Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Hammurabi of Babylon r. c. 1792 – 1750 BC
(●) The Babylonian king who carved his laws on a stone for anyone to read, and whose code is the standing comparison for the law of Moses. Walk into the Mesopotamian galleries of the Louvre in Paris and one object stops nearly everyone: a black stone pillar a little taller than a tall man, its whole surface packed with tiny wedge-shaped writing. At the top a king stands with his hand raised to his mouth in the gesture of prayer, facing a seated god with rays of light rising from his shoulders. The god is Shamash, the sun, who in Babylon was also the judge of heaven and earth. The king is Hammurabi, and the writing below, some four thousand lines of it, holds close to three hundred laws that he set up near the end of his reign so that "the strong should not harm the weak." He is on a Christian site because of what happened when that stone was found in 1901 and 1902. For the first time, readers of the Bible could set a full law collection from Abraham’s world beside the law given at Sinai and read them line by line. The two share a great deal: an eye for an eye, the ox that gores, the false witness who suffers the penalty he meant for another. They differ at exactly the points that show what each thinks a human life is worth. Hammurabi is the best witness we have to how far a conscientious ancient king could get toward justice, and the clearest measure of what was new in the law of Israel. A word about the dates, because they are slipperier than they look. No document tells us when Hammurabi was born, so his dates are the years of his reign, and even those are a convention. Babylonian king lists give him forty-three years on the throne, and those years are firm relative to one another, the way you might know that your grandfather’s farm came three years after the war without knowing which war. Pinning the first of them to our calendar depends on reconstructions of ancient astronomy that historians still argue over. The years given, c. 1792 to 1750 BC, belong to the "middle chronology," the convention most textbooks follow. The "low chronology" puts the same reign at 1728 to 1686 BC, and L. W. King, whose 1900 translation of his letters is quoted in (T4), placed him around 2200 BC. Every date for his reign slides together with that choice, which is why each one carries a "c."
(●) c. 1792 BC: He inherited a small kingdom on the Euphrates, one power among many. Hammurabi was the son of Sin-muballit and the sixth king of a family that had ruled Babylon for about a century. They were Amorites, descendants of a Semitic-speaking people (Semitic is the language family that includes Hebrew and Arabic) who had drifted in from the western steppe and settled into the old cities of Mesopotamia, the land between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers in what is now Iraq. When he took the throne, Babylon was a modest city-state, and nobody in the region would have bet on it. To the south, Rim-Sin of Larsa had ruled for decades over the old cities of Sumer, the far south of the river plain, where the Sumerians had built some of the world’s first cities. To the east sat Eshnunna, and beyond it the great power of Elam in what is now southwestern Iran. To the north the Assyrian conqueror Shamshi-Adad was building an empire that swallowed the city of Mari on the middle Euphrates. His first official act that we know of was not a battle. Babylonian kings named each year after something they had done, the way a family might remember "the year we moved" or "the year the roof fell in," and his second year was named for the occasion when he "established justice in the land." The word in Akkadian, the Semitic language Babylon spoke and wrote, is mîšarum, and it meant something concrete: a royal decree cancelling certain debts, usually the loans ordinary farmers took out for seed and food, so that families who had fallen behind could start again. He would issue more than one in his reign.
