Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

Wolfhart Pannenberg of Stettin 1928 – 2014 AD

(●) The German Lutheran who told modern theology that faith rests on what really happened, and argued for the resurrection of Jesus in front of the historians. + Imagine a courtroom where one side announces that its key witness cannot be cross-examined, because his testimony is too sacred for questions. The jury would draw its own conclusions. For much of the twentieth century, a good deal of German theology was conducted rather like that. Karl Barth taught that God’s Word stands above all human judgment; Rudolf Bultmann taught that what matters about Easter is the decision of faith it calls for today, not what happened to a body in a Jerusalem tomb. Either way, the historian was politely shown the door. Wolfhart Pannenberg opened the door again. Revelation, he argued, happens in public, in events that anyone can examine, and the claim at the center of the faith, that God raised Jesus from the dead, is a claim about something that happened in our world at a particular time and place. Like every such claim it has to stand up to investigation, and he spent his career arguing that it does. That is why he belongs on a Christian apologetics site. He was not a popular apologist; he was one of the most demanding academic theologians of his century, the author of a three-volume Systematic Theology and nearly seven hundred publications. But one of his doctoral students was William Lane Craig, and the habit of arguing for Easter on the evidence, which runs through so much evangelical apologetics today, owes him a debt that his own guild was slow to forgive.

(●) 1928 AD: Born in Stettin to parents who had left the church, he grew up on Nietzsche rather than the Bible. + Pannenberg was born on 2 October 1928 in Stettin, a port on the Oder in what was then the German province of Pomerania; today it is Szczecin, in Poland. His father was a customs official, and the family moved wherever the job sent him: to Berlin in 1942, then back to Pomerania in March 1944 to escape the bombing. He had been baptized as an infant, but his parents had left the church, and religion played no part in his upbringing. What filled the gap was books. He was a precocious reader, and by his own account he read Nietzsche and Kant before he ever read the Bible. "I was nourished on Nietzsche’s philosophy," he later said. Nietzsche, the nineteenth-century philosopher who announced that "God is dead," taught him to think of Christianity as a religion of resentment and weakness. It would take some actual Christians to unsettle that picture.

(●) 1945 AD: At sixteen, walking home at sunset, he was flooded by a light he later understood as the light of Christ. + On 6 January 1945, with Germany collapsing and the Red Army closing in from the east, a sixteen-year-old boy was on a lonely two-hour walk home from his piano lesson as the sun went down. What happened next he described for the rest of his life with the same care. Light, he said, flooded all around him and through him, and he did not know where he was or how long it lasted. He said he had become, "so to speak, metaphysically awakened," by which he meant woken up to questions about what is ultimately real, the questions that lie behind everything else, and that he did not yet know what it was for. Only later did he learn that 6 January is Epiphany, the feast on which the church celebrates the manifestation of Christ to the nations, and he came to believe that what he had seen was the light of Christ. The war did not wait for him to work it out. He belonged to the generation of schoolboys pressed into service in the last months of the Third Reich, the same generation as Jürgen Moltmann and Joseph Ratzinger. He was drafted, and at sixteen he was briefly a prisoner of war of the British. One account says that a case of scabies kept him from the front line.

(●) 1947 AD: A literature teacher who did not fit Nietzsche’s picture of Christians sent him to study theology. + Back at school after the war, Pannenberg met a literature teacher who had belonged to the Confessing Church, the Protestant movement that refused to let the Nazi state take over the German churches. Here was a Christian who did not match anything Nietzsche had said about Christians. Pannenberg began to wonder whether he had been told the truth about Christianity, and he decided to find out the hard way: by studying it. In 1947, at nineteen, he began theology and philosophy in Berlin, then moved on to Göttingen, to Basel in 1950 to hear Karl Barth, and finally to Heidelberg. He later called what happened during those years an intellectual conversion: the conclusion, reached by thinking, that the Christian claims were true. The time in Basel was brief and not happy; he admired Barth’s insistence that God comes first in theology, but found that Barth did not like criticism from his students. In Heidelberg he found his teachers: the Old Testament scholar Gerhard von Rad, who read Israel’s faith as faith in a God who acts in history; the philosopher Karl Löwith; and the Lutheran theologian Edmund Schlink, whose assistant he became and who gave him a lifelong passion for the unity of the churches. Under Schlink he wrote a doctorate on the doctrine of predestination in Duns Scotus, the medieval Franciscan philosopher. Predestination is the teaching that God decides beforehand who will come to salvation, and it raises a question that every thoughtful believer has felt at some point: if God chooses, what is left for us to do? The thesis was submitted in 1953 and published in 1954. In 1954 he married Hilke Schütte, who traveled with him for the rest of his life, and in 1955 he qualified to teach at university level with a long study of analogy, the old question of how human words can speak truly of God.

(●) 1961 AD: With three young colleagues he published Revelation as History, and challenged the two giants of German theology at once. + In Heidelberg in the 1950s a group of young scholars from different fields began meeting to read and argue together. People came to call it the Pannenberg circle. In 1961 four of them, Pannenberg with the Old Testament scholar Rolf Rendtorff, the New Testament scholar Ulrich Wilckens, and the ethicist Trutz Rendtorff, published a slim volume of essays, Offenbarung als Geschichte, translated in 1968 as Revelation as History. All four were in their early or middle thirties. Its thesis was simple to state and explosive in its setting. God does not reveal himself by dropping sacred words from heaven that faith must accept unexamined; he reveals himself indirectly, through what he does in history, and those deeds are open to anyone who looks (T1). That put the circle at odds with both of the great schools of the day. For Barth, revelation is God’s Word confronting us from above. For Bultmann, the gospel is a summons spoken to each person here and now, calling for the decision of faith and a new understanding of one’s own existence, not a report about the past. Either way, nothing the historian could examine was allowed to matter for faith, and the young men from Heidelberg said a great deal of it did. The reviews were largely hostile. By then he was teaching systematic theology, the branch of theology that sets out the whole of Christian belief as one connected account (God, creation, Christ, the church, the end), at the church seminary in Wuppertal (1958 to 1961), and in 1961 he moved to a chair at the University of Mainz. There he wrote the book that made his name abroad, Grundzüge der Christologie (1964), translated in 1968 as Jesus: God and Man, which built its whole account of who Jesus is on the resurrection as an event of history (T2, T3). American universities began inviting him: Chicago in 1963, Harvard in 1966, Claremont in 1967.

(●) 1967 AD: At Munich he taught for more than a quarter of a century and worked to heal the old divisions between Protestants and Catholics. + In 1967 (some records give 1968) Pannenberg accepted the chair of systematic theology in the newly founded Protestant faculty at the University of Munich, a Catholic city with a great Catholic faculty next door. With the Catholic theologian Heinrich Fries he founded an ecumenical institute ("ecumenical" is the word for work toward unity among the separated churches, Protestant, Catholic, and Orthodox), and despite calls to more famous universities at home and abroad he stayed in Munich until he retired in 1994. The Munich years produced the big books. Theology and the Philosophy of Science (1973) argued that theology is a real discipline, the "science of God," whose claims can be tested like hypotheses in any other field. Anthropology in Theological Perspective (1983) read what the biologists, psychologists, and sociologists say about human beings and argued that their findings point beyond themselves toward God (T4). All the while he was giving himself to the unity of the churches, the passion Schlink had planted in him at Heidelberg. From 1975 to 1990 he represented the Evangelical Church in Germany on the Faith and Order Commission of the World Council of Churches, where he helped draft the 1982 Lima document, Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry. For many years he led the Protestant side of an ecumenical working group of Protestant and Catholic theologians whose Catholic leader was Karl Lehmann, later bishop of Mainz. Think of two families who have not spoken since a quarrel four hundred years ago, and who finally sit down to ask whether the hard words their ancestors exchanged were ever really about the people at the table now. Their joint study, published in 1986, asked exactly that: whether the condemnations Protestants and Catholics had hurled at each other in the sixteenth century still applied to what the churches actually teach now, and in many cases answered no. Few Protestant theologians of his century were read so closely by Catholics.

(●) 1988 AD: He gathered everything into a three-volume Systematic Theology, finished in 1993. + For thirty years Pannenberg had published essays, studies, and polemics. In 1988 he began publishing the work they had all been leading toward, a complete account of Christian doctrine in three thick volumes: the first on the truth of theology and the doctrine of God (1988), the second on creation, humanity, and Christ (1991), the third on the Spirit, the church, and the end (1993). Geoffrey Bromiley, the scholar who had translated Barth’s Church Dogmatics, translated it into English between 1991 and 1998. The work follows the old order of the creeds, from the Trinity through creation and Christ to the church and the last things, but it treats every doctrine as a claim about reality that has to make sense of everything else we know. The Catholic theologian Michael Root, writing in First Things in 2012, summed up its ambition with Pannenberg’s own words: it is necessary to explore every field of knowledge in order to speak of God reasonably. Its final page ends not with an argument but with an image, the love of God as a heartbeat that holds the whole world (T5).

(●) 2014 AD: He spent his last years warning his own church against drifting from Scripture, and died at home near Munich at eighty-five. + Retirement did not make him quieter. In 1994 he gave the Erasmus Lecture in New York, "Christianity and the West," warning that a culture cut off from its Christian roots would not long keep the freedoms that grew from them. He was hard on his own Protestant church too, which he thought had become thoughtless and too eager to follow the spirit of the age. When many of the regional Protestant churches of Germany moved toward blessing same-sex partnerships in the 1990s, he answered from Scripture: what God does not approve, he said, the church may not bless. In 1997, after the German president had given the Federal Cross of Merit to a lesbian feminist active in the church, Pannenberg sent back his own, awarded ten years earlier, in protest. He died on 4 September 2014 at his home in Gräfelfing, outside Munich, in his eighty-sixth year. The university preacher Christoph Levin and two of his students, Jan Rohls and Gunther Wenz (Wenz his successor in the Munich chair), led the funeral, and he was buried in Hamburg’s Ohlsdorf cemetery. Hilke Pannenberg outlived him by ten years.

What He Taught

(T1) God makes himself known through what he does in history, and those deeds are open to anyone with eyes to see. + Think about how you come to know what a friend is really like. You do not usually learn it from a single announcement ("I am a loyal person"). You learn it by watching what they do over years: who they stand by when it costs them, how they behave when things go wrong. Their character shows itself indirectly, through a history, and you understand it best once you can see the whole story. Pannenberg thought God makes himself known the same way. In the theses of Revelation as History he argued that God’s self-revelation is indirect: not a secret message whispered to a few, but the meaning of public events, the exodus, the return from exile, and above all the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus. Because those events happened in the open, the revelation in them is open too. It is not reserved for people who already believe; anyone willing to look can examine it, and faith is trust in what has been shown, not a substitute for seeing. This put him close to the oldest Christian instinct and far from much modern theology. Peter told the crowd at Pentecost that the deeds of Jesus were done "in your midst, as you yourselves know" (Acts 2:22), and Paul told King Agrippa that "this has not been done in a corner" (Acts 26:26). There was a second half to the idea, and it is what made it his own. He took it, with corrections, from the nineteenth-century German philosopher Hegel, who thought of all history as one long unfolding story: the meaning of history as a whole, Pannenberg said, can only be seen from its end, the way you cannot judge a friend’s whole life while it is still half lived. If that is so, how can anyone know what God has revealed before the story is over? His answer was Easter. In the resurrection of Jesus, he argued, that end has appeared ahead of time, in the middle of history (T5).

(Q) "In distinction from special manifestations of the deity, the historical revelation is open to anyone who has eyes to see. It has a universal character." + Source: Wolfhart Pannenberg, "Dogmatic Theses on the Doctrine of Revelation," thesis 3, in Pannenberg, ed., Revelation as History, translated by David Granskou (Macmillan, 1968), page 135. The third of seven theses with which Pannenberg set out the circle’s program. A "special manifestation" is a private vision or oracle that only its recipient can vouch for; historical revelation, by contrast, belongs to everyone.

(T2) The resurrection of Jesus really happened, and a claim about the past has to face the historian. + Suppose someone tells you, "My grandfather fought at Normandy." That is a claim about the past, and it can be checked: there are service records, letters, photographs, people who remember. Nobody would accept the reply, "You cannot check it; you just have to believe it." Pannenberg thought the same logic applies to Easter. To say that Jesus rose on the third day is to say something happened, at a particular time, outside a particular city. Saying that exposes the claim to testing, and Christians should welcome the test rather than dodge it. So he made the case. He argued that the earliest list of appearances, which Paul hands on in 1 Corinthians 15:3–8, goes back to within a few years of the events. And he argued that the empty tomb is hard to deny for a simple reason: the first Christians preached the resurrection in Jerusalem, the city where Jesus was executed and buried. For a Jew of the first century, "resurrection" did not mean a soul surviving death or a ghost appearing to friends; it meant the body that had died being raised to life. If, as Jews of the time understood resurrection, the claim implied an empty tomb, "then it is hardly conceivable that the Christian message of the resurrection could have spread abroad in Jerusalem unless the presupposition of the empty tomb were tenable," as he put it in the Systematic Theology (volume 2, page 357). He leaned harder on the appearances than on the tomb, since a tomb found empty can be explained in more than one way. He was careful about what "historical" means. It does not mean the resurrection is like other events (it is the beginning of a new creation, not a corpse revived to die again), and it does not mean the matter is beyond all dispute; many historical facts are disputed. It means the event really took place, and that the claim will stand up to honest investigation.

(Q) "Any assertion that an event took place in the past implies a historical claim and exposes itself to testing. This necessarily applies, then, to the Christian assertion that Jesus rose again the third day after his death." + Source: Wolfhart Pannenberg, Systematic Theology, volume 2, translated by Geoffrey W. Bromiley (Eerdmans and T&T Clark, 1994), chapter 10, page 360. The opening of his summary of what it means to call the resurrection historical. The points that follow are the qualifications given in (T2): unique is not the same as unreal, and disputed is not the same as false.

(T3) We learn who Jesus is by starting from his history, and Easter is God’s answer to the claim Jesus made. + There are two ways to come to know a stranger who claims to be the heir to a throne. You can start from the royal family tree and work down to him, or you can start with the man in front of you, what he says and does and what happens to him, and work up to the question of who he is. Theologians call the first approach Christology "from above": it begins with the eternal Son of God and asks how he became a man. The second is Christology "from below": it begins with the historical Jesus of Nazareth and asks what his history shows about him. Jesus: God and Man took the road from below, and it is the book’s signature. Jesus came preaching that the kingdom of God was near, and he acted with an authority that only God could claim: forgiving sins, setting his own word beside the law. A claim like that is either blasphemy or the truth, and it waited for a verdict. The crucifixion looked like the verdict, and then the resurrection reversed it. Paul says Jesus "was declared to be the Son of God in power according to the Spirit of holiness by his resurrection from the dead" (Romans 1:4). For Pannenberg, Easter is God’s confirmation of everything Jesus had claimed, and from there the church’s confession of his divinity follows. Late in life he said his finished system was no longer simply a Christology from below, because it set Jesus within the doctrine of the Trinity from the start. But he kept the method as its foundation: the church’s confession has to be read off the history, not laid over it.

(Q) "Not infrequently the response of faith to the proclamation of Jesus is seen as the origin and basis of the confession of faith in the Easter event, though in fact the biblical testimony presents the Easter event as the basis of the faith of the disciples." + Source: Wolfhart Pannenberg, Systematic Theology, volume 2, translated by Geoffrey W. Bromiley (Eerdmans and T&T Clark, 1994), chapter 9, page 286. He is criticizing the versions of Christology from below that make the disciples’ faith produce Easter, rather than Easter produce their faith. The order matters: on his reading, as in the New Testament, the event comes first.

(T4) Human beings are made open beyond everything finite, and that restlessness is an unspoken openness to God. + A bee lives inside a world that fits it exactly: flowers, the hive, the sun to steer by. Nothing outside that world interests it. A child is different. Give a child the answer to one question and it asks another; take it to the edge of the town and it wants to know what lies past the hills. Twentieth-century German philosophers of human nature, among them Max Scheler, Helmuth Plessner, and Arnold Gehlen, called this human trait "openness to the world": unlike other animals, we are not fitted to a fixed environment, and we keep reaching past whatever we have. Pannenberg took their findings seriously and pushed them one step further. Our openness, he argued, does not stop at the world. We can think of "the world" as a whole only because we are already aware, dimly, of something beyond everything finite, everything that has edges and limits, the way you can only see a fence as a fence if you sense that there is ground on the other side. That unspoken awareness is an openness to God, present in every human being before anyone names it, which is why every culture has had religion, and why unbelief is possible at all: you can only close a door that is there. He was reaching for something Christians had said long before. Augustine opens the Confessions by telling God that "our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee" (Confessions I.1, Pusey translation). Pannenberg spent a whole book, Anthropology in Theological Perspective, showing how far the modern sciences of human nature bear that out.

(Q) "It is of the nature of our human form of life to be 'eccentric' relative to other things and beings, in awareness of a horizon that transcends their finitude, and hence to be able to move on constantly to new experiences. An expression for this is 'openness to the world.'" + Source: Wolfhart Pannenberg, Systematic Theology, volume 2, translated by Geoffrey W. Bromiley (Eerdmans and T&T Clark, 1994), chapter 8, page 229. "Eccentric" here means off-center in the literal sense: a human being’s center of gravity lies outside the self. The passage goes on to call this an "innate and implicit openness to God."

(T5) History is understood from its end, and only the end will show that God’s love was at work all along. + Anyone who has read a good mystery knows the feeling. Halfway through, a scene seems pointless, a character seems cruel, a clue seems to lead nowhere. Then the last chapter comes, and everything earlier falls into place: the pointless scene was the key, the cruel character was protecting someone. You could not have known the meaning of the middle without the end. Pannenberg believed history is like that, and that the end is the coming kingdom of God. The meaning of any event, and of the whole human story, will be clear only when God brings everything to its goal. In the meantime one thing has already appeared: in the resurrection of Jesus the end has broken into the middle of history ahead of time. Theologians call this prolepsis, from a Greek word for "taking beforehand," the way a single scene from the final chapter might be printed on the first page. That gave him his answer to the hardest question of all, the problem of evil. He did not think any argument could fully justify God in the face of the world’s suffering here and now. "Only the eschatological consummation in which God will wipe away all tears (Isa. 25:8; Rev. 21:4) can remove all doubts concerning the revelation of the love of God in creation and salvation history," he wrote, "even though the love of God has been at work already at each stage in the history of creation" (Systematic Theology, volume 3, page 645). "Eschatological" means having to do with the last things, the end God is bringing. God is not acquitted by philosophers; he will vindicate himself, and the love that was hidden in the middle chapters will be plain at the last.

(Q) "The distinction and unity of the immanent and economic Trinity constitute the heartbeat of the divine love, and with a single such heartbeat this love encompasses the whole world of creatures." + Source: Wolfhart Pannenberg, Systematic Theology, volume 3, translated by Geoffrey W. Bromiley (Eerdmans and T&T Clark, 1998), chapter 15, page 646. The last sentence of the whole Systematic Theology. The "immanent" Trinity is God as he is in himself, Father, Son, and Spirit in eternal love; the "economic" Trinity is the same God at work in the world, creating, reconciling, and bringing it home. The two are distinct, and yet they are one God, and Pannenberg pictures their relation as the beat of a single heart.

(Q) "The story of Jesus Christ has to be history, not in all its details, but in its core, if the Christian faith is to continue." + Source: Wolfhart Pannenberg, An Introduction to Systematic Theology (Eerdmans, 1991), chapter 1, "The Need for Systematic Theology," page 5. From lectures given in America near the end of his career. He had just warned that calling the gospel a "story" lets people slide past the question of whether it is true. Paul had put the same point more bluntly: "And if Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain" (1 Corinthians 15:14).

What the Church Made of Him

(†) Apologists took up his case for the resurrection, beginning with his own student William Lane Craig. + For evangelical Christians in the English-speaking world, who had long argued for the resurrection on the evidence, Pannenberg was a surprise: a leading German university theologian, trained in all the critical methods, who agreed with them that Easter is an event of history and can be defended as one. William Lane Craig went to Munich to study with him and finished his theology doctorate there in 1984, with a dissertation on the historical argument for the resurrection during the deist controversy of the eighteenth century. The deists believed in a Creator who made the world and then left it to run like a wound-up clock, and they denied that he ever broke into it with miracles; their Christian opponents answered them, in part, with the evidence for Easter. The empty tomb and the appearances, defended as historical facts in front of skeptical audiences, became the backbone of Craig’s work, and Pannenberg in turn cited his former student’s articles in his own Systematic Theology. The influence ran wider than one student. When the philosopher Antony Flew debated the resurrection with Gary Habermas in 1985, Pannenberg was among the scholars invited to respond in the published volume, Did Jesus Rise from the Dead? (1987). Even his disagreements served the cause. Moltmann, his near contemporary, also put Easter back at the center of theology, but he denied that it could be called historical in the ordinary sense, and Pannenberg answered him in print. A whole generation learned from the exchange that the old question, "Did it really happen?", was still a respectable question for a theologian to ask and to answer.

(†) Catholics and Protestants alike read him as a guide to what they still share, and his work helped prepare the 1999 agreement on justification. + In the judgment of his Munich colleague Friedrich Wilhelm Graf, no Protestant theologian of the twentieth century drew so many Catholic theologians into conversation, some agreeing and some disagreeing, as Pannenberg did. He was proud that Catholic students who had written doctorates with him or about him went on to become bishops. He and Joseph Ratzinger, later Pope Benedict XVI, knew each other well, and the cardinal once walked him and his wife through the Vatican gardens, though Pannenberg grew more and more disappointed in him after Rome’s 2000 declaration Dominus Iesus said the Protestant communities were not churches in the proper sense. His ecumenical work bore fruit he lived to see. Justification is the old word for how a guilty person is put right with God: is a sinner declared righteous for Christ’s sake through faith, or made righteous by grace renewing the person from within, and how do the two belong together? It was the question at the heart of Martin Luther’s break with Rome in the sixteenth century, and for four hundred years each side had condemned the other’s answer. The study of the sixteenth-century condemnations that he led with Karl Lehmann helped lay the ground for the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, signed by the Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church in 1999, and he was one of its most prominent defenders among German professors, many of whom opposed it. In America, his influence ran through students and readers such as the Baptist theologian Stanley Grenz, and through the journal First Things, which published his essays for years and in 2012 honored him as a theologian who, unlike most of his peers, set out to address universal human reason.

(†) Where many believers part ways with him: the virgin birth treated as legend, and a God who in some sense does not yet exist. + Pannenberg defended the core of the creed with more rigor than most of his colleagues, which makes the two places where he departed from it the more striking. - The virgin birth. Matthew and Luke both say that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit without a human father (Matthew 1:18–25; Luke 1:34–35), and the Apostles’ Creed confesses that he was "born of the virgin Mary." Pannenberg kept the doctrine’s meaning, that Jesus was the Son of God from his very birth, and he honored Mary as the Mother of God with the Council of Ephesus, the early church council (431) that confirmed that title for her to say that the child she bore was truly God. But in Jesus: God and Man and again in the Systematic Theology he judged the infancy narratives, the stories of Jesus’ conception, birth, and childhood in Matthew 1–2 and Luke 1–2, to be legend. His stated reason was not that miracles are impossible, but "the apparently legendary nature of the narrative" (Systematic Theology, volume 2, page 318). Critics across the traditions, Catholic, Orthodox, and evangelical alike, noted that the same historical judgment that defended the resurrection could just as well be turned on the infancy narratives, since both rest on early testimony to a unique act of God, and that the creed had confessed the virgin birth from the beginning. - The future of God. Think of a king in exile: in one sense he is king already, and in another his kingship is not real until he returns and reigns. Pannenberg pushed that thought very far. Because he identified God’s being with his rule, and God’s rule with the kingdom still to come, the young Pannenberg argued in Theology and the Kingdom of God (1969) that in a limited but important sense God does not yet exist, a line his critics and admirers have quoted ever since. Read carelessly, the line seems to make God a product of history rather than its Lord. Pannenberg meant that God’s lordship over the world is not yet fully established, and in the Systematic Theology he grounded everything in the eternal life of the Trinity, which needs nothing from the world. Many readers thought the later work corrected the earlier phrase; others felt the early way of speaking was never quite left behind. Neither departure touched what he cared about most. The man who doubted the infancy narratives was the same man who told the theologians of his day that if Christ was not raised, there was nothing left to talk about.

Pannenberg wrote in German, and his bibliography runs to nearly seven hundred titles, most of them essays and articles. The books below are the ones a reader is likely to meet, listed by the date of the German original, with the English title where there is a translation. Collections of essays that overlap with one another are grouped together. Early scholarship, 1954–1961: - Die Prädestinationslehre des Duns Skotus (1954): His doctoral thesis under Edmund Schlink, on how the medieval Franciscan John Duns Scotus understood predestination, set within the development of scholastic theology. Untranslated. - Analogie und Offenbarung (written 1955, published 2007): His habilitation thesis, a critical history of the idea of analogy in the knowledge of God, from the Greeks through the Middle Ages. It waited more than fifty years for publication. - Offenbarung als Geschichte (1961), English Revelation as History (1968): The manifesto of the Pannenberg circle, edited by Pannenberg with essays by Rolf Rendtorff, Ulrich Wilckens, and Trutz Rendtorff. Pannenberg’s "Dogmatic Theses on the Doctrine of Revelation" argue that God reveals himself indirectly, through public history (T1). - Was ist der Mensch? (1962), English What Is Man? (1970): A short book on human nature in the light of modern anthropology, introducing the theme of "openness to the world" that the later Anthropology worked out at length (T4). Christology and the kingdom, 1964–1972: - Grundzüge der Christologie (1964), English Jesus: God and Man (1968): His most famous book. A Christology "from below" that begins with the historical Jesus and treats the resurrection as a historical event confirming his claim (T2, T3). It also contains his early critical treatment of the virgin birth. - Grundfragen systematischer Theologie (two volumes, 1967 and 1980), English Basic Questions in Theology (two volumes, 1970–1971, translating the first German volume; the British edition counts The Idea of God and Human Freedom as a third, 1973): Collected essays on hermeneutics, history, faith and reason, and the idea of God, including his rebuttal of Ernst Troeltsch on whether history allows for the unique, and "Redemptive Event and History" (1959), the essay since which, he wrote in 1981, his theological outlook had not fundamentally changed. - Reformation zwischen gestern und morgen (1969): A short book on the Reformation and its meaning for the churches of the present. Untranslated. - Theology and the Kingdom of God (1969), German Theologie und Reich Gottes (1971): Lectures given in America on the kingdom as the key to theology, ethics, and the church, including the much-quoted claim that in a limited but important sense God does not yet exist. Published first in English, edited by Richard John Neuhaus. - Spirit, Faith, and Church (1970, with Avery Dulles and Carl E. Braaten): Three theologians, Lutheran and Catholic, on the Holy Spirit and the church; Pannenberg’s chapter treats the working of the Spirit in creation and in the people of God. - Erwägungen zu einer Theologie der Natur (1970, with A. M. Klaus Müller): An early joint venture in theology and natural science, written with a physicist, on a theme he returned to for the rest of his life. - Thesen zur Theologie der Kirche (1970): Short theses on the church and its unity. - Das Glaubensbekenntnis (1972), English The Apostles’ Creed in the Light of Today’s Questions (1972): A clause-by-clause exposition of the creed for thoughtful lay readers. - Gottesgedanke und menschliche Freiheit (1972), English The Idea of God and Human Freedom (1973): Essays arguing that belief in God is the ground of human freedom rather than its rival, with a long reply to the philosopher Hans Blumenberg. - Christentum und Mythos (1972): A study of myth and its late echoes in the Bible and Christian tradition, asking where the gospel uses mythic language and where it breaks with myth. Theology among the sciences, 1973–1988: - Wissenschaftstheorie und Theologie (1973), English Theology and the Philosophy of Science (1976): Theology defended as a genuine discipline, the "science of God," whose claims are tested like hypotheses for their power to make sense of all reality. - Gegenwart Gottes (1973): A collection of his sermons. Untranslated. - Glaube und Wirklichkeit (1975), English Faith and Reality (1977): Shorter essays and addresses on faith, history, and the Christian life. - Human Nature, Election, and History (1977), German Die Bestimmung des Menschen (1978): Five lectures from a 1975–1976 tour of British and American schools, in two parts: the Christian idea of the human person, and the doctrine of election as the calling of a people within history. Published first in English. - Ethik und Ekklesiologie (1977), English in two parts as Ethics (1981) and The Church (1983): Essays on the foundations of Christian ethics and on the church as a sign of the kingdom. - Anthropologie in theologischer Perspektive (1983), English Anthropology in Theological Perspective (1985): His great book on human nature, reading biology, psychology, and sociology to show that human beings are constitutively open to God (T4). - Christian Spirituality (1983), published in Britain as Christian Spirituality and Sacramental Community (1984), German Christliche Spiritualität (1986): A short book on Christian piety in a secular age, arguing that the church gathered at the eucharist is a sign of the wider human community people are searching for. - Lehrverurteilungen, kirchentrennend? (1986, edited with Karl Lehmann), English The Condemnations of the Reformation Era: Do They Still Divide? (1990): The joint Protestant and Catholic study of the sixteenth-century condemnations, which helped prepare the 1999 Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. - Christentum in einer säkularisierten Welt (1988), English Christianity in a Secularized World (1989): A short book on how the modern secular world grew out of Christian history and what it lost in leaving. - Metaphysik und Gottesgedanke (1988), English Metaphysics and the Idea of God (1990): Essays arguing that theology cannot do without metaphysics, the philosophical study of what is ultimately real. The system and after, 1988–2008: - Systematische Theologie (three volumes, 1988, 1991, 1993), English Systematic Theology (1991, 1994, 1998), translated by Geoffrey W. Bromiley: His masterpiece. Volume 1 on the truth of theology and the doctrine of the triune God; volume 2 on creation, humanity, and Christ (T2, T3, T4); volume 3 on the Spirit, the church, election, and the consummation (T5). - An Introduction to Systematic Theology (1991): Four lectures given in America that sketch the whole system in brief: the need for systematic theology, the doctrine of God, creation and science, and Christology. The best short door into his thought. - Toward a Theology of Nature (1993, edited by Ted Peters): Essays on theology and the natural sciences, including his use of the physicist’s idea of a field to speak of the Spirit. - Grundlagen der Ethik (1996): A compact philosophical and theological account of the foundations of ethics. - Theologie und Philosophie (1996): A history of how theology and philosophy have shaped each other from the Greeks to the twentieth century. - Problemgeschichte der neueren evangelischen Theologie in Deutschland (1997): A history of German Protestant theology from Schleiermacher to Barth and Tillich, told through its problems. - Beiträge zur Systematischen Theologie (three volumes, 1999–2000): His later essays on philosophy, religion, revelation, ethics, the church, and the dialogue with science, gathered by theme. - Hintergründe des Streites um die Rechtfertigungslehre in der evangelischen Theologie (2000): A lecture to the Bavarian Academy of Sciences on why German Protestant theologians quarreled so fiercely over the 1999 Joint Declaration, tracing the dispute to the several rival versions of the doctrine within Protestant theology itself. - Freude des Glaubens (2001): A second collection of sermons. - Beiträge zur Ethik (2004): Collected essays on ethics, a companion to the Grundlagen. - The Historicity of Nature (2008, edited by Niels Henrik Gregersen): Late essays on science and theology, published in English. Essays in English worth knowing: "Christianity and the West," the 1994 Erasmus Lecture, published in First Things (December 1994); his response in Did Jesus Rise from the Dead? The Resurrection Debate, by Gary Habermas and Antony Flew, edited by Terry L. Miethe (Harper & Row, 1987). For his life and thought: his autobiographical essays, "God’s Presence in History" (The Christian Century, 11 March 1981, in the "How My Mind Has Changed" series), which tells the story of the light experience of 1945, and "An Intellectual Pilgrimage" (Dialog 45, no. 2, 2006); Thomas Jay Oord’s interview with him, "Future Perfect" (Books & Culture, September/October 2001); Carl E. Braaten and Philip Clayton, eds., The Theology of Wolfhart Pannenberg (Augsburg, 1988), with his own autobiographical sketch; Stanley J. Grenz, Reason for Hope: The Systematic Theology of Wolfhart Pannenberg (Oxford, 1990; second edition Eerdmans, 2005).
Playlist
Justified True Belief