Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn of Kislovodsk 1918 – 2008 AD
(●) The prisoner who came back from the Soviet labor camps a Christian, and told the world what had been done there and why. For most of the twentieth century the Soviet Union ran a vast network of forced-labor camps, the Gulag (a Russian acronym for the Chief Administration of Camps), and for most of that century the outside world could pretend not to know. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn made the pretending impossible. A mathematics teacher and former artillery officer who had spent eight years as a prisoner, he gathered the testimony of hundreds of fellow survivors and set it down in The Gulag Archipelago, a book that stripped the Soviet system of much of its moral standing in the eyes of the world. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site because of what he found inside the camps. He went in a convinced Marxist, a believer in the atheist creed that history and economics explain everything. He came out a Russian Orthodox Christian, persuaded that the disasters of his century had a spiritual cause, and that the line between good and evil runs not between nations or parties but through every human heart, his own included. One fact a reader will remember: he wrote much of his early work without paper he could keep. He composed verse in his head and counted the lines first with bits of broken matchstick on a cigarette case, then with a rosary that Lithuanian Catholic prisoners kneaded for him out of soaked bread, a hundred beads with every tenth one cube-shaped. Fingering it inside his mittens on the march to work, he carried some twelve thousand memorized lines out of the camps.
(●) 1918 AD: Born fatherless in the south of Russia, he grew up poor, baptized, and a convinced young Communist. Aleksandr Isayevich Solzhenitsyn was born on 11 December 1918 in Kislovodsk, a spa town in the northern Caucasus, a year into the Russian Revolution. His father, Isaaki, an educated officer who had fought in the First World War, had died in a hunting accident some months before the birth. His mother, Taisia, raised the boy alone in Rostov-on-Don, working as a typist and living in cramped rented rooms. The family had once been prosperous, which in the new Soviet state was a thing to hide. His maternal grandfather was taken by the secret police around 1932 and never seen again. At home he absorbed the Orthodox faith of his mother and his aunts; outside he absorbed the faith of the new regime, and the second won. By the time he entered Rostov University in 1936 to study mathematics and physics, he was a committed Marxist-Leninist. That meant he held Karl Marx’s teaching that history is driven by the struggle between economic classes, in the form Lenin had put into practice in the Revolution, and he believed that Lenin had been right and that Stalin had only lost the way. He already wanted to be a writer, too: at seventeen he resolved to write the history of the 1917 Revolution as a novel, a project that would occupy him for half a century. He graduated with distinction in 1941. The year before, he had married a chemistry student, Natalia Reshetovskaya.
(●) 1945 AD: An artillery captain at the front, he was arrested for private letters criticizing Stalin and sentenced to eight years. When Germany invaded in 1941 he joined the Red Army, trained as an artillery officer, and commanded a sound-ranging battery, a unit that located enemy guns by the sound of their firing. He was decorated for bravery and fought his way through Poland into East Prussia. In February 1945, with the war nearly won, his brigade commander called him to headquarters and asked for his pistol, and two counterintelligence officers stepped out from among the staff and tore the captain’s shoulder boards off. Military censors had read his letters to a school friend, Nikolai Vitkevich, in which the two of them criticized Stalin in thinly disguised terms. Under Article 58 of the criminal code, the catch-all law against "counterrevolutionary activity," he received eight years in the camps. Prison began with humiliation of a kind he later refused to hide. In a Moscow camp in the winter of 1945–46 a security officer pressed him into signing a pledge to inform on fellow prisoners, under the code name "Vetrov." He says he never passed on a single report, and a transfer soon took him out of reach, but he wrote that the six letters of that name were "branded in shameful grooves" on his memory. Then came four years in a sharashka, a prison research institute where convict scientists worked for the state, the setting of his novel In the First Circle, and then the hard-labor camp at Ekibastuz in Kazakhstan, where he laid bricks and worked in the foundry.
(●) 1952 AD: In a camp hospital, after cancer surgery and a doctor’s last conversation, the Marxist found his way back to God. The conversion did not come in a single flash. It came the way a frozen pond thaws, over months of watching what the camps did to people, including himself. In Ekibastuz he was operated on for a tumor, and he lay feverish in the camp hospital while a doctor named Boris Kornfeld sat beside his cot in the dark and told him, with great ardor, the story of his own conversion from Judaism to Christianity. Kornfeld ended by saying he had become convinced that no punishment in this life comes to us undeserved, if we search our lives honestly enough to find the wrong we have done. Before morning Kornfeld was dead, beaten with a plasterer’s mallet as he slept, apparently by prisoners who suspected him of informing. Solzhenitsyn took the doctor’s last words as an inheritance laid on him. He began to do what Kornfeld had urged, going over his life "with a fine-tooth comb": the proud young captain who had badgered his orderly and sent men out to repair wires under shellfire, the officer who would have made a willing executioner had history placed him on the other side. In that searching he lost his Marxism and recovered the faith of his childhood. He told the story years later in the chapter of The Gulag Archipelago he called "The Ascent."
(●) 1962 AD: After exile, cancer, and years of secret writing, One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich made him famous overnight. His sentence ended in 1953, but release meant only "perpetual exile" to the village of Kok-Terek in southern Kazakhstan. His first day without an armed guard, he later noted, was 5 March 1953, the day Stalin died. There the cancer returned, and doctors gave him weeks to live; treatment at a clinic in Tashkent saved him, and became the novel Cancer Ward. He taught mathematics and physics in the village school and wrote at night, hiding his pages in bottles buried in the garden. After Nikita Khrushchev, Stalin’s successor as Soviet leader, denounced Stalin in 1956, Solzhenitsyn was freed from exile and in 1957 formally "rehabilitated," the Soviet word for a conviction quietly withdrawn. He settled in Ryazan as a schoolteacher, remarried Natalia (they had divorced while he was imprisoned), and kept writing for the drawer, as Russians said of work that no one could publish. In 1961 he sent a short novel about a single day in a labor camp to the literary journal Novy Mir. Its editor, Aleksandr Tvardovsky, sat up all night reading it, so the story went in Moscow. Then he went over the censors’ heads: through Khrushchev’s aide Vladimir Lebedev he pressed it on Khrushchev himself, who approved it as ammunition against the Stalinists, the officials still loyal to the old dictator’s ways. When One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich appeared in November 1962, a nation that had whispered about the camps for thirty years read about them in print, and the unknown teacher became the most famous writer in the country.
(●) 1974 AD: After the Nobel Prize and The Gulag Archipelago, the Soviet state stripped him of citizenship and expelled him. The thaw, as people called the brief loosening of censorship under Khrushchev, did not last. After Khrushchev fell in 1964, nothing more of Solzhenitsyn’s was published at home. Cancer Ward and In the First Circle came out abroad instead, and in 1969 the Writers’ Union, the state-run body a Soviet author needed to belong to in order to live by writing, expelled him. In 1970 he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature, and he did not dare travel to Stockholm to receive it, fearing he would not be let back in. In 1972 he wrote an open "Lenten Letter" (Lent being the season of fasting before Easter) to the Patriarch of Moscow, the head of the Russian Orthodox Church, rebuking the church’s leaders for their silent submission to an atheist state. Meanwhile, in secret, mostly in a hideout in Estonia, he had written The Gulag Archipelago. In 1973 the KGB, the Soviet secret police, extracted the location of a hidden copy from Elizaveta Voronyanskaya, one of the friends who had typed it, and she was afterward found hanged. Solzhenitsyn answered by ordering the book published in the West, and it appeared in Paris that December. On 12 February 1974 he was arrested and charged with treason; the next day he was put on a plane to West Germany, stripped of his citizenship. His second wife, Natalia Svetlova (a second Natalia), whom he had married after his marriage to Reshetovskaya ended for good, followed with their three young sons. After a stay in Zurich, the family settled in 1976 in the hills of Cavendish, Vermont, where for eighteen years he wrote twelve and fourteen hours a day on his history of the Revolution, The Red Wheel. He emerged twice to give addresses that are still read: at Harvard’s commencement in 1978, and in London in 1983, accepting the Templeton Prize for Progress in Religion.
(●) 1994 AD: He went home to Russia by way of the old camp lands, and died in Moscow in 2008. When the Soviet Union collapsed, the treason charge was lifted and his books were printed at home at last. In May 1994 he flew from Alaska to Magadan, a center of the old camp system, and then crossed the whole country from Vladivostok to Moscow by train over two months, stopping in town after town to listen to ordinary people and answer their questions. It was a deliberate choice: to come home through the land of the prisoners rather than to land at the capital. The new Russia did not quite know what to do with him. He criticized the chaos and plunder of the 1990s as sharply as he had criticized the Soviets, and a television program he was given was taken off the air within months. In 1998 he refused a state honor from President Yeltsin because of the poverty the country had fallen into; in 2007 he accepted the State Prize, which President Putin brought to his home. He spent his last years editing a thirty-volume collected edition. He died of heart failure in Moscow on 3 August 2008, aged eighty-nine, and was buried at the Donskoy Monastery after an Orthodox funeral.
What He Taught
(T1) The line between good and evil runs not between groups of people but through every human heart. Picture a prisoner in a cell, staring at the interrogator who has been beating him, and thinking: there is the evil, on the other side of the desk. That was where Solzhenitsyn began. Then, as a prisoner, he began to look honestly at his own past as a young officer, proud, sure of his ideology, ready to obey. He realized that if history had sent him to the secret-police school instead of the artillery, he might well have become one of the interrogators himself. From that realization came his most famous teaching. Every great ideology of the twentieth century said evil lived in some class or race or party: get rid of the kulaks, the wealthier peasants, or the bourgeoisie, the property-owning middle class, or the Jews, and the world would be clean. Solzhenitsyn answered that evil cannot be located and removed that way, because it lives in each of us, and the line moves within a single life, toward sainthood at one time and toward the devil at another. Christians recognized this at once as the old doctrine of sin, rediscovered in a prison camp: "The heart is deceitful above all things" (Jeremiah 17:9). It is also why he refused to write the camps as a simple story of villains and victims. The man who confessed signing as "Vetrov" knew which side of the line he had sometimes stood on.
(Q) "If only it were all so simple! If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?" Source: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago 1918–1956, vol. 1, Part I, chapter 4, "The Bluecaps" (Thomas P. Whitney translation, Harper & Row, 1974), p. 168. He has just been describing the interrogators, the "bluecaps" of the secret police, and confessing that he too had been "thoroughly prepared to be an executioner."
(T2) Suffering, accepted rather than resented, can turn a soul toward God. Most people who survive a terrible ordeal want to forget it, or want someone to pay for it. Solzhenitsyn did something stranger. He looked back on eight years of hunger, cold, and humiliation and said that prison had been good for him. He did not mean that the camps were good. He spent three volumes documenting their cruelty and naming the dead. He meant that the stripping away of everything, rank and comfort and the illusion of being a good man, had forced him to ask what a human life is for, and that the answer he found was the soul rather than prosperity. Prisoners who set out to survive at any price, he observed, ended by groveling for soft jobs and informing on their comrades. Prisoners who let that aim go, and took the meaning of life to lie not "in prospering" but "in the development of the soul," could find the camp transforming them, and come out larger than they went in. This is close to what Paul wrote about suffering producing endurance, and endurance character, and character hope (Romans 5:3–4). Solzhenitsyn was careful with it, though. He immediately put into the mouths of the dead the obvious reply: that is easy to say when you came out alive.
(Q) "I nourished my soul there, and I say without hesitation: 'Bless you, prison, for having been in my life!'" Source: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago 1918–1956, vol. 2, Part IV, chapter 1, "The Ascent" (Thomas P. Whitney translation, Harper & Row, 1975), p. 617. The closing lines of the chapter in which he tells of Boris Kornfeld and his own return to faith. The next sentence gives the dead their answer: "It is very well for you to say that."
(T3) A regime built on lies loses its grip when ordinary people refuse to repeat them. Imagine a clerk at a Soviet factory meeting. A resolution is read condemning some writer he has never read. Everyone raises a hand. He knows the resolution is false, everyone knows it is false, and he raises his hand anyway, because not raising it would cost him his job. Multiply that by two hundred million people, every day, and you have the machine Solzhenitsyn wanted to stop. On the day of his arrest in 1974 he released a short essay called "Live Not by Lies." Its argument was simple and demanding. Ordinary people could not overthrow the state, and he did not ask them to. He asked them only to stop taking part in its falsehoods: not to say what they did not believe, not to sign what they knew to be untrue, not to applaud, not to vote for, not to repeat. A lie needs people to carry it, he wrote, and when enough people refuse, it has nothing to stand on. Christians heard in this the command to put away falsehood and speak the truth to one’s neighbor (Ephesians 4:25), and the promise that the truth will set you free (John 8:32). His Nobel Lecture, published in 1972, made the same claim about literature: a single true book, honestly written, can outweigh a whole system of propaganda.
(Q) "Even if all is covered by lies, even if all is under their rule, let us resist in the smallest way: Let their rule hold not through me!" Source: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, "Live Not by Lies," dated 12 February 1974 (translated by Yermolai Solzhenitsyn, in The Solzhenitsyn Reader, ISI Books, 2006). He calls this "personal nonparticipation in lies" the simplest and most accessible key to liberation, open even to people who have no courage for anything greater.
(Q) "One word of truth shall outweigh the whole world." Source: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, Nobel Lecture in Literature, 1970 (the Nobel Foundation’s English text, reprinted in Nobel Lectures, Literature 1968–1980, ed. Sture Allén, World Scientific, 1993). He quotes it as a Russian proverb, printed in capitals, and makes it the foundation of his appeal to the writers of the world. The lecture was written for the 1970 prize but could not be delivered in person, and was published in 1972.
(T4) A civilization that forgets God loses its courage and its soul, in the free West as in the Communist East. The Harvard class of 1978 expected the famous dissident to thank America for its freedom. Instead, standing in the rain, he told them that the West had lost its courage. He said its leaders were timid, its press was shallow, and its culture was given over to comfort and entertainment. He said he could not recommend Western society as a model for his own country. The root of the trouble, he argued, was not political at all. Since the Renaissance, the West had increasingly treated man as the measure of all things, a view he called "rationalistic humanism" or "humanistic autonomy," man’s declared independence from any higher power above him. It had won real goods along the way: freedom, prosperity, science. But it had lost the sense of a Supreme Being above human desire, to whom human beings are answerable, and without that, freedom drifts toward license and courage has no ground to stand on. East and West, he said, were two forms of the same illness: in one the spiritual life was destroyed by the ruling party, in the other it was suffocated by commercial interests. Five years later, accepting the Templeton Prize in London, he put the whole diagnosis into four words remembered from his childhood.
(Q) "On the way from the Renaissance to our days we have enriched our experience, but we have lost the concept of a Supreme Complete Entity which used to restrain our passions and our irresponsibility." Source: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, "A World Split Apart," Commencement Address at Harvard University, 8 June 1978 (English text of the simultaneous translation). Delivered in Russian with live interpretation to an audience of some twenty thousand in Harvard Yard, it drew a storm of angry replies in the American press.
(Q) "If I were called upon to identify briefly the principal trait of the entire twentieth century, here too, I would be unable to find anything more precise and pithy than to repeat once again: 'Men have forgotten God.'" Source: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, Templeton Prize Acceptance Address, London, 10 May 1983 (English text published by the Templeton Prize). He opens the address by recalling older people in his childhood explaining Russia’s disasters with the words "Men have forgotten God; that’s why all this has happened." After fifty years of studying the Revolution, he says, he can find no better explanation, and he applies it to the whole century, East and West alike.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) Christians East and West received him as a confessor, a witness who had suffered for the truth and kept faith. In the early church, a "confessor" was a believer who had been imprisoned or tortured for the faith and survived; the title carried great honor, just short of a martyr’s. Many Christians thought of Solzhenitsyn in something like those terms. He had come through the camps with his faith recovered rather than destroyed, he had told the truth about the persecution that had killed priests and believers by the tens of thousands, and he had paid for it with his homeland. His "Lenten Letter" of 1972 gave voice to believers inside the Soviet Union whose leaders could not speak freely, and it stirred real debate among Orthodox Christians about how far a persecuted church may compromise to survive. In the West, Catholics, Protestants, and Orthodox alike heard in his speeches a Christian prophet who knew modern unbelief from the inside. The Templeton Prize of 1983, given before him to Mother Teresa and to Billy Graham, recognized that he had become one of the century’s best-known witnesses to the reality of God.
(†) His testimony broke the West’s illusions about the Soviet experiment and gave Christians words for the moral crisis of their own societies. Before The Gulag Archipelago, many Western intellectuals, especially in France, still regarded the Soviet Union as a flawed but hopeful experiment. After it, that was very hard to say with a straight face. The book documented the camps from the inside, from arrest to interrogation to transport to death, and traced them back to Lenin rather than treating them as a Stalinist accident. It did not end the Cold War, but it took away the moral credit the Soviet system had enjoyed among the educated classes of the West. For Christians, his greatest gift was a set of ideas that traveled. Charles Colson, the Nixon aide who became a Christian at the height of the Watergate scandal, served seven months in prison, and came out to found a ministry to prisoners, retold the story of Boris Kornfeld and Solzhenitsyn’s conversion in Loving God (1983), and a generation of evangelicals first met him there. The line through every heart (T1) became a staple of preaching on sin. "Live Not by Lies" (T3) was revived in 2020 as the title and the program of Rod Dreher’s book on how Christians should live under soft pressure to affirm what they do not believe. And "Men have forgotten God" (T4) became, for many believers, the one-line summary of what had gone wrong with the modern world.
(†) Where friendly critics part ways with him: his hopes for a strong Russian state, and the sweep of his verdicts on the West. Admirers who share his faith have still disagreed with him on several points drawn from his own writings. - An authoritarian order. In his Letter to the Soviet Leaders (1973), he told the Kremlin that Russia was not ready for Western-style democracy and could keep an authoritarian government (one that rules without free elections or a legal opposition), provided it gave up Marxist ideology, ruled by law, and left religion and conscience free. Many readers, including fellow dissidents such as the physicist Andrei Sakharov, thought he trusted strong rulers more than his own account of the human heart (T1) should have allowed. - The verdict on the West. The Harvard address (T4) named real sickness, but critics then and since have answered that it painted a whole civilization in one color, gave little weight to the churches and free institutions that had sheltered him, and underrated the protections that only free societies give to a lone truth-teller like himself. - His last years. His acceptance of the 2007 State Prize from Vladimir Putin, and his late praise for Putin’s restoration of Russian strength, troubled many who had learned from him to distrust power. None of this touches the heart of his witness. He would have been the first to say that the line between good and evil ran through his own judgments too.