Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

John Stott of London 1921 – 2011 AD

(●) The London pastor who taught a worldwide church to think hard, preach the Bible plainly, and stand at the foot of the cross. + For half a century, if a Christian in Lagos, Lima, or Leeds wanted one book to hand a curious friend, the odds were good it was by John Stott. He was the rector of a single London parish (the rector is the clergyman in charge of a parish church), a bachelor who lived in a flat over a garage behind the rectory. And yet by the end of his life he had shaped evangelical Christianity on every continent more than almost anyone except Billy Graham. Evangelicals are the broad family of Protestants who stress the authority of the Bible, the need for each person to be converted, and the saving death of Christ on the cross; Stott was, for many of them, the teacher they trusted most. The difference between him and Graham is the clue to the man. Graham called crowds to decide for Christ, and Stott taught those who had decided how to think, read, and preach in the years that followed. He belongs on an apologetics site because his whole ministry was an argument that faith and the mind belong together. His first famous book, Basic Christianity, asks the reader to examine the evidence for Christ the way a juror examines a case, and his most important one, The Cross of Christ, explains why the death of Jesus is the center of the faith rather than an embarrassment to be explained away. And there is one thing about him that tends to stick. He was a lifelong, expert birdwatcher, who carried binoculars on preaching tours across the world and wrote a whole book on what birds can teach Christians.

(●) 1921 AD: Born in London to an agnostic physician father and a Lutheran-raised mother. + John Robert Walmsley Stott was born in London on 27 April 1921. His father, Arnold Stott, was a leading Harley Street physician (Harley Street is the London address where the most eminent private doctors kept their consulting rooms), a man of science who had no use for religion. His mother, Lily, had been raised a Lutheran and took the children to church at All Souls, Langham Place, a few minutes’ walk from the family home. Nobody could have guessed that the boy in the pew would one day be its rector for a quarter of a century. His father gave him something else that lasted a lifetime: a love of the natural world. Arnold Stott taught his son to watch birds closely and name them accurately, and John never stopped. He went to boarding school at Oakley Hall and then, in 1935, to Rugby School, one of the great English public schools (in Britain, "public school" confusingly means an old, expensive private boarding school).

(●) 1938 AD: At sixteen, at Rugby School, he opened the door to Christ. + On a Sunday afternoon in February 1938 (13 February, by the usual account), a clergyman named Eric Nash, known to generations of schoolboys as "Bash," spoke to a small Christian group at Rugby. His text was Pilate’s question at the trial of Jesus: what then shall I do with Jesus? Stott later recalled how strange the idea was to him: "That I needed to do anything with Jesus was an entirely novel idea to me." Afterward Nash showed him a verse in which Christ speaks to a lukewarm church: "Behold, I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and eat with him, and he with me" (Revelation 3:20). Stott described his religion until then as believing in Jesus "on the other side of the door," saying prayers through the keyhole and pushing pennies under it. That night, at his bedside, he asked Christ to come in. There was no flash of lightning. He said he simply crept into bed and went to sleep, and that for weeks afterward he was unsure what had happened to him. What followed was slower and more durable: Nash wrote to him every week for years, teaching him to pray, read the Bible, and lead others.

(●) 1940 AD: A pacifist at Cambridge in wartime, he defied his father to study for ordination. + Stott went up to Trinity College, Cambridge, in 1940, while Britain was fighting for its life. He was then a convinced pacifist, someone who believes it is always wrong for a Christian to fight in a war, and a member of the Anglican Pacifist Fellowship (Anglican means belonging to the Church of England and the churches descended from it). As a candidate for the ministry he was exempt from military service. His father, by then a senior army medical officer, was bitterly disappointed, both by the refusal to fight and by the choice of the church over the diplomatic career he had planned for his gifted, multilingual son. For a time the two barely spoke. Stott later moved away from pacifism to the traditional Christian position on just war, the view that war can be morally permissible under strict conditions, but he never pretended the estrangement had cost him nothing. He took a double first, top honours in both parts of his degree, in French and then in theology, and trained at Ridley Hall, Cambridge, for ordination, the service in which a bishop formally makes someone a minister of the church. In 1945 he was ordained and went back to the church of his childhood, All Souls, Langham Place, as a curate, the junior clergyman in a parish.

(●) 1950 AD: Rector of All Souls at twenty-nine, he turned a bombed-out parish into a teaching church. + When the rector died in 1950, the congregation and churchwardens asked the patron of the living to appoint his twenty-nine-year-old curate in his place, and the patron took the unusual step of agreeing. (In the Church of England a parish post is called a "living," and its patron is whoever holds the right to choose who fills it; for All Souls that was the Crown.) It was a striking trust to place in a man not yet thirty. All Souls had been damaged by a German bomb during the war, and its neighborhood near Oxford Circus was a mix of shops, offices, broadcasters, and students. Stott made the pulpit the engine of the church: long, careful sermons that took one passage of Scripture at a time and explained what it meant and why it mattered on Monday morning. This is what is called expository preaching, preaching that sets out the meaning of a text the way a guide lays out a map before a walk, rather than using the text as a launching pad for the preacher’s own topic. The pulpit was only the start. He trained his congregation to explain their faith to their friends, ran monthly guest services for the curious, and spent many weeks a year leading missions in universities in Britain and abroad, a week of talks and conversations aimed at students who had never taken Christianity seriously. The talks he gave on those missions became Basic Christianity in 1958, a short book that has since sold in the millions and been translated into dozens of languages. In 1959 he was appointed a chaplain to the Queen, an honorary post in the royal household.

(●) 1966 AD: He publicly opposed Martyn Lloyd-Jones’s call to leave the mixed denominations, and kept evangelicals inside the Church of England. + On 18 October 1966, a National Assembly of Evangelicals met in London, and the main speaker was the Welsh preacher Martyn Lloyd-Jones, minister of Westminster Chapel and the other towering figure of British evangelicalism. He urged evangelicals to come out of the "mixed" denominations, churches like the Church of England that tolerated teachers who denied the faith, and to stand together in a new fellowship. Stott was chairing the meeting. A chairman is supposed to thank the speaker and move things along. Instead, when Lloyd-Jones sat down, Stott rose and, from the chair, publicly disagreed. History and Scripture, he said, were against the speaker, because the faithful remnant in the Bible (the loyal few God keeps for himself when most of his people have gone astray) was found within the church, not outside it. It was a breach of the chairman’s role, and Stott later apologized to Lloyd-Jones for using the chair that way. The disagreement itself he never retracted. The next spring, in 1967, he chaired the first National Evangelical Anglican Congress at Keele University, where evangelicals committed themselves to stay in the Church of England and take a full part in its life rather than hold aloof from it. The two men’s camps went separate ways for a generation, though Stott went on admiring and quoting Lloyd-Jones.

(●) 1974 AD: He drafted the Lausanne Covenant and gave the rest of his life to the church of the majority world. + In July 1974 some 2,700 evangelical leaders from more than 150 countries gathered at Lausanne, Switzerland, for the International Congress on World Evangelization called by Billy Graham. Stott chaired the committee that drafted its statement of faith and purpose, the Lausanne Covenant, and was its chief architect. A covenant, in the Bible’s sense, is a solemn binding promise, and this one bound evangelicals to a shared account of Scripture, Christ, and the church’s mission (T4). Lausanne was not where his concern for the wider world began. Already in 1969 he had founded the Langham Trust, today the Langham Partnership, funded largely by his own book royalties, to give scholarships to promising pastors and scholars from Africa, Asia, and Latin America and to put good books into their hands. The majority world, the countries where most of the world’s Christians now live, became his parish. To make room for it, he stepped down as rector of All Souls in 1975 and gave himself to writing and travel. In 1982 he founded the London Institute for Contemporary Christianity, to help ordinary believers think Christianly about the offices, classrooms, and shops where they spent their working week. Most of his books he wrote far from London, at the Hookses, a remote cottage on the Pembrokeshire coast of Wales. The Cross of Christ appeared in 1986. The best-known public honours came late in life. In 2005 Time magazine named him among the hundred most influential people in the world, and in 2006 he was made a Commander of the Order of the British Empire, one of Britain’s royal honours.

(●) 2011 AD: He died at ninety, having laid down his pen with a last book on discipleship and dependence. + Stott never married. He said he had twice come near it, and that he came to believe God was calling him to stay single for the sake of the work, a gift he did not commend to everyone. His secretary of more than fifty years, Frances Whitehead, and a succession of young study assistants were the household; to thousands of Christians around the world he was simply "Uncle John." In 2007, at eighty-six, he gave up public ministry and moved to the College of St Barnabas, a retirement home for clergy in Lingfield, Surrey. His last book, The Radical Disciple (2010), closes with chapters on dependence and on death, written by a man in his late eighties who now needed others’ help every day. He would not let old Christians say they would rather die than be a burden: we are all, he wrote, "designed to be a burden to others," and the church is a family in which believers carry one another. He died at St Barnabas on 27 July 2011, aged ninety. He was cremated, and his ashes were buried at Dale in Pembrokeshire, near the cottage where he had written.

What He Taught

(T1) Christian faith is reasonable trust, never a leap in the dark. + Think about how you came to trust a good doctor. You did not stop thinking; you looked at the evidence of training, track record, and honesty, and then you put yourself in that doctor’s hands. Stott taught that Christian faith works the same way. Faith is trust, but it is reasonable trust, resting on what God has shown about himself, above all in the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus. That is why Basic Christianity opens by asking the reader to examine the claims and character of Christ and the evidence for his resurrection before being asked to commit to anything. In Your Mind Matters (1972) he aimed at two opposite errors. One was cold intellectualism, knowledge that never reaches the heart or the hands. The other, which he thought the greater danger among evangelicals of his day, was anti-intellectualism, the suspicion of careful thinking as unspiritual. Against it he set the plain pattern of Scripture: God made human beings rational, spoke to them in words, and calls them to be transformed "by the renewal of your mind" (Romans 12:2). Paul did not simply announce the gospel in the synagogues; he "reasoned with them from the Scriptures" (Acts 17:2).

(Q) "If we do not use the mind which God has given us, we condemn ourselves to spiritual superficiality." + Source: John Stott, Your Mind Matters: The Place of the Mind in the Christian Life (Inter-Varsity Press, 1972; IVP Classics edition, 2006). It is the thesis of the whole book in a sentence. It follows directly on "Knowledge is indispensable to Christian life and service," and it goes on to say that a mind left unused cuts us off "from many of the riches of God’s grace." Failing to think, in other words, is not humility but a loss.

(T2) At the cross God himself stood in our place and bore the penalty for our sins. + Imagine a judge who sentences a guilty friend to the full fine the law requires, then steps down from the bench, takes off his robe, and pays it himself. Justice is done, because the fine is paid; mercy is done, because the guilty man goes free. Stott thought every human illustration of the cross falls short, and this one does too, but it captures the shape of what he called the heart of the gospel. The technical name for this teaching is penal substitution. "Penal" means having to do with a penalty, and "substitution" means one taking the place of another: Christ took the place of sinners and bore the penalty their sin deserved. Scripture says it in many ways: "He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree" (1 Peter 2:24); God "made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God" (2 Corinthians 5:21). Stott’s distinctive contribution in The Cross of Christ was to insist on who the substitute is. Critics had caricatured the doctrine as an angry Father punishing an innocent third party. Stott answered that the one who bears the penalty is God himself, in the person of his Son: the Judge who is wronged is the one who pays. He called this the "self-substitution of God." He did not make substitution the only thing the cross achieves; he also expounded the cross as victory over evil and as the supreme revelation of God’s love. But he held that these rest on substitution, and that without it the others lose their footing.

(Q) "For the essence of sin is man substituting himself for God, while the essence of salvation is God substituting himself for man." + Source: John Stott, The Cross of Christ (Inter-Varsity Press, 1986), chapter 6, "The Self-Substitution of God." The sentence turns on a single word used twice. Sin is putting ourselves where only God belongs; salvation is God putting himself where only we belong.

(T3) The God of the cross is no stranger to pain, so the cross is his answer to human suffering. + Stott recalled standing in Buddhist temples in Asia, before statues of the Buddha seated with legs crossed and eyes closed, the face calm and smiling, untouched by the world’s troubles. Every time, he said, he had to turn away. In his mind he turned instead to a very different figure: a man nailed to a cross, beaten, thirsty, alone, abandoned in the dark. The problem of suffering, the question of how a good and powerful God can allow so much pain, is the oldest objection to the faith. Stott did not claim the cross explains every particular sorrow. He claimed something different: that it shows God has not stood at a safe distance from it. The one Christians worship has entered the world’s pain from the inside, borne its worst, and through it secured the end of it. A person in agony may not get an explanation, but can know that God is not indifferent, because God himself has suffered.

(Q) "I could never myself believe in God, if it were not for the cross." + Source: John Stott, The Cross of Christ (Inter-Varsity Press, 1986), chapter 13, "Suffering and Glory." The line opens the passage about the Buddha and the crucified Christ (T3), and two sentences later Stott asks the question behind it: "In the real world of pain, how could one worship a God who was immune to it?"

(T4) The church is sent to proclaim the gospel and to serve its neighbors, and the two belong together. + Picture a church that runs a food bank but never tells anyone why, and another that preaches faithfully but walks past the hungry family on its steps. Stott thought both had cut the mission of Jesus in half. Jesus sent his disciples to "make disciples of all nations" (Matthew 28:19), which Christians call the Great Commission; and he summed up the law as love of God and love of neighbor, the Great Commandment. Stott argued that the first never cancels the second: those sent to proclaim Christ are still bound to love the neighbor in body as well as soul. He had once held a narrower view, that the church’s mission is evangelism alone, and he said openly that he had changed his mind. The Lausanne Covenant he drafted states the result. It does not confuse the two (social action is not evangelism, it says, and political liberation is not salvation), and it keeps an order: "In the church’s mission of sacrificial service evangelism is primary." But it confesses that evangelicals had sometimes treated evangelism and social concern as mutually exclusive, and it puts them side by side as Christian duty.

(Q) "We affirm that evangelism and socio-political involvement are both part of our Christian duty." + Source: The Lausanne Covenant (1974), section 5, "Christian Social Responsibility," drafted by a committee Stott chaired; text as published by the Lausanne Movement. The sentence follows the covenant’s plain distinctions between social action and evangelism, and it grounds both in the doctrine of God and of man, and in love for our neighbor and obedience to Jesus Christ.

What the Church Made of Him

(†) He gave postwar evangelicals an intellectual seriousness they had been accused of lacking. + In the 1950s British evangelicals were a small and somewhat embattled party, often dismissed by the universities and the church establishment as earnest but unthinking. A generation later they were the most vigorous wing of the Church of England and a growing presence in its theological colleges. Many hands did that work, among them J. I. Packer, Stott’s friend and fellow Anglican, but Stott was its public face: a Cambridge double first who preached to students, wrote in clear and unhurried English, and treated objections as questions deserving answers. His books became the shared shelf of the movement. Basic Christianity was for decades the book handed to the inquirer, and The Cross of Christ became a standard text on the atonement (the reconciling of sinners to God through the death of Christ) in seminaries well beyond his own tradition. As founding editor of the New Testament volumes of The Bible Speaks Today series, he set a pattern of commentary written for preachers and ordinary readers rather than only for specialists.

(†) Through Lausanne and Langham he helped the church of the global South train its own teachers. + In 1900 most Christians lived in Europe and North America; by the end of Stott’s life most lived in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Stott saw the shift earlier than most and acted on it. The Lausanne Covenant gave evangelicals across those continents a common statement they had helped shape, and the movement it began still gathers them. The Langham scholarships brought hundreds of majority-world pastors and scholars to doctoral study so they could return to teach in their own seminaries, and Langham’s literature and preaching programs put books and training into the hands of pastors who had little of either. The success can be measured in names: theologians from Nigeria, India, Peru, and the Philippines who now write the commentaries and train the preachers in their own countries, many of them Langham scholars. Stott was emphatic that the aim was not to export British evangelicalism but to help the church in each place stand on its own feet under Scripture.

(†) He tentatively held that the lost will finally be destroyed rather than punished forever, against the church’s historic teaching. + In Essentials (1988), a published dialogue with the liberal Anglican writer David L. Edwards (liberal here in the theological sense: willing to revise traditional doctrine in the light of modern thought), Stott was pressed on hell and gave an answer that startled many of his readers. He found the traditional doctrine of eternal conscious punishment emotionally unbearable: "Well, emotionally, I find the concept intolerable and do not understand how people can live with it without either cauterising their feelings or cracking under the strain." He added at once that emotions are an unreliable guide to truth and that the question had to be settled by Scripture. On the biblical evidence he leaned toward annihilationism, the view that the impenitent (those who die refusing to repent) are finally destroyed and cease to exist rather than suffering without end, reading the Bible’s language of destruction (Matthew 10:28; 2 Thessalonians 1:9) at its plain face. He held the view tentatively, said so, and asked only that it be accepted as a legitimate evangelical option. Most Christians across the centuries, Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant, have read the same texts the other way, and the strongest of them is the Lord’s own sentence, which sets the two destinies side by side with the same adjective: "And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life" (Matthew 25:46). If the life is everlasting, the historic reading asks, how can the punishment be less? Many of Stott’s friends, Packer among them, thought he had let a true compassion pull him away from the text. On this one point the church’s historic teaching parts company with him, and he would have wanted the question settled exactly where he said it must be, by Scripture rather than by feeling.

Stott wrote some fifty books over almost sixty years, most of them first published by Inter-Varsity Press in Britain and InterVarsity Press in the United States, and most still in print; some appeared in America under different titles, given below. He also edited and contributed to many collections and wrote hundreds of articles and booklets, which are not listed here. Dates are of first publication. Evangelism and the basics of faith: - Men with a Message (1954): An introduction to the New Testament writers and their distinctive messages, later revised as Basic Introduction to the New Testament. - Fundamentalism and Evangelism (1956): A short reply to critics in the debate over Billy Graham’s Cambridge mission, distinguishing evangelical faith from the caricature of "fundamentalism." - Basic Christianity (1958): The case for Christ for the honest inquirer: who Jesus is, what he did on the cross, and what it means to respond. His most widely read book (T1). - Your Confirmation (1958): A handbook for those preparing to be confirmed in the Church of England. - Our Guilty Silence (1967): A call to the Church of England to recover its nerve in evangelism. - The Authentic Jesus (1985): A brief defense of the incarnation and resurrection against the doubts of a bishop of the day. - Christian Basics (1991): A handbook for new believers on beginning the Christian life, what Christians believe, and how they live. - Why I Am a Christian (2003): A late, personal statement of the reasons for faith, including the account of his own conversion. The cross, Christ, and Christian doctrine: - Christ the Controversialist (1970): A study of the debates Jesus had with his opponents, arguing that some doctrinal controversy is a Christian duty; revised as Christ in Conflict. - Understanding the Bible (1972): A guide to the Bible’s story, setting, and authority for the ordinary reader. - The Bible: Book for Today (1982; in America God’s Book for God’s People): Short studies on what the Bible is and why it still speaks with authority to Christians now. - The Baptism and Fullness of the Holy Spirit (1964; revised as Baptism and Fullness, 1975): A careful study of the Spirit’s work, distinguishing the one baptism of the Spirit at conversion from the repeated fullness of the Spirit in the Christian life. - Confess Your Sins (1964): On confession to God, to the person wronged, and in the church, and against compulsory private confession to a priest. - The Cross of Christ (1986): His major work: the centrality of the cross, the self-substitution of God, and the cross as revelation, victory, and the pattern of Christian life (T2, T3). - The Contemporary Christian (1992): On listening both to the Word and to the world, a theme that ran through his ministry. - Evangelical Truth (1999): A short statement of what evangelicals believe about revelation, the cross, and the Spirit. - The Incomparable Christ (2001): Lectures on how Christ has been presented in the New Testament, in the church, and in the world. The mind, the church, and Christian living: - One People (1969): On clergy and laity in the church, arguing that every member of the congregation is called to ministry and not only the ordained. - Your Mind Matters (1972): The case against anti-intellectualism in Christian life (T1). - Balanced Christianity (1975): A plea against swinging to extremes on intellect and emotion, form and freedom, evangelism and social action. - Focus on Christ (1979): "An enquiry into the theology of prepositions," a study of what the New Testament means by life in, through, and with Christ; published in America as Understanding Christ and later as Life in Christ. - Issues Facing Christians Today (1984; revised editions to 2006): A substantial treatment of Christian ethics on war, poverty, work, the environment, marriage, and sexuality, and among his most influential books. - Essentials: A Liberal-Evangelical Dialogue (1988, with David L. Edwards; in America Evangelical Essentials, 1989): Edwards’s chapters on what he doubted in evangelical belief, each answered by Stott, the source of his tentative annihilationism (Reception). - The Birds Our Teachers (1999): Biblical lessons drawn from the birdwatching of a lifetime, with his own photographs. - Calling Christian Leaders (2002; in America Basic Christian Leadership): Studies on leadership from 1 Corinthians 1–4. - People My Teachers (2002): Reflections on people who shaped him. - Through the Bible, Through the Year (2006): Daily readings across the whole Bible. - The Living Church (2007): His convictions about the local church, distilled from a lifetime at All Souls. - The Radical Disciple (2010): His farewell book, on eight neglected aspects of discipleship, closing with dependence and death. Preaching and mission: - The Preacher’s Portrait (1961): Five New Testament images of the preacher: steward, herald, witness, father, servant. - Christian Mission in the Modern World (1975): His argument that mission includes both evangelism and social responsibility, the two belonging together as partners, with his frank admission that he had once defined mission more narrowly (T4). - The Lausanne Covenant: An Exposition and Commentary (1975): His commentary on the covenant he drafted, clause by clause (T4). - I Believe in Preaching (1982; in America Between Two Worlds): His major book on preaching as bridge-building between the world of the Bible and the world of the hearer. Bible commentaries (most in The Bible Speaks Today series, several first published under other titles): - What Christ Thinks of the Church (1958): Expositions of Revelation 1–3, the risen Christ’s letters to the seven churches of Asia, read as a searching word to congregations now. - The Epistles of John (1964; revised as The Letters of John, 1988): A commentary in the Tyndale New Testament Commentaries. - The Canticles and Selected Psalms (1966): Brief expositions of the songs and psalms sung in the Prayer Book services of the Church of England. - Men Made New (1966): Studies in Romans 5–8, on union with Christ and life in the Spirit. - The Message of Galatians (1968; first as Only One Way): The defense of justification by grace through faith alone. - The Message of 2 Timothy (1973; first as Guard the Gospel): Paul’s last charge to his successor. - The Message of the Sermon on the Mount (1978; first as Christian Counter-Culture): The Christian life as a counterculture. - The Message of Ephesians (1979; first as God’s New Society): The church as the new humanity God is making. - Favourite Psalms (1988): Short devotional expositions of a selection of the best-loved psalms. - The Message of Acts (1990): The Spirit, the church, and the world. - The Message of 1 and 2 Thessalonians (1991): The gospel and the end of time. - The Message of Romans (1994): God’s good news for the world. - The Message of 1 Timothy and Titus (1996): Guarding the truth in the life of the church. Edited works and collaborations: he was founding New Testament editor of The Bible Speaks Today, edited the documents of the Lausanne movement, and wrote The Anglican Evangelical Doctrine of Infant Baptism (2008) with J. Alec Motyer. He has no disputed or spurious works. Some later volumes were compiled by others from his writings and preaching, among them the anthology Authentic Christianity (1995), edited by Timothy Dudley-Smith, and several chapters of Issues Facing Christians Today were also issued as separate short books. Standard biography: Timothy Dudley-Smith, John Stott: The Making of a Leader (1999) and John Stott: A Global Ministry (2001), the authorized two-volume life; Dudley-Smith also compiled John Stott: A Comprehensive Bibliography (1995). There is no collected edition; Inter-Varsity Press and InterVarsity Press keep most of the books in print.
Playlist
Justified True Belief