(P1)God forbids his people to bow down to images in worship.
+Walk into an Eastern Orthodox church and you will see people stop before an icon (from the Greek eikōn, "image"), a painted panel of Christ or Mary, then cross themselves, bow, and kiss it. What they are doing is called veneration, and the first reason to refuse it is the commandment God gave at Sinai.
(1) The second commandment forbids making images and bowing to them.
- The command reads: "You shall not make for yourself a carved image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the Lord your God am a jealous God" (Exodus 20:4-5).
- Look at the two verbs aimed at the image itself. The first forbids a posture toward the thing: you shall not bow down to it. The second forbids doing it service: you shall not serve it.
- The Greek Old Testament, which was the Bible the early church read, translates those two verbs with proskyneō (to bow down, to venerate) and latreuō (to serve in worship). Here is the thing worth noticing. When the Second Council of Nicaea defended icons in 787, it drew its line between these same two words, in their noun forms: a bow of honor, proskynēsis, could be given to an image, while latreia, worship, belonged to God alone (D2). The commandment had already forbidden both of them toward an image.
- Of course, the word proskyneō settles nothing on its own. Abraham "bowed" to the Hittites who sold him a grave, and the Greek uses the same verb (Genesis 23:7). What settles it is who or what receives the bow. Scripture allows a courteous bow to a living person, but the commandment names one thing that may receive no bow at all, and that thing is an image.
(2) The commandment covers images meant to honor the true God.
- The first commandment, "You shall have no other gods before me" (Exodus 20:3), settles which God Israel worships. The second settles how he is to be worshiped. (Catholics and Lutherans number the commandments so that these two fold into one, but the words are the same either way.)
- The clearest case is the golden calf. When Aaron made it, he built an altar in front of it and announced a feast to the LORD, using God's own name (Exodus 32:4-5). Israel did not think it had changed gods. It thought it had found a way to see the God it already had. God answered that feast with judgment, not approval.
- The pattern kept coming back. In the days of the judges, a mother dedicated silver to the LORD so that a carved image could be made for her son Micah (Judges 17:3-5). Once Micah had hired a Levite (a man of the tribe set apart to serve at God's sanctuary) as priest of his shrine, he expected the LORD to prosper him (Judges 17:13).
• It is not a pure case, since his shrine also held household idols. But the silver and the image were given to the LORD.
• Nor did the image stay in one family's house. It ended up in the shrine of a whole tribe (Judges 18:30-31), and the narrator's verdict on the whole affair is that in those days everyone did what was right in his own eyes (Judges 17:6).
- Centuries later King Jeroboam set up calves at Bethel and Dan and presented them in the very words used of Aaron's calf, as the gods who brought Israel up out of Egypt (1 Kings 12:28; Exodus 32:4). Each time, the image was tied to the God who had rescued Israel, and each time Scripture tells the story as Israel's fall into idolatry.
(3) The reason given is that God showed Israel no form.
- Moses told Israel why: "Therefore watch yourselves very carefully. Since you saw no form on the day that the Lord spoke to you at Horeb out of the midst of the fire, beware lest you act corruptly by making a carved image for yourselves, in the form of any figure, the likeness of male or female..." (Deuteronomy 4:15-16).
- At Sinai, which Deuteronomy calls Horeb, God gave Israel a voice and words, and that is how he chose to be known. An image would put something Israel had made in the place of what God had said.
- Think of a pen pal you have never met. You really do know them, through what they write. But if you painted a face to look at while you read their letters, the face would be your invention, not their gift.
Therefore, the God who gave the Ten Commandments forbids his people to bow down to images in his worship, even images made to honor him.
(P2)The images God commanded in Israel were never objects of devotion.
+Scripture is not against art. The images God himself ordered for his sanctuary show exactly where the line runs: they could be made, but they could not be bowed to.
(1) God commanded carved and woven images for his own sanctuary.
- Two golden cherubim (angelic figures) spread their wings over the cover of the ark of the covenant (Exodus 25:18-20), and cherubim were woven into the curtains of the tabernacle, Israel's portable tent of worship (Exodus 26:1).
- Solomon's temple was carved with cherubim, palm trees, and open flowers (1 Kings 6:23-29), and its great bronze basin stood on twelve bronze oxen (1 Kings 7:25).
- So the second commandment cannot mean "no religious images of any kind." God does not break his own law five chapters later.
(2) No one in Israel bowed to those images.
- Ordinary Israelites never saw the cherubim over the ark at all. The ark sat in the Most Holy Place, the inner room of the sanctuary, where only the high priest went, and he only once a year, on the Day of Atonement, the day set aside for cleansing the nation's sin (Leviticus 16:2; Hebrews 9:7).
• Even on the march the ark went wrapped in the sanctuary's veil, and the Levites who carried it were forbidden to look on it (Numbers 4:5-6, 4:20).
- Israel did, of course, fall down before the ark and pray toward the temple (Joshua 7:6; 1 Kings 8:48). But the ark was the place where God himself had promised to meet Moses and give him his commands for Israel (Exodus 25:22), and it held no likeness of him. The bow went to the LORD at the place he had named, never to a carved figure.
- No text in the Old Testament records an offering, a prayer, a kiss, or a bow directed at a cherub, a palm tree, or an ox.
- Think of the seal of the state hanging above a judge's bench. It tells you whose authority fills the room, and yet nobody in the gallery bows to it, lights a candle before it, or kisses it on the way out.
(3) When a commanded image became an object of devotion, it was destroyed.
- In the wilderness God told Moses to make a bronze serpent and set it on a pole, and the snake-bitten Israelites who looked at it lived (Numbers 21:8-9). Jesus later used it as a picture of his own cross (John 3:14). Here was an image God himself had commanded, with a real meaning God himself had given it.
- Centuries later Israel was making offerings to it (the Hebrew verb is the one for burning incense), and King Hezekiah broke it in pieces (2 Kings 18:4). You might expect Scripture to scold him for destroying a holy object. Instead it says he did what was right in the eyes of the Lord, and that he trusted in the Lord as no king of Judah had (2 Kings 18:3, 18:5).
- The serpent's history is the whole case in miniature. Its origin was holy and its meaning was good, and neither of those protected it once people began to honor it.
(4) Israel's kind of worship is called aniconism.
- Aniconism (from the Greek a-, "without," and eikōn, "image") means worship without images used as objects of devotion. It is not hostility to art. Israel's sanctuary, full of carved cherubim and palm trees that nobody prayed to, is aniconism in practice.
- Iconoclasm, literally "image-breaking," is aniconism enforced by destroying images. Hezekiah practiced it in that literal sense, and only once an image had become an idol.
- The word grew wider in the great controversy over icons that divided the Eastern Roman Empire in the eighth and ninth centuries. In that fight "iconoclast" became the name for anyone who rejected the veneration of icons, whether or not he ever broke one. Whether images should ever be destroyed is a separate question, and refusing to venerate them does not require breaking anything (C).
Therefore, the images God commanded show that Scripture permits religious art and forbids its devotional use.
(P3)The New Testament gives Christian worship no images to honor.
+The New Testament never repeals the second commandment. Nor does it ever hand the church a picture to bow to.
(1) Jesus and the apostles warn against images without a Christian exception.
- A Samaritan woman beside a well asked Jesus which mountain was the right place to worship, and he answered, "God is spirit, and those who worship him must worship in spirit and truth" (John 4:24). Worship would no longer be tied to a holy place. Nothing in the saying ties it to a holy object instead.
- At Athens, Paul told the philosophers that we ought not to think the divine being is like gold or silver or stone, an image formed by human art and imagination (Acts 17:29). Writing to the Romans, he described people who "exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images resembling mortal man and birds and animals and creeping things" (Romans 1:23).
- It is only fair to say that these texts, like the apostles' warnings to flee from idols, have pagan idols in view. What they show is more modest, then: nothing in the New Testament carves out an exception for Christian images.
(2) The apostles and angels refused religious bowing.
- When the Roman centurion Cornelius met Peter, he fell at his feet and worshiped him; the Greek verb is prosekynēsen, a form of proskyneō, the very word the commandment uses for bowing to an image. Peter lifted him up and told him to stand, because he too was only a man (Acts 10:25-26).
- When John fell at the feet of the angel who showed him his visions, the angel said, "You must not do that! I am a fellow servant with you and your brothers who hold to the testimony of Jesus. Worship God" (Revelation 19:10). John did it again, and was told the same thing again (Revelation 22:8-9).
- Bowing as a courtesy was ordinary in the Bible's world, the way a man might bow to a king or an elder. What Peter and the angel refused was bowing as an act of religion. A real apostle and a real angel would not accept it. A painting of them stands one step further removed still, and so has even less claim to the bow they turned away.
(3) The image of God the New Testament gives is Christ himself.
- "He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation" (Colossians 1:15). The Greek word for "image" is eikōn, the root of "icon." The New Testament has an icon, and he is alive and seated at the Father's right hand.
