Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Classical Greece

600 BC – 300 BC

Diogenes of Sinope c. 412 – c. 323 BC

(●) The beggar-philosopher of the storage jar, who taught Greece that a good life needs almost nothing and said so to the face of kings. + Picture a crowded Athenian marketplace at midday. An old man with a doubled cloak, a beggar’s bag and a stick is walking among the stalls holding a lit lamp, peering into faces. Asked what he is doing, he says he is looking for a man. That is Diogenes of Sinope, and almost everyone who has heard one story about ancient philosophy has heard that one. He is the founding figure of the Cynics, a word that comes from the Greek kyon, "dog." His neighbors called him the Dog because he ate, slept and argued in public, owned nothing, and barked at anyone he thought was a fraud. He took the insult and wore it. The movement that grew from him, and the Stoics who learned from it (the larger and more respectable school of philosophy that grew up in Athens after him), taught the ancient world that virtue is the one thing a person truly needs, and that money, rank and comfort are not merely unnecessary but often in the way. That is why he belongs on a Christian site. Four centuries before the gospel, Diogenes lived out a radical renunciation that Christians would later recognize, and his short, sharp sayings were collected and retold the way the sayings of the desert monks would be. He also shows, with unusual clarity, what renunciation looks like when it has no God to be renounced for. A signature fact: he wrote little or nothing that survives, and almost everything we know of him comes as anecdotes, gathered five or six centuries after his death by a biographer who happened to share his name, Diogenes Laertius.

(●) c. 412 BC: Born the son of a banker in Sinope, he left his city in disgrace over defaced coins. + Sinope was a busy Greek trading port on the southern shore of the Black Sea, in what is now northern Turkey. Diogenes was born there around 412 BC; the year is worked back from the ancient report that he died at nearly ninety, so it is a convention rather than a record. His father, Hicesias, was a banker, a man responsible for the city’s money. Something went badly wrong with that money. The ancient sources agree that the coinage of Sinope was "adulterated" (debased or defaced), and disagree about who did it. One account blames the father, another blames Diogenes, and Diogenes Laertius says Diogenes himself confessed it in one of his writings. One story adds that he had asked the oracle of Apollo (a shrine where Greeks brought their questions and believed the god would answer) what to do and was told to "alter the political currency," and only later understood that the god meant the currency of custom, not of coins. Whether he was banished or fled before he could be, he left Sinope for good. He turned the disgrace into a motto. When someone taunted him with his exile, he answered that it was through exile that he became a philosopher.

(●) c. 360s BC: In Athens he made himself a disciple of Antisthenes and a home of a storage jar. + In Athens he fell in with Antisthenes, an old companion of Socrates who taught that virtue is enough for happiness and lived plainly to prove it. The ancient story says Antisthenes did not want pupils and raised his stick to drive him off, and Diogenes bent his head and told him to strike, because no wood was hard enough to keep him away while Antisthenes had something to say. We cannot be sure the two men really met. Modern estimates for Diogenes’ arrival in Athens run from about 370 to 345 BC, and Antisthenes seems to have died around 366 BC, so their years in the city may barely have overlapped, if they overlapped at all. The debt, though, is real: Diogenes took the older man’s plainness and made it total. The famous "tub" was not a wooden barrel. It was a pithos, a large clay storage jar of the kind used for grain or wine, big enough for a man to curl up in, lying by the Metroon, the temple-archive in the Athenian marketplace. He had asked a friend to find him a cottage, and when the friend was slow about it he moved into the jar. What taught him to live that way, one source says, was a mouse: it ran about without looking for a bed, without fear of the dark, without wanting any of the delicacies people think they need. Later, seeing a boy drink water from his cupped hands, he threw away his own cup and said a child had beaten him at plain living.

(●) Mid-4th century BC: As "the Dog" he made the marketplace his school and Plato his favorite target. + Diogenes did his teaching the way a street performer works a crowd. He would begin a serious talk, find no one listening, start whistling, and then scold the people who gathered for coming running to nonsense and strolling past wisdom. He ate in the marketplace, slept in porticoes (the covered colonnades that ran along the edges of public squares), and told the Athenians they had kindly built him places to live. Plato, then the most celebrated teacher in Athens, was a natural target. When Plato defined a human being as a featherless two-legged animal, Diogenes plucked a chicken, carried it into the lecture room and announced, "Here is Plato’s man." When Plato spoke of "tablehood" and "cuphood," the eternal Forms behind ordinary tables and cups, Diogenes said he could see a table and a cup but no tablehood. Plato gave as good as he got. When Diogenes trampled Plato’s carpets to trample his pride, Plato told him he was showing a pride of his own. Asked what sort of man Diogenes was, Plato is said to have answered, "A Socrates gone mad." Aristotle, a younger member of Plato’s school, quotes a sharp saying of "the Dog" in his Rhetoric, which suggests the nickname had already stuck while Diogenes was alive.

(●) Date unknown, 4th century BC: Sold as a slave in Crete, by tradition, he ended up running the household of the man who bought him. + The best-loved story of his later life may be more literature than history, and the ancient sources themselves trace it to a work called The Sale of Diogenes. As it is told, pirates seized him on a voyage to the island of Aegina and put him up for auction in Crete. Asked what he was good at, he said, "Ruling men," and pointed to a well-dressed Corinthian named Xeniades: "Sell me to this man; he needs a master." Xeniades bought him, took him home to Corinth, and put him in charge of his sons and then of the whole household. Diogenes taught the boys to ride and throw the javelin, to learn poetry by heart, to eat plain food and drink water, to wait on themselves. When friends offered to buy his freedom, he called them simpletons. Lions, he said, are not the slaves of the people who feed them. Whether or not every detail is true, it captures what he believed: slavery is a condition of the soul, and a free man is free even on the auction block.

(●) c. 336 BC: At Corinth he told Alexander the Great to stand out of his light. + The meeting everyone remembers took place, if it took place, at the Craneum, a gymnasium and grove just outside Corinth. Plutarch, the Greek biographer, sets it at the time when the Greek cities gathered at the Isthmus of Corinth (the narrow neck of land joining the southern peninsula of Greece to the north) to name the young Alexander their leader for the war against Persia, around 336 or 335 BC. Diogenes was lying in the sun. The new master of Greece came and stood over him and invited him to ask for anything he liked. Diogenes answered, "Stand out of my light." Alexander’s companions laughed, but Alexander is reported to have said that if he were not Alexander, he would have liked to be Diogenes. It was not his only brush with Macedonian power. A Stoic source quoted by Diogenes Laertius says that after the battle of Chaeronea in 338 BC, where Alexander’s father Philip crushed the Greek cities, Diogenes was dragged before the king. Asked who he was, he said, "A spy upon your insatiable greed," and Philip, impressed, let him go.

(●) c. 323 BC: He died at Corinth at nearly ninety, and a marble dog was set over his grave. + The ancient reports of his death disagree, which is fitting for a man who left behind stories rather than records. One says he ate a raw octopus and died of the cramps; another that a dog bit him while he was dividing an octopus among the dogs; another, the one his friends believed, that he simply held his breath. They found him at the Craneum wrapped in his cloak, and thought he was asleep until they drew the cloak back. A later tradition, repeated by an ancient biographer, says he died on the very day Alexander died in Babylon, in 323 BC. That neat coincidence is exactly the kind of thing later writers liked to arrange, so the date is best taken as approximate. He had once said he wanted to be thrown out unburied for the animals. Instead his disciples quarreled over who would bury him, and he was laid by the gate leading to the Isthmus, under a pillar topped with a dog in Parian marble (marble from the Greek island of Paros). His own city, which had once driven him out, later put up bronze statues of him with verses praising him for teaching mortals "the lesson of self-sufficingness."

What He Taught

(T1) Virtue is the only true good, and a person who has it needs almost nothing else. + Think about the last time you moved house and discovered how much you owned that you never used. Diogenes would say that every one of those things was a small chain. The Greek word for his ideal is autarkeia, "self-sufficiency": being so little dependent on outside things that nothing fortune can take away is able to touch you. A cup can break, a house can burn, a patron can withdraw his favor, but a man who needs none of them cannot be robbed. For Diogenes this was not a lifestyle choice but a moral argument. He said the gods had given human beings the means of living easily, and that people had buried that gift under honey cakes and perfumes. Most of what we call needs are habits, and most habits are weaknesses dressed up as necessities. Strip them away and what is left is the one thing that really matters, a good character. Christian readers would hear an echo. Paul uses a form of the same Greek word when he tells the Philippians, "I have learned in whatever situation I am to be content" (Philippians 4:11), and a letter to Timothy says "godliness with contentment is great gain" (1 Timothy 6:6). The difference lies in what holds the contentment up. For Diogenes it was his own hard-won independence. Paul names something else two verses later: not his own strength at all, but Christ, who strengthens him (Philippians 4:13).

(Q) "A child has beaten me in plainness of living." + Source: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers VI.37 (Hicks translation). He had just watched a child drink from his hands, and threw away the cup he carried in his bag. Diogenes Laertius adds that he later threw away his bowl too, after seeing a boy scoop up lentils with a hollowed piece of bread.

(T2) Nature is the true guide to life, and custom is a counterfeit coin to be defaced. + Every society runs on unwritten rules: what you may eat in public, what clothes mark you as respectable, whom you must flatter. The Greeks had a word for that whole system, nomos, "custom" or "convention," and they set it against physis, "nature," the way things really are. Diogenes put himself entirely on the side of nature. If something is not shameful in itself, he argued, it is not shameful in public either. If eating breakfast is not wrong, eating breakfast in the marketplace is not wrong. Diogenes Laertius sums up his mission with the oracle’s old word play: he went about "adulterating currency in very truth." A false coin carries an official stamp but is not worth what the stamp says. Diogenes thought most of the honors of Greek life (good birth, fame, wealth, political office) were coins of that kind, stamped with approval but worth nothing, and he set out to deface them so people would stop trading in them. There is real moral force in this. He saw sheep at Megara wearing leather jackets while the children went bare, and said it was better to be a Megarian’s ram than his son. He mocked sacrifices offered for health at feasts that ruined it. But "follow nature" turned out to be a weaker guide than he hoped, and his own practice shows where it broke down (see the final reception row).

(Q) "To fortune he could oppose courage, to convention nature, to passion reason." + Source: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers VI.38 (Hicks translation). Diogenes Laertius reports this as Diogenes’ own claim about himself, in indirect speech, right after his complaint that every curse of tragedy had fallen on him: homeless, an exile, a beggar. The three pairs are his whole program in a sentence.

(T3) Goodness is won by hard training, the way an athlete wins a race. + Anyone who has learned the piano knows the secret: the fingers become fluent only after thousands of hours of scales. Diogenes thought character works the same way. The Greek word is askesis, "training" or "exercise," the word an athlete used for his daily workout, and it is the root of the English "ascetic." He rolled in hot sand in summer and hugged snow-covered statues in winter, not because suffering is good in itself but to teach his body and his will not to flinch. Diogenes Laertius sums up his argument: craftsmen, flute players and athletes reach astonishing skill by constant practice, so if people spent the same effort training the soul, they would not labor in vain. Even the despising of pleasure, he said, becomes pleasant once you are used to it. When friends told him he was an old man and should rest, he answered with a picture from the racetrack. The Christian word "asceticism" comes straight from this vocabulary, and Paul borrows the athlete’s picture freely: "Every athlete exercises self-control in all things" (1 Corinthians 9:25). But Scripture also warns that severity to the body can carry "an appearance of wisdom" and still be "of no value in stopping the indulgence of the flesh" (Colossians 2:23).

(Q) "If I were running in the stadium, ought I to slacken my pace when approaching the goal? ought I not rather to put on speed?" + Source: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers VI.34 (Hicks translation). His reply to people who told him, "You are an old man; take a rest." Old age, for Diogenes, was the last lap, not the cool-down.

(T4) A wise man belongs to no city but the whole world, and owes the truth to everyone in it. + Asked where he came from, a Greek normally named his city: Athens, Corinth, Sinope. Diogenes said he was a kosmopolites, "a citizen of the world." No one is known to have used the word before him, and he probably coined it; it became our "cosmopolitan." For an exile it was partly a joke, and partly a claim that the city walls and family trees Greeks were so proud of did not mark the real boundaries of human worth. The only true commonwealth, he said, is as wide as the universe. A citizen of the world owes no flattery to anyone in it, and Diogenes valued parrhesia, "frank speech," saying the true thing to anyone, above everything. Asked what was the most beautiful thing in the world, he said, "Freedom of speech." He used it on Plato, on the orator Demosthenes, on Philip and on Alexander. The New Testament uses the same word for the apostles’ "boldness" before the council in Jerusalem (Acts 4:13), and it also gives Christians a citizenship that cuts across every city: "our citizenship is in heaven" (Philippians 3:20). The difference is that the Christian is a citizen of a kingdom with a King, not a citizen of the cosmos answerable only to himself.

(Q) "I am a citizen of the world." + Source: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers VI.63 (Hicks translation). His whole answer to the question "Where do you come from?" The Greek is kosmopolites.

(Q) "I am looking for a man." + Source: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers VI.41 (Hicks translation). He lit a lamp in broad daylight and went about saying this. It is a judgment on everyone he met, and an admission too: in a whole city he could not find one person who was what a human being ought to be. Christians would agree with the search and answer it differently. For them the man was found, and found in an unlikely place: Jesus, led out by Pilate in a crown of thorns and shown to the crowd as "the man" (John 19:5).

What Christian Thinkers Made of Him

(†) The fathers held up his plain living as a rebuke to self-indulgent Christians. + The church fathers did not treat Diogenes as an enemy. They treated him as a witness, the way a preacher might point to an unbeliever who is more honest than half the congregation. Jerome, the great translator of the Bible into Latin, wrote a treatise around AD 393 against a monk named Jovinian, who taught that fasting and feasting made no moral difference. To answer him Jerome gathered examples of self-denial from the pagans, and he gave Diogenes pride of place: the folded cloak, the beggar’s bag as his pantry, the tub he turned toward the sun in winter and away from it in summer, the cup thrown away after watching a boy drink from his hand. The point was a kind of argument from the lesser to the greater. If a pagan, with no promise of heaven and no Savior to imitate, could live this simply for the sake of virtue, how much more should Christians, who follow a Lord who had nowhere to lay his head (Matthew 8:20). Paul himself had described the apostles as hungry, thirsty, "poorly dressed," and "homeless" (1 Corinthians 4:11), a description any Athenian would have recognized as the life of a Cynic.

(Q) "His most famous follower was the great Diogenes, who was mightier than King Alexander in that he conquered human nature." + Source: Jerome, Against Jovinianus II.14 (Fremantle translation, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers). Jerome has just told the story of Antisthenes, and turns to his most famous pupil. The comparison with Alexander is the one the ancient world loved best: the king who conquered nations, and the beggar who conquered himself.

(†) His style of protest lived on in the desert monks, and even a pagan emperor saw the likeness. + When Christian men and women went out into the Egyptian and Syrian deserts in the fourth century, they did many things Diogenes had done: they gave up property and family plans, lived in the open or in tiny cells, ate little, wore one rough garment, and spoke in short, cutting sayings that their followers collected and retold. The Sayings of the Desert Fathers reads in places like a Christian answer to the anecdote collections about Diogenes. The resemblance was obvious at the time. Julian, the last pagan emperor, who admired Diogenes and despised the Christians, wrote an attack in AD 362 on the wandering Cynics of his own day. He told them he had a nickname for them, "monks," a name the "impious Galilaeans" (his word for Christians) gave to certain of their own, and that in their habits the two groups were very much alike: both had left their homes and wandered the world. The deeper difference was the reason for the renunciation. Diogenes gave things up so that nothing could touch him. The monks gave things up so that God could. Antony, the most famous of them, went into the desert after hearing Jesus’ words read in church: sell what you have, give to the poor, and come, follow me (Matthew 19:21).

(†) Where the gospel parts company with him: shamelessness, pride, and a freedom with no God in it. + The Christians who admired his simplicity also had to say plainly where Diogenes himself went wrong. Three points come from his own record. - Shamelessness. Following "nature" to its end, Diogenes did everything in public, Diogenes Laertius says, including eating and sex, and he defended it with the argument that what is not wrong in private is not wrong in public. Augustine, in a chapter of The City of God headed "Of the Foolish Beastliness of the Cynics" (XIV.20), called the view "worthy indeed of dogs," and observed that the example was not followed: the Cynics of his own day still wore the cloak, but no one of them dared to do it. Scripture treats modesty not as mere convention but as part of how human beings honor the body God made (1 Corinthians 12:23). And the same reasoning reached further still. Diogenes Laertius reports that he saw nothing wrong in stealing from a temple, advocated a community of wives (recognizing no marriage but the union of a man who persuades with a woman who consents), and argued that even eating human flesh was not impious, citing foreign customs. - Pride. Diogenes made a show of having nothing, and Plato told him so to his face: in trampling Plato’s vanity he displayed a vanity of his own. The gospel locates freedom from possessions in humility, not display. "What do you have that you did not receive? If then you received it, why do you boast as if you did not receive it?" (1 Corinthians 4:7). - A freedom with no God in it. Diogenes mocked purification rites (the sprinkling with water that Greeks used to cleanse themselves of guilt), saying sprinkling could no more wash away wrongdoing than it could fix a grammar mistake, and Christians agreed with the diagnosis. But he offered no cure beyond self-discipline. Scripture says the cure is not a rite and not a regimen but a person: "the blood of Christ, who through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish to God," purifies the conscience (Hebrews 9:14). Paul’s contentment in every circumstance is real, but it is not self-made: "I can do all things through him who strengthens me" (Philippians 4:13). Diogenes saw more clearly than almost anyone in Athens how little a good life requires. What he could not see was who gives it.

Nothing Diogenes wrote survives. Even in antiquity it was disputed whether he wrote anything at all: Diogenes Laertius lists works under his name, then reports that two earlier biographers, Sosicrates and Satyrus, said he left nothing in writing, and that a third, Sotion, accepted a different and shorter list as genuine. What survives instead is a large body of anecdotes and sayings (in Greek, chreiai, short pointed stories ending in a memorable line), preserved by later writers. The works and witnesses below are what a reader can actually consult. Works attributed to him in antiquity (all lost): - Republic (Politeia): His sketch of the ideal community, a city as wide as the world, with community of wives and children and knucklebones in place of coined money. It was known and discussed by the early Stoics, and later Stoics who were embarrassed by it tried to deny that he wrote it. - Pordalus: A dialogue in which, according to Diogenes Laertius, he admitted to adulterating the coinage of Sinope. - Cephalion, Ichthyas, Jackdaw, The Athenian Demos, Art of Ethics, On Wealth, On Love, Theodorus, Hypsias, Aristarchus, On Death: The rest of the list of dialogues Diogenes Laertius gives (VI.80). Only the titles survive. - Letters: Mentioned in the ancient lists, and Diogenes Laertius cites them for the story of the jar. They are lost, and are not the same as the later collection below. - Seven tragedies (Helen, Thyestes, Heracles, Achilles, Medea, Chrysippus, Oedipus): Short plays used to dramatize Cynic teaching; the Thyestes apparently defended the claim that eating human flesh is not impious. Even in antiquity they were assigned by some to his follower Philiscus of Aegina. - Sotion’s alternative list: On Virtue, On Good, On Love, A Mendicant, Tolmaeus, Pordalus, Casandrus, Cephalion, Philiscus, Aristarchus, Sisyphus, Ganymedes, Anecdotes, Letters. The titles that differ from the first list show how uncertain the corpus was already. Wrongly attributed: - The Cynic Epistles of Diogenes: About fifty letters written in his name, composed centuries after his death, probably in the Roman period. They are valuable as evidence of how later Cynics saw him, but they are not his. Ancient sources for the life and sayings: - Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers VI.20–81: The main source, written around the third century AD. A long, loosely ordered collection of anecdotes drawn from many earlier writers, often giving two or three versions of the same story. Every quotation in the teaching rows (T1 to T4) comes from it. - Aristotle, Rhetoric III.10: Quotes a saying of "the Dog," usually taken to be Diogenes (1411a24), the one witness from his own lifetime whose text survives directly; others, such as Theophrastus, are known only through later quotation. - Plutarch, Life of Alexander 14: The classic account of the meeting at Corinth and Alexander’s remark that he would have been Diogenes. - Dio Chrysostom, Discourses 4, 6, 8, 9 and 10: Speeches by a Greek orator of the late first century AD that portray Diogenes in conversation (the fourth, on kingship, stages his talk with Alexander), a literary Diogenes rather than a historical record. - Epictetus, Discourses III.22 ("On the Calling of a Cynic"): The Stoic teacher’s portrait of the ideal Cynic, with Diogenes as the model. - Lucian of Samosata: Satirical dialogues of the second century AD, including The Sale of Lives and the Dialogues of the Dead, where Diogenes appears as a character. - Julian the Apostate, Orations 6 and 7: The emperor’s defense of Diogenes against the Cynics of his own day, and the source of his comparison of those Cynics to Christian monks. - Jerome, Against Jovinianus II.14, and Augustine, The City of God XIV.20: The two fathers whose judgments anchor the reception rows. Standard English editions: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers, translated by R. D. Hicks (Loeb Classical Library, 1925), in the public domain and free online. Robin Hard, Diogenes the Cynic: Sayings and Anecdotes (Oxford World’s Classics, 2012), gathers the ancient testimony in one volume.

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present
Playlist
Justified True Belief