Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
Sophocles of Colonus c. 497 – 406 BC
(●) The Athenian tragedian who put on stage a young woman defying a king for the sake of the unwritten laws of heaven. Picture a girl kneeling in the dust outside a city at dawn, scattering handfuls of earth over her dead brother because the king has ordered that his body be left for the dogs. She knows the penalty is death. When she is dragged before the king, she does not plead that she misunderstood the order. She says that his order was never law at all, because there are older laws that no ruler wrote and no ruler can cancel. That girl is Antigone, and the man who imagined her is Sophocles. He wrote for the theater of Athens for more than sixty years, through the city’s greatest age and into its long war with Sparta, and he was its most successful playwright. Aristotle, two generations later, took one of his plays, Oedipus the King, as his chief model of what a tragedy should be. A tragedy, in the Greek sense, is a serious play in verse in which a great person falls, usually through some flaw or blindness of their own, and the audience leaves shaken and somehow wiser. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. Antigone’s speech became the classic pagan text for natural law, the moral law every human being knows without being told, and Christians have heard in it what Paul calls "the work of the law" written on the heart (Romans 2:15). And his plays are the sharpest picture the ancient world left of the human condition without the gospel: brilliant, proud, and helpless before suffering and death. He wrote about 120 plays. Seven survive whole.
(●) c. 497 BC: Born in Colonus, a village of horsemen just outside Athens, to a prosperous family. Sophocles was born around 497 or 496 BC in Colonus, a country village (a deme, the Athenian word for a local district) about a mile north of the city walls, known for its horses, its olive groves, and its nightingales. His father Sophillus was wealthy; the ancient Life of Sophocles, a short biography written centuries later and full of anecdote, says he owned slaves who worked as smiths or carpenters. The boy got the education of a gentleman’s son, including music and dance under a well-known teacher named Lamprus. He grew up in the years when Athens beat Persia. One ancient story, told by the Life and by the later writer Athenaeus, says that after the great sea victory at Salamis in 480 BC the sixteen-year-old Sophocles, known for his good looks and his skill at the lyre, led the boys’ chorus, the band of young singers and dancers, that sang the hymn of thanksgiving. It is a tradition rather than a record, but it fits: he came of age in a city that had just discovered it could do almost anything. More than seventy years later, in his last play, he set the story of Oedipus’ death in his own village and wrote one of the loveliest songs in Greek poetry in praise of it.
(●) 468 BC: At about twenty-eight he entered his first competition and beat Aeschylus. Athenian tragedy was not a night out at a commercial theater. It was a religious festival, the City Dionysia, held each spring in honor of the god Dionysus. Three playwrights were chosen each year, each presented four plays in a single day, and a panel of citizens judged the winner. Every play had its chorus, a band of citizens who sang and danced between the spoken scenes and gave voice to what the audience was feeling. Think of it as a national competition in which the whole city sat on a hillside from dawn and watched. Plutarch, the Greek biographer who wrote centuries later, tells what happened in 468 BC. The audience was so divided between the young newcomer and the great Aeschylus, the old master who had fought the Persians at Marathon, that the presiding official broke with custom. Instead of the usual panel drawn by lot, he asked the general Cimon and his fellow generals to act as judges. They gave the prize to Sophocles. The ancient sources disagree on his final tally of victories (somewhere between eighteen and twenty-four), but the Life records that when he did not win he often came second, and that he never came third, which in a field of three meant never last. He changed the art as he won at it. Aristotle credits him with adding a third speaking actor and with painted scenery, and the ancient Life says he enlarged the chorus from twelve to fifteen. A third actor sounds like a small thing; in practice it meant three-way scenes, overheard secrets, and the kind of tangled confrontation that drama still runs on.
(●) 443 BC: He served Athens as treasurer of its empire and then as a general beside Pericles. Sophocles was not a recluse in an attic. A surviving inscription lists "Sophocles of Colonus" as one of the hellenotamiai, the treasurers of the Greek allies, for the year 443/442 BC: the officials who handled the tribute money, the yearly payments Athens collected from its allies, that paid for the Athenian navy and, as it happened, for the Parthenon then rising on the Acropolis. In 441/440 BC he was elected one of the ten generals and sailed with Pericles in the war against the island of Samos. One ancient note attached to the Antigone says the Athenians elected him because they admired that play, which would put its first performance around 442 BC. That may be a later guess. The poet Ion of Chios, who met him on campaign, left a lighter story, in which Sophocles joked that Pericles thought him a fine poet but no general. Whichever story is nearer the truth, the man who wrote about kings and cities knew from the inside what it was to hold office in one.
(●) 420 BC: By ancient report he welcomed the healing god Asclepius into his own house, and Athens later honored him as a hero for it. In 420 BC the cult of Asclepius, the god of healing, was brought to Athens from Epidaurus, in a city still scarred by the plague that had killed perhaps a quarter of its people at the start of the war. Ancient sources say Sophocles received the god, in the form of his sacred snake, into his own home until a sanctuary was ready, and that he wrote a hymn (a paean) to Asclepius that was still being inscribed in stone centuries later. After his death, according to a Byzantine reference book, the Athenians worshiped him as a hero under the name Dexion, "the Receiver." A hero, in Greek religion, was not simply a brave man but a famous dead one, honored with offerings and believed to go on watching over the city, rather as a town might keep a founder’s grave and lay flowers on it every year, only with prayers attached. Some details here are late, but the picture is consistent. Sophocles was conventionally, even devoutly, religious by the standards of his city. One comic poet of his day called him "good-tempered," and Plato’s Republic remembers him in old age, asked whether he still felt the pull of desire, answering that he was glad to be free of it, as if "escaped from a mad and furious master."
(●) 413 BC: After the disaster in Sicily, a Sophocles, probably the poet, became an emergency commissioner and later helped end the democracy. In 413 BC the great Athenian expedition to Sicily was destroyed: the fleet sunk, the army killed or sent to die in the stone quarries of Syracuse. In panic the city appointed ten elderly "commissioners" (probouloi) to steer it through the emergency, and two years later those commissioners helped bring in the short-lived oligarchy of the Four Hundred. An oligarchy (Greek for "rule by the few") hands power to a small group instead of the whole citizen body, and here it meant a council of the wealthy that replaced the democracy. Did the playwright really vote for that? Aristotle preserves the exchange. Asked whether he had, like the others, voted for setting up the Four Hundred, a commissioner named Sophocles said yes. Did he not think it wicked? Yes. So he had done a wicked thing? "Yes," he said, "for there was nothing better to do." Most historians think this was the poet, then in his mid-eighties, though the name was common and certainty is not possible. If it was he, it is a very human moment: an old man in a frightened city, choosing what he believed was the lesser evil and admitting plainly that it was one. In 409 BC his Philoctetes, a play about a wounded man abandoned on an island and the soldiers sent to trick him into coming back, won first prize.
(●) 406 BC: He died at about ninety, months after his rival Euripides, having outlived the whole golden age. In the spring of 406 BC news reached Athens that Euripides, the third of the great tragedians, had died in Macedonia. At the ceremony before that year’s festival, an ancient biography of Euripides says, Sophocles appeared dressed in mourning and brought on his chorus and actors without their festive garlands. Within the year he too was dead, in 406 or 405 BC, at about ninety. How he died, nobody knows. Ancient writers offer three stories, each suspiciously literary: that he choked on an unripe grape, that he ran out of breath reading a long speech from the Antigone aloud, or that he died of joy at a victory. Early in 405 BC Aristophanes’ comedy The Frogs already treats him as among the dead, and a lost comedy by Phrynichus from the same festival called him blessed: a man who lived long, made many fine tragedies, and ended well without enduring any evil. There is one more tradition, told by the Roman orator Cicero and by the ancient Life. In old age, the story goes, his son Iophon took him to court to have him declared incompetent to manage his property, and Sophocles answered by reading the jury the play he was then writing, the Oedipus at Colonus, and asking whether it seemed the work of a feeble mind. He was acquitted. The story may be invented, but the play is real.
(●) 401 BC: His grandson staged his last play, an old man’s meditation on death set in his own village. The Oedipus at Colonus was not performed in his lifetime. His grandson, also named Sophocles, produced it in 401 BC, after Athens had lost the war, the long walls (the twin walls that joined Athens to its harbor and kept it fed by sea in wartime) had been pulled down, and the city had lived through a brief and brutal regime of thirty tyrants. The play returns to Oedipus, now old, blind, and a beggar, led by his daughter Antigone to a grove at Colonus, where he knows he is fated to die. Athens, in the person of its king Theseus, takes him in. His death is a mystery: the gods call him, he walks unassisted into the grove, and only Theseus sees what happens. A city in ruins watched an old poet, dead five years, imagine a homecoming for a ruined man, at the place where the poet himself was born.
What He Taught
(T1) There are unwritten laws of heaven, older than any city, which no human decree can override. Imagine a traffic officer ordering you to drive past a child lying in the road. You would not need a lawyer to tell you the order is void. Something in you already knows that some things are owed to people no matter who commands otherwise. That is the situation of the Antigone. After a civil war in which two brothers have killed each other, the new king Creon decrees that the one who attacked the city, Polyneices, must lie unburied. For a Greek this was an outrage against the gods and the dead alike. His sister Antigone buries him anyway, and when Creon asks whether she knew the edict, she answers that it was not Zeus who proclaimed it, and that no mortal’s decree can override the "unwritten and unfailing statutes of heaven," which are "not of to-day or yesterday, but from all time." Sophocles does not make it easy. Creon is not a cartoon villain; he speaks well about order and loyalty to the city, and Antigone is harsh and alone. But the play leaves no doubt who is right. Creon’s stubbornness destroys his son, his wife, and his own happiness, and he ends the play admitting that he was wrong. This is the idea Aristotle would call the law of nature: a justice binding on all people that a ruler can break but never repeal. Christians recognize it as the moral law God wrote into human nature, the one Paul says even pagans "by nature" know (Romans 2:14).
(Q) "Yes; for it was not Zeus that had published me that edict; not such are the laws set among men by the justice who dwells with the gods below; nor deemed I that thy decrees were of such force, that a mortal could override the unwritten and unfailing statutes of heaven. For their life is not of to-day or yesterday, but from all time, and no man knows when they were first put forth." Source: Sophocles, Antigone 450–457 (Jebb translation). Antigone to Creon, who has just asked whether she dared to transgress his law. Aristotle quotes the last lines twice in his Rhetoric as the textbook example of an appeal to the law of nature over the written law.
(T2) Man is the most wonderful and the most dangerous thing in the world, master of everything except death. The chorus of the Antigone sings what may be the most famous song in Greek tragedy, often called the Ode on Man. It is a hymn of astonishment. Man crosses the stormy sea, ploughs the earth year after year with horses, nets the birds and fish, tames the horse and the mountain bull, teaches himself speech and thought and the arts of government, builds houses against the frost and rain. He has a resource for everything. Then the song turns twice. First: against death alone he has found no remedy. Second: his cleverness carries him "now to evil, now to good," and the man who honors the laws and the gods makes his city great, while the man who in his recklessness lives with wrong is a man without a city. The Greek word the song opens with, deinos, is the hinge of the whole thing. It means wonderful and terrible at once, the way we might call a storm at sea awesome and mean both its beauty and its danger. Christian readers know this double portrait well. Psalm 8 marvels that God made man "a little lower than the heavenly beings" and gave him dominion over the beasts, birds, and fish (Psalm 8:5–8); Genesis 3 shows what that power does when it turns against its maker. Sophocles saw both halves clearly. What he could not see was any answer to the line about death.
(Q) "Wonders are many, and none is more wonderful than man." Source: Sophocles, Antigone 332–333 (Jebb translation). The opening of the Ode on Man. Later in the same song comes the turn: "only against Death shall he call for aid in vain; but from baffling maladies he hath devised escapes" (Antigone 361–364, Jebb translation).
(T3) A man may solve every riddle but his own, so call no one happy until his life is over. Everyone has had the experience of searching the whole house for their glasses while wearing them. Oedipus the King is that experience turned into terror. Oedipus is the cleverest man in Thebes. Years before, he saved the city by answering the riddle of the Sphinx, a monster that killed everyone who failed it. Now a plague is killing the city, and the god Apollo says it will end only when the murderer of the old king Laius is found. Oedipus vows to find him, and pursues the truth with all his famous intelligence, ignoring every warning to stop, until he discovers that he is the man: that he killed his father without knowing him and married his mother without knowing her. His wife and mother hangs herself; he blinds himself with the pins of her dress. The play is not about a man punished for a sin he chose; Oedipus never meant to do what he did. It is about the limits of human knowledge. The man who could see through every puzzle was blind about the thing nearest to him, and the closing lines draw the lesson the Greeks knew from Solon, the wise lawgiver of early Athens: no one can be called happy until his life has ended free of disaster. Scripture says something close and then goes further: "The heart is deceitful above all things" (Jeremiah 17:9), and so we need to be searched and known by someone who sees us better than we see ourselves (Psalm 139:23–24).
(Q) "Therefore wait to see life’s ending ere thou count one mortal blest; Wait till free from pain and sorrow he has gained his final rest." Source: Sophocles, Oedipus the King 1528–1530 (Storr translation). The last words of the play, spoken over the blinded Oedipus, who "knew the Sphinx’s riddle and was mightiest in our state."
(T4) The gods bring down the proud and love the humble of heart. The Greeks had a word for the sin that runs through Sophocles’ plays: hubris, the arrogance that forgets you are mortal and acts as if you were a god. A champion athlete who mocks the referee, a ruler who thinks the rules are for other people: that is hubris, and in Greek tragedy it always ends in a fall. The Ajax shows it at its starkest. Ajax is the mightiest Greek warrior at Troy after Achilles, and he has boasted that he needs no help from the gods. Furious at being denied Achilles’ armor, he sets out at night to murder the Greek commanders. The goddess Athena drives him mad, and he slaughters a flock of sheep and cattle instead, believing them to be his enemies. When he wakes and sees what he has done, he kills himself from shame. Athena shows the mad Ajax to his rival Odysseus. Odysseus does not gloat; he pities him, because he sees that he himself is no more than a shadow. Then Athena draws the lesson: never speak proudly against the gods, because a single day can bring all mortal greatness low. The thought is very near Scripture’s "God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble" (James 4:6, quoting Proverbs 3:34). The difference is in the goddess. Athena in the play mocks the madman she has made; the God of Scripture humbles the proud in order to give grace.
(Q) "For a day can bring all mortal greatness low, And a day can lift it up. But the gods love The wise of heart, the froward they abhor." Source: Sophocles, Ajax 131–133 (Trevelyan translation). Athena to Odysseus, after showing him the mad Ajax. "Froward" is an old English word for stubbornly perverse, the person who will not be turned.
(Q) "’Tis not my nature to join in hating, but in loving." Source: Sophocles, Antigone 523 (Jebb translation). Creon has just told Antigone that an enemy is never a friend, not even in death, so her brother deserved no burial. Her reply is perhaps the most quoted line she speaks, and it reaches toward something the gospel would make central: a love that outlasts enmity. Creon’s answer is to send her to her death.
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Antigone’s unwritten law became the classic pagan witness to the moral law written on the heart. Aristotle did the first and decisive work. In his Rhetoric he divides law into the particular laws each community writes and a "universal law," the law of nature, a "natural justice and injustice that is binding on all men," and he gives Antigone as his example: she means, he says, that burying her brother was just by nature. Through Aristotle, her speech entered the long tradition of natural law, the conviction that right and wrong are written into what human beings are rather than invented by rulers, which Thomas Aquinas and the Christian centuries built into the foundations of Western ethics and law. Christians had their own reason to welcome her. Paul writes that Gentiles (non-Jews) who never received the law of Moses still "show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness" (Romans 2:15). Antigone is almost an illustration of that verse: a pagan with no Bible who knows that some duties outrank any king. And when the apostles stood before the council in Jerusalem, forbidden to preach, they gave her answer in its fullest form: "We must obey God rather than men" (Acts 5:29). That is the deepest thing Sophocles gave Christian apologetics: a witness from inside paganism that the moral law is not a human invention. The Christian adds only the question Antigone could not answer: if there is a law above all kings, who wrote it?
(†) Clement of Alexandria quoted him as a witness to the one God, though the lines he quoted were not genuine. The early Christian apologists, the writers who defended the faith to educated pagans, loved to show that the best Greek poets had glimpsed the truth. Clement of Alexandria, a Christian teacher in Egypt around AD 200, quotes Sophocles often, and in his Exhortation to the Greeks he cites a striking passage: "One, in truth, one is God, Who made both heaven and the far-stretching earth," followed by a rebuke of mortals who set up images of gods "of stone, or wood, or brass, or gold, or ivory." The same verses appear in the work On the Sole Government of God, which came down under Justin Martyr’s name. Honesty requires the footnote. Those lines appear in no surviving play, and scholars agree they are not by Sophocles. They almost certainly come from a Jewish writer of the last centuries before Christ who put monotheist verses into the mouths of famous Greek poets, and Clement himself, in his Stromata, says he found them in a book on Abraham attributed to the historian Hecataeus. Clement was not inventing anything; he was trusting a source he had no means of checking. The genuine Sophocles makes a quieter but sounder case. His plays show a pagan who believed the gods were real, that they punished pride and guarded the helpless dead, and that human beings were answerable to them. That is general revelation, the knowledge of God and of right and wrong available to everyone through creation and conscience, at work in a first-rate mind.
(†) Christian scribes and schoolmasters kept him alive, copying his seven school plays for a thousand years. Of roughly 120 plays, why do exactly seven survive? Because teachers in the schools of the Roman Empire, probably by the second or third century AD and before the empire was Christian, settled on seven for the classroom, and then in the Christian Byzantine Empire, the Greek-speaking eastern half of the Roman world, monks and scholars kept copying those seven for a thousand years. The oldest complete manuscript, now in Florence and known as the Laurentian manuscript, was copied in the tenth century AD, and three plays (Ajax, Electra, and Oedipus the King) were so central to Byzantine schooling that they survive in some two hundred copies. The church that judged his gods false nonetheless taught its children to read him, because Christians had long held, with Basil of Caesarea in his address to young men on reading Greek literature, that pagan writers could train the mind and even point toward virtue if read with discernment. Apart from a few papyri dug from the Egyptian sand, everything modern readers know of Sophocles passed through Christian hands.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: gods who mock the fallen, and a world in which death has the last word. Sophocles saw human greatness and human misery as clearly as anyone before Christ. But the plays also say things the gospel denies. - The gods. His gods are just in the long run but not loving. Athena laughs at the madness she inflicts on Ajax, and Oedipus is destroyed for deeds he did in ignorance, by an oracle spoken before he was born. Scripture’s God also humbles the proud, but he does it to save them, and he "gives grace to the humble" (James 4:6). - Life itself. The chorus of his last play sings that "Not to be born is, past all prizing, best," and that next best by far is to go back as quickly as possible to where one came from (Oedipus at Colonus 1224–1227, Jebb translation). Scripture knows that despair too (Ecclesiastes 4:2–3; Job 3:3), but it never makes it the last word, because the world is God’s good creation and life is his gift. - Death. The Ode on Man ends with death as the one enemy man cannot master (T2). For Sophocles that was simply true. The gospel’s whole claim is that one man did master it: "Death is swallowed up in victory" (1 Corinthians 15:54), and Christ came to "deliver all those who through fear of death were subject to lifelong slavery" (Hebrews 2:15). - Suffering. In his plays suffering teaches, and sometimes, as with the old Oedipus, it ends in a mysterious peace. Antigone dies for her brother’s honor, but no one suffers in another’s place to take away his guilt. The tragedy of the innocent sufferer is left open, and the gospel answers it with the one innocent who suffered willingly for the guilty. Sophocles stands at the edge of what the Greek mind could see without revelation. He knew there was a law above kings, that pride is fatal, and that no one can see himself truly. He did not know who wrote the law, who humbles the proud in order to lift them, or who has conquered death.