Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Gamaliel the Elder of Jerusalem fl. c. 20 – c. 50 AD
(●) The great Pharisee teacher of Jerusalem, who trained the apostle Paul and talked the council out of killing the apostles. Most of the people who appear in the book of Acts walk on for a scene and walk off again. Gamaliel walks on twice, and both times something large turns on him. In the first scene, the apostles are on trial for their lives before the Sanhedrin, the supreme Jewish council in Jerusalem, and a single speech from him sends them home alive (Acts 5:34–40). In the second, Paul, defending himself to a hostile crowd from the steps of the Roman barracks beside the Temple, names him as his teacher: "educated at the feet of Gamaliel according to the strict manner of the law of our fathers" (Acts 22:3). He was a Pharisee, a member of the lay movement within Judaism that held the written Law of Moses together with an oral tradition of how to keep it, and that believed in the resurrection of the dead. His own people remembered him as one of their greatest: the rabbis, the teachers whose discussions were later written down in the Mishnah (the first great written collection of Jewish oral law, finished around AD 200) and the Talmud (the vast commentary built on it), call him Rabban Gamaliel the Elder, "the Elder" to tell him apart from his grandson of the same name. A third collection, the Tosefta (Aramaic for "addition"), gathers material the Mishnah left out, and several of the stories about him come from it. He is on a Christian site because the church owes him its life twice over: once for the speech that let it survive its first legal crisis, and once for the education of the man who would carry its message to the Gentiles. He also matters as a witness. His few surviving sayings and rulings show a learned, careful, humane Judaism at the very moment the gospel was first preached in Jerusalem. His dates are a convention. No source gives the year of his birth, and the years of his activity (roughly AD 20 to 50) are worked out from Acts, from his grandfather Hillel, and from a later Jewish tradition that he died about eighteen years before the Temple fell. Every date in his life is an estimate, and each one is marked as an estimate where it appears.
(●) Late 1st century BC or early 1st century AD: He was born, by his own people’s reckoning, into the house of Hillel. Nobody recorded the day Gamaliel was born, or the year, or the town. What his people did record was his family. The Talmud lists the men who led the Jewish community while the Temple still stood as "Hillel, and Simeon, Gamaliel, and Simeon," four men across a hundred years (Shabbath 15a), and the tradition reads the list as father, son, grandson, and great-grandson. That makes Gamaliel the grandson of Hillel, the gentle Babylonian sage whose school became the dominant voice among the Pharisees. Of his father Simeon nothing is known beyond the name. Acts never mentions the family, and the list was written down centuries later, so the relationship is a tradition rather than a recorded fact. But it is the tradition of Gamaliel’s own people about their own leaders, it fits everything else known about him, and it is generally accepted. Growing up in that house would have meant growing up inside the arguments of the Law: what counts as work on the Sabbath, when the tithe is due (the tenth of every harvest and flock that the Law set aside for God), how a court should weigh a witness. For a boy of that family, the Law was not a set of rules on a shelf but the family business.
(●) c. 15–30 AD (conventional): He taught the Law in Jerusalem, and a young man from Tarsus sat at his feet. In the ancient world, a student did not take notes in a lecture hall. He sat on the floor while the teacher sat on a raised seat, and he listened, memorized, asked, and was asked. "At the feet of" was the ordinary phrase for being someone’s pupil, the way we might say someone "trained under" a famous surgeon. The one pupil we can name is Saul of Tarsus, the future apostle Paul, who came from a Greek-speaking city in what is now southern Turkey to be "brought up in this city, educated at the feet of Gamaliel according to the strict manner of the law of our fathers" (Acts 22:3). Paul’s own letters describe what that education produced: "as to the law, a Pharisee" (Philippians 3:5), "advancing in Judaism beyond many of my own age" (Galatians 1:14). The years of his study are not given anywhere; scholars place them roughly between AD 15 and 30 by working back from the rest of his life. Curiously, Acts is the only ancient source that names a pupil of his. The rabbinic tradition remembers him as a judge and a leader rather than as a head of school, though it does preserve one teacherly saying credited to him, a sorting of students into four kinds by comparing them to fish: the poor man’s son who has learned everything but understands nothing, the rich man’s son who has learned and understood, the student who knows it all but cannot answer back, and the student who knows it and can answer (Avot de-Rabbi Natan 40). That book, "The Fathers According to Rabbi Nathan," is a later companion to the Mishnah’s collection of the sages’ sayings, expanding each saying with stories. The details of the fish have puzzled readers ever since, but the point is clear enough: knowing the material is not the same as being able to use it.
(●) c. 20–50 AD: From the steps of the Temple Mount he governed by letter and by ruling. The rabbis preserved a picture of him at work. Gamaliel sits on a step in the Temple courts, with his scribe Johanan standing in front of him and three pieces of parchment laid out. He dictates three letters: one to the villages of Upper and Lower Galilee telling them it is time to set aside the tithe of their olives, one to the south about the tithe of their sheaves, and one to the Jews scattered in Babylon, Media, and beyond, announcing that the year will have a month added to it (Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 11b; Tosefta Sanhedrin 2:6). Why a whole people needed to be told about an extra month is a story of its own (T3). The Talmud itself wonders whether the letters belong to his grandson, but the Temple setting points to the elder man. The same steps are the setting of a second story. Someone brought him a Targum of Job, a written Aramaic translation of the book of Job, and he told the builder working nearby to bury it under a course of stones (Tosefta Shabbath 13:2; Babylonian Talmud, Shabbath 115a). The report comes from a man who remembered the scene and later told it to Gamaliel’s grandson. It is among the earliest mentions of a written Targum anywhere, and the story suggests a teacher who wanted Scripture read in Hebrew and explained aloud, not fixed in a translation he could not supervise. Another tradition says that the servants of a king and a queen, usually taken to be Herod Agrippa I (the grandson of Herod the Great, and the king who ruled Judea in the early 40s) and his wife Cypros, were twice sent to him for answers the royal couple could not give: once about which of two Passover lambs the household should eat, and once about a lizard found in the royal kitchen (Pesachim 88b). True in every detail or not, it shows the stature his people remembered: a man the royal house came to for answers. Whether he was formally president of the Sanhedrin is less certain. The rabbinic tradition gives him the title nasi, "prince" or president, but Acts shows the high priest presiding and Gamaliel speaking as one honored member among many (Acts 5:27, 34). Most historians think the title was given to the family’s earlier members after the fact. Tradition also says he was the first to be called Rabban, "our master," a title later reserved for the heads of the rabbinic court.
(●) c. 31–35 AD (conventional): When the council wanted the apostles dead, he talked it out of killing them. A few years after the crucifixion, the apostles were arrested for preaching in the Temple and brought before the Sanhedrin. The high priest reminded them they had been ordered to stop. Peter answered that they must obey God rather than men, and told the council to its face that God had raised the Jesus they had killed (Acts 5:29–32). The council was enraged and wanted to kill them (Acts 5:33). Then Gamaliel, "a teacher of the law held in honor by all the people," stood up and had the prisoners taken outside for a little while (Acts 5:34). With them out of the room, he reminded the council of two earlier would-be leaders, Theudas and Judas the Galilean, whose followings had collapsed when the men died (Acts 5:36–37). His advice was to let this one take the same test: leave these men alone, because if the movement was merely human it would fall apart on its own, and if it was from God, no council could stop it (T4). The council took his advice, though not gently. The apostles were beaten, ordered again to stop speaking in Jesus’ name, and released, and they went out rejoicing that they had been counted worthy to suffer for the name (Acts 5:40–41). No one was killed that day. Within a short time, though, his most famous pupil had chosen a very different course: Saul was going from house to house dragging believers off to prison (Acts 8:3).
(●) c. 50–52 AD (traditional): He died, and his people said the honor of the Torah died with him. A later Jewish tradition, repeated by scholars such as Charles Taylor of Cambridge, places his death eighteen years before the destruction of the Temple in AD 70, which would put it around AD 52. Like his birth, the date is a tradition and nothing firmer, which is why it is usually rounded to "about AD 50." How he was mourned is better attested than when. The Mishnah closes its treatise on the suspected adulteress, Sotah, with a list of great men and what was lost when each of them died, and Gamaliel is on it: when he died, the honor of the Torah ceased, and purity and abstinence died with him (Sotah 9:15, quoted in full after T4). The Torah is the Hebrew word for the Law of Moses, the first five books of the Bible, and more broadly for the whole teaching that grew up around them. Purity here means the careful keeping of the Law’s rules of ritual cleanness; abstinence translates a word built on the same root as "Pharisee," the separated ones. It is a striking epitaph. His people did not remember him chiefly for brilliance, but for a kind of dignity that made the Law itself look honorable.
(●) c. 66–70 AD: His son Simeon helped lead Jerusalem in the war with Rome, and his descendants led the rabbis for centuries. The family did not end with him. His son, Simeon ben Gamaliel, appears in the pages of Josephus, the Jewish historian who was a general in the revolt against Rome, as one of the leading men of Jerusalem in the war of AD 66–70. Josephus did not like him (they were on opposite sides of a quarrel), and yet he paid him a handsome compliment: Simon was "of a very noble family of the sect of the Pharisees," and "a man of great wisdom and reason" (Josephus, Life 38, sections 190–192, Whiston translation). It is one of the few places outside the New Testament and the rabbis where Gamaliel’s house can be seen from the outside. After the Temple fell, Gamaliel’s grandson, also called Gamaliel, became the leader of the rabbis gathered at Yavneh on the coast, and the line ran on through his son Simeon to his grandson Judah ha-Nasi, the compiler of the Mishnah. One more family detail survives: a granddaughter of Gamaliel the Elder, given in marriage to a priest named Simon ben Nathanael (Tosefta Avodah Zarah 3:10).
What He Taught
(T1) Take a teacher to settle your doubts, and measure your duty instead of guessing at it. Picture a farmer at harvest with a heap of grain on the threshing floor. The Law tells him a tenth belongs to God (Deuteronomy 14:22). He could measure the heap carefully, or he could squint at it and say, "That looks like about ten bushels; one for the Levites." (The Levites were the tribe set apart to serve at the sanctuary, and the tithe was how they were fed.) Gamaliel’s point is that the squint will nearly always come out in the farmer’s favor. A man estimating what he owes is a judge in his own case. The one saying the Mishnah’s collection of sages’ sayings, Pirke Aboth ("Sayings of the Fathers"), puts under his name has three parts. Get yourself a teacher. Get free of doubt. Do not tithe by guesswork. Read together, they make a single piece of advice about conscience: do not leave your obedience to your own impressions, where self-interest can quietly tilt the scales, but settle it by someone who knows, and then do exactly what you owe. Charles Taylor, the Cambridge scholar who edited the saying in 1897, summed it up well: leave as little room as possible for personal bias and the temptations of self-interest. Christians will hear in this the seriousness of a Pharisee about the Law, and something more as well. Jesus himself said that whoever is faithful in a very little is faithful also in much (Luke 16:10), and that it is right to tithe even mint and dill while not neglecting justice and mercy (Matthew 23:23). Gamaliel’s saying sits on the right side of that line: it aims at honesty, not at showing off. Which Gamaliel spoke it has been questioned, since his grandson bore the same name, but its place in the collection, before Johanan ben Zakkai, the leader of the generation after the Temple fell, points to the elder.
(Q) "Make to thyself a master, and be quit of doubt; and tithe not much by estimation." Source: Mishnah, Pirke Aboth 1:16 (Charles Taylor, Sayings of the Jewish Fathers, 2nd ed., Cambridge, 1897, which numbers the saying 1:17). "Master" is Taylor’s word for a teacher; W. O. E. Oesterley’s 1919 translation renders the same three clauses "Get thee a teacher," "Put far from thee doubt," and "Be not constantly tithing by guesswork."
(T2) The Law should be kept in a way that lets ordinary life, and its weakest people, go on. Imagine a witness who has walked all night to Jerusalem to report that he saw the new moon, so that the court can announce the start of the month. He arrives on the Sabbath. The Law limits how far a person may walk on the Sabbath, so under the old practice he had to stay in the courtyard where the witnesses gathered, all day, unable to take a step beyond it. Gamaliel changed that: such witnesses could go two thousand cubits (roughly half a mile) in any direction, as if they lived there, and so could a midwife on her way to a birth and anyone running to help with a fire, a raid, a flood, or a collapsed building (Rosh Hashanah 2:5). The rabbis called rulings like this takkanot, ordinances, and they credited Gamaliel with several made "for the good order of the world" (tikkun ha-olam), meaning rulings that kept the Law from being turned against the people it was given to protect (Gittin 4:2–3). Most of them protected women. A husband could no longer cancel a bill of divorce behind his wife’s back by convening a court somewhere else, a trick that could leave her remarrying in good faith while still legally married. Divorce documents had to name the husband and wife by every name they were known by, so no one could later claim the paper meant someone else. A widow could collect what her marriage contract promised her by making a vow, instead of an oath the courts had grown reluctant to impose. And Rabbi Akiva, the most celebrated rabbi of the early second century, later brought back from Babylonia a tradition that Nehemiah of Beth Deli had received from Gamaliel the Elder: a woman whose husband had vanished could remarry on the word of a single witness to his death, rather than being left bound to a man who would never come home (Yevamot 16:7). There is a family likeness here to the Sabbath arguments in the Gospels, where Jesus asks whether it is lawful on the Sabbath to do good or to do harm, to save life or to kill (Mark 3:4). Gamaliel would have answered that question the way Jesus’ hearers should have.
(Q) "Rabban Gamaliel the elder ordained, that they might go two thousand cubits on every side. And not only they, but the midwife going to a birth; and they who go to rescue from fire, or from enemies, or from inundation, or from fallen buildings." Source: Mishnah, Rosh Hashanah 2:5 (Joseph Barclay, The Talmud, London, 1878, p. 152, where the treatise is titled "The New Year"). The ruling is reported about him rather than spoken by him, which is how the Mishnah records most of what he decided. "They" are the witnesses who came to testify that they had seen the new moon.
(T3) One people keeps one calendar, from Galilee to Babylon. Anyone who has tried to coordinate a family holiday across several time zones has a small sense of Gamaliel’s problem. Israel’s festivals followed a lunar calendar of twelve months, which runs about eleven days short of the solar year. Left alone, Passover would drift backward through the seasons until it fell in winter, when there were no lambs ready and no barley ripe for the offering of firstfruits, the first sheaf of the new harvest brought to God before anyone ate from it. So every few years the court in Jerusalem added a thirteenth month, and everyone, from the hill villages of Galilee to the Jewish communities of Babylon a month’s journey away, had to hear about it in time. The three letters he dictated to his scribe Johanan, sitting on a step in the Temple courts, are that decision going out to the whole people. They are worth noticing for two reasons. First, they show what holding the Law together meant in practice: one calendar, one set of feasts, one people, however scattered. Second, they show his manner. He gives his reasons in plain farmer’s terms (the pigeons are still tender, the lambs still thin, spring has not come), and he speaks for himself and his colleagues together. The Talmud, telling the story, sets the phrase "me and my colleagues" beside a letter under the name of another leader of the family, Rabban Simeon ben Gamaliel, that says only "it has pleased me." The difference is a few words long, and on the face of the two letters it is the difference between a ruling announced by one man and a ruling announced together with his colleagues. The early church was born into this world. When Luke notes that Jews from Parthia, Media, Elam, and Mesopotamia were in Jerusalem for Pentecost (Acts 2:9), the calendar that brought them there on the same day is the one Gamaliel’s letters kept in step.
(Q) "May your peace be increased everlastingly! We inform you that the pigeons are soft, and lambs thin, and the time of spring has not yet come, and it pleases me and my colleagues to add to this year thirty days." Source: Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 11b (Rodkinson translation, Tract Sanhedrin, p. 25); the same report appears in Tosefta Sanhedrin 2:6. The third of the three letters, addressed "to our brethren in exile in Babylon, and to our brethren in Media, and to all other Israelites who are scattered in exile." The Talmud attributes the letters simply to Rabban Gamaliel and wonders aloud whether they belong to his grandson; the setting on the Temple steps, decades before the Temple fell, is the reason they are usually given to the elder.
(T4) What is from God cannot be overthrown, so a court should be slow to fight a movement it does not yet understand. Most of us have watched an enthusiasm sweep through a town, or an office, or a church, and then quietly disappear. Gamaliel had watched two of them in his own lifetime. Theudas had gathered about four hundred men and been killed, and his followers scattered. Judas the Galilean had raised a revolt at the time of the Roman census and perished, and his followers were dispersed (Acts 5:36–37). Neither movement needed the council’s help to fail. So when the council wanted to put the apostles to death, Gamaliel offered it a test that rests on a conviction every Pharisee shared: God rules history. A movement that is merely human will fall apart under its own weight, however loudly it begins. A movement that is from God will survive anything the council throws at it, and the council will find that it has been fighting God (Acts 5:38–39). Either way, killing these men is the wrong move. It was wise counsel, and it saved the apostles’ lives. It was also, by its own terms, a decision not to decide yet. Gamaliel did not say the apostles were right; he said the council could afford to wait and find out. Christians have read the speech ever since with gratitude for what it did and with a question about what it left open, which is exactly where the gospel parts company with him.
(Q) "So in the present case I tell you, keep away from these men and let them alone, for if this plan or this undertaking is of man, it will fail; but if it is of God, you will not be able to overthrow them. You might even be found opposing God!" Source: Acts 5:38–39 (English Standard Version). The close of Gamaliel’s speech to the Sanhedrin, given while the apostles waited outside. Luke adds at once: "So they took his advice."
(Q) "When he died the honor [outward respect] of the Torah ceased, and purity and piety became extinct." Source: Mishnah, Sotah 9:15, as rendered by Solomon Schechter and Wilhelm Bacher in the Jewish Encyclopedia, article "Gamaliel I" (1901–1906); the bracketed gloss is theirs. Not his words, but his people’s verdict on him: the Mishnah’s epitaph, set in a list of great teachers and what was lost when each one died. Charles Taylor rendered the same line "the glory of the Thorah ceased, and purity and [perishuth] died," leaving the last word, the separateness the Pharisees took their name from, in Hebrew (Sayings of the Jewish Fathers, 1897, note on Aboth 1:17).
What Christians Made of Him
(†) Luke drew him as a just man, and Paul named him with pride. It would have been easy for the first Christian writers to paint the whole Jewish leadership in one dark color. Luke does not. In Acts the council that tried Jesus is still hostile, but in the middle of it stands a Pharisee "held in honor by all the people," and Luke records his speech in full and lets it carry the day (Acts 5:34–39). Later in the book, when Paul is on trial, it is again scribes of the Pharisees’ party in the council who stand up and say, "We find nothing wrong in this man" (Acts 23:9). Luke wants his readers to see that the faith of Israel at its best was not the enemy of the gospel. Paul, for his part, never disowned his teacher. Standing before the crowd in Jerusalem after his arrest, he opens his defense by naming Gamaliel (Acts 22:3), and before the council he says, "I am a Pharisee, a son of Pharisees" (Acts 23:6). Whatever Paul came to count as loss for the sake of Christ (Philippians 3:7), his mastery of the Scriptures was not among the things he threw away. The man who wrote Romans, threading the promises to Abraham through the Law and the Prophets, learned to read that way somewhere, and Acts tells us where. Christian readers have also seen providence in the timing, meaning God’s quiet steering of ordinary events toward his own ends, the way a good host arranges a dinner so that the right two guests end up talking. The same God who would one day stop Saul on the Damascus road had already, through Saul’s own teacher, kept the council from killing the apostles.
(†) Later Christian legend made him a secret believer and a saint, though no early record says he believed. Gratitude has a way of turning into stories. The Clementine Recognitions, a Christian romance about Peter and his companion Clement compiled around the fourth century from older material, sets him in a debate between the apostles and the priests at the Temple and calls him "a chief of the people," "who was secretly our brother in the faith, but by our advice remained among them" (Recognitions 1.65, Thomas Smith translation, Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 8). Later in the same book he sends the believers secret word that "that enemy," Saul, has a commission from the high priest Caiaphas to go to Damascus with letters and arrest them (Recognitions 1.71). In December 415 a priest named Lucian, serving at the village of Caphargamala near Jerusalem, reported that Gamaliel had appeared to him in a dream. In Lucian’s account, Gamaliel said he had taken the body of the martyr Stephen and buried it on his own land, and that he himself, his son Abibas, and Nicodemus lay in the same tomb. A tomb was opened, Stephen’s relics (the bones of a saint, kept and honored as a link to his life) were carried to Jerusalem, and Lucian’s letter about the discovery spread through the Latin and Greek churches. From such stories Gamaliel came to be honored as a saint in both East and West (the Greek-speaking churches and the Latin-speaking church of Rome), remembered alongside Stephen. These are legends, and they are best named as legends. The New Testament gives no hint that Gamaliel ever confessed Jesus as Messiah, and his own people, who knew him best, remembered him as the very model of a faithful Pharisee to the end. As Charles Taylor put it, the tradition that he died a Christian arose "from Acts v. 39," which is to say from Christian gratitude for one good speech.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: a teacher is not the final word, and the resurrection does not wait for history to decide. Gamaliel left the church in his debt, and that debt stands. But two things he taught stop short of where the gospel goes. - The teacher. His first piece of advice was to get yourself a teacher and let him settle your doubts (T1). That is wise as far as it reaches, and the church has always had teachers. But Jesus told his disciples, "you are not to be called rabbi, for you have one teacher, and you are all brothers" (Matthew 23:8). In the gospel the doubt that matters most is settled not by the best-trained master in Jerusalem but by the one Master himself, and every human teacher, Gamaliel and Paul included, stands under him. - The waiting. His counsel to the council was to wait and see whether the movement survived (T4). As a rule for a court deciding whether to kill men, it was sound. As an answer to what the apostles had just said, it was not enough. Peter had not asked the council to wait for history. He had told them that God raised Jesus, and that he and the others were witnesses (Acts 5:30–32). A claim like that is not settled by watching to see whether a movement lasts; it is settled by asking whether the witnesses are telling the truth. Gamaliel’s test treated as an open question for the future what the apostles presented as a fact of the recent past, and as far as the record shows, he never took the step his own words left open. He said that if this was from God, no one would be able to overthrow it. Nobody has. The church he saved from the council that morning is the best answer to the question he chose to leave for time.