Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Samuel of Ramah fl. c. 1050 BC
(●) The last of Israel’s judges and the first of the prophets who stood beside its kings, the man who made kings and held them to the word of God. Samuel stands at a hinge in Israel’s story. Before him, the tribes were a loose confederation led in emergencies by judges, local deliverers raised up for one crisis at a time. After him, Israel had a king, a capital on the way, and a line of prophets who stood in the king’s court and told him when he was wrong. Samuel is the man who carried the nation across that gap. He anointed both of its first kings, Saul and David, and he set the pattern that the throne answers to the word of the Lord rather than the other way round. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site for that reason and for one more. The word "anointed" (in Hebrew mashiach, the word that comes into English as "Messiah") is first used of a king in his mother’s song, sung before Israel had any king at all, and the anointing Samuel gave to David with a horn of oil is the beginning of the royal line the New Testament traces to Jesus. A word on dates. Scripture gives Samuel’s life no fixed year, and every date below is a convention, reckoned backward from the usual dating of Saul’s reign (roughly 1050 to 1010 BC) and David’s (roughly 1010 to 970 BC). They mark the order of events and their rough distance apart, not a calendar anyone kept.
(●) c. 1100 BC: Born in answer to a childless woman’s prayer, he was given back to God at the sanctuary of Shiloh. The story begins not with Samuel but with his mother. Hannah was one of two wives of a man named Elkanah from Ramathaim-zophim, in the hill country of Ephraim (1 Samuel 1:1), a town the narrative mostly calls Ramah. The other wife had children and taunted her for having none. Every year the family went up to Shiloh, where the tabernacle and the ark of the covenant then stood. The tabernacle was Israel’s sanctuary, the house of worship the people had carried with them since the wilderness, and the ark was the gold-covered chest kept inside it, holding the tablets of the law and marking the place where God met his people. And every year Hannah wept and would not eat. One year she stood in the sanctuary praying so intensely, her lips moving without a sound, that the old priest Eli took her for drunk. She had made a vow: if the Lord would give her a son, she would give him back "to the Lord all the days of his life" (1 Samuel 1:11). The son came, and she named him Samuel, explaining, "I have asked for him from the Lord" (1 Samuel 1:20). When he was weaned, which in that world could mean as late as two or three, she brought him to Shiloh with a bull, flour and wine, and left him with Eli. "Therefore I have lent him to the Lord," she said (1 Samuel 1:28). Every year after that she came up with a little robe she had made for him. The later book of Chronicles places Samuel’s family among the Levites, the tribe set apart for sanctuary service (1 Chronicles 6:26-28, 33-34), a family that lived in Ephraim’s hills. So the boy who grew up wearing a linen ephod, a simple priestly garment, at Shiloh (1 Samuel 2:18) was serving where his ancestry had always pointed.
(●) c. 1090 BC: As a boy he heard the Lord call him in the night, and the word he was given was judgment on Eli’s house. Shiloh in those days was a sanctuary in decay. Eli was old and nearly blind, and his two sons, Hophni and Phinehas, were priests who helped themselves to the sacrifices and slept with the women who served at the entrance. The narrator sums them up in one flat line: they "were worthless men. They did not know the Lord" (1 Samuel 2:12). And the narrator adds a line about the whole age: "the word of the Lord was rare in those days; there was no frequent vision" (1 Samuel 3:1). Then one night, with the lamp of God not yet gone out, the boy heard his name. He ran to Eli, who had not called him, and was sent back to bed. It happened a second time, and a third, before the old man understood and told him what to say. The fourth time Samuel answered as he had been taught, and the message he received was terrible: the Lord would punish Eli’s house because his sons were blaspheming God "and he did not restrain them" (1 Samuel 3:13). In the morning Samuel was afraid to tell, and Eli made him tell everything. The first-century Jewish historian Josephus says Samuel was twelve when he began to prophesy; Scripture says only that he was a boy. From that night on, "the Lord was with him and let none of his words fall to the ground," and all Israel "from Dan to Beersheba," the country’s whole length from north to south, knew him for a prophet (1 Samuel 3:19-20).
