Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Malachi the Prophet fl. c. 430 BC
(●) Remembered as the last of the Old Testament prophets, he argued a tired people back toward God and promised a messenger who would prepare the Lord’s way. Picture a congregation that has been faithful for a long time and has quietly stopped expecting anything. The building is up, the services run on schedule, and nobody is quite sure any more why it matters. That was Jerusalem in Malachi’s day, some eighty or ninety years after the first exiles came home from Babylon, and Malachi is the prophet God sent to it. His four short chapters are a series of arguments with that congregation, and they end by looking forward to a messenger and to "Elijah the prophet" (Malachi 4:5). He matters on a Christian apologetics site for a simple reason: he is the hinge between the Testaments. In the order most English Bibles follow, his book is the last page before the Gospel of Matthew, and the Gospels open by saying his promise came true in John the Baptist. Later Jewish teachers counted him, with Haggai and Zechariah, among the last of the prophets, after whom no new prophetic word was recorded for centuries. We know almost nothing about the man himself. The book gives no father, no hometown, no king’s reign and no year. It can be dated only by what it describes: a rebuilt temple with sacrifices running, a Persian governor over Judah, and abuses that match the ones Nehemiah fought. On that evidence most scholars place him in the middle of the fifth century BC, somewhere around 460 to 430 BC. The date of about 430 BC in the title is that convention, not a recorded year.
(●) After 515 BC: He grew up after the exiles had rebuilt the temple, in a generation that found the promised glory slow in coming. The story behind Malachi begins with an ending. Babylon destroyed Jerusalem and its temple in 586 BC; Cyrus of Persia took Babylon in 539 BC and let the exiles go home the next year; and after long delays the second temple was finished "in the sixth year of the reign of Darius the king" (Ezra 6:15), which is 515 BC. The prophets Haggai and Zechariah had urged the builders on with large promises. Haggai had said, "The latter glory of this house shall be greater than the former" (Haggai 2:9). Then the years went by. Judah stayed a small province of the Persian Empire, paying taxes to a foreign king, and the glory did not visibly arrive. Think of a family that moves into the house it saved for, and a generation later the children who grew up there have forgotten it was ever a dream. That is the mood Malachi was born into. We do not know when he was born or where; we only know that by the time he spoke, the temple was old enough to be taken for granted.
(●) Date unknown: His name means "my messenger," and from early on readers wondered whether it was a name at all. The book opens, "The oracle of the word of the Lord to Israel by Malachi" (Malachi 1:1). An oracle is a solemn message from God, and the Hebrew word behind it (massa) can also mean a burden, something heavy to carry. The name Malachi means "my messenger," the same word God uses in the promise "Behold, I send my messenger" (Malachi 3:1). Because the name and the promise match so neatly, ancient readers asked whether "Malachi" was a personal name or a title. Imagine a letter signed only "Your Friend," and you can see the puzzle. The Greek translation of the Old Testament, the Septuagint, rendered the opening line as "by the hand of his messenger," as though it were a title. The Targum went further. A targum is an Aramaic paraphrase of Scripture (Aramaic was the everyday language many Jews spoke after the exile, so the Hebrew was explained aloud in it), and this one added that the messenger was Ezra the scribe. The rabbis kept the question open. The Talmud, the great collection of rabbinic teaching completed in late antiquity, records some who said he was Ezra, others who said Mordecai (Esther’s cousin in the book of Esther), and others who said Malachi was simply his name (Megillah 15a). Jerome, the great Bible translator of the early church, passed on the Jewish view that he was Ezra. Many readers, ancient and modern, have taken it as a real name, the kind the other eleven of the Twelve Prophets carry. (The Twelve Prophets are the short prophetic books, Hosea through Malachi, that close the Old Testament in English Bibles.) A much later book of legends, the Lives of the Prophets, says he was born at a place called Sopha after the return (some versions add that he was of the tribe of Zebulun, one of the twelve tribes of Israel), and that people called him "messenger" because they honored him as holy and gentle, and because he was beautiful to look at. That is legend, and it is all the tradition offers.
(●) c. 460–430 BC: He confronted priests who were offering blind and lame animals on God’s altar. The first people Malachi took on were the priests, the men whose job was to keep the worship of God honest. They were keeping the sacrifices going, but with the animals nobody wanted: the blind ones, the lame ones, the sick ones. Malachi’s reply has a dry humor to it. Try giving that to the Persian official who governs you, he says: "Present that to your governor; will he accept you or show you favor?" (Malachi 1:8). He also reminded them what a priest was for. A priest was meant to be a teacher whose words could be trusted, and Malachi uses for him the same word that is in his own name: "For the lips of a priest should guard knowledge, and people should seek instruction from his mouth, for he is the messenger of the Lord of hosts" (Malachi 2:7). "The Lord of hosts" is one of Malachi’s favorite names for God: hosts are armies, and the title means the Lord who commands the armies of heaven. The worst thing about a careless priest was not the bad animal on the altar. It was the bad lesson it taught everyone watching, that God could be fobbed off with leftovers.
(●) c. 460–430 BC: He preached by argument, quoting his hearers’ objections back to them and answering each one. Malachi has a way of speaking that no other prophet uses so steadily. He states what God says, then voices the people’s comeback, then answers it. "I have loved you, says the Lord. But you say, How have you loved us?" (Malachi 1:2). "Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me. But you say, How have we robbed you?" (Malachi 3:8). Scholars call this the disputation form: a dispute in which the audience’s objection is quoted and then taken apart, much as a teacher might say, "You are thinking, why should I care? Here is why." The book falls into six of these disputes: about God’s love (1:2–5), about the priests’ contempt (1:6–2:9), about faithlessness in marriage (2:10–16), about whether God is just (2:17–3:5), about tithes, the tenth of the harvest given to God (3:6–12), and about whether serving God is worth it (3:13–4:3). The people’s lines are worth reading slowly, because they are so ordinary. "What a weariness this is" (Malachi 1:13). "It is vain to serve God" (Malachi 3:14). These are not the words of open rebels. They are the words of people who are bored with God and a little hurt that he has not done more for them.
(●) c. 445–432 BC: The sins he named are the ones Nehemiah fought as governor, which places him in the same generation. Lay Malachi beside the last chapter of Nehemiah and the two read like the same news story told by two reporters. A word first about the Levites, who turn up on both sides. They were the tribe of Levi, set apart to serve at the temple, and the priests came from among them; "the covenant of Levi" is God’s charge to that priestly tribe. Malachi rebukes priests who have corrupted "the covenant of Levi" (Malachi 2:8); Nehemiah prays against men who "have desecrated the priesthood and the covenant of the priesthood and the Levites" (Nehemiah 13:29). Malachi accuses the people of robbing God in their tithes (3:8); Nehemiah finds that the Levites’ portions had not been paid, so they had gone back to farming (Nehemiah 13:10). Both men deal with marriages that broke faith (Malachi 2:10–16; Nehemiah 13:23–27). That overlap is the main clue to Malachi’s date. Most scholars place him either just before Nehemiah arrived in 445 BC, preparing the ground, or around Nehemiah’s second term after 432 BC, when the reforms had slipped. The book never names Nehemiah or Ezra, and its "governor" (Malachi 1:8) is unnamed, so the exact decade stays open. What is clear is that he spoke into the same struggle, and with the same diagnosis: the trouble in Jerusalem was not the walls but the heart.
(●) Date unknown: His book closes the prophets with Moses and Elijah, and later Jewish teachers counted him among the last of them. The book ends with two looks, one backward and one forward. Backward to Moses: "Remember the law of my servant Moses, the statutes and rules that I commanded him at Horeb for all Israel" (Malachi 4:4). Forward to Elijah: "Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the great and awesome day of the Lord comes" (Malachi 4:5). Horeb is another name for Mount Sinai, where God gave Moses the law, and "the day of the Lord" is the prophets’ phrase for the day God steps in to judge evil and set things right. In the Hebrew Bible these verses close chapter 3, which is why Hebrew Bibles count three chapters and English Bibles four. We do not know how Malachi’s life ended; the Lives of the Prophets says only that he died young and was buried in his own field, and that is legend again. What we do know is how he was remembered. The Talmud says that when the last prophets, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, died, the holy spirit of prophecy departed from Israel (Sanhedrin 11a). Christians would later call the gap that followed the four hundred silent years, and Malachi’s promise of a coming messenger the last word spoken before it.
What He Taught
(T1) God’s love for his people came first, and it stands even when they doubt it. Every argument in Malachi starts from the same place. Before God says a word about blemished sacrifices or broken marriages, he says, "I have loved you." It is a little like a parent who has to have a hard conversation with a grown child and begins by saying, before anything else, that nothing about to be said changes how much they love them. The people’s answer is the saddest line in the book: "How have you loved us?" They are poor, small and ruled by foreigners, and they cannot see it. God answers by pointing to their history. Israel and Edom both descend from twin brothers, Jacob and Esau, yet God chose Jacob’s line for his covenant (his binding promise to be their God and make them his people), while Edom, Esau’s nation, lay in ruins. The words "Esau I have hated" (Malachi 1:3) are covenant language about two peoples: God chose one nation for his purposes and passed over the other. The point Malachi draws from it is not about Edom at all. It is that Israel’s whole existence is evidence that God loved them first. Christians recognize the pattern. Scripture does not say people earn God’s love by behaving well; it says God loves first, and calls people back on the strength of that love.
(Q) "I have loved you, says the Lord. But you say, How have you loved us?" Source: Malachi 1:2 (English Standard Version). The opening words of the first dispute, and the key to the rest: every rebuke that follows is spoken by a God who has already declared his love.
(T2) Half-hearted worship dishonors God, and one day his name will be great among all the nations. Malachi’s complaint about the priests is a complaint about honor. "A son honors his father, and a servant his master. If then I am a father, where is my honor?" (Malachi 1:6). Bringing God a lame animal is like showing up to a friend’s wedding with a gift you found in a drawer and did not bother to wrap. The gift itself says what you think of the person. God would rather the temple doors were shut than keep receiving worship like that (1:10). Then, in the middle of the rebuke, Malachi turns to something astonishing. While Israel’s own priests were bored with God, God says his name "will be great among the nations," from east to west, and "in every place" a pure offering will be brought to him (Malachi 1:11). For a people taught that sacrifice belonged at one altar in Jerusalem, this was a startling horizon: the true God worshiped in every place, by peoples who had never known him. Christians read that verse as one of the Old Testament’s clearest glimpses of the church gathered from every nation.
(Q) "For from the rising of the sun to its setting my name will be great among the nations, and in every place incense will be offered to my name, and a pure offering." Source: Malachi 1:11 (English Standard Version). Spoken to priests who were offering God their worst. The contrast is deliberate: what Jerusalem treats with contempt, the nations will one day bring with reverence.
(T3) Marriage is a covenant with God as its witness, and breaking faith with a spouse is breaking faith with him. The third dispute begins with tears. The people are weeping at the altar, Malachi says, and asking why God no longer accepts their offerings (2:13). His answer goes straight into their homes. Men of Judah were divorcing the wives they had married when they were young, and some were marrying women who worshiped other gods (2:11). Malachi’s word for the wife is "companion" and "your wife by covenant" (2:14). A covenant is more than a contract. A contract says, "I will do this if you do that." A covenant says, "I bind myself to you," and it is made before God, who stands as witness. Think of a wedding where the vows are spoken before a judge who never leaves the room. Malachi says God was that witness, and that a man who sends away the wife of his youth "covers his garment with violence" (Malachi 2:16). The quarrel with God at the altar and the quarrel at home are the same quarrel. The chapter is notoriously hard to translate, and verse 16 in particular is rendered differently from one English Bible to the next. The line of thought, though, is plain: God made husband and wife one, and he takes the breaking of that bond personally.
(Q) "Because the Lord was witness between you and the wife of your youth, to whom you have been faithless, though she is your companion and your wife by covenant." Source: Malachi 2:14 (English Standard Version). The people have just asked, "Why does he not?", meaning why God no longer accepts their offerings. This is his answer: he was in the room when they made their vows, and he saw what became of them.
(T4) God will send his messenger to prepare the way, and then the Lord himself will come to his temple to refine his people. The fourth dispute starts with a cynical question: "Where is the God of justice?" (Malachi 2:17). Evil people are doing well, the people say, so either God approves of them or he is not paying attention. Malachi’s answer is that God is coming, and they may not like it when he does. First a messenger will go ahead to "prepare the way." Then "the Lord whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple" (Malachi 3:1). The one who comes is also called "the messenger of the covenant," and he arrives not as a guest but as a refiner. A silversmith heats the metal until the impurities rise to the surface and can be skimmed off; a fuller (an ancient launderer) scrubs cloth with strong soap until it is clean. "But who can endure the day of his coming?" Malachi asks (3:2). Those who wanted God to come and judge had not thought about the fact that the judging would start with them. Notice the shape of the promise: a forerunner, then the Lord himself, arriving at his own temple. That shape is exactly what the New Testament would say was fulfilled, in John the Baptist and in Jesus.
(Q) "Behold, I send my messenger, and he will prepare the way before me. And the Lord whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple; and the messenger of the covenant in whom you delight, behold, he is coming, says the Lord of hosts." Source: Malachi 3:1 (English Standard Version). This is God’s answer to the people’s taunt, "Where is the God of justice?" Its first line is the one the Gospels would quote of John the Baptist (Mark 1:2; Matthew 11:10; Luke 7:27).
(T5) God does not change, so a people who have drifted can still return, and he remembers those who fear him. "For I the Lord do not change; therefore you, O children of Jacob, are not consumed" (Malachi 3:6). The logic runs the opposite way from what we might expect. We tend to think God’s constancy is bad news for sinners, because he will not bend the rules. Malachi says it is the only reason they still exist: God made promises to Jacob, and he does not go back on them. So the door stays open. "Return to me, and I will return to you" (Malachi 3:7). Returning had a practical shape. The people had been holding back the tithe, the tenth of the harvest that supported the temple and the Levites, and Malachi tells them to bring it all and see what God will do: "put me to the test," God says, and see "if I will not open the windows of heaven for you" (Malachi 3:10). The final dispute turns on a quiet scene. While some were saying "It is vain to serve God," others who feared the Lord began talking with one another, and "a book of remembrance was written before him" (Malachi 3:16). It is the picture of a few faithful people in a cynical town, keeping each other going, and God writing their names down.
(Q) "Then those who feared the Lord spoke with one another. The Lord paid attention and heard them, and a book of remembrance was written before him of those who feared the Lord and esteemed his name." Source: Malachi 3:16 (English Standard Version). These are the faithful few in the last dispute, the ones who went on fearing God while their neighbors called it vain. The next verse calls them God’s "treasured possession" (3:17).
(Q) "Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the great and awesome day of the Lord comes. And he will turn the hearts of fathers to their children and the hearts of children to their fathers, lest I come and strike the land with a decree of utter destruction." Source: Malachi 4:5–6 (English Standard Version). The last words of the book, and in most English Bibles the last words of the Old Testament. The angel who announced John the Baptist’s birth would echo them (Luke 1:17).
What the Church Made of Him
(†) The Gospels heard his promised messenger and his returning Elijah in John the Baptist. The New Testament picks up exactly where Malachi left off. Mark’s Gospel opens with a quotation that joins Malachi 3:1 to Isaiah 40:3 under Isaiah’s name: "Behold, I send my messenger before your face, who will prepare your way" (Mark 1:2). Before John was even born, the angel told his father Zechariah that the boy would go "in the spirit and power of Elijah, to turn the hearts of the fathers to the children" (Luke 1:17), lifting the words straight from Malachi’s last verse. Jesus himself made the connection explicit. Speaking of John, he said, "This is he of whom it is written, Behold, I send my messenger before your face" (Matthew 11:10), and added, "if you are willing to accept it, he is Elijah who is to come" (Matthew 11:14). When John was asked directly whether he was Elijah, he said no (John 1:21): he was not the old prophet come back in person, but he came in Elijah’s spirit and power. That is how the Gospels read Malachi’s promise: a forerunner like Elijah, and then the Lord coming to his temple, as Jesus did.
(†) The early church read his "pure offering" in every place as the worship of the church among the nations. Malachi 1:11 became one of the Old Testament verses the early church reached for most often when it spoke of its own worship. The Didache, a short church manual from around AD 100, cites it when it tells believers to gather on the Lord’s Day and confess their sins before they break bread and give thanks, so that their sacrifice may be pure (Didache 14). Breaking bread and giving thanks is the Lord’s Supper, the meal of bread and cup Jesus gave his disciples, which the early church called the Eucharist, from the Greek word for thanksgiving. A generation or two later the verse was still being quoted. Justin Martyr, the second-century philosopher who became a Christian and died for it, argued in his Dialogue with Trypho (chapter 41) that the verse foretold the sacrifices offered by Gentiles (non-Jewish peoples) in every place, "the bread of the Eucharist, and also the cup of the Eucharist." Irenaeus, bishop of Lyons in Gaul, said the same (Against Heresies 4.17.5), and Augustine discussed the verse with the rest of Malachi in the City of God (18.35). Christians agree that the verse foresees the worship of the nations; they have read the "pure offering" itself in more than one way. The Catholic tradition, following these fathers, sees in it the sacrifice of the Mass (the Catholic name for the Eucharist, which Catholic teaching holds is a true sacrifice, making present Christ’s one offering on the cross), and the Council of Trent, the Catholic Church’s sixteenth-century council answering the Reformation, cited Malachi by name when defining it (Session 22, chapter 1). Protestant interpreters such as John Calvin read it as the spiritual worship of the gospel age, prayer and praise offered by believers in every place. Both readings take Malachi to be looking past Jerusalem to the church of every nation.
(†) Paul took up his words about Jacob and Esau in Romans, and Christians have read that use in more than one way. In Romans 9, Paul wrestles with why so many of his own people had not believed in Jesus, and he quotes Malachi: "As it is written, Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated" (Romans 9:13). The point he draws is that God’s choosing has always been his own free act, never something earned, because God chose Jacob while the twins were not yet born and "had done nothing either good or bad" (Romans 9:11). Christians have understood what that choosing is in different ways. Augustine, bishop of Hippo in North Africa, read Paul in his later writings as speaking of God’s choice of individuals for salvation, and after him so did Aquinas, the great medieval theologian, and Calvin and the Reformed tradition (the churches that grew from Calvin’s side of the Reformation). Many of the Greek fathers, the early church teachers who wrote in Greek, read it differently: John Chrysostom, the famous preacher of Antioch and Constantinople, tied God’s choice to his foreknowledge of the two men, his knowing beforehand what each would be. Arminian interpreters (named for the Dutch theologian Jacobus Arminius, a minister of the Reformed church who resisted its teaching that God chooses individuals unconditionally) and Wesleyan interpreters, John Wesley the founder of Methodism among them, read it as God’s choice of a people and their role in history, noting that in Malachi the words are about two nations, Israel and Edom. All of these readings agree on the thing Malachi himself was saying: Israel’s place in God’s purposes rested on his love, not on their merit.
(†) His refiner’s fire and his "sun of righteousness" passed into the church’s Christmas music. Because his book stands at the door of the New Testament, Malachi’s images have become part of how Christians prepare for Christmas. In Advent, the weeks of waiting before Christmas, churches read his promise of the messenger alongside the stories of John the Baptist. Two of his lines are sung every December. In Handel’s Messiah (1742), a soloist sings Malachi 3:2 in the King James wording, "But who may abide the day of His coming?" (Handel first set it for a bass and later rewrote it for an alto, the voice that usually sings it now), and the chorus follows with "And He shall purify the sons of Levi" (3:3). And Malachi’s promise that "the sun of righteousness shall rise with healing in its wings" (Malachi 4:2) is behind a line of Charles Wesley’s Christmas hymn of 1739, sung today as "Hark! The Herald Angels Sing," which says of Christ that he is "risen with healing in his wings." Christians from the early centuries on have read Malachi’s rising sun as a picture of Christ. His own record leaves nothing to set against him: he is known only through his book, and the book is a prophet doing a prophet’s work.