- God's plan is for his people "to be conformed to the image of his Son" (Romans 8:29). The images the New Testament cares about are the risen Christ and the believers being remade to look like him.
- Paul could write to the Galatians, "It was before your eyes that Jesus Christ was publicly portrayed as crucified" (Galatians 3:1), and in the next verse he reminds them that they had received the Spirit by hearing with faith (Galatians 3:2). What they had seen, they had seen in a sermon. As he told the Romans, "So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ" (Romans 10:17).
- Until Christ returns, Paul says, believers walk by faith and not by sight (2 Corinthians 5:7), and Peter writes to Christians who love Christ though they have not seen him (1 Peter 1:8). Neither verse is about pictures. Both describe a church that does not yet see its Lord, and neither tells it to make up the lack with a likeness. It is told to trust what it has heard.
(4) The apostolic church argued over the law but never over Christian images.
- The first Christians were Jews, and they quarreled openly about what the law still required. Some taught, "Unless you are circumcised according to the custom of Moses, you cannot be saved" (Acts 15:1). Paul's letters argue about food offered to idols, clean and unclean foods, and holy days: "One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike" (Romans 14:5).
- Those same Jews came from a people who, in their own century, bared their necks to Roman soldiers rather than let the emperor's image into Jerusalem (D15). If the apostles had taught such converts to bow before pictures, it would have been the fight of the century, and the letters would carry it.
- Instead, wherever the apostolic writings mention man-made religious images at all, they are idols to be avoided. When the apostles met in Jerusalem to settle what Gentile converts must keep, they told them "to abstain from the things polluted by idols" (Acts 15:20). Paul told the Corinthians to flee from idolatry (1 Corinthians 10:14), and John closed his first letter by telling his readers to keep themselves from idols (1 John 5:21). The record knows no other kind of religious image.
- Think of an office where the staff argue by email about everything: the parking, the thermostat, casual Fridays. If the bosses had ever ordered them to wear something their families had refused to wear for generations, the inbox would be full of it. An inbox crowded with complaints about everything else, and silent about that, tells you no such order was ever sent.
Therefore, the New Testament keeps the ban on bowing to images and gives the church its picture of God in Christ, preached and believed.
(P4)For its first three centuries, the early church venerated no images.
+Whatever the church later did, its first generations worshiped without honoring any image, and their pagan neighbors noticed.
(1) Pagan critics mocked Christians for having no images.
- In a Roman city, a religion without statues looked like no religion at all, and Romans called Christians "atheists" partly for that reason. Think of the one house on a street that never puts up a single decoration at the holidays: everyone notices, and everyone has a theory.
- The pagan philosopher Celsus, writing around 175, charged that Christians shrink from setting up altars, statues, and temples (Origen, Against Celsus 8.17).
- In a dialogue written by a Roman lawyer in the early third century, the pagan speaker Caecilius asks why Christians have no altars, no temples, and no images anyone has seen (Minucius Felix, Octavius 10).
(2) Christian writers granted the charge and explained it.
- Origen of Alexandria, the leading Christian scholar of his day, answering Celsus around 248, did not deny it. Christians, he wrote, "not only avoid temples, altars, and images, but are ready to suffer death when it is necessary, rather than debase by any such impiety the conception which they have of the Most High God" (Against Celsus 7.64).
- In Octavius, the Christian replies that no image could be made of God, since a human being is already God's image (Octavius 32).
- Two more Christian teachers said the same in their own words. Clement of Alexandria wrote that "works of art cannot then be sacred and divine" (Stromata 7.5), and Lactantius, a teacher of rhetoric writing around 310, that "there is no religion wherever there is an image" (Divine Institutes 2.19).
- Granted, many of these lines were aimed at pagan idols. But Celsus and Caecilius were describing what Christians actually did, and the Christians agreed with the description.
(3) A church council ruled pictures out of churches.
- Around 305, nineteen bishops met at Elvira in Spain. A gathering like this is a synod (a regional council of bishops), and its rulings are canons, from the Greek for a measuring rule.
- Canon 36 reads, in Latin, placuit picturas in ecclesia esse non debere, ne quod colitur et adoratur in parietibus depingatur: "it seemed good that there be no pictures in church, lest what is worshiped and adored be painted on the walls."
- Think of a hospital that bans open flames in the oxygen ward before any fire has started. The bishops saw where pictures in a place of worship could lead and kept them out of the building.
(4) Fourth-century bishops refused images of Christ and the saints.
- When the emperor Constantine's half-sister Constantia asked Eusebius of Caesarea, the first great church historian, for a picture of Christ, he refused: to depict only Christ's human form, he wrote, would break God's commandment and fall into pagan error (Letter to Constantia).
• The letter survives only in fragments quoted during the later controversy, and its authenticity has been questioned, but most scholars accept it.
- Around 394 Epiphanius, bishop of Salamis on Cyprus, found a curtain in a village church in Palestine bearing an image of Christ or a saint. He wrote that "being loath that an image of a man should be hung up in Christ's church contrary to the teaching of the Scriptures, I tore it asunder" (preserved in Jerome, Letter 51.9).
- Augustine, around 388, admitted that he knew "many worshipers of tombs and pictures," and said the church condemns them and works to correct them (On the Morals of the Catholic Church 1.34.75). The practice was starting among the people, and the church's teachers disowned it.
Therefore, for its first three centuries and more, the church venerated no images, and its leaders resisted their devotional use when it began.
(P5)The veneration of icons began centuries after the apostles.
+The teaching that requires the veneration of icons was defined in 787. Those who defended it claimed it came down from the apostles, but the evidence does not supply that pedigree.
(1) A practice the apostles taught leaves a trail from the start.
- Think of two family recipes, each said to come from Great-grandma. One shows up in her own handwriting and in every daughter's cookbook. The other first appears in a cousin's kitchen generations later, and the oldest relatives say she never made it.
- Sunday worship has the first kind of history. The church received it as a practice rather than as something spelled out in a single command, and its trail begins inside the New Testament itself:
• Paul tells the Corinthians to set money aside "On the first day of every week" (1 Corinthians 16:2).
• The believers at Troas gather on the first day of the week to break bread (Acts 20:7).
• John is "in the Spirit on the Lord’s day" (Revelation 1:10).
- From there the trail never breaks:
• The Didache, a church manual from about the end of the first century, tells Christians to gather on the Lord's Day (Didache 14).
• Ignatius of Antioch, around 110, describes Christians who no longer keep the Sabbath but live by the Lord's Day, as most editors read the line (To the Magnesians 9).
• The Epistle of Barnabas keeps the "eighth day," the day after the Sabbath, on which Jesus rose (Barnabas 15).
• Justin Martyr, around 155, describes the Sunday service in detail (First Apology 67).
(2) Customs handed down without a written command leave a trail too.
- That matters, because icons are defended as just such an unwritten tradition: a custom received from the apostles by practice rather than by text. The Second Council of Nicaea counted image-making among the traditions handed down, written and unwritten.
- Two early writers drew up lists of those unwritten customs.
• Around 200, Tertullian, the North African writer, listed customs the churches kept on the strength of tradition alone, among them dipping the candidate three times at baptism and tracing the sign of the cross on the forehead (On the Crown 3-4).
• Around 375, Basil the Great, bishop of Caesarea, drew up a similar list, adding prayer facing east. It is the very passage John of Damascus, the great eighth-century defender of icons, later quoted on their behalf (On the Holy Spirit 27.66).
• Neither list is complete, but neither mentions images.
- Now set images beside Sunday and those customs. Pictures, unlike Sunday, needed painters and money, so a first-century church without them proves little by itself (D16). A teaching to bow to images needed no paint at all, though, and the apostolic record holds none (P3). From the second century through the fourth, the church's voices refuse to venerate images, and they go on refusing after Christians had pictures of their own (P4).
- So veneration has the second recipe's history. It turns up generations late, and the oldest voices in the family refused it.
(3) The cult of images grew in the sixth and seventh centuries.
- A cult, in the historian's sense, is an organized pattern of devotion: prayers, candles, incense, processions, and miracles credited to an object. Historians of Byzantine art (the art of the Greek-speaking Eastern Roman Empire, ruled from Constantinople) place the rapid growth of the cult of images in the late sixth and seventh centuries.
- Historians point to several roots:
• The cult of relics and saints' shrines.
• Stories of miraculous images.
• The court ceremony in which Roman subjects bowed before the emperor's portrait and set lamps and incense in front of it.
- On a widely held account, as the empire became Christian, those court habits found a new home in front of pictures of Christ and the saints.
- A borrowed custom is not wrong merely for being borrowed (D10). But a custom traced to the emperor's court has not been traced to the apostles.
- The full theology came later still, from John of Damascus, a monk writing near Jerusalem around 730. It was made binding in 787 by the Second Council of Nicaea, which the Orthodox and Catholic churches count as the Seventh Ecumenical Council, meaning a council of the whole church rather than of one region. That council stands about as far from the apostles as we stand from Thomas Aquinas, the thirteenth-century theologian.
(4) The story that Luke painted Mary appears centuries after Luke.
- The earliest report that the Gospel writer painted the Virgin Mary is credited to Theodore the Reader, a sixth-century historian. His history survives only in later excerpts. Some scholars think even this report was added afterward, and if they are right, the first sure witness comes from the eighth century.
- Early in the fifth century, Augustine wrote plainly that "neither do we know the countenance of the Virgin Mary" (On the Trinity 8). He was the most widely read bishop in the Latin church, and he knew of no portrait.
- Imagine a portrait of an ancestor that no letter or diary mentions for four and a half centuries, whose face the family's most careful historian says nobody knows, and that surfaces just as the family starts arguing over portraits. It might be genuine, but nobody should rest much weight on it.
(5) The letter in which Basil kisses icons is not Basil's.
- Defenders of icons sometimes quote Letter 360, credited to Basil the Great, in which the writer says he honors and kisses the images of the apostles and martyrs "inasmuch as they have been handed down from the holy apostles," and adds that the practice is not forbidden.
- Scholars widely treat Letter 360 as spurious (falsely attributed). For one thing, Basil's name drew many forgeries after his death. For another, the letter has no addressee, its language fits a later century, and it is missing from most collections of his letters.
- It also protests too much. Nobody writes that singing hymns is "not forbidden," because everyone knows it is not. A letter insisting that icons are not forbidden reads like an answer to people who said they were.
Therefore, the veneration of icons cannot claim the apostles or the early church as its source.
(C)Therefore, Christians should not venerate icons.
+Bowing to images, kissing them, praying before them, and offering them candles and incense have no place in Christian worship. Taken together, the strands (P1 through P5) strongly support that conclusion.
(1) The five strands form two groups.
- A cumulative case works the way a jury reaches a verdict, from several lines of evidence pointing the same way. It is a rope rather than a chain: a chain snaps at its weakest link, but a rope holds even when one strand frays.
- The first group is Scripture: the commandment (P1), its application in Israel (P2), and the New Testament's keeping of that ban with no exception (P3). These three interpret one another, so they stand or fall largely together.
- The second group is history: the early church's practice (P4), with the late origin of the doctrine (P5) clearing away the rival claim that icons came from the apostles.
- The two groups are not wholly independent, since the early Christians gave the commandment as the reason for their practice. Even that overlap is evidence, though. It means the readers nearest the apostles read the commandment the same way.
(2) Scripture bears the most weight.
- Suppose the late-origin strand (P5) failed, and Luke really had painted Mary. The case would still stand on Scripture and on three centuries of worship that honored no image.
- Suppose instead that the scriptural strands failed. The history would still be there, and it would still refute any claim that icons are apostolic. With that claim would go the claim that every Christian is bound to venerate them. What the history could not do by itself is forbid a practice that began later.
(3) What follows, and what does not.
- What follows: Christians should not bow to, kiss, or pray before images, or honor them with candles and incense, as acts of devotion.
- What does not follow: that Christian art is wrong. Pictures that teach, windows that tell the gospel story, and a cross on a wall all sit on the near side of the line between art and devotion. Protestants disagree among themselves about how close to that line to go.
- Nor does it follow that images should be smashed, or that Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic believers are not Christians. They are brothers and sisters who confess the same creed, and this is a disagreement inside the family.
(4) The question cannot be left as a matter of taste.
- The Second Council of Nicaea did not merely permit icons. It required their veneration, and it pronounced an anathema, a formal curse of exclusion from the church, on those who reject it.
- Nor are such curses a thing of the past. Every year on the first Sunday of Lent, the Sunday of Orthodoxy, Orthodox churches celebrate the restoration of icons in 843.
• The service includes the Synodikon of Orthodoxy, a list of affirmations and condemnations drawn up for that restoration and enlarged in later centuries.
• The full text still pronounces anathema on those who reject icons.
• Many parishes now read a shortened form, though, and which anathemas survive the shortening varies from place to place.
- So the question is not one of adiaphora (Greek for "things indifferent," like the color of the carpet in the sanctuary). One side says the practice is required. The other says it is forbidden. They cannot both be right.
- Protestants hold to sola Scriptura, "Scripture alone" as the final test of the church's teaching and practice. The church's traditions are honored where they agree with it and corrected where they do not, as Jesus did when he told the Pharisees, "So for the sake of your tradition you have made void the word of God" (Matthew 15:6).
Therefore, Christians should honor Christ as he gave himself to be known, in his word, at his table (the Lord's Supper), and in his people, and should not venerate icons.
On icons in the early church:
Brubaker, Leslie, and John Haldon. Byzantium in the Iconoclast Era, c. 680-850: A History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011.
Carpenter, John B. "Answering Eastern Orthodox Apologists regarding Icons." Themelios 43, no. 3 (2018).
Carpenter, John B. "Don't Convert: Icons and Images in the Early Church." Theopolis Institute, February 25, 2025.
Carpenter, John B. "The Early Church on the Aniconic Spectrum." Westminster Theological Journal (2021).
Finney, Paul Corby. The Invisible God: The Earliest Christians on Art. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994.
Holl, Karl. "Die Schriften des Epiphanius gegen die Bilderverehrung." Sitzungsberichte der Königlich Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (1916): 828-868.
Kitzinger, Ernst. "The Cult of Images in the Age before Iconoclasm." Dumbarton Oaks Papers 8 (1954): 83-150.
Newman, John Henry. An Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine. 1845. Rev. ed. London: Longmans, Green, 1878.
Sahas, Daniel J. Icon and Logos: Sources in Eighth-Century Iconoclasm. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1986.
On idolatry:
Beale, G. K. We Become What We Worship: A Biblical Theology of Idolatry. Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2008.
Keller, Timothy. Counterfeit Gods: The Empty Promises of Money, Sex, and Power, and the Only Hope That Matters. New York: Dutton, 2009.
Video presentations:
Horn, Trent, and Jimmy Akin. "REBUTTING Gavin Ortlund on Icons." The Counsel of Trent, YouTube.
Manning, Erik. "Why I Can't Accept Eastern Orthodox Icon Veneration." Testify, YouTube, October 23, 2026. https://youtu.be/m9kc9f4y_lw.
Ortlund, Gavin. "Icon Veneration Is CLEARLY an Accretion!" Truth Unites, YouTube, January 5, 2023. https://youtu.be/_ytYX4dXpRo.
Ortlund, Gavin. "Response to Horn and Akin on Icons." Truth Unites, YouTube, January 23, 2023. https://youtu.be/BRpO54h59dU.
On Jewish art and the synagogues:
Kraeling, Carl H. The Synagogue. The Excavations at Dura-Europos, Final Report 8, part 1. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1956.
Weiss, Zeev, and Ehud Netzer. Promise and Redemption: A Synagogue Mosaic from Sepphoris. Jerusalem: Israel Museum, 1996.
Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic sources engaged:
Alfeyev, Hilarion. "Theology of Icon in the Orthodox Church." Lecture at St Vladimir's Orthodox Theological Seminary, February 5, 2011.
Bigham, Steven. Early Christian Attitudes toward Images. Rollinsford, NH: Orthodox Research Institute, 2004.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997. Paragraphs 2129-2132.
Code of Canon Law (1983).
Hefele, Charles Joseph. A History of the Christian Councils. Vol. 1. Translated by William R. Clark. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1871.
John of Damascus. Three Treatises on the Divine Images. Translated by Andrew Louth. Crestwood, NY: St Vladimir's Seminary Press, 2003.
Ouspensky, Leonid. Theology of the Icon. 2 vols. Crestwood, NY: St Vladimir's Seminary Press, 1992.
Second Vatican Council. Dei Verbum (Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation), 1965. Section 10.
Second Vatican Council. Unitatis Redintegratio (Decree on Ecumenism), 1964. Section 3.
Theodore the Studite. On the Holy Icons. Translated by Catharine P. Roth. Crestwood, NY: St Vladimir's Seminary Press, 1981.
Reformation sources:
Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Edited by John T. McNeill. Translated by Ford Lewis Battles. Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1960. Book 1, chapter 11.
Luther, Martin. "Eight Sermons at Wittenberg, 1522." In Luther's Works, vol. 51, Sermons I, edited by John W. Doberstein. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
The Westminster Larger Catechism (1648). Question 109.
Ancient sources:
Athanasius. Orations against the Arians 3.5.
Augustine. On the Morals of the Catholic Church 1.34.75; On the Trinity, book 8.
Basil of Caesarea. On the Holy Spirit 18.45, 27.66. Pseudo-Basil, Letter 360.
Clement of Alexandria. Stromata 7.5.
Didache 14.
Elvira, Synod of (c. 305). Canon 36.
Epistle of Barnabas 15.
Epiphanius of Salamis. Letter to John of Jerusalem, preserved in Jerome, Letter 51.
Eusebius of Caesarea. Church History 1.13, 7.18; Letter to Constantia.
Evagrius Scholasticus. Ecclesiastical History 4.27.
Gregory the Great. Letters to Serenus, bishop of Marseilles (599 and 600).
Ignatius of Antioch. To the Magnesians 9.
Irenaeus. Against Heresies 1.25.6.
Josephus. Jewish War 1.648-655, 2.169-174; Antiquities of the Jews 18.55-59.
Julian. Fragment of a Letter to a Priest.
Justin Martyr. First Apology 67.
Lactantius. Divine Institutes 2.19.
Martyrdom of Polycarp 17-18.
Minucius Felix. Octavius 10, 32.
Mishnah. Avodah Zarah 3:4. In The Mishnah, translated by Herbert Danby. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1933.
Nicaea, Second Council of (787). Definition and anathemas.
Origen. Against Celsus 7.62, 7.64, 8.17.
Paris, Council of (825).
Pliny the Younger. Letters 10.96.
Synodikon of Orthodoxy (843).
Tertullian. On Idolatry 3-5; On Modesty 7, 10; On the Crown 3-4.
Theodore the Reader (Theodore Lector). Ecclesiastical History, fragments.
Biblical citations:
Genesis 23:7; 33:3; 47:31. Exodus 20:3-5; 25:18-20, 25:22, 25:40; 26:1; 32:4-6. Leviticus 16:2; 26:1. Numbers 4:5-6, 4:20; 21:8-9. Deuteronomy 4:15-19. Joshua 7:6. Judges 17:3-6, 17:13; 18:30-31. 1 Samuel 24:8. 1 Kings 6:23-29; 7:25; 8:48; 12:28. 2 Kings 18:3-5. Isaiah 42:8; 44:17; 60:14. Ezekiel 14:3. Daniel 6:10. Matthew 4:10; 15:6. Mark 5:27-29; 7:7. John 1:14, 1:18; 3:14; 4:24; 14:9. Acts 10:25-26; 15:1; 15:20; 17:11; 17:29; 19:12; 20:7. Romans 1:23; 8:29; 10:17; 14:5. 1 Corinthians 10:14; 16:2. 2 Corinthians 5:7. Galatians 1:8-9; 3:1-2. Colossians 1:15; 3:5. Hebrews 1:3; 9:7; 11:21. 1 Peter 1:8. 1 John 1:1; 5:21. Revelation 1:10; 3:9; 19:10; 22:8-9. All quotations from the English Standard Version.
+When the Son of God became man, the invisible God became visible. Refusing to picture Christ denies that he truly took flesh, which is why the church called the iconoclasts heretics.
1. The Incarnation answers whether Christ can be pictured, not whether a picture may be bowed to.
The strongest form of this objection comes from John of Damascus and Theodore the Studite, the great eighth- and ninth-century defenders of icons.
- Moses grounded the ban in the fact that Israel "saw no form" (Deuteronomy 4:15). But in Christ, God was seen: "No one has ever seen God; the only God, who is at the Father’s side, he has made him known" (John 1:18). The reason for the ban, they argue, has expired.
- On this view, to refuse to paint the face God showed us is to treat the Incarnation (the eternal Son of God becoming a real, visible man) as if it had not happened.
- John of Damascus pressed it further. He venerated not matter, he said, but the maker of matter, who became matter for our sake, and he would not stop honoring the matter through which his salvation came. To despise the material image, on his view, is to despise the matter God took up.
That argument has real force against the strictest Protestant view, which holds that Christ may not be pictured at all. Many Reformed churches, the Protestant family descended from John Calvin, teach exactly that, as the Westminster Larger Catechism of 1648 does (question 109). Protestants divide on that question, and it can be left open.
It can be left open because the second commandment has two halves. One forbids making the image, and the other forbids bowing to it. Even if the Incarnation answered the first half for pictures of Christ, nothing in it licenses the second. And Mary and the saints were never invisible in the first place. The commandment already forbade bowing to the likeness of anything "in the earth beneath."
2. The people who saw him made no images.
The apostles wrote of the Word of life "which we have seen with our eyes, which we looked upon and have touched with our hands" (1 John 1:1). If seeing Christ in the flesh was meant to become an icon, the eyewitnesses are the people who would have made one. Instead they left four Gospels that never describe his face, and Paul spoke of Christ being "publicly portrayed as crucified" (Galatians 3:1) by preaching.
Think of it this way: the people who knew him best did not paint him, and the church that painted him did not know him.
3. God works through matter without asking us to bow to it.
John of Damascus is right that the Incarnation honors matter, and Protestants have no quarrel with that. God healed through the edge of Jesus' cloak (Mark 5:27-29) and through cloths that had touched Paul (Acts 19:12), and Christians are baptized in water and fed with bread and wine because Christ commanded it.
- None of those things was a likeness of anyone, and none was kept, bowed to, or kissed afterward. When Israel did keep such an object, the bronze serpent, matter through which God had healed the dying, Hezekiah broke it once it began to receive offerings (2 Kings 18:4).
- The matter the Son took up is his own body, risen and reigning, and every honor given to it is given to him. A painted panel is not his body. It is a picture of it, and the commandment speaks to pictures.
4. Whether Christ's two natures can be painted is a separate question.
The iconoclast Council of Hieria (754) argued that a picture of Christ must either show his humanity apart from his divinity, splitting him in two, or claim to picture his divinity, which no one can. The defenders of icons answered that an icon shows the person (Greek hypostasis), not a nature by itself, and that is a serious reply.
Veneration can be rejected whichever side wins that exchange. The problem is the bow, not the brush.
+Veneration is not worship: the Second Council of Nicaea distinguished honor given to images from the worship owed to God alone. Kissing an icon is like a soldier kissing a photo of his wife.
1. The commandment forbids both words.
The council called the honor it allowed timētikē proskynēsis (honoring veneration) and reserved latreia (worship) for God alone.
- The distinction itself is real. Honoring a saint is not the same thing as worshiping God, and Scripture knows a bow of honor given to living people (P1).
- The trouble is where the council applied it. The Greek Old Testament renders Exodus 20:5 with both words: you shall not proskynēseis them, nor latreusēs them.
- So the council permitted toward images the very act that the commandment, in the church's own Greek Bible, forbade.
2. The commandment covers likenesses of real things, not only false gods.
An icon is not an idol in the sense its defenders mean: no Orthodox or Catholic believer thinks the painted panel is a god. But the commandment never drew its line between images of false beings and images of true ones.
- Its list is made of real creatures: anything in heaven, on earth, or in the water (Exodus 20:4), and in Moses' retelling male and female, beasts, birds, creeping things, and fish (Deuteronomy 4:16-18), with a warning against bowing to the sun and stars right after (4:19).
- Its reason, that Israel "saw no form" at Horeb (Deuteronomy 4:15), only makes sense if images of the LORD himself were in view.
- Some interpreters read the verse differently. In Hebrew the "them" of Exodus 20:5 is plural while "carved image" is singular, so they take "them" to point back to the "other gods" of verse 3. On that reading, what Israel may not bow to is other gods, not images as such.
• Deuteronomy 4 answers it, since Moses ties the ban on carved images to the day Israel saw no form of the LORD at Horeb.
• Leviticus 26:1 answers it too, forbidding Israel to set up a figured stone to bow down to it.
3. Israel's image-worshipers also meant to honor the Lord.
Aaron proclaimed a feast to the LORD before the golden calf (Exodus 32:5), and the bronze serpent was a holy object God had ordered (2 Kings 18:4). Neither good intentions nor a holy origin made bowing to an image acceptable. God judged the act, not the worshiper's account of what was happening inside.
None of this is a charge that Orthodox and Catholic Christians mean to worship wood and paint. They plainly do not, and their intention is to honor Christ. The point is that Scripture judges the bow to an image by what it is, whatever the heart behind it.
4. The family photo comparison proves too little.
A soldier kisses a photo of his wife, and nobody objects, because the photo is a keepsake. Nobody burns incense before it, lights lamps to it, carries it in procession, prays before it for healing, or is anathematized for refusing to honor it. Icons receive every one of those. In the ancient world prostration (lying face down), kissing, lamps, and incense were the ordinary acts of worship, and they are what pagans gave their images.
Aniconism does not threaten family photos, either. The comparison quietly offers only two choices, smash every picture or venerate icons, and the early church lived comfortably between them.
5. Pagans drew the same distinction, and the church rejected it.
Celsus argued that only a simpleton would think the statues were gods: they were offerings to the gods and images representing them, so the honor they received was meant for the gods themselves (Origen, Against Celsus 7.62).
- You might think, "But the pagans honored false gods, and Christians honor the true one." That is the obvious reply.
- Origen's answer, though, was not only about which god was honored. He did not say, "Then we Christians may do the same." He said Christians would rather die than worship before images, because such worship debases the conception they have of the Most High God (Against Celsus 7.64).
- His objection was to the way of worshiping, and it would apply to an image of the true God as much as to a statue of Zeus.
+God himself commanded images: cherubim over the ark, cherubim on the curtains, carvings in Solomon's temple, and the bronze serpent. The second commandment cannot be a ban on sacred images.
1. Granted: the commandment does not ban every image.
God's own sanctuary proves it, and that very fact is part of the evidence against veneration (P2). What the commandment forbids is bowing to images and serving them. The question is not whether religious art may exist but whether it may be venerated.
2. Not one of those images was venerated.
The cherubim over the ark were hidden in the Most Holy Place, seen by one man once a year. No one prayed to the temple's carved palm trees or kissed its bronze oxen. These images marked God's house, but nobody ever spoke to them.
3. The bronze serpent shows what happens when the line is crossed.
It was commanded by God, healed the dying, and later served Jesus as a picture of his cross (John 3:14). When Israel began making offerings to it, Hezekiah broke it in pieces, and Scripture praises him for it (2 Kings 18:3-5). If any image in history had a claim to veneration, this one did.
4. God's command is not the church's permission.
Moses made exactly what God specified, after the pattern he was shown (Exodus 25:40). Tertullian, the North African Christian writer of around 200, called the serpent an "extraordinary precept": Christians may follow it, he said, only when God commands them as he commanded Moses (On Idolatry 5). No such command exists for icons.
+"The honor paid to the image passes to its prototype." Basil the Great said it, and Nicaea built on it: bowing to an icon of Christ honors Christ, as kissing the emperor's portrait honored the emperor.
1. Basil was teaching the Trinity, not icons.
The line comes from On the Holy Spirit 18.45, and the prototype in it is the original that an image pictures. Basil is explaining why worshiping the Father and the Son does not make two gods: "we speak of a king, and of the king's image, and not of two kings." The Son is the Father's perfect image, so honor given to the Son is honor given to the Father.
The strongest form of the Orthodox reading grants all that and argues from the illustration itself. An illustration works only if its audience accepts it. Basil's works only if bowing to the emperor's portrait really does honor the emperor. Athanasius used the same picture a generation earlier: whoever bows to the emperor's image, he wrote, honors the emperor in it (Orations against the Arians 3.5). On this reading two great fourth-century fathers (the early church's leading teachers and writers) took the principle for granted, and the Second Council of Nicaea simply applied it.
That is true as far as it goes. After Constantine, Christians did honor the emperor's portrait as court ceremony, and both fathers drew on that custom. But an illustration chosen to explain a doctrine is not an instruction for worship, any more than Jesus' parable of the unjust judge teaches judges to give justice only to whoever pesters them.
2. Basil's image is the Son himself.
The principle does its work in Basil because the image in question is divine. The Son shares the Father's nature, so honoring him simply is honoring God.
- John of Damascus himself sorted images into kinds, and he put the Son, the Father's "natural" image, in a different class from images that people make.
- A son who has his father's face and a photograph of the father are both "images" of him, but only one of them is a person you could honor for his own sake.
- Moving the principle from the natural image to a painted one is the step the icon argument needs, and it is the step Basil never took.
3. Christians died rather than honor the emperor's image.
Around 112, the Roman governor Pliny wrote to the emperor Trajan about people accused of being Christians. He released those who called on the gods, offered incense and wine before the emperor's image, and cursed Christ, adding that real Christians could not be forced to do any of it (Pliny, Letters 10.96).
Those Christians were refusing divine honors, and a defender of icons will say that icon veneration claims no such thing. That is fair. But the acts they refused were incense and offerings set before a portrait, and incense and lamps before a portrait are what icons receive.
4. Scripture never accepts honor passed through an image.
- Aaron's calf was presented as a way to honor the LORD (Exodus 32:5), and God did not accept it as honor passed through.
- Isaiah spoke against the idols of the nations, but the reason God gives there is general: "my glory I give to no other, nor my praise to carved idols" (Isaiah 42:8).
The principle is also the one Celsus used to defend pagan statues (Origen, Against Celsus 7.62), and Origen's reply, which objects to the way of worshiping rather than only to the god being worshiped, answers it here too (D2).
+Archaeology shows Christian images from the start: paintings in the Roman catacombs, the house church at Dura-Europos, and figures of the Good Shepherd. The early church had sacred images.
1. Art is not an icon.
Orthodox teachers themselves define an icon by its use: it is made for prayer and worship, and "a gallery is the wrong place for icons," as the Russian Orthodox bishop Hilarion Alfeyev put it. So the discovery of early Christian art does not show icons unless it shows the art being venerated, and that is where the evidence runs out.
2. The earliest Christian art is narrative and decorative.
No distinctly Christian art can be dated before about 200. What appears in the third century is mostly stories of rescue painted in burial places: Jonah and the great fish, Noah in the ark, Daniel among the lions, the shepherd carrying a sheep.
- The catacombs were cemeteries, not churches, though Christians did gather there for prayer and memorial meals at the graves.
- At Dura-Europos, a frontier town in Syria, the house church (around 240) had paintings in its baptism room, while its large assembly hall, where the congregation met, had none.
- A baptism room is a place of worship, and it is fair to admit what that means: by the middle of the third century, images had entered a room set apart for the church's worship. But decoration in a place of worship is what Solomon's temple had too (P2). Nothing in either setting shows anyone bowing to, kissing, or praying before the pictures.
Archaeology can rarely show how an image was used, and that cuts both ways. Think of the stained glass in an old Protestant church: a stranger finding it in a thousand years might guess at its use, but the people who sat under it never prayed to it.
3. Early writers traced image-honoring to pagan habit.
Where an early writer does describe images being honored, he files it under pagan custom.
- Around 180, Irenaeus described the Carpocratians, a Gnostic sect (one of the early movements that claimed a secret knowledge beyond the apostles' teaching), who kept painted images of Christ, crowned them, and set them beside images of Pythagoras, Plato, and Aristotle, honoring them "after the same manner of the Gentiles" (Against Heresies 1.25.6), that is, the way pagans honored their own images.
- Early in the fourth century, Eusebius reported painted likenesses of Peter, Paul, and Christ, and a bronze statue at Caesarea Philippi said to show Jesus healing a woman who had touched his cloak. He granted that they existed and put them down to an old Gentile habit of honoring benefactors (Church History 7.18).
So portraits of Christ did exist before the great councils. That much is simply true, and the two writers who report them both trace the honoring of them to pagan custom rather than to the apostles.
+Elvira was a small local synod in Spain with no authority over the church. Its canon 36 is obscure, and it may only have protected sacred images from pagan mockery during persecution.
1. Elvira is evidence, not authority.
Nobody needs to obey Elvira to learn from it. Historians cite the same synod's canon 33, which required clergy to abstain from relations with their wives, as evidence that clerical celibacy was taking hold in the West, and they are right to. Canon 36 is evidence of the same kind: nineteen bishops recording what the church in their region practiced around 305. A local synod's rulings show local practice, and that is exactly what is in question.
2. Every proposed translation keeps the two points that matter.
Some argue the standard translation is wrong, and they offer alternatives such as "it has seemed good that images should not be in churches so that what is venerated and worshiped not be painted on the walls." Set the renderings side by side, though, and every one keeps the same two points. Pictures are kept out of the church, and what is worshiped is not to be painted.
The strongest attempt to narrow it reads the canon as forbidding only paintings of God himself ("what is worshiped and adored"), or only paintings on walls. Either way, portable panels of the saints would be untouched.
- The main clause is general: no picturas, no pictures, in church. The "lest" clause gives the bishops' reason. It does not shrink their rule.
- Even on the narrow reading, the bishops kept the object of worship off the walls of the place of worship. Images of Christ, set where the congregation prays, are what an Orthodox church places at its center.
A nineteenth-century history of the church councils, written by a Catholic historian who became a bishop, concluded from the canon that the ancient church did not tolerate images.
3. The protection theory has no footing in the text.
Nothing in canon 36 mentions persecution, desecration, or pagans. And even if protection were the motive, the canon would show that images could be removed from churches entirely with no loss to worship. An icon that the liturgy (the church's set order of public worship) can do without is not what the Orthodox church means by an icon.
+The fathers quoted were attacking pagan idols, not Christian images. Origen was later condemned as a heretic, and Patriarch Nicephorus exposed the letters of Epiphanius against images as forgeries.
1. Celsus and Caecilius were describing Christians, not idols.
Many early statements target pagan statues, and there is no point pretending otherwise. But Celsus and Caecilius were not describing idols. They were describing Christians, and their complaint was that Christians had no images. Origen and Minucius Felix agreed with the description and defended it.
2. Origen's later condemnation does not touch his testimony.
Origen's speculative theology was condemned long after his death, but what matters in P4 is his testimony as a witness to how Christians worshiped in the third century. A man's errors about the soul's preexistence give him no motive to misreport what happened in his own congregation, and nobody in his century contradicted him.
3. The case for Epiphanius's letter is strong.
Consider first who raised the forgery charge, and when.
- It was raised during the eighth- and ninth-century controversy by defenders of icons, who had an obvious interest in the outcome. It came up at the Second Council of Nicaea, and most fully from Nicephorus, patriarch (chief bishop) of Constantinople, in the early ninth century.
- Nicephorus aimed chiefly at the treatises and letters against images, under Epiphanius's name, that the iconoclasts were quoting. In 1916 a leading German church historian examined his arguments in detail and defended those writings as genuine.
- Not every scholar was persuaded, but the great majority of twentieth-century scholars agreed with him.
The curtain story (P4) stands on firmer ground still.
- It comes from the letter to John of Jerusalem, which survives in Jerome's Latin translation, made in the mid-390s, centuries before anyone had a stake in the fight.
- No surviving copy lacks the passage about the curtain. Some scholars have suspected that the paragraph was added, but no manuscript supports the suspicion.
- What it reports fits everything else: Elvira's canon, Eusebius's refusal, and Augustine's complaint about worshipers of pictures.
+Holy Tradition traces icons to the apostles: Luke painted the Mother of God, Christ sent his own image to King Abgar of Edessa, and Basil wrote that icons were handed down from the apostles.
1. The Luke story appears four and a half centuries after Luke.
The first report is credited to Theodore the Reader in the sixth century (P5). Augustine, writing early in the fifth century, said that we do not know what the Virgin Mary looked like (On the Trinity 8). An eyewitness portrait of Mary would have been famous long before then.
2. The Abgar story grew an image over time.
The story of King Abgar of Edessa, who wrote to Jesus asking to be healed, can be watched growing across nearly three centuries.
- Early in the fourth century, Eusebius tells it with letters and no picture (Church History 1.13).
- Around 400, a painted portrait appears, made by the king's archivist, in the Doctrine of Addai, a work in Syriac (the Aramaic dialect of Edessa's Christians).
- At the end of the sixth century, Evagrius Scholasticus has the miraculous image "not made by hands" (Ecclesiastical History 4.27).
The image arrives in stages, which is what legends do and what eyewitness memory does not.
3. Basil's Letter 360 is not Basil's.
The letter that says icons were "handed down from the holy apostles" is widely judged spurious (P5). The genuine Basil wrote about the Son as the Father's image, not about painted panels.
4. A late tradition can preserve a true memory.
Of course it can. The question, though, is what the earliest witnesses say, and here they say the opposite: the church of the first three centuries venerated no images, and its writers explained why.
+The Seventh Ecumenical Council (787) settled the question, and Protestants accept the councils of Nicaea and Chalcedon. Picking which councils to keep makes you the judge of the church.
1. Protestants accept councils because they agree with Scripture.
The Reformation principle is sola Scriptura: Scripture is the final test, and councils are honored where they agree with it. That is not a modern invention.
- The Bereans were praised for "examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so" (Acts 17:11), even after hearing Paul.
- Jesus himself tested the tradition of the elders by the word of God and warned against "teaching as doctrines the commandments of men" (Mark 7:7).
Nicaea (325) is accepted because it says what Scripture says about the Son, and Chalcedon (451), which confessed Christ as one person with two natures, on the same ground. The same test, applied to 787, gives a different answer.
Nor does any of this lean on the Protestant rule alone. The Orthodox test is continuity with the church of the fathers, and on icons that test sends the reader to the church's first centuries (P4), where the evidence runs against veneration.
2. "Settled" is not the right word for 787.
The question was fought over before 787, and it stayed contested for half a century after.
- In 754 the Council of Hieria, with 338 bishops, condemned the veneration of images.
- Pope Hadrian I, whose legates (his official representatives) attended, defended the council. But in 794 the Council of Frankfurt, meeting under Charlemagne, rejected its teaching on the adoration of images. It did so partly because it was working from a poor Latin translation of the council's acts (its official record).
- In 825, under Charlemagne's son Louis the Pious, Frankish bishops and theologians met at Paris and again rejected the veneration of images, while keeping images for decoration and remembrance and faulting the Byzantine iconoclasts for destroying them.
- Iconoclasm returned to Byzantium from 815 to 843, and the veneration of icons was restored for good only in 843.
None of that refutes the council, of course. A disputed council is not thereby a false one. Nicaea in 325 was resisted for half a century, and in 359 the twin councils of Rimini and Seleucia, larger than Nicaea itself, endorsed a creed that dodged its teaching. What the disputes over 787 do show is that its authority does not end the conversation, and that the test of Scripture has to do the deciding.
3. The council condemned the earlier church's position.
The Second Council of Nicaea pronounced anathema on everyone who rejects the veneration of images. It did not mean to strike at the fathers it honored. So when the iconoclasts quoted earlier witnesses against it, the council set those witnesses aside.
- It dismissed Eusebius as a man of Arian sympathies, that is, leaning toward Arius's teaching that the Son was a created being rather than fully God.
- It dismissed the writings of Epiphanius as forgeries (D7).
But the position it condemned is the one Epiphanius, Eusebius, and the bishops of Elvira held. A council that has to discard the church's earlier witnesses before it can condemn their position cannot claim merely to preserve it.
See also:
PT / The Trinity: The Two Errors Nicaea Refused
+Doctrine develops: the early church held icon veneration in seed, the way an acorn holds an oak. Silence in the first centuries is no objection to later growth.
1. The early church's stance on icons was a ban, not a seed.
The nineteenth-century theologian John Henry Newman's theory of development holds that later doctrine unfolds what was present in the earliest church. Some doctrines do grow that way.
The strongest version of this objection finds the seed in the second century's honor for the martyrs. After Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, was martyred, his church counted his bones more valuable than precious stones, laid them in a fitting place, and gathered there each year on the day of his death (Martyrdom of Polycarp 18). Honor for holy people and holy things, on this view, flowered later into honor for their images.
That is a real line of continuity. But the same church drew the line in the same document: Christ, they wrote, we worship as the Son of God, and the martyrs we love as his disciples (Martyrdom of Polycarp 17). Honoring a martyr's memory is not bowing to his picture.
An acorn is consistent with the oak it becomes. The early church on icons was not a seed of later practice. It was a ban on it (P4):
- The bishops at Elvira kept pictures out of church.
- Eusebius refused an image of Christ.
- Epiphanius tore one down.
That is less like an acorn and more like weed killer.
2. Development can fill in but cannot reverse.
A doctrine may become clearer over time, as the church's language for the Trinity did. It cannot become the opposite of what the church first taught, or "development" would justify anything.
- Newman said so himself. In his essay on development (1845, revised 1878) he set out seven "notes," or tests, that tell a true development from a corruption. Two of them are the preservation of type, meaning the grown doctrine keeps the shape of the young one, and a "conservative action upon its past," meaning it protects what came before rather than overturning it.
- Put simply, a true development keeps and protects what came before it. A corruption reverses it.
- By that test, a practice the early church forbade (P4) and a later council required is not an oak grown from an acorn. It is a corruption, in Newman's own word.
The strongest Catholic reply turns Newman against that verdict. Another of his notes is the "power of assimilation," a living faith's ability to take in customs from outside and make them its own. Newman himself listed incense, lamps, candles, and, at a later date, images among the customs of pagan origin that the church sanctified by adopting them.
- That reading of Newman is accurate, and it should be granted: he judged the use of images a true development.
- But his test outranks his verdict. Assimilation can take in what the early church never refused, the way it took in church calendars and wedding rings. It cannot take in the very act the early church named as the pagan one and refused: incense set before a portrait, which Christians died rather than offer (D4), and worship before images, which Origen said they would die rather than give (P4).
- Think of a family that adopts a neighbor's Christmas carols with no trouble at all. If it adopts the one custom its grandparents went to jail rather than keep, that is no longer assimilation. It is a change of mind.
3. Eastern Orthodoxy claims continuity, not development.
Newman wrote as a Roman Catholic. Eastern Orthodox teachers more often claim unbroken continuity with the early church, a church that has not changed. On icons, that claim has no theory of growth to fall back on. It has to meet the early evidence (P4) directly, and the early church it claims to continue is the church that refused to venerate images.
+Protestants are inconsistent: they have stained glass, children's Bible pictures, Jesus films, crosses, and nativity scenes. If images are fine there, the objection to icons collapses.
1. The line is devotion, not depiction.
Scripture permits pictures (P2). What it forbids is bowing to them, kissing them, praying before them, and offering them candles and incense. A child's Bible with a picture of Noah's ark sits on the near side of that line, and so does a stained-glass window nobody prays to.
2. Protestants honestly disagree about pictures.
Some Reformed churches, following the Westminster Larger Catechism (question 109), refuse any picture of Christ. Lutherans keep crucifixes and painted altarpieces. The early church held a similar range of views, from Tertullian, who wanted artists to stop making images altogether, to bishops who used a cup engraved with the Good Shepherd. What all of them shared was the refusal to venerate.
3. The line binds Protestants too.
A Protestant who kneels to pray before a stained-glass Jesus is crossing the same line, and the same commandment answers him. Consistency means applying the line to everyone, not abandoning it.
+Iconoclasm has an ugly history: emperors who tortured monks, mobs who smashed church art in the Reformation, and ideas borrowed from Islam and Judaism.
1. Iconoclast persecution does not decide the question.
The iconoclast emperor Constantine V persecuted monks who defended icons, and some died for it. That is real history, and it should not be softened. But a doctrine's truth is not settled by the conduct of its worst defenders, or no Christian doctrine would survive the history of the church.
2. Rejecting veneration does not mean destroying images.
Riots against images have no part in that rejection. Martin Luther himself returned to Wittenberg in 1522 and preached against the image-breakers, insisting that images be taken from hearts by the word rather than torn from walls by force. The conclusion (C) is that Christians should not venerate images, and a church can live it out without breaking anything.
3. The early church's aniconism is older than Islam.
Islam began in the seventh century. Christian worship that honored no image is documented four centuries earlier.
The Jewish background is the Bible's own. In the apostles' century, Jews in Jerusalem risked death rather than let images into the holy city (D15). That is the world the apostles came from.
+Pope Gregory the Great called pictures the books of the unlettered, and the church has always used images to teach. Rejecting icons throws that away.
1. Gregory drew the same line.
Around 600, Gregory rebuked Serenus, bishop of Marseilles, for smashing the pictures in his churches. In the same letters he praised Serenus for forbidding people to adore them. Pictures, Gregory said, let those who cannot read learn the story of what is to be adored, and adoring the picture itself is another thing altogether.
Teaching pictures, yes; veneration, no. That is the line drawn in P2. Gregory stands at the generous end of the early church's range on images, and he still would not cross the line into worship.
2. Teaching and veneration are different uses.
A picture of the crucifixion in a children's Bible teaches. The same picture, set on a stand, kissed, censed, and prayed before, is being venerated. Only the second use crosses the line.
+Scripture itself approves bowing before holy things and holy people: Joshua fell on his face before the ark, Israel prayed toward the temple, and Jacob bowed in worship over his staff. Icon veneration is that same honor, not the worship owed to God.
1. Scripture's bow of honor goes to living people.
The strongest form of this objection gathers the texts defenders of icons have used since John of Damascus.
- Abraham bowed to the Hittites (Genesis 23:7) and Jacob to Esau (Genesis 33:3), with the same Greek verb the commandment uses.
- Joshua lay on his face before the ark until evening (Joshua 7:6).
- Hebrews says the dying Jacob was "bowing in worship over the head of his staff" (Hebrews 11:21).
- Christ himself promises that the persecutors of the church at Philadelphia will bow down before its feet (Revelation 3:9).
If Scripture approves all that, the argument runs, a bow before a holy thing cannot be idolatry, and an icon is a holy thing.
Much of this is simply right. Scripture knows a bow of honor that is not worship, and the Bible's people gave it freely.
- Abraham's and Jacob's bows have company: David bowed the same way to King Saul (1 Samuel 24:8). Revelation 3:9 belongs with them, since it echoes Isaiah 60:14, where Zion's oppressors come bowing to her, and it pictures enemies made to acknowledge the people God has loved.
- Every one of those bows lands on a living, present person. Think of a wedding reception: the guests rise when the bride walks in, and nobody rises for her photograph on the gift table.
- The commandment forbids the bow to one object by name, an image, and Scripture's bow of honor never once lands on a likeness.
2. The ark and the temple were places God appointed.
Joshua's prostration and Israel's prayer toward the temple are the strongest texts in the list, and they have a clear answer.
- God promised to meet Moses above the ark, between the cherubim (Exodus 25:22). Solomon's prayer keeps the two things apart in one line: exiled Israel would "pray to you toward their land, which you gave to their fathers, the city that you have chosen, and the house that I have built for your name" (1 Kings 8:48). The prayer went to God. Only its direction went toward the house.
- Daniel prayed at windows "open toward Jerusalem" (Daniel 6:10) while the temple lay in ruins. His prayer could not have been honor paid to an object, because the object was gone.
- An icon differs on both counts. God never appointed it as a place to meet him, and it is a likeness. Israel faced the temple because God told it to, and a church may not appoint its own meeting place with God and bow before it (D3).
3. Jacob bowed over his staff, not to it.
- Hebrews 11:21 follows the Greek Old Testament of Genesis 47:31. The Hebrew consonants there can be read as "bed" (mittah) or "staff" (matteh). The Hebrew text, as it was later supplied with vowels, says Jacob bowed at the head of his bed, and the Greek says his staff.
- Either way the scene is an old man, too weak to stand, bowing to God as he leaned on whatever held him up. The worship went to God.
- A grandfather who leans on his cane to bow his head at grace is not saying grace to the cane.
- Some later readers took "his staff" to mean Joseph's, a ruler's staff, and read the verse as reverence for the top of it. That asks a dying man's posture to carry a doctrine the text never mentions.
+Judaism was not aniconic. The synagogues at Dura-Europos and Sepphoris were covered with painted and mosaic scenes of Abraham, Moses, and even the zodiac, so Christian images grew naturally from Jewish soil.
1. The synagogue art is real and striking.
The strongest form of this objection, pressed by Orthodox writers, uses these finds against the claim that the apostles' world worshiped without images. The finds are remarkable.
- At Dura-Europos, the same frontier town as the house church (D5), an inscription dates the rebuilding of the synagogue to about 244. Its assembly hall was painted wall to wall with biblical scenes: Moses leading Israel through the sea, Ezekiel in the valley of dry bones, Abraham about to sacrifice Isaac, and the hand of God reaching down from heaven.
- At Sepphoris in Galilee, a fifth-century synagogue floor carries a mosaic of the binding of Isaac, a zodiac wheel, and the sun riding a chariot.
- Judaism after the apostles made far more room for religious art than older textbooks allowed, and that correction stands.
2. The finds come from long after the apostles.
- Dura's paintings come two centuries after Jesus, and the Sepphoris floor four. Using them to describe Jesus' Galilee is like describing how Americans furnished their homes in 1825 from photographs taken in 2025.
- The first-century evidence runs the other way. When Herod the Great set a golden eagle over the temple gate, students of the law climbed up and cut it down, and some died for it (Josephus, Jewish War 1.648-655). When Pilate brought the emperor's image into Jerusalem on his standards, crowds bared their necks rather than accept it (Jewish War 2.169-174).
- The coins tell the same story. The Hasmonean kings (the Jewish dynasty that ruled Judea before Herod) and Herod Antipas, ruler of Galilee in Jesus' day, struck coins with anchors, wreaths, and plants, never a face. Antipas's brother Philip, ruling a mostly Gentile territory, was the exception.
3. The synagogues decorated without venerating.
- No evidence shows anyone bowing to, kissing, or lighting a lamp before the Dura walls. At Sepphoris the binding of Isaac was laid in the floor, where the congregation walked across it every Sabbath. A picture you walk on is a picture nobody venerates.
- The Mishnah, the first written collection of rabbinic law (compiled around 200), draws the same line. Rabban Gamaliel, a leading rabbi, was asked how he could bathe in a bathhouse at Acre that held a statue of Aphrodite, and he answered that the statue was there to decorate the bath, not to be served as a goddess (Mishnah, Avodah Zarah 3:4).
- That is the line drawn in P2: art in the house of worship, devotion to God alone. The synagogues are witnesses for it, not against it.
+The early church lacked images because it was poor, persecuted, and surrounded by idols, not because of principle. Once Christians had buildings and peace, they made images, and that was natural growth, not betrayal.
1. On art, the historians are right.
The strongest form of this objection comes from historians of early Christian art. They argue that the old picture of an image-hating early church is a myth: Christians before 200 had no land, little money, and no visual style of their own, and they began making art as soon as they had the means.
- The conclusion (C) already grants the point that matters. The early church's quarrel was with images in worship, not with every picture: Tertullian stood at the strict end in wanting no images at all, Elvira kept pictures out of church buildings, and others allowed a Good Shepherd on a cup (D11). Nor is the case against veneration a case against pictures as such.
- The question is not when Christians began to paint. It is whether they bowed to what they painted.
2. The Christians gave their own reasons.
- Origen did not tell Celsus that Christians could not afford statues. He said they would rather die than debase their conception of God (Against Celsus 7.64). The Christian in Octavius said a human being is already God's image (Octavius 32). Those are reasons drawn from the second commandment, not from a budget.
- Think of a neighbor who tells you she keeps her shop shut on Sundays because of her convictions. You might suspect the real reason is that business is slow, until business booms and the shop stays shut.
3. The refusals continued after the poverty ended.
- Eusebius refused the emperor's own half-sister a picture of Christ, after Constantine had made the church rich and safe. Constantia could have hired any painter in the empire. It was the bishop, not her purse, who said no.
- Augustine's complaint about worshipers of pictures (388) and Epiphanius's torn curtain (394) came from a church that by then had basilicas (great public church halls), patrons, and artists (P4).
Calling what came afterward "natural growth" is the development claim, and D10 answers it: development can fill in what the church first taught, but it cannot reverse it.
4. Avoiding pagan worship is the commandment's own reason.
- If the first Christians kept images out of worship to avoid worshiping the way their neighbors did, that is the reason Moses gave. Israel was not to be drawn into bowing to the sun, moon, and stars, the worship of the peoples around them (Deuteronomy 4:19).
- That reason did not lapse when the temples closed. Augustine's worshipers of tombs and pictures were not pagans at all. They were people the church counted as its own children. The danger lived in the worshiper, then, rather than in the pagan next door.
+Idolatry means treating a created thing as God or giving it the sacrificial worship due to God alone. No one who venerates an icon thinks the panel is God, so the ban on idols does not touch icons.
1. This is a real Catholic and Orthodox position.
The Catholic apologist Jimmy Akin has defended exactly this definition: idolatry is taking an image to be a god, or giving it latria (the Latin form of the Greek latreia), the sacrificial worship due to God alone. On that definition a believer who kisses an icon of Christ, knowing it is wood and paint, is not an idolater, whatever else he is doing.
It is fair to grant that no Orthodox or Catholic Christian thinks the panel is God (D2). The question is whether that settles anything.
2. The narrow definition misses the educated pagan.
Some idolaters really did take the wood for a god. Isaiah mocks the man who carves a block, falls down to it, and prays, "Deliver me, for you are my god!" (Isaiah 44:17), and the narrow definition describes him exactly.
- But the pagans the church actually argued with did not. Celsus said only a simpleton would take statues for gods, since they were offerings to the gods and images representing them (Origen, Against Celsus 7.62).
- Two centuries later the emperor Julian, trying to restore the old religion, told a priest the same thing. The images of the gods are not mere stone or wood, he wrote, but neither are they the gods themselves, just as an emperor's statue is not the emperor, though whoever loves the emperor delights to look at it (Julian, Fragment of a Letter to a Priest). That is the portrait argument for icons (D4), in a pagan's mouth.
- The church still called that idolatry and refused it (D2). A definition that clears Celsus and Julian is too narrow for the very cases the fathers condemned.
3. The commandment forbids the bow as well as the sacrifice.
A defender of the narrow definition has a ready reply to the golden calf. Israel offered burnt offerings before it (Exodus 32:6), and sacrifice is latria, so the calf fits his definition and icons, which receive no sacrifice, do not.
- That is a fair reply, and it shifts the question to the commandment's wording. "You shall not bow down to them or serve them" (Exodus 20:5) has two verbs. If only the service of sacrifice were forbidden, the ban on bowing would add nothing (P1).
• Some scholars read the pair as one idea, "worship them," the way "cease and desist" says one thing in two words. Even then, the forbidden act is the bow of worship to an image, and the Greek word the church's Bible uses for it is the word the Second Council of Nicaea chose for what icons receive (D2).
- Incense sits on the line he draws. In the Old Testament, burning incense was an offering, and it is what Israel gave the bronze serpent until Hezekiah broke it (2 Kings 18:4). Icons are censed.
- Orthodox clergy cense the congregation too, as bearers of God's image, which shows they intend honor and not sacrifice. The intention should be granted (D2). But the serpent had a holy origin and an honorable purpose as well, and Scripture judged the act.
4. Scripture's idea of idolatry is wider than a theory about statues.
- God told Ezekiel that the elders of Israel "have taken their idols into their hearts" (Ezekiel 14:3), and Paul calls covetousness "idolatry" (Colossians 3:5). A greedy man needs no statue at all.
- Idolatry in Scripture is devotion given to something other than God, or given to God by a means he forbade, as the calf was (P1). It is a matter of where honor goes and how it gets there, not only of what a worshiper believes about an object.
- Think of a wife who has asked her husband, in so many words, never to give her a certain gift. If he gives it anyway and insists it is all for her, his sincerity is real, and the gift is still not the love she asked for.
+The case is an argument from silence that assumes sola Scriptura. The New Testament never mentions icons, and nothing follows from what a text leaves unsaid.
1. The case rests on a command, not a silence.
An argument from silence draws a conclusion from what a text does not say. The strongest form of this objection, pressed by the Catholic apologists Trent Horn and Jimmy Akin, says that a Protestant who points to the New Testament's silence on icons is begging the question, that is, assuming the very point in dispute: he takes for granted that only what Scripture says counts.
- But the case does not begin with silence. It begins with an explicit prohibition, "You shall not bow down to them or serve them" (Exodus 20:5), and its explanation in Deuteronomy 4 (P1).
- What the New Testament adds is that the prohibition was never reversed. An argument from silence infers something from nothing. This argument infers that a standing command still stands. Whether the command reaches icons at all is a real question, and it is argued on its merits, not assumed (P1, P2, D1, D17).
- Think of a sign at a lake that says "No swimming." If the park newsletter never mentions swimming again, nobody concludes from the silence that swimming is now allowed. You would need a new sign.
2. Silence where noise is expected is evidence.
Historians reason from silence all the time when a record ought to speak.
- A rule as startling as bowing to images, given to Jewish converts, would have left a trail of argument, the way circumcision did (P3).
- A practice the apostles taught would have left a trail of witnesses, the way Sunday worship did (P5).
In one Sherlock Holmes story the decisive clue is a watchdog that did not bark in the night, which told Holmes the visitor was someone the dog knew. Silence is evidence when something ought to have made a noise, and the apostolic record is silent in exactly that way.
That silence tells against one claim only, the claim that the apostles taught veneration. A Catholic who holds that the practice developed later expects no noise in the first century. Against that view, what counts is what came next: the early church refused the practice (P4), and a development cannot reverse what came before it (D10).
3. The premises do not need sola Scriptura.
They need only a principle Catholics and Orthodox share.
- Both churches teach that true tradition never contradicts Scripture. The Second Vatican Council said the church's teaching office is not above the word of God but serves it (Dei Verbum 10). So if the commandment forbids bowing to images (P1), no tradition can permit it, on Catholic terms as much as Protestant ones.
- The same document adds that the teaching office alone interprets Scripture authentically, and that is where the real disagreement lies: not over whether Scripture binds tradition, but over who may read it. The fairest reader to call is the church nearest the apostles, which read the commandment as a ban (P4).
- The Orthodox test is continuity with the early church (D9). On that test the history strand does its work without any Protestant premise: the early church refused the practice (P4), so veneration cannot be apostolic, and no Christian can be bound to it (C).
- Think of a court of appeal that decides a case using only the precedents both lawyers have already accepted. Neither lawyer can complain that the judge applied his own private rule.
See also:
PT / Bibliology: Sola Scriptura
+Icon veneration is a secondary matter. Protestants disagree among themselves about baptism and church government without breaking fellowship, so treating icons as a dividing line is out of proportion.
1. As a private habit, it might be secondary.
Protestants sort doctrines by weight, a practice sometimes called theological triage, after the way an emergency room sorts patients by how urgently they need care. That much should be granted: a believer who quietly kisses a picture of Christ, without insisting anyone else must, might well be a case for patient teaching rather than division.
2. The council made it a test of communion.
It was not Protestants who made icons a dividing line. The Second Council of Nicaea required veneration and pronounced anathema on everyone who refuses it, and the Synodikon used on the Sunday of Orthodoxy still pronounces anathema on those who reject icons (C). A Protestant cannot join a church whose binding council curses what he believes Scripture teaches.
That is a line about which church a Christian can join, not about who is a Christian. Orthodox and Catholic believers remain brothers and sisters (C).
3. In 787 an anathema was a curse, not a disciplinary note.
Jimmy Akin argues that the anathemas were disciplinary measures for their own time and place, not permanent verdicts on modern Protestants.
- To be fair, Catholic canon law (the church's own legal code) no longer uses anathema as a penalty, and the Second Vatican Council taught that those born into separated communities cannot be charged with the sin of separation (Unitatis Redintegratio 3). No Catholic need think a Protestant neighbor is under a curse.
- But the word comes from Paul's "let him be accursed" (Galatians 1:8-9), and the council used it in that solemn sense. It condemned not only rioters who smashed images but anyone who declines to venerate them, and it treated their refusal as a denial of the Incarnation itself.
- The definition the anathemas protected still stands as the teaching of an ecumenical council in both churches. A curse can be retired from the law books while the doctrine it guarded stays in force.