Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Suetonius the Biographer c. 69 – after 122 AD
(●) The palace secretary who wrote the lives of the first twelve Caesars, and in passing gave some of the earliest pagan notices of Christians at Rome. Gaius Suetonius Tranquillus was a scholar who spent his working life close to power without ever holding much of it. He was a friend of Pliny the Younger, a keeper of the emperor’s libraries, and for a few years the man who handled the emperor Hadrian’s letters. Out of that access, and out of the palace archives it opened to him, came the book that made his name: the Lives of the Caesars, twelve portraits running from Julius Caesar to Domitian. He matters to a Christian reader for two short sentences and one long shadow. The sentences are a line in his life of Claudius about Jews at Rome rioting over someone named "Chrestus," and a line in his life of Nero about the punishment of "Christians." With the historian Tacitus and his own friend Pliny, he is one of the three Latin authors of the early second century whose surviving works mention the new faith at all, and he does it with the bored contempt of an official noting a nuisance. The shadow is the form he perfected: the short life of a famous man, told topic by topic (T1). The Christian biographer Jerome built the first catalog of Christian authors on Suetonius’s model, and said so. His dates are uncertain at both ends. No ancient source gives the year of his birth; "c. 69" is a modern inference from two remarks in his own books about being a young man around AD 88, and scholars place it anywhere from AD 69 to 70 or a little later. His death is not recorded at all. The last firm fact about him is his dismissal from Hadrian’s service, conventionally dated to AD 122, and he may have lived and written for many years after.
(●) c. 69 AD: He was born the son of an officer who had just fought for a losing emperor. The year AD 69 is remembered as the Year of the Four Emperors. Nero had killed himself the summer before, and Galba, Otho, Vitellius and Vespasian took the throne one after another, three of them by marching armies at one another. Suetonius’s father, Suetonius Laetus, was a junior officer in the Thirteenth Legion and fought for Otho at the battle of Bedriacum in northern Italy, which Otho lost. Years later the son wrote down his father’s memories of that campaign, in particular a story he often told: a common soldier who brought news of the defeat, and was called a liar, fell on his sword at Otho’s feet to prove it. That is nearly all we know of his family, and we do not know where he was born. The family were equestrians, members of the second order of Roman society, below the senators: landed, comfortable, eligible for army commands and imperial posts, but not for the consulship. An inscription honoring Suetonius was found in 1952 at Hippo Regius in North Africa (modern Annaba in Algeria, the same town where Augustine would later be bishop), and some scholars take that as a sign that Hippo was his home town. Others think it only shows that the town wanted to honor a famous patron. Either way, by the time he was a young man he was living at Rome.
(●) c. 88–90 AD: As a youth in Domitian’s Rome he watched the state strip an old man in open court to see whether he was a Jew. Suetonius almost never talks about himself, which makes the two moments he does stand out. In his life of Nero he says that twenty years after Nero’s death, "at which time I was a young man," an impostor claiming to be Nero turned up among the Parthians, Rome’s great rival empire beyond its eastern frontier, and was warmly received. And in his life of Domitian he recalls a scene from his youth that has stayed with every reader since. Domitian was collecting, with great severity, the special tax laid on Jews after Jerusalem fell to Rome in AD 70, and his agents went after people who lived as Jews without registering, and people who hid that they were Jews. Suetonius remembers being present in a crowded court when a man of ninety was examined, publicly and bodily, so that the official could see whether he was circumcised, the covenant mark that Jewish men carried in the body. He records it without comment, but he chose to record it, and the picture says a great deal about how Rome in those years watched the line between Jews and everyone else. It was in that same suspicious city, under that same emperor, that Christians were learning what it meant to be neither Jew nor pagan in the eyes of the state.
(●) c. 97–110 AD: Pliny the Younger took him into his circle, a nervous advocate who would rather study than serve. What we know of Suetonius as a young man comes almost entirely from the letters of his friend and patron Pliny the Younger, a senator and lawyer some seven or eight years older than he was. They are affectionate letters, and they show a particular kind of person. In one, Suetonius has written in alarm because he dreamed something that he fears bodes ill for a case he is about to argue in court, and he asks Pliny to get the hearing postponed. Pliny promises to try, quotes Homer that "dreams descend from Jove" (in William Melmoth’s old translation; Jove is Jupiter, king of the gods), and then gently tells the story of a frightening dream of his own that preceded his first great success. In another, Pliny is helping him buy a small country property, just enough land, Pliny says, for a scholar to clear his head and walk about. In a third, Pliny has obtained for him a post as military tribune, a junior officer’s commission and a usual first step in an equestrian career, and Suetonius asks to have it transferred to a relative instead. In a fourth, Pliny teases him for sitting on a finished piece of writing and begs him to publish it at last. Put those together and you have a man who was careful, cautious, a little anxious, more at home with books than with camps or courtrooms, and in no hurry to publish until his work was right.
(●) c. 110–112 AD: At Pliny’s request, the emperor Trajan granted him the legal privileges of a father of three. Augustus had passed laws to push Romans of the upper classes into marrying and raising children, and a man with three children received real advantages: in inheritance, in careers, in exemptions from public burdens. The emperor could grant the same privileges, called the "right of three children," as a personal favor to a man who had none. Pliny, by then governing the province of Bithynia-Pontus on the southern coast of the Black Sea, wrote to Trajan to ask that favor for Suetonius. He called him, in Melmoth’s rendering, "a most excellent, honourable, and learned man," said he had long since taken him into his household, and explained, with the frankness of a friend, that Suetonius needed the privileges because of the "ill-success of his marriage." Trajan, who granted such favors sparingly, granted this one. It is the only hint we have of his marriage: he had a wife, and no children. There is a striking neighbor in the same book of letters. A few letters later, Pliny writes to Trajan asking what to do with the Christians being denounced to him in his province, perhaps the most famous pagan document about the early church. Some scholars think Suetonius was with Pliny in Bithynia, but nothing in the letters says so, and we do not know.
(●) c. 114–121 AD: He rose to run the emperor’s libraries and then his correspondence, and wrote the Lives with the archives open to him. The inscription from Hippo, broken but readable, lists the posts he held. He was in charge of the emperor’s studies (a studiis), probably an adviser on literary and learned matters; then in charge of the public libraries of Rome (a bybliothecis); and finally in charge of the emperor’s correspondence (ab epistulis), under Hadrian. That last post is something like a chief of staff for paperwork: every letter to and from the emperor passed through his office. For a man writing the lives of emperors, the job was a gift. Suetonius quotes from the private letters of Augustus, in Augustus’s own spelling, and he says he once owned a small bronze statue of Augustus as a boy, which he gave to Hadrian. Much of what readers still treasure in the Lives, the habits and sayings and handwriting, the household detail, came from documents most historians never saw. He dedicated the Lives of the Caesars to Gaius Septicius Clarus, commander of the praetorian guard, the emperor’s bodyguard, a post Septicius held from about AD 119 to 122. That gives the usual date for at least the first books of the work.
(●) c. 122 AD: Hadrian dismissed him, and he disappears from the record. The fall came suddenly, and the only account of it is short and late. The Historia Augusta, a collection of imperial biographies written some two and a half centuries afterward and not always trustworthy, says that Hadrian replaced both Septicius Clarus and Suetonius because they had behaved toward his wife, the empress Sabina, with more familiarity than the etiquette of the court allowed. What that means we do not know. It may have been no more than a breach of protocol while Hadrian was away; he was touring the provinces, and the dismissal is usually placed in AD 122, during or around his visit to Britain. After that there is silence. No one recorded when or where Suetonius died. Some of his many smaller works may belong to these later years, and some scholars think the last books of the Lives, which are shorter and draw less on the archives, were written after he had lost access to them. It is a plausible guess, and only a guess. He simply walks out of the story, a quiet man who spent his life writing about loud ones.
What He Recorded
(T1) A ruler is known by his habits, so a life is best told topic by topic rather than year by year. Think of how you would describe a grandfather to someone who never met him. You probably would not start with a timeline. You would say what he did for a living, how he treated his family, what he ate, what made him laugh, how he looked at the end. That is how Suetonius writes. After a brief run through each emperor’s family and career, he breaks the life into headings: wars, laws, public building, games and shows, then the private man, his appearance, his health, his tastes, his superstitions, his death. Historians call this arrangement by species, Latin for "kinds" or "categories," as opposed to the method of an annalist like Tacitus, who marches through events one year at a time. The result reads less like history and more like a file kept on each man. Suetonius rarely explains causes or draws morals out loud. He lays out the evidence under its headings, good and bad side by side, and leaves the reader to weigh it. That is why Caligula’s cruelty and his terror of thunderstorms can sit a few pages apart. It is also why his little notices of Jews and Christians are where they are. They are not in a narrative of events but filed under a heading, among an emperor’s regulations (T3, T4).
(Q) "Having thus given a very short summary of his life, I shall prosecute the several parts of it, not in order of time, but arranging his acts into distinct classes, for the sake of perspicuity." Source: Suetonius, Life of Augustus 9 (Thomson translation, revised by T. Forester, Bohn’s Classical Library). This is his plainest statement of method, and it comes at the turn from the outline of Augustus’s career to the topical survey. "Perspicuity" is the old word for clarity.
(T2) Heaven sends signs, and the East expected a ruler to come out of Judea. The same man who asked Pliny to postpone a hearing because of a bad dream filled his books with omens. Almost every emperor’s life in Suetonius has its portents: an eagle that settles on a child, a statue that turns on its pedestal, a dream that comes true, a lightning strike before a death. He does not argue that the signs are real. He collects them, carefully, as part of the record, the way a modern biographer would collect letters. The most important of these for Christian readers sits in his life of Vespasian. A belief had spread through the East, he says, that at that time men coming out of Judea would rule the world. Suetonius reads it the way a loyal Roman would: it came true when Vespasian, commanding the army in Judea during the Jewish revolt, was proclaimed emperor. The Jewish historian Josephus, who surrendered to Vespasian in that war, gives the same reading in his Jewish War, and Tacitus reports the same expectation in his Histories. What all three are describing is a real hope among Jews of the first century, drawn from their Scriptures, that God would raise up a king from Israel to rule the nations. That is the hope the church says was fulfilled in someone else from Judea, a generation before Vespasian. Suetonius is a witness that the expectation was in the air, widely enough that a Roman antiquarian, a collector of old customs and curious facts, thought it worth setting down.
(Q) "A firm persuasion had long prevailed through all the East, that it was fated for the empire of the world, at that time, to devolve on some who should go forth from Judaea." Source: Suetonius, Life of Vespasian 4.5 (Thomson translation, revised by T. Forester, Bohn’s Classical Library). The next sentence gives his reading: "This prediction referred to a Roman emperor, as the event shewed," and he adds that the Jews, applying it to themselves, rose in revolt. Compare Josephus, Jewish War 6.312–313, and Tacitus, Histories 5.13.
(T3) Under Claudius the Jews of Rome kept rioting at the prompting of one "Chrestus," and the emperor expelled them. Imagine a newspaper item from a distant city: "Police dispersed a disturbance in the immigrant quarter caused by followers of one Mr. Kristos." The reporter has no idea who Mr. Kristos is and does not care. That is roughly what Suetonius gives us, in a list of Claudius’s dealings with foreign peoples, wedged between a tax exemption for Troy and a seating arrangement for German ambassadors. The name is the puzzle. "Chrestus" was a common Greek name at Rome, especially among slaves and freedmen (former slaves), meaning "useful" or "kindly." "Christus," the Latin spelling of the Greek title Christos, "Christ," meaning "anointed," sounded almost identical in the Greek of the day, so that a listener could easily hear one and write down the other. Christian writers of the second century complain that pagans confused the two. Most historians therefore take Suetonius to be garbling a report of quarrels in the Jewish synagogues of Rome over the claim that Jesus was the Messiah, the anointed king Israel was waiting for, with "Chrestus" mistaken for a living troublemaker on the spot. A minority think Chrestus was simply a local Jewish agitator of that name. Suetonius himself does not say which, and almost certainly did not know. What makes the line matter is Luke. In Acts, Paul arrives in Corinth and meets "a Jew named Aquila, a native of Pontus, recently come from Italy with his wife Priscilla, because Claudius had commanded all the Jews to leave Rome" (Acts 18:2). A Roman archivist and a Christian historian, writing independently, record the same expulsion. The Christian historian Orosius dated it to AD 49, which fits Paul’s stay in Corinth.
(Q) "He banished from Rome all the Jews, who were continually making disturbances at the instigation of one Chrestus." Source: Suetonius, Life of Claudius 25.4 (Thomson translation, revised by T. Forester, Bohn’s Classical Library). The Latin is only seven words: three give the ruling, and four, tucked in the middle, give the reason: Iudaeos impulsore Chresto assidue tumultuantis Roma expulit, "the Jews, constantly rioting at the prompting of Chrestus, he expelled from Rome."
(T4) In his eyes Christians were a new and harmful superstition, and Nero did well to punish them. The second notice is shorter still. In his life of Nero, Suetonius first gathers the emperor’s acts that were, in Thomson’s rendering, "in part unexceptionable, and in part highly commendable," to keep them apart from the crimes that follow. Among them: new rules for building after fires, limits on luxury, a ban on cookshops selling anything but vegetables, a crackdown on rowdy charioteers, and punishment for the Christians. They sit in the list of sensible public-order measures, between the cookshops and the charioteers. Two Latin words carry his judgment. Superstitio did not mean, for a Roman, a fear of black cats. It meant a foreign or excessive cult, the opposite of religio, the proper and traditional honoring of the gods that held the city together. A superstitio was what other people had: too emotional, too exclusive, too strange. And he calls this one malefica, "harmful" or "mischievous," a word with a hint of black magic about it. Notice what he does not say. Tacitus ties Nero’s punishment of Christians to the great fire of Rome in AD 64, and says Nero used them as scapegoats. Suetonius, who blames the fire on Nero himself, never connects the two. For him the Christians are simply a nuisance the government was right to suppress, and he reports it with approval. He is a hostile witness, and that is what makes him useful: no Christian put these words in his mouth.
(Q) "He likewise inflicted punishments on the Christians, a sort of people who held a new and impious superstition." Source: Suetonius, Life of Nero 16.2 (Thomson translation, revised by T. Forester, Bohn’s Classical Library). The Latin calls them genus hominum superstitionis novae ac maleficae, "a class of people given to a new and harmful superstition." Thomson’s "impious" softens malefica, which more literally means "evil-doing."
(T5) The senate could vote a dead emperor into a god, and the shrewdest emperor joked about it on his deathbed. Every one of Suetonius’s first two subjects, Julius Caesar and Augustus, was declared a god after death. The process had a name, consecratio, and it worked something like a posthumous promotion: the senate voted, a temple and priests followed, and the dead man was called divus, "the deified." Living emperors were honored with sacrifices offered for their genius, their guardian spirit, across the provinces. Some, like Caligula and Domitian, wanted to be addressed as gods while alive, and Suetonius records it as a mark of their madness and arrogance. Vespasian, the plain soldier from the Sabine hills northeast of Rome, saw through all of it. As his final illness came on, he made a dry joke at his own expense, and Suetonius, who loved a good last line, preserved it. When the end came, struggling to rise, Vespasian said that an emperor ought to die standing, and died in the arms of those helping him up. This is the world the first Christians lived in, and it is why the emperor cult mattered so much to them. Pliny, Suetonius’s friend, tested accused Christians by asking them to offer incense and wine to the emperor’s image. The Romans who did it often believed no more than Vespasian did. The Christians who refused believed that there is one Lord, and that he is not in Rome.
(Q) "I suppose," said he, "I shall soon be a god." Source: Suetonius, Life of Vespasian 23.4 (Thomson translation, revised by T. Forester, Bohn’s Classical Library). The Latin, Vae, puto deus fio, is more literally "Oh dear, I think I am becoming a god." Suetonius sets it in a chapter on Vespasian’s wit, which he says did not desert him even in fear of death.
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Jerome took his catalog of famous men as the pattern for the first catalog of Christian writers. Besides the emperors, Suetonius wrote a long work called On Famous Men, short lives of Roman poets, orators, historians, philosophers, grammarians and teachers of rhetoric. In AD 392 Jerome, the scholar who gave the Latin church its Bible, was asked by a friend named Dexter to do the same for the church, and he took the assignment in exactly those terms. His On Illustrious Men opens by naming Suetonius as the model, and goes on to give 135 short lives of Christian authors, from Peter to Jerome himself. Jerome had a pointed purpose. He closes his preface by challenging the pagan critics Celsus, Porphyry and Julian, who sneered that the church had no philosophers or men of learning, to look at the list and learn how many such men had founded, built and adorned it. Suetonius had shown what a nation’s literature looked like set in order. Jerome used his form to show that the church had a literature too. Jerome had already drawn on Suetonius’s On Famous Men for the dates of Roman writers in his Chronicle, a year-by-year history of the world, and those borrowings are one of the reasons parts of the lost work survive at all. Later Christian biographers kept the form going: Einhard’s Life of Charlemagne, written in the ninth century, is shaped closely on Suetonius’s life of Augustus, heading by heading.
(†) Orosius read the riot over "Chrestus" as a quarrel over Christ and set it beside the Acts of the Apostles. Paulus Orosius, a Spanish priest and a younger friend of Augustine, wrote his Seven Books of History Against the Pagans around AD 417 to answer the charge that Rome had fallen to the Goths because it had abandoned its old gods. When he came to the reign of Claudius he quoted Suetonius directly, reading "Christo" for "Chresto," and confessed that he could not tell whether Claudius meant to restrain the Jews rioting against Christ, or to expel the Christians with them as people of a kindred religion. He also dated the expulsion to the ninth year of Claudius, AD 49, and credited the date to Josephus, though no such passage survives in Josephus. That reading, Christ behind the riots and the expulsion of Acts 18 behind the line, is still the majority view among historians, and it is how the line is most often read.
(†) Modern apologists count him among the hostile witnesses who confirm the outline of the church’s first decades. When Christian historians today gather the non-Christian evidence for Jesus and the early church, Suetonius sits beside Tacitus, Pliny and Josephus. What he adds is modest, and it is worth being exact about it. - The name. By the time of Nero, Roman officials knew a group called "Christians" at Rome by that name, the name the disciples were first given at Antioch (Acts 11:26). - The punishment. The state punished them under Nero, as Tacitus also reports, and Suetonius approved of it. - The expulsion. Under Claudius, Jews were expelled from Rome after disturbances connected with "Chrestus," matching Luke’s report of Aquila and Priscilla in Acts 18:2. - The expectation. In the first century a hope that a ruler would come out of Judea was widespread enough for a Roman scholar to record it (T2). What he does not add is any account of Jesus himself. He never describes the crucifixion, and the "Chrestus" line, read as most read it, tells us only that Christ was being argued about in the synagogues of Rome within twenty years of the crucifixion. That is a small thing, and also not a small thing: a faith was already crossing the Mediterranean and causing trouble in the capital while many of those who had seen Jesus were still alive.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: the faith was not new, it was not harmful, and Nero was not right to punish it. Suetonius passed judgment on the Christians in a single line, and each part of it is answered from the record he did not consult. - Not new. To a Roman, "new" in religion meant suspect: a cult without ancestors. The apostles insisted the reverse, that the gospel was the fulfillment of what God "promised beforehand through his prophets in the holy Scriptures" (Romans 1:2), the same Scriptures from which came the very expectation Suetonius recorded (T2). - Not harmful. Peter told the scattered churches to keep their "conduct among the Gentiles honorable, so that when they speak against you as evildoers, they may see your good deeds" (1 Peter 2:12). Pliny, Suetonius’s own friend, examined accused Christians a few years before the Lives were written, even putting two slave women who served in their worship to torture, and reported to Trajan (Letters 10.96, Melmoth translation) that they met before dawn to pray to Christ "as to a divinity," bound themselves by oath "never to commit any fraud, theft, or adultery," and then shared "a harmless meal." He still called the faith a superstition, but he could name no crime. - Not rightly punished. Suetonius files the punishment among Nero’s sensible measures, beside the regulation of cookshops. He never asks what the Christians had done. The early apologists (the Christian writers who answered the faith’s critics in public, from Justin Martyr onward) pressed exactly that question: that Christians were being punished for a name, not for a crime. None of this makes him a dishonest writer. He was a careful archivist who recorded what the files said and what his class believed, and on this one subject his class believed wrongly.