Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Ancient History

3000 BC – 400 BC

Hesiod of Ascra fl. c. 700 BC

(●) The farmer-poet of Boeotia who gave the Greeks the family tree of their gods and their first sermon on justice and hard work. + Two poets stand at the head of Greek literature, and the Greeks always named them together: Homer and Hesiod. Homer sang of heroes at Troy and a king finding his way home. Hesiod sang of where the gods came from, and of how an ordinary man should plough, sail, pay his debts, and keep his word. Between them they gave the Greek world its picture of heaven, and when the first Christian writers set out to answer that picture, it was very often Hesiod’s lines they quoted. He matters on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. His Theogony, a poem whose title means "the birth of the gods," is the nearest thing the Greeks had to a Genesis, and setting the two side by side shows with unusual clarity what the doctrine of creation actually claims. And his Works and Days is a pagan farmer’s cry for justice, written by a man who believed that heaven sees what crooked judges do. The church fathers found in him both a foil and, now and then, an ally. The dates are a convention, and they should be read as one. No ancient source gives the year of his birth or death. Herodotus, writing around 430 BC, guessed that Homer and Hesiod lived four hundred years before him, which would put them near 830 BC. Most modern scholars place Hesiod around 700 BC instead, chiefly because of the funeral games at Chalcis he says he sang at, and they still argue whether he or Homer came first. Every date given for him carries a "c." for that reason. What we do have is something no poet before him gave us. Hesiod is the first poet in European literature to tell us his own name and something of his own life. Homer stays hidden behind his heroes; Hesiod steps forward and talks about his father, his village, and his prize. And the grievance he comes back to most, like a man who cannot leave an old family quarrel alone, is that his brother cheated him.

(●) 8th century BC: His father fled poverty overseas and settled in a hamlet under Mount Helicon. + Almost everything we know of Hesiod’s family comes from a few lines he wrote to his brother. Their father, he says, had been a trader who sailed for a living out of Cyme, a Greek town on the Aeolian coast of what is now western Turkey. He did not leave because he was rich. He left, in Hesiod’s words, to escape "wretched poverty which Zeus lays upon men," crossed the Aegean, and settled on the mainland near Mount Helicon in Boeotia, the farming country north-west of Athens. The place was a village called Ascra, and Hesiod did not love it. He calls it "a miserable hamlet, Ascra, which is bad in winter, sultry in summer, and good at no time" (Works and Days 639–640). Anyone who has grown up in a small town and described it to a stranger will hear the tone. Whether Hesiod was born in Cyme before the move or in Ascra after it, the poems do not say; the convention calls him Hesiod of Ascra because that is where his life was lived.

(●) c. 700 BC: The Muses met him while he herded lambs on Helicon, and the shepherd became a poet. + The Theogony opens with a scene that has been painted and retold ever since. A young man is out on the slopes of Helicon with his lambs, an ordinary day’s work, when the Muses appear to him. The Muses were the nine daughters of Zeus whom the Greeks believed gave poets their songs. They do not flatter him. They call the shepherds of the hills "mere bellies," hand him a branch of laurel as a singer’s staff, and breathe into him "a divine voice to celebrate things that shall be and things there were aforetime" (Theogony 22–32). The strangest part is what they tell him before they inspire him. They can tell lies that look like truth, they say, and they can tell the truth when they choose. A poet who opens his account of the gods by admitting that the source of his inspiration is capable of deceiving him is an honest poet, and the church fathers would later take him at his word. The scene is a call story, the kind of moment when an ordinary person is summoned to a task, and readers of the Bible will think of Amos taken from following the flock, or David from the sheepfold. Calling on the Muses was already a poet’s convention in Homer. Whether Hesiod meant it as a vision, a figure of speech, or something between, he is telling us that his poetry began on a hillside while he was working.

(●) c. 700 BC: His brother Perses took the bigger share of their inheritance, with the help of judges who took bribes. + When their father died, the two sons divided the farm. Hesiod says Perses "seized the greater share and carried it off, greatly swelling the glory of our bribe-swallowing lords who love to judge such a cause as this" (Works and Days 37–39). The lords were the local nobles who sat as judges, and Hesiod plainly believed they had been paid. Then the story turns. Perses, it seems, wasted what he had taken, and came back to his brother for help. Hesiod’s answer is the Works and Days: some eight hundred lines of advice, warning and instruction addressed, again and again, to "foolish Perses." It is not a lawsuit and not a curse. It is an older brother telling a younger one, with exasperation and something like love, that the gods see crooked judgments, that idleness ends in hunger, and that the only honest road to plenty runs through the field. Some scholars have wondered whether Perses was a literary device rather than a real man, but the quarrel comes up in such scattered hints and asides, the way a person mentions a real family sore point without ever telling the whole story, that most readers take it as a real grievance.

(●) c. 700 BC: He crossed to Chalcis for a nobleman’s funeral games, won a tripod with a song, and gave it to the Muses. + Hesiod admits he knew almost nothing about ships. The only voyage of his life, he says, was the short crossing from Aulis on the mainland to the island of Euboea, a strait you could nearly shout across. He made it to compete at the funeral games of "wise Amphidamas" at Chalcis, where the dead man’s sons had announced prizes. "And there I boast that I gained the victory with a song and carried off an handled tripod," he writes, and he dedicated the prize to the Muses of Helicon "in the place where they first set me in the way of clear song" (Works and Days 650–659). A tripod was a three-legged bronze cauldron, the ancient equivalent of a silver trophy cup. This modest boast is the main anchor for dating him. Plutarch, writing some eight centuries later, identifies an Amphidamas of Chalcis who fell in the Lelantine War, a struggle between Chalcis and its neighbor Eretria that historians usually place around 700 BC. If that is the same man, Hesiod sang at Chalcis around that time. That "if" is why the dates carry a "c." Later storytellers improved on the scene beyond recognition: a work called the Contest of Homer and Hesiod has the two great poets meet at these very games, with Hesiod winning. That meeting is legend; neither of Hesiod’s poems mentions Homer, and the one stray fragment under his name that does is generally judged a later invention.

(●) After c. 700 BC: An old tradition says he was murdered in Locris, in a grove sacred to Zeus. + Of his death we have only tradition, and it is a dark one. The historian Thucydides, writing in the late fifth century BC, mentions in passing a precinct of Nemean Zeus in Locris, west of Boeotia, "in which the poet Hesiod is said to have been killed by the people of the country, according to an oracle which had foretold that he should die in Nemea" (History of the Peloponnesian War III.96, Crawley translation). An oracle was a god’s answer to a question, given through the priest or priestess of a shrine, and Greeks travelled far to ask one about their future. This one, the story goes, had warned him away from Nemea, so he avoided the famous Nemea near Corinth and walked straight into a lesser grove of the same name. Later versions add more: that his hosts suspected him of seducing their sister, that his body was thrown into the sea and carried back to shore by dolphins, and that his bones were eventually moved to the Boeotian city of Orchomenus. None of this can be checked, and the details differ from writer to writer. What can be said is that the tradition of a violent death in Locris is at least as old as Thucydides, which is old enough to be worth reporting and not old enough to be trusted.

(●) c. 430 BC: Herodotus named him with Homer as the poets who had given the Greeks their gods. + Within three centuries Hesiod had become a schoolbook. Greek boys learned his maxims by heart the way children once learned proverbs from a family Bible, and the historian Herodotus gave him a place no other poet but Homer shared: "Hesiod and Homer," he wrote, "are they who made a theogony for the Hellenes and gave the titles to the gods and distributed to them honours and arts, and set forth their forms" (Histories II.53, Macaulay translation). A theogony is an account of the gods’ origins and family relations, and Herodotus meant that the Greeks owed their whole picture of heaven to these two men. Fame brought critics with it. The philosopher Xenophanes complained that Homer and Hesiod had attributed to the gods everything that is shameful among men, theft and adultery and deceit. Plato, in the Republic, singled out Hesiod’s story of how Cronos castrated his father and was in turn overthrown by his son as "that greatest of all lies in high places," a tale not to be told to the young (Republic II, 377e–378a, Jowett translation). The poet had become important enough that a philosopher who wanted to reform the gods had to begin by arguing with him.

What He Taught

(T1) Before the gods there was Chaos, and the gods themselves were born. + Picture a family tree drawn on the inside cover of an old Bible, generation after generation branching down the flyleaf. The Theogony is a family tree of that kind, except that the family is the gods. It begins with Chaos, which in Hesiod’s Greek means not a mess but a yawning gap, an empty opening. Then Earth comes to be, and Tartarus, a dark pit far beneath the earth, and Eros, the power of desire that draws things together. Earth gives birth to Heaven; Earth and Heaven produce the Titans, an elder generation of mighty gods; the youngest Titan, Cronos, overthrows his father; and Cronos in turn is overthrown by his own son Zeus, who becomes king of the gods and rules by distributing honours fairly among them. Notice two things, because the fathers noticed them. First, the gods in Hesiod are not before the world. They are born out of it, later than Earth and Heaven, the way children are later than their grandparents. Second, nothing in the poem explains why there is a gap, an Earth, or anything at all. Things simply "came to be." Hesiod tells us the order of the generations; he never tells us who or what is responsible for there being generations. The story of the succession is violent. A father hides his children in the earth, a son maims his father, a god swallows his offspring to keep them from rising against him. Zeus wins by strength and cunning, and only then does justice begin to rule, because the new king makes it so. The contrast with Genesis, where God is before all things and speaks a good world into being, could not be sharper, and it was the first thing the Christian apologists pointed out.

(Q) "Verily at the first Chaos came to be, but next wide-bosomed Earth, the ever-sure foundations of all the deathless ones who hold the peaks of snowy Olympus, and dim Tartarus in the depth of the wide-pathed Earth, and Eros (Love), fairest among the deathless gods, who unnerves the limbs and overcomes the mind and wise counsels of all gods and all men within them." + Source: Hesiod, Theogony 116–122 (Evelyn-White translation, 1914). These are the opening lines of the creation account proper, which Hesiod reaches only after a long prelude in praise of the Muses. Read them slowly, and watch the verb, because the verb is the whole point: Chaos "came to be." Hesiod never says it was made, and never says by whom (T1).

(T2) Justice is the daughter of Zeus, and the city that keeps it prospers. + Think of a man who has lost a court case he knows he should have won, and who has to walk past the judge in the market the next morning. The Works and Days is written from that place. Its first lines praise Zeus, of whom Hesiod says that "easily he humbles the proud and raises the obscure" (Works and Days 6), and its central section is an argument that the gods are not indifferent to what the powerful do to the weak. Hesiod gives Justice a face. She is a goddess, Dike (pronounced DEE-kay), the daughter of Zeus, and when a judge twists a verdict she goes weeping through the city and sits beside her father to tell him "of men’s wicked heart" (Works and Days 256–260). The city whose judges give straight verdicts flourishes: peace, full harvests, children who look like their parents. The city of crooked judges suffers famine and plague, and often "a whole city suffers for a bad man." He even tells a fable to make the point, of a hawk that carries off a nightingale and sneers that might is the only law. Hesiod’s answer is that the hawk may be right about hawks, but it is wrong about men. Here a Christian reader is on familiar ground. Mary’s song in Luke says the same thing about the God of Israel: "he has brought down the mighty from their thrones and exalted those of humble estate" (Luke 1:52), and the prophets Hesiod never heard of, Amos above all, had preached the same message to the judges of Israel a generation or two before him. Hesiod reached it as a pagan, from a lost lawsuit and a conscience, which is exactly what Paul says the conscience can do (Romans 2:14–15).

(Q) "For the son of Cronos has ordained this law for men, that fishes and beasts and winged fowls should devour one another, for right is not in them; but to mankind he gave right which proves far the best." + Source: Hesiod, Works and Days 276–280 (Evelyn-White translation, 1914). Hesiod is answering his own fable of the hawk and the nightingale. Animals live by eating one another, and that is no fault in them; human beings were given justice, and a man who lives like the hawk has fallen below his own nature (T2).

(T3) Mankind has sunk from a race of gold to a race of iron, and is still sinking. + Every grandparent has said it at least once: things were better in my day. Hesiod turned that feeling into history. The gods, he says, made five races of mortal men, one after another. The golden race lived in the time of Cronos, without toil or sorrow, and died as if falling asleep. The silver race was foolish and would not honour the gods. The bronze race loved war and destroyed itself. The fourth race, the heroes who fought at Thebes and Troy, was nobler and more righteous, and some of them were carried off to the islands of the blessed. And the fifth race is ours, the race of iron. His picture of the iron age is bleak and oddly modern. Children dishonour their aged parents; brother is no longer dear to brother; "might shall be their right"; men praise the evil-doer; and at the end Shame and Righteous Indignation, two goddesses Hesiod calls Aidos and Nemesis, will leave the earth altogether. He does not promise a turn. Zeus, he says, will destroy this race too. Christian readers have recognized something in this: a pagan memory that the world was once better than it is and that the fault lies in human wrongdoing. Genesis also begins with a good world and tells how it was spoiled. But Hesiod’s decline is a slope with no bottom and no rescue. The biblical story runs downhill to the flood and the exile, and then turns upward toward a promise, "Behold, I am making all things new" (Revelation 21:5).

(Q) "Thereafter, would that I were not among the men of the fifth generation, but either had died before or been born afterwards. For now truly is a race of iron, and men never rest from labour and sorrow by day, and from perishing by night; and the gods shall lay sore trouble upon them." + Source: Hesiod, Works and Days 174–178 (Evelyn-White translation, 1914). This is the one moment in the myth of the five races where the poet steps out from behind the story and speaks in his own voice, like a storyteller who stops mid-tale to sigh about his own day. "Born afterwards" is a striking phrase: Hesiod seems to hope for something after the iron age, though he never says what (T3).

(T4) Toil and evil came into the world from a woman’s jar, sent by Zeus to punish the theft of fire. + Hesiod tells the story twice, once in each poem, and it begins with a question every farmer asks at harvest: why does the ground make us work so hard for so little? Because, he says, the gods hid the means of life from men. Once a man could have worked a day and lived a year. But Prometheus, a Titan who took mankind’s side, tricked Zeus and stole fire for men, hiding it in a hollow fennel stalk. Zeus’s revenge was a gift. He had the craftsman god Hephaestus mould a beautiful woman out of earth and water, the other gods dressed and adorned her, and Hermes put in her "a shameless mind and a deceitful nature." Her name was Pandora, "all-gifts." She was sent to Prometheus’ slow-witted brother Epimetheus, who accepted her despite being warned never to take a gift from Zeus. She lifted the lid of a great jar (the "box" is a much later mistranslation), and out flew diseases, toil and sorrow, to wander the earth. Only Hope stayed inside, under the rim. The parallels with Genesis 3 are real, and Christian writers saw them: a good original state, a transgression, a woman, the beginning of labour and death. The differences are larger, and they are where the gospel parts company with him. In Hesiod the gods withhold, and evil is a weapon Zeus deliberately sends to punish a theft. Whether Hope trapped in the jar is a mercy kept for men or one more good denied them, readers have argued since antiquity.

(Q) "But the woman took off the great lid of the jar with her hands and scattered all these and her thought caused sorrow and mischief to men. Only Hope remained there in an unbreakable home within under the rim of the great jar, and did not fly out at the door." + Source: Hesiod, Works and Days 94–98 (Evelyn-White translation, 1914). Here is the moment the evils are let loose, and it happens in a single gesture, a hand lifting a lid. Evelyn-White’s "scattered all these" is his rendering as printed; the evils are the "ills and hard toil and heavy sickness" of lines 91–92 (T4).

(T5) The road to goodness is steep and runs through honest work, while wickedness is close at hand and easy. + Anyone who has learned to play an instrument knows the shape of this teaching. The first months are miserable; the scales are dull and the fingers will not obey. Then one day the music comes, and what was hard is suddenly easy. Hesiod says goodness is like that. Badness lives next door and the road to it is smooth. Goodness sits at the top of a long, rough climb, and the gods have put "the sweat of our brows" between us and it. For Hesiod the climb is mostly literal. The second half of the Works and Days is a farmer’s almanac, a calendar of jobs keyed to the sky and the seasons: when the Pleiades rise (the small, bright cluster of stars also called the Seven Sisters), start the harvest; plough when you hear the crane calling from the clouds; never cross a river without washing your hands and praying. Woven through it are proverbs that have outlived the farms they were meant for: "Work is no disgrace: it is idleness which is a disgrace" (Works and Days 311). The idle man, he says, is like the drone in the hive, eating what the bees have gathered. A Christian reader will hear Proverbs here, the sluggard told to go to the ant, and Paul’s rule that "If anyone is not willing to work, let him not eat" (2 Thessalonians 3:10). Hesiod’s respect for honest labour, and his contempt for living off another’s sweat, are among the things the church found it could simply keep.

(Q) "Badness can be got easily and in shoals: the road to her is smooth, and she lives very near us. But between us and Goodness the gods have placed the sweat of our brows: long and steep is the path that leads to her, and it is rough at the first; but when a man has reached the top, then is she easy to reach, though before that she was hard." + Source: Hesiod, Works and Days 287–292 (Evelyn-White translation, 1914). These are among the most quoted lines Hesiod ever wrote, and they travelled a long way. Plato cites them in the Republic, and Basil of Caesarea would set them before Christian students seven centuries later (T5).

(Q) "Shepherds of the wilderness, wretched things of shame, mere bellies, we know how to speak many false things as though they were true; but we know, when we will, to utter true things." + Source: Hesiod, Theogony 26–28 (Evelyn-White translation, 1914). These are the Muses’ first words to Hesiod on Helicon, spoken to a young shepherd before he has sung a note. The poet’s own sources warn him that what they say may be a lie dressed as truth, and every Christian who later read the Theogony had to decide which parts were which.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) The apologists read his Theogony as proof that the Greek gods were latecomers with no account of creation. + The apologists were the Christian writers of the second century who defended the faith to an educated pagan public, and when they wanted to show that the Greek gods could not be the true God, Hesiod did much of their work for them. Athenagoras of Athens, writing to the emperors Marcus Aurelius and Commodus around AD 177, quoted Herodotus to make the point that it was "Orpheus, and Homer, and Hesiod who gave both genealogies and names to those whom they call gods": the gods had a birthday, and a fairly recent one (A Plea for the Christians 17). Theophilus of Antioch went further. In his books To Autolycus, written around AD 180 to a pagan friend, he quoted the opening of Hesiod’s creation account at length and asked the obvious question. Hesiod "has not yet explained by whom all this was made," he wrote. If Chaos and matter were there in the beginning, who gave them order and shape? Zeus could not have done it; by Hesiod’s own account he was born long after the world (To Autolycus II.6). Theophilus noticed too that Hesiod begins with the earth and builds upward, as a man builds a house, while Moses begins with the heavens, because God "creates out of nothing, according to His will, the things that are made" (II.13). The Muses fared no better: how could they tell Hesiod about the birth of the world, Theophilus asked, when they were younger than it (II.5)? Theophilus was not simply contemptuous. He judged that the poets spoke from "a deceptive fancy," yet he granted that some of them at times "wakened up in soul" and said things "in harmony with the prophets regarding the monarchy of God, and the judgment" (II.8). By "monarchy" he meant the rule of one God alone, not a throne shared among many. He names no poet at that point, but Hesiod’s Zeus who watches over justice (T2) is the kind of line the description fits.

(†) Clement of Alexandria heard in some of his lines an echo of Israel’s prophets. + Clement of Alexandria, a Christian teacher in Egypt around AD 200, read the Greek poets with a collector’s eye for anything true. In the fifth book of his Stromata ("Miscellanies," a deliberately loose patchwork of a book) he gathered lines from Greek writers that seemed to him to agree with Scripture, arguing that the Greeks had borrowed their best ideas from the Hebrews. Hesiod supplied several. Clement quotes him calling Zeus "King and Lord" of all the immortals, with whom "none else in might may strive." And beside Isaiah’s question about the mind of God, which Paul repeats as "For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor?" (Romans 11:34), Clement sets a line from Hesiod: "No prophet, sprung of men that dwell on earth, Can know the mind of Ægis-bearing Zeus" (Stromata V.14, ANF translation). The aegis was the goatskin shield Zeus shakes in Homer to raise a storm, so "Ægis-bearing" is simply one of his titles, the way a king might be called "the crowned." Modern readers will doubt that Hesiod borrowed from Isaiah, who was very nearly his contemporary. But Clement’s instinct was the one Paul showed at Athens, when he quoted Greek poets to Greeks (Acts 17:28): wherever a pagan has said something true about God, a Christian may claim it.

(†) Basil of Caesarea set his steep road to virtue before Christian students as a lesson worth keeping. + In the fourth century, Christian boys still went to school on the pagan classics, and some Christians wondered whether they should. Basil of Caesarea, one of the great bishops of the Eastern church and a man who had himself studied rhetoric at Athens, wrote a short address to young men of his family, by tradition his nephews, on how to read Greek literature. His advice was to read like a bee, taking honey from the flowers and leaving the rest. His first example was Hesiod. "If not to incite youth to virtue," Basil asked, "pray what meaning may we suppose that Hesiod had in those universally admired lines," and he paraphrased the steep road to goodness (T5): "Rough is the start and hard, and the way steep, and full of labor and pain, that leads toward virtue" (Address to Young Men on Greek Literature V, Padelford translation). He opened the address with Hesiod too, quoting his saying that the best man works out his duty for himself and the next best follows good advice (Address I, from Works and Days 293–297). Through Basil’s little book, which was read and copied for over a thousand years, Hesiod’s farmer’s wisdom became part of how Christians thought about education: the pagan poet as a schoolmaster whose moral lessons could be kept, while his gods were left behind.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: gods born inside the world, a heaven that grudges, woman made as a curse, and work as a punishment. + Hesiod’s honesty about justice and work earned him a place in Christian schoolrooms. His account of the gods and of humanity’s troubles is another matter, and four points of his own teaching stand against what Scripture says. - Creation. Hesiod’s gods come out of Chaos and Earth, later than the world they rule, and nothing in the poem accounts for there being a world at all (T1). Scripture opens with a God who is before everything: "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth" (Genesis 1:1). That one sentence answers the question Theophilus said Hesiod never asked. - A heaven that grudges. In Hesiod, Zeus hides the means of life from men and answers a gift of fire with a calculated evil (T4). The God of Scripture gives freely: "Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights" (James 1:17). Paul told the Athenians that God is not served by human hands "as though he needed anything, since he himself gives to all mankind life and breath and everything" (Acts 17:25). - Woman. Hesiod says plainly that Zeus "made women to be an evil to mortal men, with a nature to do evil," and that from Pandora comes "the deadly race and tribe of women" (Theogony 590–602). Genesis has the woman made because "It is not good that the man should be alone," as "a helper fit for him" (Genesis 2:18), and when the fall comes, Scripture lays it at the man’s door as much as the woman’s: "sin came into the world through one man" (Romans 5:12). - Work. For Hesiod, toil is a punishment the gods inflicted because of stolen fire. In Genesis, work comes before the fall: "The Lord God took the man and put him in the garden of Eden to work it and keep it" (Genesis 2:15). The fall made work painful (Genesis 3:17–19); it did not invent it. Hesiod saw the world’s injustice clearly and believed heaven cared about it, and that is no small thing for a man who never heard of Moses. What he could not see was a God who stands outside the world as its maker and gives it good things without being asked.

Two complete poems survive under Hesiod’s name and are accepted as his by nearly all scholars: the Theogony and the Works and Days. A third complete poem, the Shield of Heracles, came down with them but was doubted already in antiquity. Everything else attributed to him in the ancient world survives only in fragments: quotations by later writers, and scraps of papyrus recovered from the sands of Egypt in the last century and a half. Antiquity credited him with a whole shelf of poems, most of which were clearly written by later poets working in his manner, the "Hesiodic school." Modern scholars agree on the two complete poems and argue about almost everything else, including which of those two came first; many now put the Theogony first. Accepted as genuine: - Theogony: About a thousand lines tracing the birth of the gods from Chaos and Earth through three generations of rulers, Heaven, Cronos and Zeus, with the war against the Titans, the monster Typhoeus, and the story of Prometheus and the first woman. It opens with the Muses meeting Hesiod on Helicon and warning him that they can lie (T1). - Works and Days: About eight hundred lines of advice addressed to his brother Perses: the two kinds of Strife, Prometheus and Pandora, the five races of men, the hawk and the nightingale, the blessings of justice, and a farmer’s calendar of ploughing, harvest and sailing, ending with a list of lucky and unlucky days of the month (T2, T3, T4, T5). The Boeotians who lived near Helicon in the second century AD told the traveller Pausanias that it was the only genuine work of Hesiod, and showed him an old copy written on lead. Transmitted with him but of doubted authorship: - Shield of Heracles: About 480 lines on the fight between Heracles and Cycnus, most of it an elaborate description of the hero’s shield in imitation of the shield of Achilles in the Iliad. Its first fifty-odd lines were taken from the Catalogue of Women, and ancient critics already doubted the rest was Hesiod’s. Lost or fragmentary works attributed to him in antiquity (most regarded today as later works of the Hesiodic school): - Catalogue of Women (also called the Ehoiai, from its refrain "or such as she..."): A genealogy of the heroic families of Greece told through the mortal women whom gods loved, continuing where the Theogony ends. Substantial papyrus fragments survive; M. L. West dated it to the sixth century BC, and others put it in the late seventh. - Great Ehoiai: A longer list of heroines on the same pattern, known only from quotations. - Melampodia: A poem in at least three books on famous seers, Melampus, Teiresias, Calchas and Mopsus. - Aegimius: A poem on the Dorian king Aegimius and the help Heracles gave him; ancient writers also credited it to Cercops of Miletus. - Wedding of Ceyx: An episode in which Heracles visits King Ceyx at Trachis; Plutarch called it an interpolation, a later poem slipped in among Hesiod’s works. - Precepts of Chiron: Moral and practical advice put in the mouth of the wise centaur Chiron, teacher of Achilles. - Great Works: Apparently a longer poem in the manner of the Works and Days; its subject matter is barely known. - Astronomy: On the rising and setting of the principal stars and the legends attached to them. - Divination by Birds: Once attached to the end of the Works and Days, until the scholar Apollonius of Rhodes rejected it. - Idaean Dactyls: On the legendary first workers of metal. - Dirge for Batrachus: A lament for a young man the Byzantine lexicon called the Suda names as Hesiod’s beloved; known only from the Suda’s list of his works, and nothing of it survives. - Descent of Peirithous into Hades, Wedding of Peleus and Thetis, and the Circuit of the Earth: Episodes known only by title and a handful of quotations. About him, not by him: - Contest of Homer and Hesiod: A prose work in its surviving form from the second century AD, drawing on older material, in which the two poets compete at the funeral games of Amphidamas and Hesiod wins the prize for a poet who calls men to farming and peace. Legend, not history. Standard English editions: Hugh G. Evelyn-White, Hesiod, the Homeric Hymns and Homerica (Loeb Classical Library, 1914), the translation quoted throughout and in the public domain. The Loeb Classical Library prints the Greek on one page and an English translation facing it, and its current Hesiod is Glenn W. Most, Hesiod, two volumes (Harvard, 2006–2007), which includes the testimonia, the ancient reports about his life gathered in one place. M. L. West’s commentaries on the Theogony (1966) and Works and Days (1978) are the standard scholarly works.

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief