Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Classical Greece

600 BC – 300 BC

Anaximander of Miletus c. 610 – c. 546 BC

(●) The second philosopher of Miletus, who reasoned that whatever explains everything cannot be one of the things it explains. + Thales of Miletus had said that everything comes from water. His younger neighbour Anaximander thought about that answer for a long time and decided it could not be right. Water is wet and cold; fire is hot and dry. If the source of all things were one of those, how could its opposite ever have come to be? So he reached past every material he could name to something with no limits and no qualities of its own, and he called it to apeiron, "the boundless." He matters on a Christian apologetics site because that move, looking for the source of the world outside the list of things in the world, is the oldest ancestor of a question the cosmological arguments still ask. A cosmological argument reasons from the plain fact that a world exists to a cause beyond the world, much as you would reason from a warm teapot on the counter to someone who has just been in the kitchen. Anaximander reached the first half of that thought about six centuries before Christ, without Scripture, and he got remarkably far. He also stopped short of the one thing that would have finished it, and the church fathers, the Christian teachers of the first centuries after the apostles, noticed exactly where. Here is the fact a reader tends to remember. Anaximander wrote a book, one of the first prose books in the Greek world and perhaps the very first about nature, and of that whole book a single sentence survives, copied out by a scholar a thousand years later. It is commonly called the oldest surviving sentence of Western philosophy.

(●) c. 610 BC: Born in Miletus, the busiest Greek harbour on the coast of Asia, a generation after Thales. + Anaximander was the son of a man named Praxiades, and he was born in Miletus, a trading city on the western coast of what is now Turkey. Ships left its four harbours for Egypt, for the Black Sea, for Italy, and came back with grain, timber, news, and ideas. A boy growing up on those docks heard more languages in a week than most Greeks heard in a lifetime. His birth year is worked out backward. Apollodorus, an Athenian scholar of the second century BC who compiled a chronology of famous lives, reported that Anaximander was sixty-four years old in the second year of the 58th Olympiad, which is 547/546 BC. That needs a word of explanation. The Greek cities had no shared calendar, so scholars counted years by the Olympic Games, held every four years; an Olympiad is the four-year stretch from one Games to the next. Their year also began in midsummer, so one Greek year straddles two of ours, which is why the date carries a slash. Counting back sixty-four years gives about 610 BC. That figure is a convention built on one ancient calculation, and the "c." in front of it is meant seriously: we do not know the year he was born, only that he was roughly a generation younger than Thales.

(●) Early sixth century BC: He became the companion of Thales, and then told his teacher he had picked the wrong answer. + Theophrastus, Aristotle’s successor and the first historian of philosophy, called Anaximander a "fellow-citizen and associate" of Thales. Later writers turned "associate" into "pupil," and Hippolytus calls him "the hearer of Thales." We do not know what their days together looked like: whether there were lessons, a circle of friends, or simply two clever men in one city arguing about the same question. What we do know is what came out of it. Thales had asked what single thing everything is made of, and answered water. Anaximander kept the question and threw out the answer. That sounds ordinary to us, but it was not how learning usually passed between generations in the ancient world, where a student received a teaching and handed it on intact. In Miletus a student received a question instead, along with permission to answer it differently. Anaximenes, who came after him, would do the same thing to Anaximander.

(●) Mid-sixth century BC: He drew the first Greek map of the inhabited world and built a model of the heavens. + Imagine trying to draw a map of the world when no one has ever drawn one, using nothing but sailors’ stories and traders’ reports. Anaximander did it. Eratosthenes, the great geographer of the third century BC, named him as the first after Homer to treat geography seriously, and said he "was the first to publish a geographical map." Diogenes Laertius, a third-century AD collector of philosophers’ lives, adds that he was "the first to draw on a map the outline of land and sea," and that "he constructed a globe as well," meaning a model of the sky. The map is lost, and we can only guess its shape from what later Greeks said about early maps: probably a round world with the sea flowing around its edge. But the boldness of it is the point. He took the whole known world, from the Black Sea to the Pillars of Hercules (the two great rocks at the Strait of Gibraltar, where the Mediterranean opens onto the ocean), and put it on a single tablet you could hold in your hands. Merchants of a harbour city sending ships in every direction had good reason to want one.

(●) Mid-sixth century BC: Later writers remembered him in Sparta, setting up a sundial and warning of an earthquake. + Two stories place him in Sparta, and both should be read as stories rather than records. - The sundial. Diogenes Laertius, citing the writer Favorinus, says Anaximander "was the first inventor of the gnomon and set it up for a sundial in Lacedaemon," Lacedaemon being Sparta’s formal name. A gnomon is simply an upright rod whose shadow tells the time and season; when the noon shadow is shortest you have reached midsummer. "First inventor" cannot be right, since Herodotus says the Greeks learned the gnomon from the Babylonians, but Anaximander may well have set one up and taught its use. - The earthquake. In On Divination, a dialogue by the Roman statesman Cicero, his brother Quintus tells how Anaximander warned the Spartans to leave their city and sleep in the fields under arms because an earthquake was coming, and how the city then fell in ruins. Quintus tells it as foresight that comes from studying nature, which he refuses to call divination, and nothing else confirms it. Whatever the details, the picture is consistent: a man whose learning was useful, and who was trusted outside his own city.

(●) Mid-sixth century BC: A late report has him leading a colony for his city, and a statue bearing his name stood in Miletus. + The Roman writer Aelian reports that Anaximander led the colony Miletus sent out to Apollonia, presumably the Apollonia on the Black Sea coast. Founding a colony meant choosing a site, dividing land, and writing the first laws for people who would never come home, and cities gave the job only to men they trusted. The report is late and stands alone, so it is best held loosely. Something more solid came out of the ground, though it raises its own question. Excavators in the marketplace of Miletus found the headless lower part of an early statue with his name cut into it. Some scholars doubt that it shows the philosopher rather than another Milesian of the same name. If it is his, nobody put it up for his theory of the boundless; a city honoured a man that way because he had served it, and it is a good reminder that the first philosophers were not hermits. They were citizens with jobs to do.

(●) 547/546 BC: At sixty-four he had written one of the first Greek prose books on nature, and he died soon afterward as Persia swallowed Ionia. + Before Anaximander, Greeks who wanted to say something about the gods and the world said it in verse, as Homer and Hesiod had. Anaximander wrote prose, and later writers remembered the change. Themistius, an orator of the fourth century AD, called him the first Greek known to have published a written account of nature. Apollodorus seems to have had the book in his hands, and the date of sixty-four years in 547/546 BC probably comes from something Anaximander said in it about his own age. Those were dangerous years to be sixty-four. Around 547/546 BC Cyrus of Persia took Sardis, the capital of Lydia, the rich kingdom just inland, and the Greek cities of the coast, the region the Greeks called Ionia, fell under Persian rule one after another. Miletus was luckier than most: Herodotus says Cyrus made a treaty with the Milesians alone on the same terms the Lydian king had given them. Diogenes Laertius says Anaximander "died not long afterwards," and that is all we are told about the end. Diogenes also kept one small, human story. When some boys laughed at Anaximander’s singing, he is supposed to have said, "Then to please the boys I must improve my singing." It is the only joke we have from him, and it sounds like a man who could take a correction.

What He Taught

(T1) Everything comes from the boundless, a source that is none of the things it produces. + Picture a painter’s palette. If you want to be able to mix every colour, you cannot start with red, because red will tint everything you make; you need something more basic than any of the colours themselves. Anaximander reasoned about the world in a similar way. The Greeks of his day saw the world as a contest of opposites: hot and cold, wet and dry, light and dark. Thales had said the source of everything is water. But water is one of the opposites, cold and wet. If the source were water, and there were an endless supply of it, it would long ago have quenched every fire. Aristotle reports this line of reasoning, and most scholars think it is Anaximander’s. So the source has to be something neutral, something that is not hot or cold or wet or dry, out of which all of them can be separated. He called it to apeiron. The word is built from a-, "not," and peras, "limit": the unlimited, the boundless. It is boundless in amount, so it never runs out, and boundless in kind, with no fixed qualities to tie it down. Theophrastus says Anaximander was the first to use the word for the source of things. Christian theology would later say something with the same shape about God: he is not one more item in the world, alongside water and fire, but the source of all of it. Where the two part company is over what kind of source that is.

