Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
John Paul II of Wadowice 1920 – 2005 AD
(●) A Polish actor, quarry worker and philosopher who became pope, and spent twenty-six years telling the modern world that it could not understand itself without Christ. Karol Wojtyła lived under both of the twentieth century’s great tyrannies. He was nineteen when the German army rolled into Poland, and he spent the war breaking stone in a quarry and studying for the priesthood in secret. He was a young priest when the Communists took over, and for the next thirty years he taught, preached and governed a diocese under a government that wanted the church to wither. Then, in October 1978, the cardinals in Rome (the senior churchmen whose gravest duty is to choose a pope) elected him pope, the first non-Italian in more than four and a half centuries, and he took the name John Paul II. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. The first is that he was a working philosopher before he was a bishop, and his great theme was the human person: what a human being is, why freedom needs truth, why the body means something, why suffering is not the last word. He argued those things in the language of modern philosophy, against the materialism of his day, and he wrote the most important papal letter on faith and reason in a century. The second is that he lived what he argued, in public, for a very long time, and millions of people who never read a word of his philosophy watched him do it. The signature fact is a number. He made 104 journeys outside Italy as pope, and it was often said that more human beings had seen him in person than had ever seen anyone before him.
(●) 1920 AD: Born in a small Polish town, he had lost his mother, his brother and his father by the age of twenty. Karol Jozef Wojtyła was born on 18 May 1920 in Wadowice, a market town about thirty miles southwest of Kraków. His father, also Karol, was a retired army officer; his mother, Emilia, was often ill. Friends called the boy Lolek. He played goalkeeper in the town’s football games, including the ones where his Jewish neighbors made up the other side, and he grew up with Jewish classmates in a town where the synagogue stood a short walk from the parish church. Then the deaths came, one after another. His mother died in 1929, when he was eight. His older brother Edmund, a young doctor he worshipped, died in 1932 of scarlet fever caught from a patient. That left father and son alone in a small flat, and the father, a quiet and devout man, raised the boy largely by example: Karol later remembered waking in the night to find him on his knees. In 1938 the two moved to Kraków, and Karol enrolled at the Jagiellonian University to study Polish language and literature. He wrote poetry, acted in student theater, and fully expected to spend his life on the stage or in letters.
(●) 1939 AD: Under the Nazi occupation he broke stone in a quarry by day, acted in an underground theater, and entered a secret seminary. On 1 September 1939 Germany invaded Poland, and within weeks the occupiers closed the university and sent many of its professors to concentration camps. The plan for Poland was to reduce it to a nation of laborers. Karol, to avoid deportation for forced labor, took a job with the Solvay chemical company, first cutting limestone in a quarry at Zakrzówek, then working at the company’s plant. In February 1941 he came home from work to find his father dead. He was twenty, and he had no family left. Two things held him. One was the Rhapsodic Theater, a clandestine company that performed Polish poetry and drama in private flats, in defiance of a ban on Polish culture; to perform it was a quiet act of resistance. The other was a tailor named Jan Tyranowski, a layman who ran prayer circles for young men and handed Karol the writings of John of the Cross, the sixteenth-century Spanish mystic. Somewhere in those years the actor became convinced he was called to be a priest. In October 1942 he joined the underground seminary that Archbishop Adam Sapieha of Kraków was running in defiance of the Germans, studying at night while he worked by day. In February 1944 a German truck struck him and left him unconscious in the road; he spent about two weeks in hospital. That August, after the Gestapo swept the city for young men, Sapieha hid his seminarians in his own residence until the occupation ended.
(●) 1946 AD: Ordained a priest, he became a philosopher of the human person and a pastor to students. Sapieha ordained him on 1 November 1946 and sent him straight to Rome. At the Dominican university called the Angelicum he wrote a doctorate on faith in the writings of John of the Cross, finished in 1948. Back in Poland, now under Communist rule, he served as a parish curate, the assistant priest who does much of the ordinary work of a parish, first in the village of Niegowić and then at St Florian’s in Kraków, where he gathered a circle of university students around him. He took them hiking, skiing and kayaking, and on those trips, where a priest in clerical dress would have attracted the secret police, he went in ordinary clothes and they called him Wujek, "Uncle." Around the campfire they talked about love, marriage and sexuality, and those conversations became the raw material of his first book. Meanwhile he became a philosopher. In 1953 he completed a second thesis, the habilitation that Polish universities required of anyone who hoped to hold a professor’s chair, on whether the ethics of the German philosopher Max Scheler could support a Christian morality, and from 1954 he taught ethics at the Catholic University of Lublin, the only Catholic university behind the Iron Curtain. His Love and Responsibility (1960) argued that a person must never be used merely as a means, not even in love, and his The Acting Person (1969) studied what our free actions reveal about who we are. The method he used is called phenomenology: careful description of experience as it is actually lived, the way you might describe what it is like to make a promise before asking what a promise is.
(●) 1958 AD: Made a bishop at thirty-eight, he helped shape the Second Vatican Council and spent twenty years outmaneuvering a Communist state. The summons to become auxiliary bishop of Kraków, an assistant bishop who shares the archbishop’s work, reached him in July 1958 while he was on a kayaking trip on the Łyna River in the north. As he told it himself many years later, he left the group by canoe and then rode on a truck carrying sacks of flour. He went to Warsaw, where the Primate (the senior bishop of Poland) told him of the appointment, and he accepted. He reported to his archbishop in Kraków, and then, his business done, he took a night train back to rejoin his friends on the river. He was consecrated, that is, ordained a bishop, on 28 September 1958, the youngest bishop in Poland, and in 1964 he became Archbishop of Kraków. Pope Paul VI made him a cardinal in 1967. He attended all four sessions of the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965), the worldwide gathering of Catholic bishops in Rome that set the church’s course for the modern age. He worked on its pastoral constitution on the church in the modern world, Gaudium et Spes, and spoke for its declaration on religious freedom, which mattered intensely to a bishop whose own people had none. At home the regime had tried to build a model socialist city without a church. Nowa Huta, a steel town outside Kraków, was meant to be the workers’ paradise with no place for God. Wojtyła celebrated outdoor Masses there year after year, in the cold, until the authorities gave way, and in 1977 he consecrated the church its people had built, called the Ark of the Lord. The Communist officials had at first considered him an intellectual they could handle. They did not make that mistake twice.
(●) 1978 AD: Elected pope, he returned to Poland the next summer and told his people not to be afraid. Pope Paul VI died in August 1978, and his successor, John Paul I, died after only thirty-three days. In the second conclave of that year (a conclave is the closed-door meeting at which the cardinals elect a pope, voting again and again until one man has the majority the rules require), on 16 October 1978, the cardinals chose the fifty-eight-year-old Archbishop of Kraków. He was the first pope from outside Italy since Adrian VI in 1522, and he took his predecessor’s double name. At his inauguration he told the crowd, and through it the governments watching, "Do not be afraid. Open wide the doors for Christ." In June 1979 he went home. For nine days Poland, officially atheist, watched its own son say Mass before crowds the regime could neither hide nor count; perhaps a third of the nation saw him in person. In Warsaw’s Victory Square, on the eve of Pentecost, he prayed aloud that the Holy Spirit would descend and "renew the face of the earth, the face of this land," and the crowd chanted back, "We want God." Fourteen months later the shipyard strikes in Gdańsk gave birth to Solidarity, the first independent trade union in the Soviet bloc. He did not organize it. But many of the people who did said that June was when they stopped being afraid.
(●) 1981 AD: Shot in St Peter’s Square, he survived, and later sat in a prison cell with the man who shot him. On the afternoon of 13 May 1981, as he rode through the crowd in St Peter’s Square in an open car, a young Turkish gunman named Mehmet Ali Ağca shot him at close range. A bullet tore through his abdomen and he lost a great deal of blood; he was in surgery for more than five hours. Who, if anyone, stood behind Ağca has never been settled. The date was the anniversary of the first reported appearance of the Virgin Mary to three shepherd children at Fatima in Portugal in 1917, and the pope came to believe that her protection had turned the bullet aside from his vital organs. A year later he went to Fatima to give thanks. In December 1983 he visited Ağca in Rome’s Rebibbia prison. The photographs show the two men sitting close together in a bare cell, the pope’s hand on the gunman’s arm. He had already said publicly that he forgave him. What they said to each other he kept private.
