Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
Francis Collins of Staunton b. 1950 AD
(●) The atheist chemist whose road to faith began at a hospital bedside, who led the reading of the human genome, and who has spent the decades since arguing that the God of the Bible is also the God of the genome. Most people who argue that science and Christianity are at war have never met anyone who stands at the top of both. Francis Collins is the standing counterexample. He is a physician and geneticist who helped find the genes behind cystic fibrosis and other inherited diseases, led the international Human Genome Project to its finish, and then ran the National Institutes of Health, the United States government’s medical research agency, under three presidents. He is also an evangelical Christian who came to faith from atheism in his late twenties, largely through reading C. S. Lewis. He is on a Christian apologetics site because of what he did with that combination. In 2006 he published The Language of God, a book-length case that belief in God is reasonable and that evolution, rightly understood, is the way God chose to make living things. He then founded the BioLogos Foundation to make that case to churches. Few Christians of his generation have done more to change how evangelicals talk about science, and few have drawn more fire for it, from atheists and from fellow believers alike. The signature fact is a sentence spoken at the White House. On June 26, 2000, standing beside President Bill Clinton to announce the first rough draft of the human genome, Collins called it reading "our own instruction book." A genome is exactly that: the complete set of instructions for building and running a living body, written in the chemical letters of DNA and copied into nearly every one of its cells. The human book in question is three billion letters long; printed out, it would fill a long shelf of thick volumes. Collins had led more than a thousand scientists through reading it, and he believed every letter of it had an Author.
(●) 1950 AD: Born in Staunton, Virginia, and raised on a small farm by parents who cared more about plays and music than about church. Francis Sellers Collins was born on April 14, 1950, in Staunton, in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley, the youngest of four sons of Fletcher and Margaret Collins. His father, who held a doctorate in English, taught drama at a nearby college; his mother wrote plays. The family lived on a small farm outside town, and his mother taught him at home until the sixth grade, with a method that ran more on curiosity than on worksheets: follow the question until it runs out. Religion was present but not pressed. His parents had him sing in the choir of the local Episcopal church, mostly, he later said, for the music. He took in a good deal of hymnody and very little theology, and by his own account the faith never put down roots. A boy who loved figuring out how things worked found his real excitement in a high school chemistry class, where a teacher showed that the swirling variety of the world could be described by a few orderly laws.
(●) 1974 AD: He finished a doctorate in physical chemistry at Yale as a convinced atheist, and then left the field for medicine. At the University of Virginia, where he took a chemistry degree in 1970, Collins drifted from a vague belief to agnosticism, the view that no one can know whether God exists. At Yale, deep in quantum mechanics (the physics of atoms and the particles inside them, a world that can be described almost only in mathematics), he went further. Physical chemistry is the part of chemistry that runs on physics and mathematics, and he came to think that nothing was true except what equations like his could capture. He became, in his own later word, an obnoxious atheist, the kind who felt free to challenge the faith of anyone who mentioned it in his presence. Then a course in biochemistry changed his direction. Here was DNA, the molecule that carries the instructions for building a living thing, written in a four-letter chemical alphabet, and here were real diseases caused by a single misspelled letter. Abstract equations began to look less interesting than people. He finished his Yale doctorate in 1974 and enrolled in medical school at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, graduating as a physician in 1977.
(●) c. 1977 AD: A suffering patient asked what he believed, and the question led him through C. S. Lewis to faith in Christ. Medical school put him at the bedsides of people who were dying, and many of the North Carolina farmers and laborers he cared for met death with a calm faith that unsettled him. One elderly woman with severe heart pain, after telling him about her own faith, asked him plainly: "What do you believe, doctor?" He had no real answer to give her. He realized he had rejected God without ever examining the evidence, which for a scientist was a strange way to reach a conclusion. So he went looking, intending to confirm his atheism. A Methodist minister who lived down the road listened to his questions and handed him a small book from his shelf: C. S. Lewis’s Mere Christianity. Collins later said that within a few pages he realized his arguments against faith were those of a schoolboy. Lewis’s case from the moral law, the sense of right and wrong every human being carries (T4), hit him hardest. He struggled for about two years. The decisive moment, as he tells it, came on a fall hike in the Cascade Mountains of the Pacific Northwest, when he came round a bend and saw a frozen waterfall a couple of hundred feet high, and felt his resistance leave him. The next morning he knelt in the dewy grass and gave himself to Jesus Christ. He was about twenty-seven, and the date is his own reckoning rather than a recorded day; it falls in the late 1970s, around the end of medical school and the start of his residency.
(●) 1989 AD: His Michigan laboratory and a Toronto team found the gene behind cystic fibrosis, and that summer he went to a mission hospital in Nigeria. After his residency in internal medicine at Chapel Hill (the years of hospital training a new doctor serves after medical school), Collins went back to Yale in 1981 for a fellowship in human genetics, a further stretch of specialist training. Genes sit on chromosomes, the long, tightly coiled strands of DNA inside a cell, and a human cell carries forty-six of them. Looking for one faulty gene in that much DNA was like hunting for a single misprinted word in a library when all you know is which shelf it is on. At Yale he worked on a technique he called "chromosome jumping," a way of skipping along a chromosome in long strides rather than inching letter by letter, which made it possible to hunt down a disease gene knowing only its rough location. In 1984 he joined the faculty of the University of Michigan and set out to use it. The prize was cystic fibrosis, an inherited disease that clogs the lungs with thick mucus and in those days killed most of its patients by early adulthood. In 1989 his group and the laboratory of Lap-Chee Tsui at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto announced that they had found the gene, now called CFTR after the protein it builds (a tiny gate that lets chloride, one half of ordinary salt, pass through the walls of the cells lining the lungs and other organs), and the most common misspelling in it. Over the next few years his lab helped find the genes for neurofibromatosis (a disorder that grows tumors along the nerves) and Huntington’s disease. In the summer of 1989, the same year as the discovery, he took his medical skills to a small Baptist mission hospital in Eku, Nigeria. Faced with diseases that clean water and basic medicine could have prevented, he wondered what good one visiting doctor could do. There he drained a dangerous build-up of fluid around the heart of a young man of twenty-seven, sick with tuberculosis, and afterward, by Collins’s own account, the patient told him: "You came here for one reason. You came here for me." Collins tells the story often, as the moment he learned that the work is done one person at a time.
(●) 1993 AD: He took charge of the Human Genome Project, and in 2003 delivered the finished sequence two years ahead of schedule. In 1993 Collins left Michigan to succeed James Watson, the co-discoverer of DNA’s double helix, as head of the National Institutes of Health’s genome center (later the National Human Genome Research Institute). The Human Genome Project he inherited aimed to read every one of the roughly three billion chemical letters in human DNA, in their proper order, which is what geneticists mean by sequencing. No single laboratory could do that alone, so he led an international consortium, a partnership of laboratories across six countries working to one shared plan, and he pressed hard for one principle: the data belonged to everyone. Sequences were released to the public within a day of being read, so that no one could own the human genome. A private company, Celera Genomics, led by J. Craig Venter, raced the public project with a faster method, and the rivalry turned bitter before a truce was brokered. On June 26, 2000, Collins and Venter stood together at the White House while President Clinton announced the first working draft. Collins told the room that they were celebrating "the revelation of the first draft of the human book of life." A draft is what it sounds like: most of the text is there, but with gaps and typos still to fix, the way a first transcript of a long handwritten manuscript has blanks where the ink was hard to read. The finished sequence followed in April 2003, two years ahead of the original target, fifty years almost to the month after Watson and Crick first described the double helix.
(●) 2006 AD: He published The Language of God, debated Richard Dawkins, and the next year founded BioLogos. For years Collins had kept his faith fairly quiet in professional life. Two pressures changed that. The new atheists, writers like Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris, were telling the public that science had made God unbelievable, and at the same time many churches were telling their young people that they had to choose between Genesis and modern biology. Collins thought both were wrong, and that the second error was feeding the first. The Language of God: A Scientist Presents Evidence for Belief came out in the summer of 2006 and became a bestseller. That autumn, on September 30, Time magazine sat him across a table from Dawkins for a ninety-minute debate in New York, published that November as "God vs. Science." The two men were sharp but courteous, and the transcript shows each conceding real points to the other. In 2007 he founded the BioLogos Foundation, its name joining the Greek bios (life) and logos (word, the term John’s Gospel uses for Christ), to help churches see evolution and faith as allies. The same year President George W. Bush awarded him the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian honor.
(●) 2009 AD: He became director of the National Institutes of Health and served three presidents for twelve years, through the COVID-19 pandemic. When President Barack Obama nominated him to lead the NIH in 2009, some scientists objected in print that an outspoken evangelical should not run the nation’s research enterprise. The Senate confirmed him without dissent, he stepped away from BioLogos, and he stayed in the job under Presidents Obama, Trump, and Biden, longer than any other presidentially appointed director. He was known around the agency for showing up with his guitar; he had played in bluegrass bands since college. The pandemic of 2020 put him at the center of the push for vaccines and treatments, and it brought the hardest criticism of his career, over public-health policy and over how the agency had overseen grants for research on coronaviruses abroad. Some of it he has answered and some of it he has conceded. In 2023 he said publicly that public-health leaders, himself included, had weighed stopping the disease so heavily that they gave too little weight to what their measures did to the rest of people’s lives. In the middle of all this, in 2020, he received the Templeton Prize, a large annual international award honoring people who affirm the spiritual side of life, in recognition of his work on science and faith. He stepped down as director in December 2021, though not into a quiet life. He served for most of 2022 as acting science adviser to President Biden, and kept up his work at the laboratory bench, research in his own lab on diabetes and on a rare premature-aging disease. In 2024 he published The Road to Wisdom, a plea for truth and trust in a divided country, and in February 2025 he retired from the NIH. He is married to the genetic counselor Diane Baker and has two daughters from his first marriage.
What He Taught
(T1) Science and faith answer different questions about the same world, and studying nature can be an act of worship. Picture a kettle boiling on the stove. Ask why it is boiling and one answer is physics: heat from the burner speeds up the water molecules until they escape as steam. Another answer is personal: because someone wants a cup of tea. Both answers are true, and neither competes with the other. Collins’s whole public career rests on that distinction. Science, he argues, is superb at the questions about how: how the cell divides, how the universe expanded. It has no tools for the questions about why: why there is anything at all, what a life is for, what happens after death. So he rejected two popular positions at once. Against Dawkins, he denied that God is a scientific hypothesis to be tested and found wanting; a God who made nature is not one more object inside it, any more than an author is a character in her own novel. But against the paleontologist Stephen Jay Gould, who proposed that science and religion occupy sealed boxes that never touch, Collins insisted the boxes are open. If God made the world, then studying the world is studying his work, and every discovery is a chance to admire the Maker. The psalmist said the same: "The heavens declare the glory of God, and the sky above proclaims his handiwork" (Psalm 19:1).
(Q) "I have found there is a wonderful harmony in the complementary truths of science and faith. The God of the Bible is also the God of the genome. God can be found in the cathedral or in the laboratory. By investigating God’s majestic and awesome creation, science can actually be a means of worship." Source: Francis S. Collins, "Collins: Why this scientist believes in God," CNN.com, April 3, 2007. The closing lines of a short essay Collins wrote while still directing the genome institute, summarizing the argument of The Language of God for a general audience.
(T2) Evolution is the means God chose to create living things, and Genesis was never meant as a science textbook. A geneticist reading DNA sees something like a family resemblance written in chemistry. Humans and chimpanzees share broken copies of the same gene in the same place, the way two school essays that share the same unusual typo were probably copied from a common source. For Collins this kind of evidence settles that living things descend from common ancestors. The question that interests him is what follows for faith, and his answer is: very little that a Christian needs to fear. His position is called theistic evolution, or, in the phrase BioLogos later preferred, evolutionary creation: God created all things, and the process biologists call evolution is the way he chose to bring about the variety of life, including human beings. Because God stands outside time, Collins argued in the Time debate, he could set the process going with full knowledge of how it would turn out. Humans, on this view, are biologically kin to the animals and yet uniquely made in God’s image, with a moral sense and a longing for God that biology alone does not explain. Two warnings run through his writing. The first is to churches: binding the faith to a young earth (the belief that the earth is only some thousands of years old) sets young believers up to think they must choose between their Bible and the evidence, and he cites Augustine, who warned Christians against making the faith look foolish by pronouncing confidently on matters of nature they did not understand. The second is to fellow defenders of faith: the "God of the gaps," the habit of pointing to whatever science cannot yet explain and calling it God, is a losing strategy, because the gaps keep closing. That is why he declined to join the intelligent design movement, the argument that some biological structures are too complex to have evolved and must have been directly designed. His case for God rests instead on what science discovers, not on what it has yet to discover.
(Q) "There are sincere believers who interpret Genesis 1 and 2 in a very literal way that is inconsistent, frankly, with our knowledge of the universe’s age or of how living organisms are related to each other. St. Augustine wrote that basically it is not possible to understand what was being described in Genesis. It was not intended as a science textbook. It was intended as a description of who God was, who we are and what our relationship is supposed to be with God." Source: David Van Biema, "God vs. Science," Time, November 5, 2006, transcript of the debate between Collins and Richard Dawkins held on September 30, 2006. Collins is answering the moderator’s question about conservative Protestants who oppose evolution. The Augustine he has in mind is The Literal Meaning of Genesis, written in the early fifth century.
(T3) The universe had a beginning and is finely tuned for life, and a Creator explains both better than chance. Imagine walking into a room and finding a radio tuned exactly to the one station in a thousand miles, with the volume, bass, and treble all set just so. You would assume someone had set it. Physicists have found something like that in the basic numbers of nature. The fine-tuning of the universe is the discovery that a handful of constants, such as the strength of gravity, sit within very narrow ranges that allow stars, planets, and life; nudge them slightly and the universe would have flown apart or collapsed or stayed a thin soup of particles. Collins puts two discoveries side by side. The first is the Big Bang, the finding that the universe had a beginning roughly fourteen billion years ago; something that begins, he reasons, needs a cause outside itself, and nature cannot have created itself. The second is the fine-tuning. There are, he grants, two serious options: either there is a vast number of universes, a "multiverse," and we happen to live in one of the rare ones that suit life, or there was a plan. Applying Ockham’s razor, the rule of thumb that the simpler explanation is usually the better one, he judges a single Creator simpler than an unobserved infinity of worlds. He is careful about what this shows: it points to a God who could have made a universe, not yet to the God of Abraham and Jesus.
(Q) "The gravitational constant, if it were off by one part in a hundred million million, then the expansion of the universe after the Big Bang would not have occurred in the fashion that was necessary for life to occur. When you look at that evidence, it is very difficult to adopt the view that this was just chance. But if you are willing to consider the possibility of a designer, this becomes a rather plausible explanation for what is otherwise an exceedingly improbable event." Source: David Van Biema, "God vs. Science," Time, November 5, 2006, transcript of the debate between Collins and Richard Dawkins. The moderator had asked Collins for one example of fine-tuning, and the improbable event he means, as he says in the next words, is our own existence. Dawkins answered that a designer would be even more improbable than the universe; Collins replied that God, being uncreated, needs no fine-tuning of his own.
(T4) The moral law written in every human heart is a signpost to a God who cares about people. Two children squabble over the last cookie, and one cries out, "That’s not fair!" Neither has read a word of moral philosophy, yet both assume there is a standard of fairness that binds them, and that the other one knows it too. This is what C. S. Lewis called the Moral Law, and it was the argument that first broke through Collins’s atheism (c. 1977 AD). Human beings everywhere recognize that some things are really right and others really wrong, and they feel bound by that standard even as they break it. Collins presses the argument with a geneticist’s eye on altruism, unselfish love that costs the giver. Evolutionary biologists can explain kindness to relatives, who share our genes, and kindness that expects to be repaid. But the acts people admire most fit neither pattern: Oskar Schindler, the German industrialist, risking his own life to save more than a thousand Jews from the gas chambers, or a stranger diving into a river for someone he will never see again. Evolution may explain some features of morality, Collins grants, but it cannot explain why it should matter; if our sense of good is only a useful accident of our genes, then nothing is really good or evil at all. The better explanation, he argues, is that the standard comes from a good God who made human beings to know him, which is what Paul says of the law "written on their hearts" (Romans 2:15).
(Q) "Evolution may explain some features of the moral law, but it can’t explain why it should have any real significance. If it is solely an evolutionary convenience, there is really no such thing as good or evil. But for me, it is much more than that. The moral law is a reason to think of God as plausible." Source: David Van Biema, "God vs. Science," Time, November 5, 2006, transcript of the debate between Collins and Richard Dawkins. He went on to say that it points not just to a God who sets the universe in motion but to a God who cares about human beings, since humans alone among the creatures on the planet seem to have so developed a sense of morality. Collins is replying to Dawkins’s suggestion that human goodness is a leftover instinct from life in small family groups. Dawkins answered that he did not believe good and evil exist "out there" at all, and Collins said he was glad they had found the real difference between them.
(T5) Faith rests on reason but needs revelation too, and Jesus of Nazareth demands a decision. Collins likes to describe faith with an image from music. You can study a page of sheet music, count the notes and analyze the harmony, and still not have heard the piece. Reason, for him, can take a person a long way toward God: the beginning of the universe, its fine-tuning, the moral law. But reason alone cannot prove God, and it cannot tell you who God is. That takes revelation, God making himself known, and it takes a willingness to listen with the spirit as well as the mind. For Collins, the place God made himself known was Jesus. After the moral law convinced him that God exists, he went looking for what God is like, and found a man with strong historical evidence for his life, who taught love of neighbor, and who claimed to be the Son of God. Following Lewis, he concluded that such a man could not be merely a good teacher; his claims meant he was either deluded or telling the truth. That is a decision no laboratory can make for anyone, and Collins is frank that it required a step of trust beyond the evidence, though a step in the direction the evidence pointed. He is equally frank about the church: faith’s pure water, he once said, is poured into rusty vessels called human beings.
(Q) "But reason alone cannot prove the existence of God. Faith is reason plus revelation, and the revelation part requires one to think with the spirit as well as with the mind. You have to hear the music, not just read the notes on the page. Ultimately, a leap of faith is required." Source: Francis S. Collins, "Collins: Why this scientist believes in God," CNN.com, April 3, 2007. The sentences come just after he credits Lewis with showing him that a strong rational case for God can be made, and just before he tells how his search led him to Jesus.
(Q) "Here was a person with remarkably strong historical evidence of his life, who made astounding statements about loving your neighbor, and whose claims about being God’s son seemed to demand a decision about whether he was deluded or the real thing. After resisting for nearly two years, I found it impossible to go on living in such a state of uncertainty, and I became a follower of Jesus." Source: Francis S. Collins, "Collins: Why this scientist believes in God," CNN.com, April 3, 2007. Collins’s own summary of his conversion (c. 1977 AD), and the reason his apologetics always ends where Lewis’s does: not at a Creator in general but at Christ.
What Christians Made of Him
(†) To a public told that science had buried God, he was living proof that it had not. The years around 2006 were the high tide of the new atheism, and its central claim was that serious science and serious faith cannot share one head. Collins was hard to fit into that story. The man who led the reading of the human genome was standing in public saying that he believed in God, in the resurrection, and in miracles, and that his science made his faith deeper, not weaker. For many Christians, especially students in the sciences, that example mattered more than any single argument. The Language of God became a bestseller read well beyond the churches, and Collins spent years answering letters and emails from young scientists who had been told they would have to choose. The sharpest critics took him seriously enough to attack him at length: Sam Harris wrote a scathing review of the book in 2006 and in 2009 asked in the New York Times whether a man of his beliefs should be trusted to lead the NIH. The debate with Dawkins showed that a believer could meet the most famous atheist of the day on equal terms, and courteously.
(†) Through BioLogos he made evolutionary creation a live option in evangelical churches. Before Collins, an evangelical who accepted evolution often kept quiet about it. BioLogos gave such people a home, and a stream of scientists, pastors, and biblical scholars to read. Timothy Keller, the New York pastor, wrote a paper for BioLogos on how ordinary church members can hold together the Bible’s account of creation and the scientific account of origins. Collins’s own model was Lewis, and the movement drew on a long line of orthodox Christians who had made room for an old earth and for evolution, from the Princeton theologian B. B. Warfield onward. The Templeton Prize in 2020 recognized exactly this work. When it was announced, Collins said he hoped it would show young people that it is entirely appropriate, and wonderful, to embrace both the scientific and the Christian worldview.
(†) Fellow believers have pressed him on the first humans and on design, and the debate is a family argument among Christians. Collins’s views on origins are contested inside the church, and the disagreements deserve a fair statement on each side. - From young-earth creationists. Ministries such as Answers in Genesis argue that the plain reading of Genesis 1 to 11 teaches a recent creation in six days, and that death before the fall of Adam undermines the Bible’s link between sin and death (Romans 5:12). Collins answers that Genesis was written to teach who God is and who we are, not the age of rocks, and that Augustine read it non-literally long before anyone had heard of Darwin (T2). - From the intelligent design movement. Scholars at the Discovery Institute, the Seattle think tank that is the movement’s main home, argue that Collins concedes too much: some biological machinery, they say, really does bear the marks of direct design, and evolution as usually taught is unguided by definition. Collins replies that design arguments built on present gaps in knowledge put faith at the mercy of the next discovery (T2), though he himself argues from design at the level of the universe (T3). - On Adam and Eve. Collins has said that the genetic variety in living humans points back to an ancestral population of about ten thousand, not to a single couple. Many Christians answer that a historical Adam is woven into Paul’s theology of sin and salvation (Romans 5:12–21; 1 Corinthians 15:21–22), and some scientists and theologians sympathetic to evolution have since proposed models that keep a real first pair within a larger population. The question remains open among Christians who share the Nicene faith (the faith summed up in the fourth-century Nicene Creed, which Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant churches all confess), and on all sides of it they confess God as Creator and Christ as the second Adam, Paul’s picture of Christ as a new head of the human race who undoes what the first Adam did.
(†) Where many Christians part with him: research that uses human embryos and fetal tissue. One disagreement concerns not what Collins wrote about origins but what he supported and administered. He has long favored research on human embryonic stem cells, cells taken from embryos a few days old, which destroys the embryo. In the 2006 Time debate he said that many people of strong religious conviction regard such research as morally supportable. As NIH director he put into effect the expanded federal funding for embryonic stem cell research that President Obama ordered in 2009, approving the first new cell lines that December (a cell line is a colony of cells, grown from one source, that keeps dividing in the laboratory so researchers can share it for years), and he defended the agency’s research using tissue from elective abortions. A great many Christians, across traditions, judge that wrong. The Catholic Church teaches that a human embryo is to be treated as a person from conception, and most evangelical and Orthodox bodies that have spoken to the question agree that a human life is not raw material, however good the cure it might yield. They read Scripture’s picture of God knitting a person together in the womb (Psalm 139:13–16) as a claim about the earliest human life. Collins has drawn his own lines, opposing reproductive cloning (making a baby who is a genetic copy of an existing person) and, as director, refusing NIH funding for editing the genes of human embryos. But he supports research on the embryos left over from fertility treatment, and in The Language of God he argued that cells made by placing the nucleus of a body cell into an emptied egg (somatic cell nuclear transfer) lack the moral standing of an embryo conceived from sperm and egg. On both points he stands where many of his fellow believers cannot follow.