Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Rabbi Akiva of Bnei Brak c. 50 – c. 135 AD
(●) The shepherd who learned his letters at forty, became the greatest of the early rabbis, hailed a false messiah, and died for teaching the Law. When the temple in Jerusalem burned in AD 70, the Jewish people lost the center of their worship, and someone had to show them how to go on being Israel without it. Yohanan ben Zakkai began that work at Yavneh, a small town near the coast where he gathered the scholars who survived the war. Akiva ben Joseph, a generation younger, did more than anyone to finish it. He gathered the oral law, the body of rulings and interpretations that the Pharisees, the movement of devout teachers Jesus argued with and Paul grew up in, had handed down by word of mouth alongside the written Law of Moses, and gave it an order. The Mishnah, the first great written code of that tradition, was compiled about seventy years after his death by teachers who learned from his students, and its shape is largely his. The Jewish Encyclopedia of 1901 called him, with reason, the father of rabbinical Judaism. He is on a Christian site for three reasons. He is the clearest window we have onto the Judaism that grew up beside the early church and has talked with it ever since. He stood remarkably close to the Gospels on some things (the great commandment, the holiness of every letter of Scripture, the love of God unto death) and very far from them on others. And at the end of his life he made the most consequential mistake a Jewish teacher of his century could make: he looked at a rebel general named Simon bar Kosiba and said, "This is the King Messiah." Akiva wrote no book. Everything we know comes from the rabbinic literature compiled between about AD 200 and 600. That means the Mishnah itself; the two Talmuds, vast records of the rabbis’ discussions of the Mishnah, one finished in the land of Israel (the Jerusalem Talmud) and a larger one in Babylon (the Babylonian Talmud); and the midrash, collections of rabbinic commentary that work their way through the books of Scripture. Think of it as a library of classroom notes kept by the students of his students and the generations after them. His rulings and sayings are scattered across hundreds of passages there, and his life is told in stories that grew in the telling. The dates of his birth and death are conventions rather than records: "c. 50" rests on the tradition that he began to study at forty, and "c. 135" on the end of the revolt he blessed. Scholars place his death anywhere from about 132 to 135.
(●) c. AD 50: He grew up poor and unlettered, a shepherd who by his own account hated the scholars. Akiva was born in Judea around AD 50 to a family of no standing; the rabbis who later revered him remembered that he had no distinguished ancestors to point to. He kept sheep. He could not read. He belonged to the class the scholars called the am ha-aretz, literally "the people of the land," the ordinary farmers and laborers who did not keep the finer rules of tithing and purity and did not study the Law. The resentment ran both ways, and Akiva was honest about it. Years later, as the most honored teacher in Israel, he told his students that when he was one of the am ha-aretz he used to say, "If only someone would hand me a scholar, I would bite him like a donkey." His students asked why he had not said "like a dog." Because, he answered, a donkey's bite breaks the bone (Babylonian Talmud, Pesachim 49b). A later tradition, drawn from a misread phrase in the Talmud and stated by a medieval commentator, made him a descendant of converts, even of Sisera, the Canaanite general of Judges 4. Nothing in the early sources supports it, though it says something about how his people saw him: a man who came into the house of learning from as far outside as it was possible to come.
(●) Late 1st century AD: At about forty, by the tradition, he sat down beside the schoolchildren and learned the alphabet, and his wife Rachel bore the cost. The best-known story of his turning is a small one. Standing at a well, Akiva noticed a stone worn hollow and asked who had made the hole. The water, he was told, which falls on it day after day; and the people around him teased him for not knowing the line in Job, "the waters wear away the stones" (Job 14:19). He reasoned from the lesser to the greater: if soft water can bore through hard stone, how much more can the words of the Law, which are hard as iron, cut into a heart of flesh and blood? He was about forty. He went to a school for children with his young son, and the two of them held the writing tablet together while the teacher wrote out the alphabet (Avot de-Rabbi Natan, version A, chapter 6). The Talmud adds a love story, and it is plainly a legend that grew. Akiva was the shepherd of Kalba Savua, one of the richest men in Jerusalem, and Kalba Savua’s daughter agreed to marry him on condition that he go and study. Her father disowned her. They slept on straw; she is said to have sold her hair so he could keep studying. He stayed away twelve years. When at last he came home, he overheard a man taunting her for living like a widow, and he heard her answer: she would gladly wait twelve years more. So he turned around, without going in, and went back to his studies. When he finally returned with thousands of students, she pushed through the crowd to him, his students tried to hold her back, and Akiva stopped them: "What is mine and what is yours is hers" (Ketubot 62b–63a; Nedarim 50a). A simpler telling, in Avot de-Rabbi Natan, is probably nearer the truth: he supported his wife Rachel and their many children while he studied, and in later years, when his students murmured at the gold ornament she wore, he said she had earned it by all she had suffered for his learning. His teachers were the leading pupils of Yohanan ben Zakkai: Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, the only man Akiva ever called "my master," and Joshua ben Hananiah, with Nahum of Gimzo, who taught him to weigh every small word of Scripture. The tradition says he studied thirteen years before he taught in public.
(●) c. AD 95: He sailed to Rome with the leading sages, and on the ruined Temple Mount he laughed while they wept. By the mid-90s Akiva ranked among the leading sages of Yavneh. Following the historian Heinrich Graetz, scholars date to about AD 95 a voyage he made to Rome with Gamaliel II, the head of the academy at Yavneh, and two other senior sages, Joshua ben Hananiah and Eleazar ben Azariah; the Mishnah remembers the four of them aboard ship together (Maaser Sheni 5:9). The Talmud keeps two scenes from their travels, and they show his character better than any description (Makkot 24a–b). Approaching Rome, the four heard the roar of the great city from miles away. Three of them wept: the idolaters live in safety and ease, and the house of our God has burned. Akiva laughed. If God gives this much to those who offend him, he said, how much more will he give to those who do his will? On another journey they came up to Jerusalem and saw a fox run out of the place where the Holy of Holies had stood, the innermost room of the temple, which only the high priest entered, and only on the Day of Atonement. Again the others wept, and again Akiva laughed. The prophet Micah had said "Zion shall be plowed as a field" (Micah 3:12), and the prophet Zechariah had said "Old men and old women shall again sit in the streets of Jerusalem" (Zechariah 8:4). As long as the first prophecy was unfulfilled, Akiva explained, he had feared for the second. Now that the fox ran where only the high priest had walked, he knew the word of ruin had come true to the letter, and so the word of restoration would too. "Akiva," they told him, "you have comforted us."
(●) c. AD 95–130: From his school at Bnei Brak he gave the oral law its order and trained the teachers who would write the Mishnah. Akiva seems to have taught at Lydda, a town on the coastal plain, as long as Eliezer lived there, and then opened his own school at Bnei Brak, a town a few miles inland from Jaffa. Picture what he inherited: thousands of rulings on Sabbath, purity, marriage, damages and offerings, carried in the memories of dozens of teachers, each with his own way of arguing them, arranged in little order. Akiva sorted them. A later sage compared him to a laborer who goes out with a basket and throws in wheat, barley, beans and lentils as he finds them, and then comes home and puts each into its own bin. The Talmud traces the unattributed rulings of the Mishnah, the Tosefta (a companion collection of rulings) and the early commentaries on Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy to his students, and says that "they all followed Akiva" (Sanhedrin 86a). He was not a mild man in debate. Gamaliel II and Joshua ben Hananiah once disagreed over the calendar, which fixed the date of the Day of Atonement, and Gamaliel overruled him. To make the ruling stick, he ordered Joshua to come to him carrying his staff and his purse, things no one carries on a holy day, on the very day Joshua had calculated was the holy day. It was meant to be seen. Akiva went to comfort Joshua, and he did it with an argument from Scripture that what the court proclaims stands (Mishnah Rosh Hashanah 2:9). Yet the same man joined his friend Tarfon in a remark that still startles readers: if they had sat on the Sanhedrin, the high court, no one would ever have been put to death (Mishnah Makkot 1:10). He served as an overseer of the poor, and when his own son Simeon died, he told the crowd at the funeral that they had not come for his learning or his wealth, since many there had more of both, but to honor the Torah. (Torah is the Hebrew word for the Law of Moses, and more broadly for the whole of God’s teaching that the sages studied.) One story from these years became famous. Four sages, the Tosefta says, "entered the orchard" (in Hebrew pardes), a phrase usually taken to mean the deepest speculation about God and his heavenly throne. Ben Azzai looked and died. Ben Zoma looked and lost his mind. Elisha ben Abuyah "cut the shoots" and fell away from the faith. Akiva alone "entered in peace and went out in peace" (Tosefta Hagigah 2:3; Hagigah 14b).
