Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Akhenaten of Egypt r. c. 1353 – 1336 BC
(●) The pharaoh who tried to make Egypt worship one god, the sun’s disk, and whose revolution died with him. For about seventeen years, in the fourteenth century before Christ, one of the richest kingdoms on earth was ruled by a man who believed that the countless gods of Egypt should give way to one. He called that god the Aten, the shining disk of the sun, and he built it a city in the desert, wrote or commissioned hymns to it, and sent stonecutters up and down the Nile to chisel the name of the old chief god, Amun, off the temple walls. Within a few years of his death the city was empty, the old gods were back, and before long his own name was being hacked out in its turn. Christian readers meet him for one reason above the rest. Since the early twentieth century he has been put forward, most famously by Sigmund Freud, the Viennese founder of psychoanalysis, as the real source of Israel’s faith in one God: Moses, the theory runs, learned monotheism (belief that only one god exists) in Akhenaten’s Egypt. His Great Hymn to the Aten also reads so like Psalm 104 that the two have been printed side by side for more than a century. A reader who meets those claims deserves to know who the man actually was and what he actually taught. A word about the dates, because they are softer than they look. Egyptians did not count years from a fixed starting point the way we count from the birth of Christ. They counted regnal years instead: year 1, year 2, and so on, starting over each time a new king took the throne, rather as a school counts "first grade, second grade" without saying which calendar year it is. Fixing a king’s year 1 on our calendar therefore depends on long chains of reckoning that specialists still adjust. The most common figures put his reign at c. 1353 to 1336 BC; other standard chronologies shift it a few years either way. Every date in his story is "about," and is counted from that convention.
(●) Before c. 1353 BC: A younger son of Amenhotep III and Queen Tiye, he became heir when his elder brother died. He was born Amenhotep, "Amun is content," a name that honored the very god he would later try to erase. His year of birth is unknown. His father, Amenhotep III, ruled Egypt for nearly four decades at the height of its wealth and power, and his mother, Tiye, was a commoner by birth (the daughter of a provincial official named Yuya and his wife Thuya) who became one of the most influential queens Egypt ever had. He was not meant to be king. The crown prince was his elder brother Thutmose, who held a high priestly office at Memphis, Egypt’s ancient northern capital, and whose name survives on a few monuments, including a small stone coffin he had made for his pet cat. Thutmose died young, and the younger brother stepped into his place. The Egypt he inherited already honored the sun. The sun god Re had been at the top of the pantheon (the whole family of a people’s gods) for more than a thousand years, and under his father the Aten, the visible disk of the sun, was rising in court favor. The prince did not invent the Aten. What he did with it was new.
(●) c. 1353 BC: Crowned as Amenhotep IV, he began building open-air temples to the Aten at Karnak. He took the throne at Thebes, the southern capital and the home of Amun, whose great temple at Karnak was the largest religious complex in the land. Scholars still argue whether he first ruled for some years alongside his father (a coregency, a shared reign) or only after his death; the evidence is thin either way. Within his first years he raised new temples to the Aten right beside Amun’s house at Karnak. One of them, the Gempaaten ("the Aten is found"), was lined with colossal statues of the king unlike anything Egypt had carved before: a long face, heavy-lidded eyes, a thin neck, a swelling belly and hips. Whether that strange body was a portrait, a deliberate religious symbol, or both is still debated. The temples themselves were built differently too. An Egyptian temple had always been a series of ever darker rooms leading to the hidden statue of the god; the Aten’s temples were open to the sky, because their god was the light itself. At his side from the start was Nefertiti, his great royal wife, the title Egypt gave the chief queen among a pharaoh’s wives. She appears on these early monuments more often, and more actively, than any queen before her, and the couple would have six daughters.
(●) c. 1349 BC: In his fifth year he renamed himself Akhenaten and marked out a new capital in the empty desert. In regnal year 5 the king dropped the name that honored Amun and took a new one, Akhenaten, usually rendered "effective for the Aten" or "the one who serves the Aten well." (Older books, following James Henry Breasted, spell him "Ikhnaton" and his god "Aton"; it is the same man and the same god.) That same year he sailed about two hundred miles north of Thebes to a broad bay of desert on the east bank of the Nile, ringed by cliffs and belonging to no god. There he founded a city and called it Akhetaten, "the Horizon of the Aten." Its modern name is Amarna. Along the cliffs he had great boundary stelae cut (a stela is an upright inscribed stone, here carved into the rock face), and on them he swore that the god himself had shown him the place and that he would never extend the city past its markers. Within a few years the court, the army, and thousands of workers had moved there, and a city of palaces, temples, villas, and workshops rose out of the sand. Think of a president abandoning Washington and building a new capital in the Nevada desert because his god told him to. That is roughly the scale of what he did, and Egypt’s old elites, priests above all, cannot have welcomed it.
(●) c. 1345 – 1342 BC: He sent his men to chisel Amun’s name off the monuments, and received the tribute of the known world. At some point in the middle of the reign, the toleration ended. Workmen went out across Egypt and south into Nubia (the Nile lands beyond Egypt’s southern border, in what is now southernmost Egypt and northern Sudan) with chisels to cut the name and image of Amun from temple walls, obelisks, tombs, and even small objects, and in places the plural word "gods" was erased as well. They hacked out the name of Amun even where it was part of the king’s own father’s name. The temples of the old gods lost their royal support. The Aten itself was no longer drawn as a falcon-headed man, the old image of the sun god; it was drawn only as a disk whose rays end in little human hands, reaching down to hold the sign of life (the ankh, a cross with a loop for its top arm) to the noses of the king and queen, as if the god were giving them each breath. In regnal year 12 the king held a great reception at Akhetaten, carved in the tombs of two of his officials, at which envoys from Nubia, Syria, the Aegean islands, and Libya brought gifts. It was the high point of the reign: the pharaoh enthroned in his new city, the whole known world at his feet.
(●) c. 1342 – 1337 BC: Grief came to the royal house, and letters from his vassals in Canaan begged for help. The bright years did not last. In the royal tomb carved for the family in a remote valley east of the city, one wall shows the king and queen weeping over the body of their second daughter, Meketaten, who seems to have died young, around or after year 12. His mother Tiye died in these years as well. Nefertiti fades from view, though a graffito (an informal inscription scratched or painted on a wall, here a quarry face) from regnal year 16, found in 2012 at a quarry north of Amarna, still names her as great royal wife. Meanwhile the clay tablets kept arriving. The Amarna Letters, a royal archive of some three hundred and eighty cuneiform tablets (wedge-shaped writing pressed into clay, in the Babylonian language that served as the diplomatic common tongue of the age), preserve his correspondence with the great kings of Babylon, Assyria, Mitanni (a kingdom in what is now northern Syria), and the Hittites (in what is now Turkey), and with the petty kings of Canaan who were his vassals. A vassal was a local ruler who kept his own throne in return for loyalty and tribute to a greater king, much as a franchise owner runs his own shop under the company’s name. Canaan was the land along the eastern Mediterranean coast, roughly modern Israel, the Palestinian territories, and Lebanon. Some of those vassals wrote again and again asking for troops. Abdi-Heba, the ruler of Jerusalem, warned that the land of the king was being lost to raiders he called the Habiru, a word the letters use for uprooted bands living outside the settled towns, sometimes as outlaws and sometimes as hired soldiers. Rib-Hadda of Byblos, a port on the coast of modern Lebanon, sent letter after letter. How much help was sent, and how much the king cared, historians still argue.
(●) c. 1336 BC: He died in his seventeenth year, and his successors abandoned his city and erased his name. Akhenaten died in or soon after his seventeenth regnal year. How he died is unknown. He was buried in the royal tomb at Amarna, but his body was later moved, and whether a damaged skeleton found in 1907 in tomb KV55 in the Valley of the Kings (KV for "Kings’ Valley," 55 for its place in the valley’s numbering, which roughly follows the order the tombs were found) is his remains one of the long-running arguments of Egyptology. What came next happened quickly. After one or two short and obscure reigns (the rulers called Smenkhkare and Neferneferuaten, whose identities are themselves debated), a boy named Tutankhaten came to the throne. Within a few years he had changed his name to Tutankhamun, "the living image of Amun," moved the court away, and set up a stela at Karnak recording that the temples of the gods had been "desolate" and were now restored. Akhetaten was left to the sand. Later kings went further. Horemheb and the pharaohs after him pulled down the Aten temples and reused their blocks as filling for their own buildings, and dropped Akhenaten and his immediate successors from the official king lists, the long rolls of past rulers that later pharaohs carved on temple walls to honor their predecessors. On those walls the line of kings simply skips from his father to Horemheb, as if the years between had never happened. When a lawsuit record from the reign of Ramesses II, more than half a century later, needed to refer to his reign, it called him only "the enemy of Akhetaten." The man who had erased Amun was erased in his turn.
(●) 1887 – 1905 AD: A village woman’s find of clay tablets drew the excavators to his city, and Breasted made him famous. For three thousand years he was nearly forgotten. Karl Richard Lepsius’s Prussian expedition copied the Amarna tombs and stelae in the 1840s, and scholars puzzled over the strange king they showed. Then in 1887, the usual account says, a local woman digging at Amarna for the crumbled mud brick that farmers used as fertilizer found a cache of clay tablets: the Amarna Letters. Scholars soon realized what they were, and excavators followed, Flinders Petrie in 1891 and 1892 among the first, then many others, digging out the city, the tombs of his officials, and the hymns carved on their walls. In 1905 the American Egyptologist James Henry Breasted published his History of Egypt, with the Great Hymn to the Aten printed in English beside Psalm 104, and called Akhenaten "the first individual in human history." From that point he became one of the most written-about figures of the ancient world, claimed in turn as a prophet, a pacifist, a poet, a mystic, and, by Freud in 1939, as the teacher of Moses.
What He Taught
(T1) There is one god, the Aten, who alone made the world and keeps it alive. Stand outside on a clear morning and watch the sun come up. Birds start singing, people wake and go to work, plants turn their leaves to the light. It is not hard to see why someone would think: everything alive depends on this. That is the heart of Akhenaten’s faith. The Aten, the light of the sun disk, is the one god who made everything and who keeps it all alive day by day; when it sets, the world lies "in darkness like the dead," and when it rises, life returns. Most of what we know of his teaching comes from hymns carved on the walls of his officials’ tombs at Amarna, and the longest of them, the Great Hymn to the Aten, says what was new. Egyptian religion had long praised one god as supreme over the others. Akhenaten went further: in his hymns the Aten is "sole god," maker of all things "while thou wast alone," and the other gods are simply absent. That is why many Egyptologists call his religion the first known monotheism, while others prefer a narrower word, monolatry: the worship of one god only, without ever saying that the others do not exist. Their reason is that the hymns never argue that other gods do not exist; they just leave them out, and the king’s chisels did the rest. It is the difference between a man who argues that no one else exists and a man who simply stops mentioning anyone else. Christians can recognize real light here. The God of Scripture is the one Creator who sustains every living thing (Acts 14:17). But Akhenaten’s one god is the sun itself, a thing in the sky, which Scripture calls a creature, made by God on the fourth day of creation (Genesis 1:16).
(Q) "O thou sole god, whose powers no other possesseth. Thou didst create the earth according to thy desire. While thou wast alone." Source: Great Hymn to the Aten, from the tomb of Ay at Amarna (James Henry Breasted, A History of Egypt, 1905, p. 374). These lines picture the god before anything else existed, needing no partner and no raw material from another god to make the world. Breasted notes that the other Aten hymns often say "O thou sole god, beside whom there is no other."
(T2) The Aten cares for every nation and every creature, not for Egypt alone. Egyptian kings had always been pictured trampling foreigners. Bound captives from Nubia and Syria were painted on the soles of royal sandals so the pharaoh could walk on them all day. Against that background, a few lines of the Great Hymn are startling. The Aten made Syria and Nubia as well as Egypt, gave the nations their different languages and skin colors, and provides for each of them; he even sends foreign lands a "Nile in heaven," the rain, since they have no river of their own. The hymn’s eye for small things is just as striking. It notices the chick calling from inside its shell, the fish leaping in the river, the baby comforted in its mother’s womb. Breasted, reading these lines in 1905, compared them to the Sermon on the Mount’s lilies of the field. This is the side of Akhenaten that Christian readers have found most attractive, and with reason: Scripture also teaches that one God "made from one man every nation of mankind" and fixed the boundaries of their lands (Acts 17:26). It is fair to add what the hymn does not say. Its god gives life and light to all; it nowhere asks anything of them in return, no justice, no mercy, no repentance.
(Q) "The countries of Syria and Nubia, The land of Egypt; Thou settest every man in his place, Thou supplest their necessities." Source: Great Hymn to the Aten, from the tomb of Ay at Amarna (James Henry Breasted, A History of Egypt, 1905, p. 374). Notice the order: the foreign lands are named before Egypt. The next lines speak of tongues "divers in speech" and of the god who "hast divided the peoples."
(T3) Only the king truly knows the god, and everyone else must reach the god through him. Picture an ordinary household in Akhetaten. The shrine in the house does not hold a statue of the Aten; the Aten had no statues. It holds a carved scene of the king and queen with their daughters, the sun’s rays reaching down to them. The family prays to the god by honoring the royal family. That is the third piece of the teaching, and it may be the most important: the king is the Aten’s son and the only one who knows him, and everyone else reaches the god through the king. The nobles’ tombs say this over and over. Their owners pray to the Aten for the king, praise the king’s "teaching," and thank him for their promotions; one of them, Ay, says that the man who hears the king’s teaching of life is prosperous. Breasted himself admitted that many of these converts were drawn by gold as much as by doctrine. This is also where the faith was weakest. A religion that only the king understood could not outlive the king, and archaeologists have found that even at Amarna, in the workmen’s village, people kept amulets of the household gods (Bes, the dwarf god who guarded childbirth, and others) that the court religion had no use for.
(Q) "Thou art in my heart, There is no other that knoweth thee, Save thy son Ikhnaton. Thou hast made him wise in thy designs And in thy might." Source: Great Hymn to the Aten, from the tomb of Ay at Amarna (James Henry Breasted, A History of Egypt, 1905, p. 375). These lines come from the hymn’s closing section, which Breasted headed "Revelation to the King." ("Ikhnaton" is Breasted’s spelling of Akhenaten.) The hymn ends by naming the king and Nefertiti, "living and flourishing for ever and ever."
(T4) The god chose his own city, and the king vowed to give it to him forever. People who buy land put up fences and record a deed. Akhenaten did the same thing for his god, on a vast scale. The boundary stelae around Akhetaten record that the Aten himself chose the site, a place that belonged to no other god or goddess, and that the king handed over everything inside the markers, "mountains or cliffs, or swamps . . . or uplands, or fields, or waters, or towns," people, cattle and trees, to "my father, Aton." The vow mattered because it made the city a holy place: the one spot on earth where the god was properly worshiped, with the king at its center as his priest. Akhenaten seems to have kept the vow for the rest of his reign, and the city did not outlive him by many years. There is an unmistakable echo here of Israel’s later "place that the Lord your God will choose," Deuteronomy’s name for the one sanctuary where Israel was to worship, which in time became the temple in Jerusalem. The difference is as plain as the echo. In Israel the chosen place was a house for a God who could not be contained by any house (1 Kings 8:27), and no king of Israel was ever its god’s only knower.
(Q) "This is my testimony forever, and this is my witness forever, this landmark [stela]. . . . I have made Akhetaton for my father as a dwelling." Source: the later boundary stelae of Akhetaten, the king’s oath (James Henry Breasted, A History of Egypt, 1905, p. 365; full text in Breasted, Ancient Records of Egypt, vol. II, 1906, §§ 949–972). Breasted introduces it: "His majesty raised his hand to heaven, to him who made him, even to Aton." The oath goes on to swear that the king will not pass beyond the city’s southern or northern landmarks.
(Q) "How manifold are all thy works! They are hidden from before us, O thou sole god, whose powers no other possesseth." Source: Great Hymn to the Aten, from the tomb of Ay at Amarna (James Henry Breasted, A History of Egypt, 1905, pp. 373–374; Breasted quotes the lines again on p. 377). Beside these lines Breasted printed Psalm 104:24, which in the English Standard Version reads, "O Lord, how manifold are your works! In wisdom have you made them all; the earth is full of your creatures."
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Christian readers heard in his hymn what creation tells every honest eye, and in Psalm 104 what it was missing. Set the Great Hymn beside Psalm 104 and the likeness is plain: night when the beasts creep out and the young lions hunt, morning when people go out to their work, ships on the sea, creatures beyond counting, a single maker of them all. Scholars still disagree about whether the psalmist knew some form of the Egyptian poem or whether both drew on a shared stock of Near Eastern hymn language. Christian readers have generally been unbothered either way. Paul teaches that God’s "invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made" (Romans 1:20). Theologians call this general revelation: what anyone can learn of God from the world itself, as distinct from what he has said in Scripture. An Egyptian king watching the sunrise and concluding that one power made and feeds everything is general revelation working as Paul says it does. C. S. Lewis, writing of Akhenaten in Reflections on the Psalms (1958), took him in just this spirit: whatever was true in the king’s creed, Lewis judged, came to him from God, as all truth does. What the psalm adds is the decisive thing. In Psalm 104 the sun is not the god; it is one more servant, keeping the schedule it was given: "He made the moon to mark the seasons; the sun knows its time for setting" (Psalm 104:19).
(†) The claim that Moses learned his faith from Akhenaten has not survived the evidence. In Moses and Monotheism (1939), Sigmund Freud proposed that Moses was an Egyptian nobleman, a follower of the Aten faith, who after Akhenaten’s fall passed his master’s religion on to a band of Semitic slaves (people of the family of peoples and languages that includes the Hebrews). Freud himself called the book a historical novel at one stage of its writing, and Egyptologists and biblical historians have not been persuaded, for three main reasons. - The faiths differ at the root. The Aten was the visible sun disk, approached through the king, with no law, no covenant, and no moral demands. The God of Sinai has no image, binds a whole people to himself by covenant (a solemn, binding agreement with promises on both sides, something like a treaty or a marriage vow), and commands justice and mercy. - The Aten cult had nowhere to go. It was a court religion that collapsed within a few years of the king’s death, and there is no evidence that it survived among slaves or foreigners. - The Egyptologists who looked hardest found no link. James K. Hoffmeier, an evangelical Egyptologist, concluded in Akhenaten and the Origins of Monotheism (2015) that Akhenaten’s faith was a genuine monotheism, sparked by what the king himself described as an encounter with the god, yet with no direct connection to the faith of Moses. Hoffmeier also argued that Akhenaten looked backward rather than forward, reaching for the sun religion of the pyramid builders a thousand years before him. Read that way, Akhenaten is not the father of biblical monotheism but one more witness that people have always sensed there must be one source of all things. C. S. Lewis, who had no use for the theory as history, still allowed the gentler possibility: that echoes of Akhenaten’s ideas might have survived as part of the "wisdom of the Egyptians" in which Moses was raised (Acts 7:22), one of the means God could have used. He added that there is no evidence it happened, and nothing in the faith of Sinai depends on it.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: a god in the sky, a king as the only way to it, and a faith enforced by the chisel. There is much in Akhenaten for a Christian to admire, and there is another side as well. It comes not from what later admirers made of him but from what he himself taught and did. - He worshiped a creature. The sun is the brightest thing in the sky, and Akhenaten made it god. Moses warned Israel against exactly this: "when you see the sun and the moon and the stars, all the host of heaven, you be drawn away and bow down to them and serve them" (Deuteronomy 4:19). Paul names the same mistake: worshiping "the creature rather than the Creator" (Romans 1:25). - He made himself the only way to God. "There is no other that knoweth thee, save thy son" (T3). The new covenant promises the opposite: "they shall all know me, from the least of them to the greatest" (Jeremiah 31:34). Christians confess one mediator, a go-between who brings God and people together, "the man Christ Jesus" (1 Timothy 2:5), who opened the way to the Father to everyone rather than keeping it for himself. - His god asked nothing of the heart. Breasted, his greatest admirer, conceded that "the king has not perceptibly risen from the beneficence to the righteousness in the character of God." The hymns praise light, life, and provision; they never mention sin, justice, or forgiveness. - He imposed his faith by force. He sent men with chisels to destroy the names of other people’s gods, his father’s name included, and tied favor at court to accepting his teaching. A faith carried by royal command fell when the command was lifted. He saw that one power must stand behind the world, and he saw it more clearly than any ruler of his age. What he could not see was a God who stands above the sun, speaks his law to a whole people, and comes down to them himself.