Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Jesus & the Apostles

5 BC – 100 AD

Mark the Evangelist fl. c. 44 – c. 67 AD

(●) Mark was the young man from Jerusalem who quit a mission, was given a second chance, and wrote down what Peter preached in the shortest of the four Gospels, very likely the first. + If you had to pick someone to write the first account of the life of Jesus, you would probably not pick the assistant who went home early. Mark was no apostle. He was not one of the Twelve, the inner circle of men Jesus chose to be with him, and an early witness says flatly that he never followed Jesus himself. His one appearance in the mission stories of Acts, the sequel to Luke’s Gospel that tells how the church spread, ends with him leaving, and the apostle Paul afterward refused to travel with him. Yet the church has read his book for nineteen centuries, and most scholars think two other Gospels are built on it. He matters to anyone weighing the case for Christianity because of how close he stands to the events. Every ancient witness who speaks of his Gospel says the same thing: behind Mark stands Peter, the fisherman who was there, and the book is what Peter told crowds about Jesus. A reader who wants to know how near the Gospels come to the people who saw it happen ends up, sooner or later, reading about Mark. A second reason is simply his story, in which a man the great apostle had given up on became, in that apostle’s own last letter, "very useful to me for ministry" (2 Timothy 4:11). A note on the name and the dates. Acts calls him "John whose other name was Mark" (Acts 12:12), a Jewish name and a Roman one, the way an immigrant’s child might answer to two names, one at home and one in the street. "The Evangelist" is the church’s old title for the writer of a Gospel. Neither his birth nor his death is recorded. The "fl." beside his name stands for floruit, Latin for "he flourished," and it marks the stretch the New Testament covers, from Peter’s escape from prison around AD 44 to Paul’s last letter, usually placed about AD 65 to 67. Every date given for his life is the usual reconstruction, not a recorded year. There is one more thing to admit. Marcus was among the commonest of Roman names, so no ancient text can prove that the John Mark of Acts, the Mark of Peter’s letter and the Mark who wrote the Gospel are one man. The church has generally taken them to be, though not without exception: a late list of the Seventy (the wider band of disciples Jesus sent out ahead of him in Luke 10:1, where the old copies read either seventy or seventy-two), falsely credited to Hippolytus of Rome, counts three separate Marks, and many modern scholars leave the question open. No rival candidate for the Gospel’s author has ever had a following.

(●) c. 44 AD: The night Peter escaped from prison, it was the gate of Mark’s mother’s house in Jerusalem that he came and knocked on. + Our first sight of Mark is really a sight of his front door. King Herod Agrippa I had put the apostle James to death with the sword and locked Peter up, intending to bring him out after Passover, the great spring feast of the Jews. Herod died in AD 44, so these events fall around that year. An angel led Peter out through the gates in the night, and when he realized he was free, "he went to the house of Mary, the mother of John whose other name was Mark, where many were gathered together and were praying" (Acts 12:12). What follows is one of the funniest scenes in the New Testament. A servant girl named Rhoda came to answer the knock, recognized Peter’s voice, and was so overjoyed that she ran back inside to tell everyone and left him standing in the street. The people praying for his release told her, "You are out of your mind" (Acts 12:15). Peter went on knocking. The little details say something about the family. A house with a gateway, a servant, and room for a crowd at a prayer meeting belonged to someone with means. The house is called Mary’s, not her husband’s, so she may well have been a widow. Peter knew exactly where to go in the middle of the night. So Mark grew up with the leaders of the Jerusalem church coming and going through his home, and Paul later tells us he was a cousin of Barnabas (Colossians 4:10), one of the most trusted men in that church. Later readers have guessed that the upper room of the Last Supper was in this same house, but no ancient source from the period says so.

(●) c. 47–48 AD: He sailed with Barnabas and Paul as their assistant on the first mission, and at Perga he left them and went home. + Barnabas and Saul (the name Paul still goes by at this point in the story) had come to Jerusalem with famine relief, and when they had finished delivering it they went back to Antioch in Syria "bringing with them John, whose other name was Mark" (Acts 12:25). When the church at Antioch sent the two men out, Mark went too. Luke, who wrote Acts, says only "they had John to assist them" (Acts 13:5). Think of the young staffer on a campaign: probably arranging lodging, carrying things, and running errands while the older men did the speaking. They crossed Cyprus, Barnabas’s home island, and sailed north to the coast of Asia Minor, the great peninsula that is roughly modern Turkey, and came to the town of Perga. Then comes one flat sentence: "And John left them and returned to Jerusalem" (Acts 13:13). Why did he go? Luke does not tell us, and we simply do not know. People have proposed homesickness, the dangerous mountain road ahead into the interior, or discomfort at Paul now leading in place of his cousin. Each of these is a guess. What we do know is how Paul took it: when Mark’s name came up again, Luke says Paul would not take along one who had "withdrawn from them in Pamphylia" (Acts 15:38), Pamphylia being the coastal district around Perga.

(●) c. 49–50 AD: Paul refused to take him on a second journey, Barnabas refused to leave him behind, and the two great missionaries split over him. + Imagine being the young man in the next room while the two people you most admire argue over whether you can be trusted. After the Jerusalem council, the meeting at which the church’s leaders settled whether non-Jewish believers had to keep the law of Moses, Paul suggested revisiting the churches they had planted. "Now Barnabas wanted to take with them John called Mark. But Paul thought best not to take with them one who had withdrawn from them in Pamphylia and had not gone with them to the work" (Acts 15:37–38). Neither would give way. "And there arose a sharp disagreement, so that they separated from each other. Barnabas took Mark with him and sailed away to Cyprus" (Acts 15:39). Luke, who was Paul’s friend, does not say who was right. The partnership that had carried the gospel across Asia Minor ended over a young man who had gone home, and one can only guess what that voyage to Cyprus felt like for him. After that, Acts never mentions him again, and for about ten years nobody does. We do not know what he did in those years. We do know how they ended.

(●) c. 60–62 AD: He reappears at the side of Paul, the man who had refused him, now a fellow worker and a comfort in prison. + The next time Mark’s name turns up, it is in Paul’s own handwriting, or at least his dictation, and the tone has changed completely. Paul is a prisoner, most likely in Rome, writing to the believers at Colossae in Asia Minor, and he sends greetings from "Mark the cousin of Barnabas (concerning whom you have received instructions—if he comes to you, welcome him)" (Colossians 4:10). The Greek word for "cousin" there is anepsios, which is how we know the family tie at all. Then Paul adds something that must have meant a great deal, coming from him. Mark is among "the only men of the circumcision among my fellow workers for the kingdom of God, and they have been a comfort to me" (Colossians 4:11). "The circumcision" is Paul’s phrase for fellow Jews. At a low point, with few of his own people standing with him, Paul counted the man who had once walked away as one who stayed. The short letter to Philemon, written in the same imprisonment, lists "Mark, Aristarchus, Demas, and Luke, my fellow workers" (Philemon 1:24). So in Paul’s small circle at that moment, as it happens, were the men whose names stand on two of the four Gospels. The note that the Colossians should welcome him "if he comes to you" suggests he was about to travel, and that his name still needed a word of introduction. Nobody tells us how the reconciliation happened. We only see that it had.

(●) c. 60s AD: In Rome he served as Peter’s interpreter, and he wrote down what Peter had preached about Jesus. + The first letter of Peter closes with a greeting that sounds like an old man talking about someone he loves: "She who is at Babylon, who is likewise chosen, sends you greetings, and so does Mark, my son" (1 Peter 5:13). "Babylon" was a code name for Rome among early Christians, as it is in Revelation, and Eusebius, the fourth-century historian of the church, says that is how it was understood here (Ecclesiastical History 2.15.2). "Son" need not mean family; it is what an old teacher calls a younger man he has brought along. The clearest report of what Mark was doing there comes from Papias, a bishop in Asia Minor writing around AD 110, who heard it from an elder, a senior church leader of the previous generation: Mark was Peter’s hermeneutes, his interpreter (Q, after T5). Peter was a Galilean fisherman whose first language was Aramaic, the everyday tongue of Jewish Palestine, and the crowds in Rome spoke Greek and Latin. Whether Mark stood beside him translating sentence by sentence or served more broadly as his aide and go-between, we cannot say. Either way, he heard the same stories told many times, to many audiences. Then he wrote them down. Clement of Alexandria, a Christian teacher in that great Egyptian city around AD 200, reports that the people in Rome who had heard Peter asked Mark, "who had followed him for a long time and remembered his sayings," to write them out (quoted in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 6.14.6). The ancient witnesses differ on the timing. Irenaeus, a bishop in Gaul (modern France) around AD 180, places the writing after the deaths of Peter and Paul, while Clement has Peter still alive. So the honest statement is that the Gospel belongs somewhere between the 50s and about AD 70, with the later 60s the most common estimate. The book itself fits the setting. It pauses to explain Jewish handwashing customs (Mark 7:3), it translates Aramaic phrases for its readers (Mark 5:41; 7:34; 15:34), and it borrows Latin words, spelled out in Greek letters, such as the one for "centurion," a Roman officer over a hundred men (Mark 15:39). That is just what one would expect from a Jewish writer serving a Roman audience.

(●) c. 65–67 AD: Awaiting execution, Paul sent for him by name: "he is very useful to me for ministry." + Paul’s last surviving letter was written in chains, with a verdict he expected to go against him. He tells Timothy, his younger colleague, that the time of his departure has come, and that nearly everyone has gone: Demas has deserted him, others have been sent away, "Luke alone is with me." Then comes the line that closes Mark’s story in the New Testament: "Get Mark and bring him with you, for he is very useful to me for ministry" (2 Timothy 4:11). Anyone who has ever been written off by someone they respected knows what that sentence is worth. It is a small thing, a request for a colleague in the closing lines of a letter, and it was written by the same man who, some fifteen years earlier, would rather break with Barnabas than travel with him. Mark had once "not gone with them to the work" (Acts 15:38), and now the old man wants him back for the work. We are not told whether Mark reached him in time.

(●) Tradition, date uncertain: Later writers say he carried his Gospel to Egypt, founded the church of Alexandria, and died there. + Everything after 2 Timothy is tradition, and it should be read as that. Eusebius, writing in the early fourth century, introduces it with a careful "they say": "that this Mark was the first that was sent to Egypt, and that he proclaimed the Gospel which he had written, and first established churches in Alexandria" (Ecclesiastical History 2.16.1). He adds that Annianus succeeded Mark in the church there in the eighth year of the emperor Nero, about AD 62 (2.24.1). Jerome, the scholar who gave the Western church its Latin Bible, writing at the end of that century, turns this into Mark’s death in that same eighth year of Nero, with burial at Alexandria (On Illustrious Men 8). Those dates do not sit comfortably with the letters, which put Mark in the circle of Paul and Peter in the 60s, and no one has fully reconciled them. Perhaps Mark handed over the work and left Egypt, as Eusebius’s wording would allow. We do not know. Much later, the Martyrdom of Mark (also called the Acts of Mark), a legendary account of the fourth or fifth century, tells how a mob at Alexandria dragged him through the streets by a rope at Easter until he died. No early witness confirms the story, and the year 68 often given for it is a convention. One small human detail has come down separately. Hippolytus of Rome, around AD 225, calls him "Mark, he of the maimed finger" (Refutation of All Heresies 7.30, which the old English set called the Ante-Nicene Fathers numbers 7.18), and an old preface to his Gospel explains that he was called "stump-fingered." Nobody knows why, and the explanations offered are guesses. But it is an odd thing to invent about a saint, and that may be the best reason to think it true.

What His Gospel Taught

(T1) Jesus of Nazareth is the Christ and the Son of God, and that is the good news. + Most biographies, then and now, begin with a birth. Mark has no birth, no childhood, and no family tree. He has one sentence, and then a man shouting in the desert. Before anything has happened, the reader has been told who the story is about, the way a friend might grab your arm before you walk into a room and tell you, "You should know who that is." "Christ" is the Greek translation of the Hebrew "Messiah," the anointed king God had promised Israel. "Gospel" means good news, and in the Roman world it was a word people knew from the announcements of an emperor’s birthday or victory. Mark uses it of a Galilean carpenter (Mark 6:3). What makes the story grip is that nobody inside it can see what the reader has been told. His family think he is out of his mind (Mark 3:21). His neighbors take offense. His disciples get as far as "You are the Christ" (Mark 8:29) and then cannot accept what that means. The voice from heaven calls him Son at his baptism (Mark 1:11), but the first human being in the book to say it is the Roman officer in charge of his execution, watching him die: "Truly this man was the Son of God!" (Mark 15:39). Mark opens and closes on the same title, and the officer who says it is the last person anyone would have expected.

(Q) "The beginning of the gospel of Jesus Christ, the Son of God." + Source: Mark 1:1 (English Standard Version). This is the opening line, and it does double duty as the book’s title. Mark may mean that the whole book is only the beginning of the good news, which goes on after it ends (T5).

(T2) Jesus does what only God can do: he forgives sins and commands the sea. + Picture a fishing boat in a squall on the Sea of Galilee, taking on water. Experienced fishermen are frightened, and their passenger is in the stern, "asleep on the cushion" (Mark 4:38). That cushion is exactly the kind of detail someone remembers who was in the boat. They wake him, he speaks to the wind, and everything goes still. What frightens them now is not the storm. It is him. Mark never stops the story to give a lecture on who Jesus is. He lets you stand where the bystanders stood. When friends lower a paralyzed man through a roof, Jesus says, "Son, your sins are forgiven" (Mark 2:5), and the religious scholars in the room react exactly as anyone who knew the Hebrew Scriptures would: "He is blaspheming! Who can forgive sins but God alone?" (Mark 2:7). To blaspheme is to insult God, and what they hear is a mere man helping himself to what belongs to God. They have the logic right. You can forgive someone who wronged you, but only the one who was wronged by every sin can forgive all of them. Jesus does not deny the logic. He heals the man to show that he has the authority. Mark’s first readers knew from the Psalms that it is the Lord who stills the raging sea (Psalm 89:9; 107:29). So when the disciples ask who this is, the book has already given the answer, and left them, and us, to catch up. And Mark puts this beside a very human Jesus, more so than any other Gospel: Jesus looks at people "with anger" (Mark 3:5), and looks at a rich man and "loved him" (Mark 10:21). Christians have held both of those together ever since: the one the sea obeys, and the man who can be angry and can love.

(Q) "Who then is this, that even the wind and the sea obey him?" + Source: Mark 4:41 (English Standard Version). The disciples are speaking to one another in the boat, "filled with great fear," once the storm has stopped. It is the question the first half of the book keeps asking, and Peter answers it at Caesarea Philippi, a town at the foot of Mount Hermon, north of Galilee (Mark 8:29).

(T3) The Son of Man came to die, giving his life as a ransom for many. + Anyone who reads Mark in a sitting (it can be done in an evening) notices the speed. The Greek word for "immediately" comes some forty times, and the story races from one village to the next. Then, about two-thirds of the way through, it slows to a walk. Six of the sixteen chapters cover only the final week. A German scholar, Martin Kähler, famously called the Gospels passion narratives with extended introductions, and "passion" here is the old word for Jesus’s suffering and death. It is true of Mark above all. Everything has been heading to Jerusalem. Three times on the road Jesus tells his disciples what is coming (Mark 8:31; 9:31; 10:33–34), and three times they fail to take it in. After the first, Peter takes him aside and rebukes him. After the second, they argue about which of them is greatest. After the third, James and John ask for the best seats in the coming kingdom. So Jesus explains what greatness is, and he finishes with the most important sentence in the book (Q, after T3). A ransom was the price paid to free a captive or a slave: a family scraping together silver to buy back a son taken by raiders. Jesus says his life is that price, paid for "many," and the word echoes the suffering servant in the prophet Isaiah, a figure who suffers in other people’s place and who "bore the sin of many" (Isaiah 53:12). The Son of Man is his own name for himself, drawn from Daniel’s vision of a figure who receives an everlasting kingdom (Daniel 7:13–14). Here he puts the two figures together, the enthroned king and the servant who dies, and that is why his followers found it so hard to hear.

(Q) "For even the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many." + Source: Mark 10:45 (English Standard Version). Jesus is speaking to the Twelve on the road up to Jerusalem, just after James and John have asked for the seats of honor. He has just told them that among them, "whoever would be first among you must be slave of all" (Mark 10:44).

(T4) To follow Jesus is to deny yourself and take up a cross. + We have turned "a cross to bear" into a phrase for a bad knee or a difficult relative. Nobody who first heard this would have made that mistake. In the Roman world a man carrying a crossbeam through the street was a condemned man on the way to his own execution, with the crowd looking on, and there was only one way that walk ended. Jesus says this right after Peter has confessed him as the Christ and then refused to hear about the cross (Mark 8:29–33). The order matters. Once it is clear what kind of Messiah he is, it becomes clear what kind of followers he wants, and he says it to "the crowd" as well as the Twelve, so that it is not a rule for a spiritual elite. The promise tucked inside is a paradox, a saying that sounds impossible until you see that it is true: the way to keep your life is to stop clutching it. If Mark wrote in Rome in the 60s, as the old witnesses suggest, his first readers did not need the image explained. The historian Tacitus records that under Nero, Christians in Rome were crucified and burned (Annals 15.44). A believer hearing these lines read aloud may have known people who had taken them literally.

(Q) "If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me. For whoever would save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake and the gospel’s will save it." + Source: Mark 8:34–35 (English Standard Version). Jesus has called the crowd together with his disciples, on the road near Caesarea Philippi, moments after rebuking Peter (Mark 8:33).

(T5) The disciples fail badly, and the risen Lord goes ahead of them anyway. + If you were publishing a founder’s memoir to win people over, you would probably trim the parts where the senior leadership looks foolish. Mark does the opposite. The Twelve misunderstand the parables and panic in the boat, and when the soldiers come, "they all left him and fled" (Mark 14:50). Peter, the great source behind the book, swears three times that he never knew the man, and the scene closes on him breaking down and weeping (Mark 14:72). If the old witnesses are right, the story of that failure is one Peter told on himself, again and again, to crowds in Rome. Mark even adds a figure no other Gospel mentions: a young man who follows the arrest wearing only a linen cloth, is grabbed, and runs off naked (Mark 14:51–52). Why tell it? Since the nineteenth century many readers have wondered whether this is the author signing his work in a corner, the way a painter might put his own face in a crowd scene. No ancient writer says so, and it remains a pleasant guess. But the man who ran from Perga would have understood it. Then comes the empty tomb, and the most tender two words in the book. The women are told, "go, tell his disciples and Peter" (Mark 16:7). Those two words are "and Peter." The one who denied him is named. In the oldest complete manuscripts the Gospel then stops at once, with the women fleeing, afraid (Mark 16:8). Whether Mark meant to end there or the original ending was lost, nobody knows. What the book leaves ringing is that Jesus has gone ahead of them, that the failures are invited to meet him, and that the story is not over. A deserter who was given a second chance knew something about that.

(Q) "Do not be alarmed. You seek Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He has risen; he is not here. See the place where they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter that he is going before you to Galilee. There you will see him, just as he told you." + Source: Mark 16:6–7 (English Standard Version). The speaker is the young man in a white robe, addressing Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James, and Salome inside the tomb. Galilee is where it all began (Mark 1:14), and the disciples are being sent back to the beginning.

(Q) "Mark, having become the interpreter of Peter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, whatsoever he remembered of the things said or done by Christ." + Source: Papias of Hierapolis, quoted in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 3.39.15 (A. C. McGiffert translation). Not Mark’s words but the earliest words about him, which Papias credits to an elder he calls "the presbyter," the old Greek word for just that. Here the church’s memory of Mark begins, and it begins by naming Peter behind him.

What the Church Made of Him

(†) From the earliest report onward, the church received his Gospel as Peter’s testimony set down by Mark. + The witnesses come from all over the Roman world and say the same thing. Papias in Asia Minor, around AD 110, calls Mark the interpreter of Peter. Justin Martyr, a Christian teacher in Rome around AD 155, notes that Jesus renamed one of his apostles Peter and then cites "the memoirs of Him," which many read as Peter’s memoirs, though the pronoun could also point to Jesus. In the same breath he mentions the nickname Boanerges, "sons of thunder," which appears in only one Gospel: Mark (Dialogue with Trypho 106; Mark 3:17). Irenaeus, in Gaul around AD 180, says "Mark, the disciple and interpreter of Peter, did also hand down to us in writing what had been preached by Peter" (Against Heresies 3.1.1). Clement in Alexandria, and after him Origen, the most learned Christian scholar of his day, report the same (Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 6.14.6; 6.25.5). Think about what that name is doing. Later Christian writers who forged gospels reached for the most impressive names they could find: Peter, Thomas, Philip, even Mary. Nobody trying to give a book authority would invent a Gospel "according to Mark," a secondhand witness and no apostle, whom readers of Acts knew best as the man who went home. No other name was ever attached to the book. The simplest explanation is that it was his. That same attribution has drawn fresh attention in recent decades. Richard Bauckham, a British New Testament scholar, in Jesus and the Eyewitnesses (2006), points out that Simon Peter is the first disciple named in the Gospel (Mark 1:16) and the last (Mark 16:7), and argues that this is an ancient way of marking the book’s chief eyewitness, like bookends set around a shelf.

(†) Long treated as a mere summary of Matthew, his Gospel came in the nineteenth century to be seen by most scholars as the first one written. + For well over a thousand years, Mark was the Gospel people owned and rarely opened. Nearly all of it reappears in Matthew, and much of it in Luke, and both of those add the Sermon on the Mount, the Christmas stories, and a great deal more. Why read the shorter book? Augustine, the great bishop of North Africa, writing around AD 400, gave the settled opinion when he said of Matthew that Mark "follows him closely, and looks like his attendant and epitomizer" (Harmony of the Gospels 1.2.4), an epitomizer being someone who writes a short digest of a longer book. Commentaries on Matthew and John piled up in the early centuries, while Mark waited. The earliest known commentary on his book is a late Greek compilation of older comments, gathered under the name of Victor of Antioch, and after it comes a Latin commentary of about the seventh century, long credited to Jerome. The first by a major Western writer came from Bede, the English monk, in the eighth century. The reversal came in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, as scholars laid the Gospels side by side and asked who was copying whom. It seemed to many of them far likelier that Matthew and Luke had each expanded Mark than that Mark had dropped the Sermon on the Mount from Matthew. Most scholars have held Mark to be the first Gospel ever since, though a minority still defend Matthew’s priority, which is simply the view that Matthew came first. Augustine held it, and Clement’s report that the Gospels with genealogies (family trees of Jesus) came first would suggest it. Either way, the overlooked little book moved to the center of the study of the historical Jesus, the attempt to work out what can be known of his life by the ordinary methods of historians. It is a striking turn for a man once thought not worth taking along: if the majority is right, two other evangelists followed where he had gone first.

(†) Alexandria claimed him as its founder, Venice claimed his bones, and Christian art gave him the lion. + The Coptic Orthodox Church of Egypt, the country’s ancient Christian church, counts its popes (its own line of leaders, separate from the pope in Rome) as the successors of Mark in an unbroken line, and calls him the founder of Christianity in Africa. The whole of the Alexandrian church’s memory, including its great theologians like Athanasius and Cyril, runs back to him in its own reckoning. Its old liturgy, the order of worship used there, carries his name, though in its present form it is much later than he was. He is honored by East and West alike on April 25, and by the Copts, as that church’s members are called, on a date of their own calendar. In AD 828, Venetian merchants carried off from Alexandria what were said to be his relics (the physical remains of a saint, kept and honored by the faithful), smuggled past the customs men, as the story has it, under a load of pork. The basilica of St. Mark in Venice was built to house them, and the winged lion became the city’s emblem. In 1968 Pope Paul VI sent a portion of the relics back to Pope Cyril VI of Alexandria. The lion itself comes from the four living creatures around God’s throne in Revelation 4:7, which early Christians matched to the four Gospels. Irenaeus actually gave the lion to John and the eagle to Mark (Against Heresies 3.11.8). The assignment that stuck appears in Victorinus of Pettau, a bishop in what is now Slovenia, late in the third century, and Jerome took it up. It started from the voice crying in the wilderness at the opening of Mark, which readers heard as a lion’s roar.

(†) Where he fell short: he left the mission at Perga, and Paul counted it desertion until Paul himself named him a fellow worker. + The first-century record holds one fault against Mark. He had "withdrawn from them in Pamphylia," and Paul judged that seriously enough to end a partnership over it (Acts 15:38–39). We should not soften that, since Paul did not. Whatever his reason for going, others were left to carry on without their assistant into hard country, and Paul was stoned nearly to death on that very journey (Acts 14:19). But it is the only fault on record, and the same witnesses who record it record how it ended. The last word from Paul on Mark is not "withdrawn" but "useful" (2 Timothy 4:11). If a page of the New Testament ever gave a failed young Christian grounds to try again, it is the one in which the man who refused Mark asks for him by name.

Mark left one book, and the church has copied it more or less continuously ever since. Everything else we know of him comes from a handful of mentions in the New Testament and from a chain of early witnesses, and several later writings have borrowed his name. His one work - The Gospel according to Mark: The shortest of the four Gospels, sixteen chapters of plain, fast Greek, written for a largely non-Jewish audience, probably in Rome. It tells the story of Jesus from John the Baptist to the empty tomb, and most scholars take it to be the source of the shared narrative in Matthew and Luke (T1–T5). The title "according to Mark" is the form attached to it in the manuscripts, and no other author was ever proposed. • 1:1–13: The opening: John the Baptist, the baptism of Jesus, and the temptation in the wilderness, all at speed (T1). • 1:14–8:26: The ministry in Galilee and around it: healings, parables, the calming of the storm, forgiveness of the paralytic, feedings, and growing opposition (T2). • 8:27–10:52: The road to Jerusalem: Peter’s confession at Caesarea Philippi, three predictions of the passion, and the teaching on the cross and on service (T3, T4). • 11:1–15:47: The final week: the entry into Jerusalem, the temple, the discourse on the end, the Last Supper, Gethsemane, the arrest, Peter’s denial, the trial, the crucifixion, and the burial (T3, T5). • 16:1–8: The women at the empty tomb and the message for "his disciples and Peter" (T5). The endings added after 16:8 The two oldest complete manuscripts, Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus of the fourth century, stop at 16:8 (a codex is simply a book with pages, rather than a scroll). Eusebius reports that the accurate copies known to him, almost all of them in fact, ended there, and Jerome, following him, repeats that almost all the Greek copies lacked what comes after. Three additions circulated, and none is judged by most textual scholars (those who study how ancient copies relate) to be from Mark’s own hand. - The longer ending (Mark 16:9–20): Appearances of the risen Jesus, the great commission (his charge to carry the gospel to all the world), and the ascension. Known by the second century, since Irenaeus quotes it as Mark (Against Heresies 3.10.5 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, 3.10.6 in the modern critical edition), and found in the great majority of manuscripts. The church has read it as Scripture in many traditions, and the ESV prints it set apart with a note. - The shorter ending: A sentence or two reporting that the women told Peter’s circle and that Jesus sent out the message of salvation. Its only standalone witness is the Old Latin Codex Bobbiensis (Old Latin meaning the translations made before Jerome’s); elsewhere it is joined to the longer ending. - The Freer Logion: A saying added after 16:14 in the fifth-century Codex Washingtonianus, in which the disciples excuse their unbelief and Jesus answers them. Jerome knew part of it (Against the Pelagians 2.15). A logion is simply a saying. The first-century witnesses about him - Acts 12:12–17: Peter at the gate of Mary’s house, and the first mention of her son. - Acts 12:25; 13:5; 13:13: Mark brought to Antioch, assisting on Cyprus, and leaving at Perga. - Acts 15:36–41: The quarrel between Paul and Barnabas over him, and the voyage to Cyprus. - Colossians 4:10–11: Paul’s greeting from "Mark the cousin of Barnabas," a fellow worker and comfort, and the only source for the family tie. - Philemon 1:24: Named as a fellow worker beside Luke. - 2 Timothy 4:11: Paul’s last request: "Get Mark and bring him with you." - 1 Peter 5:13: "Mark, my son," with Peter at "Babylon," which is Rome. The early witnesses to his Gospel - Papias of Hierapolis, c. AD 110, in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 3.39.15: The oldest report: Mark as Peter’s interpreter, accurate though not in order (Q, after T5). - Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 106, c. AD 155: Cites "the memoirs of Him," often read as Peter’s memoirs, for a detail found only in Mark. - Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.1.1, c. AD 180: Mark hands down in writing what Peter preached, after the "departure" of Peter and Paul. - Clement of Alexandria, Hypotyposes, c. AD 200, in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 2.15 and 6.14.5–7: The hearers in Rome ask Mark to write; Peter "neither directly forbade nor encouraged it" in one report, and sanctions the book in the other, with Eusebius passing on both. The Hypotyposes, or Outlines, survives only in fragments like these. - Tertullian, Against Marcion 4.5, early third century: What Mark published "may be affirmed to be Peter’s whose interpreter Mark was." - Hippolytus, Refutation of All Heresies 7.30 (7.18 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers), c. AD 225: The nickname, "he of the maimed finger." - The Muratorian Fragment, of debated date: An early Latin list of New Testament books whose opening is torn away. Its first surviving words, "at which nevertheless he was present," are usually taken as the end of a sentence on Mark, since the next line calls Luke the third Gospel. - The so-called Anti-Marcionite Prologue: A short Latin preface to the Gospel, of debated date (perhaps second to fourth century). Reports the nickname "stump-fingered," explains it by the shortness of his fingers, and places the writing in Italy after Peter’s death. The name comes from a 1928 theory that such prefaces were written against Marcion, a second-century teacher who cut down the New Testament. - Origen, Commentary on Matthew, in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 6.25.5, third century: The second Gospel is "by Mark, who composed it according to the instructions of Peter." - Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 2.15–16, 2.24, early fourth century: Gathers the Roman tradition and adds what "they say" of Egypt and Annianus. - Jerome, On Illustrious Men 8, AD 392–393: The classic short life, with the death in the eighth year of Nero and burial at Alexandria. - Augustine, Harmony of the Gospels 1.2.4, c. AD 400: Mark as Matthew’s "attendant and epitomizer," the verdict that stood for centuries. Attributed to him or told of him, but not his - The Martyrdom of Mark (also called the Acts of Mark): A Greek account of perhaps the fourth or fifth century, telling of his preaching at Alexandria, the cobbler Annianus whose wounded hand he healed, and his death by dragging. Legendary, and the foundation of the later tradition of his martyrdom. - The Acts and Miracles of Mark: A separate Byzantine compilation in Greek, later than AD 1000, which expands the Martyrdom and gives him an early life and travels with Barnabas, Paul and Peter. Easily confused with the older book, and of no independent worth as history. - The Liturgy of St. Mark: The ancient Greek order of worship of the Alexandrian church. Its core is old, but it comes from the church that honored him, not from him. - The Acts of Barnabas: A fifth-century Cypriot book claiming to be written by John Mark, telling of Barnabas’s last journey and death. Not by him. - The "Secret Gospel of Mark": Known only from a letter attributed to Clement of Alexandria, which Morton Smith, an American scholar, reported finding copied into a book at the Mar Saba monastery in 1958. The letter cites a longer, private edition of Mark. The manuscript survives only in photographs, and whether the letter is a real ancient text or a modern forgery remains in dispute. Nothing in the early church knows of such a book. Standard editions and further reading: the New Testament in Nestle-Aland, 28th edition, the standard scholarly edition of the Greek text; in English the ESV, the translation quoted throughout. Eusebius in the A. C. McGiffert translation (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, volume 1); Jerome’s On Illustrious Men in the E. C. Richardson translation (volume 3 of the same series); Irenaeus, Justin and Hippolytus in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, volumes 1 and 5; Augustine’s Harmony in the S. D. F. Salmond translation (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series, volume 6). All are in the public domain. Modern discussion: Richard Bauckham, Jesus and the Eyewitnesses (Eerdmans, 2006; 2nd ed. 2017).

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief