Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Galen of Pergamon 129 – c. 216 AD
(●) The greatest physician of the Roman world, who admired the courage of Christians and faulted them for believing without proof. For about thirteen hundred years, if a doctor anywhere from Baghdad to Paris wanted to know how the body worked, he opened Galen. Medical students in medieval universities learned anatomy from him; Arab physicians built their textbooks on him; Byzantine doctors abridged him for busy practitioners. Only in the sixteenth century, when the anatomist Andreas Vesalius cut open human bodies and found that some of Galen’s descriptions fit apes better than people, did his authority begin to give way. Even then, the habit he preached, test it for yourself, was the habit that overturned him. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for two reasons. First, he is one of the earliest pagan writers to mention Christians by name, and what he says cuts both ways. Their faith, he thought, rested on stories rather than demonstration. By demonstration he meant proof the way a geometer gives it, each step following from the one before until the conclusion cannot be denied, the way you once proved in school that the angles of a triangle add up to two right angles. Christians, as he saw them, had nothing like that. And yet their contempt for death and their self-control matched the philosophers’. That complaint, that faith means believing without evidence, is still the most common objection Christians hear. Second, his whole medical work is an argument from design. He looked at the hand, the eye and the kidney and concluded that a wise and good maker had shaped them, and Christian writers for centuries took that argument up gladly, while parting from him on what kind of maker it was. One signature fact: Galen is the most prolific author to survive from the ancient Greek world. His surviving works fill twenty volumes, bound as twenty-two thick books, in the standard nineteenth-century edition, more than everything left to us of Plato and Aristotle together, and that is after a fire destroyed a large part of his library in his own lifetime. His dates need a word of caution. His birth in 129 AD is fairly secure, worked out from his own remarks, though a few scholars prefer 130. His death is not: one Byzantine encyclopedia gives him seventy years, which would mean about 199 AD, while Arabic biographers give him eighty-seven, which would mean about 216. Hints in his late writings make the later figure more likely, and "c. 216" is the common convention rather than a known date.
(●) 129 AD: Born in Pergamon to a gentle father and a furious mother, and he chose to become like his father. Pergamon, on the Aegean coast of what is now Turkey, was one of the great cities of the Roman East. It had a library second only to Alexandria’s and a famous healing sanctuary of Asclepius, the Greek god of medicine, where the sick came to sleep in the temple and wait for a healing dream. Galen was born there in 129 AD. His father Nicon was a well-to-do architect, trained in mathematics and philosophy, and he gave his son the best education the city could offer: geometry, logic, and lectures from teachers of all four of the great philosophical schools of the day. There were the Platonists and the Aristotelians, who followed the two great masters who had taught at Athens; the Stoics, who taught that a wise person stays calm by caring most about the things no misfortune can take away; and the Epicureans, who taught that the gods do not meddle with us and that a quiet, untroubled life is the best one. Galen later wrote that their contradictions nearly drove him to despair of knowing anything at all, and that geometry rescued him, because it showed him what a real proof looks like. Galen remembered his parents with startling frankness. His father, he wrote, was just, good and kind. His mother was another matter: she had such a temper that she sometimes bit her serving-maids, and she shouted at her husband constantly, "worse than Xanthippe with Socrates" (Xanthippe was the wife of Socrates, a byword for a scold). The boy watched both of them and decided, deliberately, to love what he saw in his father and to hate what he saw in his mother. The name Nicon chose for him, Galenos, means "calm" or "peaceable." Galen grew up to write fierce polemics, books written to attack and demolish an opponent, against other doctors, and his readers have sometimes wondered whether the name took.
(●) c. 145 AD: A dream turned his father’s plans toward medicine, and Galen spent a decade studying across the Greek East. Nicon had meant his son for philosophy. Then, when the boy was about sixteen, the father had a vivid dream, which Galen himself reports, telling him to have his son study medicine as well. In Pergamon, with the sanctuary of Asclepius a short walk away, nobody would have thought it strange to take such a dream seriously, and Nicon did. Galen kept the double training all his life: he never stopped thinking of himself as a philosopher, and one of his short books argues that the best physician must also be one. His father died when Galen was about nineteen, leaving him wealthy enough to study wherever he liked, and he went looking for the best teachers he could find. He studied anatomy at Smyrna and heard the Platonist philosopher Albinus there; he went to Corinth after another teacher; and he spent several years in Alexandria, the old capital of Greek science, where human skeletons could still be seen and studied. It was a long apprenticeship, about a dozen years in all, and it left him with a lasting suspicion of anyone who had learned medicine from one teacher and one school.
(●) 157 AD: Back home, he became physician to the gladiators of Pergamon. At about twenty-eight Galen returned to Pergamon and took a job that tells you a great deal about the Roman world: doctor to the gladiators kept by the high priest of the province, the official who staged the games. Gladiators were expensive property, and keeping them alive was worth paying for. For a young doctor it was also a school no university could match. In an age when nobody cut open a living person on purpose, the arena did it for him: men came to him with deep wounds, many of them cuts across the front of the thigh that laid the muscle open, and he could see inside them while he worked. Historians since have called those deep wounds windows into the body, and through them he learned what muscles, tendons and arteries look like in a living man. He was proud of his record, and he says that far fewer gladiators died under his care than under the man before him. He held the post through several high priests, about four years in all, and then, ambitious and restless, he left for the one city where a physician’s reputation could be made for good.
(●) 162 AD: In Rome he won fame with public dissections and bold diagnoses, and enemies with his tongue. Imagine a crowded lecture hall in Rome, senators and philosophers in the front rows, and a young Greek doctor with a live pig on the table. He cuts down to two fine nerves in its neck and ties them off, and the squealing animal falls silent. He loosens them and the squeal returns. The audience has just watched a demonstration that the voice is controlled by nerves running from the brain, not, as many of them had been taught, from the heart. Shows like this made Galen famous within months. So did his cures. In his book On Prognosis he tells how he treated the Aristotelian philosopher Eudemus, an older acquaintance from Pergamon, through a dangerous fever that the city’s leading doctors had misjudged, predicting each turn of the illness correctly. Eudemus told everyone, and wealthy patrons, among them the consul Flavius Boethus, began sending for him. (The consulship had been the highest office of the old Roman Republic; by Galen’s day, under the emperors, it was more an honor than a power, but it marked a man as belonging to the very top of Roman society.) A doctor whose name was passed around at dinners like that did not stay obscure for long. He also made himself hated. He told Rome’s fashionable physicians, often to their faces, that they were ignorant, greedy, or both, and he believed some of them would have poisoned him if they could. In 166 AD he left Rome suddenly and went home to Pergamon. He said it was because of his enemies; it was also the year a terrible epidemic, now usually guessed to have been smallpox, reached the city, and his critics then and since have wondered whether the plague had something to do with the timing.
(●) 168 AD: The emperor summoned him back, and he spent the rest of a long life in Rome as a court physician and writer. Within two years an imperial letter arrived. The co-emperors Marcus Aurelius and Lucius Verus were gathering an army at Aquileia, in northern Italy, for a war against the Germanic tribes on the Danube, and they wanted Galen with them. He went, and found the camp ravaged by the same plague; Lucius died of illness on the road early in 169. When Marcus asked Galen to follow him to the front, Galen excused himself in a way his patron would respect: Asclepius, he said, had advised against it. He considered himself the god’s servant, he explains elsewhere, because Asclepius had once saved him from a deadly abscess. Marcus let him stay in Rome and gave him charge of the health of his young son Commodus. The decades that followed were the most productive of his life. He wrote at a pace that is hard to believe, dictating to teams of secretaries, and he went on treating the imperial household under Commodus and later under Septimius Severus, for whom he prepared theriac, an elaborate antidote that emperors took daily against poison.
(●) 192 AD: A fire in Rome burned his storeroom of books, drugs and instruments, and he wrote about how to bear the loss. Galen kept his most precious things in a storehouse near the Temple of Peace in the center of Rome, a district many scholars used because it was thought to be fireproof. In 192 AD a great fire swept through it. He lost drugs he had collected from across the empire, instruments he had designed himself, recipes, and many books, including his own corrected copies of his works and rare editions of older authors that existed nowhere else. A friend asked him how he had borne it so calmly, and Galen answered in a short essay called On Avoiding Distress. For centuries it was known only by title. Then in 2005 a young French scholar, Antoine Pietrobelli, found a complete Greek copy in a manuscript at the Vlatadon monastery in Thessaloniki. It is one of the most personal things Galen wrote, part inventory of what was lost and part reflection, much in the Stoic manner, on how a sensible person meets misfortune. His advice is the kind a wise grandparent might give: you prepare for losses in advance, and you remember that you still have what matters most.
(●) c. 216 AD: He died in old age, probably in Rome, and his books ruled medicine for thirteen centuries. We do not know how or where Galen died, and we do not know the year. The tradition of Arabic biographers that he lived to eighty-seven puts his death around 216 AD; a Byzantine encyclopedia called the Suda gives him only seventy years, which would mean about 199. Some of his late writings seem to come from well into the reign of Septimius Severus, perhaps after 200, which favors the longer life, but "c. 216" remains a convention, not a record. What is certain is what happened to his books. Within a few centuries, the medical teachers of Alexandria had made a canon of sixteen of his works, a fixed reading list that became the core of medical education. Think of it as the set textbooks of a degree course, except that the course ran for hundreds of years. Christian scholars translated him into Syriac, and then into Arabic in ninth-century Baghdad; from Arabic and Greek he passed into Latin and into the medieval universities. Galen had spent his life telling doctors not to treat any teacher as infallible. The irony of his afterlife is that he became exactly that, until the anatomists of the Renaissance took his advice and looked for themselves.
What He Taught
(T1) The body is the work of a supremely skilled craftsman, and nothing in it is made in vain. Hold up your hand and look at it. The thumb faces the fingers, so you can grip a hammer or pick up a needle. The fingers have several joints, so they can curl around a ball. The fingertips have nails behind them to give them firmness, but no bone at the very tip, so they stay soft enough to feel. Galen spent the first book of his great work On the Usefulness of the Parts on the hand alone, and his conclusion was that no part of it could be arranged better than it is. That is the heart of his teaching about nature. The technical word is teleology, from the Greek telos, "end" or "purpose": the view that the parts of living things exist for the sake of what they do, the way the parts of a clock exist for the sake of telling time. Galen took the principle from Aristotle, "nature does nothing in vain," and pushed it further than anyone before him. Nature, he says, is artistic (his Greek word is technikē, the skill of a craftsman), and the forethought shown in an animal’s body is the forethought of a wise and good maker. In On the Usefulness of the Parts he goes so far as to call his anatomical writing a sacred hymn to the one who made us: true piety, he says there, lies less in sacrificing many bulls than in learning and teaching others how great is the maker’s wisdom, power and goodness. Christian readers recognized this at once. It is very close to what Paul says in Romans 1:20, that God’s "invisible attributes" are "clearly perceived" in the things he has made. Galen’s maker, though, is not quite the God of Scripture, as (T3) shows.
(Q) "This faculty we also state to be artistic, nay, the best and highest art, doing everything for some purpose, so that there is nothing ineffective or superfluous, or capable of being better disposed." Source: Galen, On the Natural Faculties I.6 (Arthur John Brock translation, Loeb Classical Library, 1916). Galen is describing the "shaping" power that forms the stomach, intestines and womb while an animal is still being formed in the womb, and he promises a fuller proof in On the Usefulness of the Parts (T1). In Brock the words "nay, the best and highest art" stand between dashes rather than commas.
(T2) A claim about the body must be tested by experiment, not accepted because a school teaches it. In Galen’s day, being a doctor usually meant belonging to a sect. The Empiricists trusted only experience and refused to theorize about hidden causes. The Methodists, who had nothing to do with the later Christian movement of that name, reduced all disease to a few simple states of the body. The followers of Erasistratus and Asclepiades, two famous earlier physicians, had their own doctrines. A patient often got the treatment his doctor’s school prescribed, whatever was actually wrong with him. Galen despised this. His method combined the two things the sects had split apart: careful reasoning, the kind of logical demonstration a geometer uses, and careful observation, above all the observation of living and dead animals on the dissecting table. In On the Natural Faculties he tells of a doctor who insisted that urine did not really pass from the kidneys to the bladder. Galen did not argue for long. He described how to tie off the tubes from the kidneys in a living animal and watch them swell while the bladder stayed empty, then release them and watch the bladder fill. Anyone, he said, who would test this for himself would be convinced. His complaint about his rivals was not that they were stupid but that they were "enslaved to their sects": loyalty to a school had made them unwilling even to look. That habit of mind, demonstrate what you claim and check it against what you can see, is Galen’s most lasting gift. It is also exactly the standard he turned on the church (T4), and there, Christians would say, he applied it unfairly.
(Q) "The fact is that those who are enslaved to their sects are not merely devoid of all sound knowledge, but they will not even stop to learn!" Source: Galen, On the Natural Faculties I.13 (Arthur John Brock translation, Loeb Classical Library, 1916). Galen has just told of a sophist (a professional speaker, and in Galen’s mouth a word for someone more interested in winning an argument than in finding the truth), arguing the case for Asclepiades, who made one clever objection and then jumped up and walked off as though Galen had no answer, and he goes on to describe the experiment on the kidneys and bladder that would have settled the question (T2).
(T3) God shapes the world from the best that matter allows, and does not attempt what is impossible by nature. Think of a master carpenter handed a load of pine. He can build a fine table from it, the best table that pine allows, but he cannot make the pine into oak, and a sensible carpenter does not try. Galen pictured God that way. His maker is wise and good, but he works with a material that was already there and has its own fixed nature, and even divine skill chooses the best of what is possible rather than doing anything at all. He says this in so many words, and he says it against Moses. In book eleven of On the Usefulness of the Parts he is explaining why our eyelashes stay the same length while the hair on our heads keeps growing. It is not, he says, merely that the Creator commanded them to stop: no command could make hair stand straight unless it were rooted in firm, gristly tissue, and so the Creator put it there. Then he names the contrast. Moses, he says, thinks it enough that God willed matter to be arranged and it was arranged, because for Moses all things are possible to God. Galen sides with Plato and the Greeks, who held that some things are impossible by nature. This is one of the earliest pagan comments on Genesis that survives, and it is a careful one: Galen had clearly read, or heard, enough of the Jewish Scriptures to see exactly where they parted from Plato’s Timaeus, in which a divine craftsman shapes material that was always there. He saw the fault line between a God who creates and a God who arranges, and he chose the second.
(Q) "For the latter it seems enough to say that God simply willed the arrangement of matter and it was presently arranged in due order; for he believes everything to be possible with God, even should He wish to make a bull or a horse out of ashes." Source: Galen, On the Usefulness of the Parts XI.14 (Richard Walzer translation, Galen on Jews and Christians, 1949, reprinted in Menahem Stern, Greek and Latin Authors on Jews and Judaism, vol. 2, no. 376). No public-domain English translation of the passage exists. "The latter" is Moses, whom Galen has just set against "Plato and the other Greeks who follow the right method in natural science." The sentence continues: "We however do not hold this; we say that certain things are impossible by nature and that God does not even attempt such things at all but that He chooses the best out of the possibilities of becoming" (T3).
(T4) Jews and Christians are told to accept their teaching on faith, without demonstration. You may have met someone who will not change their mind no matter what you show them. Galen had met many, and when he wanted an example of that stubbornness the first that came to mind was the followers of Moses and Christ. In his long work On the Differences of Pulses, irritated by doctors who would not reconsider their teachers’ doctrines, he wrote that it would be easier to teach something new to Jews and Christians than to them. Earlier in the same work he complains of a famous physician who laid down rules about the pulse without proof, as if one had come into "the school of Moses and Christ" and were hearing "undemonstrated laws." Notice what the remark is and what it is not. It is not a charge of crime or immorality, the kind of rumor other pagans repeated about Christians. It is a philosopher’s complaint about method: to Galen, a school worth joining proves its claims, and these people seemed to be told simply to believe. In another passage, preserved only in Arabic, he says the followers of Moses and Christ "order them to accept everything on faith." It is a fair description of how the faith looked from outside, and a fair challenge, and Christians did not ignore it. Their answer, in brief, was that the apostles never asked anyone to believe without evidence; they asked people to trust the testimony of eyewitnesses to things that had happened.
(Q) "One might more easily teach novelties to the followers of Moses and Christ than to the physicians and philosophers, who cling fast to their schools." Source: Galen, On the Differences of Pulses III.3 (Richard Walzer translation, Galen on Jews and Christians, 1949, reprinted in Menahem Stern, Greek and Latin Authors on Jews and Judaism, vol. 2). No public-domain English translation of the passage exists. The comparison is meant as an insult to the doctors: even Jews and Christians, whose stubbornness Galen takes for granted, would be easier to persuade (T4). He adds that he finally resolved to spare himself idle talk by not discussing anything with such men at all.
(Q) "Of this sort we now see the people who are called Christians deriving their faith from such allusive sayings. Yet on their part deeds have been produced equal to the deeds of those who are in truth philosophers." Source: Galen, from a lost summary of Plato’s Republic, quoted in Arabic by the historian Abulfeda, among others (M. Sprengling translation of Abulfeda’s text, "Galen on the Christians," The American Journal of Theology 21, 1917, p. 96). Galen has just said that most people cannot follow a strict proof and so need "allusive sayings," which a note in the Arabic text explains as tales of rewards and punishments in the world to come. Then comes the surprise. These same Christians, he goes on, are "free from the fear of death," keep strict sexual self-control, some men and women for their whole lives, and in self-discipline and the desire for righteousness "do not fall short of those who are in truth philosophers." It is among the warmest things any pagan of the second century wrote about the church, and it comes from a man who thought their faith had no proof.
What Christian Thinkers Made of Him
(†) Christians in Rome read him in his own lifetime, and one group admired him so much that the church took alarm. Galen was not just a distant observer of the church; some of its members were reading him. Around the year 200 a group in Rome gathered around a leather-worker named Theodotus, who taught that Jesus was an ordinary man on whom the Spirit came at his baptism. The church in Rome excommunicated Theodotus, which is to say it formally put him out of its fellowship. An anonymous writer whom the historian Eusebius later quoted complained that his followers spent their time on logic and geometry instead of Scripture. They measured out Euclid, the great teacher of geometry; they admired Aristotle and his successor Theophrastus; and some of them, he added sharply, perhaps even worshiped Galen. You can almost hear the writer shaking his head. The complaint is about what they did with Galen, not about Galen. They were trying, it seems, to bring his standard of logical demonstration to the Bible, and the Roman church judged that they had ended by bending the faith to fit the method. But the line is a striking witness to how quickly his books reached Christian readers, and how seriously they were taken.
(†) Christian scholars carried his medicine through the centuries, and his design argument became theirs. Around 400 AD, Nemesius, bishop of Emesa in Syria, wrote On the Nature of Man, one of the first Christian handbooks of human nature, and drew on Galen’s anatomy and physiology on page after page. He used the same kind of evidence Galen had used, the fit of every organ to its work, to argue for the providence of God, the belief that God cares for and governs what he has made. That move became a fixture of Christian natural theology, the study of what can be known of God from nature: the body as a piece of workmanship that points to its Maker. Christians also kept his books alive. In the sixth century Sergius of Reshaina, a Syriac-speaking priest and physician, translated many of Galen’s works into Syriac. In ninth-century Baghdad, Hunayn ibn Ishaq, a Christian of the Church of the East (the ancient Syriac-speaking church of Mesopotamia and Persia, beyond the Roman frontier), led the translation of well over a hundred Galenic works into Syriac and Arabic, and through those versions Galen reached the whole medieval world, Muslim, Jewish and Christian alike. The physician who thought Christians lacked proof owes much of his survival to Christian scholars who copied his proofs with care.
(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: a Creator not bound by matter, and a faith that rests on testimony. Galen saw the two points of disagreement himself, and stated them better than many later critics. Christians can grant how much he got right and still part with him at both. - The Creator. Galen’s God is a supreme craftsman working with material that was always there and choosing the best that it allows (T3). The God of Genesis creates the material itself: "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth" (Genesis 1:1), and "what is seen was not made out of things that are visible" (Hebrews 11:3). Galen was right that Moses believed all things possible with God, and Jesus says the same: "With man this is impossible, but with God all things are possible" (Matthew 19:26). That does not make God arbitrary, as if he might make a horse out of ashes for no reason; it means the order Galen admired in the body is not a compromise with stubborn matter but the free work of a God who made matter too. - Faith and proof. Galen thought Christians were told to believe without demonstration (T4). The New Testament describes something different: faith as trust in testimony. Luke writes so that his reader "may have certainty," having followed things closely and drawn on "eyewitnesses and ministers of the word" (Luke 1:1–4); Paul lists the witnesses of the risen Christ, most of them still alive to be asked (1 Corinthians 15:3–8); and Christians are told to be ready to give "a reason for the hope that is in you" (1 Peter 3:15). A doctor trusts the colleague who reports what he saw at the dissecting table without repeating the dissection; the apostles asked for the same kind of trust in what they had seen. - The pagan gods. Galen called himself the servant of Asclepius and credited the god with saving his life. It is easy to understand a grateful man who once lay sick with an abscess and got up again. Still, the gospel calls that devotion misplaced: the healing Galen sought from a god of medicine is offered in Christ, who healed the sick and rose from the dead. His own words about Christians remain a fair witness to them. He looked at their lives and admitted that people with no philosophy had reached the self-control philosophers only talked about. Christians would say he had found the evidence he was asking for, and did not follow it home.