Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
Norman Geisler of Warren 1932 – 2019 AD
(●) The apologist who taught a generation of evangelicals to reason step by step from truth itself to God, to Christ, and to a Bible without error. Picture a staircase. At the bottom step is a question nobody can dodge: can we know anything true about the world at all? At the top is the claim that the Bible is the Word of God. Norman Geisler spent fifty years building the steps in between, one at a time, so that a student could climb from the first to the last without ever being asked to leap. That staircase, with its twelve numbered steps, became for many evangelicals the standard picture of classical apologetics. Apologetics is simply the reasoned defense of the faith; "classical" names the old method of Augustine and Thomas Aquinas, which first argues that God exists and only then argues that Jesus is who he said he was. He was not born into any of this. He grew up in a working-class suburb of Detroit in a home that did not take him to church, and he came to faith because two men kept stopping a church bus at his door. He went on to write or co-write more than a hundred books, to help draft the best-known modern statement on the truthfulness of Scripture, and to co-found two seminaries. He was also a fighter. The same conviction that built the staircase made him one of the most determined guardians of biblical inerrancy (the teaching that Scripture, as God first gave it, contains no errors) in his generation, and some of his fellow believers thought he guarded it too hard. Both halves belong to the story.
(●) 1932 AD: Born outside Detroit, he was picked up by a church bus every Sunday for eight years. Norman Leo Geisler was born on July 21, 1932, in Warren, Michigan, a working-class town on the northern edge of Detroit. His parents were not churchgoers. When he was nine, a neighborhood vacation Bible school drew him in, and after that a Sunday school bus began stopping for him. It kept stopping. He later wrote that two men, whom he remembered as Mr. Costie and Mr. Sweetland, picked him up "more than 400 times," every Sunday from the age of nine until he was seventeen. For most of those years he heard the gospel and turned it down. It is worth sitting with that number for a moment. Four hundred Sunday mornings is eight years of a driver idling at the curb for a boy who kept saying no, and Geisler never forgot it: he credited that bus, more than any argument, with putting him in a position to believe.
(●) 1950 AD: At seventeen he gave his life to Christ, and began training to answer the questions he had once asked. In his senior year of high school, after a youth director spoke to his Sunday school class, he went home convicted, knelt beside his bed, and committed himself to Christ. He was seventeen. That same year he finished a diploma at Emmaus Bible School and began studies at William Tyndale College in Detroit, and within two years he was directing a Youth for Christ chapter in the northeastern suburbs. At a Youth for Christ rally he met Barbara Jean Cate, and they married in June 1955. They had six children, and the marriage lasted sixty-four years. He pastored a small church in Silverwood, Michigan, where he was ordained in 1956, and then went to Wheaton College, graduating with honors in philosophy in 1958 and taking a master’s degree in theology in 1960. Through the early 1960s he taught Bible and apologetics at Detroit Bible College while pastoring Memorial Baptist Church back in his hometown of Warren. Philosophy was not a detour from the pastorate for him. The questions a skeptic asks (how do you know? why believe that?) were the questions he had once asked himself, and he wanted answers that would hold.
(●) 1970 AD: With a doctorate in philosophy, he took the chair of philosophy of religion at Trinity and wrote the books that made his name. In 1970 he completed a PhD in philosophy at Loyola University Chicago, a Jesuit university, and the Thomas Aquinas he studied there stayed with him for the rest of his life (T3). That same year he became chairman of the philosophy of religion department at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School in Deerfield, Illinois, a post he held until 1979. The Trinity years were the most productive of his life as a scholar. Philosophy of Religion (1974) was named a book of the year by Christianity Today, and Christian Apologetics (1976) laid out the method he would teach for the rest of his career. In 1976 he became the first president of the Evangelical Philosophical Society. He also began to debate in public, on university campuses from Calgary to Texas, with philosophers such as Michael Scriven and, later, the humanist Paul Kurtz, on whether God exists and whether Christianity is credible.
(●) 1978 AD: He helped frame the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy, and spent a decade publishing in its defense. In the 1970s American evangelicals were arguing among themselves about whether the Bible could be wrong in matters of history and science while still being trustworthy on faith and morals. Put the way a layman would put it: if the Bible could slip on a date or a battle, how far could it be trusted on the empty tomb? In 1977 a group of scholars and pastors formed the International Council on Biblical Inerrancy to settle the matter in writing, and Geisler was a founding member, sat on its drafting committee, and served as its general editor and director of publications from 1977 to 1987. In October 1978 some three hundred scholars met at a hotel near O’Hare airport in Chicago and signed the statement the council had prepared: a short summary, nineteen articles each stated as an affirmation and a denial, and a commentary. Its twelfth article is the one most often quoted: "We affirm that Scripture in its entirety is inerrant, being free from all falsehood, fraud, or deceit." Geisler edited the council’s first book, Inerrancy (1979), and its study of the philosophical roots of errancy (1981), errancy being the opposite view, that the Bible does contain mistakes. He also wrote the official commentary on its later statement on hermeneutics, the rules for reading a text rightly. While all this was going on, in 1979, he moved to Dallas Theological Seminary as professor of systematic theology, and stayed until 1988. Systematic theology is the work of gathering everything the Bible teaches on one subject, say sin or salvation, from every book where it comes up, and setting it out as one ordered account.
(●) 1981 AD: He was the state’s first witness in the Arkansas creation trial, and the law he defended was struck down. In 1981 Arkansas passed a law requiring public schools that taught evolution to give "balanced treatment" to creation science, an effort to argue from scientific evidence alone, without quoting Genesis, that the world was created suddenly and fairly recently and was later reshaped by a worldwide flood. The American Civil Liberties Union sued, and in December the case of McLean v. Arkansas came to trial in Little Rock. Geisler, by then at Dallas, was the first witness called for the state’s defense. His argument was philosophical: belief in a first cause is not in itself religious, he said, because Aristotle reached an unmoved mover (a first source of all change that nothing else sets in motion) without any religion at all; it becomes religious only when a person commits to that God in worship. The cross-examination went badly, and it is a reminder that in a courtroom a vivid sentence outlives a careful one. Asked about his own beliefs, he said he believed Satan is real, and that he thought UFOs were "a satanic manifestation in the world for the purpose of deception." That line traveled further than his argument did. On January 5, 1982, Judge William Overton struck the law down, rejecting Geisler’s distinction as contrary to common understanding. Geisler published his own account of the trial, The Creator in the Courtroom, that same year, and returned to the subject twenty-five years later in Creation and the Courts.
(●) 1992 AD: He co-founded Southern Evangelical Seminary in Charlotte, a school built around apologetics. After Dallas, Geisler spent two years as dean of a research center at Liberty University, and then, in 1992, joined Ross Rhoads, pastor of Calvary Church in Charlotte, North Carolina, to found Southern Evangelical Seminary. He served as its dean, and from 1999 to 2006 as its president. It was a small school with an unusual aim: to make the defense of the faith not an elective but the center of a theological education. These were also the years of his largest books. The Baker Encyclopedia of Christian Apologetics (1999), a single author’s alphabetical reference running from accommodation theory to Zen Buddhism, became a standard desk book for pastors. His four-volume Systematic Theology followed between 2002 and 2005. With his former student Frank Turek he wrote I Don’t Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist (2004), the most widely read book to carry his name. In 1998 he served as president of the Evangelical Theological Society, the main scholarly society for evangelical theologians, whose members must affirm in writing that the Bible is inerrant. That affirmation mattered to him more than the office did. Five years later he resigned his membership of forty-four years, after the society declined to expel two members whose views on God’s knowledge of the future he judged incompatible with its statement on inerrancy.
(●) 2019 AD: He taught until the spring he died, at eighty-six, in Charlotte. In 2007 he co-founded a second school, Veritas Evangelical Seminary in Southern California (later Veritas International University), and served as its chancellor, while continuing to teach at Southern Evangelical Seminary. Well past seventy he kept writing: a twelve-step handbook of the faith, a two-volume history of Western philosophy, short books on cremation and on Ecclesiastes. His son David carried the work into a ministry of conversational evangelism, and the two wrote a book on it together. He retired from teaching and writing in May 2019 because of failing health, and that same month Southern Evangelical Seminary renamed its graduate school of apologetics after him. In the last days of June he was hospitalized with a blood clot in the brain, and he died in Charlotte on July 1, 2019, three weeks short of his eighty-seventh birthday. When he died, his ministry posted Paul’s word to the grieving at Thessalonica, that believers "may not grieve as others do who have no hope" (1 Thessalonians 4:13–14).
What He Taught
(T1) Truth is what corresponds to reality, and anyone who denies that truth can be known refutes himself. Geisler liked to begin with a desk. The sentence "I am writing on a brown desk" is true, he said, only because there really is a brown desk under the writer’s hands. That is the correspondence view of truth: a statement is true when it matches the way things are, and false when it does not. It sounds too obvious to need saying, and that was his point. Every serious argument about God depends on it. Then he turned to the skeptic who says no one can know the truth about reality. Is that statement itself true about reality? If it is, then at least one truth about reality is known, and the statement is false. If it is not, there is no reason to listen to it. A claim like this is self-defeating: it has to be wrong in order to be right. Philosophers call the starting points of all knowledge "first principles," and Geisler held that the most basic of them cannot even be denied without being used. His whole method rests on a handful of them. The most important is the law of non-contradiction: a thing cannot both be and not be in the same sense at the same time, so two opposite claims cannot both be true. This is the bottom step of the staircase. Before anyone argues about God, Geisler wanted it settled that there is such a thing as truth, that it can be known, and that when two religions contradict each other they cannot both be right.
(Q) "When the skeptic states that we cannot know any truth about the real world that statement is a truth claim about the real world." Source: Norman L. Geisler, Twelve Points That Show Christianity Is True (Bastion Books, 2012), chapter 1, "Truth About Reality Is Knowable." The opening move of his twelve-step case, written for ordinary readers near the end of his career: skepticism about truth cannot be stated without contradicting itself (T1).
(T2) Faith is a step in the light, not a leap in the dark: first show that God exists, and then that Jesus is God. Imagine stepping into an elevator with the lights off. A sensible person wants to know the floor is there first. Geisler used that picture to say what kind of faith Christ asks for: trust, yes, but trust in the light of evidence. Peter pictured believers "always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you" (1 Peter 3:15), and Geisler took that "reason" seriously. His method is called classical apologetics, and it moves in two stages. The first stage argues that a theistic God exists, meaning one infinite, personal Creator who is distinct from the world, using reason alone, without first appealing to the Bible. His favorite argument here came from Aquinas: everything around us exists, but nothing around us has to exist, so something must be giving it existence right now, and that something must exist by its very nature. Arguments that reason from the existence of the world (the Greek word is kosmos) back to its cause are called cosmological arguments, and this one, from the bare fact that things exist at all, was the one he trusted most. The second stage follows from the first. If such a God exists, miracles are possible, and then the historical record of Jesus can be weighed without ruling the resurrection out in advance. He set the whole route down as twelve points, each the conclusion of one step and the premise of the next. Gathered into seven lines, the chain runs like this: - Truth about reality is knowable, and opposites cannot both be true (T1). - The theistic God exists, so miracles are possible. - Miracles can be used to confirm a message from God. - The New Testament documents are historically reliable, and in them Jesus claimed to be God. - Jesus’ claim was confirmed by a unique set of miracles, above all his resurrection, so Jesus was God in human flesh. - Whatever Jesus affirmed as true is true, and Jesus affirmed that the Bible is the Word of God (T4). - So the Bible is the Word of God, and anything opposed to it is false. The order is the argument, and here is where he parted from some of his friends. Evidentialists, another school of apologists, think the resurrection can be argued first and can itself show that God exists; Geisler thought a skeptic who has already ruled God out will explain away any miracle, so the question of God has to come first.
(Q) "Indeed, Christ does not call on us to make a leap of faith in the dark but to take a step of faith in the light." Source: Norman L. Geisler, Twelve Points That Show Christianity Is True (Bastion Books, 2012), Introduction. The sentence continues, "in the light of the evidence." In his encyclopedia he put the method in two sentences: "Classical apologetics is characterized by two basic steps: theistic and evidential arguments. Theistic arguments are used to establish the truth of theism apart from an appeal to special revelation (e.g., the Bible)." (The Big Book of Christian Apologetics, 2012, "Apologetics, Types of," the lightly revised reissue of the 1999 Baker Encyclopedia of Christian Apologetics.)
(T3) Evangelicals should learn from Thomas Aquinas rather than fear him. When Geisler was a young scholar, most evangelical leaders treated Thomas Aquinas, the thirteenth-century Dominican friar who wrote the Summa Theologiae, as a man to be warned against. Francis Schaeffer blamed him for setting reason loose from faith and so opening the door to modern humanism. Cornelius Van Til, the father of presuppositional apologetics (the school that holds you must begin by presupposing the God of Scripture rather than arguing up to him), called Thomism (the philosophy of Aquinas and of the school that follows him) a position halfway between Christianity and paganism. Carl Henry and Gordon Clark thought his arguments for God failed. Geisler had read Aquinas closely at Loyola, and he thought most of these critics were attacking a Thomas who never existed. In Thomas Aquinas: An Evangelical Appraisal (1991) he walked through the evangelical complaints one by one and argued that Aquinas did not make reason autonomous, did not deny the effects of sin on the mind, and did not reduce talk about God to guesswork. On that last point he defended Aquinas’s doctrine of analogy: when we call God "good," the word means neither exactly what it means of a good man nor something unrelated, but something truly similar, the way a painting of a face really does resemble the face. He was a Protestant in his doctrine of salvation and of the church, and wrote at length on where Rome and the Reformation part (Roman Catholics and Evangelicals, 1995). But on God, being, knowledge and the proofs, he counted himself Aquinas’s student.
(Q) "As for myself, I gladly confess that the highest compliment that could be paid to me as a Christian philosopher and apologist is to call me "Thomistic."" Source: Norman L. Geisler, Should Old Aquinas Be Forgotten? (Bastion Books, 2013), chapter 1, "The Contemporary Relevance of Aquinas"; the revised and expanded edition of Thomas Aquinas: An Evangelical Appraisal (Baker, 1991). He goes straight on to qualify it: he does not accept everything Aquinas wrote, "neither do I agree with everything I ever wrote," but he can "see a lot farther standing on his shoulders than by attacking him in the back."
(T4) God cannot err, the Bible is God’s Word, and so the Bible cannot err. Suppose a friend who has never once lied to you, and who knows everything, hands you a letter he wrote. You might misread the letter, and a copyist might smudge a word, but you would not suspect the friend of a mistake. That is the shape of Geisler’s case for inerrancy, and he liked to set it out as a three-line syllogism (an argument whose conclusion follows necessarily from two premises): God cannot err; the Bible is the Word of God; therefore the Bible cannot err. Each premise has its own support. God cannot err because he knows everything and cannot lie (Titus 1:2). The Bible is God’s Word because Jesus, whose authority the earlier steps establish (T2), treated the Old Testament that way and promised his apostles the Spirit to lead them into truth. Geisler was careful about what inerrancy does not mean. It applies to the original manuscripts, not to every later copy or translation. It allows round numbers, ordinary descriptions of nature ("the sun rose"), and paraphrase, the way a newspaper is not lying when it rounds a crowd to ten thousand. What it rules out is that anything the biblical writers actually affirm is false. That is why he cared so much about hermeneutics, the rules of interpretation. A reader who decides that a passage written as history is really a legend has not found an error, but by Geisler’s lights he has taken away the same thing an error would: the truth of what the text affirms happened.
(Q) "God cannot err unintentionally because He is all-knowing (omniscient). And He cannot err intentionally because He is morally perfect, and an intentional falsehood would be a lie, which is contrary to His moral perfection. Hence, God cannot err in any way." Source: Norman L. Geisler, Twelve Points That Show Christianity Is True (Bastion Books, 2012), chapter 10, "Whatever Jesus Affirmed Is True, Is True." The first premise of the inerrancy syllogism (T4), resting on the God the earlier steps of the case argue for: a God who knows everything cannot be mistaken, and a God who is wholly good will not deceive.
(T5) God’s choosing and our free choices are not rivals: we are chosen, but free. Two Christians can sit in the same pew and read Ephesians 1 in opposite ways. One hears that God chose his people before the foundation of the world and concludes that our choices are simply the outworking of his. The other hears the gospel’s "whoever believes" and concludes that God’s choice must wait on ours. Geisler thought both were missing something, and in Chosen But Free (1999) he argued for a middle position he called moderate Calvinism. The first reading is the one Calvinism, the Reformed tradition named for the sixteenth-century Reformer John Calvin, is known for. At its heart is unconditional election: God chose whom he would save without basing the choice on anything he saw in them, not even their faith, the way a father adopts a child not because the child applied. Geisler kept the name because he affirmed all five of Calvinism’s classic points in his own sense, unconditional election among them: nothing outside God prompted his choice, though faith is the one condition for receiving the gift, and those he chooses will surely be saved. He added "moderate" because he denied that God’s choosing overrides the free choice of the one chosen. His answer started from God’s eternity. God does not first look ahead and then decide, nor first decide and then look; his knowing and his willing are one eternal act. So God can "knowingly determine" everything that happens, including free acts, without anyone being forced. Human free will, for Geisler, meant self-determination: a free act is one caused by the person himself, which could have been otherwise. And he held just as firmly that no one can turn to God at all without God’s grace going first: "While all truly free acts are self-determined and could have been otherwise, nonetheless, it is also true that no free human act can move toward God or do any spiritual good without the aid of His grace" (chapter 2). The book drew a book-length reply from the Reformed apologist James White, The Potter’s Freedom (2000), defending unconditional election, and Geisler answered White in an appendix to his second edition. Calvinists said his "moderate Calvinism" kept the name and gave up the substance; Geisler said he stood where most of the church fathers, the early Augustine and Aquinas had stood.
(Q) "There is no contradiction in God knowingly predetermining and predeterminately knowing from all eternity precisely what we would do with our free acts. For God determined that moral creatures would do things freely. He did not determine that they would be forced to perform free acts. What is forced is not free, and what is free is not forced." Source: Norman L. Geisler, Chosen But Free, second edition (Bethany House, 2001), chapter 3, "Viewing the Alternatives." The heart of the book in four sentences, closing the section where he argues that God’s foreknowledge and his choosing are one eternal act rather than one coming before the other (T5).
(Q) "But seven hundred years from now no one will even recognize my name, while Aquinas’s works will still be used with great profit." Source: Norman L. Geisler, Should Old Aquinas Be Forgotten? (Bastion Books, 2013), chapter 1, "The Contemporary Relevance of Aquinas." The sentences just before it are the confession of (T3): "No, I do not agree with everything he ever wrote. On the other hand, neither do I agree with everything I ever wrote." A prolific man’s honest guess about which books would last.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) A generation of apologists learned the craft from him, in classrooms, in debates, and in more than a hundred books. Ask an evangelical apologist of a certain age which books first taught them to answer a skeptic, and When Skeptics Ask (1990, with Ronald Brooks) and the Baker Encyclopedia of Christian Apologetics come up again and again. Geisler wrote at every level: dense philosophy for specialists, handbooks for pastors, short paperbacks for teenagers, and When Critics Ask (1992, with Thomas Howe), which works through hundreds of alleged contradictions in the Bible from Genesis to Revelation. The encyclopedia won a Silver Medallion in 2000, and his books have been translated into many languages. His students carried the method on. Frank Turek, his co-author, took the twelve-step case onto college campuses; Southern Evangelical Seminary, which renamed its graduate school of apologetics after him in 2019, and Veritas International University both trained a generation of teachers in it. Richard Land, then president of Southern Evangelical Seminary, called him "the pre-eminent Christian apologist of the past half-century." Even those who thought him too combative rarely doubted that he had done more than almost anyone to put the reasoned defense of the faith within reach of ordinary believers.
(†) He brought Aquinas back into evangelical apologetics, and the argument he started about method is still going. When Geisler began, saying a kind word about Aquinas in an evangelical seminary was close to a confession of disloyalty. By the end of his life a good many evangelical philosophers and apologists (R. C. Sproul and John Gerstner among the Reformed, and many others) used Thomistic arguments openly, and Geisler was among those who had done most to make that respectable. The philosopher Winfried Corduan wrote that his book on Aquinas struck "a credible blow against the current unfounded prejudice toward St. Thomas in evangelical thought." Not everyone was persuaded. Presuppositional apologists in the line of Van Til argued that starting from neutral reason concedes to the unbeliever the very independence from God that Scripture denies him. Evidentialists answered from the other side that the resurrection can be argued directly, without first winning the cosmological argument. Geisler’s classical method remains one of the main schools in the field, and these debates over where to begin are still the frame in which apologetics students learn their trade.
(†) Fellow believers in inerrancy divided over how hard he pressed its boundaries, from Gundry in 1983 to Licona in 2011. Geisler believed a doctrine without a boundary is no doctrine at all, and he acted on it. Three episodes, each his own doing, show both the conviction and the cost. - Robert Gundry, 1983. Gundry, a respected New Testament scholar at Westmont College, wrote a commentary arguing that Matthew freely embellished his sources, for instance turning the shepherds of Luke’s nativity into the wise men, in a Jewish style of interpretive retelling (often called midrash). Geisler, by then at Dallas, organized the effort to remove him from the Evangelical Theological Society and wrote the document laid before the members at their business meeting in Dallas. In December 1983 the members voted 116 to 41 to ask for Gundry’s resignation, and he left the society. - Leaving the society, 2003. When the society voted not to expel two open theists (theologians who hold that God does not know in advance everything free creatures will do), Geisler resigned after forty-four years, writing that the society had "lost its doctrinal integrity." - Michael Licona, 2011. In a seven-hundred-page defense of the resurrection, Licona suggested that the saints raised at Jesus’ death (Matthew 27:52–53) might be an apocalyptic image (the kind of vivid, symbolic picture Jewish writers used for the end of the age, as Revelation does with its beasts and lampstands) rather than a report of an event. Geisler answered in a series of open letters calling on him to recant, describing the view as "unorthodox, non-evangelical, and a dangerous precedent." Licona resigned from Southern Evangelical Seminary and lost his post with the Southern Baptist North American Mission Board, though he never denied the resurrection of Jesus itself. Geisler’s defenders, Albert Mohler among them on the Licona question, saw a man refusing to let the doctrine erode one exception at a time. Others who shared his doctrine of Scripture thought he had confused his own interpretation with the text’s authority. The New Testament scholar Craig Blomberg spoke of "the tragedy of ‘witch hunts’ of this nature," and Daniel Wallace, who rejected Licona’s reading, warned that treating one’s interpretation as inerrant "could ironically elevate tradition and erode biblical authority." The quarrel was never over whether the Bible is true. It was over how the defenders of that truth should treat one another, and the church has not settled it.