Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
Marilyn McCord Adams of Oak Park 1943 – 2017 AD
(●) The medieval scholar and Episcopal priest who made philosophers face the worst evils one life at a time, and answered them with the goodness of God in Christ. Most arguments about God and evil are conducted at a great height. Philosophers ask whether a world with suffering in it could still be the best world God could make, whether free will is worth the price of its misuse, whether the books of the universe balance. Marilyn McCord Adams came down from that height and stood beside one person. Picture a truck driver who accidentally runs over his own beloved child. Does it help him, she asked, to be told that his grief is a small entry in a cosmic ledger that comes out in the black? She thought it did not help at all, and she thought Christians had no business pretending otherwise. She belongs on a Christian apologetics site because she changed the question. Her name for the worst evils, "horrendous evils," became standard vocabulary in the philosophy of religion, and her answer to them was not a cleverer reason why God permits them but an account of how God, in Christ, can defeat them inside the life of each person who suffers or commits them. She was also one of the founders of the Society of Christian Philosophers, and one of the leading scholars of William of Ockham, the fourteenth-century English friar whose thought she spent two volumes and some fourteen hundred pages explaining. She was a philosopher and a priest at once, a professor who also heard confessions and preached on Sundays. In 2004 she became the first woman, and the first American, to hold the Regius Professorship of Divinity at Oxford, one of the oldest chairs of theology in the English-speaking world.
(●) 1943 AD: Born in Oak Park, Illinois, she grew up in the Midwest and went to the state university to study philosophy. Marilyn McCord was born on October 12, 1943, in Oak Park, Illinois, a suburb on the western edge of Chicago, the daughter of William Clark McCord and Wilmah Brown McCord. She grew up in Illinois, and in 1961 she went down to the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, where she majored in philosophy and graduated in 1964. The record of her childhood is thin, and her obituaries add little to it. What the rest of her life makes plain is a mind that liked hard, old questions and would not let go of them, and a faith that wanted to be argued with rather than protected.
(●) 1964 AD: At Cornell she married Robert Merrihew Adams and wrote her doctorate on God’s foreknowledge and human freedom. In 1964 she began doctoral work in philosophy at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. There she met Robert Merrihew Adams, a former Presbyterian pastor who had come to Cornell for the same degree, and on June 10, 1966, they married. The marriage lasted fifty years, and it was a working partnership as well as a home: they taught at the same universities, led seminars together, and in 1990 edited a standard anthology on the problem of evil side by side. She finished her doctorate in 1967 with a dissertation on an old puzzle about God’s foreknowledge and free will, as Boethius (the Roman statesman who wrote The Consolation of Philosophy in prison around AD 524) and William of Ockham had wrestled with it. The puzzle goes like this. If God knew yesterday that you would order coffee tomorrow, and God cannot be wrong, it seems you cannot do otherwise than order coffee, since you cannot change what God already believed. That same year she published her first article, "Is the Existence of God a ‘Hard’ Fact?" in The Philosophical Review. Philosophers had begun to distinguish "hard" facts about the past, which are over and done with (the coffee was spilled at nine), from "soft" facts, which are partly about the future (it was true at nine that the coffee would be drunk at ten). Following Ockham, she argued that God’s past beliefs about what you will do are soft facts of this kind. The article helped set the terms of a debate that still runs.
(●) 1972 AD: At UCLA she became a leading interpreter of William of Ockham and helped found the Society of Christian Philosophers. After a year teaching at the State University of New York at Cortland and four at the University of Michigan, she moved in 1972 to the University of California, Los Angeles. She stayed twenty-one years, became a full professor in 1978, and chaired the philosophy department from 1985 to 1987. Her scholarly reputation rested first on the Middle Ages. With Norman Kretzmann she had already translated Ockham’s treatise on predestination and God’s foreknowledge (1969), and in 1987 she published William Ockham, two volumes and 1,402 pages that remain the most thorough study of him in English. Ockham is the friar remembered for "Ockham’s razor," the rule of thumb that you should not multiply entities beyond necessity, the way a good mechanic does not assume three faults when one explains the noise. Adams showed how much more there was to him: a logician, a theologian, and a man who thought hard about what God can and cannot do. In 1978 she was one of the small group of philosophers, with her husband, William Alston, Alvin Plantinga, Arthur Holmes, Ralph McInerny and George Mavrodes, who signed the letter calling the first meeting of the Society of Christian Philosophers. It became the home of the revival of Christian philosophy in the English-speaking academy, and she served as its president from 1986 to 1989.
(●) 1987 AD: After two degrees at Princeton Seminary and ministry among the dying, she was ordained a priest in the Episcopal Church. In the middle of a successful career she went back to school. At Princeton Theological Seminary she took a Master of Theology in biblical studies in 1984 and a second, in developmental psychology and faith development, in 1985. In Los Angeles in those years the AIDS epidemic was raging, and her obituaries record that her ministry among AIDS patients in Hollywood was part of what drew her toward ordination. It is not hard to see why. A philosopher of evil who sits beside a young man dying of a disease no one can yet treat learns quickly which answers are worth giving aloud. She was ordained a deacon in the Diocese of Los Angeles on June 20, 1987, and a priest on December 1, 1987. For the rest of her life she held parish posts alongside her professorships: at Trinity Church and St. Mary in Palms in Los Angeles, as a chaplain at UCLA, at St. Augustine’s by-the-Sea in Santa Monica, and later in New Haven, Oxford and Trenton. That autumn she and her husband led a graduate seminar on the problem of evil at UCLA, and out of it came the paper that defined her work, "Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God," read to the Aristotelian Society in Britain and published in 1989 (T1, T2).
(●) 1993 AD: At Yale Divinity School she turned her answer to evil into two books and the Gifford Lectures. In 1993 she moved from a philosophy department to a divinity school, becoming professor of historical theology at Yale, and from 1998 the Horace Tracy Pitkin Professor. In New Haven she served on the staff of Christ Church and St. Thomas’s Church while she taught. The Yale years produced her two major books on evil. Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God (1999) gathered and extended the argument she had been making for a decade. Then came an invitation to give the Gifford Lectures at the University of St Andrews in 1998 and 1999. The Giffords are the most distinguished lecture series in natural theology, which is the attempt to learn what we can about God from reason and the world everyone can see, the way a careful reader can work out a good deal about an author from the book alone. Adams used her turn at that lectern to talk about the person of Christ, and the lectures became Christ and Horrors: The Coherence of Christology (2006) (T4). Christology is the part of theology that asks who Jesus is, and how one person can be both God and man; her subtitle announced that the Christian answer hangs together. She and Robert Adams are the only married couple who have each given Gifford Lectures.
(●) 2004 AD: She became Oxford’s Regius Professor of Divinity, the first woman and the first American to hold the chair. The Regius Professorship of Divinity at Oxford (regius is Latin for "royal") was founded by Henry VIII, and its holder is also a canon, one of the senior clergy who share in the life and running of a cathedral, at Christ Church Cathedral, the college chapel that doubles as the cathedral of the diocese. For four and a half centuries the chair had been held by men, and never by an American. In 2004 it went to a philosopher from Illinois. She held it until 2009, preaching in the cathedral, sitting in the Church of England’s General Synod, its national governing assembly, something like a parliament for the church, as a representative of the university, and publishing a steady stream of sermons in The Expository Times. In 2008 Oxford awarded her its Doctor of Divinity, the first woman to receive it. She also stepped into the fiercest quarrel in the Anglican world of those years, arguing in sermons, newspaper columns and essays for the blessing of same-sex unions and the ordination of gay and lesbian bishops (†3).
(●) 2009 AD: She returned to America to teach at North Carolina and Rutgers, and died of cancer in Princeton in 2017. From 2009 she was a distinguished research professor of philosophy at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and from 2013 at Rutgers University in New Jersey. In 2015 she was elected a fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. Her last parish post was as an associate priest at Trinity Cathedral in Trenton. She died of cancer at her home in Princeton, New Jersey, on March 22, 2017, at seventy-three. Colleagues remembered the brilliance first, and then the rest: a great cook, a generous host, a funny and deeply humane friend. A book on Anselm of Canterbury, on which she had worked for years, was left unfinished. Memorial services followed that spring at Trinity Cathedral in Trenton, where she had served, and at All Saints Church in Beverly Hills.
What She Taught
(T1) Some evils are horrendous: they threaten to make a life not worth living. Not every evil is the same size. A stubbed toe, a lost job, a broken engagement: these hurt, sometimes badly, but most people can look back on a life that included them and still call it good. Adams asked about the other kind. She gave a list, and it is hard to read: torture meant to destroy a personality, parents who abuse their children, the death camps, the choice forced on a parent of which child terrorists will kill, the driver who runs over the child he loves best. She called these "horrendous evils," and she defined them by what they do to the person caught up in them, whether as the one who suffers or the one who does the deed. A horrendous evil gives that person good reason, on the face of it, to doubt whether their life could still be a great good to them as a whole. The Latin phrase she used for "on the face of it" is prima facie: the doubt is reasonable at first look, even if it might be answered later. To explain what "answered" would mean, she borrowed a distinction from the American philosopher Roderick Chisholm between balancing off and defeat. A cancelled debt balances off a loan: the plus and the minus sit side by side and cancel out. Defeat is different. A small patch of muddy brown in a painting is ugly on its own, but in the finished picture, as the shadow that makes the light glow, it becomes part of what makes the whole beautiful. The bad part is not cancelled; it is taken up into a whole that gives it new meaning. Horrendous evils, she said, seem at first to swallow up all the good in a life, and they cry out not merely to be outweighed but to be defeated in that second sense.
(Q) "For present purposes, I define ‘horrendous evils’ as ‘evils the participation in (the doing or suffering of) which gives one reason prima facie to doubt whether one’s life could (given their inclusion in it) be a great good to one on the whole’." Source: Marilyn McCord Adams, "Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 63 (1989), p. 299. The definition that made her name. The 1999 book of the same title restates it early in the book with slightly different wording ("constitutes prima facie reason to doubt"), and the sentence that follows in the article explains it: the doubt arises "because it is so difficult humanly to conceive how such evils could be overcome."
(T2) God’s goodness must reach each person, not merely the world as a whole. Imagine a city council that builds a magnificent new park by bulldozing one family’s house without asking. The city as a whole may be better off, and the council can show the figures. But no one would say the council has been good to that family. Adams thought the standard answers to the problem of evil had made exactly this mistake about God. She distinguished two ways God might be good. God might be good as a maker of the world, producing a universe whose total of good outweighs its evil. Or God might be good to each person in it, loving each one. The famous defenses of theism (the belief in one personal God who made the world) all work at the first level. The German philosopher Leibniz argued that ours is the "best of all possible worlds." Others argued that a world with free creatures is worth the evil they do. Alvin Plantinga’s free will defense showed that it is at least possible God could not make genuinely free creatures who never do wrong, so that God and the evil in the world do not contradict each other. Each of these explains, or tries to explain, why the world as a whole might be worth having. None of them says anything to the mother whose life has been wrecked by what was done to her child, and Adams argued that offered to her alone they make things worse, painting a God who uses people as means. So she held Christians to a higher standard than most of their critics did: God must be good to every created person, making each life, horrors and all, a great good to that person on the whole. She held, too, that a God this good would see to it that no one is finally lost, a point where most Christians have parted from her (†3).
(Q) "For God cannot be said to be good or loving to any created persons the positive meaning of whose lives He allows to be engulfed in and/or defeated by evils." Source: Marilyn McCord Adams, "Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 63 (1989), p. 302. The sentence goes on to name such people: "individuals within whose lives horrendous evils remain undefeated." She is explaining why showing that God makes a good world overall does not yet show that God is good to the people in it.
(T3) We may never learn why God permits horrors, but we can see how God defeats them. Think of a two-year-old who needs heart surgery. The child cannot understand why the people who love her are letting strangers hurt her, and no explanation, however patient, would get through; she is simply too young. What reaches her is not the reason but the mother: holding her, staying with her through the pain, being there when she wakes. Adams argued that this is our situation before God and the worst evils. She agreed with Plantinga that we cannot even conceive of a plausible reason God might have for permitting them, and she did not think we needed one. The question "why?" asks for an explanation, and she thought it beyond our grasp. The question "how?" asks how God could still be good to a person who has suffered or done such things, and that, she thought, Christianity can answer. She pointed to Job, who never receives God’s reasons but at the end sees God, and says, "I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you" (Job 42:5). Her answer to "how" was that the good of knowing God face to face is so much greater than any created good or evil that it can outweigh even horrors, and more than that, defeat them, by weaving them into a person’s relationship with God so that the person would not, in the end, wish them away. Paul had said something like it: "the sufferings of this present time are not worth comparing with the glory that is to be revealed to us" (Romans 8:18).
(Q) "The two-year old heart patient is convinced of its mother’s love, not by her cognitively inaccessible reasons, but by her intimate care and presence through its painful experience." Source: Marilyn McCord Adams, "Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 63 (1989), pp. 305–306. The sentence that follows turns to Job: God does not give Job his reasons, but Job "sees God’s goodness face to face."
(T4) Because God in Christ suffered horrors, a person’s worst suffering can become a place of meeting with God. Two friends who have both buried a child can sit together in a way no one else can sit with them. Neither has to explain anything. Adams believed the Incarnation, God becoming a human being in Jesus, puts God in that chair. The crucifixion was itself a horror by her own definition: a judicial murder that seemed to wreck Jesus’ calling as the Messiah, since the law of Moses counted anyone hanged on a tree as accursed, and a crucified Messiah looked, to most who watched, like a contradiction in terms. Because God in Christ went through that, a human being’s own horrors can become a way of being joined to Christ, sharing what he shared. She drew on the medieval mystic Julian of Norwich for a second picture. Julian saw that when the redeemed reach heaven, before they can thank God, God thanks them for their suffering, and the joy of that gratitude outweighs every pain. Adams loved the scene because it shows suffering defeated rather than merely outweighed: the pain becomes the occasion of honor. In the Gifford Lectures and Christ and Horrors (2006) she argued that Christ is the one who defeats horrors on every front: by sharing them in his death, by healing human beings so that they can no longer be destroyed by them, and by raising them to a life where horrors are no longer possible. The Letter to the Hebrews had put the first part simply: "we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin" (Hebrews 4:15).
(Q) "First, because God in Christ participated in horrendous evil through His passion and death, human experience of horrors can be a means of identifying with Christ." Source: Marilyn McCord Adams, "Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 63 (1989), p. 307. The first of three ways she sketches by which God might weave horrors into a person’s relationship with him; the second is Julian of Norwich’s picture of divine gratitude, and the third the thought that suffering itself may be a dim vision of God.
(Q) "The worst evils demand to be defeated by the best goods. Horrendous evils can be overcome only by the goodness of God." Source: Marilyn McCord Adams, "Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 63 (1989), p. 309. The opening of her conclusion. A few lines later she sums up the "basic Christian intuition" behind the whole paper: "that the powers of darkness are stronger than humans, but they are no match for God!"
What Christian Thinkers Made of Her
(†) She moved the problem of evil from the world’s balance sheet to the single human life, and her term became standard. Before Adams, most of the debate among philosophers turned on a narrow question: is it even logically consistent to believe in God and in evil at the same time? J. L. Mackie, the Australian atheist, had argued in 1955 that it was not, and Alvin Plantinga’s free will defense had answered him with great success. Adams accepted that answer and then raised the stakes. She had made the case in "Problems of Evil: More Advice to Christian Philosophers" (1988), and her paper of 1989 sums it up. It was not enough, she said, to show that God could coexist with some evil or other; a full account had to face evils "in the amounts and of the kinds found in the actual world." Think of an engineer who proves a bridge can carry one small car. That is worth knowing, but nobody driving across at rush hour, behind a line of loaded trucks, will feel the question has been answered. Her paper of 1989 was reprinted in anthologies for decades, and "horrendous evils" became a term every student of the subject learns. It also gave Christian philosophers permission to do something they had been shy of: to answer the problem with specifically Christian resources, the Incarnation, the cross, the beatific vision (the sight of God face to face promised to the redeemed), rather than only with what believer and unbeliever share. Since the critic’s charge is that Christian beliefs contradict each other, she argued, Christians are entitled to show how the whole of their beliefs hangs together. Plantinga himself later turned to the Incarnation and atonement in his own work on evil, and she answered him in print (2008).
(†) She brought the medieval masters back into Christian philosophy as working partners, not museum pieces. Anselm, Duns Scotus, Ockham and Julian of Norwich run all through her work on evil and on Christ. She edited the essays of the Franciscan scholar Allan Wolter on Scotus (1990), wrote on Anselm’s method of "faith seeking understanding," and in Some Later Medieval Theories of the Eucharist (2010) traced how Aquinas, Giles of Rome, Scotus and Ockham tried to say what happens at the Lord’s Supper. Her conviction, stated in an essay title, was that the history of philosophy is a tutor to Christian philosophy: the medieval theologians had already thought harder about the Incarnation and the sacraments than most moderns, and the way forward often ran through them. She was equally a pastor. Her sermons, collected in Wrestling for Blessing (2005), and her book of prayers, Opening to God: Childlike Prayers for Adults (2008), carry the same concern into the pew: a God who is not distant from the worst a person has known.
(†) Where Christians part ways with her: she taught that every person will be saved, and she campaigned against the church’s historic teaching on sexuality. Two of her own positions put her outside what the great majority of Christians, Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant alike, have taught. - Universal salvation. From her early papers, "Universal Salvation: A Reply to Mr. Bettis" and "Hell and the God of Justice," to "The Problem of Hell: A Problem of Evil for Christians" (1993), she argued that a God who is good to each person must bring every person, in the end, to a life that is a great good to them. Her 1989 paper says so outright: each created person "will have a life that is a great good to him/her on the whole." Everlasting punishment, on her view, would itself be a horror God permits and never defeats. The historic church has not been able to follow her, because the warnings come from Jesus himself: "And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life" (Matthew 25:46). Her concern that God love each person is one every Christian shares; her conclusion that God will not let anyone finally refuse that love is the point of parting. - Sexuality. As a priest and especially as Oxford’s Regius Professor she argued in essays such as "Hurricane Spirit, Toppling Taboos" (1996) and "Sexuality without Taboos" (2005) for blessing same-sex unions and consecrating gay and lesbian bishops, and she opposed the Windsor Report (2004) and the proposed Anglican Covenant that sought to restrain those changes. The Catholic and Orthodox churches and most Protestant churches have continued to teach that sexual union belongs within the marriage of a man and a woman (Genesis 2:24; Matthew 19:4–6), and on this she set herself against that common teaching. Neither point cancels what she gave the church on evil. A Christian who believes some may finally refuse God can still learn from her that God’s love is aimed at each person by name, and that the cross is God’s answer to horrors, not a reason he gives for them.