(●) 2005 AD: He saw the Communist regimes of Europe fall, and then let the world watch him grow old and die. In 1989 the Communist governments of Eastern Europe fell one after another, almost without bloodshed, beginning in Poland. On 1 December 1989 Mikhail Gorbachev, the Soviet leader, came to the Vatican to meet him. Historians still argue over how much weight to give the pope against economics, the arms race and Gorbachev himself, but few leave him out, and Gorbachev later said that what happened in Eastern Europe would have been impossible without him. The last fifteen years were spent in a long public decline. He suffered from Parkinson’s disease, a progressive disorder of the nervous system, and the athlete who had skied the Tatra Mountains became a stooped old man whose hand shook and whose speech slurred. He did not hide it. He led the great Jubilee of the year 2000 (a jubilee, in Catholic practice, is a holy year of pilgrimage, repentance and pardon, an idea borrowed from the jubilee year of Leviticus 25), prayed at the Western Wall in Jerusalem that March, and kept traveling long after his doctors would have liked him to stop. The world that prizes youth and strength watched a dying man keep working, and understood that it was being taught something. He died in the Vatican on the evening of 2 April 2005, at eighty-four. At his funeral the crowd held up banners reading Santo subito, "a saint at once." He was beatified in 2011 (declared "Blessed," the last step before sainthood) and canonized, formally declared a saint, on 27 April 2014.
What He Taught
(T1) A human being is made for love and cannot make sense of himself until he meets the love of God in Christ. Think of someone who has been given a beautifully made tool and has no idea what it is for. He can weigh it, measure it, take it apart and admire the workmanship, and still not understand it, because a tool is understood by its purpose. John Paul II thought the modern world was in exactly that position with the human being. It had measured us, explained our chemistry and our economics, and still could not say what we are for. His answer, which ran through his first encyclical (a formal teaching letter from the pope to the whole church) in 1979 and everything he wrote after it, was that we are made for love, meaning the gift of oneself to another, and that the pattern and source of that love is Christ. He liked to repeat a sentence from Gaudium et Spes, the council document he had helped to draft: Christ "fully reveals man to man himself." The incarnation, the Christian teaching that God the Son became a human being in Jesus, is not only God showing us who God is. It is God showing us who we are. This is his version of an old Christian claim, and it is an argument as much as a confession. If human beings consistently find that they cannot be satisfied with possessions, power or pleasure, and come alive only when they give themselves away, that is what you would expect if they were made by a God who is himself self-giving love, and much harder to explain if they are not.
(Q) "Man cannot live without love. He remains a being that is incomprehensible for himself, his life is senseless, if love is not revealed to him, if he does not encounter love, if he does not experience it and make it his own, if he does not participate intimately in it." Source: John Paul II, Redemptor Hominis 10, 4 March 1979 (Vatican English translation). The passage goes on to say that this is why Christ the Redeemer "fully reveals man to himself" (T1). It was the first encyclical of the pontificate, and it set the theme of the next twenty-six years.
(T2) The human body is not a machine we happen to own: it speaks, and what it says is that we are made for self-giving. A wedding ring is a small piece of metal, and nobody thinks that is all it is. It makes visible something invisible, a promise. John Paul II argued that the human body works like that: it is the place where the invisible person becomes visible, so that what we do with our bodies is never merely physical. He set this out in 129 short talks at his Wednesday general audiences, the weekly gatherings where a pope meets pilgrims in Rome, between 1979 and 1984. They were later gathered as the "theology of the body." He started where Jesus started. Asked a question about divorce, Jesus sends his hearers back to the beginning (Matthew 19:4–8), and so to Genesis, where God creates humanity male and female in his own image (Genesis 1:27) and the two become "one flesh" (Genesis 2:24). From there John Paul II drew his name for the body’s capacity for self-gift: its "nuptial meaning," from the Latin word for marriage, because the body is built, so to speak, for giving oneself to another. Man and woman, made for each other, are a living picture of the communion of persons that God himself is. The point was aimed squarely at a culture that treats the body as raw material, an object to be used, enhanced or discarded at will. On his account the body is part of the person, so using someone’s body is using them. That is why he thought the sexual revolution, for all its talk of freedom, had made the body cheaper rather than freer.
(Q) "The body, and it alone, is capable of making visible what is invisible: the spiritual and the divine." Source: John Paul II, General Audience of 20 February 1980 (Vatican English translation). The talk is collected in the theology of the body catecheses, published in English as Man and Woman He Created Them. He is speaking of man and woman in the garden before the fall, whose bodies were, he says, a kind of "primordial sacrament": a visible sign of the invisible mystery hidden in God (T2). The word is chosen with care. A sacrament, in the church’s older language, is a visible sign that carries something unseen, the way water in baptism carries cleansing, and "primordial" means there from the very beginning: before any church existed, the bodies of the first man and woman were already that kind of sign.