(●) AD 132: When Simon bar Kosiba rose against Rome, the old rabbi hailed him as the King Messiah. In AD 132, after the emperor Hadrian had begun to rebuild Jerusalem as a pagan Roman colony, Judea rose in a second great revolt. Its leader was Simon bar Kosiba; letters in his own name, sent to his officers, were found in caves by the Dead Sea in 1960 and 1961, curt military notes about wheat, deserters and the keeping of the feast. For about three years he held much of the Judean countryside and struck coins dated "Year One of the redemption of Israel." Akiva, by now an old man, saw in him the fulfillment of the oracle of Balaam, the foreign seer in the book of Numbers whom a Moabite king hired to curse Israel and who blessed it instead: "a star shall come out of Jacob" (Numbers 24:17). He punned on the general’s name, reading Kosiba as kokhav, star, and he said, "This is the King Messiah." The rebel is remembered by that pun as Bar Kokhba, son of the star, the name Christian writers used for him. One of his colleagues, Yohanan ben Torta, answered him with a sentence that history vindicated: Akiva, grass will grow from your cheekbones, and the son of David will still not have come (Jerusalem Talmud, Taanit 4:5; Lamentations Rabbah 2:2). How far Akiva went beyond those words is unknown. Later writers imagined him touring the Jewish world to raise support for the war, but no early source says so, and the Talmud gives a religious rather than a political reason for his death. The revolt ended in AD 135 with the fall of the fortress of Betar. The Roman historian Cassius Dio reports that 580,000 Jews died in the fighting and that nearly the whole of Judea was laid waste; Jews were barred from Jerusalem, which became Aelia Capitolina. A Talmudic tradition says that twenty-four thousand of Akiva’s students died in a single season "because they did not treat one another with respect," and that he started over in old age with five students in the south, among them Meir, Judah ben Ilai and Simeon bar Yohai, through whom the Torah of his school survived (Yevamot 62b). The number is haggadic, a teaching story’s round figure; the five names are real, and the Mishnah is full of them.
(●) c. AD 135: Arrested for teaching Torah in defiance of Rome, he was tortured to death and died saying "The Lord is one." During the revolt or just after it, Rome forbade the teaching and practice of the Law. Akiva kept teaching in public. A man named Pappus ben Judah found him gathering crowds to study and asked whether he was not afraid of the government. Akiva answered with a parable. A fox walking by a river saw fish darting from place to place and asked what they were running from. From the nets men cast for us, they said. Then come up onto the dry land, said the fox, and live with me, as my ancestors lived with yours. You are the one they call the cleverest of animals? the fish answered. You are a fool. If we are afraid in the place that keeps us alive, how much more in the place where we die? So it is with us and the Torah, Akiva said, and he applied to it the words of Moses, "your life and length of days" (Deuteronomy 30:20). If we are in danger while we study it, how much worse if we leave it (Berakhot 61b). He was arrested and held for a long time; one tradition has his students consulting him through the prison window. He was executed, the Jerusalem Talmud says, under the governor Tinnius Rufus, and the place is traditionally Caesarea. The Romans tore his flesh with iron combs. It was the hour for reciting the Shema, Israel’s daily confession of faith, "Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one" (Deuteronomy 6:4), and Akiva recited it. His students cried out, "Our master, even to this point?" He told them he had waited all his life for this (T5), and he drew out the last word, echad, "one," until his breath left him (Berakhot 61b; Jerusalem Talmud, Berakhot 9:5). The Mishnah’s lament for the great sages, which marks what passed from the world with each of them, says that when Akiva died, the honor of the Torah ceased (Sotah 9:15). Synagogues still remember him every Day of Atonement, in a liturgical poem about ten rabbis martyred by Rome.
What He Taught
(T1) Every human being is beloved by God, because every one bears his image. Think of a coin with a king’s face stamped on it. Deface the coin and you have insulted the king. Akiva reasoned about people the same way. Genesis says that God made man in his own image (Genesis 9:6), and Akiva drew the conclusion that whoever sheds human blood has diminished the likeness of God himself (Genesis Rabbah 34:14). A human life is not cheap because the face on it is not cheap. He went further. God did not only make us in his image; he told us so, and that telling is a second gift of love. A creature that bears its maker’s likeness and knows it can never think of itself, or of its neighbor, as nothing. From there it is a short step to the commandment he called the great principle of the Torah: "you shall love your neighbor as yourself" (Leviticus 19:18), a saying preserved in the commentary on Leviticus called the Sifra. His younger colleague Ben Azzai preferred a different verse, the line from Genesis about the book of the generations of Adam, because it reminds us that every human being descends from the one man God made (Genesis Rabbah 24:7). The two of them were arguing about which verse grounds love for all people; neither doubted that it was owed. Christians will hear the Gospels in this. Asked which commandment is greatest, Jesus joined the Shema’s love of God to the love of neighbor from Leviticus 19:18 (Mark 12:28–31), and Paul says the whole law is fulfilled in that one word (Galatians 5:14). James makes Akiva’s very argument: it is perverse to bless God and curse people who are made in the likeness of God (James 3:9).
(Q) "Beloved is man, that he was created in His image, and, moreover, that he was notified that he was so created." Source: Mishnah, Avot 3:14 (Rodkinson translation, Tract Aboth, 1900). The Mishnah is divided into sixty-three tractates, books on a single subject such as the Sabbath or marriage. Avot, "the Fathers," is the odd one out: instead of rulings it collects the sayings of the sages, teacher by teacher, like a family album of wisdom. The saying goes on to quote Genesis 9:6 as its proof, and the two sayings after it extend the same love to Israel: beloved because they are called children of God, and beloved because they were given the Torah, the instrument with which the world was made.
(T2) God foresees everything, yet human beings choose freely, and the world is judged with goodness. Akiva liked to describe the world as a shop. The shop is open and the shopkeeper gives credit. The ledger lies open and the hand writes in it. Anyone who wants to borrow may come and borrow, but the collectors make their rounds every day and take payment, whether the debtor agrees or not, and they have a sound case to rely on, and the judgment is a true judgment. And everything is made ready for the banquet (Mishnah Avot 3:16). The medieval commentators, Obadiah of Bartenura among them, read the picture something like this. The shop is the world, and the credit is God’s patience: he does not punish at once, and anyone may take what he likes on account. The open ledger is God’s record of what each person does, and nothing in it is forgotten. The collectors are the troubles that come on people day by day, and the banquet is the world to come, made ready once the debts are settled. Nobody leaves the shop without the account being settled, and nobody is cheated when it is. In the saying just before that picture sits one of the most compact statements of an old puzzle ever made. God knows everything in advance; nothing surprises him. Yet the person who walks into the shop really chooses to borrow, and really owes what he borrowed. Akiva does not explain how both can be true. He simply holds both, which is what Scripture does, and what the church would do after him: Justin Martyr and Origen both insisted that God’s foreknowing a choice does not cause it. The second half of the saying holds two more things together. The world is judged "by grace," or "with goodness" (the Hebrew is be-tov); God’s judgment is not cold. And yet everything goes according to the abundance of a person’s deeds: good deeds and evil deeds are weighed, and the heavier side decides. That last clause is where the apostle Paul, himself trained as a Pharisee a generation before Akiva, parts company with the rabbis (see the final row).
(Q) "Everything is foreseen and free-will is given. And the world is judged by grace; and every one is judged according to the majority of his deeds." Source: Mishnah, Avot 3:15 (Rodkinson translation, Tract Aboth, 1900). Some texts read "and not according to the majority of deeds," but the positive reading is the one most editions and commentators follow. Charles Taylor’s 1897 edition, which numbers the saying III.24, renders the same line, "Everything is foreseen; and freewill is given. And the world is judged by grace; and everything is according to work."
(T3) Every word and letter of Scripture carries meaning, because nothing in it is there by accident. When a careful person reads a letter from someone they love, they notice everything: the word underlined, the "always" where "usually" would have done. Akiva read the Law that way, as words from God in which nothing is filler. Hebrew has small words that look like padding, among them et, a particle that marks the object of a verb and has no meaning of its own, and gam, "also." Akiva spent twenty-two years with his teacher Nahum of Gimzo, who taught that every such particle adds something (Hagigah 12a), and Akiva carried the method further than anyone. An earlier sage, Simeon of Emmaus, who had expounded every et in the Law, gave up when he reached "You shall fear the Lord your God" (Deuteronomy 10:20), since nothing could be added to God; Akiva answered that the particle there includes the teachers of the Law (Pesachim 22b). The Talmud tells a playful story about how far he took this. Moses goes up to heaven and finds God fastening little crowns to the letters of the Torah. Who is holding you back, Moses asks, that you must add these? There will be a man, God answers, named Akiva ben Joseph, who will draw heaps of laws from every one of these little marks. Moses asks to see him, and sits at the back of Akiva’s classroom, and cannot follow the lesson, until a student asks where a ruling comes from and Akiva answers, it is a law given to Moses at Sinai. Then Moses is comforted (Menachot 29b). The story laughs at the method and honors it in the same breath. The same reverence made him a guardian of the canon, the list of books Israel holds as Scripture. He fought for the Song of Songs and for Esther when others questioned them, and he said that whoever reads the "outside books," the writings outside the canon, has no share in the world to come (Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1). Christians will remember Jesus’ words that "not an iota, not a dot, will pass from the Law until all is accomplished" (Matthew 5:18). They will also notice the danger in Akiva’s method, which his own colleague Ishmael pointed out: the Torah speaks in human language, and a reader who finds a law in every particle can make the text say what he already believes.
(Q) "The whole world is not worth so much as the day when the Song was given to Israel. Thus while all the Hagiographa are holy, the Song is most holy." Source: Mishnah, Yadayim 3:5, as translated in the Jewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906), article "Bible Canon." The Hagiographa are the "Writings," the third part of the Hebrew Bible after the Law and the Prophets. The sages were debating whether the Song of Songs and Ecclesiastes "make the hands unclean," their technical way of saying that a book is holy Scripture. Akiva read the Song as the love between God and Israel, and called it the holy of holies among the Writings; about a century later Origen and, centuries after him, Bernard of Clairvaux read it as the love between Christ and his church.
(T4) With the temple gone, God himself makes his people clean. For centuries the Day of Atonement had meant the high priest, the sprinkled blood, and the goat sent away into the wilderness. By Akiva’s day all of it was a memory. The Mishnah’s tractate on the Day of Atonement ends with two sages facing that loss. Eleazar ben Azariah teaches that the day atones for sins against God, but not for sins against a neighbor until the sinner has made peace with the neighbor he wronged. Then Akiva speaks, and his words turn on a pun. The Hebrew word mikveh means "hope," and it also means a pool of water, the ritual bath in which an unclean person was made clean. Jeremiah calls the Lord "the hope of Israel" (Jeremiah 17:13), mikveh Israel. Akiva reads it the other way: the Lord is Israel’s cleansing pool. As the bath cleanses the unclean, so the Holy One cleanses Israel. The altar is gone, but the God who gave the altar is not. Christians can say amen to most of this, and gladly. It is the Father who cleanses. The question that remains between church and synagogue is how, and at what cost (see the final row).
(Q) "Happy are ye, Israel; before whom do ye purify yourselves? Who purifies you? your Father which is in Heaven." Source: Mishnah, Yoma 8:9 (Charles Taylor’s translation, in Sayings of the Jewish Fathers, 1897, Excursus V, "The Lord’s Prayer," p. 124). Taylor quotes the line to illustrate the address "Our Father in heaven," as part of showing that the expressions of the Lord’s Prayer have close parallels in the rabbinic writings and rest, as he puts it, "ultimately on the Old Testament itself."
(T5) To love God with all your soul is to love him even when he takes your life. The Shema commands, "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your might" (Deuteronomy 6:5). Every observant Jew says those words twice a day. Akiva asked what "with all your soul" could possibly mean, and answered: even if he takes your soul (Berakhot 61b). To love God with your life, on his reading, is to love him on the day your life is demanded. The same trust shows in a smaller story. Once, the Talmud says, Akiva came to a town and could find no lodging, so he slept in the field outside. He had a lamp, a rooster to wake him, and a donkey. The wind blew out the lamp, a cat ate the rooster, and a lion ate the donkey. Each time he said, "Whatever the Merciful One does is for good." That night soldiers raided the town and carried its people off; a burning lamp, a crowing rooster or a braying donkey would have led them to him (Berakhot 60b). It is a folk tale, and it is told to teach the saying he lived by. In his death he did what he taught (the final life row). Christians recognize this faith. It is the faith of Job, "Though he slay me, I will hope in him" (Job 13:15), and of the martyrs the church remembers from the same Roman century, Ignatius and Polycarp among them.
(Q) "All my days I have been troubled about this verse: Thou shalt love the Lord ... with all thy soul, even if He should take away thy spirit. When, said I, will it be in my power to fulfil this? Now that I have the opportunity shall I not fulfil it?" Source: Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 61b (Charles Taylor’s translation, in Sayings of the Jewish Fathers, 1897, note 31 on Aboth III.19). His answer to his students as the Romans tore his flesh with iron combs, moments before he died drawing out the word "one."
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) The church fathers knew him by name as the master of the rabbis’ oral law and of Aquila, whose Greek Bible they studied. Christian scholars of the fourth century knew that the Judaism of their day rested on more than the Old Testament. Epiphanius of Salamis, a bishop on Cyprus who wrote a vast catalog of heresies, lists the deuteroseis, the "repetitions" or second laws, which the Jews traced back to Moses, to a teacher he calls Rabbi Akiba, to Judah, and to the Hasmoneans, the family of priest-kings who ruled Judea before Herod (Panarion 33.9). Jerome, who learned his Hebrew from Jewish teachers in Bethlehem, names the same master, in a garbled form, among those whose traditions the rabbis followed (Letter 121, to Algasia). Jerome also passes on the report that Akiva was the teacher of Aquila, a convert who in the early second century made a new and almost painfully literal Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible (commentary on Isaiah 8). The Greek-speaking synagogues adopted it partly because the church had made the older Greek version, the Septuagint, its own. Christian scholars did not throw Aquila away, however. Origen set his version in a column of the Hexapla, the great six-column Bible he built to compare the Hebrew with every Greek translation, and Jerome consulted it constantly. In that indirect way, Akiva’s word-by-word reverence for the Hebrew text became one of the tools Christian scholars used to read their Old Testament more accurately.
(†) The messiah he hailed punished Christians who would not deny Jesus, and Jewish believers in Jesus could not follow him. The church remembered the Bar Kokhba revolt from the other side. Justin Martyr, a Christian philosopher writing in Rome some twenty years later, told the emperor that in the Jewish war which had just raged, the rebel leader "gave orders that Christians alone should be led to cruel punishments, unless they would deny Jesus Christ and utter blasphemy" (First Apology 31, Roberts and Donaldson translation). Eusebius, the church’s first historian, quotes Justin and adds that the leader traded on his name, pretending to be a star come down from heaven to bring light to the Jews in their misfortunes (Church History 4.6 and 4.8). Jewish historians note that only Christian writers report the persecution, and that its likely cause was simple: the Christians refused to fight. For Jews who believed Jesus was the Messiah, there was no way to join an army whose leader was being called Messiah by Israel’s greatest teacher. Their refusal, and the war that followed, drew a line between synagogue and church that had been blurry until then. Akiva did not cause the parting of the ways, but the most famous sentence he ever spoke stands at one of its turning points.
(†) Christian readers have found him standing remarkably close to the Gospels. Modern Christian students of the New Testament read the rabbinic literature to understand the world Jesus and Paul argued in, and Akiva turns up again and again beside the Gospels. - The great commandment. Akiva’s great principle, the love of neighbor (T1), is the second half of Jesus’ answer to the scribe (Mark 12:28–34) and the whole of Paul’s summary of the law (Romans 13:9; Galatians 5:14). - The lowest seat. A saying Akiva taught in the name of his colleague Ben Azzai advises a guest to sit a few places below his rank, since it is better to be told "come up" than "go down" (Leviticus Rabbah 1:5). Jesus tells nearly the same parable in Luke 14:7–11, a reminder that he taught in the idiom of his people. - The thrones of Daniel. Daniel saw that "thrones were placed" before the Ancient of Days (Daniel 7:9). Akiva once explained the plural this way: one throne for God, and one for David, that is, for the Messiah. His colleague Yose the Galilean rebuked him for profaning the Divine Presence (Hagigah 14a; Sanhedrin 38b). Christian readers have noticed that Jesus applied the same vision to himself before the high priest, "you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of Power" (Mark 14:62), and was condemned for blasphemy. - Faith unto death. Akiva’s martyrdom (T5) stands beside the deaths of the Christian martyrs of the same century, and Christian writers have honored it as the death of a man who loved the God of Israel more than his life. None of this makes Akiva a secret Christian, and he would have refused the label with some heat. It shows that the gospel was preached into a Judaism with deep reverence for God’s word and God’s image in man, and that the church inherited far more of that reverence than it sometimes remembers.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: who the Messiah is, how a person is judged, and what makes the unclean clean. Akiva’s own words and acts mark three points where the church cannot follow him. - The Messiah. Akiva took the star of Balaam’s oracle, "a star shall come out of Jacob" (Numbers 24:17), and set it on the head of a general whose war ended in the ruin of Judea, and whom his own people afterward called Bar Koziba, "son of the lie." His colleague’s retort came true: the son of David did not come in that war. The New Testament had already given the star another name. The magi came because "we saw his star" (Matthew 2:2), and the risen Jesus calls himself "the root and the descendant of David, the bright morning star" (Revelation 22:16). The Messiah Akiva looked for was a king who would break Rome; the Messiah the apostles proclaimed had let Rome break him, and rose. - The scales. Akiva taught that the world is judged with goodness, yet that every person is judged by the majority of his deeds (T2). The gospel does not deny the judgment, or the weight of what we do. But it denies that anyone is saved by the balance of the scales: "For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast" (Ephesians 2:8–9). - The cleansing. Akiva was right that the Father himself makes his people clean (T4). The New Testament says the Father does it at a price he paid himself: "the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin" (1 John 1:7). The temple Akiva mourned had pointed to a sacrifice; the church says that sacrifice had been offered, outside the city wall, about forty years before the temple fell (Hebrews 9:11–14; 13:12). Akiva loved the God of Israel, revered his word, and died with his name on his lips. That is exactly why the parting matters. He looked for the Messiah with all his heart, and when he thought he had found him, he was wrong.