Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
Thucydides of Athens c. 460 – c. 400 BC
(●) The Athenian general who lost a city, was exiled for it, and spent his exile writing the most exacting history the ancient world produced. Imagine two neighbors describing the same car accident. One saw it from the curb; the other heard about it at the coffee shop an hour later and has already improved the story. A good insurance adjuster does not simply believe whichever account arrives first. She sets the stories side by side, asks who was standing where, and notices which details only an eyewitness could know. Thucydides brought that adjuster’s habit to the whole of a war more rigorously than any writer before him. He matters on a Christian apologetics site for a reason he could never have guessed. When people ask whether the Gospels and Acts are reliable history, the honest way to answer is to measure them by the standards ancient historians set for themselves, and Thucydides set the highest of those standards. His History of the Peloponnesian War is the yardstick. If Luke, the physician and companion of Paul whom the early church named as the author of both the Gospel that bears his name and the book of Acts, is to be trusted, he must be trusted on terms a reader of Thucydides would recognize. His dates are approximate, worked out the way a detective works out an age from a few clues. He tells us he was old enough to follow events from the war’s first day in 431 BC and that he was a general in 424 BC, which by Athenian law put him at thirty or older; the conventional birth date of about 460 BC rests on those two facts, and the death date of about 400 BC rests on the fact that he lived to see Athens fall in 404 BC but never finished his book. The one signature fact to remember: the man who wrote the standard account of Athens’ great war wrote most of it as an exile, banished by his own city.
(●) c. 460 BC: Born to a wealthy Athenian family with gold mines and old ties to Thrace. Thucydides names his father once, when he tells of his own command in Thrace: Olorus (4.104). The name is not Greek but Thracian, from the wild, wooded country north of the Aegean, and it points to a family connection the ancient biographers made much of. Olorus was also the name of a Thracian king whose daughter married Miltiades, the victor of Marathon (the battle of 490 BC in which Athens turned back a Persian invasion), and Plutarch, the Greek biographer writing some five centuries later, reports that Thucydides was kin to Cimon, the son of Miltiades and the leading Athenian statesman of the 470s and 460s BC. The exact family tree is lost, but the link to Thrace is solid. So is the money. Thucydides tells us, in passing and in the third person, that he "possessed the right of working the gold mines" in that part of Thrace (4.105), and that this gave him great influence with the people who lived there. A boy from such a family grew up in Athens at the height of its power, in the years when Pericles was building the Parthenon on the Acropolis and Athens was turning a league of free allies into an empire that paid it tribute. He would spend his life explaining what that empire did to the city that built it.
(●) 431 BC: When war broke out between Athens and Sparta, he began writing its history at once. Most historians write about wars after they end. Thucydides started while the first armies were still marching. The opening sentence of his book says so: he began "at the moment that it broke out, and believing that it would be a great war and more worthy of relation than any that had preceded it" (1.1). The war he meant was a struggle between the two great powers of Greece. On one side stood Athens, a democracy with a navy, an empire of island and coastal cities, and the Long Walls, two parallel walls running some four miles down to the sea, so that a city under siege could still be fed by ship. On the other stood Sparta (the Greeks also called it Lacedaemon), a military society that ruled the southern peninsula of Greece, the Peloponnese, with an army no one could beat on land. Their allies are why the struggle is called the Peloponnesian War. It would last, with one treacherous interval of truce, for twenty-seven years. He was right that it would be great. He kept notes, questioned people who had been present, and wrote the war season by season, summer and winter, so that a reader could always tell what happened before what.
(●) 430 BC: Plague struck Athens, and he caught it and lived. In the first winter of the war Pericles, the leading man of Athens, gave the funeral speech for the year’s fallen, and Thucydides records it as a hymn to the city: Athens, Pericles says, is "the school of Hellas" (2.41), the city every other Greek city should learn from (Hellas was the Greeks’ own name for Greece). The very next thing in the book is the plague, and a reader feels the jolt, like turning from a proud family photograph to the news of its ruin. It came in the early summer of 430 BC, while the whole population of the countryside was packed inside the city walls to wait out the Spartan invasions, and it killed on a scale no one had seen. Thucydides refused to guess at its cause. Instead he did something unusual: he described the symptoms one by one, from the heat in the head and the red eyes down to the body’s extremities, so that it "may be recognized by the student, if it should ever break out again." He could do it, he says, "as I had the disease myself, and watched its operation in the case of others" (2.48). The description is so careful that doctors still argue over what the disease was: typhus, smallpox, measles, and typhoid fever have all been proposed. Pericles himself died in the epidemic’s aftermath the following year.
(●) 424 BC: As a general he arrived too late to save Amphipolis, and Athens banished him. In 424 BC Thucydides was one of Athens’ ten elected generals, posted to the coast of Thrace, where his family’s name carried weight. That winter the ablest Spartan commander of the war, Brasidas, marched north and made a sudden attack on Amphipolis, an Athenian colony on the river Strymon that supplied the navy with timber. Thucydides tells what happened next about himself, in the third person and without a word of self-defense. He was at the island of Thasos, half a day’s sail away, when the call for help came. He set out at once with seven ships. Brasidas, knowing that Thucydides was coming and that his influence in Thrace might stiffen the town, offered generous terms, and the town took them. Thucydides sailed into the harbor of Eion, the port at the river mouth, late the same day, just in time to save Eion and too late to save Amphipolis (4.104–106). Athens did not forgive him. He mentions his punishment only once, years later and almost in passing: "It was also my fate to be an exile from my country for twenty years after my command at Amphipolis" (5.26). Later ancient writers say he was condemned on the motion of Cleon, the most powerful politician in Athens after Pericles; Thucydides does not say so, though his portrait of Cleon is the harshest in the book.
(●) 424–404 BC: Twenty years of exile let him hear the war from both sides. Exile ended his career and made his book. A general at home in Athens would have heard the Athenian version of every battle. A banished Athenian with Thracian estates and money could travel among the enemy, and Thucydides says that is exactly what happened: "being present with both parties, and more especially with the Peloponnesians by reason of my exile, I had leisure to observe affairs somewhat particularly" (5.26). You can feel the difference as you read. His accounts of Spartan councils and Syracusan debates are as detailed as his accounts of the Athenian assembly, and the hero of his Thracian chapters, the man who cost him his career, is Brasidas, whom he describes with open admiration. Even the war’s length caught his eye. All through the war, he remembers, people said the oracles had fixed its length at three times nine years, and so it proved, twenty-seven years in all; he calls this an instance of "faith in oracles" being "for once justified by the event," and he adds that he lived through the whole of it, "being of an age to comprehend events, and giving my attention to them in order to know the exact truth about them" (5.26).
(●) c. 400 BC: He died after Athens fell, and his history stops in the middle of a sentence. Thucydides lived to see the end. In 404 BC Sparta took the Long Walls and the harbor of Piraeus, the lifeline that had fed the city all through the war, and dismantled the Athenian empire, and he mentions that ending as something he knew (5.26). The exile presumably ended too, since the peace terms brought exiles home. But the book never reached 404. It breaks off in the autumn of 411 BC, seven years short, in the middle of an episode: a Persian governor is on his way to the Hellespont, the narrow strait between Europe and Asia, and stops at Ephesus to sacrifice to the goddess Artemis, and there the text ends (8.109). It is like finding a letter on a desk with the pen still lying across the last line. The eighth book also has no speeches. Every earlier book is full of them, and they are where Thucydides does his most careful shaping, so their absence suggests a draft he never came back to revise. How he died is unknown, and the ancient traditions do not agree. Pausanias, the travel writer of the second century AD, reports that a decree was passed recalling Thucydides to Athens, that he was murdered on his way home, and that his tomb stood near the Melitid Gate; Plutarch reports that he was murdered at Scapte Hyle in Thrace, but that his remains were brought home and his monument stood among the tombs of Cimon’s family. What is certain is the unfinished manuscript, which within a generation other historians, Xenophon among them, set out to continue from the very point where it stops.
What He Taught
(T1) The truth about the past is found by testing witnesses against one another, not by believing the first story told. Every Athenian schoolboy knew who had freed the city from tyranny: Harmodius and Aristogiton, who stabbed the tyrant Hipparchus in 514 BC (a "tyrant," in Greek, was a man who held power outside the law, whether he ruled cruelly or not) and were honored with statues in the marketplace. Thucydides points out, twice (1.20 and 6.54–59), that the story is wrong. Hipparchus was not the tyrant; his elder brother Hippias was, and Hippias ruled for three more years and was driven out in the fourth (6.59). Most people, he says, take little trouble over "the investigation of truth, accepting readily the first story that comes to hand" (1.20). Against that habit he set a method. For the events of the war he did not trust any single account, not even his own memory. Instead he compared what he saw with what others saw for him and tested every report as severely as he could. He admits the job was hard, because eyewitnesses disagree, "sometimes from imperfect memory, sometimes from undue partiality for one side or the other" (1.22). That last observation is an early form of what historians now call source criticism: the discipline of asking, of every witness, how they could know and what they might want you to believe. He was equally candid about the speeches, which fill a quarter of his book. No one could carry a speech home word for word, he says, so he wrote what each speaker needed to say on the occasion, "adhering as closely as possible to the general sense of what they really said" (1.22). Here is a historian telling his readers exactly how much to trust each kind of material he gives them, and that candor is part of why he is trusted.
(Q) "And with reference to the narrative of events, far from permitting myself to derive it from the first source that came to hand, I did not even trust my own impressions, but it rests partly on what I saw myself, partly on what others saw for me, the accuracy of the report being always tried by the most severe and detailed tests possible." Source: Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War 1.22 (Crawley translation). The passage comes in his statement of method near the end of the first book’s opening survey, directly after he has said how he handled the speeches.
(T2) Human nature does not change, so an exact record of the past is a guide to the future. A doctor who keeps careful notes on one epidemic is not only writing about the past. When the same fever turns up again in twenty years, those notes will tell the next doctor what is coming. Thucydides thought of his whole history that way, which is why he wrote up the plague’s symptoms for a future "student" (2.48). The reason he gives is human nature, which he holds to be constant. People in the same situations, under the same fears and the same temptations, will act in much the same ways, so that the future, "in the course of human things," must "resemble if it does not reflect" the past (1.22). He says the same thing about the horrors of civil war: they "have occurred and always will occur, as long as the nature of mankind remains the same" (3.82). A precise record of one war is therefore a lesson for every war. That is why he refused to entertain. He knew that a book without legends and marvels would be less fun to read, the way a field guide to mushrooms is less fun than a fairy tale about them, and he accepted the cost. He was writing, he said, not to win a prize at a public recitation but for every later reader who wanted to understand. A Christian reader will hear in his steady view of human nature something close to what Scripture says about the human heart, though Thucydides drew from it no hope of a remedy.
(Q) "If it be judged useful by those inquirers who desire an exact knowledge of the past as an aid to the interpretation of the future, which in the course of human things must resemble if it does not reflect it, I shall be content. In fine, I have written my work, not as an essay which is to win the applause of the moment, but as a possession for all time." Source: Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War 1.22 (Crawley translation). The closing lines of his statement of method. "A possession for all time" is the most quoted phrase he wrote, and it is the claim the last twenty-four centuries have granted him.
(T3) Wars are driven by power and fear, whatever reasons the speeches give. Two children fighting over a toy will each tell you the other one grabbed first. A wise parent listens, and then notices that the real trouble started when the younger one got bigger. Thucydides read the outbreak of war the same way. Both sides published grievances: a quarrel over the island of Corcyra off the western coast, a siege at Potidaea in the north, a trade ban against Megara, Athens’ small neighbor. He records them all carefully. Then he gives his own verdict: "The real cause I consider to be the one which was formally most kept out of sight. The growth of the power of Athens, and the alarm which this inspired in Lacedaemon, made war inevitable" (1.23). This distinction, between the occasions people announce and the deeper cause they keep quiet, is one of the lasting tools of political thought. His most chilling scene shows power with the mask off. In 416 BC Athens demanded that Melos, a small island that wanted to stay neutral, submit to the empire. Thucydides writes the negotiation as a dialogue. The Melians appeal to justice, to the gods, and to hope; the Athenian envoys answer that justice is only a question between equals in power, and that the gods themselves, like men, "rule wherever they can" (5.105). Melos refused. Athens took it, killed the men, and enslaved the women and children (5.116). These are the Athenians’ words, not Thucydides’ verdict, and he does not comment. But he lets the arrangement speak: the very next chapters of his book tell how Athens, swollen with the same confidence, sailed against Sicily and met the greatest disaster of the war.
(Q) "You know as well as we do that right, as the world goes, is only in question between equals in power, while the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must." Source: Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War 5.89 (Crawley translation). Spoken by the Athenian envoys to the council of Melos. It is among the most famous statements in ancient literature of the view that power, not justice, governs the dealings of nations, and Thucydides puts it in the mouth of his own city.
(T4) Under plague and civil war, a people’s morals collapse, and even their words change meaning. Most of us behave well partly because life is orderly: there is food on the table, a court down the road, and a future to protect. Thucydides watched what happens when that order is taken away, and he wrote it down twice. The first time was the plague. People who expected to die tomorrow stopped caring about honor and spent what they had on pleasure. "Fear of gods or law of man there was none to restrain them," he writes: they saw the pious and the impious dying alike, and no one expected to live long enough to be tried for a crime (2.53). The second time was civil war, called stasis in Greek, the faction-fighting inside a city between the party that wanted Athens and the party that wanted Sparta. On the island of Corcyra in 427 BC it turned neighbors into murderers, and Thucydides saw something deeper than the killing. To excuse what they were doing, people had to rename it. Recklessness became courage; caution became cowardice; moderation became weakness. War, he says, "proves a rough master, that brings most men’s characters to a level with their fortunes" (3.82). He noticed, too, that members of the factions trusted one another not because of any religious sanction, the fear of breaking the gods’ law, but because they were partners in crime, the way two thieves keep faith only because each could hang the other.
(Q) "Words had to change their ordinary meaning and to take that which was now given them. Reckless audacity came to be considered the courage of a loyal ally; prudent hesitation, specious cowardice; moderation was held to be a cloak for unmanliness." Source: Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War 3.82 (Crawley translation). From his reflection on the civil war at Corcyra, one of the few places where he steps out of the narrative to speak in his own voice at length.
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Luke wrote his Gospel and Acts in the tradition of careful history that Thucydides founded. Thucydides never heard of Israel, and the New Testament never names him. But by the first century his way of writing history had become the ideal every serious Greek historian claimed. Lucian of Samosata, a pagan satirist of the second century AD, wrote a handbook called How to Write History that holds Thucydides up as the model and repeats his phrase about "a possession for all time." Luke opens his Gospel with a preface in exactly that tradition. Many have written already, he says; his account rests on those "who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word," and he has "followed all things closely for some time past" in order to write "an orderly account," so that his reader "may have certainty" (Luke 1:1–4). The word behind "closely" is akribōs, "accurately," from the same family as the akribeia, the exactness, that Thucydides claimed for his own research (1.22). Christian scholars have taken that resemblance seriously, because it tells us what kind of book Luke meant to write: not legend, but history as the Greeks understood the word. The classicist and New Testament scholar Colin Hemer, in The Book of Acts in the Setting of Hellenistic History (1989), judged Luke by the standards of the Greek historians, weighing the speeches in Acts in the light of Thucydides’ stated principle of keeping to "the general sense of what they really said," and tested hundreds of Luke’s details of places, titles, and officials against the inscriptions and coins.
(†) Apologists use him as the benchmark: the Gospels are judged by the standard that makes Thucydides trusted. No one doubts that Thucydides is a reliable source for the Peloponnesian War, and that confidence makes him a useful measuring stick. F. F. Bruce, the British New Testament scholar, put the comparison memorably in The New Testament Documents: Are They Reliable? (first published in 1943 as Are the New Testament Documents Reliable?): by his count Thucydides’ history was known from eight manuscripts, the earliest from about AD 900, plus a few papyrus scraps from around the beginning of the Christian era, yet no classicist doubts the text. The New Testament, by comparison, survives in thousands of manuscripts, some within a few generations of the originals. The comparison works on more than manuscripts. Thucydides wrote about events he lived through, drew on eyewitnesses, and was writing within a generation of what he described; those are the marks that make him credible, and the case for the Gospels rests on the same marks. A reader who trusts Thucydides on the plague of Athens has already granted the principles that make Luke worth hearing on the empty tomb. The detailed case for the Gospels takes arguments of its own, but the yardstick is his.
(†) Christian Byzantium copied him, taught him, and wrote its own histories in his style. Every medieval manuscript of Thucydides we have was copied by Christian scribes, and the oldest and most important were made in the Byzantine world, the Greek-speaking Christian empire centered on Constantinople. Monks and scholars kept his difficult Greek alive for a thousand years, wrote notes on it, and taught it in their schools. They also imitated him. Procopius of Caesarea, the historian of the emperor Justinian’s wars in the sixth century AD, opens his Wars in deliberate echo of Thucydides’ first sentence, and when the plague struck Constantinople in AD 542 he described it on the model of Thucydides’ account of the plague of Athens. For centuries, to write history well in Greek meant to write like Thucydides. When he reached Western Europe in the Renaissance, he came in manuscripts that Christian copyists had preserved.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: history has a Lord, and human nature has a cure. Thucydides deliberately wrote the gods out of history. He explains events by human nature, by power and fear, and by chance, and where his contemporaries saw oracles fulfilled he saw people bending their memories. When the plague struck, the Athenians recalled an old verse foretelling a war that would bring "death"; some remembered the word as "dearth," and Thucydides remarks dryly that "the people made their recollection fit in with their sufferings" (2.54). He was right to be suspicious of convenient prophecies. But Christians part company with him at two points. - Providence. For Thucydides, nothing stands above the struggle of powers except chance and the constant pattern of human nature. Scripture says that history has a Lord: God "removes kings and sets up kings" (Daniel 2:21), and he "made from one man every nation of mankind," "having determined allotted periods and the boundaries of their dwelling place" (Acts 17:26). Paul said that last sentence in Athens itself, to Athenians. - The remedy. Thucydides saw human nature clearly, and what he saw was a disease that would recur "as long as the nature of mankind remains the same" (3.82). He offers no cure, only the hope that a reader forewarned will act more wisely. The gospel agrees with his diagnosis and denies that it is the last word: the nature that does not change by its own power can be made new (2 Corinthians 5:17). He remains the honest witness of what human beings do when power answers to nothing above it, and that is why Christians have kept reading him.