Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

Larry Hurtado of Kansas City 1943 – 2019 AD

(●) The historian who showed that Jesus was worshipped alongside God within the first few years, by Jewish believers who worshipped only one God. + Imagine finding a bundle of letters written by a small group of devout Jews about twenty years after a crucified teacher from Galilee was buried. They pray, as every faithful Jew prayed, to the one God of Israel and to no other. And yet in the same letters they sing hymns about the teacher, call on his name, baptize in it, eat a meal in his honour, and cry out to him to come back. Nobody in the letters argues for any of this. They simply do it, as if it had always been done. Larry Hurtado spent forty years asking how that could be, and his answer changed his field. He was a New Testament scholar, eighteen years at the University of Manitoba and fifteen more at the University of Edinburgh, and he argued as a historian rather than as a preacher. That is exactly why he matters to anyone weighing the case for Christianity. The old story taught in many universities was that Jesus became a god slowly, over generations, as his movement drifted out of Judaism into the pagan world. Hurtado showed that the evidence runs the other way: the worship of Jesus is there at the very beginning, among Jews, and it arrived, in his favourite word, like an eruption. One small phrase in Paul turns up in his books again and again: Maranatha, "Our Lord, come!" (1 Corinthians 16:22). Paul wrote in Greek to Greeks in Corinth, yet he left this prayer to Jesus untranslated, in Aramaic, the everyday language Jesus and the first Jewish believers in Judea spoke. Hurtado read it as a fossil, the way a geologist reads a shell pressed into the bottom layer of rock: a prayer to the risen Jesus from the oldest layer of the church.

(●) 1943 AD: Born in Kansas City to a truck driver’s family, and raised in the Pentecostal churches. + Larry Weir Hurtado was born in Kansas City, Missouri, on 29 December 1943. His father, Frank, drove a truck; his mother was Bonnie Jean, born Burton. Nothing about the household pointed toward Edinburgh, Greek papyri, or a chair at one of the old universities of Europe. What it did give him was church. He grew up among the Pentecostals, the branch of Christianity that stresses the present work of the Holy Spirit, heartfelt prayer and singing, and the gifts Paul lists in his letters, and his first college was Central Bible College in Springfield, Missouri, the training school of the Assemblies of God, one of the largest Pentecostal denominations in America. He took his BA there in 1965. And so the man who would later write seven hundred pages on the earliest devotion to Jesus had grown up in a tradition where worship was loud, personal, and addressed directly to Jesus.

(●) 1965 AD: He trained as a textual critic, writing a doctorate on one ancient copy of Mark while pastoring a church. + From Springfield he went to Trinity Evangelical Divinity School near Chicago, taking an MA in New Testament in 1967, and then to Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, where he wrote a PhD under Eldon Jay Epp, one of the leading textual critics in America. Textual criticism is the patient work of comparing the thousands of surviving hand-written copies of the New Testament to recover what the authors actually wrote, the way a detective compares several witnesses’ accounts to reconstruct one evening. His thesis, finished in 1973, studied the Gospel of Mark in a single book: Codex W, a Greek manuscript of the four Gospels copied in the late fourth or early fifth century and now kept in the Freer collection in Washington, D.C. (a codex is simply a book with pages, as opposed to a scroll). To see what he found, it helps to know that the surviving copies fall into families. A family, in this sense, is a group of manuscripts that share the same distinctive wording in many places, much as cousins share a family nose, because they descend from a common ancestor copy. One proposed family was called "Caesarean," after the city of Caesarea in Palestine. Scholars had linked Codex W’s text of Mark, along with the early papyrus P45 (papyrus being the paper-like sheets the ancient world made from strips of the papyrus reed pressed together), to that family, as its earliest or "pre-Caesarean" stage. Hurtado compared the readings and showed that the link was not there: the two had no real relationship to the Caesarean text, and the "pre-Caesarean" group dissolved. All the while, from 1971 to 1975, he was also a church pastor, and in his own telling "had other things on my plate." The book version waited eight years for its publisher and finally appeared in 1981. By his account the argument "won the day," and the textbooks were rewritten. It was a quiet beginning, but it taught him a habit he never lost: look at the physical evidence first.

(●) 1975 AD: Teaching in Canada, he set out to answer Wilhelm Bousset’s Kyrios Christos, the most famous book ever written on the worship of Jesus. + In 1975 he crossed into Canada to teach at Regent College in Vancouver, and in 1978 moved to the Department of Religion at the University of Manitoba in Winnipeg, where he would stay eighteen years, become a full professor in 1988, and serve as the founding director of the university’s Institute for the Humanities. In December 1978 he married Shannon Hunter, a historian, and he was the father of three children. In Winnipeg he picked a fight with a dead German. In 1913 Wilhelm Bousset had published Kyrios Christos ("Christ the Lord"), the masterpiece of the so-called history-of-religions school, a circle of liberal Protestant scholars at Göttingen who explained Christianity by comparing it with the other religions of the Roman world. Bousset argued that calling Jesus "Lord" and worshipping him began not among his Jewish followers in Jerusalem but in Gentile (that is, non-Jewish) churches like Antioch, where people were used to worshipping cult-gods they called "lord." Seventy years on, the book still shaped how the subject was taught. Hurtado published a critique of it in 1979 and quietly resolved to write, some day, a book on the same scale. The first instalment came in 1988, One God, One Lord. On its cover the great German scholar Martin Hengel hailed the arrival of a "new history-of-religions school," a phrase that stuck to Hurtado and a loose company of like-minded scholars for the rest of his life.

(●) 1996 AD: He took the Edinburgh chair of New Testament, and there wrote his great book, Lord Jesus Christ. + In 1996 the University of Edinburgh appointed him Professor of New Testament Language, Literature and Theology. The next year he founded the Centre for the Study of Christian Origins there, devoted to the first three Christian centuries, and from 2007 to 2010 he served as head of the School of Divinity. Students remember a professor who took them to lunch, opened his flat to them, and organised trips to see ancient manuscripts with their own eyes. In 2003 the book he had been planning since the 1970s finally appeared: Lord Jesus Christ: Devotion to Jesus in Earliest Christianity, more than seven hundred pages tracing the worship of Jesus from its first appearance to the middle of the second century. He knew of more than fifty reviews, nearly all of them favourable, and it was translated into French, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese and Korean. Honours followed. He was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Scotland’s national academy of science and letters, in 2008 and served as President of the British New Testament Society from 2009 to 2012. He kept his sense of humour about it all. When German colleagues held a day-long seminar on the book in Berlin in 2005, the chairman opened the afternoon session by saying that after roasting him on one side they would now turn him over, a nod to Hurtado’s name-saint, the deacon Laurence, martyred at Rome in AD 258 and, by an old tradition, roasted on a gridiron. He reported that he "escaped without any serious scorch marks."

(●) 2011 AD: He retired from teaching, and gave his time to a blog and a book on why the first Christians seemed so strange. + He retired in August 2011. Colleagues marked the occasion on 7 October with a day of papers at the Centre, and Richard Bauckham, his friendliest critic, gave a long appraisal of his work. It was printed four years later in Mark, Manuscripts, and Monotheism (2015), the volume of essays that two of his former students, Chris Keith and Dieter Roth, edited in his honour. Retirement turned out to be busy. His blog, begun in 2010 and kept up from Edinburgh, became one of the most read scholarly sites on early Christianity, where he answered questions from professors and from people who had never opened a Greek grammar alike. His rules for commenters were brisk: use your real name, stay on the subject, be polite, and "Trolls go elsewhere!" In 2016 came Destroyer of the gods, a book for general readers on what made the earliest Christians look so odd to their Roman neighbours (T5), followed by two collections of his essays in 2017 and a short book on Jesus in early Christian worship, Honoring the Son, in 2018.

(●) 2019 AD: Leukaemia returned after a brief remission, and he died in Edinburgh at seventy-five. + In the summer of 2018 he was diagnosed with acute myeloid leukaemia (AML), a fast-moving cancer of the blood. Two rounds of intensive chemotherapy from July to September cost him fourteen kilos, all his hair, and most of his strength, and in October his haematologist, the specialist overseeing his blood cancer, pronounced him in remission, the signs of the disease gone. He reported it to his readers almost apologetically, and then added, "Now back to our regular programmes!" The remission lasted about nine months. While it held, a former student, Holly Carey, visited Edinburgh with her family; she found him worn by the treatment and still the life of the party, showing her sons how to shoot the bow he took to an archery club. In July 2019 he told his readers the leukaemia had returned, that the remaining options might be only palliative, easing his suffering rather than curing the disease, and that he would spend his time arranging things for his wife and family. He died in his sleep in Edinburgh on 25 November 2019, aged seventy-five, survived by Shannon and his three children. The university set up a doctoral scholarship in Christian Origins in his name, and his son kept the blog online, "a testament to his work."

What He Taught

(T1) The worship of Jesus erupted within the first few years, among Jewish believers, rather than evolving slowly among Gentiles. + Think of how you can tell that a family custom is old. If a grandmother explains to everyone at the table why they light candles on a certain night, the custom may be new. If she lights them without a word and everyone simply joins in, it has been going on a long time. Hurtado read Paul’s letters that way. Paul’s earliest letters date from around AD 50, about twenty years after the crucifixion, and in them he never argues that Jesus should be worshipped. He assumes it, in letters to churches he founded and in a letter to Rome, a church he had never visited. That matters because of the dates. Paul became a follower of Jesus, by wide agreement, within one to three years of the crucifixion, and he joined a movement that was already doing what his letters take for granted. So whatever happened, it happened almost at once. Hurtado liked to point out that Bousset himself had admitted this: the "Kyrios-cult," as Bousset called it (kyrios is Greek for "lord"), broke out early and suddenly. Where Bousset went wrong was in insisting that it could not have begun among Jewish believers. The Aramaic prayer Maranatha, "Our Lord, come!" (1 Corinthians 16:22), and the bitter opposition the first Jewish believers met from other Jews over their reverence for Jesus, both point to a beginning in Judea. This view is now often called "early high Christology." Christology is the part of theology that asks who Jesus is, and a "high" Christology is one that ranks him with God. The phrase names Hurtado’s whole case in four words: very high, very early.

(Q) "Paul doesn’t spend any time explaining or advocating Jesus-devotion; he presumes that his readers already practice it." + Source: Larry W. Hurtado, "Bousset and ‘Early High Christology’," Larry Hurtado’s Blog, 27 January 2012. Written while he was teaching a segment of a master’s course on the subject, almost a century after Bousset’s Kyrios Christos. The point is about silence: a practice nobody needs to defend is one that is already settled.

(T2) For ancient Jews the line around God was worship, and the first Christians placed Jesus on God’s side of it. + A modern country can give a war hero medals, statues, songs, a holiday, and the most glowing speeches imaginable, and still nobody thinks he has become the king. Ancient Judaism worked something like that. Its writings could describe great figures in dazzling language: Wisdom personified as God’s companion at creation, Moses and Enoch exalted to heaven, the archangel Michael leading the hosts of God. Hurtado called these "chief agent" figures, God’s plenipotentiaries, a word for an envoy carrying the full authority of the one who sent him. But there was one honour no faithful Jew gave any of them: worship. Monotheism, the belief that there is only one God, was in practice a matter of whom you worshipped, and that line held. Then, Hurtado showed, the first Christians crossed it for Jesus alone, and they did so not once, in a burst of enthusiasm, but as a settled pattern. He listed six practices: - hymns sung about Jesus; - prayer to God through Jesus, and to Jesus himself; - calling on his name in baptism and healing; - the Lord’s Supper as a meal held in his honour; - public confession that "Jesus is Lord"; - prophecy spoken in the name of the risen Jesus. He called the pattern a "mutation" of Jewish monotheism, not an abandonment of it, and for years named it "binitarian," meaning two figures, God and Jesus, both reverenced. When critics read later metaphysics into the word (metaphysics here being the philosophical account of what God is in his very being, the kind of question the creeds of later centuries worked out), he switched to "dyadic," a plainer word for a pair. Either way, his insistence was the same: the first believers did not worship two gods. Honouring Jesus was, for them, a way of honouring the one God, "to the glory of God the Father" (Philippians 2:11).

(Q) "The crucial ‘red line’ issue for Roman-era Jewish tradition wasn’t the verbal depiction of this or that figure in glorious, divine-like language, but whether any such figure was to be given cultic worship." + Source: Larry W. Hurtado, "Jesus-devotion: Underscoring key Matters," Larry Hurtado’s Blog, 22 January 2018. He was answering critics who pointed to grand language about angels and patriarchs as if it explained the worship of Jesus. "Cultic" here means formal religious worship, the honour paid in gathered prayer and praise; it has nothing to do with the modern word "cult."

(T3) The first believers worshipped Jesus because they were convinced God himself had exalted him and required it. + If a stranger walked into a royal court and demanded to be bowed to, the courtiers would laugh. If the king himself seated a man at his right hand and told the court to honour him, refusing would be the insult. That, Hurtado argued, is how the New Testament itself explains the worship of Jesus. The reason given is not that Jesus was a superb teacher or held an impressive list of titles. It is what God did: God raised Jesus from the dead and gave him "the name that is above every name" (Philippians 2:9), so that God "has made him both Lord and Christ" (Acts 2:36). How did the first believers come to that conviction? Hurtado named four "forces and factors," and the last of them was the one he thought decisive: - the Jewish devotion to one God that shaped them; - the impact of Jesus’ own ministry, which had already made him the central question for friend and enemy alike; - the wider religious world of the Roman empire; - what he called "religious experiences": the appearances of the risen Jesus and the fresh, Spirit-led readings of Scripture that the first believers took to be revelations from God. Psalm 110:1, "The Lord says to my Lord: Sit at my right hand," was read in that light, and so was Isaiah 45:23, where every knee bows to the one God; Paul echoes those very words about Jesus. He chose the phrase "religious experience" on purpose, as a historian’s neutral label for what the texts themselves call acts of God. It was a description, not a dismissal: he insisted that something powerful enough to change the worship of devout Jews within months has to be taken seriously as history.

(Q) "The fundamental basis of the christological convictions expressed in these NT texts is a theo-logical claim: God has exalted Jesus and now requires him to be reverenced." + Source: Larry W. Hurtado, "Why and How did Jesus-Devotion Erupt?," Larry Hurtado’s Blog, 3 October 2016. The opening word is capitalised here; in the post the sentence begins "That is, the fundamental basis." Written in reply to Chris Tilling and Crispin Fletcher-Louis, who worried that his account gave too little weight to Jesus’ own ministry and to what Jesus had claimed for himself. His hyphen in "theo-logical" is deliberate: the claim is about theos, God, and what God has done.

(T4) The oldest Christian manuscripts are artefacts of faith, and their very pen-strokes bear witness to Christ. + An old family Bible tells you things beyond its printed words: the names written in the front, the passages underlined, the pages worn soft. Hurtado read the earliest Christian manuscripts the same way, as physical objects, in The Earliest Christian Artifacts (2006). Three features stood out. - The codex. The wider Roman world copied its literature on rolls. Christians, from the earliest copies we have, overwhelmingly preferred the codex, the bound book with pages, especially for their Scriptures. It marked their books as their own. - The nomina sacra. Latin for "sacred names." Christian scribes wrote certain words, above all God, Lord, Jesus and Christ, in a shortened form with a line drawn over them, a kind of reverent abbreviation. Hurtado argued it began very early with the name of Jesus, and that putting Jesus’ name in the same special class as "God" and "Lord" was itself an act of devotion. - The staurogram. In papyrus copies of Luke and John from around AD 200, scribes wrote the Greek words for "cross" and "crucify" with two letters laid on top of each other, a tau (shaped like our T) and a rho (shaped like our P). Hurtado argued it was a tiny picture: a head on a cross. If so, it is the earliest Christian image of the crucified Jesus, roughly 150 to 200 years older than the earliest crucifixion scenes in Christian art.

(Q) "The proposal that I support is that the device is intended as a pictographic representation of the crucified Jesus (the loop of the rho a pictographic depiction of the head of a figure on a T-shaped cross)." + Source: Larry W. Hurtado, "The ‘Staurogram’," Larry Hurtado’s Blog, 12 July 2010. A digest of his fuller study, "The Staurogram in Early Christian Manuscripts: The Earliest Visual Reference to the Crucified Jesus?," in New Testament Manuscripts: Their Texts and Their World, edited by Thomas J. Kraus and Tobias Nicklas (Brill, 2006), pp. 207–26. He was careful to add that Christians did not invent the tau-rho sign; they borrowed it and gave it a new meaning. "Pictographic" means working as a small picture of the thing meant, the way the stick figure on a road sign is a picture of a person crossing.

(T5) Early Christianity was a strange and costly faith in the Roman world, and nobody joined it for advantage. + For a Roman of the second century, religion was mostly a matter of keeping on good terms with many gods: a sacrifice here, a festival there, your city’s gods and your family’s gods and the emperor’s, all at once, with nobody asking what you believed or how you lived. Into that world came people who refused every god but one, would not burn a pinch of incense to the emperor, and were therefore called "atheists" by their neighbours. In Destroyer of the gods (2016), Hurtado set out what made them so odd. Their faith was exclusive: one God and one Lord (1 Corinthians 8:6), and no others. Their identity crossed every ethnic line, so that a Greek, a Syrian and a Gaul could belong to the same people without sharing a homeland. Their religion was bookish, built on reading, copying and sending texts to an unusual degree. And it came with a new way to live, rejecting things Roman society took for granted, such as leaving unwanted infants to die. None of this paid. Before Constantine, the first Christian emperor, joined his fellow emperor Licinius in granting the church freedom of worship in AD 313, joining the church brought no social or economic gain, and often real danger. Hurtado thought that made the early church unusually instructive for Christians in the modern West, who once again live as one faith among many.

(Q) "becoming a Christian held no social or economic advantage that I can see in the first centuries before Constantine changed things." + Source: Larry W. Hurtado, "For whom is ‘Destroyer of the gods’?," Larry Hurtado’s Blog, 18 March 2017. The sentence opens "So, becoming a Christian..." in the post. His summary of the question interviewers kept asking about the book: who it was for, and what readers today could take from it.

(Q) "To pursue historical analysis with the expectation either of legitimating or de-legitimating this or that form of contemporary Christian faith seems to me to introduce unnecessary and unhelpful theological anxiety into an already demanding task of careful historical analysis." + Source: Larry W. Hurtado, "Devotion to Jesus and Historical Investigation: A Grateful, Clarifying and Critical Response to Professor Casey," Journal for the Study of the New Testament 27.1 (2004); p. 7 of the author’s text in the Edinburgh Research Archive. The opening word is capitalised here; in the article the sentence begins "In particular, to pursue." He was replying to Maurice Casey, who had faulted him for using "evangelical rather than analytical categories" and had framed their historical disagreement as a theological one. Hurtado, who openly stated his own Christian faith in Lord Jesus Christ, answered that history should be done honestly first, and that its findings are not settled by what anyone hopes they will prove.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) His work helped turn "early high Christology" from a minority view into the field’s centre of gravity. + When Hurtado started, the slow-evolution story was the default in much of the academy. By 2013 the Zurich scholar Jörg Frey could speak of a "paradigm shift" (a change in the basic picture a whole field takes for granted) or a "new perspective" in the study of how Christology began, and described Lord Jesus Christ as its comprehensive statement. Hurtado himself was quick to share the credit: Martin Hengel before him, and contemporaries such as Richard Bauckham, were part of the same turn. The clearest sign of the shift came from a sceptic. In How Jesus Became God (2014), Bart Ehrman, drawing on Hurtado’s work among others, told readers that he had changed his mind and now accepted that the exalted view of Jesus appeared very early. Hurtado reviewed the book for the magazine Christian Century, and on his blog he summed up the gain: Ehrman "came around to the recognition that it erupted early and quickly." He rejected its claim that the earliest high view of Jesus saw him as an angel: as he had long argued, no Jewish circle of the time gave angels worship, so the comparison explains nothing. For apologists the result is plain. The worship of Jesus was not invented at the Council of Nicaea in AD 325, the gathering of bishops that formally confessed the Son as fully God, nor by Gentiles centuries after Galilee. Nicaea put into careful words what the church had been doing in its prayers and hymns since the first generation.

(†) His allies and critics argued with him in the open, and he answered them all by name. + Two kinds of disagreement ran through his career, and both were conducted with unusual courtesy. - Those who thought he went too far. James D. G. Dunn, in Did the First Christians Worship Jesus? (2010), and Maurice Casey, in From Jewish Prophet to Gentile God (1991), argued for a more gradual development; Casey held that Jesus was called fully divine only when the community behind the Gospel of John came to think of itself as Gentile. Hurtado replied that they underestimated how novel the pattern of devotion in Paul’s letters already was. - Those who thought he did not go far enough. Richard Bauckham, in God Crucified (1998) and later books, argued that the New Testament includes Jesus in the very identity of the one God, as Creator and Ruler of all things, and that worship follows from that. He faulted Hurtado for resting so much on worship and for not saying more about how Jesus is related to God. Hurtado called Bauckham’s critique "a model of clarity, accuracy, fairness," and still held his ground: the texts themselves give God’s act of exalting Jesus as the reason to worship him. Seen from the church’s side, Hurtado and Bauckham were building the same house from different ends, and Christian readers have generally used them together.

(†) He showed a generation of students that rigorous scholarship and orthodox faith can live in the same person. + The tributes at his death kept saying the same thing in different words. Colleagues said he had shown how a critical scholar could also be committed to orthodox Christian faith, and that he commanded respect from every side of the field. His doctoral students, among them Michael Kruger, Chris Keith, Dieter Roth and Holly Carey, went on to teach on both sides of the Atlantic, and the lunch tables and manuscript trips they remember were part of the training. He never wrote apologetics, and he kept his history and his theology in separate rooms on purpose, as he told Maurice Casey in 2004. But the history he did has become one of the strongest resources the church has for answering the claim that Jesus was made a god by later generations. His own life gives nothing to set against him here: where readers have disagreed with him, it was over the reading of evidence, and he met them in the open.

Hurtado’s work runs along two tracks that met in his later books: the textual and physical study of early Christian manuscripts, and the history of devotion to Jesus. Everything below is in print or in libraries; his blog, larryhurtado.wordpress.com, remains online as he left it, with several of his essays posted under "Selected Published Essays." Textual criticism and manuscripts: - Text-Critical Methodology and the Pre-Caesarean Text: Codex W in the Gospel of Mark (Studies and Documents 43; Eerdmans, 1981): His revised doctoral thesis, showing that Codex W and P45 have no real relationship to the "Caesarean" text in Mark, so that the supposed "pre-Caesarean" group does not exist. - The Earliest Christian Artifacts: Manuscripts and Christian Origins (Eerdmans, 2006): The physical features of second- and third-century Christian manuscripts read as evidence of early Christian faith: the codex, the nomina sacra, the staurogram (T4). - The Freer Biblical Manuscripts: Fresh Studies of an American Treasure Trove (editor; Society of Biblical Literature, Text-Critical Studies 6, 2006): Essays on the Freer collection in Washington, home of Codex W, the manuscript of his first book. - Texts and Artefacts: Selected Essays on Textual Criticism and Early Christian Manuscripts (Library of New Testament Studies 584; Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2017): His collected essays on the text of the New Testament and the earliest copies. The origins of devotion to Jesus: - One God, One Lord: Early Christian Devotion and Ancient Jewish Monotheism (Fortress and SCM, 1988; 2nd ed. T&T Clark, 1998; 3rd ed. Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2015): The founding book. Surveys the Jewish "chief agent" figures and shows that none received the worship given to Jesus; the second edition adds a long preface and the third a 20,000-word epilogue on later debate (T2). - At the Origins of Christian Worship: The Context and Character of Earliest Christian Devotion (Paternoster, 1999; Eerdmans, 2000): The 1999 Didsbury Lectures, given at the Nazarene college in Manchester: early Christian worship against its Roman background, with a closing chapter of reflections for worship today. - Lord Jesus Christ: Devotion to Jesus in Earliest Christianity (Eerdmans, 2003): His major work, tracing devotion to Jesus from its eruption to the middle of the second century, with his four "forces and factors" (T1, T3). - How on Earth Did Jesus Become a God? Historical Questions about Earliest Devotion to Jesus (Eerdmans, 2005): Lectures given at Ben-Gurion University in Israel in 2004, with essays including his 1998 T. W. Manson lecture on religious experience and religious innovation. - God in New Testament Theology (Library of Biblical Theology; Abingdon, 2010): A short study of how the place of Jesus reshaped the way the New Testament speaks of God. - Ancient Jewish Monotheism and Early Christian Jesus-Devotion: The Context and Character of Christological Faith (Baylor University Press, 2017): His essays on Jewish monotheism and early devotion to Jesus from some forty years of work, gathered in one volume of nearly seven hundred pages. - Honoring the Son: Jesus in Earliest Christian Devotional Practice (Lexham Press, 2018): A short, accessible statement of his case for general readers. Early Christianity in the Roman world: - Destroyer of the gods: Early Christian Distinctiveness in the Roman World (Baylor University Press, 2016): For general readers: why early Christianity looked so strange to Romans, exclusive, trans-ethnic, bookish and morally demanding (T5). - Why on Earth Did Anyone Become a Christian in the First Three Centuries? (Marquette University Press, 2016): His Père Marquette Lecture, asking what drew converts to a faith that offered no advantage. Commentary: - Mark (Good News Commentary, Harper & Row, 1983; New International Biblical Commentary, Hendrickson, 1989; later reissued by Baker in the Understanding the Bible Commentary series): A commentary for general readers, rewritten for the NIV when the series changed publishers. Edited volumes: - Goddesses in Religions and Modern Debate (editor; Scholars Press, 1990): Essays from his Manitoba years on goddess figures in the history of religions and their use in modern debate. - Religious Studies: Issues, Prospects and Proposals (co-editor with Klaus K. Klostermaier; Scholars Press, 1991): Essays on the state of religious studies as an academic discipline. - A Dictionary of Biblical Tradition in English Literature (David Lyle Jeffrey, general editor; Eerdmans, 1992): A reference work of nearly nine hundred articles on how biblical names, stories and phrases run through English literature, on which Hurtado worked with Jeffrey; his exact editorial title is not recorded in the catalogues. - "Who Is This Son of Man?" The Latest Scholarship on a Puzzling Expression of the Historical Jesus (co-editor with Paul L. Owen; Library of New Testament Studies 390; T&T Clark, 2011): Essays on Jesus’ favourite way of referring to himself. - Jesus among Friends and Enemies: A Historical and Literary Introduction to Jesus in the Gospels (co-editor with Chris Keith; Baker Academic, 2011): A textbook that meets Jesus through the people around him in the Gospels, from his family and disciples to the authorities who opposed him, each chapter by a different scholar. - Peter in Early Christianity (co-editor with Helen K. Bond; Eerdmans, 2015): Essays from an Edinburgh conference on the apostle Peter, in the New Testament and in the memory of the early church. Selected articles: - "New Testament Christology: A Critique of Bousset’s Influence," Theological Studies 40 (1979), pp. 306–17: The opening move of his life’s research programme. - "The Origin of the Nomina Sacra: A Proposal," Journal of Biblical Literature 117 (1998): His argument that the sacred-name abbreviations began with the name of Jesus. - "Pre-70 C.E. Jewish Opposition to Christ-Devotion," Journal of Theological Studies 50 (1999), pp. 35–58: Evidence that Jewish believers were opposed by other Jews for their reverence for Jesus well before AD 70. - "Devotion to Jesus and Historical Investigation: A Grateful, Clarifying and Critical Response to Professor Casey," Journal for the Study of the New Testament 27.1 (2004): His reply to Maurice Casey, on binitarian worship and on keeping history and theology distinct. - "The Staurogram in Early Christian Manuscripts: The Earliest Visual Reference to the Crucified Jesus?," in New Testament Manuscripts: Their Texts and Their World, ed. Thomas J. Kraus and Tobias Nicklas (Brill, 2006), pp. 207–26: The fullest statement of his staurogram argument (T4). - "‘Ancient Jewish Monotheism’ in the Hellenistic and Roman Periods," Journal of Ancient Judaism 4.3 (2013), pp. 379–400: Monotheism defined by the worship it permits and forbids. In his honour: Mark, Manuscripts, and Monotheism: Essays in Honor of Larry W. Hurtado, ed. Chris Keith and Dieter T. Roth (Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2015), including Richard Bauckham’s appraisal of his work. Where to start: Honoring the Son for the short case, Lord Jesus Christ for the full one, and Destroyer of the gods for the early church in its world.
Playlist
Justified True Belief