Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Cleanthes of Assos c. 330 – c. 230 BC
(●) The boxer turned water-carrier who succeeded Zeno at the head of the Stoics and wrote one of the most devout prayers the pagan Greeks have left us. Picture a big, slow, poor man hauling buckets of water through Athenian gardens by lamplight so that he can sit in a philosophy lecture all the next day. His classmates call him "the ass." He laughs and says that only an ass is strong enough to carry the load his teacher puts on him. That man, Cleanthes, went on to lead the Stoic school for more than thirty years, and he wrote a short poem to God that Christian readers have long admired. The Stoics were the most influential school of philosophy in the world the apostles preached to. They taught that a divine Reason runs through all things and steers the world, that virtue is the only true good, and that a wise person follows God willingly. Zeno founded the school; Chrysippus, Cleanthes’ own pupil, built its system out in full. Cleanthes stands between them, and he is the one who prayed. When Paul stood before Stoic philosophers in Athens and told them that "some of your own poets" had called human beings God’s offspring (Acts 17:28), his words echoed a line of the kind Cleanthes had written. We should be honest that his dates are not certain. Most of what we know about him comes from Diogenes Laertius, a third-century AD collector of philosophers’ lives, and even he could not settle how long Cleanthes lived: some authorities, he reports, put his age at death equal to Zeno’s, and another ancient source gives ninety-nine. So the years in his title are the conventional ones, about 330 to about 230 BC, and every date worked out from them below is approximate. The fact most readers remember about him is a small one. He was too poor to buy writing material, so he took down Zeno’s lectures on oyster shells and the shoulder blades of oxen.
(●) c. 330 BC: Born at Assos, a Greek town on the coast of the Troad, and trained first as a boxer. Cleanthes was the son of a man named Phanias, from Assos, a hilltop town in the Troad, the corner of northwest Asia Minor (modern Turkey) around the old site of Troy. From its walls you look south across the water toward the island of Lesbos. Aristotle had lived there for a few years shortly before Cleanthes was born. The birth year is worked out backward from the uncertain age at death, so "about 330 BC" is a convention rather than a record. The first thing the ancient sources tell us about him is that he was a pugilist, a boxer. Greek boxing was a brutal sport, fought with leather thongs wrapped around the fists, and it took a strong body and a stubborn temper. Both would show up again later in his life, put to a different use.
(●) c. 281 BC: He arrived in Athens, the story goes, with four drachmas, found Zeno, and stayed nineteen years as his student. Some say he came to Athens with four drachmas in his pocket, a few days’ wages for a laborer. There he met Zeno of Citium, who taught in the Painted Stoa, a public colonnade on the edge of the marketplace that gave the Stoics their name. Cleanthes "studied philosophy right nobly," says Diogenes Laertius, "and adhered to the same doctrines throughout." The year of his arrival is a calculation, not a record: Diogenes says he spent nineteen years as Zeno’s pupil, and Zeno is conventionally dated to have died around 262 BC. He paid his way with his hands. By night he drew water from wells to irrigate gardens; by day he sat in on arguments. The Athenians nicknamed him Phreantles, "the Well-lifter." Diogenes adds that he also ground meal for a woman who sold it, and that Zeno made him hand over an obol, a small coin, from his wages each day, as a lesson in discipline.
(●) c. 281–262 BC: A court asked how so strong a man made his living, and his witnesses were a gardener and a woman who sold meal. Athens had an old law, credited to Solon, the city’s great lawgiver of some three centuries before, against living in idleness. A sturdy young man with no visible income who spent his days listening to philosophers looked suspicious. Diogenes Laertius does not name the charge, but he tells how Cleanthes was brought before the court to explain how so strong a fellow made his living. He produced two witnesses: the gardener whose garden he watered and the woman whose meal he ground. The judges of the Areopagus, the city’s old council, were so impressed that they voted him a gift of ten minas. A mina was a hundred drachmas, so for a man who had come to Athens with four drachmas this was a small fortune. Zeno would not let him take it. He was not quick. Diogenes calls him "extraordinarily slow" and without natural aptitude for physics, and Zeno compared him to a hard wax tablet, the kind schoolchildren wrote on: difficult to write on, but it kept whatever was written. His fellow students mocked him, and the playwright Sositheus once insulted him by name from the stage while he sat in the audience. He did not move, the crowd applauded him and hissed the poet off, and when the poet apologized, Cleanthes accepted it. His reasoning was simple. Dionysus, the god of wine, and Heracles, the strongman hero, were mocked by the poets all the time without getting angry, he said, so it would be absurd for an ordinary man like him to mind.
(●) c. 262 BC: When Zeno died, the slow student was chosen over the brilliant ones to lead the school. Zeno had cleverer pupils than Cleanthes, and some of them went off to found variations of their own. Yet, as Diogenes puts it, "although Zeno had many other eminent disciples, he was able to succeed him in the headship of the school." He led the Stoa from about 262 BC until his death some three decades later. The kings of the age took notice. Antigonus Gonatas of Macedon, who had admired Zeno, is said to have attended his lectures and given him three thousand drachmas. When Ptolemy of Egypt wrote asking Cleanthes to come to his court or to send someone, his pupil Sphaerus went instead. His most important student was a former long-distance runner from Soli, on the southern coast of Asia Minor, named Chrysippus, sharper than his teacher and impatient with him. Chrysippus wanted his teacher’s conclusions and nothing more, because he trusted himself to supply the reasoning. "All he wanted was to be told what the doctrines were," Chrysippus used to say; "he would find out the proofs for himself." Yet after arguing against Cleanthes he would feel remorse and quote a line of Euripides about it.
(●) c. 262–230 BC: He defended the Stoic picture of the world against its rivals, and once urged that an astronomer be charged with impiety. As head of the school Cleanthes wrote, by Diogenes’ count, about fifty works: on the gods, on duty, on pleasure, on kingship, four books interpreting Heraclitus, and replies to rival philosophers. Among those rivals was Arcesilaus, head of Plato’s Academy, who had turned it toward skepticism, the view that we should suspend judgment because nothing can be known for certain. Yet when someone criticized Arcesilaus in his presence, Cleanthes defended him. The complaint was that Arcesilaus did not do his duty, and a philosophy that doubts everything does seem to leave no firm ground for it. But whatever his theory did to duty, he said, Arcesilaus kept it in his life. It is a generous thing to say about a rival. He also wrote a reply to Aristarchus of Samos, the astronomer who proposed that the earth moves around the sun. Plutarch, the Greek biographer and essayist writing about four centuries later, reports that Cleanthes thought the Greeks ought to indict Aristarchus, that is, bring formal charges against him, for impiety, for setting in motion the hearth of the universe, the earth fixed at the center of all things. That is the text as modern editors print it. The manuscripts have the two names swapped, and editors have corrected them since the seventeenth century. For a Stoic the cosmos was a living divine body, and moving its center seemed to him an offence against the gods. Nothing indicates the charge was ever brought.
(●) c. 230 BC: An old man with a gum infection, he began a fast on his doctors’ orders and chose not to end it. He lived to a great age, and he joked about it. When someone teased him for being old, he said he too was ready to depart, but seeing that he was still healthy and could still read and write, he was content to wait. Diogenes Laertius tells how the end came. Cleanthes developed a severe inflammation of the gums, and his doctors told him to go without food for two days. The treatment worked, and they told him he could eat again. He refused, "declaring that he had already got too far on the road," and fasted until he died. The Stoics held that a wise person might rightly choose the moment of leaving life, and he took that teaching literally. How old he was at the end, we simply don’t know. Diogenes reports that some authorities made his age the same as Zeno’s, whose own age is reported as both ninety-eight and seventy-two, while a treatise on long lives, handed down among the works of the second-century AD satirist Lucian, gives ninety-nine. Chrysippus took over the school. He was not forgotten at home. Some eight centuries later Simplicius, a Neoplatonist (one of the late followers of Plato who rebuilt his philosophy into a system), wrote a commentary on the handbook of the Stoic teacher Epictetus, and in it he noted that a statue of Cleanthes set up by decree of the Roman senate still stood at Assos.
What He Taught
(T1) The ordered motion of the heavens shows that a mind governs the world. Imagine walking into a house you have never seen before. The floors are swept, the meals come on time, every servant knows his task. You have not met the owner, but you do not for a moment suppose the household runs itself. Somebody is in charge. Cleanthes used exactly that picture. Cicero, the Roman statesman who wrote the most important surviving survey of ancient arguments about the gods, reports that Cleanthes gave four causes for why human beings believe in gods: our sense that the future can be foretold; the good things the earth and seasons give us; the terror that thunder, plague, and earthquake strike into us; and, strongest of all, the regular, beautiful order of the sun, moon, and stars. The first three explain where the belief comes from. The fourth is an argument that it is true: order on that scale, unbroken across countless ages, is not the work of chance. This is one of the oldest forms of what philosophers call the design argument, the case that the order of nature points to an intelligent orderer. Christians would take it up gladly. Where they parted from Cleanthes was over who the orderer is: for him, the governing mind was finally inside the world, not its Creator (see the final row).
(Q) "His fourth cause, and that the strongest, is drawn from the regularity of the motion and revolution of the heavens, the distinctness, variety, beauty, and order of the sun, moon, and all the stars, the appearance only of which is sufficient to convince us they are not the effects of chance; as when we enter into a house, or school, or court, and observe the exact order, discipline, and method of it, we cannot suppose that it is so regulated without a cause, but must conclude that there is some one who commands, and to whom obedience is paid." Source: Cicero, On the Nature of the Gods II.13–15 (C. D. Yonge translation, Bohn’s Classical Library, 1878, Book II chapter V). These are Cicero’s words, put in the mouth of Balbus, the Stoic speaker of the dialogue, summarizing Cleanthes’ argument. Cleanthes’ own book does not survive, so this report is the oldest account of his argument we have (T1).
(T2) One divine Reason runs through all things, and human beings alone bear its likeness. Think of the way a person’s life runs through every part of the body, warm in the hand, quick in the eye. The Stoics thought of God that way: a living, fiery breath that pervades the whole universe and holds it together, thinking in it and steering it. They called it the logos, a Greek word meaning both "word" and "reason," and they also called it Nature, Fate, and, in the old language of Greek religion, Zeus. Cleanthes’ great poem, the Hymn to Zeus, addresses this God directly. A hymn is a song of praise sung to a god, and the startling thing about this one is how personal it sounds. Zeus is "invoked by many a name," but he is one; he pilots the world "in harmony with Law"; and human beings may speak to him because they are his offspring, the only creatures on earth that share in his reason. That line is the one Christians have never forgotten. When Paul spoke to the philosophers in Athens, Stoics among them (Acts 17:18), he quoted a Greek poet: "For we are indeed his offspring" (Acts 17:28). Paul’s exact words match a line by Aratus, a poet said to have studied with Zeno, but Cleanthes’ hymn says almost the same thing, and Paul’s "some of your own poets" is plural. Either way, Paul was meeting his hearers on ground Cleanthes had helped prepare.
(Q) "Thee it is meet that mortals should invoke, / For we Thine offspring are, and sole of all / Created things that live and move on earth / Receive from Thee the image of the One." Source: Cleanthes, Hymn to Zeus, lines 3–5 of the Greek in Blakeney’s numbering (E. H. Blakeney translation, 1921). The whole hymn survives only because Stobaeus, a fifth-century AD compiler of extracts, copied it into his anthology. "Meet" is old English for "fitting": it is right for human beings to call on God, because they are his children (T2).
(T3) Nothing happens apart from God except the evil that the wicked do, and God makes even that serve the whole. If God steers everything, where does evil come from? Every serious believer in providence, the idea that God governs the course of the world, runs into that question, and Cleanthes faced it head on in the middle of his hymn. His answer has two parts. First, the wicked are the authors of their own wickedness. Every work on earth, in the heavens, and on the sea is done through God, "save only what is done by sinners in their folly." Evil is the product of human ignorance and bad choices, people chasing fame, money, or pleasure and missing the law that would have given them a good life. Second, God is not defeated by it. Like a musician who weaves a wrong note back into the melody, God "fitted things together, good and evil," so that one everlasting Reason runs through all of it. Christian readers recognize both moves. Scripture also lays sin at the door of the sinner, and Joseph tells his brothers, "you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good" (Genesis 50:20). The difference is in what comes next: for Cleanthes the harmony is simply how the world is, while Scripture promises that evil will be judged and finally put away.
(Q) "No work is wrought apart from Thee, O God, / Or in the world, or in the heaven above, / Or on the deep, save only what is done / By sinners in their folly. Nay, Thou canst / Make the rough smooth, bring wondrous order forth / From chaos; in Thy sight unloveliness / Seems beautiful; for so Thou hast fitted things / Together, good and evil, that there reigns / One everlasting Reason in them all." Source: Cleanthes, Hymn to Zeus, lines 15–21 of the Greek in Blakeney’s numbering (E. H. Blakeney translation, 1921). The heart of the hymn: God’s rule reaches everywhere, the wicked alone act against it, and even their disorder is folded back into the order of the whole (T3).
(T4) The good life is following willingly where God leads, since the unwilling are led anyway. The Stoics had a famous picture for this. A dog is tied to the back of a moving cart. It can trot along beside the cart freely, or it can dig in its paws and be dragged. Either way it goes where the cart goes. The only choice it has is how it goes. Zeno had said the goal of life is to live "in agreement with nature." Cleanthes sharpened that: the nature we must agree with is the nature of the whole universe, God’s own reason, not merely our individual human nature. Virtue, for him, was that agreement, a settled understanding of the world that lines the will up with God’s. He taught that virtue can be taught, and, more strikingly, that once it is truly gained it cannot be lost, because it rests on a firm grasp of the truth. His short prayer "Lead me, O Zeus" became one of the most quoted things any Stoic ever wrote. The handbook of Epictetus, the great Stoic teacher of the early second century AD, opens its closing chapter with it, and Seneca, the Roman statesman and Stoic writer of Nero’s day, translated it into Latin, adding a line of his own that sums it up: fate leads the willing and drags the unwilling.
(Q) "Lead me, O Zeus, and thou O Destiny, / The way that I am bid by you to go: / To follow I am ready. If I choose not, / I make myself a wretch, and still must follow." Source: Cleanthes, quoted by Epictetus, Encheiridion 53 (George Long translation, 1877, where it is numbered LII). Epictetus tells his students to keep these lines "ready to hand" in every circumstance. Seneca gives a Latin version in his Moral Letters 107.11, and Augustine, quoting the Latin in City of God V.8, took the lines to be Seneca’s own (T4).
(Q) "O Thou most bounteous God that sittest throned / In clouds, the Lord of lightning, save mankind / From grievous ignorance! Oh, scatter it / Far from their souls, and grant them to achieve / True knowledge, on whose might Thou dost rely / To govern all the world in righteousness." Source: Cleanthes, Hymn to Zeus, lines 31–34 of the Greek in Blakeney’s numbering (E. H. Blakeney translation, 1921). The hymn ends as a prayer for rescue. Cleanthes knew human beings could not find their way to the good on their own, and he asked God to save them from the darkness of their minds. It is the place where a pagan philosopher comes closest to asking for grace.
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Paul met the Stoics in Athens on ground the hymn had prepared: one God, near to all, whose offspring we are. Luke records of Paul’s days in Athens, "Some of the Epicurean and Stoic philosophers also conversed with him" (Acts 17:18), and that they brought Paul to the Areopagus to explain himself. His speech there is the New Testament’s clearest example of preaching to people who had no Bible. He begins with what they already know: the God who made the world gives everyone life and breath, is not far from any of us, and is the one whose offspring we are (Acts 17:24–28). Those points were Stoic commonplaces, and Cleanthes had put them into a prayer. Theologians call this kind of common ground general revelation: what every human being can know of God from creation and conscience, as distinct from the special revelation given in Scripture. Paul does not stop there, though. He goes on to call for repentance, to announce a coming judgment, and to point to a man God raised from the dead (Acts 17:30–31), and that was the point at which "some mocked" (Acts 17:32).
(†) The church fathers quoted him as a pagan who had glimpsed the true God. Clement of Alexandria, a Christian teacher in Egypt around AD 200, collected the best things the Greeks had said about God to persuade pagans that their own wisest men pointed toward Christ. In his Exhortation to the Greeks he quotes Cleanthes’ verses on what the good is like ("ordered, holy, pious, just...") and says that Cleanthes "sets forth no genealogy of the gods, after the manner of poets, but a true theology." Clement read the lines as a description of God; his modern editors note that Cleanthes was describing the moral good, but the instinct is telling. Tertullian, writing in Carthage at about the same time, reached for the Stoics when explaining to Roman readers how Christians speak of God’s Word. Your own philosophers, he says, regard the Logos as the maker of the universe, and "Cleanthes ascribes all this to spirit, which he maintains pervades the universe" (Apology 21). Augustine, two centuries later, quoted the Latin version of "Lead me, O Zeus" in the City of God (V.8) and argued that Stoics who meant by fate the will and power of the supreme God had the substance right, so that he would not quarrel with them over a word.
(†) Modern Christian scholars have called the hymn the noblest expression of pagan devotion in Greek. The Hymn to Zeus has had a long second life among Christian readers. The great nineteenth-century English bishop and New Testament scholar J. B. Lightfoot called it the noblest expression of heathen devotion that Greek literature has preserved, and the 1921 edition by E. H. Blakeney, the translation quoted for the hymn (T2, T3), was published by a Christian society, the SPCK (the Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, an Anglican publisher), in its Texts for Students series. The reason is not hard to see. The hymn praises one sovereign God, confesses that the wicked go astray by their own folly, and ends by begging God to rescue human beings from ignorance. It shows what a sincere and serious man could reach by reasoning about the world, and it shows the longing that Paul said God had planted in every nation, "that they should seek God, and perhaps feel their way toward him and find him" (Acts 17:27).
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: God is not the world, the soul does not burn up with it, and rescue is from sin, not only ignorance. Cleanthes’ prayer is beautiful, and Christians have rightly loved it. But at four points the gospel says something he did not. - God and the world. Cicero reports Cleanthes saying in one place that the world itself is God, and Diogenes says he made the sun the ruling part of the cosmos. The Stoic God is a fiery body inside the universe, its soul. Scripture says the God who made the world is "Lord of heaven and earth" (Acts 17:24), distinct from what he made, and Paul warns against those who "worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator" (Romans 1:25). - The soul and the end. Cleanthes taught that all souls survive death, but only until the periodic conflagration, when the universe is consumed in fire and begins again. Scripture promises neither endless cycles nor a soul that finally dissolves, but one judgment and the resurrection of the dead (Acts 17:31; Hebrews 9:27). - What we need saving from. The hymn asks God to scatter ignorance and grant true knowledge. Paul told the Athenians, "The times of ignorance God overlooked, but now he commands all people everywhere to repent" (Acts 17:30). The gospel agrees that we are blind, but says the deeper trouble is sin, and that the rescue came by a person, not a lesson: God "has given assurance to all by raising him from the dead" (Acts 17:31). - His own deeds. Two things Cleanthes himself did sit uneasily with the God of the hymn. By Plutarch’s report, as editors have long corrected it, he wanted Aristarchus prosecuted for impiety over a question of astronomy; and he chose to end his life by fasting when he could have recovered. The Stoics counted such a death reasonable; the church, from Augustine (City of God I.20) onward, has held that life is God’s gift and not ours to lay down. He was a good man by the light he had, patient under mockery, honest about his limits, earnest in prayer. That is exactly why his hymn moves Christian readers, and why its last lines read like a request that the gospel answers.