Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

Tom Holland of Oxford b. 1968 AD

(●) The English historian of the ancient world who set out to admire the pagans, and ended by arguing that the West’s deepest moral instincts are Christian. + Most people who write about Christianity’s influence on the West are either defending the faith or attacking it. Tom Holland came at the question from a third direction. He is a popular historian of Greece, Persia and Rome, a man who grew up loving the gods of Olympus far more than the God of the Bible, and whose first histories celebrated the glamour of the classical world. The longer he lived among the ancients, the less at home he felt with them, and the more he noticed that his own sense of right and wrong had come from somewhere else. He is on a Christian apologetics site because of where that noticing led. His book Dominion (2019) argues, at the length of five hundred pages and from the wars of the Greeks and Persians to the present, that the values secular Westerners take to be simply obvious (that every human life has equal worth, that the weak deserve protection, that it is nobler to suffer than to inflict suffering) are not obvious at all. They are the residue of a revolution that began with the crucifixion of a Jewish preacher. Apologists, the Christians whose work is making the reasoned case for the faith, had been saying something like this for years. Holland said it as a historian with no church to defend, and the secular world listened. A signature fact to remember him by: by his own account, the first crack in his childhood faith came at Sunday school, when he was six, from a picture of Adam and Eve standing beside a dinosaur.

(●) 1968 AD: Born in Oxford and raised a churchgoing child in Wiltshire, he traded his Sunday-school faith for dinosaurs and the gods of Olympus. + Thomas Holland was born on 5 January 1968 in Oxford and grew up in the village of Broad Chalke in Wiltshire, not far from Salisbury and its cathedral. He was brought up in the Church of England. His younger brother James would also become a historian, of the Second World War. He tells the story of his drift from faith with affection rather than bitterness. At Sunday school one day, aged six, he opened a children’s Bible and found on its first page Adam and Eve keeping company with a brachiosaur, one of the long-necked giants that scientists call sauropods. He already knew, with the certainty only a six-year-old dinosaur enthusiast can have, that no human being had ever seen a sauropod, because the last of them were gone tens of millions of years before the first people walked the earth. The teacher did not seem to care. A faint shadow of doubt had fallen. The dinosaurs gave way to ancient empires. Reading the Bible, he found himself more interested in Israel’s enemies (the Egyptians, the Assyrians, the Romans) than in Israel, and the God he vaguely went on believing in seemed far less exciting than Apollo, Athena and Dionysus. The Olympians were vain, selfish and cruel, he later wrote, and that only gave them the allure of rock stars.

(●) 1995 AD: After Cambridge and an abandoned doctorate on Byron, he began his writing life as a novelist of vampires. + Holland went up to Queens’ College, Cambridge, in 1986, where he read English (the British university way of saying he studied it) and took a double first, the highest grade in both parts of the degree. On his first day there he met Sadie, who became his wife. He then began a doctorate at Oxford on the poet Lord Byron, and left it unfinished. Byron did not leave him. In 1995 he published two novels. The first was Attis, a thriller that sets the poet Catullus and the great men of the late Roman Republic (Rome’s last troubled century before it fell under the rule of emperors) in a modern city. The second was The Vampyre, which imagines Byron as one of the undead. Four more followed over the next six years, ranging from Cromwell’s England and Victorian London to the tombs of Egypt and the dinosaur beds of the American West. They are the work of a young writer in love with the dark glamour of the past, which is a fair description of where Holland then stood.

(●) 2003 AD: Rubicon made him a historian, and three more books carried him from Rome to Persia to the year 1000. + Rubicon (2003) told the story of the last generation of the Roman Republic, the years when Julius Caesar crossed the little river that gives the book its title. It read like one of his novels, and yet every scene was built on the ancient sources. It won the Hessell-Tiltman Prize, a British award for history writing, in 2004, and it turned the novelist into one of Britain’s best-selling historians. Persian Fire (2005) told the story of the Greek wars against the Persian Empire, the clash at Marathon and Thermopylae that Western schoolchildren once learned as the birth of freedom. Millennium (2008) moved to the centuries around the year 1000 and to the Christian Europe that took shape in them. The man who had loved the classical world was now writing about Christendom, the old name for the lands where Christianity shaped the law, the government and the rhythm of ordinary days, and he was not yet sure what he thought of it.

(●) 2012 AD: His history of the rise of Islam, and the television film made from it, brought him death threats. + In the Shadow of the Sword (2012) went back to late antiquity, the centuries in which the Roman world was slowly turning into the medieval one. It asked how the great monotheisms of that age (the faiths that worship a single God: Christian, Jewish and Muslim) took the shapes they did. And it did one thing that made it dangerous. It applied to the early history of Islam the same critical questions that historians had long asked of the Bible: how close to the events the sources are, and what the earliest of them actually say. Channel 4 made the book into a documentary, Islam: The Untold Story, broadcast that summer. It drew more than a thousand complaints to Channel 4 and to Ofcom, the British broadcasting regulator, and Holland received threats against his life. That September, on security advice, Channel 4 cancelled a private screening it had planned for invited opinion formers. He did not withdraw the argument. The episode taught him something he would later write about at length: how fiercely people hold the stories that tell them who they are.

(●) 2016 AD: In an essay titled “Why I was wrong about Christianity” he confessed that his morals were not Greek or Roman after all. + The turn came slowly, over years spent among the Spartans, the Athenians and the Romans. He had gone to them expecting to admire them, and in many ways he did. But the longer he stayed, the more alien they seemed. It was not only the cruelty that shocked him (the Spartans culling their own infants, Caesar reported to have killed a million Gauls and enslaved a million more). It was the absence of any sense that the poor or the weak had any worth of their own. In September 2016 he set the change down in the New Statesman, a British political weekly. He had come to see, he wrote, that his own instincts about the dignity of the weak did not come from Athens or Rome. They came from the strange claim the apostle Paul preached, that God had been crucified. The essay travelled far beyond its first readers, and Christian broadcasters and apologists took it up at once. It was the seed of a book.

(●) 2019 AD: Dominion traced the Christian revolution from the ancient world to the present and became his most influential book. + Imagine a fish asked to describe water. It cannot, because it has never been anywhere else. Dominion is Holland’s attempt to show the modern West its water. It was published in Britain as Dominion: The Making of the Western Mind and in America as Dominion: How the Christian Revolution Remade the World. In short, vivid chapters it runs from the Persian and Greek worlds through Israel, Paul and the monasteries, on through the Reformation that split the Western church and the Enlightenment that hoped to put reason in the church’s place, all the way to the Beatles and the #MeToo movement. And at every turn it makes the same argument: the West’s revolutions, even those made against the church, were fought in Christian terms. Christian readers embraced it, secular reviewers argued with it, and it was widely read on both sides. Holland spent the following years in public conversation with believers and unbelievers alike, on Christian radio and in debate halls, explaining what he had found.

(●) 2020 AD: The Rest Is History made him one of the most listened-to historians in the world, while he had become a regular at one of London’s oldest churches. + In November 2020 Holland and his fellow historian Dominic Sandbrook launched a podcast, The Rest Is History: two friends talking, with jokes and digressions, about anything from the fall of Troy to the Beatles. It became one of the most popular history programmes in the world, and it made Holland a familiar voice to millions who had never opened his books. The books kept coming all the same. Pax (2023), on Rome at the height of its power, continued his series on the Roman world, and in 2025 his translation of the Roman biographer Suetonius’ Lives of the Caesars became a bestseller. Away from the microphone, something quieter had been happening. He had become a regular at St Bartholomew the Great, founded in 1123 and London’s oldest surviving parish church, which he began attending while researching Dominion. Then, during the pandemic, he was diagnosed with cancer. While he waited to learn whether it had spread, he went to a midnight mass and prayed, reasoning, as the old soldiers’ saying has it, that there are no atheists in foxholes. Things went right from then on, and he has said that if God had a hand in it, God has the most wonderful sense of humour. He has spoken, too, of sensing a thin place between heaven and earth in a desecrated church. A thin place, a phrase linked with Celtic Christianity and made popular in the twentieth century by George MacLeod of the Iona Community, is a spot where the distance between this world and the next seems to wear thin, so that a person standing there feels close to something beyond. Yet he has said, with characteristic honesty, that he still lacks belief in the supernatural. He lives in London with Sadie and their two daughters.

What He Taught

(T1) The crucifixion of God was an outrage to the ancient world, and its triumph is the strangest revolution in history. + Think of the most degrading death you can imagine, the kind no one would mention at dinner. For a Roman, that was crucifixion. It was the punishment for rebellious slaves, a death of public torment and humiliation, and polite writers preferred not to describe it at all. Holland’s starting point is how strange it was, against that background, to worship a crucified man as God. In the ancient world, he points out, the gods who ruled the universe kept its order by inflicting punishment, not by suffering it. A god who let himself be stripped and nailed up like a slave turned every assumption upside down. Paul knew exactly how it sounded: "but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles" (1 Corinthians 1:23). Holland takes Paul at his word. The message was a scandal, and the history of the West is the history of that scandal slowly becoming the thing everyone assumes.

(Q) "The notion that a god might have suffered torture and death on a cross was so shocking as to appear repulsive." + Source: Tom Holland, "Why I was wrong about Christianity," New Statesman, 14 September 2016. Holland is describing how Paul’s message would have struck his contemporaries, and why its eventual victory needs explaining (T1).

(T2) The ancients did not prize the weak; the conviction that every human life has equal worth is a Christian inheritance. + A Roman father could look at a newborn daughter and decide not to raise her; she would be left outside to die or be taken by a stranger, and no law forbade it. Holland does not tell such stories to make the ancients look like monsters. Many of them were brave, brilliant and admirable. His point is that they lived without an assumption we cannot imagine living without: that the poor, the sick, the enslaved and the unwanted child each have a worth no one may take away. That assumption, he argues, came into the world with the claim that God had become a man and died a slave’s death. If the Lord of the universe had stooped that low, then no one was beneath notice. Paul’s "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is no male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus" (Galatians 3:28) was, in Holland’s telling, the charter of a revolution that took centuries to work itself out, and is still working.

(Q) "...the lack of a sense that the poor or the weak might have any intrinsic value." + Source: Tom Holland, "Why I was wrong about Christianity," New Statesman, 14 September 2016. The words close a sentence in which Holland says that it was not only the extremes of ancient callousness that came to shock him, but this absence too (T2).

(T3) The secular West still lives inside Christian assumptions, even where it has stopped believing. + Children who inherit a house can repaint every room and still live within the walls their grandparents built. Holland thinks the modern West is in that position. Its churches may be emptying, but its instincts are Christian through and through: the belief in human rights, the suspicion of the powerful, the sympathy for victims, the confidence that history is moving toward something better, even the habit of confessing one’s privileges in public. This is why Dominion spends so many pages on movements that thought they were leaving Christianity behind. The abolition of slavery, the French Revolution, Marxism, feminism and the campaigns of the present day all, in his telling, appeal to moral standards that were first set down by Christians, and many of them were led by Christians. Even the protests against Christianity, he argues, are made in a Christian accent.

(Q) "Today, even as belief in God fades across the West, the countries that were once collectively known as Christendom continue to bear the stamp of the two-millennia-old revolution that Christianity represents." + Source: Tom Holland, "Why I was wrong about Christianity," New Statesman, 14 September 2016. The sentence opens the essay’s last paragraph, where Holland gathers up what his years among the ancients had taught him. Three years later Dominion set out to prove it at book length (T3).

(T4) Secularism and humanism are not neutral ground but Christian offshoots that have forgotten their parentage. + Most secular people assume that if you take religion away, what remains is simply reason and common sense: the neutral floor everyone stands on. Holland disputes this. The very idea of a "secular" sphere, a part of life set apart from the sacred, is itself a Christian distinction. It was drawn sharply in the eleventh century by the reformers around Pope Gregory VII, who insisted that the church’s authority was one thing and the king’s was another. Humanism, the belief in the dignity and rights of every person without reference to God, assumes the Christian picture of the human being while discarding the God who painted it. In Dominion he writes of the foundation myths of secularism, meaning the founding story a society tells about itself, believed so deeply that it is no longer noticed as a story. The secular West tells itself that it rose up when reason threw off faith, born as if from nowhere and owing Christianity nothing. Holland thinks the truth is nearer the opposite: that the West’s faith in reason and in human dignity grew out of Christianity, and has not yet found any other soil that will hold it.

(Q) "Yet Voltaire, in his concern for the weak and oppressed, was marked more enduringly by the stamp of biblical ethics than he cared to admit." + Source: Tom Holland, "Why I was wrong about Christianity," New Statesman, 14 September 2016. Holland has just quoted Voltaire, the eighteenth-century French writer who was the Enlightenment’s most famous enemy of the church: "Every sensible man, every honourable man, must hold the Christian sect in horror." Voltaire would not allow that his ethics owed anything to Christianity and drew them instead from classical literature, Chinese philosophy and his own reason. Holland’s point is that the debt was there all the same (T4).

(Q) "In my morals and ethics, I have learned to accept that I am not Greek or Roman at all, but thoroughly and proudly Christian." + Source: Tom Holland, "Why I was wrong about Christianity," New Statesman, 14 September 2016. The line comes from the essay that became the seed of Dominion. Notice what it claims and what it does not: his morals are Christian. Whether the Christian story is true is a different question, and he left it open.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) Christians welcomed him as a witness from outside, whose history confirmed what apologists had long argued. + Testimony counts for more when the witness has nothing to gain. A courtroom gives special weight to the witness who speaks against his own side, and Christians heard Holland that way: a secular historian, raised on the classics and unpersuaded by the creeds, telling the modern world that its morality was borrowed. What he said was not new to the church. Christian scholars had made the historical case before him. The historian Larry Hurtado, for one, had shown in Destroyer of the gods (2016) how strange early Christianity looked to its Roman neighbours, and Holland and Hurtado discussed their overlapping findings on Unbelievable?, a British radio programme that sits Christians and sceptics down together to talk. Holland also debated the philosopher A. C. Grayling there, and talked at length with the New Testament scholar N. T. Wright on the same programme. What was new was the hearing he got. Dominion reached readers who would never have opened a book of apologetics, and Christian writers built on it. Glen Scrivener’s The Air We Breathe (2022), for one, is a popular retelling of its argument for ordinary readers, written with the gospel in view.

(†) His work gave the moral argument a history: the values critics use against the faith turn out to be the faith’s own. + The moral argument for God reasons from the reality of moral obligation to a source of it beyond ourselves. Anyone who has felt bound to keep a promise when breaking it would cost nothing, and no one would ever know, has felt the thing the argument starts from. Holland supplied something the argument had often lacked: a history of where the West’s particular moral convictions came from. When a critic objects that the God of the Bible is cruel, or that the church has failed the weak, he is judging by the standard of the cross. Holland showed, with a historian’s detail, that the standard itself has a birthplace, and that it is not Athens. Christian readers have also valued his honesty about the church’s failures. Dominion does not hide the crusades, the burning of heretics, or the long Christian complicity in slavery. But it shows that the people who condemned those things most fiercely were usually condemning them on Christian grounds, often from inside the church.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: Christianity is not a moral inheritance but a claim that Christ is risen. + Holland describes, with great care, what the belief that God was crucified did to the world. He has said openly that he has not yet taken the step of believing it himself. That leaves the faith in his books as a story of enormous power, the West’s founding story, whose truth he does not affirm. The apostles would not have recognised a Christianity whose value lay in its effects. Paul staked everything on a single event: "And if Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain" (1 Corinthians 15:14), and again, "And if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins" (1 Corinthians 15:17). The values Holland traces are fruit; the gospel is about the root. A civilisation that keeps the fruit and forgets the root is living, as he himself sees, on borrowed time. To his credit, Holland has never pretended otherwise. Speaking at Westminster Chapel in London in 2024, he told his Christian hearers that what is left for the churches to do is to talk about the things no one else is talking about, and the thing he meant was the supernatural. The question his own history poses, he leaves for each reader to answer.

Holland is a living author, and the shelf is still growing. His novels and histories were published by Little, Brown in Britain (American editions from Doubleday and Basic Books, some under different titles), his translations by Penguin Classics, and much of his work since 2020 has been spoken rather than written, on The Rest Is History. The list below covers the books, the translations, and the essay that began Dominion. Novels: - Attis (1995): His first novel, a thriller that transposes the poet Catullus and the great men of the late Roman Republic (Caesar, Pompey, Cicero) into a modern setting, amid a string of brutal murders. - The Vampyre: Being the True Pilgrimage of George Gordon, Sixth Lord Byron (1995; US title Lord of the Dead): Byron as one of the undead, a gothic fantasy born of Holland’s abandoned doctorate on the poet. - Supping with Panthers (1996; US title Slave of My Thirst): The sequel to The Vampyre, set in London in 1888, where a young doctor investigating a friend’s bloodless corpse is drawn into a world of immortals, with Bram Stoker and Oscar Wilde among the cast. - Deliver Us from Evil (1997): A gothic novel that opens with satanic murders near Stonehenge in the last days of Cromwell’s republic and follows its hero into Restoration London, the Plague and the Great Fire. - The Sleeper in the Sands (1998): A supernatural adventure set in Egypt, beginning with Howard Carter’s discovery of the tomb of Tutankhamun in 1922. - The Bonehunter (2001; later reissued as The Bone Hunter): A thriller set in the American West during the rivalry of the fossil-hunters Othniel Marsh and Edward Cope, drawing on his lifelong love of dinosaurs. Histories of the ancient and medieval world: - Rubicon: The Triumph and Tragedy of the Roman Republic (2003; US subtitle The Last Years of the Roman Republic): The fall of the Republic from the Gracchi to Augustus, told as a drama. Winner of the Hessell-Tiltman Prize, 2004. - Persian Fire: The First World Empire and the Battle for the West (2005): The rise of Persia and the Greek wars against it, told with unusual sympathy for the Persian side. - Millennium: The End of the World and the Forging of Christendom (2008; US title The Forge of Christendom): Europe around the year 1000, the papal reforms, and the making of a self-consciously Christian civilisation. - In the Shadow of the Sword: The Battle for Global Empire and the End of the Ancient World (2012; US subtitle The Birth of Islam and the Rise of the Global Arab Empire): Late antiquity and the emergence of Islam, applying to the Qur’an’s early history the critical questions long asked of the Bible. - Dynasty: The Rise and Fall of the House of Caesar (2015): The Julio-Claudian emperors from Augustus to Nero, a sequel to Rubicon. - Athelstan: The Making of England (2016): A short life of the first king of all England, in the Penguin Monarchs series. - Æthelflæd: England’s Forgotten Founder (2019): A brief life of Alfred the Great’s daughter, the Lady of the Mercians, who built fortified towns and fought the Vikings, in the Ladybird Expert series. - Dominion: The Making of the Western Mind (2019; US title Dominion: How the Christian Revolution Remade the World): His most important book for Christian readers: some two and a half thousand years in short chapters, from the Persian wars to the present, arguing that the West’s moral assumptions are Christian through and through (T1–T4). - Pax: War and Peace in Rome’s Golden Age (2023): The Roman Empire from the year of the four emperors that followed Nero’s fall to the death of Hadrian, the third of his Roman histories. For children: - The Wolf-Girl, the Greeks and the Gods: A Tale of the Persian Wars (Walker Books, 2023): The Persian Wars retold for young readers, illustrated by Jason Cockcroft. Translations: - Herodotus, The Histories (Penguin Classics, 2013): A new translation of the first Greek historian, with an introduction and notes by Paul Cartledge; Holland had earlier adapted Herodotus, Homer, Virgil and Thucydides for BBC Radio 4. - Suetonius, The Lives of the Caesars (Penguin Classics, 2025): A new translation, with his own introduction, of the Roman biographies of the twelve rulers from Julius Caesar to Domitian, the gossip-rich source on which Dynasty draws heavily. Essay: - "Why I was wrong about Christianity," New Statesman, 14 September 2016: The account of his change of mind, and the seed of Dominion (T1–T4). Broadcasting: Islam: The Untold Story (Channel 4, 2012); ISIS: The Origins of Violence (Channel 4, 2017); Making History (BBC Radio 4, presenter); The Rest Is History (podcast with Dominic Sandbrook, from 2020). Christian engagement: Larry Hurtado, Destroyer of the gods: Early Christian Distinctiveness in the Roman World (Baylor University Press, 2016); Glen Scrivener, The Air We Breathe: How We All Came to Believe in Freedom, Kindness, Progress, and Equality (The Good Book Company, 2022).
Playlist
Justified True Belief