Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Jesus & the Apostles

5 BC – 100 AD

Thomas the Apostle fl. c. 28 – c. 30 AD

(●) Thomas was the apostle who would not believe the resurrection on his friends’ word, and who, when he saw the risen Jesus, gave the Gospels’ highest confession: "My Lord and my God!" + Most people know Thomas by a nickname he never had in his lifetime. "Doubting Thomas" has become ordinary English for anyone who wants proof before he will believe, and it is fair as far as it goes. But it leaves out the rest of the man John’s Gospel shows us: the disciple who was ready to walk into danger and die with Jesus, the one who asked out loud the question the others were too embarrassed to ask, and the one whose words, when the evidence finally stood in front of him, said more about who Jesus is than anyone else in the Gospels had yet said. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for that reason. The first witnesses to the resurrection are sometimes imagined as eager believers ready to see whatever they hoped to see. Thomas is the standing answer: a man who flatly refused the testimony of ten friends he trusted, named the evidence that would change his mind, and changed it only when that evidence came. A note on the dates. Thomas wrote nothing, and nothing in the first-century record gives his birth or his death. What is firm is the stretch of his life the Gospels and Acts describe, from his call into the Twelve around AD 28 to the gathering in the upper room after the ascension, when Jesus was taken up into heaven, around AD 30 (the year depends on whether one dates the crucifixion to AD 30 or 33; this site follows AD 30). That stretch is the "fl." (floruit, Latin for "he flourished") in the title. Everything later, his mission to Parthia or India and his death by a spear, comes from traditions recorded from the third century on, and every date attached to it, such as AD 52 for his landing in India and AD 72 for his death, is the convention of the Indian church that honors him, not a record.

(●) c. 28 AD: Jesus chose him as one of the Twelve, a man known by a name that simply means "the Twin." + We meet Thomas first as a name on a list. Matthew, Mark and Luke each give the roll of the twelve men Jesus chose to be with him and to send out, and Thomas is on all three (Matthew 10:3; Mark 3:18; Luke 6:15), usually paired with Matthew the tax collector. Nothing is said of his home, his family, or his trade, though the scene by the Sea of Galilee late in John’s Gospel, where he goes fishing with Peter and the sons of Zebedee, suggests he was a Galilean like most of the Twelve (John 21:2). His name is itself a small puzzle. "Thomas" is not really a personal name at all. Jesus and his friends spoke Aramaic, a close cousin of Hebrew and the everyday language of Galilee, and in Aramaic t’oma simply means "twin." John three times adds the Greek equivalent for his readers, "Thomas, called the Twin" (Greek Didymus). It is as if a man were known all his life simply as "Twin." Whose twin he was, the New Testament never says. The churches of Syria, where his memory was strongest, called him Judas Thomas, "Judas the Twin," and that may well preserve his given name.

(●) c. 30 AD: When Jesus turned back toward Judea, where men were trying to stone him, Thomas told the others, "Let us also go, that we may die with him." + Thomas’s first spoken line in the Gospels is a brave one. Jesus had withdrawn across the Jordan after the Jerusalem leadership tried to stone him. Then word came that his friend Lazarus was sick in Bethany, a village about two miles from Jerusalem (John 11:18), and Jesus announced that he was going back. The disciples protested: the authorities had just tried to kill him, and he meant to walk back into reach of them (John 11:8). It was Thomas who settled it. If Jesus was going, they would go with him, even if it meant dying alongside him (John 11:16). It is a gloomy sort of courage, the courage of a man who expects the worst and goes anyway, and it tells us something about the "doubter" before he ever doubted. Whatever else Thomas was, he was not a coward and not a fair-weather follower. He also turned out to be wrong in the best possible way: they went to Bethany expecting a funeral, and Jesus raised Lazarus from the dead.

(●) c. 30 AD: On the last night before the cross he asked, "How can we know the way?" and drew from Jesus the answer, "I am the way, and the truth, and the life." + At the Last Supper Jesus told his friends that he was going away to prepare a place for them in his Father’s house, and added, almost in passing, "And you know the way to where I am going" (John 14:4). Picture a room full of men nodding along, none of them wanting to be the one who admits he has lost the thread. Thomas was the one who said it: "Lord, we do not know where you are going. How can we know the way?" (John 14:5). It is the question of a literal, practical mind, the kind of person who wants the directions written down. And it was answered with one of the most famous sentences Jesus ever spoke: the way is not a road but a person, Jesus himself (John 14:6). An honest question, plainly asked, got the plainest answer in the Gospel.

(●) c. 30 AD: He missed the risen Jesus’ first visit to the disciples, and refused to believe it without touching the wounds himself. + On the evening of the first Easter Sunday, the disciples were together behind locked doors, afraid of the Jerusalem leadership who had just had their master crucified, when Jesus came and stood among them. Thomas, John tells us without explanation, was not there (John 20:24). When the others found him, they told him the news in four words: "We have seen the Lord." His answer was blunt. He would not take their word for it. Unless he saw the nail marks in Jesus’ hands, put his finger into them, and put his hand into the wound in his side, he would never believe (John 20:25). It is worth noticing what kind of doubt this is. Thomas did not doubt that Jesus had died; he knew exactly how, down to the nails and the spear. He doubted that a man who died like that could be standing in a room a few days later, which is the most reasonable doubt in the world. And his "never" came with a condition attached. He named his evidence. That made him, in a sense, the first person to set out the test a resurrection would have to pass.

(●) c. 30 AD: Eight days later Jesus came back, offered him the wounds, and Thomas confessed him as Lord and God. + A week passed. For eight days Thomas lived among friends who were sure of something he would not accept, which cannot have been comfortable for any of them. Then, on the following Sunday, with the doors locked again and Thomas present this time, Jesus came and stood among them once more (John 20:26). He went straight to Thomas, and he offered him exactly what Thomas had demanded, almost word for word: "Put your finger here, and see my hands; and put out your hand, and place it in my side. Do not disbelieve, but believe" (John 20:27). Jesus had heard the test, though he had not been in the room when it was set. John does not say that Thomas reached out and touched. He records only what Thomas said, and it was the fullest confession anyone makes in the four Gospels: "My Lord and my God!" (John 20:28). The skeptic of the week before became the first person in John’s story to call the risen Jesus, to his face, God.

(●) c. 30 AD: He went back to the boats in Galilee with Peter, and prayed with the others in the upper room after the ascension. + After Easter the disciples went home to Galilee, and the last chapter of John finds seven of them by the Sea of Tiberias (the Sea of Galilee under its Roman name). Thomas is named second, right after Peter. Peter said he was going fishing, the others said they would come too, and they fished all night and caught nothing, until a stranger on the shore told them where to cast the net, and the stranger turned out to be Jesus (John 21:2–7). Thomas, who had once insisted on seeing for himself, was in the boat when the net came up too heavy to haul in. The last time Scripture names him is in Jerusalem a few weeks later. After Jesus was taken up into heaven, the eleven apostles went back to the upper room where they were staying and gave themselves to prayer, waiting for the Holy Spirit Jesus had promised, and Thomas is on the list (Acts 1:13). After that the New Testament falls silent about him.

(●) After c. 30 AD: Tradition sends him east, to Parthia and to India, and says he died there by a spear; the record is late, but the Christians of India have honored him as their founder for as long as they have a history. + What Thomas did after Pentecost, the Jewish harvest feast seven weeks after Passover on which the promised Holy Spirit came upon the disciples in Jerusalem, is known only from tradition, and the traditions are of two kinds. - Parthia. The earliest notice of a mission to Parthia comes from Origen, the great third-century teacher of Alexandria, as quoted by the historian Eusebius, the bishop of Caesarea who wrote the first history of the church early in the fourth century: according to tradition, Thomas received Parthia as his field of labor (Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 3.1.1). Parthia was the empire east of Rome, covering roughly modern Iran and Iraq. Eusebius also preserves the story, from records he says he found at Edessa, a Syriac-speaking city of upper Mesopotamia (today Urfa, in southeastern Turkey), that after the ascension "Judas, who was also called Thomas" sent the disciple Thaddaeus to heal and teach the king of Edessa (Ecclesiastical History 1.13). - India. The Acts of Thomas, a Syriac romance of the early third century, tells his story at length. (Syriac is the form of Aramaic spoken at Edessa and in the churches around it. A romance, in the ancient sense, is an adventure story, closer to a historical novel than to a history.) It tells of the apostles dividing the world by lot, of Thomas drawing India and not wanting to go, and of his being sold as a carpenter to a merchant serving an Indian king named Gundaphorus. It ends with his death by the spears of soldiers under another king. The book is full of legend, but one detail is not: coins and an inscription from the first century show that a king called Gondophares really did rule in the borderlands of what is now Pakistan and Afghanistan in the early decades after Christ. One older voice points the other way. Late in the second century Heracleon, a teacher of the Valentinian school, named Thomas, with Matthew, Philip and Levi, among those who died without making a martyr’s public confession. (The Valentinians followed the second-century teacher Valentinus and were one of the Gnostic sects, groups that held salvation comes through secret knowledge.) Heracleon meant that these men were never put on trial and killed for naming Christ before a judge; they did not die as martyrs. Clement of Alexandria quotes him without dissent (Stromata 4.9). It is the oldest surviving word on how Thomas’s life ended, and it does not fit the spear. Both stories are tradition, and neither can be checked. By the fourth century the India tradition was common across the church. Gregory of Nazianzus, the fourth-century bishop and theologian, could list Thomas with India as naturally as Paul with the Gentiles, the non-Jewish nations (Oration 33.11). The pilgrim Egeria, a woman from the far West who travelled to the holy places, prayed around AD 384 at his shrine in Edessa, where his bones were said to have been brought from the East. In Kerala, on the southwest coast of India, the Saint Thomas Christians trace their churches to his preaching. Their tradition says he landed in AD 52 and died near Mylapore, now part of Chennai, in AD 72. Those dates are the church’s convention, not a record, and the tradition cannot be proved. It cannot be lightly dismissed either: Roman ships traded with that coast in the first century, and when the Portuguese reached it, from 1498 on, they found an ancient Christian community already there, using Syriac in its worship and calling itself the Christians of Saint Thomas.

What His Words Taught

(T1) To follow Jesus is to go where he goes, even if the road leads to death. + Thomas left no letters and no sermons; the four short things he says in John’s Gospel are all we have of his voice. But each of them teaches something, and the first is about what a disciple is. A disciple, in the ancient world, was a student who attached himself to a teacher and walked behind him, literally, from town to town. Think of an apprentice who does not just learn the trade but lives in the master’s house. When Thomas heard that Jesus meant to go back toward Jerusalem, he drew the hard conclusion that following means following all the way: if the teacher walks into danger, the disciple walks in after him. Jesus had already said the same thing in plainer words: "If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me" (Matthew 16:24). Thomas, who never pretended to more hope than he had, said it as a man who thought the cross might be literal.

(Q) "Let us also go, that we may die with him." + Source: John 11:16 (English Standard Version). Thomas to his fellow disciples, when Jesus announced that he was going back to Bethany, near Jerusalem, to Lazarus.

(T2) The way to the Father is not a route to be found but a person to be known, Jesus himself. + Ask someone for directions and you expect a list: left at the church, straight past the school. Thomas expected a list too. If Jesus was going somewhere, there had to be a road, and he wanted to know which one. The answer Jesus gave turned the question inside out: "I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me" (John 14:6). The road to God is not a set of instructions Jesus hands over and then leaves behind. It is Jesus. To know him is to be on the way already, and to know the Father, as he went on to tell Philip a moment later (John 14:7–9). That sentence became one of the foundation stones of Christian belief, and it came into the world because one disciple was honest enough to say "we do not know." The church has always counted that in his favor.

(Q) "Lord, we do not know where you are going. How can we know the way?" + Source: John 14:5 (English Standard Version). Thomas at the Last Supper, after Jesus had told the disciples that they knew the way to where he was going (John 14:4).

(T3) The resurrection was a bodily event that could be seen and touched, and Jesus met the doubter with the very evidence he asked for. + Thomas’s demand is the most physical sentence in the Easter stories. He did not ask for a vision, a feeling, or a sign in the sky. He asked for nail holes he could put a finger into and a wound in the side he could put a hand into. Those were the marks of one particular death, the death of the man he had followed, and he wanted to know that the same body that had died was the one his friends said they had seen. That is exactly the point the Gospels insist on. Luke records Jesus telling the frightened disciples, "Touch me, and see. For a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have" (Luke 24:39). The resurrection the apostles preached was not a ghost, a memory, or a spiritual survival of the soul. It was the crucified body, raised and transformed but still bearing its wounds. Notice, too, how Jesus treated the doubter. He did not dismiss him or scold him into silence. He came back, and he offered Thomas the test Thomas had set. Honest doubt was met with evidence, and then asked to become faith: "Do not disbelieve, but believe" (John 20:27).

(Q) "Unless I see in his hands the mark of the nails, and place my finger into the mark of the nails, and place my hand into his side, I will never believe." + Source: John 20:25 (English Standard Version). Thomas’s reply when the other disciples told him, "We have seen the Lord."

(T4) The risen Jesus is Lord and God. + Thomas’s confession is five words in English and seven in Greek, and it is the summit John’s whole Gospel has been climbing toward. The book opens with "the Word was God" (John 1:1); it closes its main story with a disciple looking at Jesus and saying "my God." What the narrator announced in the first verse, a witness confesses at the end. Two words carry the weight. "Lord" (Kyrios in Greek) could be a polite title, like "sir," but in the Greek Old Testament, the translation Greek-speaking Jews read, it was also the word that stood for God’s own name. English Bibles still show the trace: where the Hebrew has the divine name, most of them print LORD in capitals. "God" (Theos) is not ambiguous at all. A devout Jew who believed that the Lord alone is God, and who would have recited that belief daily, addressed a man he had watched die and said both words to him. And Jesus did not correct him. He accepted the confession and blessed everyone who would come to make it after him. That is why the verse has been at the center of the church’s confession of Christ’s deity ever since. It is not a later theological conclusion read back into the story. It is the first response of a skeptic to the evidence.

(Q) "My Lord and my God!" + Source: John 20:28 (English Standard Version). Thomas’s answer when the risen Jesus, eight days after Easter, invited him to see his hands and touch his side.

(Q) "Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed." + Source: John 20:29 (English Standard Version). Jesus’ reply to Thomas’s confession, and his last words in John 20, just before the Gospel’s first closing summary. It reaches past the room to every later reader. John adds at once that he wrote his book for exactly those people, who will not see, so that they may believe (John 20:30–31). Thomas saw, and his seeing became part of the testimony on which everyone after him believes.

What the Church Made of Him

(†) The church fathers read his confession as a plain declaration that Jesus is God. + When fourth-century Christians argued over whether the Son is fully God, John 20:28 was one of the verses that would not go away. A disciple had called Jesus "my God" to his face, and Jesus had accepted it. Writers on the side of the Council of Nicaea (AD 325), the gathering of bishops that confessed the Son to be "of one substance" with the Father (sharing the one being of God, not a lesser copy of it), cited it again and again. Augustine, working through John’s Gospel in North Africa in the early fifth century, put the logic of the scene in a single line. Thomas saw and touched a man, Augustine said, and confessed the God whom he could neither see nor touch (Tractates on the Gospel of John 121.5). The visible body was the evidence; the invisible deity was the conclusion. That is how the church has read the verse ever since: not as an exclamation of surprise, but as a confession of faith.

(†) His doubt came to be counted as a gift to the church, evidence that the first witnesses were not credulous. + The church could easily have been embarrassed by Thomas. Instead it treasured him. Pope Gregory the Great, preaching on this Gospel in Rome around AD 591, went so far as to say that Thomas’s unbelief did more for our faith than the faith of the disciples who believed (Homilies on the Gospels 26.7). His reasoning was simple. Because Thomas doubted, and touched, and was convinced, every later believer has one more reason to know the resurrection was not wishful thinking. That reading has only grown stronger with time. Modern skeptics often suggest the disciples wanted so badly for Jesus to be alive that they persuaded themselves he was. Thomas is the Gospels’ own reply. Here was a man who had every reason to want it, and still refused to believe ten friends until he could check for himself. The phrase "doubting Thomas" entered the language as a gentle rebuke, but in the history of Christian thought it is closer to a compliment: he is the patron of the honest inquirer.

(†) The churches of the East remembered him as their apostle, and the Christians of India still bear his name. + In the West, Thomas is chiefly the man of John 20. In the East he is a founder. The Syriac-speaking church of Edessa, one of the earliest Christian centers in the East (the city ruled its own small kingdom on Rome’s eastern frontier until Rome absorbed it in the third century), kept his memory at the heart of its own. Ephrem the Syrian, its great fourth-century poet and teacher, wrote hymns honoring the apostle whose bones the city held (Hymns of Nisibis 42), and the shrine at Edessa drew pilgrims from as far as Spain or Gaul. Further east, the Saint Thomas Christians of Kerala have carried his name through nearly fifteen centuries of recorded history. Their liturgy, the set order of their worship, came to them in Syriac through the Church of the East, the great Christian communion of Persia and Central Asia, and they have always regarded themselves as the fruit of his preaching. Whatever the historian concludes about the voyage itself, the church that bears his name has kept the faith he confessed in that upper room, among Hindu neighbors and under several foreign powers, longer than most churches in Europe have existed. Thomas’s own record holds nothing to set against him beyond the one week of doubt that John himself recounts, and that week ended in the confession the church has repeated ever since.

Thomas wrote nothing that survives, and nothing early claims that he wrote anything. What the shelf holds instead is the record about him: four short scenes in John, his name on the lists of the Twelve, the traditions that grew up in the eastern churches from the third century on, and a cluster of later books that borrowed his name. The catalog below annotates each, and marks clearly which are witnesses and which are not his. The first-century witnesses - Matthew 10:3; Mark 3:18; Luke 6:15; Acts 1:13: The four lists of the Twelve. Thomas is on every one, and Acts places him in the upper room after the ascension. - John 11:16: On the way to Bethany, "Let us also go, that we may die with him" (T1). - John 14:5–7: At the Last Supper, "How can we know the way?" and Jesus’ answer, "I am the way, and the truth, and the life" (T2). - John 20:24–29: The refusal to believe without seeing the wounds, and eight days later the confession "My Lord and my God!" (T3, T4). - John 21:2: Thomas fishing with Peter and five others on the Sea of Tiberias when the risen Jesus appears on the shore. The early traditions - Heracleon, in Clement of Alexandria, Stromata 4.9: Late second century. The oldest notice of how Thomas’s life ended, and it does not match the later story. The Valentinian teacher Heracleon, quoted by Clement, named Thomas with Matthew, Philip and Levi among those who were saved without making the spoken confession of a martyr before they died. - Origen, Commentary on Genesis, Book 3, in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 3.1.1: Third century. The earliest notice of his mission: "according to tradition," Thomas received Parthia as his field of labor. - Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 1.13: Early fourth century. The Edessa records Eusebius says he translated from Syriac, in which "Judas, who was also called Thomas" sends Thaddaeus to King Abgar of Edessa after the ascension. - The Acts of Thomas: Early third century, probably written at Edessa in Syriac and surviving also in Greek. The romance of his lot falling on India, his sale as a carpenter to the merchant of King Gundaphorus, his preaching, and his martyrdom by spears. Legendary throughout and shaped by a strict teaching against marriage, but the oldest full account of the India tradition, and among the earliest sources to call him the twin of Jesus himself. - The Doctrine of Addai: A Syriac account of the founding of the church at Edessa, usually dated to about AD 400, expanding the Abgar story Eusebius knew and keeping Judas Thomas as the apostle who sent Addai (the Syriac name for Thaddaeus). - Ephrem the Syrian, Hymns of Nisibis 42: Fourth century. Hymns in honor of Thomas and his relics at Edessa. - Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 33.11: About AD 380. Names Thomas with India among the apostles’ mission fields. - Egeria, Travels 17.1 and 19.2: About AD 384. A pilgrim from the far West describes praying at the shrine of Thomas in Edessa, where his body was said to lie. - Socrates Scholasticus, Ecclesiastical History 4.18: Fifth century. Tells of the great church of Thomas at Edessa and the crowds that gathered there. - Gregory of Tours, Glory of the Martyrs 31: Late sixth century. Reports the translation (the formal moving) of his body to Edessa and a church and monastery at the place in India where he first lay. - Marco Polo, Travels: About AD 1293. Describes the tomb of Thomas on the Coromandel coast of India and the Christians who kept it. Attributed to him, but not his - The Gospel of Thomas: A collection of 114 sayings of Jesus, complete in a fourth-century Coptic manuscript found at Nag Hammadi in Egypt in 1945, with Greek fragments of three earlier copies among the Oxyrhynchus papyri. It opens by naming "Didymos Judas Thomas" as its writer, but the collection is generally dated to the second century, and many sayings carry a Gnostic outlook, the belief that salvation comes through secret knowledge. Eusebius listed it among the books put forward by heretics (Ecclesiastical History 3.25.6), and Cyril of Jerusalem warned that a Gospel of Thomas read in his day was the work of the Manichaeans (followers of Mani, a third-century Persian prophet), "not of one of the twelve Apostles" (Catechetical Lectures 4.36; 6.31). - The Infancy Gospel of Thomas: Probably second century. Stories of the boy Jesus working wonders, some of them unsettling, between the ages of five and twelve. The name "Thomas" was attached to it later. - The Book of Thomas the Contender: A Nag Hammadi dialogue in which the risen Jesus teaches Thomas on self-knowledge and the body. Third century, and not his. - The Apocalypse of Thomas: A Latin revelation of the signs of the end of the world, probably from about the fifth century, condemned with the other apocrypha in the Gelasian Decree, a sixth-century Latin list of approved and rejected books. Standard editions and further reading: the Gospels in Nestle-Aland, 28th edition; in English the ESV, the translation quoted throughout. The traditions and the apocryphal books in M. R. James, The Apocryphal New Testament (Oxford, 1924), in the public domain, and J. K. Elliott, The Apocryphal New Testament (Oxford, 1993). Eusebius in the A. C. McGiffert translation (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, volume 1). On the India tradition, A. E. Medlycott, India and the Apostle Thomas (London, 1905).

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief