Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Philosophical Theology

Analytical Analyses of Christian Systematic Theology

Bibliology

The Doctrine of Scripture

Theology Proper

The Divine Nature and Properties of God

Creation

The Doctrine of Creation

TBD

Anthropology

The Doctrine of Humanity

TBD

Christology

The Doctrine of Christ

TBD

Soteriology

The Doctrine of Salvation

TBD

Ecclesiology

The Doctrine of the Church

A Critique of Orthodox Mariology

(P1) Scripture reserves to Christ alone the works of propitiation, cleansing, new birth, and access to God. + The New Testament names a handful of works that bring a sinner to God, and every time it names them, it names one person as the one who does them. (1) Christ alone is the propitiation for sin. - A propitiation is a sacrifice that turns away God's just anger by dealing with the sin that provoked it. Think of a family facing a debt so large that none of them could ever pay it, owed to a creditor who is right to demand it. Then one person pays it in full, and the demand is gone. - John says of Jesus, "He is the propitiation for our sins, and not for ours only but also for the sins of the whole world" (1 John 2:2). Paul uses the same idea: Christ is the one "whom God put forward as a propitiation by his blood, to be received by faith" (Romans 3:25). - Peter names the price. Believers were ransomed "not with perishable things such as silver or gold, but with the precious blood of Christ, like that of a lamb without blemish or spot" (1 Peter 1:18-19). (2) Cleansing and new birth come through Christ alone. - Hebrews asks a question that answers itself: "how much more will the blood of Christ, who through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish to God, purify our conscience from dead works to serve the living God" (Hebrews 9:14). John adds that "the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin" (1 John 1:7). - New birth comes the same way. God "saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, whom he poured out on us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior" (Titus 3:5-6). • Regeneration means being born again: God giving a new spiritual life to someone who was dead in sin, the way a newborn receives a life it did nothing to earn. - Notice the pattern. The cleansing is by his blood, and the Spirit who gives new birth is poured out through him. So "Christ alone" does not shut out the Father or the Spirit. What it shuts out is every creature, because these are God's works, done in and through the Son. (3) Christ alone brings sinners to the Father. - A mediator is a go-between who brings two estranged parties together. "For there is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus" (1 Timothy 2:5). - Jesus said, "I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me" (John 14:6), and Paul says that "through him we both have access in one Spirit to the Father" (Ephesians 2:18). - Because of that, the invitation is direct: "Let us then with confidence draw near to the throne of grace, that we may receive mercy and find grace to help in time of need" (Hebrews 4:16). - Picture a child who walks straight into her father's study. She does not book an appointment with his secretary first. (4) Others serve these works without sharing them. - Scripture gives human beings a real part in God's saving work, as his servants. Paul says he became the Corinthians' father in Christ Jesus through the gospel (1 Corinthians 4:15). - The same goes for prayer. Just before Paul names the one mediator, he urges "that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people" (1 Timothy 2:1). So the one mediator is no ban on Christians praying for one another. - What the servants never receive is the work itself. The one mediator is the one "who gave himself as a ransom for all" (1 Timothy 2:6), and no text tells believers to look to anyone else for cleansing, new birth, or access (D3). - Think of the best man at a wedding. He hands over the ring, and everyone is glad he came, but nobody toasts him as the groom. (5) Scripture's Mary points away from herself. - Mary herself called God "my Savior" (Luke 1:47). She needed the salvation her Son would bring, as every daughter of Adam does. - At the wedding in Cana, when the wine ran out, her one recorded instruction was to the servants: "Do whatever he tells you" (John 2:5). - When a woman in a crowd blessed the womb that bore Jesus, he answered that those who hear God's word and keep it are blessed rather (Luke 11:27-28). Mary fits that description better than anyone. Elizabeth called her blessed because she believed (Luke 1:45), and a blessing for believing God's word points to the word. Even her blessing points past her. - On another day, with his mother and brothers waiting outside to speak to him, Jesus named everyone who does his Father's will his mother and brothers (Matthew 12:46-50). Therefore, whoever else may serve them, propitiation, cleansing, new birth, and access to the Father belong in Scripture to Christ alone.

(P2) A church's fixed worship teaches its people what to believe. + What a congregation says to God every week, in words it did not write and cannot change, becomes what it believes about God. (1) The church has long held that the law of prayer sets the law of belief. - Think of a child who learns more about what her family believes from the grace said at supper every night than from any book on the shelf. - The church named this long ago. Around 440, a short collection of the Roman church's teaching on grace, usually credited to Prosper of Aquitaine, put it in a phrase still quoted: ut legem credendi lex statuat supplicandi, "let the law of praying establish the law of believing." It is often shortened to lex orandi, lex credendi, "the law of praying, the law of believing." - The point was that the prayers the whole church prays are evidence of what the whole church believes. Prayer does more than reveal belief, though. What a whole church prays, year after year, it comes to believe. (2) The Orthodox Church treats its liturgy as theology. - The Eastern Orthodox Church is the family of ancient churches of Greece, Russia, Eastern Europe, and the Middle East. Its liturgy is its set order of public worship: the prayers, hymns, and readings of every service, fixed in books, much as a traditional wedding follows a set order of vows. - Orthodox Christians commonly say that their faith is best learned not from textbooks but from the services, and their theologians appeal to the hymns as sources of doctrine. On their own account, then, the liturgy does not merely decorate the faith. It teaches it. - The services are also fixed. A parish does not choose its hymns for the Feast of the Dormition (the feast of Mary's death, kept on August 15) the way an evangelical worship leader picks songs for Sunday. The same texts are appointed for the same feast in every Orthodox church in the world. - Orthodox teachers do draw a distinction here. They set the dogmas of the councils (teachings formally defined as binding by gatherings of bishops from across the church) apart from the wider body of hymns, and no single line of a hymn carries the weight of the Nicene Creed, the church's fourth-century statement of faith (D12). - Still, a hymn need not be dogma to teach, any more than a lullaby needs to be a textbook. (3) Words repeated in prayer shape what people trust. - A believer who sings, year after year, that someone washes her conscience and gives her new birth will tend to look to that someone for those things, whatever a catechism (a church's official handbook of teaching) says in its footnotes. - Think of the lyrics of a song you have sung since childhood. You may never have analyzed them, but they come back to you in the hospital waiting room, and they shape what you reach for there. Therefore, a church's fixed hymns and refrains teach its people what to believe and whom to trust, and its widely used prayers show how those words are heard.

(P3) Orthodox worship ascribes to Mary the saving works Scripture reserves to Christ. + The fixed hymns of the Orthodox Church give Mary, again and again, the very works P1 reserves to Christ, though the same church formally confesses that she is a creature (a created being, not God), saved by her Son, and that worship belongs to God alone. Its teachers read those hymns as Old Testament pictures (D5) and say that she saves by her prayers (D3, D14), and both readings deserve a full hearing. (1) The Akathist Hymn hails Mary in the language of salvation. - The Akathist (Greek for "not sitting," because it is sung standing) is the best-known hymn to Mary in Orthodoxy, and it is old: most scholars date it to the fifth or sixth century. - The service books appoint it for every Orthodox church in Lent (the weeks of fasting before Easter). Many parishes sing it a part at a time on the Fridays and then all the way through, and countless believers pray it at home. - Its opening stanza is tied by tradition to the siege of Constantinople (capital of the eastern Roman Empire) in 626. It hails her as the city's champion general and asks her, since she has invincible power, to set the city free from every danger. Asking for protection is not one of the works in P1. Even so, it is the kind of help Paul looked to the Lord for: he trusted the Lord to rescue him from every evil deed (2 Timothy 4:18). - The greetings that follow go further. Set each one beside its verse in P1: • They hail her as the propitiation of the whole world (Greek exilasma), which is what John and Paul call Christ (1 John 2:2; Romans 3:25). • They hail her as mortals' confidence before God (Greek parrēsia). That is Hebrews' word for the confidence with which believers draw near through Christ's blood (Hebrews 4:16; 10:19). • They hail her as the "laver that washes the conscience." A laver is a washing basin, like the great bronze basin where Israel's priests washed before they served. Hebrews says it is the blood of Christ that purifies the conscience (Hebrews 9:14). • They hail her as the one who "gave new birth to those conceived in shame." Titus says God gives new birth by the Holy Spirit, poured out through Jesus Christ (Titus 3:5-6). - Even if these lines are read as pictures, they are addressed to Mary in prayer. The works they name are the works the New Testament gives to Christ. (2) The Dormition hymns credit her death with giving life to the world. - The Dormition (Greek koimēsis, "falling asleep") is the August 15 feast of Mary's death, which Orthodox tradition holds was followed by her being taken bodily into heaven. - The feast's hymns at Vespers, the evening service, sing that through her holy dormition the world has been given life, and that through her salvation has come to the whole race of mortals. - Scripture says that the one who gives life to the world is the Son (John 6:33), and that "by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified" (Hebrews 10:14). (3) Common prayers ask her for salvation itself. - One of the most familiar refrains in Orthodox services is "Most Holy Theotokos, save us." • Theotokos is Greek for "God-bearer," the ancient title for Mary as the mother of the one who is God (C2). - Prayer books are not fixed liturgy. They do show how the liturgy is heard, though, and some of them go further than the hymns. One Orthodox prayer book to the Theotokos, Mother of Light, has prayers that call Mary "the deification of mortals, our propitiation and refuge, the resurrection of those who have fallen, the ransom of my sins." • Deification is the Orthodox name for the goal of salvation: a believer united to God and sharing his life by grace, without ever becoming God by nature. - Another prayer in it says, "I do not dare to approach your Son with confidence, but I implore you that I may obtain salvation through your mediation with him," and a third, "Nothing is impossible for you, Mary; you need only to wish it." - Each line gives her a title or a power Scripture gives to God or to Christ. Jesus is the resurrection (John 11:25), his blood is the ransom (1 Peter 1:18-19), all things are possible with God (Matthew 19:26), and the believer is told to draw near to the throne of grace with confidence (Hebrews 4:16). (4) A canonized theologian made her the channel of every gift. - Gregory Palamas, the fourteenth-century archbishop of Thessalonica in Greece, is among the most honored teachers in Orthodoxy. The church has canonized him, formally declaring him a saint, and a Sunday of Lent is named for him. - In his homilies (sermons) on the Theotokos he taught that no one comes to God except through her and the Mediator born of her, that no gift of God reaches angels or human beings except through her, and that even in the age to come every revelation and gift will be beyond anyone without her. - Palamas does keep Christ in the sentence. The strongest Orthodox reading says he means what Irenaeus, the second-century bishop of Lyons, meant (P4): every gift comes through Christ's humanity, and that humanity came from her. - That reading explains why he names the Mediator born of her. What it does not explain is the phrase "except through." "No one comes to the Father except through me" is what Jesus said of himself (John 14:6), and Palamas gives that "except through" to her as well, for angels and for the age to come. - David is an ancestor of the Mediator too, and Scripture never says that no one comes to God except through David. Paul says that God has blessed believers in Christ with every spiritual blessing (Ephesians 1:3), and he names no one else. Therefore, in its fixed hymns and common refrains, Orthodox worship ascribes to Mary works Scripture reserves to Christ, and its prayer books and honored teachers take those words at full strength.