(●) c. 1792 – 1765 BC: For nearly thirty years he dug canals, rebuilt temples, and waited. Read down the list of his year names and the first three decades look less like a conqueror’s than a builder’s: a temple throne here, a city wall there, a canal dug, a statue dedicated. There were campaigns. In his seventh year he raided Uruk and Isin, cities Larsa held, and in his tenth he fought Malgium to the east. But neither raid made those cities his for good, and for most of these years he kept his head down, strengthening what he had while bigger neighbors did the fighting. The great northern empire fell apart when Shamshi-Adad died, around 1775 BC, and a prince of the old royal house, Zimri-Lim, retook the throne of Mari. Hammurabi became his ally. We know the diplomatic weather of those years unusually well because Mari’s palace archive survived, thousands of clay letters. One of them, from Itur-Asdu, an official reporting to Zimri-Lim, sums the situation up in a line historians love to quote. No king, he says, is strong on his own. Ten or fifteen kings follow Hammurabi of Babylon, as many follow Rim-Sin of Larsa, as many Ibal-pi-El of Eshnunna and Amut-pi-El of Qatna, and twenty follow Yarim-Lim of Yamhad. Think of a schoolyard with five big kids, each with a ring of smaller ones around him. Babylon was one of several great powers, and not the greatest of them.
(●) c. 1764 – 1763 BC: He helped turn back Elam, then conquered Larsa and doubled his kingdom. The turn came from the east. Elam seized Eshnunna and pressed on toward Babylon and Mari, and the Mesopotamian kings, who normally spent their energy on one another, formed a coalition and drove the invaders back. Hammurabi named a year for it. Then he turned on the partner he thought had not pulled his weight. Rim-Sin of Larsa had ruled the south for some sixty years, longer than most of his subjects had been alive, and he had sent little help against Elam. With troops from Mari at his side, Hammurabi besieged Larsa and took it, around 1763 BC, and the next year’s name records that he had overthrown Rim-Sin and brought his land under Babylon. Overnight the small kingdom on the Euphrates held the ancient heartland of Sumer, Ur and Larsa and Uruk, the city where writing itself had been invented. One of his first acts as the new ruler of the south was another debt-release decree for its people.
(●) c. 1763 – 1750 BC: He governed the south by letter, down to the dredging of a single canal. Few kings of ancient Mesopotamia left as many letters as Hammurabi did, well over a hundred of them, and dozens went to one man, Sin-iddinam, his governor at Larsa. Reading them is like opening a manager’s inbox. A canal has been cleared, but not all the way to Uruk, so boats cannot get into the city; the work "is not too great for the men that are at thy disposal," and it is to be finished in three days. The calendar has drifted out of step with the seasons, so the month now beginning is to be counted as a second Elul (Elul being a late-summer month, and the second one an extra month inserted the way we add a leap day), and the taxes due on the twenty-fifth of the following month are to arrive on the twenty-fifth of the extra one instead. And again and again, cases. A man complains that a money-lender has laid claim to land he has held from of old; the governor is to look into it, and if the lender took it on pledge (that is, as security for a loan, the way a pawnshop holds a watch), give it back and punish him. A bribe is reported in a town of metalworkers; the governor is to seal up the bribe and send the man who took it and the witness to Babylon. Behind the stone’s grand claims stands a king who personally read petitions and expected his officials to answer them.
(●) c. 1761 – 1759 BC: He conquered Eshnunna and then Mari, the city of his old ally, and tore down its walls. The alliances that had carried him lasted exactly as long as he needed them. Eshnunna fell, and its defeat named his thirty-second year. Then he marched up the Euphrates against Zimri-Lim, the king whose soldiers had helped him take Larsa, and his thirty-third year is named for defeating the armies of Mari and Malgium. Two years later he destroyed the walls of both cities. Mari was never a great city again. There is an irony in it that a historian cannot help feeling. The destruction of Mari’s palace is the reason its archive survived: buried under fallen walls, the clay letters lay undisturbed for some thirty-seven centuries until French archaeologists dug them out in the 1930s. Most of what we know about the diplomacy of Hammurabi’s world we know because he burned the house where it was filed.
(●) c. 1755 – 1750 BC: Near the end he set up his laws in stone, and died with his son already at the helm. The law stele belongs to the last years of the reign. A stele (say "STEE-lee") is what archaeologists call an upright slab of stone carved with an inscription, something like a tall gravestone set up in a public square. Its prologue lists, city by city, the places Hammurabi had conquered and the temples he had enriched, and that list includes conquests from the 1760s, so the text was composed after them. Copies were set up in more than one city; the epilogue speaks of one in Esagila, the great temple of Marduk in Babylon, and the surviving stone probably stood at Sippar, the city of the sun god Shamash. His last years were not strong ones. Two clues point that way. Works for Nergal, lord of the underworld, are recorded in his fortieth year, and a letter from his son Samsu-iluna seems to speak of the old king as gravely ill. Together they suggest that Samsu-iluna was already ruling for his father, the way a grown son takes over the family business while the old man still keeps the title, before Hammurabi died in the forty-third year of his reign, around 1750 BC. The empire did not long survive him. Within about a decade the southern cities rose in revolt and much of what he had joined together came apart again.
(●) c. 1155 BC – 1902 AD: His stone was carried off as plunder, buried for three thousand years, and found again at Susa. Six centuries after Hammurabi’s death, the Elamite king Shutruk-Nahhunte raided Babylonia and carried a cartload of its monuments home to Susa as trophies, the stele among them. Several columns near the bottom of the front were polished smooth, apparently to make room for an inscription of his own that was never carved, and with them went a few dozen of the laws. The stone lay in the ruins of Susa until a French expedition under Jacques de Morgan dug it up in three pieces in the winter of 1901 to 1902. Within months the Dominican scholar Jean-Vincent Scheil had published a transcription and a French translation, and he numbered the laws from 1 to 282, a numbering everyone still uses. Copies on clay tablets, some made in Hammurabi’s own century and some more than a thousand years later, have since filled in most of the erased laws. Babylonian scribes went on copying his prologue and laws as a school text for well over a millennium, which tells you what the stone meant to the people who first read it.
What He Taught
(T1) The gods made the king a shepherd, and called him to see that the strong do not crush the weak. Picture a shepherd on a hillside at dusk. His job is not to be loved by the sheep; it is to keep the wolves off and to stop the big rams from shoving the lambs away from the water. That is the picture Hammurabi reaches for again and again. He calls himself "the shepherd of the oppressed and of the slaves" and "the salvation-bearing shepherd, whose staff is straight." The prologue explains where the king’s authority comes from. The great gods of Babylon (Anu, the sky god, and the one the translator calls Bel, "lord," meaning Enlil, king of the gods) had raised Marduk, Babylon’s own god, to rule over mankind, and then called Hammurabi by name to bring righteousness to the land. Kingship in this picture is a commission from heaven, and the purpose of the commission is protection: of the weak against the strong, of the widow and the orphan against those who would take what little they have. A Christian reader will recognize the language. In one psalm God takes his place in judgment and demands, "Give justice to the weak and the fatherless" (Psalm 82:3), and the prophets measure Israel’s kings by exactly this standard. The difference lies in who speaks. In Hammurabi’s world the gods appoint the king and the king makes the law; at Sinai the law comes from God himself, and the king, when Israel gets one, is under it like everyone else.
(Q) "Then Anu and Bel called by name me, Hammurabi, the exalted prince, who feared God, to bring about the rule of righteousness in the land, to destroy the wicked and the evil-doers; so that the strong should not harm the weak." Source: Code of Hammurabi, Prologue (L. W. King translation, 1910). The sentence continues: "so that I should rule over the black-headed people like Shamash, and enlighten the land, to further the well-being of mankind." The "black-headed people" was the old Sumerian name for the people of Mesopotamia, their name for themselves. King’s "who feared God" renders an Akkadian phrase that modern translators give as "who reveres the gods"; Hammurabi worshipped many.
(T2) A punishment should match the injury, and its weight depends on who was injured. Most of the laws are written as cases: "If a man does this, then that shall be done to him." Lawyers call this casuistic law, from the Latin word for a case, and the method is the same one a modern court uses when it builds on precedent. A few hundred real situations are settled, and a judge reasons from them to the one in front of him. The most famous cases are the ones about injury. If a man puts out another man’s eye, his own eye is put out; if he breaks another man’s bone, his own bone is broken. The legal name for this is lex talionis, Latin for "the law of retaliation in kind," and its point is usually misunderstood. It is not a license for revenge. It is a ceiling: one eye for one eye, and not a blood feud that wipes out a family over a fight in the street. But the very next laws change the price according to the victim. Hammurabi’s society had three ranks: the full citizen (the awîlum), the commoner of lower standing, often a dependent of the palace (the muškênum, whom the older translators call a "freeman" or "freed man"), and the slave. Put out a citizen’s eye and you lose your own; put out a commoner’s and you pay a mina of silver; put out a slave’s and you pay his owner half the slave’s price. Exodus also says "eye for eye, tooth for tooth" (Exodus 21:24), and then it says something no line of Hammurabi says: a master who destroys his own slave’s eye must set the slave free because of it (Exodus 21:26).
(Q) "If a man destroy the eye of another man, they shall destroy his eye. If one break a man’s bone, they shall break his bone. If one destroy the eye of a freeman or break the bone of a freeman he shall pay one mana of silver. If one destroy the eye of a man’s slave or break a bone of a man’s slave he shall pay one-half his price." Source: Code of Hammurabi, laws 196–199 (Robert Francis Harper translation, 1904). Four laws in a row, and the whole social order of Babylon in them. A mana (the same unit as the mina) was about half a kilogram, roughly a pound of silver; at the code’s own wage for a hired laborer, six grains of silver a day (law 273), that is about five years’ pay. (A grain was a tiny weight, 10,800 of them to the mina.) Imagine a fine today that took five years of a working man’s wages, and you have the price of a commoner’s eye. L. W. King’s 1910 translation, used in (T1) and (T3), reads "gold" in law 198, but the Akkadian word is silver. The slave’s compensation goes to the owner, not to the slave.
(T3) Justice must be written down where a wronged person can read it for himself. Think of the notice of tenants’ rights a landlord in many places must post in the hallway. The landlord may never read it. The point is that the tenant can, and that nobody can pretend afterwards that the rules were secret. Hammurabi’s epilogue imagines his stone working the same way. A man with a grievance is to come and stand before the king’s image, read the inscription, and find his case explained there, so that his heart will be glad. Historians have noticed something odd about this. Thousands of legal documents survive from Hammurabi’s Babylon, contracts and court records of every kind, and almost none of them cites the code. Most scholars now think the stele was less a statute book in the modern sense than a royal monument to justice: a carefully edited collection of model verdicts, showing gods, citizens and future kings what a righteous king’s judgments look like. But the instinct behind it is real and important. Law that is published binds the king who publishes it, and a written standard can be held up against the powerful. Its rules on procedure, the rules about how a case is brought and decided, show the same instinct. A man who brings a capital charge (one that carries the death penalty) and cannot prove it is himself put to death. The law of Moses holds the false witness to the same principle: he suffers the penalty he meant for his neighbor (Deuteronomy 19:18–19). Contracts need witnesses, so that a sale cannot be denied later. And a judge whose written verdict proves wrong through his own fault pays twelve times the penalty he set and is removed from the bench for good, which is a remarkable thing to ask of a king’s own judges.
(Q) "Let the oppressed, who has a case at law, come and stand before this my image as king of righteousness; let him read the inscription, and understand my precious words: the inscription will explain his case to him; he will find out what is just, and his heart will be glad." Source: Code of Hammurabi, Epilogue (L. W. King translation, 1910). The "image" is the carved relief at the top of the stone, the king standing before Shamash. In a world where few could read, the invitation was partly a figure of speech; a scribe would have read the lines aloud. It is still a remarkable thing for a king to say.
(T4) The king answers for the honesty of his officials and for the poor who fall into debt. An ancient farmer’s whole year hung on the harvest. A bad one meant borrowing seed at high interest, and another bad one meant handing over the only security he had left: his land, and after that his wife and children, sent to work in the lender’s house until the debt was paid. Left alone, that ratchet only turns one way. Hammurabi pushed against it. Law 117 says that when a debtor sells his wife, son or daughter into service for debt, they shall work three years, and in the fourth year they shall go free. Another law protects a farmer whose crop is ruined by storm or drought: he owes no grain to his creditor that year (law 48). The debt-release decrees went further still, cancelling whole classes of debt at a stroke. And the letters show him chasing money-lenders who seized land on pledge and officials who took bribes, as if every case in the kingdom eventually landed on his own desk. Readers of the Bible will hear Israel’s release laws behind this: the Hebrew servant who went free in his seventh year of service, the debts released every seventh year, and the jubilee every fiftieth (Exodus 21:2; Deuteronomy 15:1–2; Leviticus 25:10). The concern is shared. The grounds are not: in Babylon release is a gift of the king’s favor, while in Israel it is owed because the people themselves were slaves whom God set free (Deuteronomy 15:15).
(Q) "When thou shalt behold this tablet, thou shalt examine into the matter, and, if bribery hath taken place, set a seal upon the money or upon whatsoever was offered as the bribe, and cause it to be brought unto me." Source: Hammurabi to Sin-iddinam, Letter VIII (L. W. King, The Letters and Inscriptions of Hammurabi, vol. III, 1900, pp. 20–22). An official named Summan-la-ilu has reported a bribe in the town of Dur-gurgurri and can name the man who took it and a witness. Hammurabi sends him back to the governor with two officers and these orders, and adds that once Summan-la-ilu points them out, the man who took the bribe and the witness are to be sent on to Babylon. King spells the governor’s name Sin-idinnam.
(Q) "That the strong might not injure the weak, in order to protect the widows and orphans, I have in Babylon ... set up these my precious words, written upon my memorial stone, before the image of me, as king of righteousness." Source: Code of Hammurabi, Epilogue (L. W. King translation, 1910). The omitted words name the temple, Esagila, and add that the stone was set up "to bespeak justice in the land, to settle all disputes, and heal all injuries." Widows and orphans: a millennium later, Israel’s prophets would hold their own kings to the same two words (Isaiah 1:17).
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Found in 1902, his code was first heard as a charge that Moses had copied Babylon. The stele came out of the ground in the middle of a quarrel. In January 1902 the German Assyriologist (a scholar of ancient Mesopotamia’s languages and history) Friedrich Delitzsch began a famous series of lectures called Babel und Bibel, "Babylon and the Bible," arguing that much of the Old Testament was borrowed from Babylon and that Christianity owed less to Israel than it supposed. The newly published code seemed to hand him his proof: here, centuries older than Moses, were laws about goring oxen, kidnapping, false witnesses and an eye for an eye. Christian scholars answered quickly, and the answer has held up. Shared laws are what you expect when two peoples share a world. Two towns a few hundred miles apart will both have rules about stray dogs, and nobody concludes that one copied the other. Oxen gored people in Canaan as in Babylon, and the custom of settling it had been handed down across the region for centuries before either collection was written. The older Sumerian law collection of Ur-Namma shows that Hammurabi was himself drawing on a long tradition. What decides the question is not the overlap but what each law does with it, and there the differences are not accidental. The English Assyriologist and Anglican clergyman C. H. W. Johns translated the code into English in 1903, and in his Schweich Lectures of 1912, the British Academy’s lectures on biblical archaeology, he laid its laws side by side with those of the Hebrews; scholars since have only sharpened the contrast. Many Bible readers of that generation also hoped to find Hammurabi in Genesis, as "Amraphel king of Shinar," one of the four kings Abraham defeated (Genesis 14:1). The names do not match well, and the identification has now been all but given up.
(†) Read side by side, the two laws part at the value of a human life. The comparison that has done the most good came from the Jewish biblical scholar Moshe Greenberg, in a 1960 essay called "Some Postulates of Biblical Criminal Law," and Christian Old Testament scholars such as Christopher J. H. Wright have built on it since. Greenberg asked what each law assumes without saying, and found a pattern that runs through the whole of the Torah, the five books of Moses that open the Bible. - Life and property are never traded. In Hammurabi, theft can carry the death penalty, while the death of a commoner or a slave from a blow is settled in silver. In the Torah no crime against property is punished by death, and a deliberate murder can never be bought off: "you shall accept no ransom for the life of a murderer" (Numbers 35:31). - Each one dies for his own sin. Hammurabi’s builder whose house falls and kills the owner’s son loses his own son; a man who kills a pregnant woman forfeits his daughter. Moses forbids it outright (Deuteronomy 24:16). - One rule for everyone. The Torah has no separate scale of penalties for nobles and commoners, and applies the same rule to the foreigner as to the native (Leviticus 24:22). Kenneth Kitchen and other evangelical scholars have added a point about form. Hammurabi’s laws sit inside a king’s inscription; Moses’ laws sit inside a covenant, an agreement between God and a people he has rescued, laid out with a history, terms, witnesses, blessings and curses. Law in Babylon is the king’s good government. Law at Sinai is the shape of a relationship.
(†) Christians read his prologue as Paul’s law written on the heart, carved in stone. The contrast is not the whole story, and Christian readers have never wanted it to be. A pagan king, with no Bible and no prophet, knew that the strong must not crush the weak, that widows and orphans needed a protector, that a judge who takes a bribe has betrayed his office, and that a debt should not swallow a family forever. Paul says Gentiles who have never heard the law "by nature do what the law requires" and "show that the work of the law is written on their hearts" (Romans 2:14–15). Theologians call this general revelation: what every human being can know of God’s will through conscience and the created order, as distinct from the special revelation given in Scripture. Seen that way, the stone in the Louvre is evidence for something the Bible claims rather than against it. Moral knowledge did not begin at Sinai, and Israel was not given a law written in a vacuum. What Israel was given was a law that took the conscience every nation already had and corrected it, raising the slave, the foreigner and the child to the same worth as the free man. Moses could ask, without boasting, "what great nation is there, that has statutes and rules so righteous as all this law that I set before you today?" (Deuteronomy 4:8), and Hammurabi’s stone is the best way we have of seeing what he meant.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: the source of law, the worth of persons, and punishment. Honesty requires the other column of the ledger, and it is drawn from what Hammurabi himself set in stone. - The source of law. Hammurabi received his commission from many gods, served Marduk above them, and gave the laws as his own: "the law of the land which I have given." Scripture knows one God, and law as his word, binding the king as much as the shepherd (Deuteronomy 17:18–20). - The worth of persons. His code prices an eye by the rank of the man who loses it and pays the slave’s compensation to the master. Scripture grounds human worth in the image of God shared by all (Genesis 1:27), and frees the slave whose eye his master destroys (Exodus 21:26). - The runaway slave. Hammurabi made it a capital crime to help a slave escape through the city gate or to hide a runaway (laws 15–16, 19). The Torah commands the opposite: "You shall not give up to his master a slave who has escaped from his master to you" (Deuteronomy 23:15). - Punishment. He punished children for their fathers’ crimes and put thieves to death. Scripture punishes each person for his own sin and asks the thief to repay (Exodus 22:1; Deuteronomy 24:16). - Righteousness itself. He presents himself as the king of righteousness whose deeds are unequalled. The gospel finds no one righteous by his own works (Romans 3:10), and offers a King who makes the unrighteous right with God by grace (Romans 3:23–24). Hammurabi saw much of what justice requires, and he deserves the admiration he gets. The stone shows how far a good king could reach, and where a better law had to come down to meet him.