(●) c. 1080 BC: The Philistines took the ark and Shiloh fell, and some twenty years later he led Israel back to God at Mizpah. The judgment came on a battlefield. Israel met the Philistines, the well-armed coastal people pressing up into the hill country, near Aphek, and Israel lost. The elders decided the problem was that God had not been with them, so they fetched the ark of the covenant from Shiloh and carried it into the next battle like a lucky charm. It did not work. Israel was routed, Hophni and Phinehas were killed, and the ark was captured. When a runner reached Shiloh with the news, old Eli fell backward from his seat by the gate and broke his neck (1 Samuel 4:18). Centuries later Jeremiah could still point to Shiloh as the warning everyone remembered: "see what I did to it because of the evil of my people Israel" (Jeremiah 7:12). The ark came back, after the Philistines decided it was more trouble than it was worth, and sat for a long time at a village called Kiriath-jearim, "some twenty years" (1 Samuel 7:2). Then Samuel called the nation together at Mizpah. His message was blunt: if you mean it, throw out the foreign gods, especially the Ashtaroth, the fertility goddesses of Canaan, and serve the Lord only (T2). The people fasted and poured out water before the Lord and confessed. While they were still assembled the Philistines attacked, a thunderstorm broke over them, and Israel drove them back. Samuel set up a stone and named it Ebenezer, "stone of help." For the rest of his working life he rode a circuit like a traveling judge, year by year from Bethel to Gilgal to Mizpah and home again to Ramah, where he built an altar (1 Samuel 7:15-17).
(●) c. 1050 BC: When Israel demanded a king like the nations, he warned them, then anointed Saul. Samuel grew old, and he did what Eli had done: he made his sons judges. Joel and Abijah sat in Beersheba, in the far south, and "turned aside after gain. They took bribes and perverted justice" (1 Samuel 8:3). The elders of Israel came to Ramah with a demand: "Now appoint for us a king to judge us like all the nations" (1 Samuel 8:5). Samuel took it personally, and the Lord told him not to: "they have not rejected you, but they have rejected me from being king over them" (1 Samuel 8:7). So Samuel gave them the warning in full. A king would take their sons for his chariots, their daughters for his kitchens, the best of their fields for his servants, and a tenth of everything, and one day they would cry out because of the king they had chosen. They listened, and answered, "No! But there shall be a king over us" (1 Samuel 8:19). The king turned up looking for lost donkeys. Saul, a tall young Benjamite (a man of the small tribe of Benjamin), came to Samuel because his servant had heard there was a seer in town who could tell them which way to go. Samuel poured a flask of oil over his head and kissed him (1 Samuel 10:1). That was the private anointing. The public choice came later, at an assembly at Mizpah, where the tribes cast lots, a sacred drawing of straws in which the people trusted God to guide the outcome, and the lot fell on Saul in front of everyone. Samuel then did something new: he wrote down "the rights and duties of the kingship" in a book and laid it up before the Lord (1 Samuel 10:25). The king would rule under a written charter. At Gilgal, once Saul was confirmed, Samuel gave his farewell as judge. He stood before the people and dared them to name one ox or donkey he had taken, one bribe he had accepted (1 Samuel 12:3). No one could.
(●) c. 1025 BC: He broke with Saul, grieved for him, and anointed a shepherd boy from Bethlehem. Saul’s reign went wrong twice, and both times it was Samuel who said so. The first time, at Gilgal before a battle, Saul waited seven days for Samuel to come and offer the sacrifice, watched his army melting away, and offered it himself. Samuel arrived as the smoke was rising and told him his kingdom would not last (1 Samuel 13:8-14). The second time, sent to destroy the Amalekites, the desert raiders who had been Israel’s enemies since the wilderness years, Saul spared their king Agag and the best of the livestock and then claimed the animals were for sacrifice. Samuel’s answer became one of the most quoted sentences in the Old Testament: "to obey is better than sacrifice" (T3). Samuel then put Agag to death himself at Gilgal (1 Samuel 15:33), and he and Saul parted. It cost him. "Samuel did not see Saul again until the day of his death, but Samuel grieved over Saul" (1 Samuel 15:35), and the grief went on until the Lord asked him, "How long will you grieve over Saul?" and sent him to Bethlehem with a horn of oil (1 Samuel 16:1). There Jesse paraded his sons, and Samuel was sure the tall eldest was the one, until he was told that "man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart" (1 Samuel 16:7). The one chosen was the youngest, out with the sheep. Samuel anointed David in the middle of his brothers, "and the Spirit of the Lord rushed upon David from that day forward" (1 Samuel 16:13). The convention of c. 1025 BC is a guess at the middle of Saul’s reign; Scripture gives no year, and the verse that once gave Saul’s age and length of reign has come down damaged (1 Samuel 13:1).
(●) c. 1015 BC: He sheltered the fugitive David, then died at Ramah, and all Israel mourned him. When Saul turned on David and tried to kill him, David ran to the one man in Israel who knew what had happened at Bethlehem. He came to Samuel at Ramah, and the two of them went to stay at Naioth (1 Samuel 19:18), where Samuel stood at the head of a company of prophets. Saul sent three rounds of messengers to seize David, and each in turn was overtaken by the Spirit of God and began to prophesy; Saul came himself and the same thing happened to him (1 Samuel 19:20-24). It is the last time the old prophet and the young king-in-waiting are seen together. The death notice, when it comes, is one verse long: "Now Samuel died. And all Israel assembled and mourned for him, and they buried him in his house at Ramah" (1 Samuel 25:1). He did not live to see Saul fall on Mount Gilboa or David crowned, though the conventional date of his death sits only a few years before both. One strange scene follows. On the night before his last battle, abandoned by every ordinary way of hearing from God, Saul went in disguise to a medium at Endor and asked her to bring Samuel up. The narrator reports that Samuel appeared, asked, "Why have you disturbed me by bringing me up?" (1 Samuel 28:15), and told Saul he would die the next day. Even from the grave, Samuel’s word to Saul was the same word.
What He Taught
(T1) God speaks, and a servant’s first work is to listen. Think of a child at night hearing a voice from the next room and padding in to ask what is wanted. That is exactly the scene, and Samuel’s whole career grows out of it. Three times the boy ran to the wrong person, because, the narrator explains, he "did not yet know the Lord, and the word of the Lord had not yet been revealed to him" (1 Samuel 3:7). The fourth time he said the words Eli gave him, and from then on that was his posture for life. A prophet in the Hebrew Bible is not first a fortune-teller. He is a messenger, someone who has heard a word from God and passes it on unaltered, whether it flatters the hearer or condemns him. An earlier word for the same office was "seer" (1 Samuel 9:9), the one who sees what others cannot. Samuel was both, and his authority came entirely from the hearing. He had no army, no throne and no inheritance; he had what he had been told. Christian readers have always taken the night at Shiloh as a picture of prayer that starts with listening rather than talking. And the line in the following verses, that the Lord "let none of his words fall to the ground" (1 Samuel 3:19), is the Old Testament’s test of a true prophet put in a single image: what he said came true.
(Q) "Speak, for your servant hears." Source: 1 Samuel 3:10 (English Standard Version). The boy’s answer the fourth time he was called. Eli had told him to say, "Speak, Lord, for your servant hears" (1 Samuel 3:9); Samuel, perhaps not yet daring to name the One speaking, left out the word "Lord."
(T2) Returning to God means putting away every rival and serving him only. Imagine a man who tells his wife he has given up an old flame but keeps her photograph in his wallet, just in case. Israel at Mizpah was in the same position. They "lamented after the Lord" (1 Samuel 7:2), they wanted him back, and the Baals and Ashtaroth were still standing in their villages: the Canaanite gods of storm and fertility, whose worship promised good harvests and full wombs. Samuel’s word for what they needed is the Old Testament’s word for repentance, shuv, "turn" or "return": a whole person turning around and walking back the other way. And he made it concrete. Sorrow was not enough and a sacrifice was not enough; the idols had to go out of the house. Only then would the Lord deliver them from the Philistines. This is the pattern of every revival in Israel’s later history, under Hezekiah and Josiah and in Ezra’s day, and the same note sounds in the New Testament when Paul praises the Thessalonians for how they "turned to God from idols to serve the living and true God" (1 Thessalonians 1:9). Grief over sin is where repentance starts. It is finished when the rival is gone.
(Q) "If you are returning to the Lord with all your heart, then put away the foreign gods and the Ashtaroth from among you and direct your heart to the Lord and serve him only, and he will deliver you out of the hand of the Philistines." Source: 1 Samuel 7:3 (English Standard Version). Spoken to "all the house of Israel" after the twenty years the ark spent at Kiriath-jearim, as the opening of the assembly at Mizpah.
(T3) To obey is better than sacrifice. Picture a son told to mow the lawn who instead spends the afternoon washing his father’s car, and then presents the shining car as proof of his devotion. The gift is real, and it is not what he was asked to do. That is Saul after the Amalekite campaign. He had been told to destroy everything, he kept the best sheep and oxen, and when Samuel arrived he explained they were for a sacrifice to the Lord. Samuel’s reply goes to the root of all religion. Sacrifice was commanded in the law of Moses; Samuel himself offered it. But a sacrifice is meant to express a heart that already belongs to God, and when it is offered in place of obedience it becomes a bribe. He goes further: rebellion is "as the sin of divination," the occult practice the law forbade, and stubborn presumption is as bad as idolatry, because both put the self’s judgment in God’s place. The prophets who came after him said the same thing for centuries: Hosea ("I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice," Hosea 6:6), Micah, Isaiah. Jesus quoted Hosea’s version of it twice (Matthew 9:13; 12:7). It is one of the clearest threads running from Samuel to the gospel.
(Q) "Has the Lord as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the Lord? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to listen than the fat of rams." Source: 1 Samuel 15:22 (English Standard Version). Samuel to Saul at Gilgal, after Saul had spared Agag and the best of the Amalekite flocks. The next verse delivers the sentence: "Because you have rejected the word of the Lord, he has also rejected you from being king" (1 Samuel 15:23). Look at the second half, "to listen." The same hearing that began Samuel’s life with God (T1) turns out to be the substance of obedience.
(T4) The Lord is Israel’s true king, and any human king rules under his word. The nations around Israel had kings, and those kings claimed to rule by the choice of their gods; in Egypt the pharaoh was hailed as a god himself. Their word was the law. Samuel gave Israel a king and refused to give it that kind of king. Think of the difference between a family business run by its owner and the same business run by a hired manager with a signed contract. The owner can do as he likes. The manager answers to someone, and the contract in the drawer says what he may and may not do. Samuel made Israel’s king the manager. His warning in 1 Samuel 8 is one of the oldest sustained accounts in literature of what unchecked power does: it takes. And his solution was not to abolish the throne but to put something above it. The king was anointed by a prophet, which meant he was chosen rather than self-made. His duties were written in a book and laid up before the Lord (1 Samuel 10:25), which meant they were not his to change. And the promise of blessing in Samuel’s farewell speech is conditional on both the people and the king following the Lord. The king is inside the covenant, the binding agreement between the Lord and his people, not above it. The pattern held for the rest of the monarchy. Nathan confronted David over Bathsheba, Elijah confronted Ahab, and each of them was doing what Samuel did at Gilgal. In the long run of Christian thought it became one of the deep roots of the idea that rulers are answerable to a law they did not write.
(Q) "If you will fear the Lord and serve him and obey his voice and not rebel against the commandment of the Lord, and if both you and the king who reigns over you will follow the Lord your God, it will be well." Source: 1 Samuel 12:14 (English Standard Version). From Samuel’s farewell address at Gilgal, with Saul newly confirmed as king and standing among the people. The condition binds "both you and the king" alike.
(T5) To stop praying for God’s people is itself a sin. The people had just rejected his leadership. They had asked for a king to replace him, over his objections, and on the day of his farewell a thunderstorm in the dry season of the wheat harvest frightened them into admitting they had done wrong. Most of us, in Samuel’s place, would have felt entitled to wash our hands of them. He did the opposite. His word for prayer on someone else’s behalf is what theologians call intercession: standing between God and others and pleading for them. Samuel had done it at Mizpah, crying to the Lord for Israel while the Philistines advanced (1 Samuel 7:9), and he did it all night over Saul (1 Samuel 15:11). Now he called it a duty so serious that neglecting it would be sin against the Lord. He would keep praying, and keep teaching them "the good and the right way." Scripture remembered him for exactly this. A psalm names him among "those who called upon his name" and were answered (Psalm 99:6), and Jeremiah heard God name Moses and Samuel together as the two whose pleading, if anyone’s could, would have turned him (Jeremiah 15:1).
(Q) "Moreover, as for me, far be it from me that I should sin against the Lord by ceasing to pray for you, and I will instruct you in the good and the right way." Source: 1 Samuel 12:23 (English Standard Version). The close of the farewell address, spoken to the people who had just confessed that asking for a king was a sin added to all their others (1 Samuel 12:19).
(Q) "Till now the Lord has helped us." Source: 1 Samuel 7:12 (English Standard Version). Spoken as Samuel set up the stone he named Ebenezer, "stone of help," after the victory at Mizpah. The line looks backward in gratitude and forward in trust at once, and the hymn writer Robert Robinson put it into "Come, Thou Fount of Every Blessing": "Here I raise my Ebenezer."
What the Church Made of Him
(†) Scripture itself remembered him beside Moses as an intercessor, and as the head of the line of prophets. The rest of the Bible keeps coming back to Samuel. The psalmist sets him beside Moses and Aaron (Psalm 99:6). Jeremiah, in Jerusalem’s last years, hears that the city’s sin has gone so far that even if Moses and Samuel stood before God to plead, he would not relent (Jeremiah 15:1). The Chronicler, as scholars call the unnamed author of the books of Chronicles, remembers him as "Samuel the seer," organizing the Levite gatekeepers alongside David (1 Chronicles 9:22), and dates Josiah’s great Passover by him: there had been none like it "since the days of Samuel the prophet" (2 Chronicles 35:18). In the New Testament he marks the beginning of an era. Peter, preaching in the temple, says that "all the prophets who have spoken, from Samuel and those who came after him, also proclaimed these days" (Acts 3:24): Samuel heads the line of prophets that ends in Christ. Paul, preaching at Pisidian Antioch, marks the end of the judges with "Samuel the prophet" (Acts 13:20). And the letter to the Hebrews lists him among the heroes of faith (Hebrews 11:32). Jewish tradition between the Testaments honored him just as highly. Ben Sira, a Jewish teacher of wisdom writing around 180 BC in the book that bears his name (Sirach, which Catholic and Orthodox Bibles include and Protestants count among the Apocrypha), praises him as beloved of his Lord, the one who established the kingdom and anointed rulers (Sirach 46:13-20).
(†) Luke told the births of John and Jesus in the colors of Samuel’s. Anyone who reads 1 Samuel 1 and 2 and then the first two chapters of Luke will hear the echoes. A woman long without a child, a son given to God from the womb, a mother’s song about the Lord who brings down the mighty and lifts up the poor. Hannah sang hers at Shiloh (1 Samuel 2:1-10). Mary’s song, called the Magnificat after its first word in Latin, echoes Hannah’s again and again (Luke 1:46-55). And Luke’s summary of the boy Jesus, that he "increased in wisdom and in stature and in favor with God and man" (Luke 2:52), repeats almost word for word what was said of the boy Samuel at Shiloh (1 Samuel 2:26). The church fathers noticed something else in Hannah’s song. It ends with the Lord giving strength "to his king" and exalting "the horn of his anointed" (1 Samuel 2:10). The horn is an old Hebrew picture of strength, borrowed from a bull that lowers its head to charge. And Israel had no king when she sang it. Augustine, in book seventeen of The City of God, read the song as prophecy: the barren woman who bears is the church, and "his anointed" is Christ, with his people joined to him as one body (XVII.4). The first time Scripture calls a king "anointed," it is looking past Saul and David to the One both of them foreshadowed.
(†) The fathers read his anointing of David as the start of the line that runs to Christ, and argued over whether it was truly Samuel who spoke to Saul at Endor. When Samuel poured oil on David among his brothers, he started the royal line to which God later promised an everlasting throne (2 Samuel 7:12-16), and the New Testament opens by calling Jesus "the son of David" (Matthew 1:1). Augustine, in the same book of The City of God, went a step further with Samuel’s words to Saul, that the kingdom had been torn from him and given to a better man (1 Samuel 15:28). He read them as a figure, a real event that also pictures a larger one. Israel would lose its earthly kingdom to Christ, the "neighbor" better than Saul, who would reign spiritually. And the tearing pictured a lasting division between the Israel of the flesh, the nation by descent, and the spiritual Israel, the people joined to Christ by faith (XVII.7). The Endor scene raised a question the fathers argued over for generations: was it really Samuel who spoke to Saul? Origen of Alexandria, the great third-century Bible scholar, in a sermon on the passage, held that it was, since the text says so plainly and the prophecy came true the next day. Eustathius of Antioch, a bishop of the following century, wrote a whole treatise against him, arguing that a medium could not summon a saint and that a demon had played Samuel’s part. Augustine weighed both readings more than once. Answering Simplician in the 390s, he judged either one consistent with the faith and inclined, for the time being, toward a deception worked through the medium (To Simplician II.3). Decades later, in On the Care of the Dead (15.18), he cited Samuel among the dead whom God sometimes sends to the living, pointing out that the book of Sirach says Samuel prophesied after he had died (Sirach 46:20). The debate never closed. Whoever spoke, the words Saul heard at Endor repeated the sentence Samuel had pronounced in life: the kingdom torn from his hand and given to his neighbor (1 Samuel 28:17; 15:28).
(†) His one recorded failing is a father’s: he made judges of sons who took bribes. Samuel’s record is unusually clean. No one at Gilgal could name a bribe he had taken, and the narrative never rebukes him for a sin of his own. But it does record one thing he did, and lets the reader draw the line. Eli’s house fell because his sons were corrupt and he did not restrain them (1 Samuel 3:13). A few chapters later Samuel, grown old, appointed his own sons Joel and Abijah as judges, and they "took bribes and perverted justice" (1 Samuel 8:1-3). It was their corruption the elders cited when they demanded a king. Scripture does not pass a verdict on him for it, and nothing in the text says he knew. The parallel is there to be seen, and it is an honest one: the prophet who held kings to account could not pass his own integrity on to his children by appointing them to office.