Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

The Hellenistic & Roman World

300 BC – 300 AD

Lucian of Samosata c. 125 – after 180 AD

(●) The great comic writer of the Roman world, who laughed at the gods, the philosophers and the frauds, and left one of the fullest early pagan descriptions of the Christians. + Imagine a stand-up comedian who has read everything. That is close to Lucian. He grew up speaking a Syrian dialect on the banks of the Euphrates, learned Greek well enough to write it more purely than most Greeks of his day, and spent his best years writing short, funny, merciless dialogues: the gods squabbling on Olympus, dead kings stripped of their crowns on the ferry to the underworld, philosophers auctioned off like slaves to the highest bidder. He is on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. The first is that he did, from the pagan side, much of what the early Christian apologists were doing: he took the gods of Homer at their word and showed that, taken at their word, they could not be worshipped. The second is that he looked at the Christians themselves, around AD 165, and described what he saw. He did not like them. He thought them simple, easy marks for any clever swindler. But a hostile witness who has no reason to flatter is exactly the witness a historian values, and what Lucian saw (a crucified founder still worshipped, a brotherhood that cared for its prisoners, sacred books read aloud, a contempt for death) matches the New Testament picture of the church at point after point. Almost everything known about his life comes from his own writings, and he was a writer who loved to wear masks. So his dates are approximate. Apart from the Olympic Games of AD 165, nearly every date in his story is an estimate, pieced together from hints he dropped in the works themselves, the way you might guess a stranger’s age from the songs he remembers. About eighty pieces come down under his name, and most of them are genuine.

(●) c. 125 AD: Born a Syrian at Samosata, he broke his first piece of marble and chose learning over the sculptor’s trade. + Samosata was a river town on the upper Euphrates, in the old kingdom of Commagene, which Rome had swallowed into its province of Syria. Lucian was born there around AD 125 (the year is an estimate scholars work back to from his own remarks about his age). His family was not well off. Greek was not his first language, and late in life he could still call himself, with a wink, a "barbarian" and "the Syrian." He tells the story of his boyhood in a short piece called The Vision. When he finished school, his father called a council of friends to choose him a trade, something quick to learn and quick to pay. As a schoolboy he had scraped the wax off his writing tablets to model cows and horses and little people, so the council sent him to his mother’s brother, a sculptor. On his first day his uncle handed him a chisel and told him to tap a marble slab gently. He hit it too hard, the slab broke, and his uncle took a stick to him. He ran home in tears. That night, he says, he dreamed of two women pulling him by the hands. One was Sculpture, a working woman with dusty hair and calloused hands, promising honest labour. The other was Culture (the Greek word is Paideia, education in the whole literary inheritance of Greece), who promised him fame, eloquence and a name men would honour. Before she had finished speaking, he had chosen her. Whether the dream happened as he tells it, nobody can say; he told it decades later, to an audience in his home town, as a lesson that a poor boy could rise.

(●) c. 145–160 AD: He made his name as a travelling orator, from Ionia to Italy and Gaul. + The second century was the age of the star speaker. A famous orator arriving in a city was an event, rather the way a touring celebrity is now, and the men who could hold a theatre spellbound with an improvised speech on any subject the audience shouted out were rich and admired. The Greeks called such a man a sophist or rhetor: a professional of public speaking, who taught pupils, wrote speeches for clients and gave paid displays of his skill. Lucian went west to Ionia, the Greek coast of what is now Turkey, and made himself one. He seems to have taught himself largely by reading the classic Athenian orators, historians and poets until he could write like them. Some of his practice speeches survive: a mock-trial on behalf of a man who killed a tyrant’s son, a speech in praise of a fly. He worked his way through Greece and Italy and settled for a time in Gaul, roughly modern France, where, he later boasted, he was one of the speakers who could command the highest fees.

(●) c. 165 AD: At about forty he settled in Athens and turned from speeches to comic dialogue, the form he claimed as his own invention. + In his thirties Lucian came home a success, then moved on, by way of Antioch, to Athens, taking his father with him. There, at about forty, he did something he regarded as the one truly original act of his life. He gave up rhetoric and took up dialogue. A dialogue, in the Greek tradition, meant the philosophical conversation of the kind Plato wrote: two or three characters reasoning their way, question by question, toward the truth. Lucian married it to comedy. He kept the question-and-answer form but filled it with jokes, fantasy and satire, and wrote it to be read aloud for entertainment. In The Double Indictment he puts himself on trial before the gods as "the Syrian," accused by Rhetoric of deserting her and by Dialogue of dragging him down from philosophy to farce. He wins both cases. The next ten years or so, roughly AD 165 to 175, produced nearly all the works he is remembered for, written in Athens and read to audiences on tours of other cities.

(●) 165 AD: At the Olympic Games he watched the philosopher Peregrinus burn himself alive, and wrote down what he knew of the man’s years among the Christians. + Peregrinus, who called himself Proteus, was a Cynic, a member of the school of street philosophers who lived rough, owned nothing and insulted everyone in the name of virtue. He had announced that at the Olympic Games of AD 165 he would build a pyre and throw himself on it, to teach men to despise death. Lucian was in the crowd. He watched the old man, at night and by moonlight, step into the flames, and he wrote it all up in a letter to a friend, The Passing of Peregrinus. Lucian thought the whole thing was vanity: a man who would do anything to be talked about, including die. Along the way, though, he reports a speech he heard before the burning at Elis, the city that ran the Games. The speaker is not named, and readers have long suspected he was Lucian himself. He told the crowd about the old man’s earlier career, and part of that career was spent among the Christians in Palestine. Peregrinus, the speaker says, learned their "queer creed," rose to be a leader and interpreter of their books, was imprisoned for it, and lived well for years on the gifts they showered on him, until they caught him doing something forbidden and threw him out. Lucian meant it as a story about a con man. It became one of the most valuable outside descriptions of second-century Christianity in existence (T4).

(●) c. 160s AD: He bit the hand of a false prophet, and the prophet tried to have him drowned. + An oracle, in the ancient world, was a shrine where people paid to put their questions to a god and receive an answer, rather the way a worried person today might pay a fortune-teller, except that governments consulted them too. On the Black Sea coast, in a little town called Abonoteichus, a handsome operator named Alexander had built a booming oracle around a tame snake fitted with a linen human head. He called it Glycon, the new incarnation of the healing god Asclepius, and sold its answers to questions sealed in scrolls (which his staff quietly opened, read and resealed). Senators and governors consulted it. Lucian thought it a scandal, and when he passed through the town with a small military escort, Alexander, who knew his reputation, invited him in. What happened next Lucian tells without a trace of shame. Alexander held out his hand to be kissed, as he did with everyone. Lucian took it and bit it, hard. The crowd wanted to strangle him; Alexander, smooth as ever, calmed them, made friends, and offered Lucian a ship for the next stage of his journey. Halfway across, the captain broke down in tears and confessed that his orders were to throw his passengers overboard. He could not do it, he said: he was sixty and had lived an honest life. He put them ashore instead, and Lucian made it safely to the city of Amastris on a passing ship. From then on, he says, it was war between the two of them.

(●) After 180 AD: He wrote his exposé of the prophet, held a government post in Egypt in his later years, and died at a date no one recorded. + Lucian took his revenge in ink. Alexander the False Prophet, dedicated to a friend named Celsus, lays out the whole machinery of the oracle: the snake, the linen head, the opened scrolls, the network of agents. He wrote it after Alexander’s death. There is also a small clue to the date. When he comes to Marcus Aurelius’s wars against the Germanic tribes, he gives the emperor the honorific title Romans gave only to an emperor who had died and been declared a god (section 48 of the book). Marcus died in AD 180, so the book belongs after that. (Whether this Celsus is the Platonist who wrote against the Christians is a question his own biography takes up.) In his later years (the date is uncertain: some scholars place it under Marcus Aurelius, others under his son Commodus) Lucian accepted a salaried post on the staff of the Roman governor of Egypt, and wrote a slightly embarrassed defence of himself, since years before he had written a scathing essay on educated men who sell themselves into the service of great households. He suffered from gout and wrote a comic play about it. After that the record goes quiet. We do not know when or where he died. A Byzantine dictionary of the tenth century, the Suda, says he was torn to pieces by dogs for blaspheming Christ; the story appears nowhere earlier and is almost certainly a pious legend, the kind of ending later readers thought a mocker deserved.

What He Taught

(T1) The gods of Homer, taken at their word, are absurd, and no one should worship them. + Lucian’s favourite trick was simple: take the old stories seriously, and watch them fall apart. In the Dialogues of the Gods, Zeus and Hera bicker like an unhappy couple over his affairs, Hermes complains that he is overworked, and the whole of Olympus behaves like a petty royal court. In Zeus Rants the gods hold an emergency meeting because two philosophers are publicly debating whether gods exist at all, and the gods’ side is losing. The sharpest of these pieces is Zeus Cross-Examined. A Cynic named Cyniscus asks Zeus a simple question. The poets say that the Fates spin every man’s destiny at birth, and that nothing can change it. Zeus agrees: even the gods hang from the Fates’ thread. Then why, Cyniscus asks, does anyone bother to sacrifice to you? Zeus has no answer. It is a real argument, not just a joke: a god who is himself a puppet of fate cannot hear a prayer and do anything about it. Christians had been making the same point for decades. The apologists of the second century (Christian writers who defended the faith in public, from the Greek apologia, a speech for the defence in court), Justin, Athenagoras and Tatian, and a generation later Clement of Alexandria, filled pages with the scandals of the Olympians to show that such beings were not divine. Lucian had no God to offer in their place. But his demolition of the old gods was so thorough that later Christian readers often treated him as an unexpected ally.

(Q) "If the case stands thus, if the Fates are mistresses of all, and their decisions unalterable, then why do men sacrifice to you, and bring hecatombs, and pray for good at your hands? If our prayers can neither save us from evil nor procure us any boon from Heaven, I fail to see what we get for our trouble." + Source: Lucian, Zeus Cross-Examined 5 (H. W. and F. G. Fowler translation, 1905). Cyniscus has just got Zeus to admit that the gods themselves hang from the thread of the Fates. A hecatomb is a great public sacrifice, originally of a hundred oxen.

(T2) No philosophy has proved that it alone is true, so the wise man holds them all at arm’s length. + Lucian loved philosophy and despised most philosophers. In Philosophies for Sale, Zeus and Hermes auction off the founders of the great schools like slaves: Pythagoras, Diogenes, Socrates, the Stoic Chrysippus, each one demonstrating his wares for bidders, and most of them going cheap. In The Fisherman the angry philosophers come back from the dead to punish him for it, and he wins them over by arguing that he attacks only the fakes who wear their cloaks and beards. His most serious work is the long dialogue Hermotimus. Hermotimus is a sincere old student who has spent twenty years following a teacher of the Stoic school, which taught that virtue is the only true good and that the wise man meets whatever fate sends with calm, and expects to reach wisdom in another twenty. Lycinus, Lucian’s stand-in, gently asks how he knew the Stoics were the right school in the first place. You cannot judge a road you have never walked, so to choose fairly among the schools you would have to study each one as long as Hermotimus has studied Stoicism. It is like being told to choose a spouse only after living twenty years with every candidate. They do the arithmetic together, and the answer comes to more than two hundred years. The conclusion is skepticism: the view that we cannot know which of the great systems is true, so the honest man suspends judgment and gets on with living decently. This is the point where Lucian’s honesty becomes his limit. His argument assumes that truth can only be reached by a mind testing every system for itself, from the inside, for decades. The Christian claim is different in kind. It is not one more school to be sampled for twenty years. It is a report of something that happened in public, at a particular time and place, and a report like that can be weighed the way any testimony is weighed, by asking who saw it and whether they can be trusted (T3).

(Q) "Well, let us add up. Twenty years we gave Pythagoras, the same to Plato, and so to the others. What will the total come to, if we assume only ten schools?" + Source: Lucian, Hermotimus 48 (H. W. and F. G. Fowler translation, 1905). Lycinus is speaking. Hermotimus replies, "Over two hundred years," and the dialogue’s skeptical conclusion follows from that sum.

(T3) The historian’s whole duty is to tell what happened, flattering no one. + In AD 165 Rome was at war with Parthia, the great empire to the east, and every literary man in the Greek cities seemed to be writing a history of it. Most of these histories were dreadful: battle reports dressed up as epic poetry, emperors praised to the skies, invented casualty figures, a general who reached the enemy capital in the author’s imagination long before he reached it on the map. Lucian wrote a short, sharp handbook in reply, How to Write History, the only treatise on the subject to survive from the ancient world. His rule is the one a careful juror would apply to any witness. The historian must be fearless, incorruptible and free, must not care whom he offends, and must write for readers not yet born rather than for the patron in the front row. He must find out the facts himself where he can, and where he cannot, prefer the witnesses with no reason to bend the story. His model is Thucydides, the Athenian who wrote, he said, a possession for all time. There is a quiet irony here that Christian readers have always enjoyed. Lucian’s standard is exactly the standard the Gospel writers claim for themselves. Luke opens his Gospel by saying that he "followed all things closely for some time past" and drew on those "who from the beginning were eyewitnesses" (Luke 1:2–3). The Gospels ask to be judged as history by the rule Lucian laid down.