(Q) "Anaximander of Miletos, son of Praxiades, a fellow-citizen and associate of Thales, said that the material cause and first element of things was the Infinite, he being the first to introduce this name for the material cause. He says it is neither water nor any other of the so-called elements, but a substance different from them which is infinite, from which arise all the heavens and the worlds within them." + Source: Theophrastus, Opinions of the Natural Philosophers, fragment 2, preserved by Simplicius, Commentary on Aristotle’s Physics 24.13 (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). These are not Anaximander’s own words but the summary of Aristotle’s pupil, who had the book in front of him, and he describes it in Aristotle’s vocabulary. A "material cause" is what a thing is made of, the way bronze is the material cause of a bronze statue. The "so-called elements" are the four that later Greeks settled on: earth, water, air, and fire. Burnet renders apeiron as "the Infinite"; it is the same word translated "the boundless" in (T1).

(T2) The world runs on justice: things pay one another back for their wrongs in the order of time. + Think of the year. Through the summer, heat pushes in and takes over: the streams dry up, the grass browns. Then winter comes and cold takes everything back, and in spring the balance tips again. Nothing wins for good. Anaximander looked at that rhythm and described it in the language of a courtroom. Each opposite, when it grows, trespasses on the territory of its rival; that is its "injustice." In time it has to pay the penalty and give the ground back; that is its "reparation." And everything that comes out of the boundless returns to it in the end, as a debt is repaid. His one surviving sentence says exactly this, and Theophrastus, quoting it, remarked that Anaximander put it "in these somewhat poetical terms." The idea is larger than it looks. Anaximander was claiming that nature is not a heap of accidents but an order, and a moral one: the world keeps a ledger. That conviction, that the universe has a lawfulness the mind can trace, is part of what made science possible. A Christian reader also notices what is missing from the courtroom. There is a verdict and a sentence, but there is no judge.

(Q) "And into that from which things take their rise they pass away once more, as is ordained; for they make reparation and satisfaction to one another for their injustice according to the appointed time." + Source: Anaximander, fragment 1 (Diels-Kranz 12 B1), quoted by Simplicius, Commentary on Aristotle’s Physics 24.13, from Theophrastus (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). The sentence comes down inside Theophrastus’s summary, and scholars disagree about where Anaximander’s own words begin. Burnet marks only the part from "as is ordained" onward as a direct quotation; others take the whole sentence as his. Either way, it is the oldest piece of Greek philosophical prose that survives.

(T3) The boundless is divine: it never began, it never dies, and it encompasses all things. + Ask a child where the river comes from, and then where that comes from, and the questions do not stop until you reach something that does not need a source. Anaximander reached that point and recognized what he had found. A source of everything cannot itself have a source, or it would not be the first. It cannot have begun, and it cannot end. So he gave the boundless the titles the Greeks gave their gods. Aristotle reports that the early thinkers who made the boundless the first principle said it "encompasses" and "steers" all things, and he quotes Anaximander directly for two words: it is "deathless and imperishable." Hippolytus, a Christian writer of the early third century, records that Anaximander called it "eternal and undecaying," and said that it contains all the worlds. That is a real insight, and Christians have always said the same of God: he has no beginning, he does not decay, and everything is held within his reach. But notice what the boundless does not do. It does not know anything, choose anything, or love anything. It is divine the way the sea is vast. Augustine, looking back on him nearly a thousand years later, put his finger on exactly that gap.

