Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
Richard Bauckham of London b. 1946 AD
(●) The English scholar who argued that the first Christians worshiped Jesus as the one God of Israel, and that the Gospels rest on the testimony of people who saw him. Most of us trust a witness every day without thinking about it. A friend tells you the road is closed at the bridge, and you take the long way home; you did not see the barrier, but you know your friend, and you know she was there. Richard Bauckham has spent much of a long career asking New Testament scholars to treat the Gospels with that same ordinary, rational trust: not blindly, but as testimony from people in a position to know. He matters to a Christian apologetics site for two arguments above all. The first is about God: the earliest followers of Jesus, devout Jews who prayed daily that the Lord is one, did not slowly promote their teacher to divinity over several generations. From the very start they placed him inside the identity of the one God, the Creator and Ruler of all things. The second is about history: the Gospels were written within living memory of Jesus, and they are much closer to what the eyewitnesses actually said than a century of skeptical scholarship assumed. There is one more thing about him worth knowing, because it says something about the man behind the footnotes. Bauckham is a lay Anglican who was never ordained: a layman who preaches from parish pulpits without a clerical collar. He also writes haiku and other poems, and he has written two children’s books about a family of Scottish bears called the MacBears of Bearloch.
(●) 1946 AD: Born in London, he grew up in the north of the city as a boy who was always reading. Richard John Bauckham was born in London on 22 September 1946, the son of John Robert Bauckham and Lilian Bauckham, and he grew up in the north London suburbs in the lean years after the Second World War. He went to Downhills and Merryhills primary schools and then to Enfield Grammar School, the kind of selective state school that sent clever children of ordinary families on to the universities. He has said little in print about his childhood, but when he came to write a memoir in his late seventies, he called its second chapter simply "Always Reading." Reading, and later writing, became the thing he believed God had made him for. That conviction is worth holding on to, because sixty years later it would be tested in the hardest way possible. He is also, by his own cheerful insistence, a man whose name people get wrong. It rhymes with the comedian Eric Morecambe ("BAWK-um"), he explains on his website, and he was once introduced to a young academic who heard the name as Dawkins, a mix-up he did not notice for a while.
(●) 1966 AD: He went up to Cambridge to read history, and came out a historian of the English Reformation. In 1966 Bauckham went to Clare College, Cambridge, to read history (the British university way of saying he studied it), and it is worth noticing that he chose history, not theology. He took a first-class degree, the top grade, and stayed on for a doctorate, and then held a research fellowship at St John’s College for three years, a post that leaves a young scholar free to research and write. Several of his earliest articles are the work of a sixteenth-century specialist. He wrote on the Marian exiles (the English Protestants who fled abroad under the Catholic Queen Mary), on the Elizabethan Puritan William Fulke (the Puritans were the Protestants who wanted the Church of England reformed further than Queen Elizabeth allowed), and on the Anglican divine Richard Hooker (a divine, in the old sense, is a theologian). His first book, Tudor Apocalypse (1978), studied how the English Reformers read the book of Revelation and what they expected of the end of the world. Yet even then his mind was running further back. His very first article, in 1974, was on the great tribulation in the Shepherd of Hermas, an early Christian writing, and papers on Colossians and on Revelation followed within three years. So the Reformation historian was already reading the ancient apocalypses his Tudor subjects had read: the visionary books, Revelation among them, in which a heavenly messenger pulls back the curtain on God’s plans for history. That double training shaped everything after. A historian learns to ask of every document who wrote it, when, how close the writer stood to the events, and why anyone should believe him. Those are exactly the questions Bauckham would later put to the Gospels.
(●) 1977 AD: At Manchester he taught theology for fifteen years and became a leading interpreter of the German theologian Jürgen Moltmann. After a single year teaching theology at the University of Leeds, Bauckham moved to the University of Manchester, where for fifteen years he taught historical and contemporary theology: the story of Christian doctrine and its living conversation partners. One of those partners was the German theologian Jürgen Moltmann, whose The Crucified God had put the cross at the center of the doctrine of God. Bauckham’s books on him, Moltmann: Messianic Theology in the Making (1987) and The Theology of Jürgen Moltmann (1995), made him Moltmann’s leading English-language interpreter. The same years show how wide his range already was. For the Word Biblical Commentary, a major scholarly series that works through the Bible book by book, he wrote Jude, 2 Peter (1983), a thick technical work on two of the shortest and most neglected letters in the New Testament. He wrote The Bible in Politics (1989), on how to read Scripture for public life without dragging modern prejudices into ancient texts. And he wrote Jude and the Relatives of Jesus in the Early Church (1990), tracing what became of Jesus’ own family, the brothers and their descendants, in the first Christian generations. Alongside all this he served for some years on the Doctrine Commission of the Church of England, the panel of theologians the church asks to think through questions of belief on its behalf.
(●) 1992 AD: He became Professor of New Testament at St Andrews, and there wrote the books that changed how scholars talk about Jesus. In 1992 Bauckham crossed the border to the University of St Andrews in Scotland, the old grey university town on the North Sea, as Professor of New Testament Studies and Bishop Wardlaw Professor (one of the university’s named chairs). The next fifteen years were astonishingly productive, and most of the books people now know him for were written there. In 1993 came two books on Revelation at once: the short and much-read The Theology of the Book of Revelation, and the large The Climax of Prophecy for scholars. In 1996 he gave the Didsbury Lectures, a named series of public lectures, and they were published as God Crucified (1998): seventy-nine small pages that set out his case on Jesus and the one God (T1, T2). In 1998, too, he edited The Gospels for All Christians. Scholars had long assumed that each Gospel was written for one isolated congregation, a Matthew church here and a Mark church there; the book argued instead that the Gospels were written to circulate among all the churches. Honors followed. He was elected a Fellow of the British Academy, Britain’s national academy for the humanities, in 1998, and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Scotland’s national academy, a few years later. Then came Gospel Women (2002), a study of the named women in the Gospels, from Joanna the wife of Herod’s steward to Mary Magdalene.
(●) 2006 AD: He published Jesus and the Eyewitnesses, then retired early to Cambridge to keep writing. Jesus and the Eyewitnesses: The Gospels as Eyewitness Testimony appeared in 2006. It runs to more than five hundred pages, and it is the book most readers mean when they say his name (T3, T4). The honors came quickly. It won the Christianity Today book award for biblical studies in 2007; in 2008 the British Academy gave him its Burkitt Medal for services to biblical studies; and in 2009 the book won the Michael Ramsey Prize, a prize for theological writing named after the former Archbishop of Canterbury Michael Ramsey. In 2007 he retired early from St Andrews, at sixty, and for an unusual reason. Most people retire to do less; he wanted more time to research and write. He moved to Cambridge, where he became Senior Scholar at Ridley Hall, a college that trains Anglican clergy, and later a visiting professor at St Mellitus College in London. Retirement did not slow him down in the least. In the years that followed came The Testimony of the Beloved Disciple (2007), Jesus and the God of Israel (2008), Bible and Ecology (2010), Jesus: A Very Short Introduction (2011) and Gospel of Glory (2015).
(●) 2016 AD: He debated Bart Ehrman on memory and the Gospels, and answered his critics in an enlarged second edition. In 2016 the agnostic scholar Bart Ehrman (an agnostic is one who does not claim to know whether God exists) published Jesus Before the Gospels, drawing on psychological studies of how memory distorts over time to argue that the stories about Jesus had been changed in the retelling. That spring the two men debated for Premier Christian Radio in London, Bauckham in the studio and Ehrman on the line, and the program Unbelievable? broadcast the exchange in two parts from April 2016. They disagreed courteously and sharply. Bauckham’s point was not that human memory never errs; it was that the Gospels came from people who had every reason to remember carefully, within living memory, while the witnesses could still be asked. The same year his former students and colleagues presented him with a Festschrift, a volume of essays written in someone’s honor: In the Fullness of Time (2016). And in 2017 he published a second edition of Jesus and the Eyewitnesses, with three new chapters, more than a hundred new pages, engaging the memory research and the critics of the first edition head on.
(●) 2022 AD: He nearly lost his sight, and found God closest in the months he could not read. Imagine a man who has read every day of his life, who believes reading and writing are his calling from God, being told he may not read again. That happened to Bauckham early in 2022, when his eyesight began to fail. He later called it one of the most difficult times of his life, and also the time he felt closest to God. He told the story in The Blurred Cross: A Writer’s Difficult Journey with God (2024), part memoir, part reflection on providence (the doctrine that God cares for and guides his creatures through everything that happens to them), and part poetry. One of its chapter titles says it in six words: "God Will Be with Me Whatever." The poems had been there for years, and in 2022 he gathered them in Tumbling into Light. He writes haiku, Advent and Christmas sequences, and odes to Francis of Assisi, and the poet-priest Malcolm Guite chose his "Song of the Shepherds" for Waiting on the Word (2015), an anthology of Advent poems, where it sits beside Milton and Herbert. The scholar who taught a generation to trust the eyewitnesses spent his mid-seventies learning, in his own body, to trust God without seeing.
What He Taught
(T1) From the very beginning, the first Christians included Jesus within the identity of the one God of Israel. Picture a devout Jew in Jerusalem in the year 35, a few years after the crucifixion. Every morning and evening he recites the Shema, "Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one" (Deuteronomy 6:4). He would rather die than bow to the emperor’s statue. And yet he now sings hymns to Jesus and calls on him as Lord. How did that happen? For most of the twentieth century the standard answer was a story of slow evolution: Christians started with a merely human Messiah, and over several generations, especially as the church moved into the Greek world, they slowly promoted him to divine status, perhaps borrowing from Jewish ideas about exalted angels and patriarchs along the way. Bauckham argued that this gets both Judaism and the New Testament wrong. Start with what made Israel’s God unique. In the Jewish writings of the period, the one God is identified above all as the sole Creator of all things and the sole Ruler of all things, and he alone may be worshiped. Angels and exalted figures are always on the creature side of that line; they never create, never rule on the heavenly throne, never receive worship. Bauckham calls this God’s "unique identity": not first an abstract list of attributes, but who God is, the one who made and rules everything. Then look at what the earliest Christian texts do with Jesus. They seat him on God’s own throne, returning to Psalm 110:1 again and again, the verse in which God invites David’s Lord to sit at his right hand. They say all things were created through him (1 Corinthians 8:6, Colossians 1:16). Paul even takes the Shema itself and splits it around the Father and Jesus, so that there is "one God, the Father" and "one Lord, Jesus Christ" (1 Corinthians 8:6). And they worship him. Here is the heart of the matter. For a Jew of that time there was no halfway category between Creator and creature; everything stood on one side of the line or the other. So, Bauckham concludes, the first Christians were not edging Jesus upward a rung at a time. They were deliberately placing him on the Creator side of the line, within the identity of the one God. The church’s teaching about who Jesus is goes by the name Christology, and Bauckham’s way of summing up the result, in the preface to Jesus and the God of Israel (2008), was that the earliest Christology was already the highest Christology.
(Q) "What the New Testament texts in general do is take up the well-known Jewish monotheistic ways of distinguishing the one God from all other reality and use these precisely as ways of including Jesus in the unique identity of the one God as commonly understood in Second Temple Judaism." Source: Richard Bauckham, God Crucified: Monotheism and Christology in the New Testament (Carlisle: Paternoster, 1998), chapter 1, "Understanding Early Jewish Monotheism"; reprinted in Jesus and the God of Israel (2008). Here is the thesis of the Didsbury Lectures in a single sentence. It comes from the opening statement of his method, where he says that what earlier discussion lacked was a proper grasp of how Judaism understood the uniqueness of God. Monotheism is simply the belief that there is only one God. "Second Temple Judaism" is the Judaism of the period between the rebuilding of the temple after the exile and its destruction by Rome in AD 70, which is to say the Judaism Jesus and the apostles lived in.
(T2) The cross does not hide who God is; it reveals him most fully. There is a second step in the argument, and it is the reason the little book is called God Crucified. If Jesus belongs within the identity of the one God, then that includes the Jesus who was humiliated, stripped and nailed to a Roman cross. The crucifixion is not an embarrassing interruption between his heavenly glory before and after. It is where God shows who he is. Bauckham traced how the New Testament writers learned this from the prophet Isaiah, chapters 40 to 55. Two passages there matter most. In one, the one God declares that every knee will bow to him (Isaiah 45:23). In the other, his servant is "high and lifted up" through suffering (Isaiah 52:13). Now watch what the New Testament does with them. Paul’s hymn in Philippians 2:6–11 takes the very words of Isaiah 45 and applies them to the Jesus who "humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross" (Philippians 2:8). The Gospel of John speaks of Jesus being "lifted up" on the cross, and treats that lifting up as his glorification. And Revelation shows a slain Lamb standing at the center of God’s throne. Think of how you learn what a person is really like. You can read a list of their qualities, but you learn far more by watching what they do when it costs them everything. For Bauckham, the New Testament says that God’s own character, his self-giving love, is seen most clearly not in power displayed but in power laid down.
(Q) "The profoundest points of New Testament Christology occur when the inclusion of the exalted Christ in the divine identity entails the inclusion of the crucified Christ in the divine identity, and when the christological pattern of humiliation and exaltation is recognized as revelatory of God, indeed as the definitive revelation of who God is." Source: Richard Bauckham, God Crucified: Monotheism and Christology in the New Testament (Carlisle: Paternoster, 1998), chapter 3, "God Crucified: The Divine Identity Revealed in Jesus"; reprinted in Jesus and the God of Israel (2008). Here Bauckham turns from the exalted Christ, raised to glory and seated at God’s right hand, to the crucified one, and then traces that turn through Philippians 2, Revelation and John’s Gospel.
(T3) The Gospels were written within living memory, and they stand close to how the eyewitnesses told their stories. For most of the twentieth century, New Testament scholars worked with a picture inherited from the form critics, German scholars of the 1910s and 1920s who studied the small units ("forms") of the Gospel stories. On their picture, the stories about Jesus circulated anonymously for decades, like folk tales passed around a village, shaped and reshaped by the needs of each community, until the evangelists (the four Gospel writers) collected them. The eyewitnesses had dropped out of the picture almost entirely. Bauckham argued that the eyewitnesses never dropped out. They were still alive and still known when the Gospels were written, and they remained the recognized sources of the traditions they had first told. He pointed to Papias, a bishop in Asia Minor (modern Turkey) writing early in the second century, who said he preferred to ask people who had heard the Lord’s disciples rather than rely on books. He pointed to the way Mark’s Gospel begins and ends with Peter, as if to mark him as its main source. And he pointed to the names. The Gospels name some people and leave many others anonymous. Bauckham suggested that many of the named minor characters (Bartimaeus, Cleopas, Simon of Cyrene, "the father of Alexander and Rufus," Mark 15:21) were named because they were known to the first readers as people who had been there and could still tell the story. He then checked the names against a database of about three thousand named Palestinian Jews of the period, compiled by the Israeli scholar Tal Ilan. The Gospel names match the real pattern of the time closely: Simon and Joseph were the commonest men’s names in the land, and they are the commonest in the Gospels too, which is exactly what invention far away and long afterward would not have produced. Think of a novelist today inventing a small town in the 1920s: unless she did careful homework, her characters would end up with the names of her own time and place rather than theirs. A storyteller far from Palestine, generations later, would have had the same problem, and the Gospels do not show it. He was frank about the limits of his case. He said his proposals needed to be debated, and that some of his arguments might prove wrong. But he was sure the old model had failed.
(Q) "The Gospels were written within living memory of the events. They are what historians in the ancient world regarded as the only sort of history that should really be written, that done while eyewitnesses were still accessible." Source: Richard Bauckham, interviewed by Gary Burge, "They Really Saw Him," Christianity Today (web edition), 7 June 2007. This was his answer to the objection that communities pass on traditions unreliably. The Gospels, he said, are not folklore handed down for generations, but what modern historians would call oral history: an account gathered from the people who lived through the events, while they could still be asked.
(T4) Trusting good testimony is not a leap of faith; it is how all history is known. Here is a question worth sitting with. How do you know that the Battle of Waterloo happened, or that your grandparents met at a dance? You were not there. You know because people who were there said so, and others wrote it down, and you have good reason to believe them. Nearly everything any of us knows about the past, we know on testimony. Modern critical history, Bauckham argued, developed an allergy to this. It treated a witness’s word as worth something only when the historian could check it independently, as if trust were a failure of nerve. But that standard, applied consistently, would empty the history books. A witness can be weighed, questioned and compared with other evidence, and there can be good reasons to doubt one. In the end, though, testimony asks to be trusted, and trusting a reliable witness is what a reasonable person does. He drew on a sobering modern example: the testimony of Holocaust survivors. We would have no real idea what the camps were like without the people who lived through them, and their testimony is valuable precisely because they were insiders, deeply marked by what they saw. The Gospels, he argued, are testimony of the same insider kind, from people who could speak of the meaning of the events because they had lived them.
(Q) "Trusting testimony is not an irrational act of faith that leaves critical rationality aside; it is, on the contrary, the rationally appropriate way of responding to authentic testimony." Source: Richard Bauckham, Jesus and the Eyewitnesses: The Gospels as Eyewitness Testimony (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2006), p. 5. From the opening chapter, where he argues that the kind of history the Gospels are is testimony, and that a witness can be weighed critically without being treated as worthless until proven otherwise.
(T5) Human beings belong within a community of creation, fellow creatures who join all things in praising God. Bauckham likes to tell a medieval story. Benno of Meissen, a German bishop who died in 1106, was out walking and praying when a croaking frog in a marsh disturbed him, so he told it to be quiet. A little further on he remembered the song of the three young men in the furnace, from the longer Greek version of the book of Daniel (found in Catholic and Orthodox Bibles, and in the Apocrypha of older Protestant ones), which calls on all the creatures to bless the Lord, and he worried that the frog’s croaking might please God more than his prayers. So he went back and told the frogs to carry on. The story carries his teaching on creation. Christians have rightly read Genesis 1:28, where God gives humans dominion over the other creatures, as a charge of caring responsibility rather than a license to exploit. But if dominion is the only thing we read, Bauckham argued, it sets us purely above creation, in a vertical relationship. Scripture also sets us within it, horizontally: we are creatures among creatures. Look at how often the Bible says so. Psalm 148 calls on sun and moon, sea monsters, hail, mountains, beasts and birds to praise the Lord, and only near the end gets round to kings and peoples. Job 38 to 41 shows God delighting in wild creatures that have nothing to do with human use. He called this picture "the community of creation," and set it out in Bible and Ecology (2010) and Living with Other Creatures (2011). He also traced the trouble back to the garden. Humanity’s first sin, he argued, was wanting to be like God, and that same grasping is also what goes wrong when we treat the earth as ours to use up.
(Q) "We're not the only creatures God delights in, not the only creatures that praise God." Source: Richard Bauckham, "The Community of Creation," a sermon preached at St Edward’s church, Cambridge, 28 April 2012, published on his website. He said this just after the stories of Benno and the frogs, as he turned to Psalm 148 and the choir of all creation.
(Q) "The most important point is we can be confident that in the Gospels we find the real Jesus." Source: Richard Bauckham, interviewed by Gary Burge, "They Really Saw Him," Christianity Today (web edition), 7 June 2007. Asked what his work means for ordinary believers, he went on to say that there is no need to dig behind the Gospels for a reconstructed "historical Jesus," because in them we meet "the Jesus of testimony," Jesus as understood by those in the best position to know him.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) His case for Jesus within God’s identity, beside Larry Hurtado’s work on early devotion, overturned the story that Jesus was promoted to God by slow degrees. Bauckham did not make this case alone. At the same time, Larry Hurtado was showing from the evidence of worship (prayer, hymns, baptism and the Lord’s Supper in Jesus’ name) that devotion to Jesus as divine erupted among Jewish believers within the first years, not generations later. Bauckham supplied the theological frame for Hurtado’s evidence: worship was due only to the God who creates and rules all things, and the first Christians gave it to Jesus because they placed him within that God’s identity. Together they persuaded a large part of the field that the highest Christology came first. N. T. Wright, William Lane Craig and a whole generation of evangelical and Catholic writers have built on that frame, and it now runs through much of the Christian case for the deity of Christ. The reception was not uncritical, though, and one pointed criticism came from an admirer. The theologian Stephen Fowl called God Crucified superb and correct in its main thesis. But he pushed back on its closing claim, that the church fathers (the great teachers of the church’s early centuries) largely resisted what a crucified God implies for the doctrine of God. On the contrary, Fowl argued, the fathers from Justin to Maximus the Confessor were wrestling with exactly that.
(†) Jesus and the Eyewitnesses reopened the question of the Gospels’ sources, and the debate it started is still running. Few books in biblical studies get whole journal issues devoted to them; Jesus and the Eyewitnesses did, and the critics and defenders have kept writing since. Skeptical scholars, Bart Ehrman most prominently, pressed the psychology of memory: even honest eyewitnesses misremember. Bauckham’s answer, in the second edition, was that the research shows memory is reliable in the gist and in events that matter to the rememberer, which is exactly what the Gospels claim to preserve. Christian apologists took up his arguments widely. His name statistics were developed further by the Cambridge scholar Peter J. Williams in Can We Trust the Gospels? (2018), and his case from testimony runs underneath much of the popular defense of the Gospels in the last twenty years. Within the household of faith there is one notable point of difference. John’s Gospel never names its author; it speaks only of an unnamed disciple whom Jesus loved, usually called the Beloved Disciple, and says that he is the one who bore witness and wrote. Bauckham argued that the Beloved Disciple who wrote the Fourth Gospel was a Jerusalem disciple named John who was not one of the Twelve, "John the Elder," rather than John the son of Zebedee. Many conservative readers keep the church’s older identification with the apostle, and both sides agree on the main point: the Fourth Gospel claims to come from an eyewitness who was close to Jesus (John 21:24).
(†) He gave the church a careful biblical account of creation care, and his Revelation books shaped how a generation reads the Bible’s last book. Before Bauckham, much Christian writing on the environment either ignored the Bible or used it loosely. His Bible and Ecology, which began as the Sarum Lectures of 2006, was praised by evangelical reviewers precisely because it treats Scripture as an authority and reads it closely, and it gave churches a vocabulary, the community of creation, that holds together human responsibility and human creatureliness: we care for the other creatures, and we are creatures ourselves. His The Theology of the Book of Revelation did something similar for the last book of the Bible. Against readers who treat Revelation as a coded timetable for the end, he read it as a Christian prophecy written to real first-century churches under Rome, whose message is that the Lamb who was slain has already conquered, and that his followers conquer the same way, by faithful witness even to death (Revelation 5:5–6; 12:11). Translated into Italian, Chinese, Korean, Japanese and French, it became a standard textbook in seminaries around the world.