Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
Hans Urs von Balthasar of Lucerne 1905 – 1988 AD
(●) The Swiss priest who taught that God’s glory must be seen before it can be argued, and who wrote the great Catholic theology of beauty while the church passed him over. Most defenses of the faith begin with an argument: a first cause, a fine-tuned universe, an empty tomb. Hans Urs von Balthasar began somewhere else. Think of the first time you heard a piece of music that stopped you where you stood. Nobody had to prove to you that it was good; you saw it, or rather heard it, whole, and the proving came afterward if it came at all. Balthasar thought the gospel meets a person like that. The figure of Christ, he argued, carries its own light, and the deepest reason to believe is that a person has actually seen him. He is on a Christian apologetics site because he is the twentieth century’s most sustained answer to a question every apologist eventually faces: why should anyone believe this, rather than merely accept that the arguments have not been refuted? His answer, that love alone is credible, has shaped Catholic thought since the Second Vatican Council (the gathering of the world’s Catholic bishops in Rome in the 1960s that set the course of the modern Catholic Church), and Protestant and Orthodox theologians have taken it up as well. The signature fact is the shape of his career. He held no professorship, was not invited to the Council that his friends shaped, and spent the 1950s without an official post after leaving his religious order. In those years and the ones after them he wrote some fifteen volumes of a single great work, and he died two days before he was to be made a cardinal.
(●) 1905 AD: Born in Lucerne into an old patrician family, a boy who loved music before he loved books. Hans Urs von Balthasar was born on 12 August 1905 in Lucerne, Switzerland, the eldest of three children in one of the city’s old patrician families, the leading households that had governed Lucerne for centuries. His father, Oscar, was an architect who designed churches; his mother, Gabrielle Pietzcker, helped found the Swiss Catholic Women’s League. His brother Dieter later served in the Swiss Guard at the Vatican, the small corps of Swiss soldiers who guard the pope, and his sister Renée became superior general, the head of the whole community, of a Franciscan order of sisters. Looking back, he called the faith of his home "straightforwardly Catholic," and his own faith as a boy just as straightforward, untroubled by doubt. Music came first. As a boy he played the piano seriously, and the story told by those who knew him is that he could carry whole works of Mozart in his head. He was schooled by the Benedictine monks at Engelberg, in the mountains, and then by the Jesuits at the Stella Matutina college in Feldkirch, just across the Austrian border.
(●) 1928 AD: He took a doctorate in German literature, writing on how modern German writers had imagined the end of the world. He left school early, and from 1924 he studied German literature and philosophy at Zurich, with semesters in Vienna and Berlin. In Berlin he heard Romano Guardini, a Catholic priest lecturing on the Christian view of the world to packed halls; in Vienna the psychiatrist and philosopher Rudolf Allers left a mark on him. His doctoral thesis, accepted at Zurich in 1928, traced the "eschatological problem" through modern German literature. Eschatology is the part of theology about last things: death, judgment, the end of history. Balthasar wanted to know what had become of those questions once poets and philosophers stopped believing the Christian answers. He later expanded the thesis into a three-volume work, Apokalypse der deutschen Seele (Apocalypse of the German Soul, 1937 to 1939). More than half a century later he described what he had been after: to bring the giants of German literature and thought to confession, as it were, about the ultimate and often religious attitude underneath their work.
(●) 1929 AD: Called, he said, as suddenly as a lightning strike, he entered the Jesuits and was ordained a priest in 1936. In 1927, during a retreat for students at Wyhlen, just over the German border from Basel, he went walking on a forest path and something happened that he never forgot. Some thirty years later he wrote that he could still find the tree under which he had been struck as if by lightning. What came to him was not a plan for theology or even for the priesthood, he said, but simply this: he had nothing to choose; he had been called. He entered the Society of Jesus, the order founded by Ignatius of Loyola, on 18 November 1929. (Some accounts put the retreat in 1929, the year he entered the order, but the Balthasar Foundation’s chronology dates it to 1927.) The Jesuit training of the time was long. He studied philosophy at Pullach near Munich, where Erich Przywara taught him the analogy of being: the idea that creatures really resemble God, so that the world can tell us something true about him, while the unlikeness is always greater still. Think of a child’s drawing of her mother: really like her, and unlike her in more ways than it is like. He then studied theology at Fourvière in Lyon, where Henri de Lubac pointed him to the church fathers, the Christian writers of the first centuries after the apostles. He found the official textbooks of the day dry, and spent his spare hours reading Origen, Gregory of Nyssa and Maximus the Confessor; books on all three followed. He was ordained a priest in Munich on 26 July 1936.