(Q) "It is this which is held to be the principle of other things, and to encompass all and to steer all, as those assert who do not recognize, alongside the infinite, other causes, such as Mind or Friendship. Further they identify it with the Divine, for it is 'deathless and imperishable' as Anaximander says, with the majority of the physicists." + Source: Aristotle, Physics III.4, 203b (Hardie and Gaye translation). Aristotle is surveying everyone before him who made the infinite a first principle. Only the words "deathless and imperishable" are pinned to Anaximander by name; "encompass all and steer all" describes the whole group, and Anaximander is usually thought to be its chief member. Two of Aristotle’s words need unpacking. His "physicists" are not scientists in laboratories but the physikoi, the early thinkers who studied physis, nature. And "Mind" and "Friendship" are the extra causes later philosophers added to the picture: Anaxagoras taught that a cosmic Mind set the world in order, and Empedocles that Love (or Friendship) and Strife draw things together and drive them apart. Notice Aristotle’s own aside: these thinkers had no "Mind" among their causes.

(T4) The earth hangs in the middle of everything, held up by nothing. + Thales had floated the earth on water, like a log on a pond. The obvious question is what holds up the water, and then what holds up that. Anaximander cut the chain off at the start: nothing holds the earth up, because nothing needs to. His reason is a small masterpiece. Picture a marble resting at the exact bottom of a perfectly round bowl. Every direction it could roll is uphill, and no direction is favoured over any other, so it stays where it is. Anaximander said the earth sits at the centre of everything, the same distance from every edge, and so it has no reason to move one way rather than another. Hippolytus reports that he called the earth "poised aloft, upheld by nothing," keeping its place "on account of its equal distance from all." He pictured it as a squat drum, like a section of a stone column, with its depth a third of its breadth, and we live on one of its flat faces. The shape was wrong. The idea of an earth with no pillar beneath it was startlingly right, and his is the first known argument for it rather than a bare assertion. The book of Job praises the God who "hangs the earth on nothing" (Job 26:7); Anaximander reached the same picture by a geometer’s argument.

(Q) "There are some, Anaximander, for instance, among the ancients, who say that the earth keeps its place because of its indifference. Motion upward and downward and sideways were all, they thought, equally inappropriate to that which is set at the centre and indifferently related to every extreme point." + Source: Aristotle, On the Heavens II.13, 295b (Stocks translation). "Indifference" here means having no preference: the earth is related to every edge of the cosmos in exactly the same way. Aristotle went on to call the view "ingenious but not true," and argued instead that earth sits at the centre because heavy things naturally move there.

(T5) Life began in the wet, and the first human beings were nursed inside fish-like creatures. + Anyone who has looked after a newborn knows how helpless a human baby is. A foal stands within an hour; a child needs years of feeding and carrying before it can fend for itself. Anaximander noticed this and drew a conclusion: the first human beings could not have arrived as babies with no one to look after them, or they would have died. So something else must have sheltered them. His answer was that living things first arose in moisture, warmed by the sun, and that the first humans developed inside fish-like creatures, protected until they were grown enough to come out onto dry land and feed themselves. In one of Plutarch’s dinner-party dialogues, a guest who preferred another theory reports that the first humans were reared inside fish, sheltered the way the dogfish, a small shark, shelters its young, until they could look after themselves. Hippolytus puts it in one line: man "was, originally, similar to a different animal, that is, a fish." Modern writers sometimes call him the first evolutionist. That overstates it. He offered no mechanism of gradual change, only a single dramatic transition to solve one puzzle. What deserves credit is the method: he took an ordinary fact about infants seriously and followed it as far as he could.

(Q) "Further, he says that man at first was generated from animals of other kinds, because while the other animals quickly find food of themselves, man alone needs to be nursed for a long time; and for this reason, being such as he is, he could not in the beginning have been kept alive." + Source: Pseudo-Plutarch, Stromateis 2, preserved in Eusebius, Preparation for the Gospel I.8 (Gifford translation). The summary comes from a lost handbook wrongly credited to Plutarch, and it survives only because the Christian historian Eusebius copied it into his own book, along with the views of the other early philosophers, to let readers compare them.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) Christian writers kept his memory alive, mainly to show how far the philosophers disagreed. + Anaximander’s book was lost in antiquity, and what we know of him comes from summaries copied from summaries. A surprising amount of that copying was done by Christians. - Hippolytus, a teacher in the church at Rome in the early third century, opens his Refutation of All Heresies with a survey of the Greek philosophers, Anaximander among them. His aim was to show that the heretical teachers of his day had borrowed from pagan philosophy rather than from Scripture, and to do that he first had to set the philosophy out. His chapter is one of our fullest accounts of what Anaximander taught. - Eusebius of Caesarea, the first great historian of the church, copied a summary of the early philosophers into his Preparation for the Gospel around AD 315, and invited readers to "observe the mutual disagreement" of the authors. Thales said water, Anaximander the boundless, Anaximenes air: three answers, each overturning the last. The point both men were making is fair. Brilliant minds reasoning without revelation had reached real insights, and also reached them in contradiction to one another. Imagine three honest witnesses describing the same accident and getting three different cars. You would not conclude there had been no accident; you would want someone who saw it. For the fathers, that was a reason to look for a word from outside the argument: revelation, God making known what reason, left to itself, could not settle.

(†) Augustine named exactly what was missing: a mind behind it all. + In Book VIII of The City of God, Augustine walks through the Greek philosophers in order, looking for the ones who came nearest to the truth about God. He gives Anaximander a fair paragraph, though by Augustine’s time the reports had blurred: he describes not one boundless source but principles "infinite in number," each thing springing from its own, and countless worlds forever dissolving and arising again. Then he names the gap. Anaximander, he says, did not, "any more than Thales, attribute anything to a divine mind in the production of all this activity of things." That is precisely the point where Christian faith takes Anaximander’s own question further than he did. He saw that the source of everything must be eternal, without beginning, and not one of the things it produces (T1, T3). Christians agree with every word of that. What they add is that the source is someone and not merely something: a God who knows and wills the world into being. When Paul spoke to the philosophers of Athens, he described the God in whom "we live and move and have our being" (Acts 17:28), and that is Anaximander’s "encompassing" source with a face. Augustine traced the slow approach to that truth among the Greeks. It ran through Anaxagoras, born about a century after Anaximander, the first Greek known to have said that a Mind set the world in order, and on to the Platonists, the followers of Plato, whom Augustine thought had come nearest of all. He saw in it a road that only revelation finishes.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: a source without a mind, a world without a beginning, and justice without a judge. + Anaximander saw further than almost anyone of his century, and the places where he stopped are worth naming plainly. - The source. The boundless is eternal and divine, but it is not a person, and it can no more know or will anything than the sea can. Scripture opens with a God who speaks: "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth" (Genesis 1:1), and the universe "was created by the word of God" (Hebrews 11:3). - The cycle. For Anaximander, things separate out of the boundless and are taken back into it, and later reports say whole worlds arise and dissolve this way. Scripture tells a story with a beginning and a goal: creation from nothing, and a world not dissolved back into the source but renewed by its Maker, "Behold, I am making all things new" (Revelation 21:5). - Justice. Anaximander’s cosmos pays its debts, but no one presides over the court. Abraham could appeal to a person: "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do what is just?" (Genesis 18:25). Justice in Scripture is personal, and so is mercy. - Humanity. Anaximander’s first humans began inside fish. Genesis says that "God created man in his own image" (Genesis 1:27): whatever the stages of the body’s making, what makes a human being human is a likeness to God, not a likeness to another animal. None of this diminishes him. He asked the right question about the source of everything and refused to accept a small answer. The answer he could not reach is the one Christians believe has been given.

Nothing Anaximander wrote survives except one sentence. His book was still being read in the fourth century BC, when Theophrastus summarized it, and Apollodorus seems to have seen a copy in the second; after that it disappears. Everything else we know comes through later writers who summarized the summaries, a chain scholars call the doxography (from the Greek doxa, "opinion": collections of what the philosophers held). The catalog below lists the works ancient writers credited to him, then the sources through which he is known. Works credited to him (all lost): - On Nature: The prose book on the origin and order of the world, the first of its kind among the Greeks so far as Themistius knew (Pherecydes of Syros, a near contemporary, has a rival claim to the first Greek prose). The title is the conventional one later writers gave to such books, and may not be his. Its single surviving sentence is the fragment on reparation and injustice (T2). - Circuit of the Earth: Listed by the Byzantine encyclopedia called the Suda. Probably an account of lands and peoples to go with his map. - On the Fixed Stars: Listed by the Suda. Nothing of its content is known beyond the astronomy reported in the doxography. - The Sphere: Listed by the Suda, probably connected with the model of the heavens Diogenes Laertius says he built. - The Suda adds "and some others." Some scholars think these titles are sections of a single book rather than separate works. Things he made rather than wrote: - The map: The first Greek map of the inhabited world, according to Eratosthenes as reported by Strabo (Geography I.1.11) and Agathemerus. Later improved by his fellow Milesian Hecataeus. - The globe: A model of the heavens, reported by Diogenes Laertius (II.2). - The gnomon at Sparta: A shadow-rod sundial for marking solstices and equinoxes, reported by Diogenes Laertius (II.1) from Favorinus. Herodotus (II.109) says the Greeks learned the gnomon from the Babylonians. The ancient sources for his life and thought: - Theophrastus, Opinions of the Natural Philosophers: The lost history of philosophy by Aristotle’s successor, the root of nearly all later reports. Its section on Anaximander survives in quotation by Simplicius, who preserves the one fragment (T1, T2). - Aristotle, Physics I.4, III.4–5 and On the Heavens II.13: The earliest surviving discussions of his ideas. Aristotle reports that the opposites separate out of the one source, quotes "deathless and imperishable" (T3) and reports the argument for the earth’s resting place (T4). - Hippolytus, Refutation of All Heresies I.6: A Christian summary of his cosmology, astronomy, and account of human origins (T3, T4, T5). Numbered chapter 5 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers translation. - Pseudo-Plutarch, Stromateis 2, preserved in Eusebius, Preparation for the Gospel I.8: A short doxographical summary, including his argument from the helplessness of human infants (T5). - Aëtius, Opinions: A later handbook of philosophers’ views, reconstructed from Pseudo-Plutarch and Stobaeus, with many short reports on his astronomy. - Plutarch, Table Talk VIII.8.4 and Censorinus, On the Birthday 4.7: The fullest reports of the first humans growing inside fish-like creatures (T5). - Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers II.1–2: The short biography, with Apollodorus’s date, the gnomon, map and globe, and the story of the singing. - Cicero, On Divination I.50.112: The story of the earthquake warning to Sparta. - Aelian, Historical Miscellany III.17: The report that he led a colony to Apollonia. - Pliny the Elder, Natural History II.31: Credits him with recognizing the slant of the zodiac (the tilted path the sun appears to follow through the stars) in the 58th Olympiad. - Themistius, Orations 26: Calls him the first Greek known to have published a written account of nature. - Augustine, The City of God VIII.2: The Christian assessment that he, like Thales, assigned nothing to a divine mind. - Archaeology: The headless lower part of an early statue found in the marketplace of Miletus, inscribed with his name; whether it portrays the philosopher is debated. Standard editions: Hermann Diels and Walther Kranz, Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, chapter 12 (the standard numbering, "DK 12"); G. S. Kirk, J. E. Raven and M. Schofield, The Presocratic Philosophers, 2nd ed. (Cambridge, 1983), chapter 3; André Laks and Glenn W. Most, Early Greek Philosophy, Loeb Classical Library, vol. II (2016). John Burnet’s Early Greek Philosophy (1892; 2nd ed. 1908; 3rd ed. 1920) and Arthur Fairbanks’s The First Philosophers of Greece (1898) are in the public domain and free online.

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief