Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
Pontius Pilate the Prefect fl. c. 26 – 36 AD
(●) The Roman governor who sentenced Jesus to the cross, and whose name the church has said in its creed ever since. Every Sunday, in churches of almost every tradition, people stand and say what they believe about Jesus: born of the Virgin Mary, "suffered under Pontius Pilate," crucified, dead, and buried. It is a strange thing, when you stop to think about it. The creed names only two human beings besides Jesus. One is his mother. The other is a middle-ranking Roman official who governed a small, difficult province for about ten years and would be almost forgotten if he had not, one spring morning, signed an order for a crucifixion. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. The first is that his name is a date. By saying "under Pontius Pilate," the church tied its faith to a real year, a real place, and a real officeholder anyone could look up, which is the opposite of how myths are told. The second is that few people in the Gospels are better attested outside them. Josephus, the Jewish historian, and Philo, the Jewish philosopher of Alexandria, both describe his government; the Roman historian Tacitus names him as the man under whom Christ was executed; and in 1961 archaeologists at Caesarea, his seat of government on the coast, turned over a building stone carved with his name and title. His dates are the dates of his office, because no source gives his birth or his death. The year he arrived, AD 26, is the conventional figure, worked out from Josephus’ statement that his predecessor governed for eleven years; the year he left, the winter of 36/37, comes from Josephus too. Everything before and after those ten years is silence, or legend.
(●) c. 26 AD: The emperor Tiberius sent him to govern Judea, a province Rome had ruled directly for twenty years. We know nothing of where Pilate was born or how he grew up. His family name, Pontius, belonged to an old clan of the Samnites, a hill people of central Italy whom Rome had conquered centuries before, and his surname Pilatus may come from pilum, the heavy javelin of the Roman soldier, though no one can be sure. Men who governed provinces like Judea came from the equestrian order, Rome’s second rank of nobility below the senators: wealthy, usually with a military career behind them, trusted with a hard post but not a grand one. Judea had been under a Roman governor of its own since AD 6, when Augustus removed Herod’s son Archelaus for misrule. Pilate was the fifth man in the job, succeeding Valerius Gratus. His title was prefect (praefectus), a military commander placed over a territory. Later writers, Tacitus among them, call him procurator instead. That word first meant an agent who managed a master’s money and property, rather like a steward running an estate for an absent owner, and it became the title governors of Judea carried from the time of the emperor Claudius. The Gospels simply call him the governor, and Luke dates the start of John the Baptist’s preaching by him: "In the fifteenth year of the reign of Tiberius Caesar, Pontius Pilate being governor of Judea" (Luke 3:1). He lived at Caesarea, the gleaming harbor city Herod the Great had built on the Mediterranean, and went up to Jerusalem for the great feasts, when the city swelled with pilgrims and trouble was most likely. His wife came with him; Matthew mentions her, and later tradition gave her the name Procla.
(●) c. 26 AD: He marched the emperor’s images into Jerusalem by night, and backed down when the crowd offered him their necks. Roman soldiers marched behind standards, tall poles topped with emblems, and the standards of some units carried small medallion portraits of the emperor. Earlier governors had known that the law of Moses forbids images, and had brought plainer standards into Jerusalem. Pilate did not. Josephus says he sent the image-bearing standards into the city by night, so that Jerusalem woke up to find Caesar’s face looking down on the holy city. A great crowd went down to Caesarea and begged him to take them away. He refused, and they stayed, lying motionless on the ground for five days and five nights. On the next day he took his seat on the judgment platform in the open market-place, called them in as if to give his answer, had soldiers surround them three ranks deep, and told them they would be cut to pieces unless they accepted the images. They threw themselves down, bared their necks, and said they would rather die than see their law broken. Pilate blinked. Josephus says he was "deeply affected with their firm resolution to keep their laws inviolable," and he ordered the standards carried back to Caesarea. It is a revealing first act. He was willing to provoke, and willing to threaten a massacre, but not, when it came to it, willing to carry one out against unarmed people who would not move.
(●) c. 26 to 36 AD: Again and again his government collided with the conscience of the people he ruled. The standards were not the last quarrel. Think of a manager who keeps doing the one thing the staff have told him they cannot bear, not always out of malice, sometimes just because he does not see why it should matter. The record of Pilate’s ten years reads a little like that, and sometimes much worse. - The aqueduct. He built an aqueduct to bring water to Jerusalem, a real public good, and paid for it with the temple treasury, money called corban, meaning "an offering," given to God. When crowds gathered to shout at him, he sent soldiers among them dressed as civilians with clubs under their clothes, and at his signal they beat the crowd. Many died, from the blows or in the crush (Josephus, Antiquities 18.60–62; Jewish War 2.175–177). - The shields. He hung gilded shields in Herod’s old palace in Jerusalem, bearing no image, only an inscription naming himself and Tiberius. Even so, the people and four of Herod’s sons protested, wrote to the emperor, and Tiberius ordered the shields moved to the temple of Augustus at Caesarea (Philo, Embassy to Gaius 299–305). - The coins. Between about AD 29 and 32 he struck small bronze coins for everyday use, the first issue stamped with a simpulum, a ladle used to pour offerings at pagan sacrifices, and the later ones with a lituus, the curved staff of a Roman augur (a priest who read omens). No image of a person, but symbols of Roman religion in every Jewish purse. - The Galileans. Luke mentions, in passing, "the Galileans whose blood Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices" (Luke 13:1): pilgrims killed while offering in the temple courts. No other source records the incident, which is just the sort of brief, local event Josephus would not have bothered with. Philo, writing a few years after Pilate left, describes him through a letter of King Agrippa I, Herod the Great’s grandson, as "a man of a very inflexible disposition, and very merciless as well as very obstinate." Of course, Philo had his own reasons to paint the darkest picture he could. The letter he reports was pleading with the emperor Gaius not to set up his own statue in the temple, and a harsh governor whom even Tiberius had to correct made a useful contrast. Still, the incidents Josephus reports, told independently, point the same way.
(●) c. 30 AD: The Jerusalem council brought him Jesus at dawn, and after finding no guilt in him, he had him scourged and crucified. It was Passover week, and Pilate was in Jerusalem. Early in the morning the chief priests and the council, the city’s leadership (whom John’s Gospel calls "the Jews" in these scenes), brought Jesus to his headquarters bound, with a charge that was bound to get a governor’s attention: this man claims to be a king. As for the year, it is either AD 30 or 33, the two Passovers in Pilate’s term that best fit the Gospels and the calendar; c. 30 is a common convention. All four Gospels tell what followed, and they agree on its shape. Pilate questioned Jesus and was not persuaded he was dangerous. Luke has him say it three times over, that he finds no guilt in him (Luke 23:4, 14, 22). When he learned that Jesus was a Galilean, he tried to pass the problem along, sending him to Herod Antipas, the ruler of Galilee, who happened to be in the city. Herod sent him back, and Luke adds a small, sour detail: the two men, enemies before, became friends that day (Luke 23:12). Meanwhile his wife sent a message to the judgment seat: "Have nothing to do with that righteous man, for I have suffered much because of him today in a dream" (Matthew 27:19). He tried another way out as well. Under a festival custom a prisoner could be released, and he offered the crowd the choice. They chose Barabbas, a man jailed for rebellion and murder. Then the pressure turned personal. "If you release this man, you are not Caesar’s friend" (John 19:12). "Friend of Caesar" was close to an official honor, and losing it could end a career, or a life. Pilate gave way. Mark puts it plainly: "So Pilate, wishing to satisfy the crowd, released for them Barabbas, and having scourged Jesus, he delivered him to be crucified" (Mark 15:15). To scourge was to flog with a Roman whip, leather straps weighted with bits of bone or metal, a beating so savage that some men did not survive it to reach the cross.
(●) c. 30 AD: He wrote "King of the Jews" over the cross, refused to change it, and gave the body to Joseph of Arimathea. A crucified man often carried a placard stating his crime, so that passers-by would know what Rome did to people like him. Pilate had one made in Aramaic, Latin, and Greek: "Jesus of Nazareth, the King of the Jews" (John 19:19–20). The chief priests asked him to change it to say only that Jesus had claimed the title. He refused, in three words of Greek that English needs seven to carry (T4). By late afternoon Jesus was dead. Joseph of Arimathea, a member of the council and a secret disciple, came to ask for the body. Pilate was surprised that Jesus had died so soon, and before granting the request he sent for the centurion, the officer commanding the execution squad (a centurion led about a hundred men), to confirm it (Mark 15:44–45). Matthew adds a last scene: the chief priests came the next day asking for the tomb to be secured, and Pilate told them, "You have a guard of soldiers. Go, make it as secure as you can" (Matthew 27:65). These small details matter more than they seem. A Roman governor who personally checked that a condemned man was dead, and then signed over the body, is one of the reasons the Gospels’ account of a real burial in a known tomb has to be reckoned with.
(●) 36 AD: His troops cut down a crowd of Samaritans, and the governor of Syria ordered him to Rome to answer for it. The end came from the north. The Samaritans lived in the hill country between Judea and Galilee. They worshiped the God of Israel and kept the five books of Moses, but they held that the true place of worship was their own Mount Gerizim, not Jerusalem, and Jews and Samaritans had been at odds over it for centuries. A Samaritan prophet promised his people that if they gathered on Gerizim, he would show them sacred vessels Moses had buried there. They came armed, and assembled at a village called Tirathaba at its foot. Pilate sent cavalry and infantry to block the roads. Some of the crowd were killed, others fled, and many were taken prisoner, and afterward Pilate had the leaders executed (Josephus, Antiquities 18.85–87). The Samaritan council complained to Lucius Vitellius, the governor of Syria and the senior Roman official in the region, insisting they had not been rebelling at all. Vitellius sent a friend of his named Marcellus to take charge of Judea, and ordered Pilate to Rome to answer to the emperor. Josephus says Pilate "had tarried ten years in Judea" and hurried to obey. But before he reached Rome, Tiberius was dead (March of AD 37), and with him, perhaps, the case.
(●) After 37 AD: He passes out of history, and legend gave him both a suicide and a conversion. No reliable source tells us what happened to Pilate after he sailed for Rome. We simply don’t know whether he was tried, retired, or died soon after. The gap filled up with stories, and they contradict each other in an instructive way. Eusebius, the church historian of the early fourth century, reports that Pilate fell into such misfortunes under the emperor Gaius (Caligula) that he took his own life, and he cites as his source unnamed "Greek historians who have recorded the Olympiads," that is, chroniclers who dated events by the four-year cycle of the Olympic Games (Church History 2.7). No such chronicle survives, and the report cannot be checked. Later legends went further in both directions. One, the Death of Pilate, has his corpse rejected by every river it was thrown into, and a medieval tradition attached him to a mountain near Lucerne in Switzerland that still bears the name Pilatus. Others made him a believer who died repentant. These are legends, not history, and the record of the man himself ends with a ship to Rome.
What He Held
(T1) Truth was a question a practical man could leave unanswered. Pilate wrote no books and taught no school. What he held, we know from what he said and did, and the most famous thing he ever said is a question. Picture a busy official with a crowd outside, a deadline, and a prisoner who will not give straight answers. Pilate asks Jesus whether he is the King of the Jews. Jesus answers that his kingdom is not of this world, and that he came into the world "to bear witness to the truth. Everyone who is of the truth listens to my voice" (John 18:37). Pilate’s reply is three words, and then, without waiting for an answer, he goes back outside. Readers have heard every tone in it: a sneer, a tired shrug, a cynic’s honest doubt. John does not say which. What John shows is the man’s posture. Pilate was not a philosopher denying that truth exists; he was a governor for whom the question did not need answering, because the decision in front of him would be made on other grounds. That is a position too, and a very common one: truth as an interesting topic that a sensible person sets aside when there is work to do.
(Q) "What is truth?" Source: John 18:38 (English Standard Version). Pilate’s answer to Jesus’ claim that he came to bear witness to the truth. In the same verse he goes out to the crowd and tells them, "I find no guilt in him."
(T2) A Roman governor’s power over life and death was his own to use. In a Roman province, the power to execute belonged to the governor. Roman lawyers came to call it the ius gladii, "the right of the sword," and it is why the Jerusalem council, which could judge Jesus by its own law, had to bring him to Pilate to have him put to death (John 18:31). Pilate knew exactly what he held. When Jesus would not answer him, he reminded the prisoner of it in so many words. It is the voice of every official who has ever said "Do you know who I am?": authority understood as something a man simply owns. Jesus’ answer turned that around. "You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given you from above" (John 19:11). Pilate’s power was real, and Jesus did not deny it; but it was lent, not owned, and a lent power is answerable to the one who lent it. Christian thinking about the state has drawn on that sentence ever since: rulers bear the sword by God’s appointment, and for that very reason they will give account for how they use it (Romans 13:1–4).
(Q) "You will not speak to me? Do you not know that I have authority to release you and authority to crucify you?" Source: John 19:10 (English Standard Version). Pilate has just asked Jesus "Where are you from?" and received no answer. John says he had become "even more afraid" when he heard the charge that Jesus made himself the Son of God (John 19:8).
(T3) A judge could hand over a man he believed innocent and call himself clean of the blood. We still say someone "washes his hands" of a thing, and we owe the phrase to this morning. Matthew tells how Pilate, seeing that he was getting nowhere and that a riot was starting, called for water and washed his hands in front of the crowd. Notice what the gesture claims. Pilate does not say Jesus is guilty. He says the opposite, and then hands him over anyway, as though the responsibility could be poured off with the water. It is the reasoning of a man caught between his judgment and his safety: I think this is wrong, I am going to do it, and the fault belongs to the people who pushed me. Scripture does not accept the transfer. The judge who condemns the righteous is held to account for the verdict (Proverbs 17:15), and the apostles, praying with the believers in Jerusalem weeks later, named Pilate among those gathered "against your holy servant Jesus" (Acts 4:27), even though Peter had just reminded the crowds at the temple that he had "decided to release him" (Acts 3:13). Both things were true. He did not want to do it, and he did it.
(Q) "I am innocent of this man’s blood; see to it yourselves." Source: Matthew 27:24 (English Standard Version). Spoken as Pilate washed his hands before the crowd, after his wife’s warning and the crowd’s choice of Barabbas, and just before he released Barabbas and handed Jesus over to be scourged and crucified.
(T4) What the governor had written stood written. Here is the strange last turn in Pilate’s story. The man who would not hold firm on the verdict held perfectly firm on the placard. The chief priests wanted the wording changed so that it recorded a claim rather than a title: not "The King of the Jews," but "This man said, I am King of the Jews" (John 19:21). Pilate, who had given way on everything that mattered that morning, would not give way on this. Perhaps it was spite, a last jab at the men who had backed him into a corner. Perhaps it was a Roman official’s pride in his own written word. Either way, Christians have found it hard not to smile at what he left standing over the cross, in three languages, for anyone passing on the road to read: the plain truth about the man who hung there, posted by the man who had just asked what truth is.
(Q) "What I have written I have written." Source: John 19:22 (English Standard Version). Pilate’s answer to the chief priests’ request that he change the inscription "Jesus of Nazareth, the King of the Jews" (John 19:19). His last recorded words in John’s Gospel.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) The church wrote his name into its creeds, so that the cross would always carry a date. Why would Christians keep repeating the name of the man who condemned their Lord? Because it fixed the gospel in history. Pagan myths happened "once upon a time." The death of Jesus happened in the governorship of Pontius Pilate, a date as specific as saying "when Tiberius was emperor" or "in the year of such-and-such a consul." (Rome named each year after its two consuls, the chief magistrates elected for that year, much as we might date a memory by who was president at the time.) The habit is there from the start. Paul reminds Timothy of "Christ Jesus, who in his testimony before Pontius Pilate made the good confession" (1 Timothy 6:13). Ignatius of Antioch, writing on his way to martyrdom around AD 110, insisted against teachers who said Jesus only seemed to suffer that he "was truly persecuted under Pontius Pilate" (To the Trallians 9). Justin Martyr, writing to the emperor in the 150s, says repeatedly that Christ "was crucified under Pontius Pilate, procurator of Judæa, in the times of Tiberius Cæsar" (First Apology 13). The baptismal creed of the Roman church, ancestor of the Apostles’ Creed, carried the phrase, and the creed of the Council of Constantinople in AD 381, the form of the Nicene Creed churches still say, confesses Christ "crucified for us under Pontius Pilate." Every time a congregation says those words, it is saying: check the records.
(†) The Gospels and the early fathers made him a reluctant witness to Jesus’ innocence, and some churches came to honor him. The Gospel writers took care to record that the Roman judge found no crime in Jesus. That mattered in a world where Christians were followers of a man executed by Rome as a rebel: the governor himself had said he was no rebel. Peter’s sermon in Acts makes the point within weeks of the event (Acts 3:13), and Paul makes it again in the synagogue at Pisidian Antioch, in what is now west-central Turkey: "though they found in him no guilt worthy of death, they asked Pilate to have him executed" (Acts 13:28). The early fathers pressed the point further. Tertullian, the North African writer of around AD 197, says Pilate was already "in fact a Christian in his own convictions" and reported on Christ to Tiberius (Apology 21), and Eusebius tells of the report to the emperor, quoting Tertullian, and adds that "they say" Tiberius referred the matter to the Senate (Church History 2.2). Neither claim can be checked, and both are best read as early Christian traditions. Later still came the apocryphal writings, books outside the Bible that borrow a biblical name and claim to fill in what the Gospels left out, the way a fan might write a missing chapter of a favorite novel. One of them, the Acts of Pilate, written in its surviving form around the fourth century, dramatized the trial with Pilate as a sympathetic figure. Out of these traditions grew a remarkable reception in the East. The Ethiopian Orthodox Church honors Pilate and his wife together as saints on June 25, and the Eastern Orthodox churches commemorate his wife, under the traditional name Procla, on October 27. The Western church never joined in, and remembered him mainly through the creed.
(†) A carved stone, a handful of coins, and three ancient historians confirm the governor the Gospels describe. In 1961 an Italian expedition excavating the Roman theater at Caesarea found a limestone block that had been reused in a later rebuilding. Its broken Latin inscription names a Tiberieum, a building dedicated in honor of Tiberius, and the man who dedicated it: "[Po]ntius Pilatus, [Praef]ectus Iuda[ea]e," Pontius Pilate, Prefect of Judea. It is the only inscription known that names him with his office, and it settled a small question too: his official title was prefect, which is what a governor of Judea was called before the reign of Claudius. The stone is now in the Israel Museum in Jerusalem. His coins survive by the thousands, and a copper-alloy ring from Herod’s fortress of Herodium, excavated in 1968–69 and published in 2018, carries the Greek letters for "of Pilatus." Whether it belonged to the prefect himself, to someone in his service, or to another man of the same name is uncertain. Then there are the writers. Philo and Josephus describe his government in detail; Tacitus, among the most careful of Roman historians and no friend of Christians, records that "Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus" (Annals 15.44). Josephus, in a passage Christian copyists later embellished but whose core most scholars accept, says the same: Pilate condemned Jesus to the cross "at the suggestion of the principal men amongst us" (Antiquities 18.63–64). None of this proves that Jesus rose from the dead. What it shows is that the trial in the Gospels was held before a real man, in a real office, in the years the Gospels say.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: a man he judged innocent condemned to keep the peace, and truth set aside for safety. For all the sympathy some later Christians felt for him, Pilate’s own record is not a hard one to judge, and the Gospels judge it plainly. - The verdict. He declared Jesus innocent and sentenced him to death anyway, to quiet a crowd and protect his standing with Caesar. Scripture’s standard for a judge is the reverse: "do not kill the innocent and righteous" (Exodus 23:7). Washing his hands did not change what his order did. - The truth. Standing before the one who said he came to bear witness to the truth, Pilate asked what truth is and walked away before the answer (T1). The gospel holds that truth is not only a question but a person, and that no one stays neutral about him (John 14:6). - The power. He spoke of his authority over life and death as though it were simply his own (T2). Jesus told him it was given from above, and a power that is given is a power that will be answered for. - The rest of the record. Josephus, Philo, and Luke describe a governor who repeatedly met protest with force: the clubbing of the aqueduct crowd, the Samaritans cut down at Tirathaba, the Galileans killed at their sacrifices (Luke 13:1). And yet the gospel’s last word on Pilate is not only judgment. The cross he ordered is the place where, Christians believe, God dealt with the guilt of those who put Jesus there, Pilate included. The apostles preached forgiveness in Jerusalem to the very city that had condemned him (Acts 3:17–19), and nothing in the gospel puts a Roman governor beyond its reach.