Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Jesus & the Apostles

5 BC – 100 AD

Caiaphas the High Priest fl. c. 18 – 36 AD

(●) The high priest who held Jerusalem steady under Rome for eighteen years, and who judged that Jesus must die so the nation could live. + Every Good Friday, somewhere in the reading of the Passion (the Gospels’ account of Jesus’ arrest, trial, and death), a congregation hears his name: Caiaphas, the high priest, in whose house Jesus stood bound in the middle of the night. He is not a villain from a morality play. He was a capable, cautious man with a hard job, the chief priest of the Jerusalem temple at a time when the Romans could appoint and dismiss high priests as easily as a company replaces a manager. Most men who held the office in his century lasted a year or two. Caiaphas lasted about eighteen, longer than any other high priest of that century, and that fact alone says a great deal about how carefully he walked. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. The first is that he is the man who set in motion the trial at the center of the Gospels, and the words John records from him, that it was better for one man to die for the people than for the whole nation to perish, are among the most remembered sentences in the whole Passion story. The second is that he is one of the best-attested people in the whole story. Josephus, the Jewish historian of the first century, names him twice. And in 1990, workmen building a park south of Jerusalem broke into a family tomb that held an ornate limestone bone box inscribed, most scholars agree, with his name. His dates come from Josephus rather than from any record of his birth or death, which no source gives. He was appointed high priest around AD 18 (the year is worked out from Josephus’ sequence of appointments, not stated by him) and removed in AD 36 or 37, depending on which Passover the Roman legate Vitellius visited Jerusalem. (A legate was an emperor’s appointed deputy over a province; Vitellius governed Syria, the great province to the north, and its governor was senior enough to step in over Judea’s, as Vitellius did.) That is why the title says "fl.", short for the Latin floruit, "he flourished": the range marks the years he is known to have held office, nothing more. It is the label a historian puts on a man whose working life can be dated but whose cradle and grave cannot.

(●) c. 18 AD: The Roman governor made Joseph Caiaphas high priest, after three men in a row had lasted about a year each. + His given name was Joseph; Caiaphas was a family name or nickname, and Josephus calls him "Joseph, who was also called Caiaphas." He came from a priestly family, and he had married into the most powerful priestly house of the age: John tells us he was the son-in-law of Annas (John 18:13), who had been high priest from AD 6 until a Roman governor removed him in AD 15. Five of Annas’ sons would later hold the office too, which Josephus thought had never happened to any other high priest. The high priest was the most important Jew in the land. He presided over the temple, the one place on earth where Israel offered sacrifice to God, and once a year, on the Day of Atonement, he alone went behind the curtain into the innermost room, the Holy of Holies, to make atonement for the whole people (Leviticus 16). He also presided over the council, the Sanhedrin, the ruling body of priests and elders that governed Jewish affairs in Jerusalem under Rome. But by Caiaphas’ day the office was in Roman hands. The governor Valerius Gratus, who arrived in AD 15, deposed Annas, then appointed and removed three men in quick succession, each lasting about a year, before he settled on Caiaphas. The Romans even kept the high priest’s sacred vestments locked in their fortress beside the temple, handing them out only for the festivals. A high priest wore his robes, quite literally, at Rome’s pleasure.

(●) 26 AD: Pontius Pilate arrived as governor, and for ten years the two men kept an uneasy peace together. + Gratus went home after eleven years and Pilate came in his place. Pilate had a gift for provoking the Jews of Jerusalem. Josephus tells of military standards, the tall poles Roman soldiers marched behind, carrying the emperor’s image and brought into the city by night, in a land whose law forbade such images. He also tells of sacred money from the temple treasury spent on an aqueduct. Either one could have set the city alight, and Caiaphas had to live with both. Yet Pilate never removed Caiaphas, and Caiaphas never lost the office while Pilate held his. Think of two department heads who do not much like each other but have learned that each keeps his job only as long as the building stays quiet. That is very likely what eighteen years in office meant. Luke, dating the start of John the Baptist’s preaching the way a historian would, by the rulers of the day, names "the high priesthood of Annas and Caiaphas" (Luke 3:2). Only one man held the title at a time, but Luke’s pairing tells the truth about how things worked: the father-in-law still carried enormous weight behind the son-in-law’s office, which is why, on the night of the arrest, Jesus was taken to Annas first (John 18:13).

(●) c. 30 AD: After Lazarus was raised, Caiaphas told the council that one man should die for the people. + The year is the conventional one; many scholars prefer AD 33, and the Gospels themselves give no year. What John gives is the moment. Jesus had raised Lazarus at Bethany, a village less than two miles from Jerusalem, and crowds were going over to him. The chief priests and the Pharisees (a mostly lay movement of teachers devoted to keeping the law of Moses down to its smallest detail, and usually no friends of the priestly aristocracy) gathered the council in alarm. Their fear was political: if this went on, everyone would believe in him, "and the Romans will come and take away both our place and our nation" (John 11:48). "Our place" most likely means the temple itself. You can almost hear the room: frightened men talking over one another, each with a worry and none with an answer. Caiaphas cut through their hand-wringing with a blunt rebuke and a plan (T1). From that day, John says, they made plans to put Jesus to death (John 11:53). Matthew adds a scene in the high priest’s own palace, where the chief priests and elders plotted to arrest Jesus by stealth, and a practical worry worthy of a man who knew crowds: "Not during the feast, lest there be an uproar among the people" (Matthew 26:5). The feast was Passover, when pilgrims packed Jerusalem to several times its usual size, and every one of them remembered that Passover celebrated Israel’s escape from a foreign king. In the end Judas offered them a quiet arrest at night, and they took it.

(●) c. 30 AD: He questioned Jesus at night, tore his robes at the answer, and sent him to Pilate at dawn. + The arrest came in an olive grove across the Kidron valley. Jesus was taken first to Annas, then sent bound to Caiaphas, where the scribes and elders had gathered (John 18:24; Matthew 26:57). Outside, in the courtyard, Peter warmed himself by a fire and denied knowing him. Inside, the hearing went badly for the prosecution. Witness after witness came forward and their stories would not agree; the best they could manage was a garbled report that Jesus had threatened to destroy the temple and rebuild it in three days. Jesus said nothing. So Caiaphas did what a skilled examiner does when the evidence collapses: he put the accused on oath and asked him directly whether he was the Christ (T2). "Christ" is the Greek word for the Hebrew "Messiah," the Anointed One, the promised king Israel had been waiting for; the question was whether this bound prisoner claimed to be that king. Jesus answered, and Caiaphas tore his robes and called it blasphemy, an insult to God himself, and the council agreed that he deserved death (Matthew 26:59–66; Mark 14:55–64). The council could condemn, but under Rome it could not carry out an execution on its own authority, so early in the morning they led Jesus from the house of Caiaphas to the governor’s headquarters (John 18:28). The charge laid before Pilate was a political one, a man claiming to be a king. By the afternoon Jesus was dead on a Roman cross.

(●) c. 30 to 36 AD: The apostles kept preaching in Jesus’ name, and the high priest’s council kept summoning them. + Caiaphas must have hoped the matter was closed. It was not. Within weeks the followers of the crucified man were standing in the temple courts, the high priest’s own ground, announcing that God had raised him from the dead. When Peter and John healed a lame man at the temple gate, the rulers had them arrested, and Luke lists who sat in judgment: "Annas the high priest and Caiaphas and John and Alexander, and all who were of the high-priestly family" (Acts 4:6). Luke gives Annas the title out of respect for the old man’s standing, as people still call a retired judge "Judge." In the chapters that follow, Acts calls the presiding officer simply "the high priest": the one who had the apostles jailed (Acts 5:17), who interrogated Stephen before his stoning (Acts 7:1), and who gave the young Pharisee Saul letters to arrest believers in Damascus (Acts 9:1–2). Acts never names him in those scenes, but by Josephus’ reckoning Caiaphas held the office until 36 or 37, so these were very probably his decisions too. Luke records that the council was persuaded at one point to let the apostles go with a beating, on the advice of the respected teacher Gamaliel (Acts 5:34–40). He also records that "a great many of the priests became obedient to the faith" (Acts 6:7), men who served in the temple Caiaphas ran.

(●) 36 or 37 AD: Soon after Pilate was sent to Rome, the Roman legate removed Caiaphas, and he passes out of the record. + The partnership ended the way it had lasted, together. In the winter of 36/37 Pilate was ordered to Rome to answer for a massacre of Samaritans, by Lucius Vitellius, the governor of Syria and the senior Roman official in the East. Vitellius then came up to Jerusalem at Passover, was received with great ceremony, handed the high priest’s vestments back into the priests’ own keeping, and, as Josephus puts it in the same breath, "deprived Joseph, who was also called Caiaphas, of the high priesthood." His replacement was Jonathan, one of Annas’ sons. After that, silence. No ancient source records what Caiaphas did in retirement, how long he lived, or how he died. He simply steps off the stage, a man whose eighteen years of careful management are remembered almost entirely for one night.

(●) 1990 AD: Builders south of Jerusalem broke into a family tomb holding a bone box inscribed with his name. + In November 1990 a work crew building a water park in the Peace Forest, in the North Talpiot district of southern Jerusalem, collapsed the roof of a burial cave. Inside, the archaeologist Zvi Greenhut of the Israel Antiquities Authority found a dozen ossuaries. An ossuary is a limestone box about the size of a child’s toy chest; Jewish families of Jesus’ time laid their dead in a tomb niche, and a year later gathered the bones into such a box. One of these boxes was richly carved with rosettes, and scratched on it twice in Aramaic, the everyday language of Jews in the land, was a name: Yehosef bar Qayafa, "Joseph son of Caiaphas." Inside were the bones of six people, among them a man of about sixty. Most scholars identify him as the high priest: the name Joseph with the rare family name Caiaphas matches Josephus exactly, and the box is the finest in the tomb. Some have doubted it, pointing to the missing priestly title and to a second, shorter spelling of the name, and the identification is a strong probability rather than a certainty. In 2011 a second ossuary, seized by the authorities from antiquities robbers, was authenticated bearing the inscription "Miriam daughter of Yeshua son of Caiaphas, priests of Maaziah from Beth Imri." Maaziah was the last of the twenty-four priestly divisions that took turns serving in the temple (1 Chronicles 24:18), which places the Caiaphas family on the priestly roster David is said to have drawn up.

What He Held

(T1) The nation and its temple had to survive under Rome, and one man’s death was a price worth paying for it. + Imagine a ship’s captain in a storm who decides to throw one passenger overboard to lighten the boat. He may tell himself he is saving everyone. He may even be right about the arithmetic. But he has decided that an innocent life is something he is entitled to spend. That is the logic Caiaphas laid before the council. Caiaphas wrote nothing, and everything we know of his thinking comes from the men who opposed him, chiefly John; but the reasoning John reports hangs together and fits the man Josephus shows us. Caiaphas did not argue that Jesus was guilty. He argued that Jesus was dangerous: a popular movement around a man some were calling king could bring the legions down on Jerusalem, and the Romans had shown in Galilee and elsewhere that they would burn a town to stamp out a rebellion. The word for this kind of reasoning is expediency: judging an action by whether it is useful rather than by whether it is right. John repeats the word himself when he reminds the reader who Caiaphas was: the one who "had advised the Jews that it would be expedient that one man should die for the people" (John 18:14). In this scene of John’s Gospel, as through its conflict scenes, "the Jews" means the Jerusalem leadership, the council Caiaphas was addressing. From the high priest’s chair, the reasoning had a grim kind of responsibility to it. His office existed to keep the temple standing and the sacrifices going, and he had kept them going for a dozen years by never giving Rome an excuse. You might think, "Surely a leader sometimes has to make a hard call for the greater good." The Christian answer is that hard calls are one thing, and buying the safety of the many with the blood of the innocent is another; that, no office permits. And John hears in the same sentence a turn Caiaphas never intended, one the church has pondered ever since.

(Q) "You know nothing at all. Nor do you understand that it is better for you that one man should die for the people, not that the whole nation should perish." + Source: John 11:49–50 (English Standard Version). Caiaphas, "high priest that year," answers a council paralysed by fear of what Rome will do if Jesus’ following keeps growing. The words "for you" are pointed: it is the council’s own interest he is appealing to.

(T2) A man who claimed to be the Christ and to sit at God’s right hand was guilty of blasphemy and deserved death. + In a modern courtroom a defendant cannot be forced to testify against himself. Caiaphas had no such rule to stop him, and when the witnesses failed he did the one thing that could settle the matter: he put Jesus under oath. "I adjure you by the living God" is the formula of a sworn statement, the way a witness today places a hand on a Bible. To refuse to answer an oath in God’s name would itself have been a kind of contempt. Jesus answered, and his answer reached past the question. He spoke of the Son of Man seated at the right hand of Power and coming on the clouds of heaven. "Son of Man" was Jesus’ favourite way of speaking about himself, and "Power" was a reverent way of saying "God" without pronouncing the holy name. The words were woven from two Old Testament passages every priest knew: the Lord’s invitation to David’s lord to sit at his right hand (Psalm 110:1) and the vision of one like a son of man coming with the clouds to receive an everlasting kingdom (Daniel 7:13–14). To sit at God’s right hand is to share his throne. Caiaphas understood exactly what was being claimed. His verdict was blasphemy: speaking of God in a way that dishonours him, which the law of Moses punished with death (Leviticus 24:16). And he tore his robes, the traditional sign of grief and horror at hearing God insulted. On his own premises the verdict made sense: if Jesus was only a man, a man who claims a seat on God’s throne is speaking blasphemy. Everything turns on whether the claim was true, and the Christian answer is that God himself gave the verdict on the third day.

(Q) "I adjure you by the living God, tell us if you are the Christ, the Son of God." + Source: Matthew 26:63 (English Standard Version). The high priest’s sworn question at the night hearing, after the false witnesses had failed to agree. Two verses later, at Jesus’ answer, "the high priest tore his robes and said, He has uttered blasphemy. What further witnesses do we need?" (Matthew 26:65). Mark gives the same exchange with Jesus answering plainly, "I am" (Mark 14:61–62).

(T3) The apostles’ preaching in Jesus’ name had to be stopped before it spread. + Anyone who has tried to put out a grass fire with a broom knows the feeling: you beat out one patch and the wind carries sparks to three more. That is the high priest’s council in the early chapters of Acts. They had dealt with the leader, and now his followers were preaching his resurrection in the temple courts, healing in his name, and gathering thousands. The council’s response was to forbid the name itself. After the lame man was healed, they admitted among themselves that the sign was undeniable, and resolved instead "that it may spread no further among the people" by warning the apostles to speak no more in this name (Acts 4:16–17). When the apostles went on preaching, the high priest had them jailed, and Luke names who stood with him: "the party of the Sadducees" (Acts 5:17). The Sadducees were the priestly aristocracy’s party, and they held, as Luke explains elsewhere, that "there is no resurrection, nor angel, nor spirit" (Acts 23:8). For a Sadducee high priest, men announcing that a crucified man had risen were not only a political danger; they were preaching something he believed could not happen. Notice what the council never did. They did not produce the body. The simplest way to end the preaching of a resurrection is to open the tomb, and the men who had every motive and every means to do it settled instead for threats.

(Q) "We strictly charged you not to teach in this name, yet here you have filled Jerusalem with your teaching, and you intend to bring this man’s blood upon us." + Source: Acts 5:28 (English Standard Version). The high priest addresses the apostles after they have been rearrested for preaching in the temple. Acts does not name him here, but Caiaphas held the office in these years. Notice that he will not say the name of Jesus: "this name," "this man." Peter’s reply is the church’s charter for conscience: "We must obey God rather than men" (Acts 5:29).

(Q) "By what power or by what name did you do this?" + Source: Acts 4:7 (English Standard Version). The question the assembled rulers put to Peter and John the morning after the healing at the temple gate, with Annas and Caiaphas among them (Acts 4:6). Peter’s answer names the very man the court had condemned: "by the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, whom you crucified, whom God raised from the dead" (Acts 4:10).

What the Church Made of Him

(†) John heard in his cynical counsel a prophecy he never meant: Jesus would die for the nation and for the scattered children of God. + Sometimes a person says something truer than they know. A father tells a nervous son on his wedding day, "This is the last time you’ll be just you," meaning it as a joke, and years later the son remembers it as the plain truth. John saw something like that in Caiaphas’ words, only more so. The high priest meant that Jesus should be sacrificed to save the nation from Rome. John says he spoke better than he knew: "He did not say this of his own accord, but being high priest that year he prophesied that Jesus would die for the nation" (John 11:51), and not for the nation only, but to gather into one the scattered children of God (John 11:52). The irony runs deep. The man whose office was to offer the sacrifice for the people’s sins on the Day of Atonement pronounced, without knowing it, the meaning of the one sacrifice that would end the need for all the others. The letter to the Hebrews would later build a whole argument on exactly that contrast between the high priests who stood daily at the altar and the High Priest who offered himself once for all (Hebrews 7:27). The fathers of the church, the great teachers and bishops of Christianity’s first centuries, took John’s comment seriously and asked how such a man could prophesy. Augustine, preaching on the passage in the early fifth century, drew the lesson that God can speak even through a man who opposes him: "the Spirit of prophecy used the agency even of wicked men to foretell what was future," and John credits the prophecy not to Caiaphas’ character but to his office as high priest (Tractates on the Gospel of John 49.27, John Gibb translation).

(†) The apostles offered forgiveness to the very rulers who had condemned Jesus. + What is striking about the earliest Christian preaching is how little it sounds like revenge. Peter told the crowd in the temple, "And now, brothers, I know that you acted in ignorance, as did also your rulers" (Acts 3:17), and called them to repent and be forgiven. Standing before the council itself, he proclaimed that God had exalted Jesus "to give repentance to Israel and forgiveness of sins" (Acts 5:31). The door was held open for the high priest’s own court. Some walked through it. Luke reports that a great many priests became obedient to the faith (Acts 6:7), and the young Saul, who carried the high priest’s letters to Damascus, became the apostle Paul. Whether Caiaphas ever heard the gospel he had tried to silence as anything but a threat, no source tells us. The church has remembered him, rightly, as a sobering warning rather than a monster: a religious leader, learned in the Scriptures and responsible for the worship of God, who looked at the Messiah and saw only a problem to be managed. Dante, writing his Inferno in the early fourteenth century, placed him among the hypocrites, pinned to the ground across their path, "This transfixed one, whom thou seest, / Counselled the Pharisees that it was meet / To put one man to torture for the people" (Inferno 23.115–117, Longfellow translation). The poet’s point is the lesson Christian readers have always drawn: holy office does not make holy judgment.

(†) Josephus and the ossuary give Christians outside confirmation of the man the Gospels name. + A story invented decades later and far away would be likely to get its officials wrong. The Gospels get Caiaphas right. They name him as high priest at the time of Jesus’ death, they make him the son-in-law of Annas, and they show Annas still wielding influence beside him (Luke 3:2; John 18:13). Josephus, writing independently in Rome around AD 93, confirms that Joseph Caiaphas held the office through exactly these years, that Annas was the patriarch of a priestly dynasty, and that Caiaphas fell together with Pilate. The 1990 ossuary added a physical witness. Christian writers on the reliability of the Gospels routinely list it beside the Pilate inscription found at Caesarea in 1961, a building stone carved with Pontius Pilate’s name: two officials from the Passion narratives whose names have come out of the ground. Neither find proves that Jesus rose from the dead, and no honest apologist claims it does. What they show is that the Gospel writers were describing real people in a real city, and that the trial of Jesus was conducted by men history can still name.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: an innocent life traded for safety, a true claim judged blasphemy, and the truth forbidden. + A fair account has to set something against the long years of careful service, and it should be what Caiaphas himself did, by the testimony of the sources, rather than what anyone later made of him. Three things stand out. - Expediency over justice. He proposed the death of a man he did not claim was guilty, because the death was useful (John 11:50). The law he served commanded the opposite: "Keep far from a false charge, and do not kill the innocent and righteous" (Exodus 23:7). The hearing he then presided over sought out witnesses against the accused and could not make their testimony agree (Matthew 26:59–60; Mark 14:55–59). - A true claim called blasphemy. His verdict rested on the assumption that Jesus could not be who he said. Christians hold that the claim was true and that God vindicated it publicly: Peter told the same council, "The God of our fathers raised Jesus, whom you killed by hanging him on a tree" (Acts 5:30). - Silencing the witnesses. Faced with a healing he admitted he could not deny (Acts 4:16), he chose to forbid the name rather than examine the claim, and jailed the men who would not stop speaking of what they had seen (Acts 5:17–18). He was a careful man who kept the peace for eighteen years, and on the night it mattered most he chose the peace over the truth.

Caiaphas wrote nothing that survives, and nothing suggests he wrote at all. Everything known about him comes from the New Testament, two passages of Josephus, a bone box very probably his own, and a second that names his family. Those primary witnesses come first, then the most important later Christian readings, then a standard modern study. The New Testament: - Matthew 26:3–5: The chief priests and elders meet "in the palace of the high priest, whose name was Caiaphas" and plot to arrest Jesus by stealth, but not during the feast. - Matthew 26:57–68: The night hearing before Caiaphas: the false witnesses, the oath, Jesus’ answer from Psalm 110 and Daniel 7, the torn robes, and the verdict (T2). - Mark 14:53–65: The same hearing, with the high priest unnamed and Jesus answering "I am." - Luke 3:2: The start of John the Baptist’s preaching dated "during the high priesthood of Annas and Caiaphas." - Luke 22:54, 66–71: Jesus taken to the high priest’s house, then examined by the council at daybreak; the high priest is unnamed. - John 11:45–53: The council after the raising of Lazarus, Caiaphas’ counsel that one man should die for the people, and John’s comment that he prophesied (T1). - John 18:13–14, 19–24, 28: Jesus taken first to Annas, "the father-in-law of Caiaphas," then sent bound to Caiaphas, then led from his house to Pilate. - Acts 4:1–22: Peter and John before the rulers, with "Annas the high priest and Caiaphas and John and Alexander" present; the order not to speak in Jesus’ name (T3). - Acts 5:17–41: The high priest and the Sadducees jail the apostles; the interrogation, Peter’s "We must obey God rather than men," and Gamaliel’s counsel. The high priest is unnamed but in these years was Caiaphas. - Acts 7:1 and Acts 9:1–2: The high priest questions Stephen, and later gives Saul letters to the synagogues of Damascus; unnamed, and most likely Caiaphas. Josephus: - Jewish Antiquities 18.33–35 (18.2.2 in Whiston’s numbering): Valerius Gratus deposes Annas and runs through three high priests before "Joseph Caiaphas was made his successor." - Jewish Antiquities 18.88–95 (18.4.2–3): Pilate sent to Rome; Vitellius at Passover in Jerusalem returns the vestments to the priests and "deprived Joseph, who was also called Caiaphas, of the high priesthood," appointing Jonathan son of Annas. - Jewish Antiquities 20.197–198 (20.9.1): Annas ("Ananus") called most fortunate because five of his sons held the high priesthood after him; the context for Caiaphas’ marriage into the family. Archaeology: - The Caiaphas ossuary (found November 1990, Peace Forest, North Talpiot, Jerusalem): an ornate limestone bone box inscribed twice in Aramaic, "Yehosef bar Qayafa" and a shorter "Yehosef bar Qafa," holding the bones of six people. Published by Zvi Greenhut, with the inscriptions read by Ronny Reich, in ’Atiqot 21 (1992). Now in the Israel Museum. - The Miriam ossuary (authenticated 2011): "Miriam daughter of Yeshua son of Caiaphas, priests of Maaziah from Beth Imri," recovered from antiquities robbers and published by Boaz Zissu and Yuval Goren in the Israel Exploration Journal 61 (2011). It ties the family to the priestly division of Maaziah. Later Christian readings: - Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 49.27: on how Caiaphas could prophesy, the Spirit speaking even through a wicked man by virtue of his office. - The Gospel of Nicodemus (also called the Acts of Pilate): a legendary expansion of the Passion, in its present form from about the fourth century, in which Annas and Caiaphas appear as the accusers before Pilate. Not history, but a witness to how Christians retold the story. - Dante, Inferno 23: Caiaphas crucified on the ground among the hypocrites, with Annas and the council nearby. Standard modern study: Helen K. Bond, Caiaphas: Friend of Rome and Judge of Jesus? (Westminster John Knox, 2004). Whiston’s translation of Josephus and Gibb’s of Augustine are in the public domain and free online.

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief