Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

René Girard of Avignon 1923 – 2015 AD

(●) A French literary critic who found one pattern of envy and blame under the great novels and the oldest myths, and found in the Gospels the one story that breaks it. + Think of two small children in a playroom full of toys. One picks up a battered plastic truck that nobody has touched all morning, and at once the other wants that truck and no other. Within a minute there are tears. René Girard spent his life arguing that this ordinary scene, magnified and repeated, explains a great deal of human history: we learn what to want by watching other people want it, our wants collide, and when a whole community is at war with itself it finds peace by turning together on one victim. He was not a theologian. He was a professor of French literature who began with Cervantes, Stendhal, Proust and Dostoevsky, moved on to Greek tragedy and the myths of ancient peoples, and arrived, to the surprise of his colleagues and in some ways of himself, at the Bible. The myths, he argued, are told by the crowd that killed the victim and are sure the victim deserved it. The Bible, from Joseph to Job to the Passion, keeps telling the same kind of story from the side of the innocent one. That is why he belongs on a Christian apologetics site. Girard offered a reply to the old charge, made famous by the anthropologist James Frazer, that the story of Jesus is one more myth of a dying god. The resemblance is real, he said, and that is exactly what makes the difference visible: the Gospels tell the old story and, finishing what the stories of Joseph and Job began, take the victim’s side all the way.

(●) 1923 AD: Born on Christmas Day in Avignon, the son of the city’s museum curator. + René Noël Théophile Girard was born in Avignon on 25 December 1923, in the southern French city where the popes had lived for most of the fourteenth century. His father, Joseph Girard, was a historian and curator who looked after the city’s Musée Calvet and later the great Palace of the Popes itself; his mother was a devout Catholic, his father a man of the anticlerical, church-wary republican left. The boy grew up between the two, and by his teens he had quietly stopped practicing the faith. He followed his father into the archives. While France was still under German occupation he began his studies in Paris at the École des Chartes, the school that trains France’s archivists in reading medieval handwriting and old charters, and in 1947 he qualified as an archivist-palaeographer (an expert in old scripts) with a thesis on private life in Avignon in the second half of the fifteenth century. It was careful, dusty, document-by-document work, and he found that he did not want a lifetime of it.

(●) 1947 AD: He crossed to America for a single year of teaching and stayed for the rest of his life. + In 1947 Girard accepted a post teaching French at Indiana University, meaning to stay a year. He stayed in America for nearly seventy. At Indiana he took a doctorate in history in 1950, with a dissertation on American opinion of France between 1940 and 1943, and there he met an American student, Martha McCullough, whom he married in 1951. They had three children. The early academic years were not a triumph. Indiana did not keep him, and he moved through Duke and then Bryn Mawr, a young foreigner teaching language classes and writing about novels he loved. In 1957 he came to Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, and there the ideas that made his name began to come together.

(●) 1959 AD: Writing a book about novelists turned into a conversion, and in Holy Week he returned to the church. + Girard was finishing a book on five great novelists when he noticed something they all shared. Each one had begun by writing heroes who imagined their desires were their own. Each, in his greatest work, had seen through that illusion. And in the novels the moment of seeing through it looks very like a religious conversion, often with the hero facing death. Girard later said that he could not write about that experience without beginning to undergo it himself, and so in the winter of 1958 to 1959 his own conversion began as an intellectual and aesthetic one. Then, in Lent of 1959 (the season of fasting and repentance that leads up to Easter), a lesion appeared on his forehead and his doctors feared skin cancer. For weeks he lived with the fear of a death sentence. The all-clear came, by his own account, on the Wednesday of Holy Week, the last week before Easter. He went to confession, received communion on Holy Thursday, had his marriage blessed in the church and his two young sons baptized. He spoke of the day the fear lifted as the most wonderful of his life, and he practiced the Catholic faith from then until his death.

(●) 1961 AD: His first book argued that we borrow our desires from other people. + The book was Mensonge romantique et vérité romanesque (1961), "romantic lie and novelistic truth," published in English as Deceit, Desire and the Novel (1965). Its argument is that the Romantics told a lie about desire, that it springs spontaneously from inside the self, while the great novelists told the truth: Don Quixote wants to be a knight because he has read about Amadis of Gaul, and Proust’s snobs want invitations because other snobs want them. The book made Girard a figure in American letters. In October 1966 he helped organize, with his Hopkins colleagues Richard Macksey and Eugenio Donato, a symposium called "The Languages of Criticism and the Sciences of Man." It brought Jacques Derrida, Jacques Lacan and Roland Barthes to the same American stage, and it is usually remembered as the moment French theory arrived in American universities. "French theory" is the name Americans gave to the new and often difficult ways of reading texts, minds and cultures that those three men stood for, and for a generation it carried great weight in many English and literature departments. Girard himself, however, was already walking in a different direction from most of his guests.

(●) 1972 AD: He turned from novels to myth and sacrifice, and then said openly that the Gospels hold the key. + At the State University of New York at Buffalo, where he taught from 1968, Girard asked what happens when borrowed desires collide on a large scale. His answer was La Violence et le sacré (1972), Violence and the Sacred in English (1977): a theory that archaic religion, the religion of early and tribal societies, with its sacrifices, its taboos (the things a people must never touch, eat or do) and its myths, grew out of communities saving themselves from their own violence by uniting against a single victim. The book won wide attention in France and made him a public intellectual there. What it did not do was mention the Bible in any sustained way. That came six years later, back at Johns Hopkins, in Des choses cachées depuis la fondation du monde (1978), a long book of conversations with two psychiatrists, Jean-Michel Oughourlian and Guy Lefort, published in English as Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World (1987). The title comes from Matthew, where Jesus speaks in parables to fulfill the prophet’s word, "I will utter what has been hidden since the foundation of the world" (Matthew 13:35). The thing hidden, Girard now argued in print, is the founding murder, and it is the Gospels that bring it to light. Many admirers of the earlier book were dismayed to find a secular theorist defending the uniqueness of Christianity.

(●) 1981 AD: At Stanford he wrote his clearest Christian books and was elected to the Académie française. + In 1981 Girard moved to Stanford University as Andrew B. Hammond Professor of French Language, Literature and Civilization, and he taught there until he retired in 1995. The Stanford years produced The Scapegoat (1982), a study of medieval persecution texts (accounts of real persecutions told from the persecutors’ point of view) set beside the myths; a book on Job (1985); a long study of Shakespeare (1990 in French, 1991 in English); and, in 1999, Je vois Satan tomber comme l’éclair, published as I See Satan Fall Like Lightning (2001), his most direct and readable account of the Bible. Its title is Jesus’ own saying: "I saw Satan fall like lightning from heaven" (Luke 10:18). Admirers founded the Colloquium on Violence and Religion in 1990 to carry his work across disciplines, and theologians, anthropologists, literary critics and economists all took part. On 17 March 2005 Girard was elected to the Académie française, the forty "immortals" who are France’s highest literary honor, and he was formally received there that December.

(●) 2015 AD: He died at home in Stanford at ninety-one, still a practicing Catholic. + Girard’s last books were conversations, a format that suited a man who thought best in argument with friends: on evolution and the origins of culture, on Christianity and postmodern "weak" faith with the Italian philosopher Gianni Vattimo, who held that the faith’s gift to the modern world is a softened belief that lets go of firm claims to truth, and on war and the end of history with Benoît Chantre in Achever Clausewitz (2007), a book built around the Prussian strategist Clausewitz. In his last years a long illness slowed and finally stopped his work. He died at his home in Stanford, California, on 4 November 2015, at ninety-one, after that long illness. The man who had once been the most celebrated secular theorist in French letters died as he had lived for fifty-six years, a member of the church he had returned to in the Holy Week of 1959.

What He Taught

(T1) We learn what to want by imitating what others want. + Go back to the playroom and the plastic truck. Nobody wanted it until somebody else did. Girard called this mimetic desire, from the Greek mimesis, "imitation": once our bodily needs are met, our desires are not fixed in us the way a cow’s appetite for grass is fixed. We take them from a model, a person we admire or envy, and want what the model wants. Advertisers have always known this; that is why the watch is sold on the wrist of a film star. He drew a picture of it as a triangle: the person who desires, the object, and, at the third corner, the model, whom he also called the mediator. When the model is far away (a knight in an old romance, a celebrity) imitation is harmless, even admirable. When the model is close (a classmate, a colleague, a brother) the model becomes a rival, because two people reaching for the same thing get in each other’s way. Then the object fades and the rivals fix on each other. Girard insisted that mimetic desire is not bad in itself. Without it, he wrote, there would be neither freedom nor humanity, since we could never learn to want anything new, and it is the way children learn language and adults learn to love good things. Christians noticed at once how close this comes to the tenth commandment, "You shall not covet" (Exodus 20:17), which Girard read as the root of the four commandments before it: stop desiring your neighbor’s goods and you will never kill, commit adultery, steal or bear false witness to get them. And they noticed that the New Testament’s answer is not to stop imitating but to imitate the right model: "Be imitators of me, as I am of Christ" (1 Corinthians 11:1).

(Q) "Once his basic needs are satisfied (indeed, sometimes even before), man is subject to intense desires, though he may not know precisely for what. The reason is that he desires being, something he himself lacks and which some other person seems to possess." + Source: René Girard, Violence and the Sacred, chapter 6, "From Mimetic Desire to the Monstrous Double," p. 146 (trans. Patrick Gregory, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1977). The sentence that follows finishes the thought: the subject looks to the other person to tell him what he should desire in order to acquire that being. We do not finally want the truck; we want to be the child who has it.

(T2) Communities torn by rivalry make peace by uniting against a scapegoat. + Imagine an office where everyone has been sniping at everyone for months. Then one employee makes a mistake in public, and within a week the whole floor agrees that he is the problem. The sniping stops. People who could not stand each other eat lunch together and trade stories about him. When he leaves, the office feels better, and everyone is sure they were right about him. Girard argued that this is how human societies first survived their own violence. Mimetic rivalry spreads like a contagion, each person copying the anger of the next, until a whole community is near a war of all against all. Then the contagion turns: all against all becomes all against one. The group fixes on a single victim, usually someone marked out by weakness, foreignness or some oddity, kills or expels him, and peace returns. This is the scapegoat mechanism, named after the goat of Leviticus 16 that carried Israel’s sins into the wilderness. And because the peace seems to come from the victim, the victim is remembered as both the cause of the trouble and the source of the cure: a monster and then a god. Ritual sacrifice, on this account, is the community re-enacting the original killing in a controlled form, with an animal or a substitute in place of the first victim. The mechanism only works if nobody sees it. The crowd must believe the victim is guilty. A scapegoat everyone knows to be innocent cannot unite anyone, which is why, Girard said, the Gospels were so dangerous to it.

(Q) "Violence is not to be denied, but it can be diverted to another object, something it can sink its teeth into." + Source: René Girard, Violence and the Sacred, chapter 1, "Sacrifice," p. 4 (trans. Patrick Gregory, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1977). Girard has just compared sacrifice to the fairy tales in which the wolf or the ogre is fed a large stone in place of the child. He goes on to read the story of Cain and Abel the same way: the brother with no sacrificial outlet is the one who kills.

(T3) Myths are told by the persecutors, and the Bible tells the same stories from the side of the innocent victim. + Put two stories side by side. In the Greek myth, the city of Thebes is struck by plague, and the cause turns out to be its king, Oedipus, who has killed his father and married his mother. He is driven out and the plague lifts. In Genesis, a young man is hated by his brothers, sold into Egypt, accused by his master’s wife of trying to rape her, and thrown into prison. The two stories share the same bones: a lone figure, a charge of sexual crime, a community that expels him. The difference, Girard argued, is everything. In the myth the crowd is right: Oedipus really did it, and the expulsion is justified. In Genesis the crowd is wrong: Joseph is innocent, the accusation is a lie, and in the end he forgives the brothers who sold him, saying, "As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good" (Genesis 50:20). Girard traced the same reversal through the Psalms, where the speaker is surrounded by enemies who hate him without cause, and through Job, whose friends insist he must have done something to deserve his ruin while Job insists that he has not. Girard read Job’s friends as the voice of the crowd, and Job’s refusal to agree with them as the Bible’s refusal to let the victim be blamed. This is a historian’s point as much as a believer’s. When a medieval chronicler reports that the Jews poisoned the wells and so were rightly burned, a modern reader knows at once that the text is written by persecutors and that the victims were innocent. Girard asked why we read the myths any differently, and answered that we learned to read that way from the Bible.

(Q) "In the myth, the victim is always wrong, and his persecutors are always right. The reverse is true in the Bible." + Source: René Girard, I See Satan Fall Like Lightning, chapter 9, "The Uniqueness of the Bible," p. 109 (trans. James G. Williams, Orbis Books, 2001). Girard is comparing the myth of Oedipus with the story of Joseph and his brothers, and he goes on at once to Joseph’s innocence against his brothers, against Potiphar’s wife, and against the Egyptians who imprison him.

(T4) The cross exposes the scapegoat mechanism, and the resurrection breaks its power. + The Passion has every feature of the old pattern. A city is tense at a feast. Rivals who were enemies the day before, Herod and Pilate, become friends that day (Luke 23:12). The high priest Caiaphas states the scapegoat logic in a single sentence: "it is better for you that one man should die for the people, not that the whole nation should perish" (John 11:50). Even Peter is swept along by the crowd around the fire and denies his master. All against one. And yet this time the story is told by the victim’s friends, and they say he was innocent. Girard thought that was the most important fact in the Gospels: the same events that produce a myth everywhere else here produce its unmasking. Jesus prays for his killers, "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do" (Luke 23:34), and Girard took the words literally: the crowd does not know what it is doing, because the mechanism works only in the dark. He read Satan, "the accuser," as the name the Gospels give to the whole process of rivalry and accusation, the power that casts out its own disorder by casting out a victim. So when Jesus says he saw Satan fall like lightning (Luke 10:18), Girard heard the accuser’s power to unite crowds against the innocent being undone. But Girard knew exposure alone was not enough. The disciples had fled with everyone else. What turned them around, and made them able to tell the story against themselves and against the crowd they had joined, was meeting Jesus risen from the dead. Here Girard said that he could no longer explain things in purely anthropological terms, the terms of anthropology, the study of how human cultures work, which had carried him through every other question. Something stronger than the crowd had to have entered the world.

(Q) "The Resurrection is not only a miracle, a prodigious transgression of natural laws. It is the spectacular sign of the entrance into the world of a power superior to violent contagion." + Source: René Girard, I See Satan Fall Like Lightning, Conclusion, p. 189 (trans. James G. Williams, Orbis Books, 2001). Just before this, Girard admits that every other question in the book had found a plausible answer in commonsense and anthropological terms, and that this one could not: to break the power of a unanimous crowd, there must be a power greater than the crowd, and none exists on earth.

(T5) The modern concern for victims is an inheritance from the Gospels. + Turn on the evening news in any Western country and count the stories about victims: of injustice, of disaster, of discrimination, of crime. Girard thought this was the strangest thing about the modern world, and the least noticed. No earlier civilization talked this way. The ancient world admired the strong; it pitied the weak, sometimes, but it did not build its moral vocabulary around them. He argued that the change came from the Passion narratives. Once a culture has heard, Sunday after Sunday, the story of an innocent man condemned by a unanimous crowd, it can never again quite believe the crowd. Hospitals, the abolition of slavery, human rights and the instinct to ask "who is being blamed, and is it fair?" all grow, in his account, from that root, even in people who no longer believe the story that planted it. He also saw the danger. Concern for victims can itself become a weapon: a way of accusing others, of competing for the status of victim, of hunting new scapegoats in the name of protecting the old ones. Girard called the movement that takes the Gospel’s concern for victims and turns it against Christianity the most powerful anti-Christian movement of the age. Both the gift and its corruption, he thought, show where the gift came from.

(Q) "Our society is the most preoccupied with victims of any that ever was. Even if it is insincere, a big show, the phenomenon has no precedent." + Source: René Girard, I See Satan Fall Like Lightning, chapter 13, "The Modern Concern for Victims," p. 161 (trans. James G. Williams, Orbis Books, 2001). The chapter opens with the great angel on the portals of medieval churches weighing souls for eternity, and suggests that a modern sculptor would carve, over the doors of parliaments, universities and television stations, a weighing of victims.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) Theologians took up his theory to explain original sin and the cross. + Among the first theologians to see what Girard had found was the Swiss Jesuit Raymund Schwager, who taught at Innsbruck. The two began corresponding in 1974, and Schwager’s Brauchen wir einen Sündenbock? (1978), in English Must There Be Scapegoats?, read the whole Bible through Girard’s lens: a long story of God slowly drawing his people out of the logic of the scapegoat, completed on the cross. Schwager went on to build what he called a "dramatic theology" at Innsbruck, which reads the story of salvation as a drama played out between God and human beings, act by act, and the correspondence between the two men has since been published. Others followed. The English Catholic theologian James Alison, in The Joy of Being Wrong (1998), used mimetic theory to re-read the doctrine of original sin, the teaching that every human being is born into a fallen race and shares its bent toward sin. In Alison’s hands it becomes not an abstract stain but a real inheritance of rivalry and blame, which we can see clearly only from the far side of forgiveness. Writers from many traditions, Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox and Mennonite, found in Girard a way to say something old in a fresh vocabulary: that sin is social as well as private, that the cross shows us what we are, and that the forgiveness offered there is offered to the crowd that did it.

(†) Apologists welcomed his answer to the claim that Christ is one more dying god. + Since James Frazer’s The Golden Bough (1890 and after), a standard skeptical move has been to line up the Passion with the myths of gods who die and rise and conclude that Christianity is one more of them. Many Christian replies have tried to deny the resemblance. Girard did something more interesting: he granted that the Passion has the shape of a myth, a crowd, a victim, a death and a return, and argued that this is exactly what makes the difference stand out. A myth is the crowd’s account; the Gospels are the victim’s, and they convict the crowd, the disciples included. That turned a weakness into evidence. If the Gospels were simply myth, they would blame the victim and justify the killing, as myths do. They do the opposite, and they do it from inside the very pattern they expose. Girard’s admirers have used this to argue that the Gospels could not have been produced by the ordinary religious imagination, and his analysis of the modern concern for victims (T5) gave Christian writers a way to show secular readers how much of their own morality they owe to the story they doubt. Recognition came from outside the academy as well. Richard John Neuhaus, the Catholic priest who edited First Things, called him "beyond question one of the seminal Christian thinkers of our time," and in 2005 the Académie française honored a man whose best-known books were defenses of the uniqueness of the Gospels.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: for years he denied that the cross was a sacrifice, and later he took it back. + In Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World (1978), Girard argued for what he called a "non-sacrificial reading" of the Gospels. Because sacrifice in his theory is the scapegoat mechanism in ritual form, he concluded that the death of Jesus must not be called a sacrifice at all, and he laid the blame for the church’s sacrificial language on the Epistle to the Hebrews, which he treated as a relapse into the old religion. He went further and rejected the idea that the Father demanded the death of his Son, calling the medieval account of God requiring that victim the line of reasoning that had done more than anything else to discredit Christianity in the eyes of people of goodwill. The New Testament does not let that stand. Paul writes that Christ "gave himself up for us, a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God" (Ephesians 5:2); Hebrews says that Christ "has appeared once for all at the end of the ages to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself" (Hebrews 9:26); and Jesus himself said he came "to give his life as a ransom for many" (Mark 10:45). Christians across the traditions, Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant alike, have always read these as the heart of the gospel rather than a lapse from it. Hans Urs von Balthasar, in the fourth volume of his Theo-Drama, praised Girard’s analysis of violence but pressed exactly this point: a cross that only unmasks the crowd leaves out what God does there for sinners. Girard came to agree in part. In an interview published in 1993, and again in later books such as Battling to the End, he acknowledged that he had been unfair to Hebrews, and he allowed that the word sacrifice has two senses: the sacrifice of others, which is the scapegoat mechanism, and the sacrifice of oneself, the gift of one who would rather die than kill, which is what Christ offered. That is a real revision, though Girard never built on it a full account of the atonement, the Christian teaching about how Christ’s death reconciles sinners to God. Christians who learn from him do well to keep his insight about the crowd and to keep, beside it, what the apostles said the cross accomplished.

Girard wrote mostly in French and published with Grasset in Paris, and nearly all of his books appeared in English within a few years, usually from Johns Hopkins University Press, Stanford University Press, Orbis Books or Michigan State University Press. Several of his most important books are conversations, and his co-authors are named below. Dates are of first publication, with the English edition after. Early scholarship: - La vie privée à Avignon dans la seconde moitié du XVe siècle (1947): His thesis at the École des Chartes, a study of private life in fifteenth-century Avignon from the archives. Unpublished as a book; it shows the archivist he trained to be. - American Opinion of France, 1940–1943 (1950): His doctoral dissertation in history at Indiana University, on how Americans saw France between the fall of 1940 and the liberation years. Literature and desire: - Mensonge romantique et vérité romanesque (1961); Deceit, Desire and the Novel: Self and Other in Literary Structure (1965, trans. Yvonne Freccero): The founding book of mimetic theory. Cervantes, Stendhal, Flaubert, Proust and Dostoevsky as the novelists who saw through the "romantic lie" that desire is spontaneous (T1). - Proust: A Collection of Critical Essays (1962, editor): A volume in the Twentieth Century Views series, with his own introduction. - Dostoïevski, du double à l’unité (1963); Resurrection from the Underground: Feodor Dostoevsky (1997, trans. James G. Williams): A short study of Dostoevsky’s path from the rivalrous "doubles" of the early fiction to the conversion at the heart of The Brothers Karamazov. - Critique dans un souterrain (1976): Collected French essays on literature, including the Dostoevsky study. - "To Double Business Bound": Essays on Literature, Mimesis, and Anthropology (1978): Essays written in English on Dostoevsky, Camus, Nietzsche, Freud and Lévi-Strauss, among others. - Shakespeare: les feux de l’envie (1990); A Theater of Envy: William Shakespeare (1991): His longest literary study, written in English first: the plays read as the most complete account of mimetic rivalry in literature, from the early comedies to The Winter’s Tale. Violence, myth and the sacred: - La Violence et le sacré (1972); Violence and the Sacred (1977, trans. Patrick Gregory): The theory of the scapegoat mechanism as the origin of sacrifice, taboo and myth, worked out through Greek tragedy and anthropology (T1, T2). - Des choses cachées depuis la fondation du monde (1978, with Jean-Michel Oughourlian and Guy Lefort); Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World (1987, trans. Stephen Bann and Michael Metteer): A book-length conversation in three parts, on anthropology, the Bible and psychology; the first full statement of his reading of the Gospels, including the "non-sacrificial reading" he later revised. - Le Bouc émissaire (1982); The Scapegoat (1986, trans. Yvonne Freccero): Medieval persecution texts, such as the accusations against Jews during the Black Death, set beside myths to show they share one structure, with the Passion as the text that reverses it. - La Route antique des hommes pervers (1985); Job: The Victim of His People (1987, trans. Yvonne Freccero): Job read as a scapegoat whose friends speak for the crowd, and whose refusal to accept their verdict breaks the mythic pattern (T3). - Violent Origins: Walter Burkert, René Girard, and Jonathan Z. Smith on Ritual Killing and Cultural Formation (1987, ed. Robert G. Hamerton-Kelly): Girard’s paper and the debate with two leading historians of religion who disagreed with him. - La Voix méconnue du réel: Une théorie des mythes archaïques et modernes (2002): Essays on myth and persecution, most of them first written in English, gathered in French translation as a compact statement of the theory. - Le Sacrifice (2003); Sacrifice (2011, trans. Matthew Pattillo and David Dawson): Lectures at the French national library on the Vedic Brahmanas, ancient Indian priestly writings that explain the rites of sacrifice, read as an ancient tradition that came near to seeing the mechanism behind its own sacrifices. The Bible and Christianity: - Quand ces choses commenceront (1994, conversations with Michel Treguer); When These Things Begin (2014, trans. Trevor Cribben Merrill): Wide-ranging interviews, including his own account of his life and faith. - Je vois Satan tomber comme l’éclair (1999); I See Satan Fall Like Lightning (2001, trans. James G. Williams): His clearest and most popular statement of the Bible’s uniqueness: the tenth commandment, Satan as the accuser, myth against Gospel, the cross, the resurrection and the modern concern for victims (T3, T4, T5). - Celui par qui le scandale arrive (2001); The One by Whom Scandal Comes (2014, trans. M. B. DeBevoise): Essays and an interview on violence, Islam, the Holocaust and the Christian revelation, including his later thoughts on sacrifice. - Verità o fede debole? (2006, with Gianni Vattimo); Christianity, Truth, and Weakening Faith: A Dialogue (2010, trans. William McCuaig): Girard defends the truth of the Christian revelation against Vattimo’s postmodern "weak thought." - Wissenschaft und christlicher Glaube (2007), with the English original, Knowledge and the Christian Faith: His address on receiving the Leopold Lucas Prize at Tübingen in 2006, a short account of how his research led him to the Christian faith, printed in German and English side by side. - Dieu, une invention? (2007, with André Gounelle and Alain Houziaux): A short French exchange on whether God is a human invention, in which Girard answers from the Bible’s unmasking of the sacred. Late conversations and collections: - Les Origines de la culture (2004, with Pierpaolo Antonello and João Cezar de Castro Rocha); Evolution and Conversion: Dialogues on the Origins of Culture (2008): His theory set beside Darwin and the human sciences, with his fullest account of his own conversion. - Achever Clausewitz (2007, with Benoît Chantre); Battling to the End: Conversations with Benoît Chantre (2010, trans. Mary Baker): A dark, apocalyptic book on escalating violence in the modern world, read through the Prussian strategist Clausewitz and the Christian apocalypse. - De la violence à la divinité (2007): The four major French books on violence and religion gathered in one volume, with a new introduction. - Mimesis and Theory: Essays on Literature and Criticism, 1953–2005 (2008, ed. Robert Doran): His uncollected literary essays across half a century. - La Conversion de l’art (2008): French essays on the novelists and on conversion as the hidden subject of great fiction, issued with a filmed conversation with Benoît Chantre. - Anorexie et désir mimétique (2008); Anorexia and Mimetic Desire (2013): A short essay on eating disorders as mimetic rivalry over thinness. - Discours de réception à l’Académie française (2005): His reception speech, honoring his predecessor in seat 37, the Dominican Ambroise-Marie Carré; published with Michel Serres’s speech of welcome as Le Tragique et la pitié (2007). Anthologies in English: The Girard Reader (1996, ed. James G. Williams), the best single-volume introduction, and Oedipus Unbound: Selected Writings on Rivalry and Desire (2004, ed. Mark R. Anspach). The full biography is Cynthia L. Haven, Evolution of Desire: A Life of René Girard (Michigan State University Press, 2018).
Playlist
Justified True Belief