(C1) Therefore, Orthodox worship teaches its people to look to Mary for what belongs to Christ. + Take the rule of P2, that what a church prays it comes to believe, and apply it to the hymns and refrains of P3: they teach believers to seek from Mary what P1 reserves to Christ. (1) The conclusion follows by modus ponens. - Modus ponens is the simplest valid form of argument: if A, then B; A is true; so B is true. If it rained last night, the street is wet; it rained last night; so the street is wet. - Here, if a church's fixed worship gives someone a work, it teaches its people to look to that person for it (P2). Orthodox worship gives Mary works Scripture reserves to Christ (P1, P3). So it teaches its people to look to her for what belongs to him. - An argument of this kind works like a locked chain. If each link holds, the conclusion cannot slip out. No link has to be certain, either: each premise needs only to be more plausible than its denial. (2) The worship itself points believers to Mary for Christ's works. - The hymns and refrains, sung by the whole church, direct believers to Mary for propitiation, cleansing, new birth, and access to God, the works Scripture gives to Christ alone. - Think of a road sign. A driver can know perfectly well where the city lies, but if every sign on the highway points down a side road, the signs are teaching him to take it. (3) The charge concerns the worship, not each worshiper's heart. - No one is accused of consciously worshiping Mary as God. You may have an Orthodox friend who would be startled by the very idea, and her church backs her: it teaches that Mary is a creature, and most Orthodox believers would say so at once. - Nor is every Orthodox believer said to pray these prayers or read these hymns this way. The question is what the church's worship says, and so what it teaches. Therefore, if Scripture gives these works to Christ alone (P1), fixed worship teaches belief (P2), and Orthodox worship gives them to Mary (P3), that worship teaches its people to look to her for what belongs to him.

(P4) The church of the first four centuries honored Mary without ascribing saving works to her. + The earliest Christians honored Mary as the woman through whom the Savior came, and for four centuries they gave her none of the works P1 reserves to Christ. (1) The New Testament's last word on Mary puts her at prayer with the church. - After Jesus was taken up into heaven (the ascension), the apostles devoted themselves to prayer, "together with the women and Mary the mother of Jesus, and his brothers" (Acts 1:14). That is the last time the New Testament names her. - The apostles' letters, which explain at length how sinners come to God, never mention her by name. Paul says only that God "sent forth his Son, born of woman" (Galatians 4:4). - Imagine a family letter that explains in detail how the estate is to be settled. If one person held a key to every room, the letter would say so. (2) The earliest teaching about Mary honored her obedience, not her mediation. - Justin Martyr, around 155, and Irenaeus of Lyons (in what is now France), around 180, set Mary's obedience beside Eve's disobedience: through Eve's unbelief came death, and through Mary's faith came the one who gives life (Justin, Dialogue with Trypho 100; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.22.4, 5.19.1). - This theme of Mary as the New Eve, the woman whose obedience answered Eve's disobedience, is ancient, and Protestants can affirm it gladly. - Irenaeus goes further still. He says that Mary, by obeying, became the cause of salvation for herself and the whole human race, and he calls her the advocate of Eve (D4). - What he means is that by her yes the Savior came into the world and Eve's disobedience was undone. Neither he nor Justin prays to her or names her the propitiation. (3) The earliest known prayer to Mary asks for her protection. - A short Greek prayer on a scrap of papyrus (the reed paper of the ancient world), known by its Latin name Sub tuum praesidium ("beneath your protection"), asks the Theotokos for refuge and deliverance. - Scholars date the papyrus anywhere from the third century to the seventh. That is a window of some four hundred years, about the distance from the Mayflower to today. - That much should be granted plainly: prayer to Mary is old. But this prayer is a plea for her protection, not a hymn calling her propitiation or regeneration. It may well come from after the great councils, too (the gatherings of bishops from across the church, such as Nicaea in 325 and Ephesus in 431). (4) The fourth century still drew a hard line. - Around 377, Epiphanius, bishop of Salamis on Cyprus, rebuked a group called the Collyridians who offered small cakes to Mary. Let Mary be honored, he wrote, but let the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit be worshiped, and let no one worship Mary (Panarion 79). - A few years later, around 381, Ambrose, bishop of Milan, put the same line in a picture. Mary was the temple of God, he wrote, not the God of the temple, and the one to be worshiped is the one who was at work in the temple (On the Holy Spirit 3.11.80). - Orthodox Christians stand with both bishops against worshiping Mary. What the two show is where the fourth century placed her: she is the temple, and the work belongs to her Son. (5) The language of P3 came later. - Epiphanius said plainly that no one knew how Mary's life had ended (Panarion 78.11). The written stories of her Dormition appear only later, and the feast was fixed on August 15 throughout the eastern Roman Empire around 600. - The Akathist belongs to the years after the Council of Ephesus in 431, when praise of Mary grew quickly (P3). Palamas preached in the fourteenth century. - Put in family terms, the Akathist was first sung more than a dozen generations after the apostles. Therefore, the church of the first four centuries honored Mary as the faithful mother of the Lord and gave her none of the works Scripture reserves to Christ.

(C2) Therefore, in giving Mary Christ's works, Orthodox devotion goes beyond Scripture and the early church. + In giving Mary Christ's works, Orthodox devotion goes beyond what Scripture teaches and beyond what the church closest to the apostles knew. Its worship directs believers to Mary for what Scripture gives to Christ (C1), and the church of the first four centuries did not (P4). (1) Honor Mary as Scripture does. - Mary is the Theotokos, the God-bearer, because the child she bore is God the Son. The Council of Ephesus confessed the title in 431 to protect the truth that Jesus is one person, fully God and fully man, and Protestants confess it with them. - She herself foretold, "from now on all generations will call me blessed" (Luke 1:48), and every generation of Christians should. She is the model believer: "Behold, I am the servant of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word" (Luke 1:38). (2) The correction is a narrow one. - What follows is this: Christians should not sing or pray to Mary as the one who propitiates, cleanses, regenerates, or opens the way to God. Those works are Christ's. - What does not follow is that Orthodox believers are not Christians. They confess the same creed and the same Lord, and this is a disagreement inside the family. - Nor does it settle three separate questions: • Mary's perpetual virginity, the belief that she remained a virgin all her life. • The Catholic Marian dogmas, teachings about Mary that Rome has defined as binding, such as the Immaculate Conception (1854): that she was kept free from original sin, the sin inherited from Adam, from the moment she was conceived. • Whether believers may ask the departed saints, Christians who have died and are with the Lord, to pray for them. (3) The remedy is the invitation. - God's glory is not shared: "I am the Lord; that is my name; my glory I give to no other" (Isaiah 42:8). Isaiah spoke those words against carved idols, of course, and Orthodox Christians do not treat Mary as one (C1). - The glory at stake is the one God claims in the very next chapter: "I, I am the Lord, and besides me there is no savior" (Isaiah 43:11). - The way to honor the mother is to do what she said at Cana and go to her Son. Therefore, in giving Mary works Scripture gives to Christ, Orthodox devotion goes beyond Scripture and the early church, and Christians should honor Mary as the blessed mother of the Lord while coming boldly to Christ himself for mercy and grace.

On Mary in Scripture and the early church: Graef, Hilda. Mary: A History of Doctrine and Devotion. New ed. Notre Dame, IN: Ave Maria Press, 2009. McKnight, Scot. The Real Mary: Why Evangelical Christians Can Embrace the Mother of Jesus. Brewster, MA: Paraclete Press, 2007. Mimouni, Simon Claude. Dormition et assomption de Marie: Histoire des traditions anciennes. Paris: Beauchesne, 1995. Pelikan, Jaroslav. Mary through the Centuries: Her Place in the History of Culture. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1996. Peltomaa, Leena Mari. The Image of the Virgin Mary in the Akathistos Hymn. Leiden: Brill, 2001. Perry, Tim. Mary for Evangelicals: Toward an Understanding of the Mother of Our Lord. Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2006. Shoemaker, Stephen J. Ancient Traditions of the Virgin Mary's Dormition and Assumption. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. Shoemaker, Stephen J. Mary in Early Christian Faith and Devotion. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2016. Eastern Orthodox sources engaged: The Akathist Hymn to the Most Holy Theotokos. The Divine Liturgy of Saint John Chrysostom. First antiphon. The Menaion for August 15 (Dormition of the Theotokos), Vespers stichera and troparion. Mother of Light (Orthodox prayer book to the Theotokos), as quoted in Manning, "Does Orthodox Devotion to Mary Go Too Far?" Palamas, Gregory. Mary the Mother of God: Sermons by Saint Gregory Palamas. Edited by Christopher Veniamin. South Canaan, PA: Mount Thabor Publishing, 2005. Ware, Timothy (Kallistos). The Orthodox Church. New ed. London: Penguin, 1993. Reformation sources: Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Edited by John T. McNeill. Translated by Ford Lewis Battles. Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1960. Book 4, chapter 9. Luther, Martin. "The Magnificat" (1521). In Luther's Works, vol. 21, The Sermon on the Mount and the Magnificat, edited by Jaroslav Pelikan. St. Louis: Concordia, 1956. Melanchthon, Philip. Apology of the Augsburg Confession (1531), Article 21. In The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church, edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. Video presentation: Manning, Erik. "Does Orthodox Devotion to Mary Go Too Far? (Yes)." Testify, YouTube, November 4, 2026. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2hsy-l_tTCk. Ancient sources: Ambrose of Milan. On the Holy Spirit 3.11.80. Chalcedon, Council of (451). Ephesus, Council of (431). Epiphanius of Salamis. Panarion 78-79. Irenaeus. Against Heresies 3.22.4, 5.19.1. Justin Martyr. Dialogue with Trypho 100. Leo the Great. Sermons 25.5 (On the Nativity). Prosper of Aquitaine (attributed). Indiculus (Capitula Caelestini) 8. Prudentius. Cathemerinon 9. Sub tuum praesidium. Rylands Papyrus 470. Vincent of Lérins. Commonitorium 2.6, 23. Biblical citations: Exodus 32:30-33. Numbers 16:46-48. Psalm 49:7-8; 141:2. Isaiah 42:8; 43:11. Matthew 5:14; 12:46-50; 15:6; 19:26. Luke 1:38, 1:45, 1:46-55; 11:27-28. John 2:1-11; 6:33; 8:12; 11:25; 14:6; 19:26-27. Acts 1:14. Romans 3:25. 1 Corinthians 4:15; 9:22; 10:14. Galatians 4:4. Ephesians 1:3; 2:18. Colossians 1:24. 2 Thessalonians 2:15. 1 Timothy 2:1-6; 4:16. 2 Timothy 4:18. Titus 3:5-6. Hebrews 4:16; 7:25; 9:5, 9:14; 10:11-14, 10:19. James 5:20. 1 Peter 1:18-19. 1 John 1:7; 2:1-2; 4:10. Revelation 12:1-17. All quotations from the English Standard Version.
+ The Orthodox Church teaches that Mary is a creature saved by her Son and that worship belongs to God alone. Its hymns honor her; they do not make her a rival Savior.
1. This is what the Orthodox Church officially teaches. Orthodox catechisms and theologians say exactly this, and it needs no qualifying. No Orthodox council teaches that Mary is divine, and Orthodox Christians reject the idea with real feeling. - The teaching goes back at least to Epiphanius, the fourth-century bishop who wrote that Mary should be honored and that no one should worship her (P4). 2. The question is the worship, not the catechism. What matters is what the fixed hymns and common prayers teach (P2). A church can confess one thing in its definitions and pray another in its services. When the two pull apart, think about which one people actually meet. Ordinary believers hear the services far more often than they read the definitions, and it is the services that shape what they reach for. - Picture a parent who tells a child that money cannot buy happiness, then spends every evening talking about salaries. The child learns from the evenings. 3. "Rival" is not the charge. The charge is not that Orthodoxy sets Mary against Christ. It is that Orthodoxy sets her beside him, in works Scripture gives to him alone (P3). Giving her his titles and his place is the problem, even when it is done in his honor. - Think of the best man again (P1). No one fears he will run off with the bride. The trouble would be toasts that give him the groom's place, however warmly they were meant.
+ The hymns are poetry. Byzantine hymns pile up images and greetings, and no one reads every line of a hymn as a doctrinal definition.
1. Poetry still says things. Hymns use images, of course, and the Byzantine hymns (the Greek church's hymns from the centuries of the eastern Roman Empire, which Orthodoxy still sings) are full of them. Images should not be read like a legal contract. But an image still points somewhere. "A mighty fortress is our God" is a picture, and it teaches something true about God. "Laver that washes the conscience," addressed to Mary, is a picture too, and it teaches something about Mary. 2. The Orthodox themselves treat the liturgy as theology. The Orthodox defense of icons (the painted images of Christ and the saints used in prayer), of the title Theotokos, and of much else appeals to the hymns as evidence of the church's faith (P2). A church cannot cite its hymns as theology when they support it and call them mere poetry when they embarrass it. - A lawyer cannot read a letter to the jury as proof when it helps his client, then wave the same letter away as a joke when it hurts him. The fairest Orthodox answer is that hymns are read through the councils and the fathers (the great teachers of the early church), not line by line. That is a sound rule for reading any poetry. But for these lines the fathers of the first four centuries supply no such reading (P4), and the people singing them on a Friday in Lent do not have a commentary open. 3. The prayers are not hymns. "I implore you that I may obtain salvation through your mediation with him" is not a poetic greeting. It is a petition, and it asks a creature for what Hebrews tells the believer to seek with confidence at the throne of grace (Hebrews 4:16). - Think of the difference between a love song and a mortgage application. One can exaggerate. The other says exactly what is being asked for.
+ Scripture shares Christ's work and titles with his people: Paul saves some and becomes a father to converts, Moses and Aaron make atonement, and the disciples are the light of the world. Mary's titles, and "Most Holy Theotokos, save us," work the same way.
1. This is the strongest Orthodox reply. Scripture does speak this way, and often: - Paul became all things to all people so that he might save some (1 Corinthians 9:22), and he tells Timothy that by keeping close watch on his teaching he will save both himself and his hearers (1 Timothy 4:16). - James says that whoever brings back a wandering sinner will save his soul from death (James 5:20). - Paul says he became the Corinthians' father in Christ Jesus through the gospel (1 Corinthians 4:15). - After the golden calf, Moses went up to the Lord in the hope that he could make atonement for Israel's sin (Exodus 32:30), and when a plague broke out, Aaron made atonement for the people with incense (Numbers 16:46-48). - Jesus calls himself the light of the world (John 8:12). He gives the same title to his disciples: "You are the light of the world" (Matthew 5:14). - Paul even writes, "in my flesh I am filling up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church" (Colossians 1:24). On this reading, Mary saves the way any faithful Christian saves, by prayer and witness that God uses, and she bears Christ's titles the way his disciples do: by grace, in a lesser and borrowed sense. 2. Scripture shares the calling, never the once-for-all work. In each of these texts a believer serves a work that Christ alone accomplishes, once for all and never to be repeated. - Paul saved by preaching Christ, and his fatherhood came through the gospel. A man on a pier who shouts "Grab the rope!" to a drowning swimmer can fairly say he saved her. He would never say he was the rope. - When Moses went up to make atonement, he asked God to forgive Israel or else blot him out of his book, and the Lord answered that whoever had sinned would be blotted out (Exodus 32:30-33). Whatever Moses meant by the offer, God did not accept a man in the sinners' place. - Aaron's incense belonged to the old priesthood. Its repeated offerings, Hebrews says, could never take away sins, and they gave way to Christ's single offering (Hebrews 10:11-14). - Colossians 1:24 is among the hardest verses in Paul, but almost no interpreter, Orthodox or Protestant, reads it as adding to Christ's atoning death. Paul's sufferings are a servant's, borne for the sake of the church. 3. Scripture does its own sharing. When Scripture shares a title, the one who owns it does the sharing: Jesus himself tells the disciples that they are the light of the world. No apostle calls anyone but Christ the propitiation, the ransom, the one mediator, or the resurrection, and no text hails any believer as the one who washes the conscience (P1). - A king can knight a subject and call him "Sir." The subject cannot crown himself, and his friends cannot crown him either. 4. The prayers and hymns go far past intercession. Intercession is praying on someone else's behalf, the way a friend prays for you when you are in the hospital. Whether believers may ask the departed to pray for them is a separate question (C2). The prayers and hymns of P3 do not stop at "pray for us." They call Mary the ransom of sins, the resurrection of the fallen, the deification of mortals, and the one for whom nothing is impossible, and an honored teacher makes her the necessary channel of every gift. No one in Scripture who "saves" others is given titles like these.
+ Mary is the New Eve. Irenaeus, a second-century bishop, called her the cause of salvation for the whole human race and the advocate of Eve, so high honor for Mary is ancient, not medieval.
1. The New Eve is an ancient and good teaching. Justin and Irenaeus contrasted Eve's disobedience with Mary's obedience, and Irenaeus did call Mary the cause of salvation for herself and the whole human race (Against Heresies 3.22.4). There is no need to hedge on that (P4). The strongest form of this objection adds a second passage. Eve, Irenaeus writes, was led astray by the word of an angel, and Mary obeyed the word an angel brought her, so that the virgin Mary might become the advocata of the virgin Eve (Against Heresies 5.19.1). The Latin word means "advocate," though some translations render it "patroness." Advocate is the title John gives Christ (1 John 2:1), so on this reading Irenaeus already gives Mary a pleading part in salvation. 2. Irenaeus means her yes, not her mediation. His point is that by consenting to bear the Son, Mary became the door through which the Savior entered the world. - Irenaeus thinks in terms of recapitulation: Christ went back over the human story from its start and set right, step by step, what Adam had set wrong. Mary's part in that story is her obedience. The knot Eve tied by unbelief, he says, Mary untied by faith (3.22.4). - So when he calls her Eve's advocate, it is her obedience that pleads Eve's case, by undoing Eve's failure. The advocacy is something she did in Nazareth, not a prayer addressed to her afterward. - Even on the strongest reading, in which Mary prays for Eve, that is intercession, a separate question (C2), and not the works of P1. - Think of the mother of a great surgeon. Her yes to bearing him made every operation he ever performed possible, and she deserves honor for it, but the operations are his. - Irenaeus never prays to her, never calls her the propitiation, and never says that gifts reach believers only through her. 3. Ancient roots do not make the later growth ancient. That Mary was honored early is true. That she was given the works of P1 early is the claim the evidence does not support (P4). - A farmhouse built in 1750 can have a kitchen added in 1990. The house is old, but the kitchen is not two hundred years old because the house is.
+ The Akathist's titles are typology, not rival claims. Mary is the ark that carried God and the type of the baptismal font, so hailing her as propitiation and laver honors the place where Christ's work happened, not a work of her own.
1. The typology is real. Typology reads people and things in the Old Testament as pictures that the New fulfills, the way an architect's sketch looks forward to the finished house. The church fathers, the great teachers of the early centuries, often saw Mary in the ark of the covenant, the sacred chest in Israel's tabernacle that carried God's presence. The Akathist itself hails her as an ark gilded by the Spirit. That reading deserves its full weight, and it is the most charitable way to hear these lines. - The mercy seat was the ark's gold cover, where Israel's high priest sprinkled sacrificial blood once a year on the Day of Atonement. Its Greek name is hilastērion (Hebrews 9:5). On this reading Mary is hailed as the world's propitiation the way the ark could be called the place of atonement: because the Son rested in her, as God's presence rested above the ark. - The laver line sits beside a greeting that hails her as the one who pictures the font of baptism. Leo the Great, bishop of Rome in the fifth century, drew the same picture: Christ gave to the font of baptism the beginning he took in the Virgin's womb (Sermons 25.5). - Or the line is metonymy, a figure of speech that names a container for what it holds, the way a host says "have another cup" and means the coffee. Mary held the propitiation, so she is hailed by his name. 2. The hymn's word names the price, not the place. The line reads chaire, pantos tou kosmou exilasma, "hail, propitiation of the whole world." The mercy seat's word, hilastērion, names the place where atonement was made. The hymn uses a different word. - Exilasma is not the mercy seat but the atoning price itself. The Greek translation of the Old Testament uses it in the psalm that says no one can give God the ransom for another's life (Psalm 49:7-8). - Think of the counter at the bank where you paid off a loan. You might fondly call it the place where your debt was settled. You would never call the counter the payment. 3. In Scripture's pictures, Christ is the one who acts. - Paul gives the mercy seat's own word to Christ: God put him forward "as a propitiation by his blood" (Romans 3:25), and the Greek there is hilastērion. John says God sent his Son "to be the propitiation for our sins" (1 John 4:10). When the New Testament reads the mercy seat, it finds the Son, not the mother. - Leo's sentence keeps Christ as the one who acts: he gave to the font what he gave to his mother. A type can make Mary the vessel. The hymn's grammar makes her the doer, the laver that washes and the one who "gave new birth." - Think of the stone font in an old village church. Generations have been baptized in it, and the parish treasures it, but nobody prays to it, "You gave me new birth." 4. A figure of speech teaches only what its hearers already know. "Have another cup" works because everyone at the table already knows the cup is not the drink. Metonymy borrows that knowledge from its hearers. It does not supply it. So a worshiper who sings "propitiation of the whole world" to Mary hears Christ's title given to her, and only teaching she already has tells her it means her Son (P2). The hymn itself does not. 5. The other lines have no such escape. Even if every reader took "propitiation" and "laver" as pictures, the hymn still hails her as mortals' parrēsia before God (P3), the confidence Hebrews says believers have "to enter the holy places by the blood of Jesus" (Hebrews 10:19). And the prayers still ask her for salvation itself. Typology explains a picture. It does not explain a petition.
+ At Cana Mary asked and Jesus acted. Her intercession works, and asking for it honors the Son who listens to his mother.
1. Mary's request at Cana is real. She told Jesus that the wine had run out, and he acted on it, turning water into wine (John 2:1-11). Her word to him mattered. Christians who ask for her prayers point to this scene, and it is a moving one. 2. She sent the servants to him. Jesus first answered her, "Woman, what does this have to do with me? My hour has not yet come" (John 2:4), a reminder that his hour was set by his Father, not by her. Her answer was to send the servants to her Son: "Do whatever he tells you" (John 2:5). - She acts like a friend who walks you to the doctor's door. She does not write the prescription, and she tells you to listen to him. 3. Cana is not a prayer to her. Whether believers may ask the departed saints to pray for them is a separate question (C2). Cana shows a living mother speaking to her living Son. It does not show anyone calling her the propitiation or the way to the Father.
+ Scripture gives Mary a place in the church. From the cross Jesus gave her to the beloved disciple as his mother, and Revelation shows a woman crowned with stars who bears the Messiah.
1. John 19 is a son caring for his mother. Jesus entrusted his mother to the disciple he loved, and John adds that from that hour the disciple took her into his own home (John 19:26-27). The plainest reading is a dying son providing for his widowed mother. 2. Revelation 12 pictures God's people. The woman clothed with the sun gives birth to the Messiah, flees into the wilderness, and has other offspring who keep God's commandments (Revelation 12:1-17). Many readers, ancient and modern, see Israel and the church in her, and some see Mary as well. 3. Even the generous readings stop short. Grant that the church may call Mary its mother, and that Revelation 12 includes her. Neither text makes her the propitiation, the cleansing of conscience, or the door to the Father. A mother is honored. She is not given her Son's work.
+ The apostles handed down unwritten traditions as well as letters: "hold to the traditions that you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or by our letter." Orthodox devotion to Mary is part of that tradition.
1. Unwritten tradition is real. Paul did write, "stand firm and hold to the traditions that you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or by our letter" (2 Thessalonians 2:15). Protestants should not pretend he did not. 2. A tradition has to be shown, not assumed. A claim that something is apostolic tradition is a historical claim, and it needs historical evidence. The early church honored Mary but gave her none of the works of P1 (P4). Calling a later practice apostolic does not make it so. - Think of a family recipe said to come from Great-grandma. If it first appears in a cousin's kitchen generations later, and the oldest relatives say she never made it, the label on the card does not settle the question. 3. Tradition answers to Scripture. Jesus tested the tradition of his day by the word of God: "So for the sake of your tradition you have made void the word of God" (Matthew 15:6). A tradition that gives Mary what the apostles' letters give to Christ alone fails that test, however old it is. Nor does the answer lean on the Protestant rule alone. The Orthodox test is agreement with the fathers, and a tradition that came from the apostles should show up in the fathers nearest them. On these titles the first four centuries are silent (P4). See also: PT / Bibliology: Sola Scriptura
+ The argument rests on the New Testament's silence about Mary's role, and arguments from silence are weak. The New Testament was written for particular needs, not to say everything.
1. Silence on small things proves little. An argument from silence concludes something from what a text does not say, and on minor details it is weak. The objection is right about that. - A postcard from a friend's vacation that never mentions breakfast tells you nothing about what she ate. 2. This silence falls where speech is expected. Paul, John, and the author of Hebrews explain again and again how a sinner comes to God, receives grace, and finds an advocate: by Christ, through his blood, in one Spirit, with confidence before the throne (P1). If Mary had a necessary place in that approach, those explanations are where she would appear. She never does. - Directions are another matter. Picture a friend's directions to her house that name every turn and every landmark. If there were a gate you could not get through without a key, the directions would mention it. 3. The case does not rest on silence alone. It rests on what Scripture says: that the works of P1 belong to Christ alone, and that besides the Lord there is no savior (Isaiah 43:11).
+ The Dormition traditions are ancient, and some scholars trace them to the third century. The church has always believed that Mary fell asleep and was taken bodily into heaven.
1. Devotion to Mary is older than many Protestants assume. The strongest form of this objection comes from the historian Stephen Shoemaker. He argues that the earliest accounts of Mary's death may reach back to the third century, though they survive only in later copies. He also reads the Collyridians (P4) as one sign of a devotion to Mary that was wider in the fourth century than Epiphanius's attack on them suggests. - That much can be granted, even though other historians date the first stories of her death later. Prayer to Mary is old (P4), and before the Council of Ephesus some Christians were honoring her in ways their bishops argued about. - Think of a song found in an attic, copied out in a grandchild's hand. The copy is recent, but the song may be much older. 2. Early is not apostolic. The written accounts of Mary's death and assumption (her being taken bodily into heaven), sometimes called the Transitus ("passing") stories, survive in copies from the fifth century on, about four hundred years after her lifetime. The feast was fixed on August 15 across the eastern Roman Empire around 600. Even with third-century roots, a fourth-century bishop said plainly that no one knew. Around 377, Epiphanius wrote that no one knew how Mary's life had ended, whether she died or remained alive (Panarion 78.11). If the church had always known, a bishop born in Palestine, who had led a monastery there for years, would have known too. 3. The question is the hymns, not the event. A third-century root would show early interest in how Mary's life ended and early honor for her. It would not show the hymns of P3, which give her the works of P1, and those come after the line the fourth century drew (P4). Whatever happened at the end of Mary's life, the feast's hymns credit her falling asleep with giving life to the world and bringing salvation to the race of mortals (P3). Scripture gives those works to the Son (John 6:33; Hebrews 10:14). Whether she was taken bodily into heaven is a separate question, like Rome's dogma of the Assumption (1950), and C2 does not depend on it.
+ Veneration is not worship: the Orthodox give God alone latreia, the worship due to him, and give Mary only a special honor. No one worships Mary, so there is no idolatry.
1. The distinction is real. Veneration is honor shown to a saint, such as bowing before an icon, kissing it, or lighting a candle in front of it. Orthodox theology gives God alone latreia (worship) and gives the saints honor, with a higher honor for Mary. Catholic theology calls hers hyperdulia. The word builds on dulia, the honor given to the saints, and means a higher degree of that same honor, still short of worship. Orthodox Christians sincerely mean the distinction, and they should be believed about their intentions. 2. The works matter more than the label. The question is not what the honor is called but what it gives. Calling an act "veneration" does not change what its words say, and here the prayers ask Mary for salvation and call her the ransom of sins, while an honored teacher makes her the channel of every gift (P3). - Think of a thank-you letter addressed to the courier who delivered a gift. The courier deserves thanks, but if the letter credits him with the gift itself, the giver has been forgotten, however warm the letter is. 3. Scripture says flee, not measure the distance. Paul's instruction is to flee from idolatry (1 Corinthians 10:14), not to see how near the line one can safely stand. Orthodox Christians stand with Epiphanius against the women who offered cakes to Mary (P4), and they do not mean to worship her. But his caution is the point: he saw honor for Mary drifting toward worship in his own century, and he told the church to honor her and worship God.
+ A prayer book and one theologian's homilies are not dogma. Private devotions do not bind the Orthodox Church.
1. The heart of the evidence is liturgical. Whatever counts as dogma (a church's formally defined, binding teaching), the Akathist and the Dormition hymns are not private devotions. They belong to the services appointed for every Orthodox church in the same season every year (P3), and "Most Holy Theotokos, save us" recurs through the ordinary services and the prayer books. 2. Palamas is not a fringe voice. Gregory Palamas is a canonized saint with a Sunday of Lent kept in his honor, and his theology is treated across Orthodoxy as a touchstone. His homilies on the Theotokos are read, not hidden. 3. Widely used prayers shape widely held trust. Orthodox prayers to the Theotokos often travel under the names of saints such as Ephrem the Syrian, the fourth-century hymn writer. Many scholars doubt that the Greek prayers circulating under Ephrem's name are his. Whoever wrote them, believers pray them from Orthodox prayer books, and a church whose people pray them cannot treat them as nothing (P2).
+ Protestants neglect the Mother of God and dishonor her Son by it. Their reaction against Mary goes too far the other way.
1. Some of this is fair. Many Protestant churches mention Mary only at Christmas, and that is a loss. She is the mother of the Lord and a model of faith, and Scripture says all generations will call her blessed (Luke 1:48). 2. The Reformers honored her. Martin Luther wrote a warm commentary on the Magnificat, Mary's song (Luke 1:46-55), in 1521. Luther kept the title Mother of God gladly, and the Reformers, the sixteenth-century leaders of the Protestant Reformation, affirmed the faith of the Council of Ephesus that gave it. The Protestant tradition at its best honors Mary by imitating her faith. 3. Correcting neglect does not require excess. The cure for too little honor is the honor Scripture gives, not the works Scripture reserves to Christ. A Protestant can sing the Magnificat with joy and still refuse to call Mary the propitiation of the world.
+ The liturgy explains its own greetings. The Divine Liturgy prays, "Through the prayers of the Theotokos, O Savior, save us," so in Orthodox worship Christ saves and Mary prays.
1. The refrain says exactly who saves. The strongest form of this objection turns the law of prayer (P2) around. Orthodox services are addressed overwhelmingly to the Holy Trinity and to Christ. A handful of greetings to Mary, picked out of thousands of hymns, cannot show what the whole worship teaches. And where the services do explain her part, they explain it as prayer. - An antiphon is a psalm sung with a short refrain. The first antiphon of the Divine Liturgy, the Orthodox service of the Lord's Supper, repeats "Through the prayers of the Theotokos, O Savior, save us" between its verses, and many Orthodox churches sing it every Sunday. - Think of the key printed in the corner of a map. It tells you how to read every symbol on the sheet. - The feast of the Dormition carries the same key. Its troparion, the short hymn that sums up a feast, says that by her prayers she delivers our souls from death. - Even the Akathist's propitiation line has a partner. The greeting just before it hails her as the acceptable incense of intercession, and Scripture says that Aaron made atonement for the people with incense (Numbers 16:46-48). That much should be granted in full: the refrain names Christ as the one who saves and Mary as one who prays, and Orthodox teachers read the greetings to her by it. 2. A liturgy that says both teaches both. The law of prayer takes in the whole liturgy, the greetings as well as the refrain (P2). A worshiper who prays "O Savior, save us" in one service and hails Mary as the propitiation of the whole world in another has been taught both things. The refrain does not erase the greetings. - Take the Akathist's own pair of greetings. The first hails her as the acceptable incense of intercession, and Scripture does picture prayer rising like incense (Psalm 141:2). As for Aaron's incense, it belonged to the old priesthood (D3). - The second greeting is another matter. "Propitiation of the whole world" is the title John gives Christ, in substance and nearly in words (1 John 2:2, where the Greek is the related word hilasmos). Hebrews, for its part, names one priest who saves completely those who draw near to God through him, because he lives forever to intercede for them (Hebrews 7:25). The second greeting says more than the first, and singing the first does not unsay the second. - Nor are the greetings rare. The Akathist is appointed in full every Lent, and "Most Holy Theotokos, save us" recurs through the services and the prayer books (P3). - Think of a medicine label that prints the right dose on the front and a dangerous one on the back. The front does not make the back safe. 3. Prayer cannot explain the lines that make her necessary. "By her prayers" fits "save us." It cannot fit a creature through whom every gift must pass, or a believer who does not dare approach the Son and asks for salvation through her mediation instead (P3). - The Reformers pressed this question in 1531, in one of the Lutheran confessions of faith. Grant that Mary prays for the church: does she receive souls at death, conquer death, or give life? If she does those things, they asked, what is left for Christ to do? Mary herself, they added, would rather be followed than made Christ's equal. - The question is not idle, because the Dormition hymns do credit her falling asleep with giving the world life (P3). - A friend who prays for you walks into the room beside you. She does not stand in the doorway as the one you must get past. 4. The fix is already in the service book. If "Through the prayers of the Theotokos, O Savior, save us" governed every line about Mary, the greetings would be sung the way the refrain sings: Christ the propitiation and the laver of the conscience, his mother praying with the church. The correction a Protestant asks for is one the Orthodox liturgy already knows how to say.
+ The Akathist comes from the church that confessed Mary as Theotokos at Ephesus and defined Christ's two natures at Chalcedon. Protestants who trust that church's creeds cannot dismiss its hymns.
1. Every Protestant owes that church a debt. This is a fair challenge, and it should be felt. The Nicene Creed, the fourth-century statement of faith many churches still recite, is confessed across the Protestant churches, and so is the Council of Chalcedon's definition of Christ as one person in two natures, fully God and fully man (451). The Akathist comes from the same era (P3). The strongest form of the challenge adds the Bible itself: the church of those centuries recognized the books of the New Testament that Protestants read every Sunday. - Protestants sing that era's hymns too. "Of the Father's Love Begotten" began as a Latin poem by Prudentius, a Christian poet from Spain, written around 400. 2. Councils are trusted for what they defined. Ephesus confessed Theotokos to say who Jesus is: the child in Mary's arms was God the Son. Chalcedon defined how he is both God and man. Neither council, and no council of the whole church since, defined Mary as the propitiation of the world, the laver of the conscience, or the channel of every gift. Those lines come from hymns and homilies, and the Orthodox themselves distinguish hymns and homilies from dogma (P2, D12). - The Reformers said so from the start. They received Nicaea, Ephesus, and Chalcedon because what those councils defined was Scripture's own teaching rightly explained, and they held everything else those centuries produced to the same standard. - The canon, the list of books that belong in the Bible, works the same way. The church recognized the books the apostles had left and bound itself to them; it did not write them. A hymn the church composed centuries after the apostles is a different kind of thing from a book it received from them. - Think of a citizen who accepts the Constitution without accepting every speech its signers ever gave. Accepting what a council defined has never meant accepting everything sung in its century. 3. That same century supplied its own test. Around 434, three years after Ephesus, Vincent, a monk at the island monastery of Lérins off the coast of what is now southern France, wrote that the church must hold what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all (Commonitorium 2.6). The test comes from inside the church of the councils, not from the Reformation. And "always" is exactly what these titles lack: the church of the first four centuries did not give them to Mary (P4). - The Orthodox reply is that doctrine grows, and Vincent agreed. He welcomed real progress, but only in the same sense and the same meaning, the way a child grows into a man and is still the same person (Commonitorium 23). - Theotokos is a claim about the Son, and honor for his mother has grown from it ever since. "Propitiation of the whole world" is not that child grown up. It hands her a title Scripture gives to her Son (1 John 2:2). See also: PT / Ecclesiology: Iconoclasm: The Rejection of Icon Veneration PT / Bibliology: Sola Scriptura PT / Bibliology: New Testament Canon

Eschatology

The Doctrine of Last Things

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief