Justified True Belief
Natural Theology
Christian Evidences
Resurrection of Jesus
Divinity of Christ
Prophecy Fulfillment
New Testament Criticism
Old Testament Criticism
Common Objections
Problem of Evil
Science
Bad Claims
Miscellaneous
World Religions
Mormonism
Islam
Jehovah's Witness
Philosophy
Logic
Logic: Common Fallacies
Epistemology
Metaphysics: Free Will
Philosophical Theology
Prolegomena
Bibliology
Theology Proper
The Trinity
Creation
Anthropology
Christology
Soteriology
Ecclesiology
Eschatology
Public Theology
Theology of the Family
Biographies
Ancient History
Classical Greece
The Hellenistic & Roman World
Jesus & the Apostles
The Early Church
The Church Fathers
The Early Middle Ages
The High Middle Ages
Late Middle Ages & Renaissance
Reformation & Counter-Reformation
The Age of Reason
Enlightenment & Awakening
The Nineteenth Century
The Early Twentieth Century
Contemporary Voices
John Polkinghorne of Weston-super-Mare 1930 – 2021 AD
(●) John Polkinghorne was the Cambridge physicist who gave up his chair to become a parish priest, and spent forty years showing that science and faith are two eyes looking at one world. Picture a man at the top of his field, a professor of mathematical physics at Cambridge and a Fellow of the Royal Society (a member, that is, of the national academy of Britain’s leading scientists), who at the age of forty-eight hands in his resignation, goes back to being a student, and a few years later is visiting the sick in a working-class parish in Bristol. That is the hinge of John Polkinghorne’s life, and it explains why he matters to anyone who wonders whether a scientist can honestly believe. He was not a scientist who dabbled in religion, or a clergyman who dabbled in science. He had spent twenty-five years in theoretical particle physics, the study of the smallest building blocks of matter, in the years when physicists worked out that protons and neutrons are made of quarks, and his own calculations helped fill in that picture. Then he spent the rest of his long life writing more than twenty-five books arguing that the questions physics raises but cannot answer (why the universe can be understood at all, why its laws are so finely balanced for life) point toward the God of the Christian creed. His own image for this was binocular vision. One eye is science, the other is faith, and a person who closes either one loses depth. He did not want religion to borrow science’s prestige, or science to swallow religion; he wanted both eyes open at once.
(●) 1930 AD: Born in Weston-super-Mare, the son of a Post Office man, into a family already acquainted with grief. John Charlton Polkinghorne was born on 16 October 1930 in Weston-super-Mare, on the Somerset coast. His father, George, worked for the Post Office and rose steadily through it, which meant the family moved as he was promoted: to Street, in Somerset, when John was five, and later to Wells and then Ely as head postmaster. The surname is Cornish, from his father’s side. The house he was born into had already known loss. A sister, Ann, had died as a small child before he was born. His brother Peter, nine years older, joined the Royal Air Force in the Second World War and was killed in 1942 on a mission over the North Atlantic, when John was eleven or twelve. He was a quick, mathematical boy. He went to the Quaker school in Street, then to the grammar school there, and in 1945, when the family moved to Ely, to the Perse School in Cambridge. The church was part of ordinary life throughout: he would later say that Christianity had always been central to him, not something he arrived at late.
(●) 1949 AD: He went up to Trinity College, Cambridge, to read mathematics, and came out a physicist with a wife. First came National Service, the compulsory spell of military service then required of young British men. He did his in the army, where he ended up teaching rather than soldiering. Then he entered Trinity College in October 1949 and read mathematics, graduating in 1952. He stayed on to research quantum field theory, the mathematics that describes particles as ripples in fields that fill all of space, first under Nicholas Kemmer and then under Abdus Salam, who would later share a Nobel Prize. Salam gave him a piece of advice he liked to repeat: publish your ideas, because people remember the ones that turn out right and forget the rest. At Cambridge he met Ruth Martin, a fellow mathematics student, and they married on 26 March 1955. That same year he took his doctorate and was elected a Fellow of Trinity, which made him a full member of the college, with a place at its table and time to do research. It was a crowded, happy stretch of life. A fellowship took the young couple to the California Institute of Technology, where he worked alongside Murray Gell-Mann, the physicist who would soon name the quark. He then lectured at Edinburgh from 1956 to 1958, and it was there that their first son, Peter, was born, before the family came back to a lectureship at Cambridge. A daughter, Isobel, followed in 1959, and a second son, Michael, in 1963.
(●) 1968 AD: Cambridge made him Professor of Mathematical Physics, in the years when physicists discovered what protons are made of. He was promoted to reader in 1965 (in British universities, the senior rank just below a professor) and in 1968 elected Professor of Mathematical Physics. His specialty was the theory of how high-energy particles collide and scatter, work gathered in The Analytic S-Matrix (1966), which he wrote with three colleagues. The S-matrix ("S" for scattering) is a kind of master table that links what goes into a collision with the chances of each thing that might come out. Think of the whole enterprise as learning what is inside a locked box by throwing things at it and watching how they bounce: in the 1960s and 1970s, collisions like these showed that protons and neutrons are not solid balls but are built from smaller pieces, the quarks. Polkinghorne was one of the many theorists who helped make sense of that picture. In 1974 he was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society, Britain’s oldest scientific academy, and one of the highest honors open to a British scientist. He spent periods at Princeton, Berkeley, Stanford, and CERN, the great European laboratory near Geneva. Yet the travel and the honors are only half the picture. Through all of it he remained a practicing Christian, quietly asking how what he knew as a physicist fit with what he believed as a Christian.
(●) 1979 AD: He resigned his professorship to train for the priesthood, and became a student again at forty-eight. In 1977 he decided to seek ordination in the Church of England, and in 1979 he gave up his chair. Colleagues were astonished; some assumed he had lost faith in physics. He insisted he had not left science because he was disillusioned. His reasons were plainer than that. Theoretical physics, he thought, is a young person’s game, and after twenty-five years he had done his bit; Christianity had always been the center of his life, and the priesthood offered a second vocation in which he could serve it with his whole time. So the professor went back to school. He spent two years at Westcott House, the Anglican theological college in Cambridge, studying alongside students half his age, and he admitted it was odd to become a student again after so many years of teaching. For Ruth and the children the decision meant a much smaller income and a very different life.
(●) 1981 AD: Ordained deacon and then priest, he learned the work of a curate in Cambridge and Bristol and a vicar in Kent. He was ordained deacon in 1981 and priest in 1982. In the Church of England a new clergyman is usually made a deacon first, an ordained minister who may preach and baptize but not yet celebrate Communion, and is ordained priest a year later. He then serves as a curate, an assistant priest learning the trade under a vicar, the priest in charge of a parish. Polkinghorne’s apprenticeship was entirely ordinary: first part-time at St Andrew’s, Chesterton, in Cambridge, then from 1982 at St Michael and All Angels in Windmill Hill, a working-class parish in south Bristol. The man who had once calculated scattering amplitudes (the numbers that give the odds of each outcome when particles collide) now took funerals, visited the housebound, and prepared couples for marriage. During the Bristol years he fell seriously ill and needed surgery, a reminder that the second career came with no guarantees. In 1984 he became vicar of the village of Blean, just outside Canterbury. At last he had a parish of his own, and the people of a Kentish village came to him to have their children baptized, to be married, and to bury their dead.
(●) 1986 AD: Cambridge called him back, first as a college chaplain and then as President of Queens’, and the books began to pour out. In 1986 he returned to Cambridge as Fellow, Dean, and Chaplain of Trinity Hall, the priest responsible for the college’s chapel and for the pastoral care of its students and staff, and in 1989 he was elected President of Queens’ College, the head of the whole college, a post he held until he retired in 1996. He was now in the unusual position of being both a former professor of physics and a working priest, and he used it. The writing had already begun with The Way the World Is (1983), a short book addressed to his former scientific colleagues, and a trilogy followed: One World (1986), Science and Creation (1988), and Science and Providence (1989). In 1993 and 1994 he gave the Gifford Lectures in Edinburgh, the most distinguished lecture series in natural theology (learning about God from reason and the study of the world, without appeal to Scripture or revelation), and published them as The Faith of a Physicist. The book is a physicist’s walk through the Nicene Creed, clause by clause. That creed is the summary of Christian belief hammered out by the church councils of the fourth century, beginning with God the Father as maker of heaven and earth, and Catholic, Orthodox, and many Protestant churches still recite it today. He also served the public. In 1988 and 1989 he chaired the British government’s committee reviewing the guidance on research using fetal tissue, which reported in 1989, and he later sat on other national bodies dealing with medical ethics and genetics. In 1997 he was appointed a Knight Commander of the Order of the British Empire for services to science, religion, learning, and medical ethics; as a clergyman he did not use the title "Sir."
(●) 2002 AD: He received the Templeton Prize, buried his wife four years later, and kept writing until he died in Cambridge at ninety. In March 2002 the Templeton Prize, then worth £700,000 and awarded each year for contributions to the understanding of religion, was announced for him, and he received it from Prince Philip at Buckingham Palace. That same year he became the founding president of the International Society for Science and Religion, a learned society for scholars working where the two meet. Ruth died in 2006, after more than fifty years of marriage. It was a heavy loss, but he did not stop working. He went on writing: an autobiography, From Physicist to Priest (2007), short books for ordinary readers, and a stream of answers to the questions people sent him, gathered in Questions of Truth (2009). For more than a decade before that, from 1994 to 2005, he had been Canon Theologian of Liverpool Cathedral. A canon is one of the clergy attached to a cathedral, and a canon theologian is one appointed to serve the cathedral as a teacher of the faith, an honorary post that brought him to Liverpool to preach and lecture. He died in Cambridge on 9 March 2021, aged ninety, survived by his two sons and his daughter.
What He Taught
(T1) Science and theology are cousins: both seek the truth about one reality, and both hold their beliefs for reasons. Think of a kettle coming to the boil in a kitchen. Ask why it is boiling, and there are two true answers. The gas is burning and heating the water; and someone wants a cup of tea. Polkinghorne loved this example, because it shows that "how?" and "why?" are different questions about the same event, and that a full account needs both. Science answers the first kind of question; theology the second. But the answers have to fit: putting the kettle in the refrigerator because you want tea makes no sense. That is why he rejected the popular idea that science deals in facts and religion in opinion. Science does not simply read facts off nature; every interesting fact is already interpreted by theory. And theology, at its best, is not the repetition of an authority’s say-so, but reflection on real experience and on events in history in which God has made himself known. His name for the stance both share is critical realism. "Realism" means the world (and God) are really there, independent of us; "critical" means our knowledge of them is partial and correctable. A map of the London Underground is a good example: it is not a photograph of London, and it would be useless for finding a café, but it is true to the reality it was made for. So his constant question, to scientists and believers alike, was the scientist’s question: what makes you think that might be the case? He called this "motivated belief," belief held because there is evidence that moves you to it.
(Q) "Both respond by appeals to the experiential motivations for their beliefs and both claim that what is called critical realism best describes their achievements. This means that neither attains exhaustive knowledge ... but both believe that they achieve verisimilitude, the making of maps of aspects of reality that are adequate for some, but not every, purpose." Source: John Polkinghorne, The Science and Religion Debate: An Introduction, Faraday Paper No. 1 (The Faraday Institute for Science and Religion, April 2007), p. 2. "Both" means science and theology. He is answering the charge that the two are just stories that communities tell themselves. The words left out explain why neither knows everything: nature keeps surprising its explorers, and the infinite God will always exceed the grasp of finite minds. "Verisimilitude" means likeness to the truth, which is exactly what the Underground map has (T1): not every detail, but a faithful likeness for the journey it was drawn for.
(T2) The universe can be understood because a Mind stands behind it. Evolution can explain why our ancestors learned that stepping off a cliff is a bad idea. What it cannot so easily explain is why the same minds can understand the curved space-time of Einstein and the strange behavior of quarks, things that have no bearing on survival and are utterly unlike anything in ordinary experience. Polkinghorne thought scientists took this astonishing fact far too much for granted. Einstein once wrote that the eternal mystery of the world is its comprehensibility. There is a second surprise inside the first. In fundamental physics, he pointed out, the best way to find a true theory is to look for beautiful equations, and it works: Paul Dirac, the greatest physicist Polkinghorne knew personally, made his discoveries that way. Why should patterns that mathematicians dream up at their desks turn out to be written into the structure of the world? Polkinghorne called these "metaquestions," questions that arise from doing science but go beyond what science can answer. The reason is simple once you see it: science has to assume that nature is orderly and understandable before it can begin, so it cannot turn around and explain why that assumption works. A carpenter’s tape measure can measure every board in the shop, but not the trustworthiness of the tape measure. His answer was the doctrine of creation. Our minds and the order of the world fit together because they have one source, the rationality of God, and we are made in his image (Genesis 1:27). This is a new and humbler natural theology (learning about God from the world itself): not a "proof" that forces assent, but the claim that belief in God explains more than unbelief does.
(Q) "A religious understanding renders the intelligibility of the universe itself intelligible, for it says that the world is shot through with signs of mind precisely because the Mind of its Creator lies behind its wonderful order." Source: John Polkinghorne, The Science and Religion Debate: An Introduction, Faraday Paper No. 1 (The Faraday Institute for Science and Religion, April 2007), p. 2. The sentence closes his argument that it is "intellectually very unsatisfactory" to treat the success of science as a happy accident. He made the same case at greater length in "An Intelligible Universe," Euresis Journal 1 (2011), pp. 107–112.
(T3) The universe was fine-tuned for life from the beginning, and creation explains that better than a multitude of unseen worlds. Imagine a radio that only plays music if a dozen dials are each set to almost exactly the right position. If you came into a room and found it playing, you would not shrug. That, roughly, is what physicists discovered in the second half of the twentieth century about the universe. The strength of gravity, of electromagnetism, of the nuclear forces, the balance between the universe’s expansion and gravity’s pull: change any of these a little and there would be no stars that burn for billions of years, no carbon, and so no life. This is called the anthropic principle, from the Greek anthropos, "human being," and the image physicists use for it is "fine-tuning." Polkinghorne liked a parable from the philosopher John Leslie. You face a firing squad of expert marksmen; the order is given; and you find yourself alive. You do not walk away saying, "That was close." Either a vast number of executions are happening and you happen to be in the one where everyone missed, or the marksmen missed on purpose. Translated into cosmology: either there is an enormous multiverse of unseen universes and we are in the lucky one, or the universe was made this way by design. He granted that some multiverse ideas are respectable physics, but thought the more sweeping versions were a metaphysical guess on a lavish scale: a guess, that is, about what exists beyond anything we could ever observe or test, made partly to avoid the alternative. It matters what kind of design he meant. He did not picture a God tinkering with each creature, but one who built the potential for life into the laws of nature from the first moment.
(Q) "The universe was billions of years old before life appeared in it, but it was pregnant with that possibility from the beginning." Source: John Polkinghorne, The Anthropic Principle and the Science and Religion Debate, Faraday Paper No. 4 (The Faraday Institute for Science and Religion, April 2007), p. 1. He is explaining that the "chance" of evolution could never have produced life on its own unless the "necessity" of the laws of nature had first taken the very specific form life requires.
(T4) God’s love lets creation make itself, and that freedom has a cost. Every parent knows the moment of taking the hand off the back of a child’s bicycle. Love that never lets go is not quite love; it has to give the beloved room to be itself, even to fall. Polkinghorne thought God’s relationship to creation is like that. In the decades after Darwin, two Victorian churchmen, Charles Kingsley and Frederick Temple, had said that God could have made a ready-made world, but had done something cleverer: he made a world so fertile that its creatures were allowed "to make themselves," emerging through a long exploration of possibilities. Theologians call this self-limiting love kenosis, from the Greek word Paul uses when he says Christ "emptied himself, by taking the form of a servant" (Philippians 2:7). In creation, Polkinghorne argued, God makes room for creatures to be truly themselves. The world is not a puppet theater with God pulling every string. This was his main help with the problem of suffering. Alongside the familiar free-will defense (moral evil, the harm people choose to do, is the cost of free persons), he set a "free-process defense": natural evil, the suffering no one chooses, such as earthquakes and disease, is the cost of a world allowed to develop. The engine of life’s fruitful history is genetic mutation, and the same chemistry that lets new forms of life appear lets some cells mutate and become cancerous. Cancer, he wrote, is not a careless oversight a better Creator could have fixed, but the shadow side of a world that makes itself. He did not think this removed the grief, and he never pretended it did.
(Q) "Christian theology believes God’s fundamental character to be love. Such a deity could not be supposed to act as a Cosmic Tyrant, pulling every string in a creation that was no more than a divine puppet theatre. The gift of love must always be some due form of independence granted to the object of that love." Source: John Polkinghorne, The Science and Religion Debate: An Introduction, Faraday Paper No. 1 (The Faraday Institute for Science and Religion, April 2007), p. 3. The passage leads straight into his account of creation as divine self-limitation, and from there to cancer as "the inescapable shadow side of evolving fruitfulness" (T4).
(T5) The world is not a machine: God acts in it, and the resurrection of Jesus is a question of evidence, not of prejudice. For two centuries after Newton many people pictured the universe as clockwork, every movement fixed in advance, and a clockwork universe leaves God nothing to do but wind it up. Polkinghorne pointed out that twentieth-century physics broke the clock. Quantum theory found unpredictability at the level of atoms, and chaos theory found it at the level of the weather: the famous butterfly whose wingbeat can, in principle, change a storm a month later. He took these openings as signs that the future is not fixed by the past alone. Human choices and God’s providence (his continuing care and guidance of the world he made) can both be real causes in a world that science describes truthfully but not exhaustively. Miracles he treated the same way a physicist treats a strange experimental result. Science assumes that what usually happens is what always happens, but it cannot use that assumption to rule out a unique event. The right question is not "Is it reasonable?", as if we already knew the shape reason must take, but "What makes you think that might be the case?" Light, after all, turned out to behave as both wave and particle, which any philosopher in 1899 could have "proved" impossible. He put that question to the center of the faith: the resurrection of Jesus, which he defended as a bodily event with an empty tomb, and the ground of the Christian hope that God will raise the dead (1 Corinthians 15:20). He described the human soul as the living pattern of a person, which God will remember and re-embody in the new creation, the renewed world the Bible promises at the end of history. Think of a piece of music: the notes on one particular piano can fall silent, but the composer still holds the melody and can play it again on a new instrument.
(Q) "Scientists do not instinctively ask the question, 'Is it reasonable?', as if they knew beforehand what shape rationality had to take. ... Instead, they ask 'What makes you think that might be the case?', an enquiry at once more open and, in its insistence on evidence, more demanding." Source: John Polkinghorne, The Science and Religion Debate: An Introduction, Faraday Paper No. 1 (The Faraday Institute for Science and Religion, April 2007), p. 4. The words left out are his reason: "The physical world has too often proved too surprising for that to be appropriate." He goes on to say that miracle must be approached the same way, neither ruled out in advance nor believed without adequate motivation.
(Q) "I believe that I need the binocular approach of science and religion, if I am to do any sort of justice to the deep and rich reality of the world in which we live." Source: John Polkinghorne, statement at the announcement of the 2002 Templeton Prize, New York, 14 March 2002 (Templeton Prize). The whole of his work in one sentence: not science or religion, but the depth that comes from looking with both.
What the Church Made of Him
(†) With Ian Barbour and Arthur Peacocke, he made "science and religion" a field of study with its own societies, journals, and readers. In the second half of the twentieth century three scientists led the way in turning the relationship between science and faith from a running quarrel into a serious discipline: the American physicist Ian Barbour, the Oxford biochemist Arthur Peacocke, and Polkinghorne. The Templeton Prize went to all three in quick succession (Barbour in 1999, Peacocke in 2001, Polkinghorne in 2002), and Polkinghorne compared their approaches in Scientists as Theologians (1996), honest about where he differed from the other two. He was a founding member of the Society of Ordained Scientists, a community of clergy who are also working scientists, and the first president of the International Society for Science and Religion. When the Faraday Institute for Science and Religion in Cambridge began publishing its free Faraday Papers in 2007, the first in the series was his. Of the three, he was the one who stayed closest to the historic creeds, and that is a large part of why ordinary churchgoers, and not only academics, read him.
(†) Christian thinkers carried his fine-tuning and intelligibility arguments into the wider defense of the faith. Polkinghorne’s two metaquestions, why the universe can be understood and why it is fine-tuned for life, were not his inventions (Einstein and the physicist Eugene Wigner had marveled at the first, and physicists such as Brandon Carter had laid out the data for the second), but the way he put them became standard equipment for Christians answering the claim that science has made God unnecessary. Because he was a Fellow of the Royal Society arguing from inside physics, he could not be dismissed as a pastor who did not understand the science, and his books gave students and pastors a way to speak about the big bang and evolution without fear. He was equally useful as a model of temperament. He took the strongest objections seriously, refused to set faith against established science, and insisted that a Christian should be as eager for evidence in theology as in the laboratory. Psalm 19:1 says, "The heavens declare the glory of God, and the sky above proclaims his handiwork," and Paul says that God’s "invisible attributes" are "clearly perceived" in "the things that have been made" (Romans 1:20). Polkinghorne’s life work was an attempt to show a scientific age what that might mean. The critics noticed him too. In The God Delusion (2006) Richard Dawkins, naming him among several British scientists of faith, said he remained baffled that such men could believe in the resurrection and the forgiveness of sins; Polkinghorne, for his part, told an interviewer in 2009 that debating Dawkins was hopeless because there was no give and take.
(†) Where many Christians part company with him: God’s knowledge of the future, and where the dead wait for the resurrection. Polkinghorne’s own teaching departs from the great majority of Christian tradition at two points, both of them consequences of ideas he held on purpose. - The open future. He argued that a world of real becoming requires God to limit not only his power but his knowledge: the future, he said, is not yet there to be known, even by God. Augustine, Aquinas, Calvin, Arminius, and the Catholic and Orthodox traditions all hold that God knows the future completely, and Scripture speaks of a God "declaring the end from the beginning" (Isaiah 46:10) and writing in his book "the days that were formed for me, when as yet there was none of them" (Psalm 139:16). Foreknowledge simply means knowing something before it happens. Many Christians, notably those who follow the Dutch theologian Jacobus Arminius and the Spanish Jesuit Luis de Molina, agree with Polkinghorne that creatures are genuinely free and that their choices really shape the future. Yet they hold that God foreknows those free choices without causing them, much as your remembering what a friend did yesterday did not make her do it. In their view his worry can be met without giving up foreknowledge. - The soul and the intermediate state. He held that the soul is not a separate spiritual substance but the information-bearing pattern of the whole person, which God remembers and will re-embody at the resurrection. Most Christian traditions affirm both the resurrection of the body and a conscious life with Christ between death and resurrection, what theologians call the intermediate state, as Paul says his "desire is to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better" (Philippians 1:23). Some Christian philosophers share Polkinghorne’s view of the person, but it remains a minority one. Neither point touched the creed he expounded in The Faith of a Physicist: the Creator, the incarnation, the bodily resurrection of Christ, and the hope of new creation (Romans 8:21) he confessed without reservation.