospels were gathered together, Matthew’s was nearly always placed first. Much of the church’s best preaching grew out of it: John Chrysostom, the great preacher of Antioch and Constantinople, gave ninety sermons on it around 390, and Augustine wrote a two-book commentary on the Sermon on the Mount. Its Lord’s Prayer, its beatitudes (the string of "Blessed are..." sayings that opens the Sermon on the Mount), and its commission to baptize became the daily language of Christian worship, East and West.
(†) Every ancient witness who names its author names Matthew, and no rival author was ever proposed. For a book written by someone so unimportant before his call, the agreement is striking. Papias in the early second century, Irenaeus around 180, Origen in the third century, Eusebius in the fourth, and Jerome at its end all say Matthew wrote it. Origen put it plainly: "the first was written by Matthew, who was once a publican, but afterwards an apostle of Jesus Christ." A publican is the old English word for a tax collector. Put yourself in the early church’s place for a moment. If it had been inventing an author for its favorite Gospel, it had better candidates: Peter, the leader of the Twelve, or John, the beloved disciple. Instead it named a former toll collector who never says a word in any Gospel story. The simplest explanation of why everyone named him is that he wrote it.
(†) His call became the church’s favorite picture of a grace that reaches anyone. Around 1600 the painter Caravaggio was asked to decorate a chapel in the church of San Luigi dei Francesi in Rome, and he painted the moment at the booth. A group of men sit counting coins at a table in a dim room; a shaft of light falls across them from where Jesus stands at the edge of the picture, pointing; and one of the men looks up, as if to ask "Me?" Four centuries later, crowds still queue to see it. The church had been preaching the same scene for over a thousand years. Bede, the English monk and historian of the eighth century, said in a sermon for Matthew’s feast that Jesus saw the tax collector miserando atque eligendo, "by having mercy and by choosing." A man whom everyone else saw as a collaborator and a cheat was seen by Jesus with mercy, and chosen. Jerome assigned him the first of the four living creatures in Ezekiel’s vision (they appear again around God’s throne in Revelation), the one with a human face, because his Gospel begins with the human family tree of Jesus; that is why Matthew is so often painted with an angel or a man beside him. Scripture records nothing he taught or did after his call that the church has had cause to correct. The only fault on his record is the life he walked away from.