Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Judah ha-Nasi of Sepphoris c. 135 – c. 217 AD
(●) The patriarch of the Jews in Roman Galilee who gathered the oral law into the Mishnah, the book rabbinic Judaism is built on. Imagine a family that has never written down its recipes. Grandmother taught her daughters at the stove, they taught theirs, and every cook in the line added a note or a warning of her own. Then a war scatters the family across three countries, and someone realizes that unless the recipes are gathered and set in order now, they will be gone within a generation. Judah ha-Nasi was that someone for the Jewish people. After two wars with Rome had destroyed the temple and emptied Jerusalem, he gathered the teaching the rabbis had passed down by word of mouth, the oral law, and set it in order in the Mishnah, around AD 200. The Jewish tradition remembers him simply as "Rabbi," the teacher, as though there had been no other. It also calls him Rabbenu ha-Kadosh, "our holy teacher," and ha-Nasi, "the Prince." That last was the title of the patriarch, the leader whom Rome recognized as head of the Jews of the land of Israel. He was rich, powerful, learned, and by the stories told of him often difficult, and he spent his last years in Sepphoris, a Galilean city a few miles from Nazareth. He belongs on a Christian site because the Mishnah is the oldest large record of the rabbis’ law, and it preserves much of the Jewish custom that stands behind the New Testament: hand washing before meals, a Sabbath day’s journey, the Passover meal, the high court that tried Jesus. Most of what we know about him comes from the Talmud, the vast record of the later rabbis’ discussion of the Mishnah, line by line, gathered over the centuries after his death. It comes in two versions: the Jerusalem Talmud, from the schools of Galilee, and the larger Babylonian Talmud, from the Jewish schools of Mesopotamia. Both mix law with story, and the stories about Judah were told by admirers long after he was gone. That is why his dates come from tradition rather than record. Birth around AD 135 rests on a story tying it to the death of Akiva, the most revered teacher of his grandfather’s generation, and the year of his death is given variously, about 217 AD by the usual reckoning. Every date in his life is the conventional one, and it carries "c." for that reason.
(●) c. 135 AD: He was born into the house of Hillel in the year Rome crushed the last great Jewish revolt. Judah was the son of Rabban Shimon ben Gamaliel, the second of that name. Ben means "son of," and Rabban, "our master," was a grander form of "Rabbi" given to the heads of the house of Hillel and to very few others. So Judah was by family tradition a descendant of Hillel the Elder, the great teacher of the generation before Jesus. Later sources went further and traced Hillel’s line, and so Judah’s, back to King David. He was born into a ruined world. The revolt led by Simon bar Kokhba, whom Akiva had hailed as the messiah, ended in AD 135 with the fall of the fortress of Betar, and Jews were forbidden to enter Aelia Capitolina, the pagan colony the emperor Hadrian had founded on the site of Jerusalem. The teachers of the law were hunted, and Akiva himself was executed. Later the rabbis looked back on those years and saw providence in them. In the Talmud, and in Genesis Rabbah, their ancient commentary on the book of Genesis, they said that "when Rabbi Akiva died, Rabbi was born" (Babylonian Talmud, Kiddushin 72b; Genesis Rabbah 58:2): one sun set and another rose. It is a teaching story, not a birth record, and the only firm date it gives is roughly the right decade.
(●) c. 150 AD: As a young man he learned the law from the surviving students of Akiva. When Hadrian died in AD 138 the persecution eased, and the scattered teachers came out of hiding and met in Galilee, at the town of Usha, where Judah’s father became head of the restored court. The boy grew up among the men who had carried Akiva’s teaching through the dark years: Shimon bar Yochai, Judah bar Ilai, Yose ben Halafta, Eleazar ben Shammua. The Talmud preserves him remembering his student days, studying with Shimon at Tekoa and arriving at the school of Eleazar ben Shammua (Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat 147b; Yevamot 84a), and the tradition counts the other two among his teachers as well. He learned the way every student of the oral law learned, by repetition. The word mishnah comes from the Hebrew for "to repeat": a teacher recited a ruling, the students repeated it back until it was fixed in memory, and the next ruling followed. Picture a schoolroom reciting multiplication tables, except that the tables covered the whole of life, from the blessing over bread to the purity of a cooking pot, and the students would one day be the only books there were.
(●) c. 170 AD: He succeeded his father as patriarch, and the rabbis said no one since Moses had joined learning to power as he did. Around AD 170, by the usual reckoning, Judah followed his father as nasi, the patriarch. The office made him the Jewish community’s spokesman before Rome and its chief authority within: he appointed judges, fixed the calendar, and sent teachers to the towns. He was also very rich, with estates, flocks and servants, and he lived like a man of rank. The rabbis summed him up with a famous line: from Moses until Rabbi, Torah and greatness were not found in one place (Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 59a). Torah here is God’s teaching and the learning of it; greatness is wealth and rank. Think of a town where the best scholar is poor and the mayor has never opened a book. Learning and power had usually belonged to different men, and in him, for once, they met. A cluster of stories pairs him with a Roman emperor called Antoninus, who visits him by a secret tunnel, sends him gifts, and asks him questions about the soul and the resurrection (Babylonian Talmud, Avodah Zarah 10a–b; Sanhedrin 91a–b). Which emperor is meant, if any, no one knows: Marcus Aurelius, Septimius Severus and Caracalla have all been proposed. The stories are best read as the rabbis’ picture of a patriarch so respected that even Rome came to him to learn. How much power the office carried, we learn from an unexpected witness. Origen, the Christian scholar who lived at Caesarea a generation later, watched it at work. He called the patriarch the Jews’ ethnarch, a Greek title meaning "ruler of the nation," and wrote that by Caesar’s leave the man held so much power that, as Origen and others who had seen it knew, he "differs in little from a true king" (Letter to Africanus 14). He was describing one of Judah’s successors, of course, but the office was the one Judah had made great.
(●) c. 175–200 AD: He led the high court at Beit She’arim, then moved to Sepphoris for his health. After the temple fell, the rabbis’ high court, the Sanhedrin, wandered like the ark in the wilderness. The Talmud lists its stations: from Jerusalem to Yavneh, to Usha, to Shefaram, to Beit She’arim, to Sepphoris, and at last to Tiberias (Babylonian Talmud, Rosh Hashanah 31a–b). Two of those stops were Judah’s. He presided first at Beit She’arim, a town on the hills above the Jezreel Valley, and later moved to Sepphoris, where the mountain air was thought better for a sick man. The tradition says he lived in Sepphoris seventeen years, and that he applied to himself the verse about the patriarch Jacob in Egypt: "Jacob lived in the land of Egypt seventeen years" (Genesis 47:28; Jerusalem Talmud, Kilayim 9:3). Sepphoris was the capital of Galilee, a Roman city with a theater and paved streets, an hour’s walk from Nazareth. Judah’s court there made it, for a generation, the center of Jewish learning in the world.
(●) c. 200 AD: He completed the Mishnah, the oral law set in six orders. Before Judah, every school had its own collection of rulings, and Akiva and his student Meir had already begun to arrange them. Judah took the collections, chose among the rulings, and fixed their wording, in the clear and compact Hebrew that scholars now call Mishnaic Hebrew. The result fills six orders, or divisions, subdivided into sixty-three tractates, or topics: Seeds (prayer and farming), Appointed Times (Sabbath and festivals), Women (marriage and divorce), Damages (civil and criminal law), Holy Things (sacrifices and the temple), and Purities (ritual cleanness). Two things about the book still surprise first-time readers. It argues: page after page records "Rabbi Meir says this, and the sages say that," and it explains why it keeps the losing opinion as well as the winning one, so that a later court may rely on the minority view if it ever needs to (Mishnah Eduyot 1:5). And it describes in loving detail a temple that had been rubble for more than a century, down to the measurements of its courts. You might expect that a man who completed a book wrote it down. Whether Judah did, or instead fixed the Mishnah in a form to be memorized, is an old question. Sherira Gaon gave the classic account of its making in a letter of AD 987. (Gaon, "excellency," was the title of the heads of the great Babylonian academies, and Sherira led the one at Pumbedita.) Medieval authorities disagreed on the point, and we simply do not know. Either way, the oral law now had a shape, and it never lost it.
(●) c. 200–217 AD: The rabbis told that one pitiless word brought him thirteen years of suffering, and one merciful word ended them. The rabbis did not make their great men flawless, and the best-known story about Judah is a story against him. A calf being led to slaughter broke away, ran to him, and hid its head in the folds of his cloak, lowing. He pushed it back: "Go, for this you were created." Because he had shown no pity, the story says, suffering came on him, and it stayed for thirteen years. The traditions set the suffering late in his life. The Babylonian Talmud says he was moved to Sepphoris when he fell ill (Ketubot 103b), and the Jerusalem Talmud counts thirteen of his seventeen years there as years of pain, a toothache in its telling (Kilayim 9:3). In the Babylonian version the suffering ended as it began, with a young animal, and this time in his own house. One day his maid was sweeping out a nest of young weasels, and he stopped her: let them be, for it is written, "his mercy is over all that he has made" (Psalm 145:9). Because he had shown pity, pity was shown to him, and the suffering left (Babylonian Talmud, Bava Metzia 85a). Whether or not it happened that way, the story says something true about how the rabbis saw him: a man of enormous authority, capable of impatience, who learned mercy late and was remembered for having learned it.
(●) c. 217 AD: He died in Sepphoris, saying he had toiled in the law with ten fingers and taken no pleasure with even one. The Talmud tells his death at length (Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 103a–104a). On his deathbed he settled the succession: his son Gamaliel would be patriarch, his son Shimon the sage, and Hanina bar Hama would preside over the academy. His students fasted and prayed for him, and his maid at first prayed with them. Then, seeing how he suffered, she climbed to the roof and threw down a jar; the crash broke off the prayers for a moment, and in that moment he died. Before the end, the story says, he raised his ten fingers toward heaven and told God that he had labored in the law with all ten and had not enjoyed this world even with his little finger. He was carried from Sepphoris for burial at Beit She’arim. In the 1930s archaeologists began to uncover a vast necropolis there, a city of the dead cut into the hillside, cave after cave of carved tombs, and one catacomb holds graves inscribed with the names Rabbi Shimon, Rabbi Gamaliel and Hanina, the very names of his deathbed instructions; many take it to be the family tomb, though the identification is not proven. A line added at the end of the Mishnah’s tractate Sotah gave the rabbis’ verdict on his passing: when Rabbi died, humility and the fear of sin came to an end (Mishnah Sotah 9:15).
What He Taught
(T1) The teaching given at Sinai came down in an unbroken chain of teachers, and it had to be guarded. Think of the way a family Bible records births and marriages on its flyleaf, one hand after another, so that the latest owner can trace the book back through every generation that held it. The tractate of the Mishnah called Avot, "the Fathers," opens with exactly that kind of record, for the teaching itself: Moses to Joshua, Joshua to the elders, the elders to the prophets, the prophets to the men of the Great Assembly (the council of scribes said to have led Israel after the exile, which older translations call the Great Synagogue), and on through the pairs of teachers who led each generation two at a time, down to Hillel and his rival Shammai, and then through Judah’s own forefathers down to his father. Behind the chain stands a claim. The rabbis held that God gave Moses two Torahs at Sinai: the written law, the five books of Moses, and an oral law that explained and completed it, passed down by word of mouth. Torah means "teaching" or "instruction" more than "law." The Mishnah is that oral teaching set in order, and placing the chain at the head of Avot declares where its authority comes from. The chain also explains the work of Judah’s life. A teaching that lives only in memory is one massacre away from being lost, and Judah had been born in the year of one. The famous saying at the top of the chain, "make a fence about the Torah," means surrounding the commandments with extra rules, the way a farmer fences a well so no one falls in by accident. The Mishnah is in large part that fence.
(Q) "Moses received the Torah from Sinai, and handed it down to Joshua, and Joshua to the elders, and the elders to the prophets, and the prophets delivered it to the men of the Great Synagogue. They said three things, ‘Be deliberate in judgment; raise up many disciples; and make a fence about the Torah.’" Source: Mishnah, Avot 1:1 (Gorfinkle translation, 1913). These are the opening words of the tractate of the Fathers, the most widely read part of the Mishnah, in the collection Judah edited; they are the voice of the book he gave its shape rather than a saying with his name attached. Gorfinkle notes that "Torah" here means the oral law, the teaching that explains and completes the written books (T1).
(T2) Keep the small commandments as carefully as the great ones, because only God knows what each is worth. Everyone has a private ranking of duties. Telling the truth in court matters; returning the shopping cart to the rack does not, or not much. Judah’s best-known saying, the one the Mishnah attaches to his own name, refuses the ranking. A "light" precept, an easy or minor commandment, is to be kept as scrupulously as a "grave" one, because we do not know what reward God has attached to either. He adds a piece of bookkeeping. Before you keep a commandment, reckon what it will cost you against what it will gain; before you break one, reckon what the sin will gain you against what it will cost. Done honestly, he implies, the ledger always comes out on the side of obedience, because the cost of a commandment is paid in this world and its reward is paid in the next. Christians will hear Jesus in the first half: "whoever relaxes one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven" (Matthew 5:19). The bookkeeping in the second half is harder, and it is one of the places where the gospel parts company with him.
(Q) "Be as scrupulous about a light precept as about a grave one, for thou knowest not the grant of reward for each precept. Reckon the loss incurred by the fulfilment of a precept against the reward secured by its observance, and the gain gotten by a transgression against the loss it involves." Source: Mishnah, Avot 2:1 (Gorfinkle translation, 1913). The saying opens the second chapter of Avot under the heading "Rabbi said," the Mishnah’s way of naming Judah. Just before these lines he asks which is the right course a man should choose. His answer is the one that does him honor in his own eyes and in the eyes of others.
(T3) Every deed is seen and heard by God and written in his book. A shopkeeper who knows the security camera is running behaves differently from one who thinks it is switched off. Judah’s cure for temptation is to remember that the camera is always running. Consider three things, he says, and you will not fall into the power of sin: above you there is an eye that sees, an ear that hears, and a book in which all your deeds are written. The picture is Israel’s own. The Psalms ask, "He who planted the ear, does he not hear?", and the prophet Malachi says that when those who feared the Lord spoke together, "a book of remembrance was written before him" (Psalm 94:9; Malachi 3:16). Judah turns the old images into a habit of mind, a short list a man can carry through his day. Christians share it entire: the books opened before the throne in Revelation 20:12 are the same books.
(Q) "Consider three things, that thou mayest not come within the power of sin. Know what is above thee: a seeing eye, and a hearing ear, and all thy deeds written in a book." Source: Mishnah, Avot 2:1 (Gorfinkle translation, 1913; the translator’s dash before "a seeing eye" is given here as a colon). These lines close the same saying (T2). Having told his hearers to keep a ledger of cost and reward, Judah reminds them that the real books are kept by God, not by us.
(T4) Body and soul sin together, and God will join them again to judge them together. Two children are caught standing over a broken vase. "I never touched it," says one; "I wasn’t even in the room," says the other. Any parent knows what to do. In the Talmud the emperor Antoninus puts a version of this puzzle to Judah. At the judgment, he says, body and soul can each blame the other: the body can say it has lain still as a stone in the grave since the soul left it, and the soul can say it has flown free as a bird since it left the body. Who, then, can be punished? Judah answers with a parable. A king set two watchmen over his orchard of fine figs, one blind and one lame. The lame man saw the figs and climbed onto the blind man’s shoulders, and together they stripped the tree. When the king came, each pleaded his own disability. So the king set the lame man on the blind man’s shoulders again, and judged them as one. So God will do: he will put the soul back into the body and judge the whole person (Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 91a–b). Here Judah stands squarely with the Pharisees (the party of lay teachers of the law whose heirs the rabbis were) and against the Sadducees (the priestly party that denied any resurrection). On the point itself he stands with the apostles too. A human being is not a soul that happens to be wearing a body; the two act together, answer together, and will be raised together.
(Q) "The owner then put the lame one on the shoulders of the one who was blind, and punished them together. So also the Holy One, blessed be He ... puts the soul in the body and punishes them together." Source: Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 91a–b (Rodkinson translation, Tract Sanhedrin, 1918 edition, pp. 271–272; the ellipsis marks a repeated "He"). Judah’s answer to Antoninus, as the Talmud remembers it some centuries after his death. He goes on to read Psalm 50:4, where God "calls to the heavens above and to the earth," as the soul and the body summoned to judgment together (T4).
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) The church fathers knew his book as the Jews’ "second teaching," and some of them learned from the rabbis who studied it. The fathers wrote in Greek and Latin, and they had a word for the Mishnah: deuterōsis, "repetition" or "second teaching," a fair translation of the Hebrew. Epiphanius of Salamis, a bishop of the fourth century, reports that the Jews kept four such collections of the traditions of the elders, one under Moses’ name, one under Akiva’s, one under the name of a certain Judah, and one under the sons of the Hasmoneans, the Maccabean family who had ruled Judea before the Romans came (Panarion 33.9); scholars usually take the Judah to be Rabbi. Jerome, who learned his Hebrew from Jewish teachers, knew the same word and used it of the same traditions. The contact was not only bookish. Origen, the greatest Christian scholar of the third century, worked at Caesarea in the generation after Judah, and he tells of consulting "not a few Jews" about Hebrew words and of learning traditions from a Hebrew teacher (Letter to Africanus 6–8). The rabbis of Judah’s schools and the scholars of the church were reading the same Scriptures in the same small country, and sometimes they talked.
(†) Christian scholars have read the Mishnah for centuries as a window onto the world of the New Testament. Open the Gospels and you meet customs they never stop to explain. Mark has to pause to tell his Gentile readers that the Pharisees "do not eat unless they wash their hands properly, holding to the tradition of the elders" (Mark 7:3). Luke says the Mount of Olives is "a Sabbath day’s journey" from Jerusalem (Acts 1:12) without saying how far that is. The Mishnah has whole tractates on these things: hand washing in Yadayim, the Sabbath limits in Eruvin, the Passover meal in Pesachim, the high court and its procedure in Sanhedrin. Christian Hebraists, scholars who learned Hebrew to read the Jewish sources, saw this early. The English scholar John Lightfoot worked through the Gospels verse by verse with rabbinic texts beside them in his Horae Hebraicae et Talmudicae (1658–1674); Willem Surenhuys published the whole Mishnah in Latin at Amsterdam (1698–1703); and the standard English translation of the twentieth century was made by Herbert Danby, an Anglican canon of St George’s Cathedral in Jerusalem (1933). The careful ones always add a caution. The Mishnah was finished about a hundred and seventy years after the crucifixion, so it shows what the rabbis of Judah’s day remembered and required, and its picture of earlier practice has to be weighed rather than simply assumed. Read that way, it remains the richest Jewish witness we have to the world in which Jesus taught.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: the authority of the oral law, the temple that is gone, and the ledger of reward. Judah and the apostles worshiped the God of Abraham, read the same Scriptures, and hoped for the same resurrection (T4). The disagreements are real all the same, and they run along three lines. - The oral law. The Mishnah rests on the claim that a second, unwritten Torah came from Sinai with the first (T1). Jesus judged the tradition of the elders by the written word and found it wanting where it set that word aside: "You leave the commandment of God and hold to the tradition of men" (Mark 7:8). Christians receive the written Scriptures as God’s word and the traditions of the elders as human teaching, to be honored where they serve the word and set aside where they bury it. The Mishnah itself admits that some of its rules hang on the Scriptures "like mountains hanging by a hair," with little text and many rulings (Mishnah Hagigah 1:8). - The temple. A whole order of the Mishnah, Holy Things, preserves the laws of sacrifice in exact detail for a temple that had already fallen, as though waiting for it to rise again. The New Testament says the waiting is over: "when Christ had offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins, he sat down at the right hand of God" (Hebrews 10:12). - The ledger. Judah taught men to weigh the cost of a commandment against its reward (T2). He did so inside God’s covenant with Israel, and the same tractate also records Akiva’s saying that the world is judged with goodness, though all according to the amount of the work (Mishnah Avot 3:15). But the gospel closes the ledger altogether: "For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast" (Ephesians 2:8–9). Judah gathered his people’s memory when it was in danger of being lost, and Christians who read the Gospels with the Mishnah open are in his debt. The question that divides the two books is the one Jesus put to his own generation: who has the authority to say what the law of Moses means.