(Q) "The historian’s one task is to tell the thing as it happened." + Source: Lucian, How to Write History 39 (H. W. and F. G. Fowler translation, 1905, where it is titled The Way to Write History). A little later he adds that the man who takes up history "must sacrifice to no God but Truth."

(T4) Most people would rather believe a marvel than the truth, and every fraud lives off them. + The question that runs through Lucian’s later work is why sensible people believe nonsense. The Lover of Lies is set at the sickbed of a rich old man, where a roomful of distinguished philosophers swap ghost stories, each more incredible than the last, and swear to every one of them. One is the tale of a magician’s pupil who brings a pestle to life to fetch water and cannot make it stop: the story that, sixteen centuries later, became Goethe’s poem and Disney’s "Sorcerer’s Apprentice." The narrator leaves in disgust. Alexander the False Prophet shows the same weakness turned into a business. And The Passing of Peregrinus shows it in a group Lucian thought especially soft: the Christians. They believe, he says, that they are immortal, so they despise death; their founder taught them they are all brothers; and they "take quite on trust" everything they are told, which makes them easy prey for any smooth talker who joins them. Look at what he has described, though. A crucified founder still worshipped as divine. A community of brothers and sisters who visit their prisoners at dawn, feed them, and send delegations from city to city to help. A people who share their goods, read their sacred writings together, and do not fear death. Lucian thought he was describing gullibility. He was also describing, from the outside and without a shred of sympathy, the church of Acts 2 and Hebrews 13.

(Q) "You see, these misguided creatures start with the general conviction that they are immortal for all time, which explains the contempt of death and voluntary self-devotion which are so common among them; and then it was impressed on them by their original lawgiver that they are all brothers, from the moment that they are converted, and deny the gods of Greece, and worship the crucified sage, and live after his laws." + Source: Lucian, The Passing of Peregrinus 13 (H. W. and F. G. Fowler translation, 1905, where it is titled The Death of Peregrine). The words come from the speech Lucian gives to an unnamed man at Elis who answers the admirers of Peregrinus, still alive and waiting for his pyre, a speaker readers have long taken for Lucian himself. A few lines earlier the speaker has said that the Christians "worship a man to this day," the one "who introduced their novel rites, and was crucified on that account" (11).

(Q) "He led the litany with, 'Christians, avaunt!' and the crowd responded, 'Epicureans, avaunt!'" + Source: Lucian, Alexander the False Prophet 38 (H. W. and F. G. Fowler translation, 1905, where it is titled Alexander the Oracle-Monger). This is the opening of the mystery rites Alexander set up, secret ceremonies open only to initiates. A proclamation first ordered any "atheist or Christian or Epicurean" to leave. Then came the litany, a chant in which a leader calls out a line and the crowd answers it. "Avaunt" is old English for "be gone." The fraud knew which two groups would not be fooled by his snake: the Epicurean philosophers, who denied that the gods meddle in human affairs, and the Christians, who worshipped one God and no other. Earlier in the book Alexander had urged the people of Pontus to stone the "atheists and Christians" who spread reports against him (25).

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) His sneer became evidence: an outsider’s confirmation of how the early church lived and whom it worshipped. + When historians ask what non-Christian writers of the first two centuries said about Jesus and his followers, Lucian stands in a short line with the Roman historian Tacitus, the governor Pliny the Younger, the biographer Suetonius and the Platonist Celsus. He is valuable for the same reason they are: he had no reason to help. Set what he says beside the New Testament and the match is striking: - A crucified founder, worshipped. "The Christians, you know, worship a man to this day," crucified for introducing his teaching (Peregrinus 11). Compare Paul: "we preach Christ crucified" (1 Corinthians 1:23). - Prisoners visited and fed. Widows and orphans waiting outside the jail at dawn, meals carried in (Peregrinus 12). Compare "Remember those who are in prison, as though in prison with them" (Hebrews 13:3). - Goods held in common. They "despise all worldly goods alike, regarding them merely as common property" (Peregrinus 13). Compare Acts 4:32. - Churches helping one another across cities. Delegations sent from the cities of Asia to support a brother in chains (Peregrinus 13), the same network of letters and visitors the epistles show. - Discipline. In the end the Christians threw Peregrinus out, apparently for eating forbidden food (Peregrinus 16), which is to say they did eventually see through him. A satirist who meant to show how foolish the Christians were left instead a snapshot of a second-century church doing what its Lord had told it to do.

(†) Byzantine Christians kept his books, schooled their sons on his Greek, and argued about his soul. + It is a small paradox that we have Lucian at all only because Christian copyists kept him. The monks and scholars of the Byzantine empire, the Greek-speaking Christian empire centred on Constantinople, valued him as a model of pure Attic Greek, the classical Greek of Athens that every educated writer was taught to imitate, and his dialogues became schoolbooks. They were also glad of an ancient pagan who had made the old gods ridiculous. Their feelings about the man were mixed. Photius, the learned patriarch (chief bishop) of Constantinople in the ninth century, praised his style in his great book of reading notes, and judged that he mocked the beliefs of the pagans while holding no belief of his own. Other readers wrote angry notes in the margins of their copies, calling him a blasphemer, and the Suda’s story of his death by dogs grew out of the same anger. One satire against Christians that circulated under his name, the Philopatris, is now known to have been written by a Byzantine author centuries after he died.

(†) Erasmus and Thomas More translated him together, and taught Christian satire to laugh. + When Greek learning came back to western Europe in the fifteenth century, Lucian was one of its favourites. In 1506 two friends, the Dutch scholar Desiderius Erasmus and the English lawyer Thomas More, published Latin translations of a set of his dialogues side by side. Both men went on to write the most famous Christian satires of the Renaissance, Erasmus’s Praise of Folly and More’s Utopia, and both books carry Lucian’s fingerprints: the mock praise, the imaginary voyage, the straight face over an absurd world. In Utopia itself, the traveller who visits the island says the Utopians were delighted by Lucian’s wit. Erasmus and More were humanists, scholars who went back past the medieval textbooks to the original Greek and Latin writers and to the Bible in its own languages. What these Christian humanists took from Lucian was a tool: that laughter can be a form of honesty, and that a pompous lie, whether it wears a philosopher’s beard or a bishop’s mitre, is sometimes best answered by showing how silly it looks. They aimed the tool at the corruptions of their own church, and in doing so they made satire one of the voices of Christian reform.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: he mistook faith for credulity, and his doubt left him nowhere to stand. + Lucian looked straight at the Christians and called them gullible, and that judgment deserves an answer rather than a shrug. - Faith is not credulity. Lucian lumped the Christians in with the crowds at Alexander’s snake. But the apostles did not ask anyone to believe a marvel on a stranger’s say-so. They pointed to public events and named witnesses: "he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive" (1 Corinthians 15:6). And the New Testament warns against the very fraud Lucian exposed: "do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world" (1 John 4:1). - His own story shows the church testing. The Christians did, in the end, throw Peregrinus out (Peregrinus 16). A manual of church order written before his day, the Didache, tells congregations that a travelling apostle who asks for money is a false prophet (Didache 11). The churches knew about men like Peregrinus and had rules for them. - His history rule, applied. Lucian taught that a historian must "tell the thing as it happened" (T3). The Christian answer to his scorn is to take him at his word: weigh the testimony to the resurrection by the standard he set for weighing any testimony. He never did. - Doubt with nowhere to stand. The Hermotimus concludes that no one can know which philosophy is true (T2), yet Lucian himself plainly believed in honesty, courage and decency, and held up his friend Demonax as the best philosopher he ever knew. Mockery is like a demolition crew: it can clear away false gods, but it cannot put up anything in their place. It cannot say why truth and goodness matter, and Lucian, who served both all his life, never offered a reason. A century earlier, in the same Athens, Paul had pointed the Athenians to an altar of theirs dedicated to an unknown god, and offered them what Lucian never found: the God they already worshipped "as unknown" (Acts 17:23), now named. None of this needs Lucian to have been a villain. He was a brilliant, funny, honest man who hated lies and saw a great many of them. He simply looked at the one claim that was not a lie, and laughed at it too.

About eighty pieces come down under Lucian’s name, preserved by Byzantine copyists who prized his Attic Greek. Most are genuine; a dozen or so are doubted or rejected, and are listed at the end. The traditional order of the corpus follows the manuscripts, not the date of writing; the groups below are by kind, and most of the great dialogues probably fall between about AD 165 and 175. Autobiographical and introductory pieces: - The Vision (or The Dream): The boy, the broken marble, and the dream of Sculpture and Culture, told to his home town as a grown man. - The Double Indictment: Lucian, as "the Syrian," is tried before the gods by Rhetoric for deserting her and by Dialogue for turning him into a clown, and acquitted on both counts. - A Literary Prometheus (You Are a Prometheus in Words): His defence of his invention, the blend of philosophical dialogue and comedy. - Dionysus and Heracles: Short introductory talks, given late in life when he returned to public readings. - Zeuxis, Harmonides, Herodotus (or Aetion), The Scythian: Introductory lectures for reading tours, each opening with an anecdote about an artist or a visitor to Greece. - Swans and Amber: A light lecture that debunks two pretty myths about the river Po, and promises an audience no more than it can deliver. - Apology for "On Salaried Posts": His half-sheepish defence, written in old age after taking a government post in Egypt. - A Slip of the Tongue in Greeting: An elaborate excuse for having greeted a patron with the wrong formula in the morning. Dialogues on the gods and religion: - Dialogues of the Gods: Twenty-five short scenes of Olympian domestic life: Zeus and his affairs, Hera’s jealousy, Hermes run off his feet (T1). - Dialogues of the Sea-Gods: Fifteen comic sketches of Poseidon, the nymphs, the Cyclops and the creatures of the sea. - Zeus Cross-Examined: Cyniscus forces Zeus to admit that if fate rules all, sacrifice is pointless (T1). - Zeus Rants (Zeus Tragoedus): The gods in panic watch two philosophers debate their existence, and the gods’ advocate loses. - The Parliament of the Gods (The Gods in Council): Momus, god of fault-finding, moves to expel the foreign and half-human gods who have crowded onto Olympus. - The Judgement of the Goddesses: Hermes brings Hera, Athena and Aphrodite to the shepherd Paris on Mount Ida, and each goddess tries to buy his vote, Aphrodite winning it with the promise of Helen. - Prometheus (or The Caucasus): Prometheus, chained to his rock, argues that Zeus had no right to punish him for making men. - Icaromenippus: The Cynic Menippus flies to heaven on borrowed wings to settle the philosophers’ disputes, and finds Zeus fielding prayers through trapdoors. - Timon the Misanthrope: Zeus restores the wealth of a man ruined by ungrateful friends, who then beats off the flatterers who come back. - On Sacrifices: A short, scathing essay on what offering animals to the gods implies about the gods. - On Funerals (Of Mourning): The customs of grief, from Greece to Persia, shown to make no sense. - Saturnalia, Cronosolon, and the Saturnalian Letters: The winter festival of Saturn (Cronus), with a poor man’s complaint about the rich and the old god’s rules for a fair holiday. - The Goddess of Syria: A description of the temple of Atargatis at Hierapolis, written in the manner of Herodotus; its authorship has been debated, though many scholars now accept it as his. Dialogues on death and the underworld: - Dialogues of the Dead: Thirty scenes in Hades where kings, beauties and millionaires discover their wealth and rank did not survive the crossing, with the Cynics laughing at them. - Menippus (or The Descent into Hades): Menippus visits the underworld to ask the prophet Tiresias how best to live, and is told to live as ordinary people do and laugh a lot. - Charon (or The Inspectors): The ferryman of the dead takes a day off to look at the living, and is astonished at what they worry about. - The Downward Journey (or The Tyrant): A tyrant tries to bargain his way out of death while a poor cobbler crosses gladly. Dialogues on philosophy and philosophers: - Hermotimus (or On the Schools): His longest and most serious dialogue, concluding that no one can live long enough to test every philosophy and choose the true one (T2). - Philosophies for Sale (Sale of Creeds): Zeus and Hermes auction the founders of the philosophical schools like slaves. - The Fisherman (or The Dead Come to Life): The angry philosophers return from Hades to punish him, and he persuades them that he mocks only the frauds. - The Runaways: An attack on fake Cynics, written after the uproar over Peregrinus. - The Cock (or The Dream): A cobbler’s rooster turns out to be Pythagoras reincarnated, and proves to him that the rich are miserable. - The Banquet (or The Lapiths): A wedding feast where the philosophers end up in a brawl. - The Parasite: A parody of Plato proving that sponging off the rich is an art. - Nigrinus: Warm praise of a Platonist philosopher in Rome and of Athens over Rome; one of his earliest dialogues. - Demonax: A memoir of his friend, the gentle philosopher of Athens, whom he admired above all others, told through sayings and anecdotes. - The Eunuch: Two philosophers dispute whether a eunuch may hold a chair of philosophy; its genuineness is sometimes doubted. - Anacharsis: A Scythian visitor to Athens asks why Greek men wrestle in the mud, and the lawgiver Solon defends athletic training. On fraud, superstition and credulity: - The Passing of Peregrinus: The Cynic who burned himself at Olympia in AD 165, with the account of his years among the Christians (T4). - Alexander the False Prophet: The exposé of the snake oracle at Abonoteichus, dedicated to his friend Celsus, including the bite and the attempted drowning (T4). - The Lover of Lies (The Liar): Philosophers at a sickbed trading ghost stories, including the sorcerer’s apprentice (T4). Fiction and fantasy: - A True Story (True History): A voyage beyond the Atlantic, to the moon, into the belly of a whale and to the Isles of the Blessed, written to parody travellers’ tall tales, whose author announces that the only true thing he will say is that he is lying. - The Ship (or The Wishes): Four friends daydream about what they would do with unlimited wealth, power and magic. - Toxaris (or Friendship): A Greek and a Scythian trade stories of heroic friendship. - Dialogues of the Courtesans: Fifteen sketches of the lives of Athenian courtesans, in the manner of the New Comedy, the stage comedy of everyday Athenian life. Literary criticism and essays: - How to Write History: The only surviving ancient handbook on writing history, prompted by the hacks writing up the Parthian war of AD 162–166 (T3). - Slander (On Not Being Quick to Believe Slander): An analysis of how slander works, framed by a painting of Apelles. - The Ignorant Book-Collector: A rich man who buys rare books as ornaments, and cannot read them. - A Professor of Public Speaking (The Rhetorician’s Vade Mecum): Ironic advice on how to become a famous orator without learning anything. - Lexiphanes: A pretentious writer is purged, literally, of his obsolete words. - The Mistaken Critic (Pseudologista): An abusive reply to a man who mocked him for misusing a word. - Essays in Portraiture and Essays in Portraiture Defended: A composite portrait of Panthea, mistress of the emperor Lucius Verus, and his reply when she thought it too flattering. - The Dance (Of Pantomime): A defence of the pantomime dancer’s art. - The Hall: A display speech on whether a beautiful hall helps or hinders a speaker. - On Salaried Posts in Great Houses (The Dependent Scholar): A bitter account of the humiliations of a learned man living as a rich Roman’s paid companion. - Consonants at Law (Trial in the Court of Vowels): The letter Sigma sues the letter Tau for stealing its words. - A Conversation with Hesiod: The poet is teased for failing to deliver the prophecies he promised. Rhetorical display pieces: - Phalaris I and II: The infamous Sicilian tyrant’s envoys present his bronze bull to the god at Delphi. - The Tyrannicide and Disowned (The Disinherited): Mock legal speeches on imaginary cases. - The Fly: A comic speech in praise of the house fly. - Patriotism (My Native Land): A short speech in praise of one’s homeland. - Dipsas: A display piece on the African snake whose bite brings unquenchable thirst. - Hippias (or The Bath): Praise of a bath-house; its genuineness is doubted. - Gout (Tragodopodagra): A mock tragedy in verse, written by a gouty old man about his own disease. Doubtful or spurious works transmitted under his name: Lucius, or the Ass (a short version of the comic tale of a man turned into a donkey, whose relation to Lucian and to Apuleius’s Golden Ass is still debated), Amores (Affairs of the Heart), Demosthenes, an Encomium, The Cynic, Octogenarians (Longaevi), On Astrology, Halcyon (also transmitted among Plato’s works), Charidemus, Nero, Ocypus, The Purist Purized (Soloecista), the Epigrams (a handful of short poems, most of them doubtful attributions), and the Philopatris, a Byzantine satire on Christians written centuries after his death. Standard English editions: The Works of Lucian of Samosata, translated by H. W. and F. G. Fowler (4 vols, Clarendon Press, 1905), public domain and the translation quoted throughout; the complete Greek text with facing English is the Loeb Classical Library Lucian (8 vols, 1913–1967), translated by A. M. Harmon, K. Kilburn and M. D. Macleod.

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief