Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
Herod the Great c. 73 – 4 BC
(●) The king of Judea who rebuilt the Temple Jesus taught in, and who tried to kill him in his cradle. Every Christmas pageant has a Herod in it, usually a boy in a cardboard crown who scowls at the wise men and then disappears. The real man was far larger than the part. For thirty-three years he ruled the Jewish homeland as Rome’s chosen king, and he left behind some of the greatest buildings of the ancient world: a harbor city on open sea, palaces on desert clifftops, and a Temple in Jerusalem so splendid that a disciple of Jesus, walking out of it decades later, could only say, "Look, Teacher, what wonderful stones and what wonderful buildings!" (Mark 13:1). He is on a Christian apologetics site because the Gospels tie the birth of Jesus to him by name. Jesus was born "in the days of Herod the king" (Matthew 2:1), and Luke opens his whole account "in the days of Herod, king of Judea" (Luke 1:5). Herod is one of the best-documented rulers of his age, thanks above all to the Jewish historian Josephus, who devoted large parts of two of his histories to him, so the Gospels at this point are anchored to a man we can check. What Josephus tells about his character, a ruler who killed a wife, three sons and a brother-in-law to protect his throne, is exactly the man Matthew describes. His dates take a word of care. He died, by the reckoning most historians use, in the spring of 4 BC, shortly after an eclipse of the moon that Josephus mentions; a minority of scholars argue for 1 BC instead. His birth year is worked out backward from Josephus’ remark that he was about seventy when he died, so "c. 73 BC" is an estimate, not a record.
(●) c. 73 BC: He was born into an Idumaean family that was rising fast by making itself useful to Rome. Herod’s people came from Idumaea, the dry country south of Judea that the Old Testament calls Edom. About fifty years before his birth the Jewish king John Hyrcanus had conquered the Idumaeans and required them to be circumcised and to live by the Jewish law, so Herod was born a Jew by religion but an outsider by descent. His father Antipater was the shrewd chief minister of the weak Jewish high priest and ruler Hyrcanus II, John Hyrcanus’s grandson, and in practice the man who ran things; his mother Cypros came from a distinguished Arab family of the Nabataean kingdom, whose capital was Petra. That mixed descent followed him all his life, the way a family name can follow a man into rooms where he would rather not be known. When the Romans later offered him a throne, his rival for it, a prince of the old Jewish royal family named Antigonus, sneered that Herod was "a private man, and an Idumean, i.e. a half Jew" (Josephus, Antiquities 14.403). His court historian, Nicolaus of Damascus, answered by inventing for him a pedigree from the leading Jews who had come back from exile in Babylon five centuries before, the closest thing Judea had to old nobility, which Josephus dismissed as flattery. A Christian writer of the third century, Julius Africanus, preserved a hostile story that his grandfather had been a temple servant in the Philistine city of Ascalon; it is a tradition, and not a kind one. What the family had instead of a pedigree was a talent for picking the winning Roman. When Julius Caesar was trapped in Alexandria in 48–47 BC, Antipater marched troops to his rescue, and Caesar rewarded him with Roman citizenship and the government of Judea.
(●) 47 BC: Made governor of Galilee as a young man, he executed a bandit chief without trial and faced down the Sanhedrin. Antipater put his sons to work. The elder, Phasael, got Jerusalem; Herod got Galilee, the northern district where Jesus would grow up. Josephus says Herod was fifteen at the time, which cannot be right if he died at about seventy, and most historians think a copyist turned twenty-five into fifteen. Either way he was young, and he moved fast. He hunted down a bandit chief named Hezekiah, who had been raiding across the Syrian border, and put him and many of his men to death. The Syrian villages loved him for it. In Jerusalem the leading men were alarmed. Jewish law did not allow a governor to kill a man the Sanhedrin, the nation’s supreme council of priests and elders, had not condemned, and the mothers of the dead men came to the Temple every day demanding justice. Herod was summoned to trial. He arrived in purple with his hair trimmed and an armed guard at his back, and the council sat in silence. One member, whom Josephus calls Sameas, broke it: every other man brought before this court, he said, had come humbly in mourning clothes, and this one had come ready to kill his judges; and he warned that the man they were about to let go would one day punish them all. Hyrcanus adjourned the case, and Herod slipped out of the city before a verdict. Josephus adds the sequel. When Herod became king, he put to death the members of that council, sparing Sameas, whom he honored for his courage.
(●) 40–37 BC: Driven out by a Parthian invasion, he fled to Rome, was voted king of the Jews by the Senate, and won his kingdom back with Roman legions. In 40 BC the Parthians, Rome’s great rival empire to the east, swept into Syria and set Antigonus, the prince who would later sneer at Herod’s birth and the last fighting member of the old Jewish royal house, on the throne in Jerusalem. That royal house was the Hasmonean family, the descendants of the Maccabees who had freed Judea from Greek rule a century before. Herod’s brother Phasael was taken prisoner and killed himself in captivity. Old Hyrcanus had his ears mutilated so that, under the law of Leviticus, which barred any man with a bodily blemish from serving at the altar, he could never serve as high priest again. It was a cruelty with a lawyer’s precision. Herod got his family out by night to the rock fortress of Masada, by the Dead Sea, and went looking for help. The Nabataean king sent word that he was not welcome; he crossed to Egypt, sailed through a winter storm, and reached Rome. There, with Mark Antony and the young Octavian speaking for him, the Senate declared him king of Judea. It was meant, Josephus says, as a way of opposing the Parthians, and Herod had not even expected it: he had come asking the crown for a young Hasmonean prince, the brother of Mariamme, the princess Herod meant to marry. He left Rome after seven days. It took him three years of hard fighting to collect the kingdom he had been given. In 37 BC, with the Roman general Sosius and some eleven legions, he took Jerusalem after a long siege. While the siege works were going up he slipped away to Samaria and married Mariamme, granddaughter of both Hyrcanus and the brother who had fought Hyrcanus for the throne, binding himself to the royal house he was replacing. Antigonus was sent in chains to Antony and beheaded.
(●) 35–28 BC: One by one he destroyed the royal family he had married into, and last of all Mariamme, the wife he loved. The Hasmoneans were the family the people loved, and Herod could neither do without them nor bear them. Mariamme’s younger brother Aristobulus was made high priest at seventeen, and when he stood at the altar at the Feast of Tabernacles (the autumn harvest festival, when families camped for a week in shelters of branches) in his robes, tall and handsome, the crowd wept for joy. Within weeks, at a party in the palace gardens at Jericho, Herod’s men held him under in a swimming pool until he drowned. Herod wept at the funeral. Hyrcanus, past eighty and harmless, was put to death in 30 BC on a charge of plotting with the Nabataeans. Mariamme was the hardest case, because Herod loved her. Twice, when he left the country on business that might have cost him his life, he left secret orders that if he did not come back she was to be killed, so that no other man would have her; twice she found out. His sister Salome fed his suspicions, and in 29 BC Mariamme was tried before the court and executed. Josephus says she went to her death without changing color. Herod fell into a grief that was close to madness, calling for her through the palace as if she were alive, and then into a sickness that nearly killed him. Her mother Alexandra was executed the next year.
(●) 25–10 BC: At peace and rich, he became the greatest builder the Jewish homeland had ever had, and in 20 BC he began rebuilding the Temple. The same man could be generous on a grand scale. When drought and plague struck in the thirteenth year of his reign, about 25 BC, and there was no grain left to buy at any price, Herod stripped the gold and silver furniture from his own palace, sparing not even his finest vessels, and sent the money to Egypt to buy grain for his people. Josephus says it won back, for a time, even those who hated him. Then he built. On a straight coast with no natural harbor he made one, sinking enormous breakwaters into open sea, and around it raised a whole Greek city with a theater and a temple to Rome and Augustus (the title the young Octavian took in 27 BC as Rome’s first emperor). He named it Caesarea, after the emperor; Paul would later sit two years in its prison (Acts 23–26). He rebuilt Samaria as Sebaste (the Greek form of "Augustus"). He crowned the cliffs of Masada with palaces and storerooms, raised an artificial mountain south of Bethlehem for a fortress-palace he called Herodium, and built a fortress beside the Temple named Antonia, after Antony. Abroad he paid for colonnades, gymnasiums and temples in Greek cities, and endowed the failing Olympic Games. In the eighteenth year of his reign, about 20 BC, he announced the work he hoped would make his name forever: rebuilding the Temple in Jerusalem (T2). The sanctuary itself was finished in a year and a half, by priests trained as masons so that no unqualified hands touched the holy place; the courts took eight years more; and work on the great complex went on long after his death. Some of its retaining walls still stand today, and the stones are as wonderful as the disciple said.
(●) 7 BC: Convinced his sons were plotting against him, he had two of them strangled. Herod married ten women in all, and his household became a nest of rival sons, mothers and aunts. Mariamme’s two sons, Alexander and Aristobulus, were raised in Rome and came home as princes the people favored, proud of their royal Hasmonean blood. Their half brother Antipater, son of Herod’s first wife Doris, and their aunt Salome worked on the old king for years with whispers and forged evidence. Augustus himself tried to reconcile father and sons. In the end Herod accused them before a court held at Berytus (modern Beirut), with Roman permission, and in 7 BC the two young men were strangled at Sebaste, the city where their father had married their mother. A story preserved centuries later by the Roman writer Macrobius has Augustus remark, on hearing of Herod’s killings, that it was better to be Herod’s pig than his son. The joke works in Greek, where "pig" (hys) and "son" (huios) sound alike, and it turns on a fact: a Jewish king would never slaughter a pig.
(●) 4 BC: Dying in agony at Jericho, he killed one more son, and was carried to his tomb at Herodium. His last years were savage. Over the great gate of the Temple he had set a golden eagle, and two teachers of the law, Judas and Matthias, urged their students to pull it down because the law forbade images. The young men did it in broad daylight; Herod had the leaders burned alive. That very night, Josephus notes, there was an eclipse of the moon, the astronomical marker by which most historians date his death. In these same last years, by Matthew’s account, wise men from the east came to Jerusalem asking where the newborn king of the Jews was. Herod sent them on to Bethlehem, and when they did not come back he ordered every boy in Bethlehem and its region two years old or under to be killed (Matthew 2:1–18). Josephus does not mention it; his account is crowded with killings at court, and Bethlehem was a village where the boys of that age may have numbered a dozen or two. It is the kind of order Josephus describes Herod giving again and again. His disease, which Josephus describes in harrowing detail, drove him to the hot springs near the Dead Sea and back to his palace at Jericho. Five days before he died he had Antipater, the son who had schemed against his brothers, executed for plotting against him. He died about seventy, having ruled thirty-four years from the taking of Jerusalem and thirty-seven from his crowning in Rome, and he was carried on a golden bier to Herodium for burial. His kingdom was divided among three sons: Archelaus in Judea, Antipas in Galilee (the Herod of the trial of Jesus), and Philip in the north. In 2007 the archaeologist Ehud Netzer announced that he had found the tomb on the slope of Herodium, after a search of more than thirty years.
What He Stood For
(T1) A king of the Jews could survive only as a faithful friend of Rome. Herod wrote no philosophy, but he lived by a creed, and he stated it most clearly on the worst day of his political life. In 31 BC his patron Mark Antony was beaten at sea at Actium by Octavian, the man who would soon be called Augustus. Every ruler who had backed Antony expected to lose his throne or his head. Herod sailed to meet the victor at Rhodes, took the crown off his head before the meeting, and then did something no one expected: he did not beg. He told Octavian that he had been Antony’s loyal friend, that he was not ashamed of it, and that a man who could be that loyal to Antony could be just as loyal to him. Octavian put the crown back on his head, and within months added territory to his kingdom. The scene shows Herod’s whole understanding of power. He was a client king, a local ruler who held his throne because Rome found him useful, the way a regional manager keeps his post only as long as head office is pleased with the numbers. Judea’s peace, his own survival, and in his mind the good of the Jewish people all ran through one channel: Rome’s trust. Everything he built, and much of what he destroyed, was built or destroyed to keep that channel open. That made him, for many of his subjects, a foreign tyrant in a Jewish crown. It is also why the Gospels can say that Jesus was born under Caesar Augustus and under Herod at once (Luke 2:1; Matthew 2:1): in that world the two were not rival powers but one.
(Q) "But if thou wilt put him out of the case, and only examine how I behave myself to my benefactors in general, and what sort of friend I am, thou wilt find by experience that we shall do and be the same to thyself, for it is but changing the names, and the firmness of friendship that we shall bear to thee will not be disapproved by thee." Source: Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 15.6.6 (15.193) (Whiston translation). Herod to Octavian at Rhodes in 30 BC. "Him" is Mark Antony: set aside my friendship with Antony, Herod says, look at what kind of friend I have been to every patron, and you will find the same loyalty turned toward you. Ancient historians composed speeches in the speaker’s voice to give the substance of what was said, so these are Herod’s words as Josephus reports them, not a transcript; Josephus here likely drew on Nicolaus of Damascus, who knew the king well.
(T2) The God of Israel deserved a Temple worthy of him, and Herod meant to be the king who gave it. Think of a family that has lived for generations in a house that was rebuilt in a hurry after a fire: sound, but smaller than the one their grandparents remember. That was the Temple in Herod’s day. The Jews who came back from exile in Babylon had rebuilt it in the late 500s BC, under Persian kings who set its dimensions, and the old men who remembered Solomon’s Temple wept when they saw how modest the new one was (Ezra 3:12). Herod proposed to put that right. When he announced the plan, the people were frightened that he would tear the old Temple down and never finish the new one, so he promised not to touch it until every stone and timber was ready, and he kept his word: a thousand wagons, ten thousand workmen, and a thousand priests trained as builders. The result doubled the Temple platform and made it the largest sacred enclosure in the Roman world. The rabbis, who had no love for Herod, still said that whoever had not seen Herod’s building had never seen a beautiful building. Was it piety or self-advertisement? Probably both, and Herod’s own speech mixes them freely. He thanked God for his kingdom and in the same breath reminded his hearers how well regarded he was by the Romans. But the building itself became something he could not have imagined. It was the Temple where the infant Jesus was presented (Luke 2:22), where the boy Jesus sat among the teachers (Luke 2:46), and where the grown man taught daily, and it was of this building that Jesus said not one stone would be left upon another (Mark 13:2).
(Q) "But since I am now, by God's will, your governor, and I have had peace a long time, and have gained great riches and large revenues, and, what is the principal thing of all, I am at amity with and well regarded by the Romans, who, if I may so say, are the rulers of the whole world, I will do my endeavor to correct that imperfection, which hath arisen from the necessity of our affairs, and the slavery we have been under formerly, and to make a thankful return, after the most pious manner, to God, for what blessings I have received from him, by giving me this kingdom, and that by rendering his temple as complete as I am able." Source: Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 15.11.1 (15.387) (Whiston translation). The close of Herod’s speech to the assembled people announcing the rebuilding, about 20 BC, again in the form Josephus gives it. "That imperfection" is the Temple’s height, sixty cubits (about ninety feet) short of Solomon’s.
(T3) Whatever threatened the throne had to die, whether a rival, a wife, a son, or a child in Bethlehem. There is a pattern to Herod’s killings, and once it is seen, it explains them all. He did not kill at random. He killed whoever could be held up as a better claim to his crown: the bandit chief who defied his authority, the boy high priest the crowds cheered, the old king, the royal wife, the sons with royal blood, and at the end the son who had grown impatient to inherit. Each one was a person around whom Jews unhappy with an Idumaean king might rally. That is why the scene in Matthew fits him so exactly. Strangers arrive at his court asking, "Where is he who has been born king of the Jews?" (Matthew 2:2). Herod was king of the Jews by vote of the Roman Senate; here was talk of one who was king of the Jews by birth, of David’s line, in David’s town. Josephus never mentions the wise men, but he would have recognized the reaction instantly. Herod’s answer was what it always was: friendly words in public, and an order to kill. Matthew adds a detail that Josephus would also have recognized. Herod did not send soldiers with the wise men; he sent the wise men alone, with a pious message, and waited. The man who rebuilt God’s house could speak of worship while planning murder.
(Q) "Go and search diligently for the child, and when you have found him, bring me word, that I too may come and worship him." Source: Matthew 2:8 (English Standard Version). Herod to the wise men, after he had called them to him secretly and learned from them when the star appeared. Matthew records what followed: warned in a dream, they went home another way, and Herod, "when he saw that he had been tricked by the wise men, became furious" (Matthew 2:16).
(Q) "I shall die in a little time, so great are my pains; which death ought to be cheerfully borne, and to be welcomed by all men; but what principally troubles me is this, that I shall die without being lamented, and without such mourning as men usually expect at a king's death." Source: Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 17.6.5 (17.175) (Whiston translation). Herod to his sister Salome and her husband Alexas on his deathbed at Jericho. He had summoned the leading men of the whole nation and locked them in the hippodrome, and he ordered that they be killed the moment he died, so that every family in the land would be weeping at his funeral. Salome and Alexas released them instead. He wanted a nation in mourning; the only mourning Scripture records from his reign is Rachel weeping for her children (Matthew 2:18).
What the Church Made of Him
(†) His reign fixes the birth of Jesus in history, a few years before the date our calendar assumed. Matthew and Luke wrote independently of each other and tell very different nativity stories, yet both set the birth of Jesus in Herod’s reign (Matthew 2:1; Luke 1:5). That agreement matters, because Herod’s reign is one of the best-dated stretches of ancient history: the Roman consuls in office each year, an Olympiad (the four-year cycles, counted from the Olympic Games, by which Greeks numbered their years), a lunar eclipse, and Josephus’ careful count of his years all converge. It also explains a puzzle that surprises many readers: Jesus was born "before Christ." Our calendar of years "AD" (anno Domini, "in the year of the Lord") was worked out by a monk named Dionysius Exiguus in AD 525, and he placed the birth of Jesus a few years too late. Since Herod was alive when Jesus was born, and the usual dating has Herod dead in 4 BC, Jesus was born around 6 to 4 BC. The error is Dionysius’s, and the correction comes straight from the Gospels’ own anchor in Herod.
(†) The church honored the boys of Bethlehem as the first to die for Christ, and kept Herod as the picture of a ruler who rages against him. Matthew read the killing at Bethlehem through the prophet Jeremiah, who had heard Rachel, the mother of Israel, weeping for her children carried into exile: "A voice was heard in Ramah, weeping and loud lamentation, Rachel weeping for her children; she refused to be comforted, because they are no more" (Matthew 2:18; Jeremiah 31:15). Israel’s old grief, in Matthew’s telling, came round again in Herod’s Bethlehem. The early church honored those boys as the first martyrs, children who died in place of the Christ they never knew. Around AD 400 the Latin poet Prudentius was greeting them in a hymn as the "flowers of the martyrs," cut down on the threshold of life; the feast of the Holy Innocents, kept in December in the West, became one of the oldest days of the Christmas season, and the Eastern churches keep it too. Even a pagan writer of the early fifth century, Macrobius, knew the story: he tells Augustus’ joke about Herod’s pig and his son as a remark made when the emperor heard that among the boys under two years old killed on Herod’s order, the king’s own son had died. Herod himself passed into Christian imagination as the pattern of the frightened tyrant: the king who heard of a child born to rule and "was troubled, and all Jerusalem with him" (Matthew 2:3). The medieval mystery plays made him a ranting villain, and the cardboard crown in the Christmas pageant is his descendant.
(†) Where his own record condemns him: murder for the sake of power, and a temple to God built beside temples to Caesar. The ledger here needs no help from later legend; Josephus, who used the king’s own court historian, supplies all of it. - Blood. He had his wife Mariamme, three of his sons, his brother-in-law the high priest, Hyrcanus his wife’s grandfather, and Mariamme’s mother put to death, and he burned the teachers who pulled down his eagle. Josephus’ own verdict at his death is "A man he was of great barbarity towards all men equally, and a slave to his passion" (Antiquities 17.191). The killing of the boys of Bethlehem (Matthew 2:16) is of a piece with all of it. - Divided worship. He rebuilt the house of the God of Israel and in the same years built temples to Rome and Augustus at Caesarea, Sebaste and Paneas, where the emperor was honored as a god. The God whose house he adorned had said, "You shall have no other gods before me" (Exodus 20:3). - The law of the king. Moses’ law for Israel’s kings had warned, "And he shall not acquire many wives for himself, lest his heart turn away, nor shall he acquire for himself excessive silver and gold" (Deuteronomy 17:17). Herod married ten wives and gathered wealth on a scale few kings of his time could match, and his household became the engine of his worst crimes. Matthew tells his story with one quiet irony. The man who held the title "king of the Jews" by a vote in Rome tried to kill the child born to it, and the title came back, at the end of the Gospel, nailed over a cross: "This is Jesus, the King of the Jews" (Matthew 27:37). Herod built a temple that would be torn down within a lifetime of his death. The child he sought to kill spoke of another temple, his own body, and said that if it were destroyed he would raise it up in three days (John 2:19–21).