Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

Sam Harris of Los Angeles b. 1967 AD

(●) The neuroscientist and meditator who became the New Atheism’s moralist, arguing that faith deserves no shelter from criticism and that science can answer moral questions. + In the first decade of this century four writers turned unbelief into a bestseller list: Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, Christopher Hitchens, and Sam Harris. Journalists called the movement the New Atheism. Dawkins brought biology to it, Dennett philosophy, Hitchens wit and fury. Harris brought something the others mostly did not: a moral argument. Religious faith, he said, is not merely mistaken but dangerous, and the decent thing is to stop treating it politely. He is on a Christian apologetics site for that reason, and for a second one that surprises people. The same man who wrote that faith should lose its protected status also spent years in silent meditation retreats in Asia, insists that spiritual experience is real, and denies, with unusual bluntness, that anyone has free will. His positions press on three questions a Christian has to be able to answer: what faith actually is, where moral truth comes from, and whether there is anyone home behind the eyes to choose, to love, and to be saved. A signature fact to remember him by: he began writing his first book on September 12, 2001, the day after the attacks on New York and Washington.

(●) 1967 AD: Born in Los Angeles to an actor and a television writer, and raised in a secular home. + Samuel Benjamin Harris was born in Los Angeles on April 9, 1967. His father, Berkeley Harris, was an actor who came from a Quaker background; his mother, Susan Harris (born Spivak), came from a Jewish family and went on to become one of the most successful writers in American television, the creator of Soap and The Golden Girls. His parents divorced when he was two, and he was raised by his mother. The household was neither religious nor hostile to religion. God was simply not discussed much, and Harris has said that he grew up with no strong views about faith one way or the other. His father died when Sam was seventeen. Nothing in the boyhood, as far as the public record goes, predicted the man who would later be called one of the "Four Horsemen" of unbelief.

(●) c. 1986 AD: A drug experience at Stanford sent him out of college and into eleven years of meditation in Asia and America. + Harris went to Stanford University to study English. In his second year, by his own account, he and a friend took MDMA (the drug sold on the street as ecstasy), and the experience changed his life: for a few hours he found that he wished his friend nothing but well, without any sense of self-interest in the wishing. He came away convinced that the mind could be changed deeply and on purpose, and that the old contemplative traditions had been exploring how. He left Stanford not long afterward. For the next eleven years he studied meditation, much of the time in India and Nepal, with Tibetan Buddhist teachers including Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche and Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche ("Rinpoche" is a Tibetan title of respect for a teacher, meaning roughly "precious one"), and in Western retreat centers with teachers of the Theravada tradition such as Joseph Goldstein. Theravada, "the teaching of the elders," is the older school of Buddhism found in Sri Lanka and Southeast Asia, and its Western teachers are best known for mindfulness: the plain practice of noticing, moment by moment, what is happening in the body and mind. He has estimated his time on silent retreats at about two years in all: days and weeks without speaking, reading, or writing, doing nothing but paying attention. Picture spending the better part of two years with your own mind as your only company, and you have some sense of why he would never afterward dismiss the inner life as mere superstition. In 1997 he went back to Stanford, this time to study philosophy, and took his degree in 2000.

(●) 2001 AD: The day after the September 11 attacks he began The End of Faith, and it made him famous. + On September 11, 2001, nineteen men who believed they would be rewarded in paradise flew airliners into buildings. Harris started writing the next day. His conviction was simple and uncomfortable: the men had done exactly what they believed, and the real problem was not that a few people misused religion but that whole societies treated belief without evidence as a virtue, which left no common ground from which to argue anyone out of anything. The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason appeared from W. W. Norton in 2004. It spent many weeks on the New York Times bestseller list and won the PEN/Martha Albrand Award for First Nonfiction in 2005. It was hard on Islam, hard on Christianity, and almost as hard on religious moderates, whom he accused of giving cover to the fundamentalists by insisting that faith itself must never be criticized. In 2004 he also married Annaka Gorton, a writer and editor who would later write on consciousness herself.

(●) 2006 AD: Thousands of letters, the angriest from Christians, drew from him a short reply, Letter to a Christian Nation. + American readers of The End of Faith wrote to him in large numbers, many of them Christians, many of them furious. His answer was a book short enough to read in an evening, addressed directly to the Christian reader who believes the Bible is the word of God. Letter to a Christian Nation (Knopf, 2006) pressed on suffering, on the moral teaching of the Old Testament, on the conflict he saw between faith and science, and on the claim that morality needs God. It too became a bestseller. The next year, on September 30, 2007, he sat down in Christopher Hitchens’s apartment in Washington with Hitchens, Dawkins, and Dennett for a filmed two-hour conversation. The video circulated widely under the title "The Four Horsemen," a name the four took up half in jest, and the conversation was published as a book in 2019. Back in 2007, the year of that conversation, he and his wife also founded Project Reason, a nonprofit meant to spread scientific and secular thinking.

(●) 2009 AD: He earned a doctorate in neuroscience, then argued in public that science can answer moral questions. + While he was writing bestsellers, Harris was also working toward a Ph.D. in cognitive neuroscience at UCLA under Mark Cohen. His research put people in an fMRI scanner (a machine that tracks which parts of the brain are working hardest) and asked them to judge statements true, false, or undecidable, some ordinary ("Alexander the Great was a very famous military leader") and some religious ("Jesus Christ really performed the miracles attributed to him in the Bible"). He reported that the brain seems to handle believing a religious claim and believing an ordinary fact in much the same way. The doctorate was awarded in 2009, and his dissertation became the basis of The Moral Landscape: How Science Can Determine Human Values (Free Press, 2010). In the summer of 2009, the year of his doctorate, he also took a public stand that Christian readers remember. When Francis Collins, the geneticist and evangelical Christian who led the Human Genome Project, was nominated to direct the National Institutes of Health, Harris argued in the New York Times that Collins’s public faith should count against him. The Senate confirmed Collins anyway. On April 7, 2011, at the University of Notre Dame, he debated the Christian philosopher William Lane Craig on the question "Is the Foundation of Morality Natural or Supernatural?", one of the best-known exchanges he has had with a Christian thinker.

(●) 2012 AD: He denied free will in one short book and defended spirituality without religion in another, and puzzled friends on both sides. + In 2012 Harris published Free Will, a book of fewer than a hundred pages arguing that the ordinary feeling of being the author of one’s choices is an illusion. His fellow atheist Daniel Dennett answered it with a long, sharp review; Christians answered it too. The year before, he had published Lying, a short essay arguing that we should never tell even the small social lies most people think harmless. In 2014 came Waking Up: A Guide to Spirituality Without Religion, part memoir, part neuroscience, part meditation manual. It surprised many of his secular readers. The man who had written that faith deserved no shelter from criticism now argued that the experiences mystics describe are real and worth seeking, so long as they are pursued without doctrine. That October he clashed on television with the actor Ben Affleck over whether criticism of Islam is bigotry, an exchange that made him a lightning rod for years. A dialogue with the Muslim reformer Maajid Nawaz followed, Islam and the Future of Tolerance (2015).

(●) 2013 AD: A podcast and later a meditation app became his main work, and long conversation replaced the attack book. + In September 2013 Harris began a podcast, first called Waking Up and later renamed Making Sense. Most of his work since has happened there, in long conversations with scientists, philosophers, journalists, and opponents, a few of them Christians. In 2018 he held public dialogues with the psychologist Jordan Peterson on whether religion is needed for meaning and morality, and in the same year he launched the Waking Up app, which teaches meditation and has since grown into a large part of his work. A selection of the conversations appeared as Making Sense (2020). The later years brought quarrels with former allies as well as old opponents. He left Twitter in late November 2022, explaining on his podcast that the platform had become bad for his own mind and conduct. He is still writing and speaking, and his views on faith, morality, and free will have not changed in substance since the books that made him known.

What He Taught

(T1) Faith is belief without evidence, and it deserves no shelter from criticism. + Imagine a neighbor who tells you, quite calmly, that a diamond the size of a refrigerator is buried in his back yard. You ask how he knows. He says he has no evidence, but believing it makes him happy, and his parents believed it too. You would not admire his faith. You would worry about him, and you would worry more if he started digging up your yard. That is Harris’s picture of religious belief. Faith, as he uses the word, means believing a claim about the world more firmly than the evidence warrants. In every other part of life we treat that as a fault; only in religion, he argues, do we call it a virtue and agree not to question it. And because beliefs drive actions, a society that protects unevidenced belief has disarmed itself against the most dangerous ones. His harshest words were for religious moderates, whom he accused of keeping that protection in place for everyone. Christians reply that he has defined faith in a way the New Testament does not. In the Bible faith is trust in a person, and the trust is meant to rest on testimony and evidence: Luke writes so that his reader "may have certainty" (Luke 1:3–4), and Paul stakes the whole faith on a public event that could in principle be checked (1 Corinthians 15:14). The disagreement is not only about whether God exists but about what believing in him has ever meant.

(Q) "We have names for people who have many beliefs for which there is no rational justification. When their beliefs are extremely common we call them 'religious'; otherwise, they are likely to be called 'mad,' 'psychotic,' or 'delusional.'" + Source: Sam Harris, The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason (New York: W. W. Norton, 2004; paperback 2005), chapter 2, "The Nature of Belief," p. 72. The line is the book at its most provocative: the claim that only numbers separate religious belief from delusion (T1).

(T2) Morality is about the well-being of conscious creatures, so science can in principle answer moral questions. + Think about health. Doctors cannot give a perfect definition of it, and it means different things for a child and a marathon runner, yet nobody concludes that health is a matter of opinion. Some diets really are better than others, and a man coughing blood really is worse off than one who is not. Harris argues that morality is like that. His starting point is a thought experiment he called "the worst possible misery for everyone": a world in which every creature suffers as much as it can for as long as it can. Anyone who understands the words, he says, can see that such a world is bad, and that any move away from it is a move toward the good. Morality, on this view, simply is the pursuit of the well-being of conscious creatures, and since well-being depends on facts about brains, bodies, and societies, the sciences of the mind can in principle tell us which ways of living are better and worse. The space of possible lives is the "moral landscape" of his title, with peaks of flourishing and valleys of misery. The book aimed at two targets at once: religious people who say morality needs God, and secular academics who say morality is only preference. Christian critics have answered that he quietly assumes what he set out to prove. That misery is bad and well-being ought to be pursued is itself a moral claim, and no brain scan supplies it. A scan can show that a tortured man’s pain centers are firing; it cannot show that someone ought to stop the torturer. That gap is where the moral argument for God lives. The moral argument says, in its simplest form, that if some things really are right or wrong whether anyone agrees or not (cruelty for fun, say), then something has to make them so, and a good God is the best explanation of what that something is. So the question it raises is not how we know right from wrong, which Harris and his critics mostly agree we can, but what makes anything right or wrong at all.

(Q) "...we can speak about the well-being of conscious creatures rationally, and in the context of science." + Source: Sam Harris, "Toward a Science of Morality," published on his website, May 6, 2010, a summary of the case he made at length in The Moral Landscape later that year (T2). The words close his complaint that science’s silence about values had handed religion a nearly uncontested claim to be the authority on morality. That surrender, he wrote, had been unnecessary, and these words are the reason he gave.

(T3) Free will is an illusion: no one is the ultimate author of his own choices. + Try a small test. Think of a city, any city. Now ask yourself why that one came to mind and not another. You did not survey every city you know and weigh them; one simply appeared. Harris says every choice is like that if you watch closely enough. Thoughts and intentions arise in consciousness out of causes you did not choose and cannot see, from genes, upbringing, and the state of your brain a moment before. So he denies free will outright, and he means the kind most people assume they have. Philosophers call it libertarian free will (the word has nothing to do with politics): the power to be the true source of a choice, so that the choice starts with you rather than merely passing through you. Its ordinary mark is that you could have chosen otherwise with everything else the same. Harris says no one has that power. He also rejects a gentler position that philosophers call compatibilism. A compatibilist says freedom survives even if every choice is fixed by prior causes, because freedom just means acting on your own desires without outside force. Think of two men handing over their wallets: one to a robber holding a gun, the other to a church collection plate because he wants to give. Both acts were caused, says the compatibilist, but only the second was free, since only the second came from the man’s own wishes. To Harris that is a change of subject. Your wishes, too, arrived from causes you never chose. If he is right, nobody deserves blame in the old sense. He drew from that a humane conclusion, that hatred loses its footing, while still building prisons for the dangerous; if we could lock up earthquakes and hurricanes, he wrote, we would build prisons for them as well. Christians have pressed on the cost. Scripture everywhere addresses people as able to answer God’s call or refuse it ("choose life," Deuteronomy 30:19), and Christian philosophers have asked whether a person who cannot author a belief can be said to reason his way to it, including to the belief that free will is an illusion.

(Q) "Free will is an illusion. Our wills are simply not of our own making." + Source: Sam Harris, Free Will (New York: Free Press, 2012), p. 5. The opening thesis of the book, stated in its first pages with no preliminaries (T3).

(T4) The self is an illusion that meditation can see through, and spiritual experience needs no religion. + Most of us feel that we live somewhere behind our eyes, a little thinker who has thoughts and steers the body. Harris says that if you look for that thinker in meditation, carefully and long enough, you do not find him. There are thoughts, sights, sounds, and sensations, but no one standing apart from them to whom they happen. Seeing this, he argues, is what the great contemplatives were really after, and it brings a freedom from anxiety and grasping that is open to anyone who practices, with no creed required. That is why the same author can attack religion and praise mysticism in one book. Mysticism, as he uses the word, is the practice of examining consciousness directly, and he counts it as an experiment anyone can repeat; religion, in his view, attaches that experience to unevidenced claims about gods and scriptures. He is especially drawn to the Buddhist and Hindu traditions he studied in his twenties, which he thinks came closest to describing the mind accurately. Christians answer that the experiences are real and that his reading of them is not the only one. The Christian contemplative tradition knows the quieting of the self too, but as the self being made whole in love rather than dissolved: the God of Scripture calls people by name (Isaiah 43:1).

(Q) "Mysticism is a rational enterprise. Religion is not." + Source: Sam Harris, The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason (New York: W. W. Norton, 2004; paperback 2005), chapter 7, "Experiments in Consciousness," p. 221. The book that made his name attacking faith closes by commending contemplative experience, the seed of Waking Up ten years later (T4).

(Q) "We should not call ourselves 'atheists.'" + Source: Sam Harris, "The Problem with Atheism," an address to the Atheist Alliance conference in Washington, D.C., September 28, 2007, published on his website October 2, 2007. Speaking to a room full of atheists, he argued that atheism is not a worldview and that the label turned critics of religion into "a marginal interest group that meets in hotel ballrooms," when what he wanted was simply for bad ideas to lose the argument. It was a telling moment: the most moralistic of the New Atheists wanted to be judged not by what he rejected but by what he thought worth defending.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) Christian writers answered him directly, and his challenge sharpened the moral argument for God. + Because Harris wrote to Christians by name, Christians wrote back. The pastor and author Douglas Wilson answered Letter to a Christian Nation with a reply of the same shape and length, Letter from a Christian Citizen (2007). The Oxford mathematician John Lennox took on Harris along with the other New Atheists in Gunning for God (2011). The most important exchange was the Notre Dame debate of 2011. William Lane Craig drew a distinction that Christian philosophers have used ever since when they meet Harris’s argument (T2). There is moral epistemology, the question of how we come to know what is right, and moral ontology, the question of what makes anything right in the first place. It is the difference between knowing a bridge will hold you and knowing what holds the bridge up: a commuter can be sure of the first every morning without a word of engineering. Craig granted that atheists can know right from wrong perfectly well; Paul says as much when he writes that Gentiles who never had the law show its work written on their hearts (Romans 2:14–15). His question was what grounds the rightness. Simply defining "good" as "well-being," he argued, assumes the very thing in dispute, and a universe of particles gives no reason why anyone ought to care about a stranger’s flourishing. Harris’s book carried the moral argument for God before a wide new audience, and its defenders sharpened it against him.

(†) His denial of free will showed how much hangs on it, and believers found common ground in his hatred of lies and cruelty. + Harris’s Free Will was useful to Christian philosophers in an unexpected way: it showed, more candidly than most writers had, what follows if every choice is the product of earlier causes the chooser never chose. Harris pressed the point further than a materialist (someone who holds that matter and its motions are all there is) needs to: even if people had immortal souls, he argued, the soul’s states would be just as unchosen, and the conclusion would stand. Moral blame in the ordinary sense goes, and so does the picture of a person weighing reasons and choosing to follow the best one. Christian defenders of free will cited the book as evidence that the stakes of the question are as high as they had said. There was common ground, too, and fair-minded Christian readers named it. His insistence on never lying, even in small ways, is closer to Scripture’s command than most people’s habits are: "Therefore, having put away falsehood, let each one of you speak the truth with his neighbor, for we are members one of another" (Ephesians 4:25). His outrage at cruelty done in God’s name, and his admission that spiritual experience is real and that secular culture has neglected it, found Christian readers agreeing with more than they expected.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: on what faith is, what grounds goodness, and whether there is a self to save. + The disagreement runs to the root, and it is fairest to say it plainly. - Faith. Harris defines faith as belief without evidence. The New Testament presents it as trust resting on witnesses: John wrote "so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name" (John 20:31), and Paul conceded that if Christ has not been raised, "your faith is in vain" (1 Corinthians 15:14). A faith that could be shown false is not belief without evidence. - Goodness. Harris holds that well-being is the good. Scripture agrees that human flourishing matters immensely, but grounds it in the God whose image every person bears: "So God created man in his own image" (Genesis 1:27). Well-being matters because persons matter, and persons matter because of whose they are. - The will. Harris teaches that no one authors his choices. Scripture addresses human beings as answerable agents to the end: "I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse. Therefore choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19). - The self. Harris teaches that the self is an illusion and that freedom lies in seeing through it. The gospel promises not the dissolving of the self but its rescue and resurrection: "Fear not, for I have redeemed you; I have called you by name, you are mine" (Isaiah 43:1). He has asked Christians the hardest questions of his generation, and asked them in public. The church’s best answer has been to take them seriously enough to answer them in kind, "with gentleness and respect" (1 Peter 3:15).

Harris is a living author, and the shelf is still growing. His books are all in print; his essays and talks are archived on his website, and most of his work since 2013 has been spoken rather than written, on his podcast and in his meditation app. The list below covers the books, the major essays, and his scientific papers. Books on religion and reason: - The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason (W. W. Norton, 2004): Begun the day after September 11, 2001; argues that faith, belief without evidence, is the root danger and that religious moderation shields it. Closes with a chapter commending meditation. Winner of the 2005 PEN/Martha Albrand Award for First Nonfiction (T1, T4). - Letter to a Christian Nation (Alfred A. Knopf, 2006): A short open letter to American Christians, answering the readers who wrote to him after the first book; on suffering, biblical morality, science, and the claim that morality needs God. - Islam and the Future of Tolerance: A Dialogue, with Maajid Nawaz (Harvard University Press, 2015): A conversation between Harris and a former Islamist turned reformer on whether Islam can be reformed and how criticism of it should be conducted. Books on morality, the will, and the mind: - The Moral Landscape: How Science Can Determine Human Values (Free Press, 2010): The argument that morality concerns the well-being of conscious creatures and that science can in principle discover moral truths; grew out of his doctoral dissertation (T2). - Lying (Four Elephants Press, 2011; expanded edition 2013): A short essay arguing that we should not tell even white lies, drawn from a seminar he took at Stanford with the philosopher Ronald Howard. - Free Will (Free Press, 2012): Under a hundred pages; argues that the sense of authoring one’s choices is an illusion and that both libertarian freedom and compatibilism fail (T3). - Waking Up: A Guide to Spirituality Without Religion (Simon & Schuster, 2014): Memoir, neuroscience, and meditation instruction; argues that the self is an illusion and that contemplative experience can be had without religious belief (T4). - Making Sense: Conversations on Consciousness, Morality, and the Future of Humanity (Ecco, 2020): Edited transcripts of conversations from his podcast with scientists and philosophers. Collaborations: - The Four Horsemen: The Conversation That Sparked an Atheist Revolution, with Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, and Christopher Hitchens (Random House, 2019): The transcript of the 2007 filmed conversation, with an essay from each surviving participant. Selected essays and talks: - "The Problem with Atheism" (2007): An address to the Atheist Alliance arguing that unbelievers should drop the label "atheist." - "Science Is in the Details" (New York Times, July 2009): His objection to Francis Collins’s appointment to lead the National Institutes of Health. - "Toward a Science of Morality" (2010): A short statement of the thesis of The Moral Landscape. Scientific papers: - "Functional Neuroimaging of Belief, Disbelief, and Uncertainty," with Sameer A. Sheth and Mark S. Cohen, Annals of Neurology 63 (2008): The first published fMRI study from his doctoral work, comparing the brain’s response to statements judged true, false, and undecidable. - "The Neural Correlates of Religious and Nonreligious Belief," with Jonas T. Kaplan and others, PLoS ONE 4 (2009): Compares belief in religious and ordinary statements and reports largely shared brain activity. - "Neural Correlates of Maintaining One’s Political Beliefs in the Face of Counterevidence," with Jonas T. Kaplan and Sarah I. Gimbel, Scientific Reports 6 (2016): How the brain responds when strongly held political beliefs are challenged. Spoken work: the Making Sense podcast (2013 to the present, originally titled Waking Up) and the Waking Up meditation app (2018 to the present). Christian replies: Douglas Wilson, Letter from a Christian Citizen (American Vision, 2007); John Lennox, Gunning for God (Lion, 2011); William Lane Craig and Sam Harris, "Is the Foundation of Morality Natural or Supernatural?" (debate, University of Notre Dame, April 7, 2011).
Playlist
Justified True Belief