Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Classical Greece

600 BC – 300 BC

Hippocrates of Cos c. 460 – c. 370 BC

(●) The Greek physician who taught medicine to look for natural causes, and whose oath has shaped the conscience of doctors for two thousand years. + Somewhere today a class of new doctors is standing in a lecture hall, right hands raised, reciting a promise that begins with their name and ends with their duty. Most of them call it the Hippocratic Oath, and most of them are saying a modern rewrite. But the name on it belongs to a real man, a physician from the small Aegean island of Cos who was born around the time Socrates was a boy, and whose reputation was already enormous while he was still alive. Plato mentions him twice, as the example of what a physician is. A Christian has two good reasons to get to know him. The first is that the medical writings gathered under his name are among the earliest sustained attempts in the West to explain illness by causes inside the world, rather than by the anger of a god or the curse of a neighbor. That is a habit of mind Christians share: the God of Scripture made a world with an order of its own, and studying that order is no insult to him. The second is the Oath. Its refusal to give a deadly drug or to cause an abortion lined up so closely with what the early church already taught that Christians kept it, rewrote its first line, and carried it through the Middle Ages and into the modern hospital. One fact to hold onto from the start: we cannot be sure that Hippocrates wrote a single one of the sixty or so books that carry his name. The collection, called the Hippocratic Corpus (corpus is simply Latin for "body," a body of writings), is the work of many hands across more than a century. Even his dates are conventions. His birth year comes from a late ancient biography, and his death year is the birth year plus the roughly ninety years the traditions give him. What survives is a famous name, a few early witnesses, and a library that grew up around both.

(●) c. 460 BC: Born on Cos into a family of physicians who traced their line back to Asclepius. + Cos is a long, narrow island off the southwest coast of what is now Turkey, a day’s sail from the mainland. Hippocrates was born there around 460 BC. The date comes from the fullest ancient life of him, which goes under the name of Soranus, a physician of the Roman era, and which places the birth in the first year of the eightieth Olympiad (the Greeks counted years by the four-yearly games at Olympia). Like most ancient dates for people who were not kings, it is a convention rather than a record. Another ancient writer, Aulus Gellius, thought him older than Socrates, which would push the birth earlier still. His father, Heraclides, was a physician, and the family belonged to the Asclepiads, the "sons of Asclepius." Asclepius was the Greek hero and god of healing, and medical families who claimed descent from him handed the craft down from father to son, rather like a family firm that still has the founder’s name over the door. Plato calls Hippocrates "the Asclepiad" as if it were his job title. Older books imagined the Asclepiads as temple priests who healed by dreams and offerings; the scholars who edited the corpus a century ago rejected that picture. The Asclepiads were working physicians, most likely a hereditary clan that grew into something like a guild by adopting outside pupils, though the evidence for how they were organized is thin.

(●) c. 440 BC: Trained by his father, he took medicine on the road and wrote down what he saw at the bedside. + The ancient lives name two teachers: his own father, and Herodicus, a trainer who believed that exercise and diet could treat illness. Later stories add the orator Gorgias and the philosopher Democritus, but those are the kind of connections biographers like to draw between famous men, and they cannot be checked. (The date of c. 440 BC is only an estimate of when a physician born around 460 would have begun to practise.) What we can see is the life of a Greek doctor in his day. Physicians were travelers. They moved from town to town, set up in a borrowed room or a public building, and were judged on results. The Epidemics, a set of notebooks in the corpus, record cases from Thasos, Abdera, Larissa, Cyzicus, and other towns of the northern Aegean. Whether or not Hippocrates kept these notes himself, they show the method his name came to stand for. The first case reads: "Philiscus lived by the wall. He took to his bed with acute fever on the first day and sweating." Then, day by day, the fever, the urine, the sleepless nights, until "about mid-day on the sixth day the patient died." Of the forty-two cases in the first and third books, twenty-five end in death, and the writer records each one without excuse.

(●) c. 433 BC: He was already the physician Athenians named when they meant the best, and he taught pupils for a fee. + Plato’s dialogue the Protagoras opens before dawn, in a conversation set around 433 BC. A young man, who happens also to be named Hippocrates, bursts into Socrates’ house wanting to study with a famous visiting teacher. Socrates slows him down with a question: if you went to your namesake, "Hippocrates of Cos, the Asclepiad," and paid him a fee, what would you expect to become? A physician, the young man answers (311b–c). Plato wrote the dialogue some decades later, but he chose the name because every reader would know it: Hippocrates was the obvious example of a man who taught medicine for money and made doctors. In the Phaedrus (270c) Plato goes further and credits him with a method: you cannot understand the body without understanding the nature of the whole. A generation later Aristotle, in his Politics (VII.4, 1326a), uses him as the natural example of greatness in a craft: we would call Hippocrates great, he says, as a physician rather than for his size. These few lines are almost all we have from people who lived near his own time. They are enough to show that he was real, famous, and a teacher.

(●) 430 BC: When plague struck Athens, later legend sent him to stop it, though the eyewitness never names him. + In the second year of the war between Athens and Sparta, a plague swept the crowded city. The historian Thucydides caught it, survived, and described it with a physician’s eye. He also says plainly that the doctors could do nothing: they died fastest of all, since they came most often into contact with the sick (2.47). Centuries later, the legend of Hippocrates told a different story. He came to Athens, lit great fires in the streets to purify the air, and stopped the plague. Other tales attached to him over time: that he cured the young king Perdiccas of Macedon of a sickness that turned out to be lovesickness; that the Persian king Artaxerxes offered him a fortune and he refused to serve an enemy of Greece; that the people of Abdera summoned him to cure their philosopher Democritus of madness, and he found Democritus the sanest man in town. Most of these come from a set of Letters and speeches written long after his death and transmitted with the corpus. They tell us what later Greeks admired in a physician (patriotism, incorruptibility, good sense) more than what Hippocrates did. The plague story in particular runs straight against Thucydides, who was there.

(●) c. 400 BC: His sons Thessalus and Draco and his son-in-law Polybus carried on his teaching. + A school is people before it is buildings. The ancient tradition says Hippocrates trained his two sons, Thessalus and Draco, and that his pupil Polybus married his daughter and carried the work forward. Aristotle quotes a passage now found in the corpus treatise Nature of Man and names its author as Polybus, not Hippocrates (History of Animals III.3). That one citation is a small window into how the collection grew: the master taught, the family and students wrote, and in time everything came to be filed under the most famous name. The grand sanctuary of Asclepius that visitors see on Cos today, with its terraces climbing the hillside, was built mostly after his death. In his own lifetime, medicine on Cos was a matter of a family, its pupils, and the sick who came to their door.

(●) c. 370 BC: He died an old man at Larissa in Thessaly, and his name outgrew everything he wrote. + The ancient lives agree that he died at Larissa, in the plain of Thessaly in northern Greece, and that he was very old. They do not agree on how old: 85, 90, 104, and 109 are all reported. The conventional death date of about 370 BC is reached by adding the commonest figure to the conventional birth date, so it is no firmer than either. Soranus adds a story that bees made honey in his tomb, and that nurses used it to treat sores in the mouths of babies. It is a tradition, but a fitting one: even in death, the story goes, he was still helping the sick. About a century after he died, scholars at the great library of Alexandria in Egypt gathered every medical book they could find that was linked to the school of Cos, and many that were not, into one collection under his name. By the second century AD, Galen of Pergamum, the most celebrated physician of the Roman Empire, had made "Hippocrates" the ideal doctor whom every later doctor should imitate. The man himself had become a symbol, and the symbol has never retired.

What He Taught

(T1) Every disease has a natural cause, and charms and purifications do not cure it. + Imagine a child at the market who suddenly falls, stiffens, and shakes, foam at the mouth, and then lies still and wakes up confused. In ancient Greece that sight was terrifying. People called epilepsy "the sacred disease," because it looked like a god had seized the body, and they sent for men who sold purifications, incantations, and lists of forbidden foods. The corpus treatise The Sacred Disease is one of the boldest pieces of writing in ancient medicine. Its author argues that epilepsy is no more divine than any other illness. It has a natural cause (he locates it in the brain), and the healers who call it sacred are hiding their ignorance behind religion, so that if the patient recovers they get the credit, and if he dies the gods get the blame. He even turns their piety against them: if a man can drive the disease out by magic, he could bring it on by magic too, and then it is a human work, not a divine one. Christians have every reason to welcome the core of this. The God of Scripture made a world that runs by an order he gave it, and finding the cause of a fever is not a rival explanation to God any more than finding the cause of the rain is. The author himself does not throw the gods out; he ends by calling all diseases "divine and all human" alike, because the weather and the seasons that cause them are divine. Where he places the divine in nature itself, Christians would part ways, because for them the winds and the seasons are things God made, not gods. But his attack on the charlatan who profits from fear is one Scripture would applaud.

(Q) "I am about to discuss the disease called 'sacred.' It is not, in my opinion, any more divine or more sacred than other diseases, but has a natural cause, and its supposed divine origin is due to men's inexperience, and to their wonder at its peculiar character." + Source: Hippocratic Corpus, The Sacred Disease 1 (W. H. S. Jones translation, Loeb Classical Library, 1923). These are the treatise’s opening words, and the author wastes no time getting to his point. Whether Hippocrates himself wrote them is unknown, but they have been read as the voice of his school since antiquity.

(T2) Medicine is learned at the bedside, by watching, recording, and foretelling the course of a disease. + Think of a good mechanic who listens to your engine for a minute and tells you not only what is wrong but what it will sound like next week if you leave it. Hippocratic medicine prized that skill above almost everything else. The Greeks called it prognosis, "knowing beforehand": from what the patient has been through and how he looks today, a good physician could say how the illness would run. A treatise called the Prognostic teaches exactly that, beginning with the face of the dying patient (sharp nose, hollow eyes, cold ears), a description doctors still call the "Hippocratic face." Prognosis was partly about trust. A traveling doctor who could tell the family what would happen before it happened earned the right to be believed about treatment. But it also expressed a conviction about how knowledge is gained: by patient observation of many cases, not by deducing medicine from a philosopher’s theory. The treatise Ancient Medicine says so outright, complaining about writers who build medicine on a single assumption such as hot and cold, and naming the philosopher Empedocles as an example of the kind of theorizing that, he says, has no more to do with medicine than with painting. From this bedside discipline comes the most famous line ever attached to his name. The Latin motto primum non nocere, "first, do no harm," is a much later coinage and appears nowhere in the corpus. What the Epidemics actually says is gentler and more practical: in treating disease, make a habit "to help, or at least to do no harm."

(Q) "Declare the past, diagnose the present, foretell the future; practise these acts." + Source: Hippocratic Corpus, Epidemics I, 11 (W. H. S. Jones translation, Loeb Classical Library, 1923). The sentence that follows contains the advice "to help, or at least to do no harm," and the passage closes by naming the three parties to every illness: the disease, the patient, and the physician, who is "the servant of the art."

(T3) Health is a balance in the body, and the physician’s work is to help nature restore it. + Anyone who has had a cold knows the pattern: a few miserable days, a turn, and then the body sorts itself out. The Hippocratic writers built a whole approach to medicine on that ordinary experience. They believed the body has its own power to heal, and that the physician is less a master of the disease than an assistant to the patient’s nature. To explain what health is, the treatise Nature of Man taught that the body contains four fluids, or humors: blood, phlegm, yellow bile, and black bile. When they are blended in the right proportion, a person is healthy; when one is in excess or out of place, he is sick. The theory was wrong in its details, and modern medicine has left it behind. But the instinct behind it, that health is a kind of balance and that diet, exercise, sleep, and surroundings all shape it, is still the first thing a sensible doctor asks about. The treatise Airs, Waters, Places told the traveling physician to study a new town before he treated anyone in it: which way it faced, what winds it caught, what water it drank, how its people lived. So the main tools were modest. Change the diet; prescribe rest or exercise; let the fever run its course and watch for the crisis, the turning point when the disease breaks one way or the other. Surgery and drugs came in when they had to. The Hippocratic doctor’s first virtue was knowing when to wait.

(Q) "Life is short, and the Art long; the occasion fleeting; experience fallacious, and judgment difficult. The physician must not only be prepared to do what is right himself, but also to make the patient, the attendants, and externals co-operate." + Source: Hippocratic Corpus, Aphorisms I, 1 (Francis Adams translation, The Genuine Works of Hippocrates, 1849). This is the first of more than four hundred short medical sayings, and it sets the tone for all of them. Its opening words became a proverb in Latin, ars longa, vita brevis, and are quoted today by people who have never heard of the rest of the book.

(T4) A physician is bound by oath never to kill, never to abuse a patient, and never to betray a secret. + A doctor is let into the most private rooms of a house, sees people at their weakest, and holds in his hands the means to heal or to kill. Every society has had to ask what keeps such a person honest. The Hippocratic answer was an oath. The Oath has two halves. The first is a contract of apprenticeship: the student promises to treat his teacher like a father, share his money with him if he is in need, and teach the teacher’s sons without fee. The second is a code of conduct, and it is remarkable. The physician will treat the sick only to help them. He will not give a poison to anyone who asks for it, nor suggest it. He will not give a woman a pessary (a medicated plug inserted into the body, a common means of causing abortion in that day) to end a pregnancy. He will leave cutting for stone (the dangerous operation to remove a stone from the bladder) to the specialists. In every house he enters he will abstain from wrong and from sexual abuse of anyone in it, "bond or free," and whatever he sees or hears that should not be spread abroad, he will keep as a holy secret. Nobody knows who wrote the Oath, or how widely it was sworn in the ancient world; it may have bound only one circle of physicians. Its strictness on poison and abortion went beyond what Greek law or common practice required. That is precisely why the church would find in it a friend.

(Q) "Neither will I administer a poison to anybody when asked to do so, nor will I suggest such a course. Similarly I will not give to a woman a pessary to cause abortion. But I will keep pure and holy both my life and my art." + Source: Hippocratic Corpus, The Oath (W. H. S. Jones translation, Loeb Classical Library, 1923). These lines are the heart of the code of conduct. Like the rest of the Oath, they were sworn "by Apollo Physician, by Asclepius, by Health, by Panacea and by all the gods and goddesses."

(Q) "Sometimes give your services for nothing, calling to mind a previous benefaction or present satisfaction. And if there be an opportunity of serving one who is a stranger in financial straits, give full assistance to all such. For where there is love of man, there is also love of the art." + Source: Hippocratic Corpus, Precepts 6 (W. H. S. Jones translation, Loeb Classical Library, 1923). Precepts is one of the latest works in the collection, written long after Hippocrates, but it gives the tradition’s ideal of the physician: generous to the poor and the stranger, and moved by love of people as much as by love of the craft. Christians would take that ideal further than its authors ever imagined, all the way to hospitals that took in anyone who came.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) The church kept his oath, struck out the pagan gods, and swore it to Christ. + The first Christians did not need a Greek oath to tell them not to kill. The Didache, a short church manual from around the end of the first century, already forbids killing a child by abortion or after birth (2.2), and writers like Tertullian, the North African Christian writer of around AD 200, treated both as murder. When they met the Hippocratic Oath, they found a pagan text that had arrived, on its own road, at the same place. That agreement mattered: it showed that the Christian rule was not an arbitrary sectarian taboo but something conscience could see. Jerome, the great Bible translator of the fourth century, pointed to the Oath when he wrote to a young priest about how to behave in the homes of his people: Hippocrates, he said, made his pupils swear an oath before he would teach them, binding them to silence and prescribing their speech, gait, dress, and manners. How much more, then, should those to whom "the medicine of the soul" is committed love the houses of all Christians as their own homes, and keep what they see there to themselves (Letter 52.15). In time the Oath itself was baptized. A Byzantine manuscript (one copied in the Greek-speaking Christian empire ruled from Constantinople), now in the Vatican Library under the shelf mark Urbinas graecus 64, preserves a version titled "From the oath of Hippocrates, insofar as a Christian may swear it," written out on the leaf in the shape of a cross. The appeal to Apollo and Asclepius is gone; in its place the physician blesses God the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, and the promises against poison and abortion stay. Copied and adapted like this, the Oath came through the Middle Ages, and the substance of its code shaped the doctor’s idea of his calling for centuries.

(†) Christians honored medicine as a gift of God, and built hospitals that took in anyone. + Some early believers wondered whether a Christian should see a doctor at all, or simply pray. The church’s answer was both. Paul had a physician among his companions, "Luke the beloved physician" (Colossians 4:14), and advised Timothy to take a little wine for his stomach (1 Timothy 5:23). Basil of Caesarea, one of the great bishops of the fourth century, devoted a section of his monastic rules to the question and answered that the medical art is God’s gift, to be used with thanksgiving and without putting our hope in it rather than in him. Basil then did something no Hippocratic physician had done. Outside Caesarea, around AD 370, he built a complex to house and treat the sick, the poor, and travelers, with physicians and nurses on staff. His friend Gregory of Nazianzus called it "the new city," a place "where disease is regarded in a religious light" (Oration 43.63). Hospitals of this kind spread through the Christian East and then the West. They used Hippocratic medicine, as filtered through Galen, because it was the best medicine there was, but they put it in the service of a different love: Jesus had said that those who visit the sick visit him (Matthew 25:36). The same Greek and Syriac Christian copyists (Syriac is the form of Aramaic spoken by the churches of Syria and Mesopotamia) who kept the church’s books also kept the Hippocratic books, and through them the corpus reached the physicians of Baghdad and, later, the universities of Europe. Much of what survives of Hippocrates survives because the church thought healing was holy work.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with the Hippocratic writings: the gods of the oath, nature as divine, and the hopeless case. + The Christian welcome was real, but it was not uncritical. At three points the writings under his name and the gospel go different ways. - The gods of the oath. The Oath is sworn "by Apollo Physician, by Asclepius, by Health, by Panacea and by all the gods and goddesses." A Christian could not swear it as written, because "You shall have no other gods before me" (Exodus 20:3). That is why the Christian version replaced its opening rather than quoting it. - Nature as divine. The Sacred Disease is right that epilepsy is no more divine than a fever, but its reason is that all diseases are "divine and all human," because the cold, the sun, and the winds that cause them are themselves divine. Scripture draws the line elsewhere. The winds and the seasons are creatures, not gods, and the God who made them stands above them, works through them, and is free to act beyond them. That is why Christians could study disease as part of nature and still pray for the sick. - The hopeless case. The treatise The Art defines medicine as relieving the sick, lessening the violence of their diseases, and refusing "to treat those who are overmastered by their diseases, realizing that in such cases medicine is powerless" (3). There was honesty in that: a physician should not take money for a cure he cannot give. But the gospel would not let the dying be sent away. Jesus said, "Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick" (Mark 2:17), and the Samaritan in his parable bound up the wounds of a stranger and paid for his care (Luke 10:34–35). Christian hospitals took in the incurable as well as the curable, because the patient was a neighbor before he was a case. The Hippocratic tradition taught the West to look for causes, to tell the truth about outcomes, and to bind the healer by conscience. The gospel added what it could not supply: a reason to stay at the bedside when there was nothing left to try.

Hippocrates is "a name without writings," in the phrase of the German scholar Wilamowitz. Some sixty to seventy treatises survive under his name, written in the Ionic dialect of Greek (the Greek of Ionia on the eastern Aegean coast, and the usual language of early Greek science, though Cos itself spoke Doric) by many authors, most of them between about 430 and 350 BC, with a few much later. They were gathered into one collection at Alexandria in the third century BC. Which of them, if any, he wrote himself is unknown: the "Hippocratic question" has been argued since antiquity. Ancient critics most often counted among his own works the Prognostic, the Aphorisms, the Epidemics I and III, Regimen in Acute Diseases, Airs, Waters, Places, and the surgical treatises on fractures, joints, and head wounds. Grouped by subject, the collection runs as follows. The physician and his calling: - The Oath: The physician’s promise to his teacher and his patients: no poison, no abortion, no abuse, no betrayed secrets (T4). The most influential ethical text in the history of medicine. - Law: A short piece comparing the training of a physician to the growing of a crop: natural ability is the soil, teaching the seed, and long study the cultivation. - The Physician: Practical advice on the doctor’s appearance, manner, and surgery: he should look healthy, be clean, and keep his instruments in order. - Decorum: On the bearing of a physician at the bedside, combining philosophy and medicine. A later work, probably of the Hellenistic age (the three centuries after Alexander the Great). - Precepts: Late advice on fees, consultations, and kindness, including the line that "where there is love of man, there is also love of the art" (quoted after T4). - The Art: A speech defending medicine against critics who said patients recover by luck. It defines medicine as relief of suffering and refusal of hopeless cases, the point where the gospel would part company with it. Method and the nature of health: - Ancient Medicine: An argument that medicine is a craft discovered by long observation, not a branch of philosophy built on hot, cold, wet, and dry (T2). - Airs, Waters, Places: How climate, water, and situation shape health and character; a guide for the physician arriving in a strange town (T3). - Nature of Man: The classic statement of the four humors: blood, phlegm, yellow bile, black bile (T3). Aristotle attributes part of it to Polybus. - Regimen in Health: Advice on diet and exercise by season and constitution; transmitted as the close of Nature of Man. - Breaths: A rhetorical treatise arguing that air is the cause of all disease. - Regimen I–III: The longest ancient work on diet and exercise, built on a theory of fire and water in the body. - Regimen IV, or Dreams: How dreams can signal the state of the body, and what to do about them. - Humours: Notes on the fluids of the body and how to read them. - Nutriment: Oracular sayings in the riddling style of Heraclitus, the philosopher of Ephesus, on food and nourishment. Later than most of the corpus. - Places in Man: A survey of the body’s parts and the diseases of each, with a strong view of medicine as a finished science. - Use of Liquids: On bathing and the uses of water, vinegar, and wine in treatment. Observation and prognosis: - Prognostic: How to foretell the course of an acute disease from the patient’s face, breathing, sleep, and excretions; source of the "Hippocratic face" (T2). - Epidemics I–VII: Physicians’ notebooks of weather, outbreaks, and day-by-day case histories from northern Greece (T2). Books I and III are the most polished and the most often credited to Hippocrates. - Aphorisms: Over four hundred short sayings on medicine, beginning "Life is short, and the Art long" (T3). Among the most copied medical books of the Middle Ages. - Prorrhetic I and II: Predictions; the first a collection of signs, the second an essay warning physicians against showy forecasts. - Coan Prenotions: A large compilation of prognostic signs, overlapping heavily with the Prognostic and Prorrhetic I. - Crises and Critical Days: Compilations on the days when fevers turn. - Sevens (On Hebdomads): A speculative work organizing the world and the body by the number seven; survives mainly in Latin. Diseases and their treatment: - The Sacred Disease: Epilepsy has a natural cause in the brain, and its purifiers are frauds (T1). - Regimen in Acute Diseases: On barley gruel, drinks, and baths for fevers, with sharp criticism of the rival doctors of Cnidus, a medical town on the mainland across the water from Cos; an Appendix of later notes is transmitted with it. - Diseases I–IV: Descriptions and treatments of many illnesses; the fourth book belongs with the treatises on generation. - Affections: A handbook of treatment written for laymen, so that they could talk sensibly with their doctors. - Internal Affections: Detailed accounts of diseases of the lungs, liver, kidneys, and other organs, with their remedies. - Sight: A short treatise on eye diseases and their treatment. Surgery: - Wounds in the Head: On skull injuries and when to trephine (to cut a small disc of bone from the skull). - In the Surgery: How to arrange the operating room, light, and bandages. - Fractures and Joints: Two masterly works on setting bones and reducing dislocations, among the best writings in the collection. - Instruments of Reduction (Mochlicon): A summary of Fractures and Joints. - Ulcers, Fistulas, Haemorrhoids: Short treatises on wounds and on minor surgery. Women, conception, and children: - Seed and Nature of the Child: One continuous work on conception and the growth of the embryo, including a famous observation of a six-day embryo. - Diseases of Women I and II, Barrenness, Nature of Women: The largest body of ancient writing on women’s health and childbirth. - Diseases of Young Girls: A short piece on illness at the onset of womanhood. - Superfetation: On a second conception during pregnancy, and on difficult births. - Eight Months’ Child and Seven Months’ Child: On which premature births survive. - Excision of the Fetus: On removing a dead fetus in obstructed labor. - Dentition: Aphorisms on teething in infants. Anatomy: - Anatomy, Heart, Fleshes, Glands, Nature of Bones: Short treatises on the body’s structure, some of them late. Heart describes the heart’s valves. Later writings transmitted with the corpus, not by Hippocrates: the Letters (the Artaxerxes and Democritus stories), the Decree of the Athenians honoring him, the Speech at the Altar, and the Embassy of his son Thessalus. All are generally dated centuries after his death, and they are the main source of the legends (430 BC). Ancient lives: Soranus, Life of Hippocrates (Roman era); the entry in the Byzantine encyclopedia called the Suda; and the verses of the twelfth-century scholar John Tzetzes. Editions: Émile Littré, Œuvres complètes d’Hippocrate, ten volumes (1839–1861), the first complete critical edition (a Greek text rebuilt by comparing the surviving manuscripts). The Loeb Classical Library Hippocrates (W. H. S. Jones, E. T. Withington, Paul Potter, Wesley D. Smith; eleven volumes, 1923–2018) gives Greek and English. Francis Adams, The Genuine Works of Hippocrates (1849), and the first two Loeb volumes by Jones (1923) are in the public domain and free online. A good single-volume selection is G. E. R. Lloyd, ed., Hippocratic Writings (Penguin, 1978).

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief