Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
Empedocles of Acragas c. 494 – c. 434 BC
(●) The Sicilian poet-philosopher who taught that the world is four elements forever joined by Love and torn apart by Strife. Ask a schoolchild in the Middle Ages what the world is made of and the answer would have come back without hesitation: earth, water, air, and fire. That answer, which held for some two thousand years, goes back to one man. Empedocles of Acragas, a Greek city on the southern coast of Sicily, was the first to say that everything is built from four unchanging "roots," and that two powers he called Love and Strife move them, one drawing things together and the other driving them apart. He was a strange and magnificent figure, several men in one: a democratic politician who, by one ancient report, refused a crown; a physician; a teacher of public speaking; and a wandering holy man who told the crowds that followed him that he was an immortal god. He has earned his place among the thinkers a Christian should know, for three reasons. For one thing, he held, against the poets, that nothing comes from nothing. For another, Aristotle thought him perhaps the first Greek to make good and evil the two great powers behind the world, and the church fathers saw in that a rival to the doctrine of one good Creator. And his teaching that fallen souls pass through body after body, even into bushes and fish, is the doctrine Tertullian and the church spent real effort answering. His dates are conventional, which is a polite way of saying no one wrote them down. Ancient chronographers (scholars who built timelines of the Greek past by fitting together the few dates they had) fixed his prime, the age of about forty, at 444 BC, and Aristotle is reported to have said he died at sixty. Most scholars think that reckoning runs some years too late, so the dates used for him, c. 494 to c. 434 BC, put his birth about a decade earlier, and they could be off by a decade either way. And one fact tends to stick. Of a man whose two great poems once ran to some five thousand lines, we have only about five hundred. We know him the way we know most early Greek thinkers, through fragments: lines that survive only because a later writer happened to quote them, the way a lost letter might survive in the bits a friend copied into a diary. The German scholar Hermann Diels gathered and numbered these fragments early in the twentieth century, and scholars still cite them by his numbers ("fragment 8," "fragment 117"). Then, in the 1990s, scholars recognized new lines of his poem on scraps of papyrus that had sat unread in a library in Strasbourg for most of a century.
(●) c. 494 BC: Born into a rich and famous family in Acragas, a boom town of temples on the Sicilian coast. Acragas (the Romans called it Agrigentum, and today it is Agrigento) was one of the wealthiest cities in the Greek world. Its citizens built a ridge of great Doric temples (the plain, heavy-columned style of the Parthenon in Athens) that still stand above the sea, and the Greek poet Pindar called it the most beautiful city of mortals. Empedocles was born into its upper class. His father, by the best ancient accounts, was named Meton, and his grandfather, also called Empedocles, had won the horse race at the Olympic Games in 496 BC, which in that world was a little like having a grandfather who owned the winner of the Kentucky Derby. No one recorded the year of his birth. It is reckoned backward: his grandfather was alive and racing horses around 496, the chronographer Apollodorus set his prime at 444, and his pupil Gorgias was born around 483. A birth in the mid-490s BC fits all three, and "c. 494" is the convention, not a record. He grew up under a tyrant. In Greek the word did not necessarily mean a cruel ruler, only one who had seized power outside the law, and Theron was a strongman who held the city and, with the ruler of Syracuse, threw back a Carthaginian invasion at Himera in 480 BC. The spoils of that victory paid for many of the temples.
(●) After 472 BC: When the tyrants fell he became the people’s champion, and by one report turned down a crown. Theron died in 472 BC. His son Thrasydaeus proved cruel and reckless, lost a war with Syracuse, and was driven out, and Acragas became a free city. In the politics that followed, Empedocles took the side of the common people against the rich families who wanted power back. The stories about this period come mostly from Timaeus, a Sicilian historian writing some 150 years later, and they read like the stories a town tells about its local hero. In one, Empedocles was invited to a dinner where the host kept the wine back until an official of the council arrived; the official was made master of the feast and began ordering the guests to drink or have the wine poured over their heads. Empedocles said nothing that night, and the next day prosecuted both men as would-be tyrants. Another story says he broke up an association called the Thousand. Aristotle, as Diogenes Laertius reports him, called Empedocles a lover of freedom who disliked every kind of rule, and the historian Xanthus told how he was offered the kingship of Acragas and refused it, because he loved a plain life. For a man who would later call himself a god, refusing a throne is an interesting choice, and his ancient biographers noticed the tension.
(●) c. 460s BC: He answered Parmenides in a long poem on nature, written in verse for a young friend named Pausanias. A generation earlier, Parmenides of Elea had argued that change is impossible: what is cannot come from what is not, and so the moving, many-colored world of the senses must be an illusion. That conclusion left every Greek thinker after him with a problem, rather like being told by a brilliant mathematician that your car cannot possibly be moving while you are driving it down the road. Empedocles took the problem seriously. Ancient writers called him a follower and imitator of Parmenides, and one report made him a fellow student of Zeno (Parmenides’ pupil, famous for his paradoxes "proving" that a runner can never finish a race) under Parmenides himself. His solution was to keep Parmenides’ rule (nothing real comes into being or perishes) and to give up only one assumption, that there is one ultimate thing. If there are several unchanging stuffs, then mixing and unmixing them can produce all the change we see without anything ever coming from nothing (T1, T2). He wrote it all in hexameter verse, the long rolling line of Homer, and addressed the poem to his student Pausanias. Aristotle could say that Empedocles and Homer had nothing in common but the meter; elsewhere he called him "Homeric." The Roman poet Lucretius, four centuries later, admired him so much that he wrote his own philosophy of nature in verse in imitation.
(●) c. 450s BC: Physician, teacher of speech, and wonder-worker, he went among the cities in garlands claiming to be an immortal god. Empedocles was also a healer. The physician Galen, writing in the second century AD, counted him among the founders of the medical school of Sicily and southern Italy, a rival to the famous schools of Cos (the home of Hippocrates) and Cnidus. Aristotle called him the inventor of rhetoric, the art of persuasive speech, and Gorgias, who would later dazzle Athens with his oratory, was remembered as his pupil. His second great poem, the Purifications, shows another side of him. It opens with a greeting to his fellow citizens of Acragas: "I go about among you an immortal god, no mortal now," he says, crowned with ribbons and garlands, followed by crowds asking for oracles and for "the word of healing" (fragment 112, Burnet translation). Legends gathered around him, many of them probably spun out of his own boasts. He was said to have stopped the summer winds that withered the crops by hanging bags of donkey hide to catch them, which earned him the nickname "Wind-Stopper"; to have kept a woman alive who had lain without breath or pulse for thirty days; and to have cleared a fever-ridden marsh at Selinus, a Greek city on Sicily’s southwest coast, by diverting two rivers through it. These are traditions, not records, and the scholar John Burnet thought most of them were simply inferences from lines in his poems.
(●) c. 444 BC: His enemies barred him from Acragas, and he spent his last years an exile in Italy and the Peloponnese. Popular leaders in Greek cities often ended up on the wrong side of a vote, and Empedocles did too. It is an old story: the man the crowd carries on its shoulders one year is the man it forgets the next. The old families he had opposed regained ground, and when he went abroad they saw to it that he could not come back. Timaeus was emphatic that he never saw Sicily again. His last years were spent among the Greek cities of southern Italy and in the Peloponnese, the great southern peninsula of mainland Greece. One ancient report, from a writer named Glaucus of Rhegium, who lived close to his time, says he visited the new Athenian colony of Thurii in southern Italy shortly after its founding in 444/443 BC; the chronographers used that visit to date his whole life. Another says his Purifications was recited at the Olympic Games by a professional reciter named Cleomenes. An exile who has his poem performed before the assembled Greek world is not a man who has gone quiet.
(●) c. 434 BC: He died abroad at about sixty, and legend said he leapt into the crater of Etna to prove he was a god. No one knows how Empedocles died. Aristotle is reported to have said he died at sixty, and Timaeus said he went away to the Peloponnese and never came back, so it happened somewhere far from Sicily. But the stories that survived were much grander than that. His admirers said that after a sacrifice, one night, he simply vanished, taken up to the gods. His detractors told the version everyone remembers: that he threw himself into the crater of Mount Etna so that people would think he had been taken up, and that the volcano gave him away by throwing back one of his bronze sandals. Burnet thought the Etna tale a malicious parody of the first story, and noted that it is always told with a hostile purpose. Neither has any good evidence behind it. Timaeus took the trouble to refute both. What lasted was the poetry. Plato and Aristotle argued with him, Lucretius praised him as the glory of Sicily, and the church fathers quoted his lines, sometimes with approval and sometimes with a smile.
What He Taught
(T1) Nothing comes from nothing, and nothing real perishes; birth and death are only mixing and unmixing. Think of a cake. Flour, eggs, sugar and butter go into the bowl, and something that was not there before comes out of the oven. But nothing has been created from scratch: the ingredients have only been combined. Leave the cake out long enough and it will fall apart into crumbs and mould, and still nothing has been annihilated. Empedocles thought the whole world works like that. He accepted Parmenides’ great rule, that being cannot arise from what in no way is, and turned it against the ordinary way of talking. When people say a man or a plant "comes into being" or "dies," they mean only that some elements have been mixed in a certain pattern or have come apart again. "Coming into being" is a name people use, he said, and he admitted with a shrug that he followed the custom too. Christian thinkers would agree with half of this and deny the other half. The principle that nothing comes from nothing, ex nihilo nihil fit as the Latin tag puts it, is one the cosmological arguments still rely on. (A cosmological argument reasons from the fact that the universe exists to a cause beyond it.) The thought is plain common sense: a thing does not pop into existence with no cause at all, any more than a grand piano appears in an empty room overnight with no one to bring it in. But Empedocles drew the wrong conclusion from it. If nothing comes from nothing, he reasoned, then the stuff of the world must have been there forever. Scripture says instead that the world was made by a God who did not need any stuff to start with: "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth" (Genesis 1:1). Nothing comes from nothing, but the world did not come from nothing; it came from God.
(Q) "There is no coming into being of aught that perishes, nor any end for it in baneful death; but only mingling and change of what has been mingled. Coming into being is but a name given to these by men." Source: Empedocles, fragment 8 in the standard Diels numbering, preserved by Plutarch and Aetius (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). "Aught" is old English for "anything." Empedocles is speaking to Pausanias, and the next fragment admits that he too goes on saying "birth" and "death" because everyone does.
(T2) Everything is built from four eternal roots: fire, air, water, and earth. A painter, Empedocles said, can make trees and men and beasts and birds from a handful of colors, simply by mixing them in different proportions. The world is the same. Four basic stuffs, in different ratios, make up everything there is. Bone, he suggested, is a fixed recipe of so many parts earth, water and fire. He did not call them elements; that word came later. He called them "roots," and he gave them the names of gods: shining Zeus, life-bringing Hera, Aidoneus (another name for Hades), and Nestis, a Sicilian water goddess. Ancient readers already argued over which god stood for which root. Water is clearly Nestis; the rest are disputed. The four elements held the field for two thousand years. Aristotle took them over, the physicians built the theory of the four humors on them (the idea that health is a balance of four bodily fluids, blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile, which is why we still call a gloomy person "melancholy," from the Greek for black bile), and medieval Christian writers from Isidore of Seville to the cathedral schools taught them as plain physics. They gave way only when the chemistry of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries showed that water and air are themselves compounds. Even so, Empedocles’ basic idea, that the visible variety of things comes from a small number of unchanging ingredients combined in different ratios, is the ancestor of every periodic table since.
(Q) "Hear first the four roots of all things: shining Zeus, life-bringing Hera, Aidoneus, and Nestis whose tear-drops are a well-spring to mortals." Source: Empedocles, fragment 6 in the standard Diels numbering, preserved by Aetius and others (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). The line opens the doctrine of the elements in the poem on nature. Clement of Alexandria quotes a version of it in his Miscellanies (Stromata VI.2), naming the roots plainly as fire, water, earth and air.
(T3) Two eternal powers, Love and Strife, take turns uniting the world into one and tearing it into many. Four ingredients, of course, do not bake themselves. Something has to stir the bowl, and Empedocles named two movers to do it. Love (he also called her Aphrodite and Joy) pulls unlike things together; Strife drives them apart. He saw Love at work in the ordinary attraction of one person to another, "she that makes them have thoughts of love and work the works of peace," and Strife in every quarrel, every war, every body that falls apart at death. The two take turns in a vast cycle. At one extreme Love wins completely, and all four roots are fused into a single perfect ball he called the Sphere, a god "rejoicing in his circular solitude." Then Strife creeps back in, the Sphere breaks up, and a world like ours, with separate seas and skies and living things, comes to be in the struggle between the two. At the other extreme Strife wins and everything lies sorted and apart. Then Love begins again. The cycle never ends and has no beginning. Aristotle noticed something new here: Empedocles was, he said, the first to make the good and the bad causes of the world, with Love the cause of good things and Strife of bad. Christian readers notice it too, and part company at once. Scripture says love is not a force alongside God but who God is: "God is love" (1 John 4:8). And evil is not God’s eternal equal, taking its turn at running the world. It is a rebellion inside a creation God made good, and it has an end.
(Q) "And these things never cease continually changing places, at one time all uniting in one through Love, at another each borne in different directions by the repulsion of Strife." Source: Empedocles, fragment 17, lines 6–8 in the standard Diels numbering, preserved by Simplicius, Commentary on Aristotle’s Physics (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). The longest surviving passage of the poem on nature, which Empedocles calls his "twofold tale": one world grows out of many things, and many things grow out of one, over and over.
(T4) Living things first arose as random limbs and monsters, and only the combinations that fit together survived. How did the elements, tumbling in the contest of Love and Strife, ever produce something as well-made as an eye or a hand? Empedocles gave an answer that sounds like a nightmare. At first, he said, separate parts sprang from the earth on their own: heads without necks, arms without shoulders, eyes without foreheads. As Love drew them together they joined as chance would have it, making oxen with the faces of men and men with the heads of oxen. Most of these monsters could not eat or breed and died out. The ones that happened to fit together lived on. Aristotle took this seriously enough to answer it. In his Physics (II.8, in the Hardie and Gaye translation) he states the view at full strength, that things which merely happened to be put together usefully "survived," while those that grew otherwise "perished and continue to perish, as Empedocles says his ‘man-faced ox-progeny’ did." Then he rejects it: what happens by chance happens rarely, and the fitness of living things comes about always or for the most part, so nature works toward ends. That reply, carried through the medieval theologian Thomas Aquinas, is the ancestor of the design argument’s appeal to purpose in nature. (The design argument is the case that the order and fitness we find in living things, an eye built for seeing, a wing built for flying, point to a mind behind them.) Charles Darwin, centuries later, quoted Aristotle’s passage in a note he added in 1866 to the historical sketch at the front of On the Origin of Species, as the principle of natural selection "shadowed forth." Empedocles did not think of the survivors as becoming something new over long ages, and he set his monsters inside a cosmic cycle of gods and elements. But the question he raised, whether chance plus survival can stand in for design, is the question still argued between the design argument and its critics.
(Q) "On it (the earth) many heads sprung up without necks and arms wandered bare and bereft of shoulders. Eyes strayed up and down in want of foreheads." Source: Empedocles, fragment 57 in the standard Diels numbering, preserved by Aristotle and Simplicius (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). The first stage of his account of how animals arose; fragment 61 goes on to the "offspring of oxen with faces of men."
(T5) The soul is a fallen divine spirit, exiled through many bodies for the sin of bloodshed, and freed only by purity. The Purifications tells a story of a fall. Certain divine beings, which Empedocles calls daimons (spirits with "length of days"), once lived in bliss. When one of them stains its hands with blood or swears falsely, an ancient decree of Necessity (the impersonal fate that, in Greek thought, even the gods could not overrule) sends it into exile for "thrice ten thousand years," to be born again and again in every kind of mortal body, tossed from air to sea to earth to sun with nowhere to rest. Empedocles says he is one of them, "an exile and a wanderer from the gods," and remembers having been a boy, a girl, a bush, a bird, and a fish. This is transmigration of souls, also called reincarnation: the belief that a soul passes after death into a new body, animal or even plant. It came to him from the Pythagoreans, the followers of the mathematician and mystic Pythagoras, and from the Orphic religious movement, named for the legendary singer Orpheus, which taught rites of purification to free the soul from the cycle of bodies. And it gave his ethics its sharp edge. If the animal on the altar might be your own son in a changed form, then sacrifice and meat-eating are murder and cannibalism, and he begged his hearers to stop "this ill-sounding slaughter." He also forbade laurel leaves and, most famously, beans. The way home was purity: abstinence, cleansing, and wisdom, until the exile rose at last through the highest human lives, prophets, poets, physicians and princes, to sit again among the gods. Christians recognize the shape of the story, a good beginning, a fall, an exile, a longing for home, and that is part of why it moved them. But they could not accept its contents: one life and then judgment rather than a wheel of lives, and a way home that is a gift rather than an achievement.
(Q) "For I have been ere now a boy and a girl, a bush and a bird and a dumb fish in the sea." Source: Empedocles, fragment 117 in the standard Diels numbering, from the Purifications, preserved by Diogenes Laertius, Hippolytus, and Clement of Alexandria (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). "Dumb" means mute. It was this line that Tertullian picked up to mock in his On the Soul (†).
(Q) "For he is not furnished with a human head on his body, two branches do not sprout from his shoulders, he has no feet, no swift knees, nor hairy parts; but he is only a sacred and unutterable mind flashing through the whole world with rapid thoughts." Source: Empedocles, fragment 134 in the standard Diels numbering, preserved by Ammonius, Commentary on Aristotle’s On Interpretation (Burnet translation, Early Greek Philosophy, 2nd ed., 1908). Ammonius says the lines were spoken chiefly of Apollo, and of the divine in general. Like Xenophanes before him (the poet-philosopher who had mocked the Greeks for picturing their gods with human bodies), Empedocles here strips God of the human body the poets had given him, and describes him as pure mind. It comes as near as any pagan line to what Jesus told the woman at the well, "God is spirit" (John 4:24).
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Clement of Alexandria quoted him as a pagan who had glimpsed that happiness lies in knowing God. Clement of Alexandria, a Christian teacher in Egypt around AD 200, read the Greek poets the way a man reads letters from distant relatives, looking for family resemblances. In his Miscellanies (the Stromata) he quotes Empedocles more than a dozen times. He cites the line "Happy is he who possesses the wealth of the divine mind," with its sequel, "But wretched he, who cares for dark opinion about the Gods," as a pagan who drew the boundary between happiness and misery exactly where it belongs, at the knowledge of God (Stromata V.14). He borrows Empedocles’ saying that instruction makes the mind grow to say that trust in the Lord makes faith grow (Stromata V.13), and quotes his line about the souls of the wise rising at last as "prophets, minstrels, and physicians" when describing the Christian made like God (Stromata IV.23). Clement was clear about the limit. The philosophers, he wrote, name God without knowing him, and their insight is like sunlight through a glass of water, a spark caught from a greater source (Stromata VI.17). That is the church’s steady reading of Empedocles: a mind that saw, through general revelation (the knowledge of God open to everyone through creation and conscience), that God is not a man with a body and that a soul is made for more than this world, and could not see further without help.
(†) Tertullian and Hippolytus answered his two great teachings, the wheel of rebirth and the two powers behind the world. Tertullian of Carthage, writing On the Soul around AD 210, gave a full chapter to Empedocles’ transmigration (chapter 32). He opens with a joke: a man who said "I once was Thamnus, and a fish" should rather have said a melon, "seeing that he was such a fool." Thamnos is simply the Greek word for a bush, so Tertullian is teasing the line in which Empedocles remembers being a shrub (T5): a man silly enough to recall life as a bush might as well have recalled life as a melon. Then, having had his laugh, he argues the point seriously. A human soul fitted to a human body could not shrink into a gnat or stretch to fill an elephant, and if it were really changed into a beast it would no longer be the same soul, so nothing would have been "reincarnated" at all. Scripture compares men to beasts in character, he says, not in substance. Hippolytus of Rome, writing in the same generation, came at Empedocles from another angle. In his Refutation of All Heresies (Book VII) he took Love and Strife seriously as a theology. He summarized Empedocles’ system at length, preserving many of the fragments in the process, and observed that it makes Strife, a raging and unstable power, the maker of the world we live in, with Love as the good power that gathers souls home. Then he turned the comparison on the Marcionites, who taught two rival gods, one good and one the hostile maker of the world. Neither Paul nor Mark taught any such thing, Hippolytus argued; the scheme came from Empedocles of Acragas, and its rules against meat and marriage were his purifications carried into the church.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: one Creator, one life, and salvation as a gift, received by men who are not gods. Empedocles taught these things himself, in his own verses, and at each point Scripture says otherwise. - Two eternal powers. He made Love and Strife co-eternal, each taking its turn at ruling. Scripture knows one God, who made all things and called them good, and evil as a later rebellion within that good creation, not its equal partner (Genesis 1:1; 1 John 4:8). - An eternal cycle. He taught a world forever forming and dissolving with no beginning and no goal. Scripture teaches a world made by the word of God, "so that what is seen was not made out of things that are visible" (Hebrews 11:3), moving toward a new creation rather than another turn of the wheel (Revelation 21:5). - Many lives. He taught that the soul passes through body after body, even into plants and fish. Scripture answers plainly: "it is appointed for man to die once, and after that comes judgment" (Hebrews 9:27). - Saved by purity. His way home was abstinence and cleansing, earned over thirty thousand years. The gospel’s way home is a gift: "For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast" (Ephesians 2:8–9). His ban on meat and beans meets Paul’s "everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with thanksgiving" (1 Timothy 4:4). - A man who called himself a god. He walked among the crowds in garlands as "an immortal god, no mortal now." When the people of Lystra tried to sacrifice to Paul and Barnabas, the apostles tore their clothes and rushed into the crowd: "We also are men, of like nature with you, and we bring you good news, that you should turn from these vain things to a living God" (Acts 14:15). Empedocles saw that the world is not as it should be, that the soul is homesick, and that God is not a man with arms and legs. Those are not small things to have seen. What he could not see was a God who comes down to the exile instead of waiting for the exile to purify himself back up.