(●) 1940 AD: As chaplain to the students of Basel he met the physician Adrienne von Speyr, and his life’s work took its shape around that meeting. After two years on the staff of the Jesuit journal Stimmen der Zeit in Munich, he was offered a teaching post at the Gregorian University in Rome, the Jesuits’ great university at the heart of the church. He chose instead to become a student chaplain in Basel, and arrived in 1940, with Europe at war around neutral Switzerland. That year a mutual friend introduced him to Adrienne von Speyr, a Protestant physician, married, with a busy medical practice in the city. He received her into the Catholic Church on 1 November 1940. Soon afterward the intense mystical experiences for which she is known began, and over the following years she dictated some sixty books of prayer and commentary on Scripture, with Balthasar taking them down by hand and publishing them. He came to regard her work and his as two halves of one mission, and he said so plainly to the end of his life. In 1945 the two of them founded the Community of Saint John, a secular institute: a community of lay people who take vows of poverty, chastity and obedience while keeping their ordinary jobs in the world. In 1947 he founded a publishing house, the Johannes Verlag, to print her books and his. Basel was also the city of Karl Barth, the most important Protestant theologian of the century. The two became friends, shared a love of Mozart, and argued about everything; in 1951 Balthasar published a study of Barth’s theology that Barth himself is reported to have regarded as the best book written on it.
(●) 1950 AD: He left the Jesuits to keep faith with the community he had founded, and spent the next decade without a post. His superiors told him that the Society could not take responsibility for the Community of Saint John. Balthasar made the full thirty-day retreat of Ignatius’ Spiritual Exercises, the month of guided silence and prayer every Jesuit makes, concluded that the community was a mission given to him by God, and in 1950 left the order he loved. It cost him nearly everything a priest of his gifts might have expected: no chair at a university, no diocese at first to receive him, for a time no fixed income. A Catholic priest is meant to belong somewhere, either to an order or to a bishop’s diocese, and for those years Balthasar belonged to neither. He supported himself by lecturing and writing, and it was 1956 before the diocese of Chur in Switzerland took him in as one of its priests. He did not go quiet. In 1952 he published Schleifung der Bastionen (Razing the Bastions), a call for the church to pull down the defensive walls it had built against the modern world and go out to meet it. In 1958 he fell seriously ill, an illness diagnosed as leukemia, and lived thirty more years. When the Second Vatican Council met in Rome from 1962 to 1965, his friends de Lubac and Joseph Ratzinger were there as theological advisers. Balthasar was not invited.
(●) 1961 AD: In the years he was passed over, he wrote a fifteen-volume trilogy on the beauty, the drama and the truth of God. The first volume of Herrlichkeit (The Glory of the Lord) appeared in 1961, and the series ran to seven volumes by 1969. It was the first part of a trilogy planned around three of what the old philosophers called the transcendentals, the properties every real thing has simply by being real: the beautiful, the good and the true. The Glory of the Lord treats God’s beauty; Theo-Drama (1973 to 1983, five volumes) treats his goodness, acted out in the drama between God’s freedom and ours; Theo-Logic (1985 to 1987, three volumes) treats his truth. A short epilogue in 1987 closed the whole. The years were not only desk work. Adrienne von Speyr died on 17 September 1967 after long illness, and he took sole charge of the community they had founded. After the Council he grew alarmed at what he saw as a church eager to blend into the world, and in 1966 he published Cordula, a sharp book asking whether a theology that makes everyone already a Christian leaves anything worth dying for. Rome began to listen. Pope Paul VI named him to the new International Theological Commission, a panel of theologians that advises the Vatican on questions of doctrine, in 1969, and in 1972 he joined Ratzinger and de Lubac in founding Communio, an international journal of Catholic theology now published in many languages.
(●) 1988 AD: Named a cardinal by John Paul II, he died in Basel two days before he was to receive the red hat. In 1984 John Paul II gave him the first International Paul VI Prize for theology. On 29 May 1988 the pope announced that Balthasar would be made a cardinal at the consistory of 28 June, the ceremony at which new cardinals receive the red hat. He had reportedly declined the honor once before; this time, tired and ill, he accepted out of obedience and even went to Rome to be measured for the robes. On the morning of 26 June 1988, at his home in Basel, he was getting ready to say Mass when he died, alone. It was two days before the consistory. On his desk lay the finished manuscript of the small book he gave his friends each Christmas; its title was Unless You Become Like This Child. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger preached at his funeral in Lucerne, and he was buried in the family grave at the Hofkirche, the city church of St. Leodegar.
What He Taught
(T1) God’s glory shows itself in a form that must first be seen, the way beauty is seen, before it can be argued about. Stand in front of a great painting and you do not first check its parts against a list and then conclude it is beautiful. You see it whole, all at once, and the seeing is a kind of knowing. Balthasar called this whole that shows itself the form (in German, Gestalt): a figure whose parts make sense only together, the way a face is more than a nose, two eyes and a mouth. His claim is that God’s self-revelation has a form like that. Its center is Jesus Christ, and Scripture’s word for the light that shines from it is glory, "the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ" (2 Corinthians 4:6). That is why he called his work a theological aesthetics. Aesthetics is the study of beauty and how we perceive it, and he did not mean that faith is a matter of taste. He meant that the first act of faith is closer to seeing than to calculating. Modern apologetics, he thought, had tried to prove Christianity from the outside, piece by piece, and in doing so had lost sight of the whole. The disciples did not believe because an argument went through; they believed because they saw who Jesus was. Christians of every tradition can recognize the point, and evangelicals will hear in it something like the old Reformed teaching (the Protestant tradition that runs back to John Calvin) that Scripture carries its own self-evidencing light. The arguments still matter; Balthasar wrote a good many of them. They work best, on his account, as clearing away what keeps a person from seeing.
(Q) "Beauty is the word that shall be our first. Beauty is the last thing which the thinking intellect dares to approach, since only it dances as an uncontained splendour around the double constellation of the true and the good and their inseparable relation to one another." Source: Hans Urs von Balthasar, The Glory of the Lord, vol. 1, Seeing the Form, Introduction, p. 18 (Erasmo Leiva-Merikakis translation). The opening of the whole trilogy. A few lines later he warns that whoever sneers at beauty’s name as if she were the ornament of a bourgeois past "can no longer pray and soon will no longer be able to love."
(T2) Love alone is credible: the gospel shows it is true the way love does, by being a love no one could have invented. Suppose a stranger gives up everything to save your life, and asks nothing back. You might wonder about his motives at first. But at some point the sheer quality of the gift becomes its own evidence: this is not a trick, because no trick would cost so much and gain so little. In a short book of 1963, Glaubhaft ist nur Liebe (Love Alone Is Credible), Balthasar set out the core of his case in about a hundred pages. Christians, he said, have tried two ways of making their faith believable. The first was the way of the fathers and the centuries after them: measure the faith against the whole cosmos, and show that it crowns everything the world’s religions and philosophies had glimpsed. The second is the modern way: measure it against human needs, and show that it answers our deepest longings. He called these the cosmological and the anthropological reductions, and the word carries his worry. To reduce something, in his sense, is to measure it by a standard brought in from outside, and so to shrink it to fit a frame we already own, the way a picture gets cropped to fit a frame bought before anyone had seen the picture. Both ways are partly right, and both end, he thought, by making God fit a frame we supply. His third way is to let revelation be measured only by itself: in the cross, God shows a love so complete that it could not have come from us, and the love is the proof. This is why he could say that the inner reality of love can be recognized only by love. A person who has never loved will find the cross foolish (1 Corinthians 1:18); a person who has been loved can recognize what is happening there.
(Q) "Love alone is credible; nothing else can be believed, and nothing else ought to be believed." Source: Hans Urs von Balthasar, Love Alone Is Credible, p. 101 (D. C. Schindler translation). He goes on to call this the "work" of faith: to believe that there is such a thing as absolute love, and that nothing is higher or greater than it.
(T3) Theology should be done on the knees, and the saints are its best teachers. Imagine learning about marriage only from people who had studied it and never married. They might know a great deal, and still miss the thing itself. Balthasar thought something like that had happened to theology. Up to the great scholastics of the thirteenth century (the theologians of the new medieval universities, Thomas Aquinas the best known of them), he argued, the great theologians were mostly saints: Irenaeus, Athanasius, Augustine, Gregory the Great, Anselm. Their theology grew out of prayer and fed prayer in turn. Then, in the later Middle Ages, the two began to separate. Theology became a university discipline, precise and argumentative, while spirituality went off into devotional books with little doctrine in them. Each lost something: the theology grew cold, and the piety grew thin. In an essay of 1948, "Theology and Sanctity," he observed that since the great age of scholasticism there have been few theologians who were saints, and he spent his life trying to close the gap. The practical upshot is a test any reader can use. A theology that cannot be prayed has gone wrong somewhere. That is why his books keep turning to the lives of saints such as Thérèse of Lisieux and Elizabeth of the Trinity as sources of theology in their own right, and why he thought holiness the most convincing evidence for the faith.
(Q) "Theology was, when pursued by men of sanctity, a theology at prayer... As time went on, theology at prayer was superseded by theology at the desk." Source: Hans Urs von Balthasar, "Theology and Sanctity," in Explorations in Theology, vol. 1, The Word Made Flesh, p. 208 (A. V. Littledale and Alexander Dru translation). The cleavage he goes on to describe is the one between "scientific" theology, which lost the tone in which holy things should be spoken of, and "affective" theology, which lost its substance.
(T4) On Holy Saturday the Son went down among the dead as one of them, so that no one dies where God has not been. Anyone who has sat with a grieving family knows the strange silence of the day after a death. The worst has happened, and nothing more is happening. Balthasar thought theology had paid too little attention to that day in the story of Jesus: the Saturday between Good Friday and Easter, when the Son of God lay dead. The Apostles’ Creed says he "descended into hell," and the older tradition, especially in the East, usually pictures that descent as a victory march: Christ proclaiming his triumph to the spirits in prison (1 Peter 3:19), breaking down the gates of the underworld and leading Adam and Eve out by the hand. In Mysterium Paschale (1969), Balthasar reads it differently. For him the descent is first of all passive: Christ goes to the dead as a truly dead man, in full solidarity with every human being who has ever died, sharing their condition of being cut off from God before he overcomes it. The point is pastoral as much as doctrinal. There is no place of abandonment so deep that God has not been there first. He drew much of this from the Holy Saturday experiences Adrienne von Speyr described each year, and it remains one of the most debated parts of his work (†).
(Q) "It is for the sake of this day that the Son became man." Source: Hans Urs von Balthasar, Mysterium Paschale: The Mystery of Easter, p. 49 (Aidan Nichols translation). The book began as his contribution to Mysterium Salutis, a multi-volume handbook of Catholic theology, and appeared on its own in 1969 as Theologie der drei Tage (Theology of the Three Days).
(T5) No one may claim to know that all will be saved, but a Christian may, and must, hope for it. A mother whose son has walked away from God does not know how his story will end, and she would be foolish to claim she did. But no one would tell her she must stop hoping. Balthasar asked whether the church should hope for everyone the way she hopes for her son. In Was dürfen wir hoffen? (1986) and Kleiner Diskurs über die Hölle (1987), published in English together as Dare We Hope "That All Men Be Saved"?, he drew a careful line between knowledge and hope. Hell is a real possibility for every person, himself included; Jesus’ warnings are serious, and each of us stands under judgment. But Scripture also speaks of God, "who desires all people to be saved" (1 Timothy 2:4), and of Christ, who said, "And I, when I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all people to myself" (John 12:32). Since we cannot know how these two sets of sayings resolve for any given person, he argued, we may not declare that hell is full, nor that it is empty. We may only pray and hope. He insisted this was not universalism, the teaching that all will certainly be saved, which he rejected. The difference is the difference between knowing and hoping.
(Q) "Whoever reckons with the possibility of even only one person’s being lost besides himself is hardly able to love unreservedly." Source: Hans Urs von Balthasar, Dare We Hope "That All Men Be Saved"? with A Short Discourse on Hell, p. 211 (David Kipp and Lothar Krauth translation). The words "besides himself" carry the weight: he counted his own loss as a real possibility, and the hope he asks for is the hope of someone who stands under judgment too. A page or two later he quotes with approval the theologian Hermann-Josef Lauter, who reasons from Paul’s words that love "hopes all things" (1 Corinthians 13:7): "It cannot do otherwise than to hope for the reconciliation of all men in Christ. Such unlimited hope is, from the Christian standpoint, not only permitted but commanded." Elsewhere in the book he puts the line between knowing and hoping in one sentence: certainty cannot be attained, but hope can be justified.
(Q) "This book has one chief aim: to prevent any attempt being made after my death to separate my work from that of Adrienne von Speyr." Source: Hans Urs von Balthasar, Our Task: A Report and a Plan, part one, Introduction (John Saward translation). The first sentence of the Introduction to a book he wrote in 1984 about the Community of Saint John and the mission he shared with Adrienne von Speyr. He goes on to say that the book will show that in no respect is such a separation possible, in theology or in the community they founded. It is how he asked to be read, and it is the claim behind one of the sharpest questions his critics have asked: how much doctrine should rest on one person’s visions (†).
What the Church Made of Him
(†) The church that left him out of the Council ended by honoring him, and two popes counted him a teacher. The turnaround was striking. The priest with no post in the 1950s was named to the International Theological Commission in 1969, received the first Paul VI Prize from John Paul II in 1984, and was named a cardinal in 1988. Henri de Lubac, his old teacher, called him perhaps the most cultured man of his time. Joseph Ratzinger, who preached at his funeral, carried his influence furthest. The journal Communio, which the two of them founded with de Lubac, became one of the main channels through which a whole generation of Catholic theologians and bishops learned to read the Council as continuing the faith of the fathers rather than breaking with it. As Pope Benedict XVI, Ratzinger marked the centenary of Balthasar’s birth in 2005 with a message saying that "theology can only develop in prayer that accepts God’s presence and entrusts itself to him in obedience," and that Balthasar had left the example of a true theologian. His reach was popular as well as academic. Prayer (1955), Heart of the World (1945) and his meditations on the Creed and the rosary are still read by people who will never open the trilogy, and the Johannes Verlag he founded to publish Adrienne von Speyr still prints both of them.
(†) Protestant and Orthodox theologians took up his theology of beauty and of drama, as he had taken up Barth. He was a Catholic who read across every line. His book on Karl Barth (1951) was a landmark among Catholic studies of Protestant theology, written to understand rather than to refute, and it helped open a conversation between the two traditions that has not closed since. The traffic ran the other way too. Protestant theologians have built on his picture of theology as drama: the American evangelical Kevin Vanhoozer, in The Drama of Doctrine (2005), describes doctrine as direction for the church’s performance of the gospel, explicitly in conversation with Theo-Drama. The Orthodox theologian David Bentley Hart’s The Beauty of the Infinite (2003) owes a great deal to the theological aesthetics. And his insistence that beauty is a way of knowing has given Christians of every tradition a vocabulary for why the gospel is not only true and good but lovely, which is the way most people first meet it.
(†) Christians have pushed back on his reading of Holy Saturday, his hope for all, and the weight he gave to private visions. Admirers and critics come from every tradition, and the criticisms worth recording are aimed at what Balthasar himself taught. Three stand out. - Holy Saturday. The creed’s descent into hell had been read for centuries, East and West, as Christ’s triumphant proclamation to the dead (1 Peter 3:19; Ephesians 4:8–10). Balthasar’s picture of the Son passively suffering the abandonment of the dead (T4) goes beyond what those texts say, and the Catholic theologian Alyssa Lyra Pitstick, in Light in Darkness (2007), argued at length that it departs from the church’s traditional teaching. Defenders such as Edward T. Oakes answered that it deepens the tradition rather than contradicting it. The question is still argued. - The hope for all. Critics grant that Balthasar never taught that all will be saved, and that he called hell a real possibility. Their objection is that Jesus himself speaks as if the outcome is known in outline: "those who find it are few" (Matthew 7:14), and "these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life" (Matthew 25:46). Ralph Martin, in Will Many Be Saved? (2012), argued that a hope Scripture does not encourage weakens the urgency of mission, and many evangelical readers make the same point. Balthasar’s answer was that hope is not a forecast, and that the church prays for all because God desires all (T5). - The visions. He treated Adrienne von Speyr’s mystical experiences as a source for his own theology and said their work could not be separated. Private revelations (visions or messages given to one person, as distinct from the revelation given once for all in Christ and recorded in Scripture) bind no one, and Christians in every communion have asked how much doctrine should rest on one person’s visions, however holy. None of this touches the center of his work, the claim that God’s love shown in Christ is its own best evidence, which the whole church can hold with him.