(T3) Faith and reason need each other, and each goes wrong when it tries to fly alone. Every child eventually asks the questions he lists at the opening of the 1998 encyclical Fides et Ratio ("Faith and Reason"): Who am I? Where have I come from and where am I going? Why is there evil? What is there after this life? Those questions, he argued, are not religious questions smuggled into philosophy. They are where philosophy starts, and every human being is a philosopher in that sense. So he defended reason in two directions at once. Against a faith that wants nothing to do with thinking, which he called fideism, he insisted that belief which refuses to reason sinks into superstition. Against a reason that refuses to look beyond itself, he warned of the modern habit of giving up on truth altogether, so that philosophy shrinks to technique and every view becomes as good as any other. He even urged philosophers to recover their nerve about the big questions (what it is for anything to exist, what truth is, what is good), which many of them had quietly abandoned. For the apologist, Fides et Ratio is a charter. It says that a Christian may follow an argument wherever it honestly leads, because truth is one and God is its author, and that reason, rightly used, can come to know God from the things he has made (Romans 1:20).
(Q) "Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth." Source: John Paul II, Fides et Ratio, opening sentence (before section 1), 14 September 1998 (Vatican English translation). The sentence continues: God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth, and in the end to know himself, so that in knowing and loving God men and women may come to the fullness of truth about themselves (T3, T1).
(T4) Freedom depends on truth, and a society that denies all truth ends in tyranny. A man who lived under the Nazis and then the Communists did not need to be told that freedom matters. What he learned from both was something subtler: a regime that decides for itself what is true will soon decide for itself who counts as human. In Veritatis Splendor ("The Splendor of Truth," 1993) he took on the idea that freedom means making up your own values. Freedom, he argued, is real, and it is precious, but it is the freedom to choose the good, the way a musician is free only once he submits to the truth of the notes. Cut it loose from truth and it becomes a kind of sovereignty in which each person creates good and evil for himself. He grounded this in Christ’s words, "you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free" (John 8:32). From there he drew a conclusion many of his readers found startling. Some acts, such as the deliberate killing of the innocent, are wrong always and everywhere, whatever the intention behind them or the circumstances around them. He called such acts "intrinsically evil," meaning evil in themselves rather than because of where they lead. No good motive rescues them: torturing a prisoner, one of the acts he names, is still torture even when the torturer hopes to save lives by it. The martyrs, he said, are the proof: they died rather than do such things. He carried the same argument into politics. Two years earlier, in Centesimus Annus (1991), written just after the Communist collapse, he welcomed democracy and the free economy while warning that neither can survive without a shared sense of what is true and good. In Evangelium Vitae (1995) he named what he saw replacing it a "culture of death," in which the weak, the unborn and the dying are counted as burdens.
(Q) "As history demonstrates, a democracy without values easily turns into open or thinly disguised totalitarianism." Source: John Paul II, Centesimus Annus 46, 1 May 1991 (Vatican English translation). The sentence before it explains the danger: if there is no ultimate truth to guide political life, ideas and convictions can easily be manipulated for reasons of power (T4).
(T5) Suffering joined to Christ’s suffering is not wasted: it can become a share in his work of redemption. Anyone who has sat beside a hospital bed knows the question that does not go away: what is the point of this? John Paul II took it on in 1984, three years after the bullet, in a letter called Salvifici Doloris ("On the Christian Meaning of Human Suffering"). He did not pretend suffering is good. It is an evil, he wrote, a loss of some good we ought to have. But Christ took suffering into himself on the cross and made it the very means of redemption, and since then human suffering has a door it did not have before. A sufferer who unites his pain to Christ’s shares in what Christ did. He leaned on Paul’s words about "filling up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions" (Colossians 1:24), and was careful to say that Christ’s redemption is complete in itself: what is "lacking" is not in the cross but in our share of it, the way a finished symphony still waits for each new orchestra to play it. Protestant readers generally put the stress differently, reading Colossians 1:24 of Paul’s apostolic sufferings for the church rather than of a general share in redemption, and the difference is real. But on the main point, that suffering can be offered to God and borne with Christ rather than merely endured, Christians across the traditions recognize their own faith. And the last years of his life were that letter acted out.
(Q) "In bringing about the Redemption through suffering, Christ has also raised human suffering to the level of the Redemption. Thus each man, in his suffering, can also become a sharer in the redemptive suffering of Christ." Source: John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris 19, 11 February 1984 (Vatican English translation). The letter is dated on the feast of Our Lady of Lourdes, the day the Catholic Church keeps as the World Day of the Sick, which he established in 1992 (T5).
(Q) "Brothers and sisters, do not be afraid to welcome Christ and accept his power. ... Do not be afraid. Open wide the doors for Christ." Source: John Paul II, Homily for the Inauguration of his Pontificate, St Peter’s Square, 22 October 1978, section 5 (Vatican English translation). The homily goes on: "To his saving power open the boundaries of States, economic and political systems." Said in Rome to a crowd that included delegations from Communist governments, it became the motto of the pontificate.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) His own church received him as the pope who gave it a catechism, a generation of young converts, and a confidence it had been losing. When he was elected, many Catholics worried that the church was losing its nerve after the council, unsure what it still believed. He answered by teaching, and by putting the teaching in one place. In 1983 he promulgated (formally issued as binding law) a revised Code of Canon Law, the church’s body of law, and in 1992 he published the Catechism of the Catholic Church, the first universal catechism in four centuries, a single book stating what the Catholic Church believes and why. He also went looking for the young. The World Youth Days he began in the mid-1980s drew crowds that ran into the millions, and many priests, religious and lay leaders of the next generation date their own conversions or vocations to one of them. Admirers began calling him "John Paul the Great" almost as soon as he died, and in 2014 the Catholic Church declared him a saint. His philosophy had a second life too. The theology of the body (T2) gave Catholic teaching on sex and marriage a language that many found persuasive rather than merely restrictive, and it has been taught in parishes and seminaries ever since.
(†) Christians far beyond Rome counted him an ally in defending the faith, and he asked them to help him heal the divisions between them. Many evangelical Protestants who disagreed with him about the papacy itself found that on the great questions of their age he was standing exactly where they were, and more articulately than almost anyone. Those questions were the dignity of every human life, the reality of moral truth, the worth of marriage and the reasonableness of faith. Billy Graham, the American evangelist, spoke of him with warm admiration. Christian philosophers outside his church welcomed Fides et Ratio (T3) as a defense of their whole vocation. He took the divisions among Christians seriously as a wound. In the 1995 encyclical Ut Unum Sint ("That They May Be One," taken from Christ’s prayer in John 17:21) he did something no pope had done before: he invited leaders of other churches to help him find a way of exercising the papacy that could serve the unity of all Christians rather than divide them. In 1999, during his pontificate, Catholic and Lutheran representatives signed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, stating a shared understanding of the doctrine over which the Reformation had broken, while recording the differences that remained. And for anyone arguing that Christianity is a living force rather than a museum piece, the collapse of Communism was hard evidence. A regime that had promised religion would die out was itself gone, and the faith it meant to bury was singing in the squares.
(†) Where his own record draws criticism: his handling of the abuse cases, and Marian and interfaith gestures other Christians could not share. The other column of the ledger has real entries, and they come from his own decisions. - The abuse cases. The most serious criticism concerns how he governed. He praised and stood by Marcial Maciel, the Mexican priest who founded the Legionaries of Christ, a fast-growing Catholic religious order, for years while accusations of sexual abuse against Maciel were reaching Rome, and as late as November 2004 he publicly honored the sixtieth anniversary of Maciel’s ordination; it was under his successor, in 2006, that the Vatican ordered Maciel to give up all public ministry. And the Vatican’s own report on Theodore McCarrick, published in 2020, found that John Paul II appointed McCarrick Archbishop of Washington in 2000 after hearing warnings about his conduct, including a 1999 letter from Cardinal John O’Connor of New York, and after McCarrick wrote to the pope’s secretary denying any misconduct. His defenders point out that he had spent his life watching Communist police invent accusations against priests, which taught him to distrust them, and that he was often badly informed. Both things can be true. The failures were real, and the people harmed by them were real. - Mary. His episcopal motto, the one he chose when he became a bishop and kept as pope, was Totus Tuus, "Entirely Yours," addressed to the Virgin Mary, and he entrusted his pontificate and the world to her. Orthodox Christians share much of his devotion to the Mother of God, but Protestant Christians, who honor her as the believing mother of the Lord (Luke 1:48), hold that this kind of entrustment gives to her what belongs to Christ alone. That disagreement runs along the line between the traditions, and it ran through him. - Interfaith prayer. In 1986 he invited leaders of the world’s religions to Assisi to pray for peace. He was careful to say they came to pray in each other’s presence, not to pray a common prayer, but many evangelicals, and many traditionalist Catholics too, thought the event gave the impression that every religion is an equally good road to God, an impression his own teaching rejected. None of this cancels what he did. It belongs beside it, as the failures belong in any honest life.