Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
R. C. Sproul of Pittsburgh 1939 – 2017 AD
(●) R. C. Sproul was the teacher at the chalkboard who spent fifty years telling ordinary Christians that God is holy, and that they could understand why it matters. Picture a big man in a blazer, pacing in front of a chalkboard, a piece of chalk in one hand, a Latin phrase on the board, and a room full of accountants, homemakers and truck drivers leaning forward to catch the next sentence. That was R. C. Sproul at work, and for half a century he did it in study centers, conference halls, radio studios and finally a church pulpit in Florida. He refused to talk down to anyone. He believed laypeople, the ordinary members of a church who are not clergy, could handle real theology if someone took the trouble to explain it well. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. He was one of the last century’s best-known defenders of classical apologetics, the old method that reasons from what anyone can know (that something exists, that effects have causes) up to God, and he defended it inside a Reformed world that mostly preferred another method. And he spent his life on one theme above all the others: the holiness of God, the truth that God is utterly unlike us in purity and majesty, and that this is the beginning of understanding everything else. The fact a reader is likely to remember is the epitaph. He wrote or edited more than a hundred books and argued hard with friends and foes alike, yet the stone over his grave at Saint Andrew’s Chapel says simply: "He was a kind man redeemed by a kinder Savior."
(●) 1939 AD: Born in Pittsburgh, he grew up on baseball and lost his father at seventeen. Robert Charles Sproul was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, on February 13, 1939, the second child of Robert Cecil Sproul, an accountant, and Mayre Ann Sproul. The boy everyone called "Sonny" lived for the Pirates and the Steelers, and he was good enough at baseball to be traded between youth teams in a deal that made the local papers. He met a girl named Vesta Voorhis at the elementary school between their homes in Pleasant Hills, he in first grade and she in second, and he later said he knew then whom he would marry. The happy years did not last. His father, home from the Second World War, suffered a series of strokes, and at fifteen Sproul gave up high school sports to help keep the family afloat. His father died in his son’s senior year of high school. One of his last sentences was a line from Paul’s final letter: "I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have kept the faith" (2 Timothy 4:7). The boy had watched his father read the Bible for years but had never read it himself, did not recognize the words, and snapped back, "Don’t say that!" It was the last thing he ever said to his father, and he carried the shame of it for the rest of his life.
(●) 1957 AD: In his first week of college a single verse about a fallen tree turned him to Christ. In September 1957 Sproul arrived at Westminster College, a Presbyterian school an hour north of Pittsburgh, on an athletic scholarship. On the first weekend he and his roommate set out to leave the dry campus, where no alcohol was allowed, for a drink across the Ohio line. He was out of cigarettes, so they went back to the dormitory machine, and there the star of the football team invited them to sit down. They talked for more than an hour. What struck Sproul was that, for the first time in his life, he was listening to someone who spoke as though he knew Jesus personally. The verse that undid him was an odd one: "in the place where the tree falls, there it will lie" (Ecclesiastes 11:3). He saw himself as that tree, fallen, going nowhere and rotting where it lay. That night he knelt by his bed and asked God to forgive him. He liked to joke that he was probably the only person in church history converted by that particular verse. He read the whole Bible in his first weeks as a Christian, and what seized him was the holiness of God, especially in the Old Testament. In The Holiness of God he later told of being drawn out of bed one night in those college years, walking to the empty chapel, and kneeling in the dark in what felt like waves of dread and then of peace. In February 1958 Vesta visited, went to a prayer meeting with him, and gave her life to Christ as well. They were married on June 11, 1960, and he graduated in philosophy the next year.
(●) 1961 AD: At seminary he fought Calvinism for over a year, then surrendered to it, and was ordained a Presbyterian minister. At Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, a school of the liberal mainline church (the "mainline" is the old, established Protestant denominations, which by then often treated much of the Bible’s teaching as open to revision), Sproul came under John Gerstner, a church historian and one of the few convinced Calvinists on the faculty. (Calvinism, or Reformed theology, is the tradition that runs from John Calvin and stresses God’s sovereign choice in salvation.) Sproul did not want it. By his own account he challenged Gerstner in class time after time and made a total pest of himself. He kept a note on his desk where he could not miss it: he was required to believe and preach what the Bible says is true, not what he wanted it to say. In his senior year a semester on Jonathan Edwards’s Freedom of the Will, alongside a one-on-one Greek course on Romans, finished the argument. Gerstner became his mentor for life. Gerstner sent him to the Free University of Amsterdam in 1964 to study under G. C. Berkouwer, the leading Dutch Reformed theologian of the day. He arrived knowing no Dutch and spent his first day working through a single page with a dictionary, one word to a card. Then home called him back. In 1965, with Vesta expecting their second child and his mother ill, he returned to teach philosophy at Westminster College. On July 1 his mother died and his son was born, the worst and the best of that year arriving on the same day; two weeks later, on July 18, he was ordained in the United Presbyterian Church. The next few years were restless ones. He taught at Gordon College and at Conwell School of Theology in Philadelphia, served a church in Cincinnati, and in 1969 went back to Amsterdam to sit the examinations for the doctorandus, the Dutch degree that qualifies a student to write a doctoral dissertation. He never wrote it, because by then the ministry had taken over his life.
(●) 1971 AD: He opened a study center in the Ligonier Valley, and from it led the fight for an inerrant Bible. In February 1970 a Pittsburgh widow named Dora Hillman, who had come to know his teaching through his ministry at the Cincinnati church, visited the Sprouls and proposed a Christian study center on fifty-two acres in the Ligonier Valley, an hour east of Pittsburgh. In 1971 the family moved to the village of Stahlstown and the Ligonier Valley Study Center opened, modeled in part on L’Abri (French for "the shelter"), the home in the Swiss Alps where Francis Schaeffer and his wife Edith took in young people with hard questions about faith. Students ate and slept in the staff homes, and the teaching went on at dinner tables as much as in classrooms. Sproul saw the work as filling the gap between Sunday school and seminary. A newsletter named Tabletalk, after Martin Luther’s mealtime conversations with his students, began in 1977 and grew into a daily Bible-study magazine. The center also became a headquarters for the defense of Scripture. The question of the hour was inerrancy, the belief that the Bible, as originally written, teaches no error in anything it affirms. Think of an honest witness in court: he may round his numbers or describe a sunrise the way everyone does, but he never tells you something false. Sproul hosted a conference on biblical authority in 1973 and drafted the Ligonier Statement on inerrancy. That work fed into the International Council on Biblical Inerrancy, founded in 1977, which Sproul served as president, and into its Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy of 1978, of which he and Norman Geisler were among the chief architects. In the middle of all this, in 1975, he left his mainline denomination for the more conservative Presbyterian Church in America.
(●) 1984 AD: Ligonier moved to Orlando, and in three years he published the three books that defined him. In 1984 the study center became Ligonier Ministries and moved to Orlando, Florida. Sproul was by then teaching part of each year at Reformed Theological Seminary in Jackson, Mississippi, and when the seminary opened its Orlando campus in 1989 he became its first academic dean. In the middle of that busy stretch, a man running a ministry and teaching seminary classes on the side brought out one defining book in each of three successive years, and those three carried his name furthest. Classical Apologetics (1984), written with Gerstner and Arthur Lindsley, made the case for reasoning from the world to God and answered Cornelius Van Til’s rival method head on (T3). The Holiness of God (1985) grew out of a series he had first given at a Young Life camp in 1970, and became the book most readers meet first. Chosen by God (1986) defended the Reformed doctrine of predestination for readers who had never opened a theology textbook. Asked late in life which of his books to read, he named The Holiness of God and Chosen by God: the first, he said, shows the transcendent majesty of God, and the second, His sovereignty.
(●) 1994 AD: He went on daily radio, and spent the decade defending justification by faith alone against friends who had signed a truce. The daily radio program Renewing Your Mind first aired in 1994, carrying his lectures to stations around the world. The same year a group of evangelical and Roman Catholic leaders, among them his friends Chuck Colson and J. I. Packer, released "Evangelicals and Catholics Together," a statement of shared witness that spoke of a common faith in Christ. Sproul believed it gave away the heart of the Reformation, the sixteenth-century break with Rome led by Luther and Calvin, whose central conviction was that a sinner is put right with God by faith alone. He said so, in print and from the platform, for years. Faith Alone (1995), Getting the Gospel Right (1999) and later Are We Together? (2012) all came out of that dispute (T4). In 1995 he also finished seven years of work as general editor of the New Geneva Study Bible, later revised as the Reformation Study Bible, with notes by more than fifty scholars. And the decade held one brush with death: in September 1993 he was a passenger on the Amtrak train that plunged off a bridge into a bayou near Mobile, Alabama, in the deadliest wreck in Amtrak’s history, and he walked away to tell the story.
(●) 1997 AD: At fifty-eight he finally took a pulpit, preached in it for twenty years, and died in December 2017 at seventy-eight. In 1997 a small new congregation near Orlando, Saint Andrew’s Chapel in Sanford, called him as its minister of preaching and teaching. It began in Ligonier’s recording studio and met in a movie theater before it had a sanctuary of its own. He preached through whole books of the Bible verse by verse, and called it the highlight of his life; his one great regret, he said, was waiting until he was fifty-eight to do it. In 2011 Ligonier opened Reformation Bible College, with Sproul as its first president. He was not a man without struggles, and he did not hide them. He fought a smoking habit from his student days, and in one sermon he told how, as a young believer, he painted a picture of Jesus on a cigarette pack to shame himself into quitting, then turned the pack over and smoked anyway. He recovered from a stroke in April 2015, but he lived with emphysema. He preached his last sermon on November 26, 2017, entered the hospital on December 2 with an emphysema flare made worse by influenza, and died on December 14, 2017. He had once written that when he died he expected to be "jumping over fire hydrants down the golden streets."
What He Taught
(T1) God is holy, holy, holy, and every other thing true of Him is true in a holy way. Think of the moment a driver sees blue lights in the mirror. A second ago he was humming along at eighty; now, for the first time all morning, he is measuring himself against the law, and he does not like what he sees. Sproul believed something like that happens, far more deeply, whenever a human being catches sight of God as He is. His text was Isaiah 6. The prophet sees the Lord enthroned in the temple, and the seraphim, the fiery angels around the throne, call to one another, "Holy, holy, holy is the Lord of hosts; the whole earth is full of his glory!" (Isaiah 6:3). Hebrew often marks emphasis by repetition, and Sproul pointed out that only here is one of God’s attributes raised to the third degree. Holiness, in his teaching, means first that God is "other," set apart from everything He made, and then that He is perfectly pure. It is not one attribute on a list; it describes all the rest. God’s love is holy love, His justice holy justice. The consequence runs through everything else he taught. Isaiah, in Sproul’s reading the most upright man in the nation, cried, "Woe is me! For I am lost" (Isaiah 6:5), because for the first time he had measured himself by the real standard. So Sproul could call sin "cosmic treason," a phrase that found its way into Bartlett’s Familiar Quotations, and he could say that the real puzzle of the gospel is not why God judges anyone but why He forgives anyone at all.
(Q) "Only once in sacred Scripture is an attribute of God elevated to the third degree. Only once is a characteristic of God mentioned three times in succession. The Bible says that God is holy, holy, holy. Not that He is merely holy, or even holy, holy. He is holy, holy, holy. The Bible never says that God is love, love, love; or mercy, mercy, mercy; or wrath, wrath, wrath; or justice, justice, justice." Source: R. C. Sproul, The Holiness of God, second edition (Tyndale House, 1998), chapter 2, "Holy, Holy, Holy." Sproul is reading the song of the seraphim in Isaiah 6:3, and drawing from its threefold repetition the point that holiness is the attribute Scripture most emphatically assigns to God (T1).
(T2) God rules every part of what He made, down to the last molecule. Imagine one loose grain of sand in a finely built watch. It does not take much: one grain in the wrong gear and the whole mechanism can stop. Sproul used a picture like that in his seminary classes. He would ask students whether God controls every single molecule in the universe, and tell them the answer would not decide whether they were Calvinists or Arminians (the two Protestant camps in the old argument over predestination, the second named for the Dutch theologian Jacobus Arminius), but whether they were theists, people who believe in God at all, or atheists. If even one "maverick molecule" ran loose outside God’s control, it might be the grain that changes history and keeps God from keeping His promises. Sovereignty, in this teaching, means God’s rightful rule and real power over everything He made. Sproul saw it as part of what it means to be God at all, and he drew from it the Reformed doctrine of predestination, that God chooses whom He will save, which he defended in Chosen by God. He insisted that this does not make people puppets: human beings really choose, and they choose according to their desires, which is why fallen people need God to change their hearts before they will come to Him. Here many Christians part company with him on how God’s choosing and ours fit together. Wesleyan and Arminian believers, and Catholic and Orthodox ones, hold that God’s grace goes before every human turn toward Him and can be resisted. Sproul knew the debate thoroughly and wrote a whole history of it, Willing to Believe. On the first point, though, that nothing at all escapes God’s government, Christians of every tradition stand with him.
(Q) "If there is any element of the universe that is outside of his authority, then he no longer is God over all. In other words, sovereignty belongs to deity. Sovereignty is a natural attribute of the Creator. God owns what he makes, and he rules what he owns." Source: R. C. Sproul, Now, That’s a Good Question! (Tyndale House, 1996), from his answer on the sovereignty of God; the answer is reprinted by permission of Ligonier Ministries. The sentences come straight after his "maverick molecule" illustration (T2), in a book of short answers to questions that listeners had sent him.
(T3) Faith is not a leap into the dark, because the case for God can be made with reason. Sproul liked to prove God from a shoe. If the shoe on your foot exists, he argued, something must exist on its own, not borrowed from anything else, or nothing would exist at all. It was a homely way of putting one of the oldest arguments in philosophy, and it shows his method. Classical apologetics, the approach of Thomas Aquinas and of most Christian thinkers before the twentieth century, starts from truths any honest person already uses (that a thing cannot both be and not be in the same way at the same time, which philosophers call the law of non-contradiction; that every effect has a cause; that our senses are basically reliable) and reasons from them to God, then to the reliability of the Bible and the claims of Christ. His Reformed colleagues mostly preferred presuppositionalism, the method of Cornelius Van Til, which holds that an unbeliever cannot reason rightly about God at all until he grants the truth of Christian faith, so the apologist argues from that starting point rather than toward it. Sproul answered that no one can even begin to argue, presuppositionalists included, without using the law of non-contradiction, and that Scripture itself appeals to evidence. Paul says God’s "eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse" (Romans 1:20). That same text kept him humble about what arguments can do. He held that unbelievers already know God exists and suppress the knowledge for moral rather than intellectual reasons, so that even an argument that cannot be answered will not change a heart unless the Holy Spirit goes with it. Why argue, then? To silence scoffers, to steady believers under attack, and to clear the ground for the gospel.
(Q) "We don’t ever ask people to jump into the absurd or to jump into the darkness. We ask them to jump out of the darkness and into the light." Source: R. C. Sproul, answer to the question "Since everyone knows God (Rom. 1:18–23), how does that affect our defense of the faith?", Ask R.C. Live event (July 2014), transcript published by Ligonier Ministries. He had just told a story of addressing a college atheist club and telling them, to their fury, that their problem was not that they did not know God exists. The line explains why he went on giving arguments anyway (T3).
(T4) God declares sinners righteous for Christ’s sake alone, received by faith alone. Picture a courtroom. The defendant is guilty, the record is complete, and the judge knows every line of it. Then a stranger steps forward and offers his own spotless record to be entered in the defendant’s name, and the judge accepts it. That picture is roughly what the Reformers meant by justification, and Sproul spent much of his life explaining it. Justification is God’s verdict that a sinner stands right with Him. Imputation is the word for how that verdict can be just: God reckons, or credits, Christ’s perfect obedience to the believer, as He reckoned the believer’s sin to Christ on the cross. Faith is the empty hand that receives it, the one instrument, adding nothing of its own. Sproul quoted Paul: "For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law" (Romans 3:28). Good works follow as surely as fruit follows a living root, but they are never the ground of the verdict. In the Reformers’ old saying, which he loved, we are justified by faith alone, but not by a faith that is alone. He took care to state the Roman Catholic view accurately, and urged Protestants to do the same. Rome also teaches that faith is necessary and that justification is by grace from first to last. The dividing question, as he framed it, was the ground of the verdict: the Council of Trent, the sixteenth-century council at which the Roman Catholic Church answered the Reformers, taught that God declares righteous those in whom His grace has made real righteousness inhere, that is, dwell within them as truly their own, while the Reformers taught that the only ground is Christ’s righteousness credited to the believer. Put back in the courtroom, Trent has the judge pronounce the defendant just because grace has actually made him just; the Reformers have the judge pronounce him just because the stranger’s record has been entered in his name.
(Q) "Trent said that God does not justify anyone until real righteousness inheres within the person. In other words, God does not declare a person righteous unless he or she is righteous. So, according to Roman Catholic doctrine, justification depends on a person’s sanctification. By contrast, the Reformers said justification is based on the imputation of the righteousness of Jesus." Source: R. C. Sproul, Are We Together? A Protestant Analyzes Roman Catholicism (Reformation Trust, 2012); the passage is reprinted by Ligonier Ministries as "What Does the Roman Catholic Church Believe About Justification?" Sanctification is the lifelong work of God making a believer actually holy; Sproul’s point is that Trent, as he read it, makes the verdict wait on that work, while the Reformers rest it on Christ (T4).
(T5) Everyone is a theologian, and the whole of life is lived before the face of God. Anyone who has ever said "God would never do that" has done theology. Sproul made the point constantly, and in his last years gave it a book title, Everyone’s a Theologian (2014). Everyone has some idea of God, he said, and draws conclusions from it, so the only question is whether a person will be a good theologian or a bad one, carefully taught by Scripture or carelessly guessing. That conviction is why he built a ministry for laypeople rather than an academic career, and why he scattered Latin phrases across his chalkboard and then patiently explained every one. His favorite of those phrases was coram Deo, Latin for "before the face of God." A businessman once asked him for the big idea of the Christian life, and that was his answer. The prodigal son ran off to a far country so that no one would see what he did; the Christian life, Sproul said, is the opposite, a life lived openly in God’s presence every moment, with no secret rooms. It was his way of tying holiness (T1) to an ordinary Tuesday.
(Q) "Now we add to that a couple of other ideas, that the big idea of Christianity is to live Coram Deo, to live all of one’s life in the presence of God, under the authority of God, to the honor and to the glory of God." Source: R. C. Sproul, Pleasing God teaching series (Ligonier Ministries), transcript published by Ligonier as "The Big Idea of Christianity" (2017). He has just told the story of the businessman’s question and explained the phrase as Luther used it (T5).
What the Church Made of Him
(†) He taught Reformed theology to more laypeople than anyone of his century, and a generation of pastors learned it from him. For millions of Christians who never set foot in a seminary, Sproul was the seminary. His recorded lecture series, first on reel-to-reel tape and videocassette from the Ligonier Valley, then on radio and online, covered the history of philosophy, the doctrine of God, the Reformation, and how to read the Bible. Tabletalk put a daily Bible study on hundreds of thousands of kitchen tables. The Reformation Study Bible put Reformed notes in the margins of the Bible itself. The fruit is visible in the revival of Reformed theology among younger evangelicals in the early twenty-first century, which the journalist Collin Hansen called "young, restless, Reformed." Sproul belonged to the older generation of teachers that movement drew on, and his books and tapes were for many readers their first meeting with the doctrines of grace, the Reformed name for the teaching that salvation is God’s sovereign work from start to finish, often summed up as the five points of Calvinism. Friends and colleagues honored him in 2003 with a Festschrift, a volume of essays written in a scholar’s honor, titled After Darkness, Light, with contributions from Robert Godfrey, Sinclair Ferguson, Michael Horton, John MacArthur and others. Christians outside his tradition, who did not share his Calvinism, still read The Holiness of God with gratitude.
(†) He kept classical apologetics alive among the Reformed, and the argument over method he joined is still going. In 1977, at Reformed Theological Seminary in Jackson, Mississippi, Sproul debated Greg Bahnsen, Van Til’s most forceful student, on how a Christian should defend the faith. Seven years later Classical Apologetics set out the case at book length and devoted its final section to a respectful but sharp critique of Van Til. Presuppositionalists answered in turn, arguing that Sproul gave unbelieving reason more credit than a fallen mind deserves. John Frame, himself a student of Van Til, reviewed the book at length. He pressed it on the unbeliever’s claim to judge by his own standard, and confessed surprise at how close its authors came to Van Til at various points. The practical effect was that a Reformed Christian no longer had to choose between Calvin and Aquinas. Sproul showed that a man could hold the Westminster Confession, the seventeenth-century statement of faith many Presbyterians still subscribe to, and still use the classical arguments for God’s existence, and later Reformed thinkers who have revived interest in Aquinas walk through a door he helped hold open.
(†) His stand against "Evangelicals and Catholics Together" divided friends, and both sides have been heard. The 1994 statement was the sharpest public dispute of his life, because the men on the other side were allies. It was like two teammates who agree completely about who the opponent is and still cannot agree on the rules of the game. J. I. Packer and Chuck Colson signed it believing that evangelicals and Catholics who confess the same Christ could stand together against a secular culture without pretending their doctrinal differences away. Sproul believed that a statement calling the two communions united in the gospel, while they still disagreed on how a sinner is justified, conceded the very point the Reformation had been fought over. He pressed the case in Faith Alone and in conferences through the rest of the decade, and many evangelicals were persuaded by him. Catholic readers, for their part, have answered that the Council of Trent teaches justification by grace from beginning to end, with no one able to merit its beginning, and that the righteousness God works in a believer is His gift, not a human achievement. Some Protestant scholars also questioned parts of his history. A 2004 article in the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society judged Faith Alone basically right about the Reformers, but pressed it on two points: what its thesis implied for Augustine and the church before Luther, and its silence about a century of Catholic dialogue with Luther. The disagreement over the ground of justification itself remains where Sproul said it was.
(†) Where he fell short: for some years he described saving grace with a violent metaphor, and later gave it up. The record of his own teaching holds one thing worth criticizing. In his 1984 novel Johnny Come Home, and again in a 1989 lecture series, Sproul described the Holy Spirit’s work in conversion as a "holy rape of the soul," meaning that God overcomes the resistance of a dead heart. He meant it as an image of utter helplessness before grace, and in a 1996 lecture, granting that some people were violently offended by the language, he still called it the most graphic and descriptive term he could think of for how he himself had been redeemed. Critics objected that the image is false to how Scripture describes God’s drawing, and Arminian writers singled it out as a portrait of grace that does violence to the person it saves. To his credit, he dropped it. By the early 2000s he was teaching that the Spirit draws people to Christ not by coercion, not by dragging them against their will, but by changing the heart, so that what once seemed unpleasant now looks sweet and desirable. That is the better account, and it was his own.