Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Classical Greece

600 BC – 300 BC

Xenophon of Athens c. 430 – c. 354 BC

(●) Soldier, exile, and the other student of Socrates, who wrote down the earliest surviving full argument that the living world was designed. + Most of what we know about Socrates comes from two men who sat at his feet. One was Plato, the philosopher of genius. The other was Xenophon, a horseman and a practical man who would rather run a farm than a seminar, and who for that very reason is the best check we have on how much of Plato’s Socrates is Socrates and how much is Plato. When the two agree, historians breathe easier. Xenophon belongs on a Christian apologetics site for a reason he would not have guessed. In his recollections of Socrates he preserved a conversation in which Socrates looks at the human eye, its lids that shut like folding doors, its lashes that screen out the wind, and asks whether anyone can seriously believe such a thing was made by chance. It is the oldest fully worked-out design argument to survive, written down four centuries before Paul told the Romans that God’s invisible power is "clearly perceived" in "the things that have been made." He also lived one of the great adventure stories of the ancient world. At about thirty he found himself one of the elected generals leading ten thousand stranded Greek soldiers out of the heart of the Persian Empire, through snow and mountains and hostile tribes, until the men at the front topped a ridge and shouted, "The sea! the sea!" Both of his dates are estimates. No ancient source gives the year of his birth; "c. 430 BC" is the scholarly convention, worked back from his calling himself a young man in 401 BC. His death is placed after his last datable work, around 355 BC, so "c. 354 BC" marks the earliest likely year rather than a known one.

(●) c. 430 BC: Born into a horse-owning Athenian family as the city went to war with Sparta. + Xenophon was born around 430 BC in Erchia, a country district a few hours east of Athens, the son of a man named Gryllus. The family had money, and in Athens money meant horses. Keeping a horse was the ancient equivalent of keeping a private plane, and the men who could afford it served in the cavalry and thought of themselves as the city’s gentlemen. Xenophon loved horses all his life and wrote two short books about them. He grew up inside the Peloponnesian War, the long struggle between Athens and Sparta that began around the time of his birth and ended in Athens’ defeat in 404 BC, when he was in his twenties. A boy of his class learned to ride, to hunt, and to admire Spartan discipline even while Athens was fighting Sparta, and that admiration would shape the rest of his life.

(●) Before 401 BC: As a young man he joined the circle around Socrates. + We do not know exactly when Xenophon first met Socrates. A story told six centuries later by Diogenes Laertius, the ancient biographer of the philosophers, says Socrates stopped him in a narrow lane by stretching out his walking stick across the path. He asked the young man where various goods could be bought, and then where men were made good and honourable. When Xenophon could not say, Socrates told him, "Then follow me and learn." It is a tradition, not a record, but it fits the man both writers describe. What is certain is that Xenophon listened closely and long enough to write four works about Socrates afterward. His Socrates is a little less dazzling than Plato’s and a good deal more practical: he helps a friend find work for his destitute relatives, scolds a son for being rude to his mother, and asks a cavalry commander whether he has actually trained his horses. Xenophon wrote him down that way because that is the Socrates who changed his life. What Xenophon did during the bloody rule of the Thirty Tyrants, the pro-Spartan clique that held Athens in 404 to 403 BC, he never tells us. Some historians suspect from his close knowledge of the cavalry that he rode with it in those months, but that is an inference, not a fact.

(●) 401 BC: Sidestepping Socrates’ caution, he joined a Persian prince’s army marching on the Persian throne. + In 401 BC a letter came from an old friend, Proxenus of Boeotia, inviting Xenophon to Sardis in Asia Minor to meet Cyrus the Younger, a Persian prince who was hiring Greek soldiers. Xenophon tells us what happened next in his Anabasis. He asked Socrates for advice, and Socrates, worried that Athens would look badly on a friend of Cyrus (who had funded Sparta against Athens in the war), told him to consult the god at Delphi, the shrine of Apollo where a priestess gave the god’s answers to anyone who came to ask. Xenophon went, but he did not ask whether he should go. He asked which gods he should sacrifice to so that his journey would succeed. When he came home and reported the answer, Socrates scolded him for settling the real question himself and only asking the god how to carry it out. "Since, however, you did so put the question," Socrates said, "you should do what the god enjoined." Xenophon sacrificed and sailed. He joined, he insists, as neither general nor soldier but as a guest of Proxenus. What almost none of the Greeks knew at first (only the Spartan general Clearchus was in on it) was the real target: Cyrus was marching east to take the throne from his own brother, the Great King (the Persians’ title for their emperor) Artaxerxes II.

(●) 401–400 BC: When the Persians murdered the Greek generals, he was elected one of the generals who led the Ten Thousand home through hostile country. + At Cunaxa, near Babylon, in 401 BC the Greeks won their part of the battle, and Cyrus lost his life. Suddenly some ten thousand Greek soldiers were stranded more than a thousand miles from home, in the middle of an empire that wanted them dead. Weeks later the Persian commander Tissaphernes invited their generals to a parley and had them seized and killed. Proxenus was among them. That night, Xenophon writes, he lay awake in distress until, snatching a little sleep, he dreamed that a bolt from Zeus struck his father’s house and set it ablaze. He woke, rallied the officers, and was elected one of the new generals. What followed is the march the Anabasis is famous for: north through the mountains of Kurdistan and Armenia, through deep snow that blinded men and froze off toes, fighting tribes at every pass. In early 400 BC the vanguard climbed Mount Theches and began shouting. Xenophon, in the rearguard, galloped up thinking the enemy was attacking the front, and heard the word being passed back down the column: "The sea! the sea!" It was the Black Sea, and the road home. The story did not end tidily, as real stories seldom do. On the coast the army quarrelled, split, and hired itself out to a prince of Thrace, the rough country north of the Aegean, and Xenophon spent months trying to keep his men together and paid.

(●) 399–394 BC: He served Sparta, fought beside its king against Athens’ allies, and was banished from home. + In 399 BC the remains of the army were taken into Spartan service for a war against the Persian governors in Asia Minor, and Xenophon went with them. It was in that same year that Athens executed Socrates; Xenophon was far away, and his Apology and Memorabilia are in part his answer to a trial he could not attend. He became a friend and admirer of the Spartan king Agesilaus, and when Agesilaus was recalled to Greece in 394 BC Xenophon marched with him, and was with him at the battle of Coronea against a coalition that included Athens. At some point Athens passed a decree of exile against him. The date and the charge are both uncertain: some place it soon after the expedition, for serving Cyrus, others in 394, for fighting on the Spartan side. Either way, the man who wrote the fullest defense of Athens’ most famous citizen could not go home.

(●) c. 390–371 BC: Settled by Sparta on an estate near Olympia, he hunted, farmed, honoured Artemis, and wrote. + The Spartans gave him land at Scillus, a small place twenty stades (a little over two miles) from the temple of Zeus at Olympia, and there Xenophon lived something like the life of an English country squire. He married a woman named Philesia and had two sons, Gryllus and Diodorus. With his share of the tithe from the campaign (a tenth of the spoils, set aside for the gods) he bought a plot for Artemis, the goddess of the hunt, built her a small temple modeled on the great one at Ephesus, and held a yearly festival at which the whole neighbourhood feasted and hunted on the sacred land. He describes it all fondly in the Anabasis: the stream with its fish and mussels, the meadows, the boar and deer. These were the writing years. Most of his books were probably drafted or finished here, far from the city that had banished him: his memoir of the march, his recollections of Socrates, his manual on running a household, and the beginnings of his history of Greece.

(●) 371–c. 354 BC: Driven from his estate, he lost a son in battle and died in old age, perhaps reconciled with Athens. + In 371 BC Thebes crushed Sparta at Leuctra, and Sparta’s protection vanished. The people of Elis, the city-state that kept the sanctuary at Olympia, took back Scillus, and Xenophon moved to Corinth. Athens and Sparta were now allies against Thebes, and his exile seems to have been lifted; both his sons fought in the Athenian army, Gryllus in the cavalry. In 362 BC his son Gryllus was killed fighting bravely in a cavalry battle before Mantinea. Diogenes Laertius tells a story that Xenophon was sacrificing, garland on his head, when the news came. He took the garland off; then, hearing that his son had died nobly, he put it back on and finished the sacrifice without a tear, saying only, "I knew my son was mortal." Whether or not it happened that way, the ancient world believed it of him, and Aristotle remarks that a great many writers composed tributes to Gryllus to please his father. His last datable work, a pamphlet on how Athens could improve its public finances, was written around 355 BC, so he was still alive and still thinking about the city that had exiled him. Ancient reports say he died at Corinth at a great age. The year is unknown.

What He Taught

(T1) The living world is built with foresight, so it is the work of a wise and caring maker. + Imagine a friend who admires great sculptors and painters but laughs at anyone who prays. That was Aristodemus, nicknamed "the little," and in the first book of the Memorabilia, Xenophon’s "things worth remembering" about Socrates, Socrates takes him on with a simple question. Which is more impressive, an artist who makes motionless statues, or one who makes living creatures that think and act? The second, says Aristodemus, provided they were made on purpose and not by chance. That proviso is the whole argument. Socrates asks him to look at his own face. The eyes are delicate, so they are shut behind lids like folding doors; the lashes screen out the wind; the brows stop sweat running down from the forehead; the front teeth cut and the back teeth grind; the mouth is placed close to the eyes and nose that check the food going in. When things are this plainly arranged for a purpose, Socrates asks, can you honestly doubt whether they came from chance or from intelligence? This is what philosophers now call a design argument, or teleological argument (from the Greek telos, "end" or "purpose"): you reason from things fitted to an end back to a mind that fitted them. Socrates presses it further. Aristodemus has a mind himself; is mind found nowhere else in the universe, only in him? And the maker, he adds, did not stop at the body: he gave human beings a soul that can know the gods. Christian thinkers would later make the same move, from the order of the world to the God who ordered it (Romans 1:20). What Socrates calls "the gods," Scripture calls the one Creator.

(Q) "I ask you, when you see all these things constructed with such show of foresight can you doubt whether they are products of chance or intelligence?" + Source: Xenophon, Memorabilia I.iv.6 (H. G. Dakyns translation). Socrates is speaking to Aristodemus, who has just listed the eyelids, the eyelashes, the eyebrows, and the teeth. Aristodemus gives way: viewed in this light, he says, they look like the handiwork of some wise artificer "full of love for all things living."

(T2) The God who orders the universe is himself unseen, but he is known by what he does. + Nobody has ever seen the wind. You see the washing flap on the line and the trees bend, and you know it is there. In the fourth book of the Memorabilia, Socrates uses exactly that example with a young man named Euthydemus, whom he is teaching to honour gods that no one can see. Socrates answers with a list of real things that are known only by their effects. The sun is the most visible thing in the sky, yet no one can stare straight at it without being blinded. The thunderbolt strikes, yet nobody sees it come or go. The winds are unseen, though we feel them. And your own soul, the very thing that runs your body, has never been seen by anyone. So do not wait to see the gods’ forms before you honour them. Look at their works. Above all, Socrates says, there is one who "orders and holds together the universe," who keeps it running, unworn and undecaying, and who is himself invisible while he does it. That one supreme God, distinct from the lesser gods, is one of the nearest approaches to monotheism, the belief that there is only one God, in classical Greek writing. The early Christian apologists noticed it and quoted it, as (†1) shows.

(Q) "This God is seen to perform the mightiest operations, but in the actual administration of the same abides himself invisible to mortal ken." + Source: Xenophon, Memorabilia IV.iii.13 (H. G. Dakyns translation). Socrates is describing "He who orders and holds together the universe," as distinct from the many gods who give their gifts without stepping "from behind their veil." The same passage goes on to the sun, the thunderbolt, the winds, and the soul as further things known only by their works.

(T3) Self-mastery is the foundation of every virtue, and nothing fine is won without toil. + Every reader of Xenophon meets the same Socrates: a man who could go without food, drink, sleep, and comfort longer than anyone around him, and who was never mastered by any of them. The Greek word for that quality is enkrateia, self-mastery or self-control, the power to rule your own appetites instead of being ruled by them. For Xenophon it was the foundation stone. A man who is a slave to his stomach or his pleasures, his Socrates says, is no use to his friends, his city, or himself. To make the point Socrates retells a famous speech by the teacher Prodicus, the story now called the Choice of Heracles. The young hero sits at a fork in the road, and two women come to him. One, painted and preening, promises the easy road: every pleasure, no work, other people’s labour to live on. Her friends call her Happiness, she says, but her enemies call her Vice. The other, plain and modest, is Virtue, and she promises nothing she cannot deliver. Every good thing worth having, she tells him, has a price in effort: the favour of the gods, the love of friends, honour, a harvest, a strong body. Christian readers have long heard something familiar in that fork in the road, the two ways of Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, one wide and easy, one narrow and hard (Matthew 7:13–14). They have also noticed the difference, which (†3) takes up.

(Q) "Know then that among things that are lovely and of good report, not one have the gods bestowed upon mortal men apart from toil and pains." + Source: Xenophon, Memorabilia II.i.28 (H. G. Dakyns translation). Virtue is speaking to the young Heracles. The fable is Prodicus’s, and Socrates retells it for the benefit of a pleasure-loving friend named Aristippus, who wants a life of ease and needs to hear what it costs.

(T4) True leadership wins willing followers, and the gift of it is partly divine. + Think of two foremen on the same farm. When one walks into the field the workers stand straighter and work harder, not because they fear him but because they want to; when the other leaves, everyone stops. Xenophon had commanded ten thousand men who could have walked away at any moment, and he never stopped thinking about what made the difference. His answer runs through almost everything he wrote. In the Oeconomicus, his dialogue on running a household and an estate, a gentleman farmer named Ischomachus says that the ability to command willing followers is the most important quality in any undertaking. In the Cyropaedia, his idealized life of Cyrus the Great, founder of the Persian Empire, the king rules by being first in hardship, generous with rewards, and better than his people at what he asks of them. A tyrant can make people obey; a true leader makes them want to. Xenophon did not think this could be fully learned. It needs training and a good nature, but at bottom, he says, it is a gift from the gods to those who have first mastered themselves (T3). Despotism over unwilling slaves is a curse. Christian readers would later find a deeper version in the one who "came not to be served but to serve" (Mark 10:45).

(Q) "This faculty of command over willing followers, by no means is it, in its entirety, a merely human quality, but it is in part divine." + Source: Xenophon, Oeconomicus XXI.12 (H. G. Dakyns translation). These are the closing words of the dialogue, spoken by Ischomachus and reported by Socrates. The sentence goes on: it is "a gift plainly given to those truly initiated in the mystery of self-command," while despotism over unwilling slaves is given to those the gods judge worthy to live the life of Tantalus, the mythical king punished in the underworld, who in the version Xenophon quotes "consumes unending days in apprehension of a second death."

(T5) The soul is unseen but real, and it is unlikely to die with the body. + At the end of the Cyropaedia the old king Cyrus lies dying and gathers his sons. The scene is Xenophon’s own invention, a Greek philosopher’s deathbed set in a Persian palace, and he gives Cyrus some of the most moving lines he ever wrote. You have never seen my soul, Cyrus tells them, but you have seen what it does; it is what gives this body life. I cannot believe it dies the moment it leaves the body. Death looks very like sleep, and in sleep the soul seems most free. So if the soul lives on, honour mine by doing what I ask. And even if it does not, the everlasting gods who see all things remain, so fear them and never do wrong "in thought or word or deed." Notice how carefully Xenophon puts it. Plato’s Phaedo, his account of Socrates’ last day in prison, argues for the soul’s immortality; Xenophon’s Cyrus hopes for it, gives his reasons, and then grounds his sons’ duty in the gods either way. It is the honest hope of a decent pagan. The Roman statesman Cicero thought enough of the speech to render it into Latin in his essay On Old Age.

(Q) "With your bodily eyes you have never seen my soul, and yet you have discerned its presence through its working." + Source: Xenophon, Cyropaedia VIII.vii.17 (H. G. Dakyns translation). The dying Cyrus is speaking to his sons Cambyses and Tanaoxares. The same argument from unseen causes known by their effects that Socrates uses for God in the Memorabilia (T2), Cyrus uses here for the soul.

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) The early apologists quoted his Socrates as a pagan witness to the one invisible God. + When the first Christian writers argued with educated pagans, they looked for places where the pagans’ own best minds had already said what the church was saying. Xenophon’s Socrates (T2) was one of those places. Clement of Alexandria, a Christian teacher in Egypt around AD 200, quotes Xenophon in the sixth chapter of his Exhortation to the Greeks as saying that the one who moves all things and is himself at rest is plainly great and powerful, but what he is in form is not revealed. Clement adds that Xenophon would have said more, had he not feared the cup of poison Socrates drank. Minucius Felix, a Roman lawyer who wrote a dialogue in defense of the faith, gathers the philosophers who pointed toward one God and reports that "Xenophon the Socratic" held that the true God’s form cannot be seen and so ought not to be inquired after. Lactantius, the tutor of the emperor Constantine’s son, makes the same point from Xenophon’s Socrates in his book on the anger of God. What they heard in him was what theologians call general revelation: the knowledge of God open to every human being through the things God has made, as distinct from the special revelation of Scripture. Paul puts it this way: "For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse" (Romans 1:20). Xenophon’s Socrates is a witness to the first half of that verse.

(†) His argument from the eye became the ancestor of the design argument in Christian natural theology. + Natural theology is the study of what can be known about God from nature and reason alone, without appealing to Scripture. Its oldest and most popular argument is the one Socrates makes to Aristodemus (T1): things plainly fitted for a purpose point to a mind that fitted them. Xenophon’s pages are where that argument is first recorded in full, and it travelled. The Stoics, the Greek school that taught that a divine reason orders the whole world, took it up, and Cicero’s On the Nature of the Gods passed their version, eyelids and all, to Latin readers. Christian writers made it their own, and in 1802 the English clergyman William Paley opened his Natural Theology with a watch found on a heath and spent a long chapter on the eye. Whether or not Paley had his Xenophon open beside him, the shape of the case is the one Socrates gave Aristodemus twenty-two centuries earlier. Christian thinkers also gave the argument something it lacked. Socrates’ maker is "full of love for all things living," but he never speaks, never makes a covenant, never comes. Scripture names him and tells what he has done.

(†) Basil the Great retold his Choice of Heracles to train Christian young people in virtue. + Probably in the 370s AD, Basil of Caesarea, one of the great bishops of the Greek church, wrote a short address to young men of his own family, traditionally taken to be his nephews, on how Christian young people should read the pagan classics. His advice was to read them the way a bee visits flowers: take what is useful for the soul and leave the rest. One of the passages he chose as most useful is the fable Xenophon preserved (T3). Basil credits it to Prodicus, as Xenophon does, and retells Heracles at the crossroads, Vice with her easy road and Virtue with her hard one. For more than two thousand years the Choice of Heracles has been one of the most retold moral stories in the West, painted, set to music, and taught in schools, and it reached all of them through Xenophon, because Prodicus’s own speech is lost. His books themselves became schoolbooks; generations of students, many of them future clergy, learned their Greek from the clear, plain prose of the Anabasis.

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: omens and many gods, hatred of enemies, and virtue as the way up. + Xenophon was a sincerely religious man, and a Christian reader likes him for it. But his own books record three places where his faith and practice part from the gospel. - Omens and many gods. Xenophon ran his life by sacrifice and divination. In the Anabasis he will not march, fight, or found a city until the entrails of a sacrificed animal give a favourable sign, and he sacrificed to whichever gods Delphi named. Scripture forbids exactly this: "There shall not be found among you ... anyone who practices divination or tells fortunes or interprets omens" (Deuteronomy 18:10). His one supreme God (T2) stands surrounded by many others, and Xenophon worshipped them all. - Enemies. Xenophon’s Socrates, offering to commend his friend Critobulus to others, sums up the good man’s character in the ordinary Greek way: "a man’s virtue is to excel his friends in kindness and his foes in hostility" (Memorabilia II.vi.35). Jesus overturns it: "But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you" (Matthew 5:44). - The way up. Virtue’s speech to Heracles (T3) is true as far as it goes, and Scripture agrees that discipline is painful now and yields "the peaceful fruit of righteousness" later (Hebrews 12:11). But for Xenophon the favour of the gods is earned like a harvest, by service paid. The gospel says the deepest good, being made right with God, cannot be earned at all; it is received as a gift (Ephesians 2:8–9). Xenophon saw that the world was made with care and that its Maker is unseen. He did not know that the Maker had a name and would one day come looking for him.

Xenophon’s whole known output appears to survive. Diogenes Laertius, writing in the third century AD, says he wrote some forty books (counting each "book" of the longer works separately), and every title on his list has come down to us. One of those titles, the Constitution of the Athenians, is now thought not to be his, and an ancient critic Diogenes names, Demetrius of Magnesia, already doubted it. His plain, clear Attic Greek (the dialect of Athens) made him a school author from Roman times onward, which helped keep every work in circulation. The Socratic works: - Memorabilia (Recollections of Socrates): Four books of conversations showing Socrates as pious, self-controlled, and useful to his friends, written to answer the charges that killed him. The source of the design argument (T1), the unseen God (T2), and the Choice of Heracles (T3). - Apology of Socrates: A short account of Socrates’ defense at his trial in 399 BC, built on reports from those who were there, explaining why he spoke so proudly to the jury: he judged it was a good time to die. - Symposium: A dinner party at the house of the rich Callias, full of jokes, dancers, and talk of love, in which Socrates praises love of the soul above love of the body before the evening closes with a danced mime of Dionysus and Ariadne. A lighter companion to Plato’s dialogue of the same name. - Oeconomicus (The Estate Manager): Socrates recounts a conversation with the gentleman farmer Ischomachus about running a household, training a young wife, and farming well. The closing chapter on leading willing workers (T4). History and memoir: - Anabasis (The March Up Country): Seven books on Cyrus the Younger’s march on Babylon in 401 BC and the Ten Thousand’s retreat to the Black Sea and beyond, with Xenophon himself as the central character, told in the third person. The most read of his works. - Hellenica (Greek History): Seven books continuing Thucydides’ unfinished history from 411 BC to the battle of Mantinea in 362 BC, the main surviving narrative of the period, written from a pro-Spartan angle. - Agesilaus: An admiring memorial portrait of his friend the Spartan king, written soon after the king’s death around 360 BC. With the Evagoras of Isocrates, the Athenian teacher of oratory, a little earlier, it is among the first prose portraits of a real man in Greek, the ancestors of biography. Political and educational writings: - Cyropaedia (The Education of Cyrus): Eight books of a largely fictional life of Cyrus the Great, a portrait of the ideal ruler and how he is formed; read for centuries as a handbook for princes. Ends with Cyrus’s deathbed speech on the soul (T5). - Hiero: A dialogue in which the tyrant of Syracuse tells the poet Simonides that the tyrant is the unhappiest of men, and Simonides advises how he might rule so as to be loved. - Constitution of the Lacedaemonians: A short, admiring account of the laws that Lycurgus, Sparta’s legendary lawgiver, gave the city (Lacedaemon was the Spartans’ own name for their state), with a late chapter lamenting that the Spartans no longer keep them. - Ways and Means (Poroi): A pamphlet of about 355 BC proposing ways to raise Athens’ public revenue without exploiting its allies, chiefly by encouraging resident foreigners and developing the silver mines. His last datable work. Technical treatises: - The Cavalry Commander (Hipparchicus): Practical advice to the officer commanding Athens’ cavalry, from recruiting and drilling to piety: begin every undertaking with the gods. - On Horsemanship: How to choose, train, and ride a horse, the oldest complete Greek work on horsemanship to survive (an earlier one by Simon of Athens exists only in fragments), still praised by riders for its gentleness toward the animal. - Cynegeticus (On Hunting): On hunting hares, deer, and boar with dogs, opened by a mythological preface praising hunting as training in virtue. Its authorship is debated, chiefly because of that florid preface. Wrongly attributed: - Constitution of the Athenians: A hostile analysis of the Athenian democracy preserved among his works and on Diogenes’ list, now generally dated to the 420s BC, too early for Xenophon, and assigned to an unknown author nicknamed the "Old Oligarch." - A handful of letters under his name are later forgeries. Standard English editions: Xenophon, in the Loeb Classical Library, seven volumes (Harvard University Press), with Greek and English on facing pages. The nineteenth-century translations of H. G. Dakyns, The Works of Xenophon (four volumes, 1890–1897), quoted throughout, are in the public domain and free online.

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief