Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
David Bentley Hart of Howard County b. 1965 AD
(●) The Eastern Orthodox scholar who answered the New Atheists with classical theism, and then argued that God will save everyone. Most people who argue about God picture the same thing when they use the word: a very large, very powerful person somewhere out there, one more item in the universe, only bigger. David Bentley Hart has spent his career telling both believers and skeptics that this picture is not what the great Christian tradition ever meant. For the church fathers, the medieval doctors, and the Orthodox East he belongs to, God is not one more thing inside the world but the reason there is a world at all. That older picture has a name, classical theism, and Hart has become one of its best-known voices (T1). He is on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons that pull in different directions. His books Atheist Delusions (2009) and The Experience of God (2013) are among the most admired Christian replies to the New Atheism, the wave of popular unbelief led by Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, and Christopher Hitchens in the 2000s. And his That All Shall Be Saved (2019) is among the most forceful modern cases for universalism, the teaching that in the end every created person will be saved, a view most Christians in every tradition have rejected. He is also, by common consent, one of the finest English prose stylists writing theology today: a scholar who has translated the whole New Testament, writes children’s mysteries with his son, and has published a book of philosophy about his dog.
(●) 1965 AD: Born in Maryland and raised Anglican, the youngest of three brothers. Hart was born in 1965 in Howard County, Maryland, into a family whose Maryland roots go back to the colony’s first settlers. The household was Anglican, part of the worldwide family of churches that grew from the Church of England, and it was churchly enough that both of his older brothers became clergymen: Addison Hodges Hart, a priest and author, and Robert Hart, rector (the priest in charge) of an Anglican Catholic parish in North Carolina. He went to Wilde Lake High School in Columbia, Maryland, took Latin and Greek there, and graduated in 1982 as a National Merit Scholar (an American award for the top scorers on a nationwide exam taken in high school), at seventeen. The languages stuck, and they would shape the rest of his working life. Thirty-five years later he would publish his own translation of the entire New Testament from the Greek (2017 AD).
(●) c. 1986 AD: At about twenty-one he was received into the Eastern Orthodox Church. At about the age of twenty-one Hart left the Anglicanism of his family for Eastern Orthodoxy. The Orthodox Church is the ancient Christianity of the Greek-speaking East, the church of the Byzantine empire, of Russia and the Balkans, and of the great Greek fathers such as Athanasius, Basil, Gregory of Nyssa, and Maximus the Confessor. He has remained an Orthodox layman ever since, never ordained. The move matters for everything that follows. Many of the convictions that make his books distinctive (God as the infinite source of being rather than a being, salvation as a share in the divine life, and his later universalism) are ones he reads out of the Greek fathers, Gregory of Nyssa above all. The second of those convictions, salvation as a share in God’s own life, has a name worth learning: deification (theosis in Greek). It does not mean becoming a second God. The fathers liked to picture an iron bar left in a fire: it stays iron, but it glows with the fire’s heat and light, and so a saved creature stays a creature while being filled with the life of God. All the while he was studying, first for a bachelor’s degree in interdisciplinary studies at the University of Maryland, then a Master of Philosophy in theology at the University of Cambridge.
(●) 1997 AD: He finished a doctorate on beauty and violence, and its book made his name among theologians. In 1997 Hart completed his doctorate in religious studies at the University of Virginia, with a dissertation titled Beauty, Violence, and Infinity: A Question Concerning Christian Rhetoric. The historian of the early church Robert Louis Wilken sat on the committee of professors who examined it. The question behind it was a sharp one, and it is easier to see with a picture. Imagine a salesman at your door who is perfectly polite, never raises his voice, and still will not leave until you have signed. Much late twentieth-century philosophy, the movement loosely called postmodernism, had learned from the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche to suspect every grand story about the world. Such a story, it held, is finally a mask for power, a way of forcing other people into your categories. If that is right, then preaching the gospel is just one more act of violence, however gently it is done: the salesman at the door, only with better manners. Hart’s answer was that the Christian story is the one story that begins not with conflict but with peace. A God who needs nothing creates out of sheer generosity, and the world is a gift to be enjoyed, the way a piece of music is, rather than a battlefield. Rewritten as The Beauty of the Infinite (2003), the dissertation became a dense book and not an easy one, but one reviewer could think of no more brilliant work by an American theologian in the previous ten years. For a dozen years he taught in a string of posts: at Virginia, the University of St. Thomas in Minnesota, Duke Divinity School, and Loyola College in Maryland, later as a visiting chair at Providence College and Saint Louis University. Along the way he became a regular columnist for First Things, the journal of religion and public life, and the essays won him a far wider audience than the academic books ever could.
(●) 2004 AD: After the Indian Ocean tsunami he wrote that a Christian may hate death rather than explain it. On 26 December 2004 an undersea earthquake off Sumatra sent a wall of water across the Indian Ocean, and more than two hundred thousand people died, most of them in a single day and many of them children. Five days later, on the last day of the year, Hart published a column in the Wall Street Journal, "Tremors of Doubt," on where God was in it. On Christian websites the column drew replies from believers who wanted to explain the disaster as part of a hidden divine plan. Explanations of that kind have an old name, theodicy, from the Greek words for God and justice: an attempt to justify God’s goodness in the face of evil. Hart answered them at length in First Things ("Tsunami and Theodicy," March 2005) and then in a short book, The Doors of the Sea (2005), and his answer was to refuse the kind of theodicy they offered. Death and suffering, he argued, are not God’s tools; they are the enemy Christ came to destroy (T2). The little book, written in the shadow of a real catastrophe rather than as an exercise, found readers well beyond theological circles, among people who had stood at a graveside and asked the same question.
(●) 2009 AD: Atheist Delusions answered the New Atheists, and four years later The Experience of God told them what God means. By 2009 the New Atheism was a publishing phenomenon: Dawkins’s The God Delusion, Hitchens’s God Is Not Great, Harris’s The End of Faith. Hart’s Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies (Yale, 2009) did not answer them argument by argument. Instead it went after the story they told about history, in which Christianity had smothered the bright reason of the ancient world until science set it free, and argued that nearly the reverse was true (T3). In 2011 it won the Michael Ramsey Prize, a British award for theological writing, presented by Rowan Williams, then Archbishop of Canterbury, at the Hay Festival, the literary festival held each year in the small Welsh town of Hay-on-Wye. The Experience of God: Being, Consciousness, Bliss (Yale, 2013) went after the other half of the confusion: the idea of God itself (T1). Its subtitle borrows three words from the Hindu tradition (sat, chit, ananda) to name three ordinary experiences, that things exist at all, that we are aware of them, and that we long for truth and goodness, each of which, he argued, points past the world to God. The Guardian columnist Oliver Burkeman, no believer, titled his review "The one theology book all atheists really should read."
(●) 2017 AD: He published his own New Testament, and two years later his case that all will be saved. In 2015 Hart became a fellow of the University of Notre Dame’s Institute for Advanced Study, and South Bend, Indiana, became home. Two of his most debated books came out of these years. The New Testament: A Translation (Yale, 2017; second edition 2023) set out to render the Greek as literally as English would allow, keeping the roughness of Mark’s Greek rough and leaving out the smoothing that most committee translations (versions made by a panel of scholars working together, as most modern Bibles are) do. Imagine a carpenter who refuses to sand a table because he wants you to feel the grain of the wood. Some readers found it a revelation. Others did not: the Anglican bishop and New Testament scholar N. T. Wright reviewed it critically in the Christian Century in January 2018, and Hart replied within days, in kind. That All Shall Be Saved: Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation (Yale, 2019) followed. It is short, fierce, and argued as philosophy more than as Bible study, and it provoked the widest controversy of his career (T4).
(●) 2021 AD onward: He turned to essays, fiction, and the philosophy of mind, writing for his own readers. From July 2021 Hart has written much of his work for Leaves in the Wind, a subscription newsletter of essays, conversations, and readers’ questions. The same year brought two books no one else in his field would have written: Roland in Moonlight, a philosophical book in which his dog, Roland, takes part in the conversation, and Kenogaia, a novel built on the old Gnostic myth of a soul trapped in a false world. (The Gnostics were ancient sects the early church opposed, who taught that the material world is a prison made by a lesser god, and that the soul escapes it through secret knowledge, gnōsis in Greek.) The scholarly books kept coming as well: You Are Gods (2022) and Tradition and Apocalypse (2022), on grace and on how doctrine grows; All Things Are Full of Gods (2024), a long dialogue arguing that mind cannot be explained away as matter; and The Light of Tabor (2025), from the Stanton Lectures he gave at Cambridge in 2024, a lecture series in the philosophy of religion. With his son Patrick he has written children’s mysteries and a translation of the Tao Te Ching, the ancient Chinese classic of the Way.
What He Taught
(T1) God is not one more being in the universe, but the infinite source of all being. Suppose someone tells you there are fairies at the bottom of the garden. That is a claim you could, in principle, check: set up a camera, wait by the roses, see what turns up. Fairies, if there are any, are things inside the world, and things inside the world can be looked for. Hart’s complaint against much modern atheism, and against a good deal of popular Christian talk too, is that it treats God the same way, as a very large and very old being who might or might not be out there, like a fairy only grander. Then the argument is about whether that being shows up in the evidence. But the God of Christian, Jewish, and Islamic tradition was never that kind of thing. Theologians call the older view classical theism: God is not a being alongside other beings but being itself, the act of existing by which anything at all exists. He is not the biggest item in the inventory of the world; he is the reason there is an inventory. That is why Hart thinks the question of God is not a question for a laboratory. It is the question why there is anything rather than nothing, and why a mind can know it. Christians of every tradition hold this much: Paul told the Athenians that in God "we live and move and have our being" (Acts 17:28).
(Q) "He is not a being, at least not in the way that a tree, a clock, or a god is; he is not one more object in the inventory of things that are. He is the infinite wellspring of all that is, in whom all things live and move and have their being." Source: David Bentley Hart, "God, Gods, and Fairies," First Things, June/July 2013. Written a few months before The Experience of God appeared, the essay sets out its central distinction in a few pages: a god is a being inside nature, however splendid, while God is the source on which nature depends. The last clause echoes Paul on Mars Hill (Acts 17:28).
(T2) Suffering and death are not part of God’s plan but the enemy Christ came to destroy. Picture a pastor at the bedside of parents whose child has just died, telling them that God planned it for a greater good they cannot yet see. Hart thinks that is exactly the wrong thing to say, and not only because it is unkind. He thinks it is bad theology. The New Testament, he argues, does not treat death as God’s instrument. It names death as an enemy, "The last enemy to be destroyed is death" (1 Corinthians 15:26), and it pictures creation as groaning under a bondage it was never made for (Romans 8:21–22). The world we live in is a good creation that has fallen, broken by the rebellion of creatures, angelic and human, and God is not the author of its wreckage but its rescuer. So a Christian may grieve without pretending the grief is secretly good, and may hate suffering and death "with a perfect hatred," as Hart put it, borrowing an old phrase from Psalm 139:22 in its King James wording. Many Christians, especially in the Reformed tradition (the churches shaped by John Calvin, Presbyterians among them, which stress God’s sovereign rule over everything that happens), have held that God ordains (decrees beforehand, as part of his plan) even great evils for wise purposes, and they answered him in those terms. Hart’s point was narrower than some of them heard. He did not deny that God permits evil and brings good out of it. What he denied is that evil in itself has a meaning to discover, as though the drowned child were a piece of a puzzle that will one day make sense. The comfort the gospel offers is not an explanation but a victory: the God who will "wipe away every tear from their eyes" (Revelation 21:4).
(Q) "As for comfort, when we seek it, I can imagine none greater than the happy knowledge that when I see the death of a child I do not see the face of God, but the face of His enemy." Source: David Bentley Hart, "Tsunami and Theodicy," First Things, March 2005. The closing paragraph of his reply to the Christians who had answered his Wall Street Journal column on the 2004 tsunami online. The same argument, expanded, became The Doors of the Sea (2005).
(T3) Christianity was a revolution that gave the West its belief in the worth of the weak. Late in the Passion narrative, the Gospels’ account of Jesus’ arrest, trial, and death, after Peter has denied Jesus three times and the rooster has crowed, the Gospel says simply that "he went out and wept bitterly" (Matthew 26:75). It is easy to read past. Hart asks his readers to stop on it, because no one in the classical world would have written it that way. In the literature of Greece and Rome a peasant’s tears were material for comedy. The Gospels treat a fisherman’s grief as worth recording, with complete seriousness. That small scene stands for his whole argument in Atheist Delusions. The popular story says that the ancient world was rational and humane until Christianity darkened it. Hart answers that the ancient world, for all its brilliance, took for granted things we now find monstrous: the exposure of unwanted infants (newborns left outdoors to die or to be taken by strangers), the casual cruelty of the arena, the conviction that the slave and the beggar simply did not count. The values modern secular people hold most dear, the dignity of every person, care for the sick and the poor, compassion as a virtue rather than a weakness, came into the West through the church. The New Atheists, on this reading, are living on borrowed capital, like heirs spending an inheritance while insisting they never had a father. He does not claim that Christians lived up to it. His point is that the standard by which critics now judge the church’s failures is itself the church’s gift.
(Q) "Nowhere in the literature of pagan antiquity, I assure you, had the tears of a rustic been regarded as worthy of anything but ridicule; to treat them with reverence, as meaningful expressions of real human sorrow, would have seemed grotesque from the perspective of all the classical canons of good taste." Source: David Bentley Hart, "Christ and Nothing," First Things, October 2003. First delivered as a lecture at St. Olaf College in Minnesota, the essay is an early statement of the "Christian revolution" thesis that Atheist Delusions worked out at book length six years later. Hart is speaking of Peter weeping after his denial (Matthew 26:75).
(T4) In the end God will save every created person, and no one will be lost forever. Hart tells how, at about fourteen, he came across an old story from the Egyptian desert in a volume of early Christian writings that belonged to his eldest brother. Abba Macarius (abba is "father," the desert monks’ title for their elders), a fourth-century monk, finds a skull that speaks: it belonged to a pagan priest, now suspended in fire, who says that when Macarius prays for the dead the damned are given a moment’s relief, a glimpse of one another’s faces. As a piece of antique literature the tale had a ghastly charm. But taken as a true picture of things, he saw, it would make the monk "immeasurably more merciful than the God he worshipped." That All Shall Be Saved is that thought worked out at length. The doctrine it defends has a name worth learning: apokatastasis, Greek for "restoration," the teaching that God will finally restore all things to himself. Three of his arguments carry most of the weight. The first is about the Creator. A God who creates freely out of nothing is responsible for the whole of what he makes, much as an author answers for the way the story ends: no novelist can blame the last chapter on the characters. So, Hart reasons, a creation that ends with some creatures in endless torment would show that God willed that outcome, and no good being could will it. The second is about freedom. We usually picture a free choice as a fork in the road, with the chooser able to go either way. Hart pictures it more like a thirsty traveler who at last finds clean water: the more clearly he sees what it is, the more surely he drinks. Freedom, on this view, is the power to reach the Good, not the power to reject it forever, and so a will that saw the Good clearly could never finally refuse it. The third is about a single word, and it matters more than its size suggests. The New Testament’s word usually translated "eternal" (aiōnios) means, he argues, "belonging to the age to come," not "endless." He builds on texts that every Christian reads: "For as in Adam all die, so also in Christ shall all be made alive" (1 Corinthians 15:22); God "desires all people to be saved" (1 Timothy 2:4); "that God may be all in all" (1 Corinthians 15:28). And he can name an ancient line of universalist hope: Origen, the brilliant third-century teacher of Alexandria, in some of his writings, and Gregory of Nyssa plainly. Most Christians, then and now, have read these texts differently, and their reasons deserve a hearing of their own (†).
(Q) "If Christianity is in any way true, Christians dare not doubt the salvation of all, and that any understanding of what God accomplished in Christ that does not include the assurance of a final apokatastasis in which all things created are redeemed and joined to God is ultimately entirely incoherent and unworthy of rational faith." Source: David Bentley Hart, That All Shall Be Saved: Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation (Yale University Press, 2019), p. 66. Hart’s own summary of the book’s thesis, stated at full strength. He admits in its opening pages that he cannot reasonably expect to persuade anyone.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) Theologians across the traditions welcomed him as a major voice and a formidable defender of the faith. Hart’s admirers have come from every branch of the church. The Beauty of the Infinite was praised by the Presbyterian theologian William Placher and the Methodist Geoffrey Wainwright as the arrival of a leading theologian. When Rowan Williams, the Anglican Archbishop of Canterbury, presented the Michael Ramsey Prize for Atheist Delusions in 2011, he said the book showed "how the most treasured principles and values of compassionate humanism are rooted in the detail of Christian doctrine." The philosopher Anthony Kenny, a former Catholic priest turned agnostic, reviewing it in the Times Literary Supplement, admired the precision with which it caught its opponents’ errors. The reason was partly the arguments and partly the voice. Apologetics (the reasoned defense of the Christian faith) had grown used to careful, defensive prose; Hart wrote with wit, erudition, and open delight in a fight, and readers who would never open a book of theology found themselves reading his.
(†) His account of God gave Christians a shared answer to the New Atheism’s "God hypothesis." Richard Dawkins had framed God as a hypothesis, a very complicated being whose existence would itself need explaining. The Experience of God gave Christians, and Jews and Muslims too, a clear way to say that this was not the God their traditions believed in (T1). The point was not new. Augustine made it around AD 400 and Aquinas in the thirteenth century, and Hart draws on both. But Hart put it in modern prose for a general reader, and Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant teachers alike have handed the book to doubting students since. His history of the church’s moral revolution (T3) did similar work. A kindred argument, that modern humanism lives on Christian capital, later reached a much wider audience through the historian Tom Holland, a nonbeliever, in Dominion (2019).
(†) That All Shall Be Saved divided his readers, and most of the church’s theologians answered it. Some praised the book, among them Robert Louis Wilken and John Behr, an Orthodox scholar of the church fathers. Far more wrote to answer it. The historian Michael McClymond, whose two-volume The Devil’s Redemption (2018) had just argued that universalism has always been a minority view, often joined to other errors, became one of his sharpest critics. The Catholic philosopher Edward Feser, otherwise a close ally on classical theism (T1), wrote against it, as did the Protestant theologian Peter Leithart. The Dominican James Dominic Rooney, a member of the Catholic order of preachers that Thomas Aquinas once belonged to, went further and judged it heretical, that is, contrary to the faith the church has defined. The debate itself was a kind of tribute. A short book of philosophical meditations drew long replies from Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant scholars, and the question of hell was argued in public again.
(†) Where most Christians part ways with him: Scripture warns of a final loss, and a creature can truly refuse God. Hart’s universalism is his own teaching, argued at length in his own books, and on it he stands apart from the main body of Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant Christianity alike. Christians who admire his classical theism and his history still part company with him at three points. - The warnings are real. Jesus closes the parable of the sheep and the goats with a contrast: "And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life." (Matthew 25:46). The same word, aiōnios, governs both halves of the sentence, and most interpreters have judged that if the life lasts, so does the loss. Paul speaks of "the punishment of eternal destruction, away from the presence of the Lord" (2 Thessalonians 1:9). Hart’s reading of aiōnios as "of the age" is a real argument about Greek, but it has persuaded few translators. - Refusal is possible. Hart holds that a will which saw the Good clearly could not finally reject it. Most of the tradition, Orthodox and Catholic as much as Protestant, has held that a creature can say a real and final no to God, and that the lost are not dragged from his presence but refuse it. C. S. Lewis put it in a sentence: "the doors of hell are locked on the inside" (The Problem of Pain, ch. 8). - The church has judged it. Gregory of Nyssa hoped for the restoration of all and was honored as a saint, so the hope itself has never been treated as simple unbelief. But the church in the East, which Hart belongs to, condemned the Origenist teaching of the restoration (the form of it descended from Origen) in the sixth century. It did so in anathemas, formal declarations that a teaching lies outside the faith, which historians link to the Fifth Ecumenical Council of 553, one of the councils of the whole early church that Orthodox and Catholics alike still accept. The Western church taught the same through Augustine and the Fourth Lateran Council of 1215, a great council of the medieval Western church. Hart answers that the anathemas targeted a different, speculative system; most of his critics are not persuaded. Some readers have also faulted the manner of the book, which labels its opponents "infernalists" (his name for those who believe some will be lost forever) and treats their view as plainly monstrous. On the substance, Christians can share Hart’s hope that many more will be saved than we imagine, and still hold, with Scripture and with most of the church, that the door can be shut from within.