Justified True Belief

Mapping the Landscape of Good Reasons for the Truth of Christianity

Christian Evidences

Evidence & Arguments for Christian Theism

Divinity of Christ

Biblical Evidence for High-Christology: Jesus is God

TBD

Old Testament Criticism

Evidence for the Reliability of the OT Bible

Common Objections

Objection Analyses to Christian Theism

World Religions

Critical Analyses of Non-Christian Religions

Philosophy

Phileō Sophia - to Love Wisdom.

Metaphysics: Free Will

Whether Our Choices Are Up to Us

Public Theology

Theological Analyses of Societal Issues

Theology of the Family

Where Faith and Family Intersect

Biographies

Notable Works & Great Quotes from Key Figures

Contemporary Voices

1960 AD – present

Charles Taylor of Montreal b. 1931 AD

(●) The Canadian Catholic philosopher who explained how belief in God went from unavoidable to one option among many. + Picture two neighbors on the same street. One goes to Mass every Sunday; the other has never prayed in her life and does not feel the lack. Neither thinks the other is mad. Each knows the other’s way of living is a real possibility, and each, on a bad night, can feel the pull of it. Five hundred years ago in Europe that street would have been almost unimaginable. Charles Taylor spent much of his career asking how we got from there to here, and his answer, A Secular Age (2007), is among the most influential accounts of modern unbelief written in our lifetime. He belongs on a Christian apologetics site because he changed the question. The usual story says science and reason simply cleared religion away, the way a lamp clears away shadows. Taylor showed, over almost nine hundred pages of history, that the story is too simple: what changed was not mainly the evidence for God but the whole background against which people believe or disbelieve. Anyone who wants to speak about Christ to a modern neighbor needs that map, and pastors, apologists, and philosophers of every tradition have used it. The signature fact is the range of the man. He is a Rhodes Scholar who helped found a magazine of the British New Left, a socialist who ran for the Canadian Parliament four times and once lost to a future prime minister, a philosopher of language and of Hegel, a practicing Roman Catholic, and the winner of both the Templeton Prize and the Kyoto Prize. Few living thinkers have argued so long, in so many fields, from the same desk.

(●) 1931 AD: Born in Montreal to an English Protestant father and a French Catholic mother, he grew up in both of Canada’s languages. + Charles Margrave Taylor was born in Montreal on 5 November 1931, the youngest of three children. His father, Walter Margrave Taylor, was an English-speaking Protestant from Toronto who made his living in steel; his mother, Simone Beaubien, was a French-speaking Roman Catholic who worked as a dressmaker and designer. The children were raised Catholic, and the house in Outremont ran in two languages at once. That double upbringing matters for everything that follows. Canada in those years was often described as "two solitudes," English and French living side by side and seldom really meeting. Taylor grew up on the seam between them, and the question that runs through his whole career began at the dinner table: how do people who see the world differently live together without either pretending the differences away or tearing each other apart? He was schooled at Selwyn House in Montreal and Trinity College School in Port Hope, Ontario, and took a degree in history at McGill University in 1952.

(●) 1952 AD: A Rhodes Scholarship took him to Oxford, where he studied philosophy and helped launch the British New Left. + A Rhodes Scholarship is a place at Oxford, paid for by the trust Cecil Rhodes left behind, awarded to a handful of promising students from around the world each year. Taylor arrived at Balliol College in 1952 and took his degree in philosophy, politics and economics with first-class honours in 1955. In 1956 he was elected a fellow of All Souls, the Oxford college that has no undergraduates at all, only scholars. He was not a quiet scholar. Before the national Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament even existed, he chaired an Oxford campaign against the hydrogen bomb, and, as he later told it, was called in by the university’s proctors (the officers who keep discipline among the students) and had his knuckles rapped for not asking permission. Then came 1956, when Soviet tanks crushed the uprising in Hungary. In the months after it Taylor spent about half a year in Vienna working for a relief organization, helping the refugee students who poured across the border from Hungary. The same tanks shook the British left. A number of British communists left the party, and the next spring Taylor joined Stuart Hall, Raphael Samuel and Gabriel Pearson as one of the four founding editors of Universities and Left Review, a magazine of the "New Left." The New Left were socialists who wanted neither Moscow nor the comfortable center, and Taylor fit the description exactly: he was, he said later, a man of the left and an anti-communist at the same time. In 1960 the magazine merged with The New Reasoner to form the New Left Review. His doctorate, finished in 1961, was supervised by Isaiah Berlin, the great historian of ideas, with Elizabeth Anscombe, the Catholic philosopher, also among his teachers. It became his first book, The Explanation of Behaviour (1964), an attack on behaviorism, the school of psychology that tried to explain human action the way a physicist explains a falling stone.

(●) 1961 AD: He came home to Montreal to teach, and ran for Parliament four times without winning once. + "I came back to Canada, Quebec, which I always intended to," he said in a 2021 interview, looking back on 1961, and he came back intending to do politics as well as philosophy. He taught political science and philosophy at McGill, and threw himself into the New Democratic Party, Canada’s social democratic party, rising to be a vice-president of the federal party and president of its Quebec wing. He stood for the House of Commons in 1962, 1963, 1965 and 1968, and lost every time. The 1965 race is the one people remember. Taylor was the NDP’s candidate in the Montreal riding of Mount Royal (a "riding" is what Canadians call an electoral district), and the Liberals parachuted in a brilliant newcomer named Pierre Elliott Trudeau, who won the seat and three years later became prime minister. Canadians still enjoy imagining the debates the country might have heard if the result had gone the other way. It is an ordinary human story of a man who wanted badly to win and kept losing. It also shaped the philosopher. Taylor never wrote about society from the outside: he had knocked on its doors, and been told no. All the while the house was filling up. In 1956 he had married Alba Romer, an artist and social worker, and between 1958 and 1965, the very years of the campaigns, they had five daughters.

(●) 1976 AD: Oxford called him back to a famous chair, and the books on Hegel and the modern self followed. + In 1976 Taylor succeeded John Plamenatz as Chichele Professor of Social and Political Theory at Oxford, one of the most senior posts in his field in the English-speaking world, held with a fellowship at All Souls. He had just published Hegel (1975), a large and sympathetic study of the German philosopher Georg Hegel, famous for dense writing about history, freedom and spirit, at a time when most English-speaking philosophers treated Hegel as a fog to be avoided. It is still one of the standard introductions. He returned to McGill in the early 1980s, and there he wrote the book that made his name outside the universities. Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity (1989) traces where the modern sense of being a "self" came from, from Plato and Augustine through Descartes, the Protestant Reformers, the Enlightenment and the Romantics (T1). It ends, unexpectedly for a work of academic philosophy, by naming the hope of Christian faith. The next year brought the hardest loss of his life. Alba Romer Taylor, his wife of thirty-four years, died in 1990, at fifty-nine. Five years later, in 1995, he married again, to Aube Billard.

(●) 1999 AD: In the Gifford Lectures at Edinburgh he asked why belief in God had become hard, and spent eight more years answering. + The 1990s brought Taylor’s faith into his public work more openly. It began quietly enough: in 1991 his Massey Lectures on Canadian radio, The Malaise of Modernity, became a short book on the pressure to "be yourself" (T2). Then in 1996 he gave the Marianist Award lecture at the University of Dayton, a Catholic university in Ohio, published as A Catholic Modernity? (1999). It was a rare occasion on which he spoke at length, in public, as a Catholic philosopher about his own church and the modern world (T5). In the spring of 1999 he gave the Gifford Lectures at the University of Edinburgh, the most famous lecture series on natural theology (what can be known of God by reason and experience). His subject was what it means to live in a secular age. The lectures grew, through a fellowship in Berlin and years of rewriting, into A Secular Age (2007): almost nine hundred pages, the first three parts drawn from the Edinburgh lectures and the last two added later (T3, T4). He had retired from McGill in 1998, and from 2002 he taught law and philosophy at Northwestern University near Chicago for several years. Retirement, for Taylor, meant writing the longest book of his life.

(●) 2007 AD: He won the Templeton Prize and was asked to help Quebec settle how far to accommodate its newcomers. + The year A Secular Age appeared, Taylor received the Templeton Prize, one of the largest annual prizes in the world, given for work affirming life’s spiritual dimension. The Kyoto Prize in arts and philosophy followed in 2008. The same year the government of Quebec asked him and the historian and sociologist Gérard Bouchard to lead a public commission on "reasonable accommodation," the question of how far public life should bend to the religious and cultural practices of immigrants. Small disputes had turned into a province-wide quarrel: frosted windows at a Montreal YMCA, a prayer room at a university, a small town’s code of conduct telling newcomers how women there may and may not dress. The two men held hearings across Quebec in 2007 and reported in 2008. Their report argued for an open secularism, in which the state stays neutral among religions without driving religion out of public life. It would have barred religious symbols only for officials who embody the coercive authority of the state, its power to compel and punish (judges, Crown prosecutors, police officers, prison guards and the presiding officers of the National Assembly), and it left teachers, civil servants and health workers free to wear them. In 2017 Taylor withdrew his support even from that narrow ban. Here the boy from the bilingual house in Outremont was doing in public what he had done at his parents’ table: listening to two sides and looking for the terms on which they could live together.

(●) 2015 AD: Honors kept coming, and past ninety he was still publishing books. + The honors kept arriving well into his eighties. In 2015 the Library of Congress awarded him the John W. Kluge Prize, shared with the German philosopher Jürgen Habermas, and in 2016 he received the first Berggruen Prize for Philosophy and Culture. At home he had long been honored too: he is a Companion of the Order of Canada (1995), the order’s highest rank, and a Grand Officer of the National Order of Quebec (2000). He did not stop working. The Language Animal (2016) gathered decades of thinking about how language does more than label things. Reconstructing Democracy (2020), written with Patrizia Nanz and his daughter Madeleine Beaubien Taylor, looked at how small towns were rebuilding civic life. And in 2024, at ninety-two, he published Cosmic Connections: Poetry in the Age of Disenchantment, a study of the Romantic and modern poets who refused to believe that the world is only matter. It is a fitting late book for a man who had argued all his life that people know more than they can say.

What He Taught

(T1) You cannot know who you are without knowing what you hold to be good. + Ask a stranger at a bus stop who she is, and she will not give you her height and weight. She will say she is a nurse, a mother, a Christian, a Quebecer, a person who does not lie. Every one of those answers is a commitment, a thing she cares about, a standard she would be ashamed to fall short of. Taylor’s point in Sources of the Self is that this is not an accident. Human beings are what he calls "self-interpreting animals": what we are is partly made up of how we understand ourselves, and we understand ourselves by reference to goods we care about. He calls the deepest of these "strong evaluations." A weak evaluation is a preference: I would rather have tea than coffee, and nothing hangs on it. A strong evaluation is a judgment that one way of living is higher or lower, nobler or baser, whatever I happen to want: courage is better than cowardice even when I am afraid. Every human life, Taylor argues, moves inside a framework of such goods, and someone who truly had none would not be a free spirit. He would be in a crisis of identity, unable to say what anything is worth. This is where the book touches apologetics. Modern people hold extraordinarily demanding moral standards: universal human rights, care for the suffering, the dignity of every person. Taylor argues that they often cannot say what grounds those standards, and that the "moral sources" behind them, the realities that make those goods worth loving, were historically supplied in large part by the God of the Bible. A culture can live for a long time on capital it no longer names. Christians have heard in this an echo of what Paul says about the law written on the heart (Romans 2:15).

(Q) "To know who I am is a species of knowing where I stand." + Source: Charles Taylor, Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity (Harvard University Press, 1989), chapter 2, "The Self in Moral Space," page 27. A "species" here means a kind: knowing who you are is one kind of knowing where you stand, morally, on the questions of what is good and worth doing (T1).

(T2) Being true to yourself is a real ideal, but it collapses when nothing beyond the self is allowed to matter. + Think of the graduation speech every one of us has sat through: follow your dream, be yourself, do not let anyone tell you who to be. Many philosophers sneer at that kind of talk as shallow. Taylor does not. In The Malaise of Modernity (1991), published in the United States as The Ethics of Authenticity, he argues that "authenticity," the ideal of living a life that is genuinely your own, is a serious moral ideal with a long history, reaching back through the Romantics to Augustine’s turn inward to find God in the depths of the soul. The trouble starts when the ideal is cut off from what he calls "horizons of significance," the background of things that matter whether or not I choose them. Choosing your own life is only worth something if some choices are better than others. If nothing outside me matters (God, the demands of other people, the claims of nature, the call of citizenship), then my choosing is like a shopper choosing between two identical boxes: free, and pointless. Authenticity, rightly understood, needs something larger than the self to be true to. Taylor names three "malaises," three sicknesses of modern life: an individualism that shrinks into self-absorption, the rule of "instrumental reason" (asking only how to get things done efficiently, never whether they are worth doing), and a resulting loss of freedom as citizens retreat into private life.

(Q) "The dark side of individualism is a centring on the self, which both flattens and narrows our lives, makes them poorer in meaning, and less concerned with others or society." + Source: Charles Taylor, The Ethics of Authenticity (Harvard University Press, 1992), chapter 1, "Three Malaises," page 4. The same text was first published in Canada as The Malaise of Modernity (Anansi, 1991). The first of the three malaises (T2). Taylor’s point is not that individualism is bad but that it has a dark side, and that the cure lies inside the ideal itself rightly understood.

(T3) A secular age is not one without faith but one in which faith has become one option among others. + What does it mean to call our age "secular"? Taylor separates three meanings. In the first, public spaces such as government, the economy and the university are emptied of reference to God. In the second, religious belief and practice decline: fewer people in the pews. Both are real, but neither is what interests him most. The third sense is a change in the conditions of belief: the background against which anyone, believer or not, believes anything. Here is the contrast he draws. In Europe around 1500 it was almost impossible not to believe in God. Not because everyone had weighed the arguments, but because the whole world spoke of him: the parish ordered the year, the king ruled by divine right, as God’s appointed deputy, storms and plagues and harvests were read as acts of God, and the alternative was barely thinkable. By 2000, for many people unbelief had become not only possible but the obvious default, and faith the thing that needed explaining. Even the most devout believer now knows, in a way his ancestors did not, that thoughtful people live perfectly well without God. Taylor calls this condition "fragilization": every belief, Christian or secular, is held while looking at neighbors who hold the opposite. His most important move is to reject what he calls "subtraction stories," the tale that modern unbelief is simply what is left once science and reason subtract the illusions. Unbelief, he argues, is not a leftover. It is a new achievement, built from new ideas about nature, society and the self, many of them Christian in origin. That changes the conversation. If secularism is not the neutral ground left when religion is cleared away, then it is a view of the world like any other, and has to make its case like any other.

(Q) "The shift to secularity in this sense consists, among other things, of a move from a society where belief in God is unchallenged and indeed, unproblematic, to one in which it is understood to be one option among others, and frequently not the easiest to embrace." + Source: Charles Taylor, A Secular Age (Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007), Introduction, page 3. The definition of the third sense of "secular," the one the whole book is about (T3). At the opening of the first chapter (page 25) Taylor puts the same point as a question: why was it virtually impossible not to believe in God in Western society around 1500, while by 2000 many find unbelief easy, even inescapable?

(T4) Modern people live inside an "immanent frame," which can be read as closed to God or open to him. + Imagine a villager in 1500 walking home after dark. The woods are full of things that can reach him: spirits, curses, the power of relics, the presence of God and the saints. His self is "porous," Taylor says, like a sponge with the world’s meanings soaking straight in. Now imagine a modern commuter walking the same road. Whatever she believes, the dark woods are just woods. Her self is "buffered": meaning lives inside her mind, and the world outside is a natural order of causes she can study. That natural order, understood as complete in itself, is what Taylor calls the "immanent frame." "Immanent" means within, as opposed to "transcendent," beyond. All of us, believers included, now live inside this frame: we explain the weather by meteorology and the plague by germs. The question is how we take the frame. Some read it as closed, a sealed box with nothing beyond it. Others read it as open, a world with windows. Taylor’s point is that neither reading is forced on us by the evidence. Either one becomes what he calls a "spin" when it is held as obvious fact rather than as one take among others, the way a press secretary presents one side of a story as simply the way things are. His main target is the closed spin, the assumption that any clear-thinking person must see the box as sealed. The honest position, he says, is to admit that the frame itself does not decide the question. What made the closed reading possible, he argues, was "exclusive humanism": for the first time in history, a widely available view of life that accepts no goal beyond human flourishing. And yet the frame never seals quite tight. Moderns find themselves "cross-pressured," pulled between a world that seems "disenchanted" (emptied of the spirits and sacred powers that filled the villager’s woods) and recurring experiences of beauty, love, guilt and longing that point beyond it, what Taylor calls a sense of "fullness."

(Q) "I would like to claim that the coming of modern secularity in my sense has been coterminous with the rise of a society in which for the first time in history a purely self-sufficient humanism came to be a widely available option. I mean by this a humanism accepting no final goals beyond human flourishing, nor any allegiance to anything else beyond this flourishing. Of no previous society was this true." + Source: Charles Taylor, A Secular Age (Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007), Introduction, page 18. "Coterminous" means sharing the same boundaries in time: modern secularity and exclusive humanism arrived together (T4). The last sentence is the weight-bearing one. Every earlier civilization, Christian or pagan, placed the point of human life at least partly beyond human life.

(T5) Modern culture carries some fruits of the gospel further than Christendom did, while closing itself off from God. + Consider the hospital ward where nurses care for a stranger of another faith with the same tenderness they would give a brother, or the court that protects the rights of a man whom everybody hates. Taylor argues that much of what is best in the modern West, its universal concern for human rights and for the relief of suffering, grew from the gospel’s command to love the neighbor, any neighbor (Luke 10:29–37). He also argues something harder for Christians to hear: that some of these fruits ripened more fully after the church lost its political grip than they ever had under "Christendom," the old order in which church and state were bound together and belonging to one meant belonging to the other. His Dayton lecture, A Catholic Modernity?, puts it in the form of a double claim. Modern secular culture contains real developments of the gospel, and it also contains a closing off to God that denies the gospel. The Christian’s task is to tell the two apart: neither to condemn modernity wholesale, as if nothing good had come of it, nor to bless it wholesale, as if the closing off did not matter. He even offers a wry vote of thanks to Voltaire and the other critics of the church for helping Christians, not always on purpose, to live the gospel more purely, free of the forcing of conscience that Christendom had practiced. For Taylor, the word "catholic" carries its old meaning of "universal," a universality reached through wholeness. A catholic church is one that gathers the whole range of human cultures into one body without flattening them into one: unity across difference, not unity through sameness. His model is Matteo Ricci, the Jesuit missionary to China, who tried to sort out what in Chinese culture was a valid human difference and what was incompatible with the faith, and he hoped the church could do the same sorting with modernity.

(Q) "In modern, secularist culture there are mingled together both authentic developments of the gospel, of an incarnational mode of life, and also a closing off to God that negates the gospel." + Source: Charles Taylor, "A Catholic Modernity?", the Marianist Award lecture at the University of Dayton (1996), in A Catholic Modernity? Charles Taylor’s Marianist Award Lecture, edited by James L. Heft (Oxford University Press, 1999). The thesis of the lecture (T5). "Incarnational" refers to the Incarnation, God the Son taking flesh: a way of life that honors the body, the ordinary and the neighbor because God himself entered them.

(Q) "It is a hope that I see implicit in Judaeo-Christian theism (however terrible the record of its adherents in history), and in its central promise of a divine affirmation of the human, more total than humans can ever attain unaided." + Source: Charles Taylor, Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity (Harvard University Press, 1989), chapter 25, "Conclusion: The Conflicts of Modernity," page 521. Nearly the last words of the book. After five hundred pages of history, Taylor names where he himself finds the moral sources strong enough to carry the high standards of modern people (T1): in the God who affirms human beings more fully than they can affirm themselves.

What the Church Made of Him

(†) A Secular Age became the map that pastors and apologists across the traditions use to reach their neighbors. + An almost nine-hundred-page history of ideas is not a book most pastors read on a Monday. Yet within a decade A Secular Age had become required equipment for Christians thinking about witness in the West, and much of that came through translators. James K. A. Smith, a Reformed (that is, Calvinist) philosopher at Calvin College, wrote How (Not) to Be Secular: Reading Charles Taylor (2014), a short guide that put the immanent frame and the cross-pressured self in front of a wide readership of pastors and students. Timothy Keller, the Presbyterian pastor in New York, built on Taylor in Preaching (2015) and Making Sense of God (2016), urging preachers to speak to the longings for meaning, freedom and justice that secular people already have. Evangelical, Catholic and Orthodox writers alike took up his vocabulary. What they found useful was the reversal at the heart of the book (T3). Secular neighbors are not people with no faith who need to be given one; they are people living inside a story with its own beliefs about freedom, meaning and the good. That story can be questioned, and its unmet longings, the "fullness" Taylor describes, are an opening. It is a modern version of what Paul did on the Areopagus, the hill in Athens where the city’s council met, starting from the altar "To the unknown god" the city already had (Acts 17:23).

(†) He showed that secularism is a worldview with a history, not the neutral ground left when faith is cleared away. + For a long time the debate between belief and unbelief ran on an unspoken rule: the secular view was the default, and only belief carried a burden of proof. Taylor’s rejection of subtraction stories (T3), and his argument that a closed reading of the immanent frame is a "spin" rather than a discovery (T4), took that rule away. If exclusive humanism is a historically new position, built out of earlier Christian materials, then it owes an account of itself just as faith does. His account of moral sources (T1) has served the moral argument in a similar way. The moral argument is the case that real moral obligations, binding on everyone whether they like it or not, point to a moral lawgiver behind them. A culture that insists on universal human dignity while denying any ground for it is living, as Taylor argued, on goods it can no longer name. Apologists have used that as a question to ask rather than an accusation to make: where does this conviction come from, and what holds it up? The Templeton Prize of 2007 recognized the same achievement from a different angle: a philosopher at the top of his profession who had treated the spiritual dimension of human life as something to be understood, not explained away.

(†) Christian readers have pressed him on two points: his account of the Reformation, and his choice to describe belief rather than defend it. + The first point concerns history. Taylor traces disenchantment (T4) in part to what he calls "Reform." By that he means a long drive in late medieval and early modern Christianity, Catholic and Protestant both, to raise every believer to the standard once expected only of monks and to sweep away magic and half-pagan custom: think of a village priest forbidding the old charms against fever and insisting that his farmers pray and examine their consciences like friars. The Protestant Reformation is one important current in that drive. Some Protestant readers think this makes the Reformers carry too much of the blame for secularism; Taylor’s own account begins Reform in the medieval church, centuries before Luther, and describes unintended consequences rather than assigning guilt. Both points are fairly made, and readers in each tradition can weigh them. The second point is a choice Taylor made on purpose. A Secular Age is written by a believer, and he does not hide it, but it is a description of the conditions of belief and deliberately not an argument for believing. It leaves the reader at the open frame and does not walk through the window. That is a fair decision for a historian, and it is the reason the book could persuade readers who would never open an apologetics book. But it means that the question apologetics exists to ask, whether Christianity is actually true, is one Taylor clears the ground for and largely leaves to others. His work prepares the way; the arguments for God’s existence and for the resurrection of Jesus have to be made elsewhere.

Taylor is a living author whose work spans more than sixty years, several languages, and a great many essays, lectures, and edited volumes. The list below gives his books, with their English editions, grouped by period, followed by the essays that shaped whole debates and the books published only in other languages. Many of his essays were gathered into collections, so a reader looking for a famous paper usually finds it in one of the volumes listed. Early work: the human sciences and Hegel (1964–1985) - The Explanation of Behaviour (1964): His Oxford doctorate turned into a book. An attack on behaviorism, arguing that human action can only be explained by purposes, not by the mechanical cause and effect of a falling stone. - The Pattern of Politics (1970): A short political book written from his years in the New Democratic Party, setting out a democratic socialist vision for Canada. - Hegel (1975): A large and sympathetic study that reintroduced Georg Hegel to English-speaking philosophers who had largely written him off. Still a standard introduction. - Hegel and Modern Society (1979): A shorter book drawn from Hegel, asking what Hegel still has to say about freedom, community and the modern state. - Social Theory as Practice (1983): Lectures arguing that theories about society are never neutral descriptions; they change the practices they describe. - Human Agency and Language (Philosophical Papers, volume 1, 1985): Essays on the self, including "Self-Interpreting Animals" and "What Is Human Agency?", where the idea of strong evaluation is set out (T1). - Philosophy and the Human Sciences (Philosophical Papers, volume 2, 1985): Essays on politics and social science, including "Interpretation and the Sciences of Man," "Atomism," and "What’s Wrong with Negative Liberty." The modern self (1989–1995) - Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity (1989): His first great synthesis. The history of the modern self from Plato and Augustine to the Romantics and modernists, and the argument that identity and the good cannot be separated (T1). - The Malaise of Modernity (1991), published in the United States as The Ethics of Authenticity (1992): The Massey Lectures. A short, readable defense of authenticity rightly understood, against both its critics and its shallow forms (T2). - Multiculturalism and "The Politics of Recognition" (1992, edited by Amy Gutmann; expanded edition 1994 as Multiculturalism: Examining the Politics of Recognition): His famous essay on why being recognized for who we are is a human need, with responses from other scholars. - Reconciling the Solitudes: Essays on Canadian Federalism and Nationalism (1993; first published in French as Rapprocher les solitudes, 1992): Essays on the English and French in Canada and how a country of two peoples can hold together. - Roads to Democracy: Human Rights and Democratic Development in Thailand (1994, with Vitit Muntarbhorn): A short study, written with a Thai legal scholar, of human rights and the growth of democracy in Thailand. - Philosophical Arguments (1995): Essays on knowledge, language, the self and politics, including "Overcoming Epistemology." Religion and secularity (1999–2011) - A Catholic Modernity? (1999, edited by James L. Heft): His 1996 Marianist Award lecture at the University of Dayton, with responses from four scholars and his reply. The fullest statement of his Catholic convictions up to that time (T5). - Varieties of Religion Today: William James Revisited (2002): Lectures revisiting William James’s classic study of religious experience, and asking why so much modern religion has become a private search. - Modern Social Imaginaries (2004): How ordinary people picture their society (the economy, the public sphere, the sovereign people), and how those pictures replaced the older ones. A preparation for the larger book. - A Secular Age (2007): His masterpiece. The Gifford Lectures of 1999 grown to almost nine hundred pages: how Western society went from almost universal belief to belief as one option among others (T3, T4). - Building the Future: A Time for Reconciliation (2008, with Gérard Bouchard): The report of the Quebec commission on reasonable accommodation, arguing for an open secularism and for integration through exchange between the majority and newcomers. - Secularism and Freedom of Conscience (2011, with Jocelyn Maclure; French original Laïcité et liberté de conscience, 2010): A short book on what a fair secular state owes to believers and unbelievers alike, drawing on the Quebec commission. - Dilemmas and Connections: Selected Essays (2011): Essays from two decades on religion, violence, democracy and modernity. - The Power of Religion in the Public Sphere (2011, with Judith Butler, Jürgen Habermas and Cornel West): A conversation in print among four philosophers on whether religious voices belong in public debate; Taylor argues that a secular state owes neutrality to every worldview, unbelief included. Late work (2015 to the present) - Retrieving Realism (2015, with Hubert Dreyfus): An argument that we are in contact with the real world from the start, not trapped behind our own mental pictures of it. - The Language Animal: The Full Shape of the Human Linguistic Capacity (2016): Language not merely as a tool for labeling things but as the medium in which human beings find meaning and value. - Avenues of Faith: Conversations with Jonathan Guilbault (2020; French original Les avenues de la foi, 2015): A book of interviews in which Taylor speaks plainly about his own Catholic faith. - Reconstructing Democracy: How Citizens Are Building from the Ground Up (2020, with Patrizia Nanz and Madeleine Beaubien Taylor): How towns that lost their industries have rebuilt civic life from below. - Degenerations of Democracy (2022, with Craig Calhoun and Dilip Parameshwar Gaonkar): Why democracies decay from within when citizens lose the sense that they share a common project, and what might renew it. - Cosmic Connections: Poetry in the Age of Disenchantment (2024): A study of the Romantic and modern poets who sought a meaningful connection to the cosmos after the old enchanted world was gone. Essays that shaped debates: - "Interpretation and the Sciences of Man" (1971): The human sciences have to interpret meanings, and cannot simply measure behavior as physics measures matter. - "What’s Wrong with Negative Liberty" (1979): Freedom is not only the absence of outside interference; it also requires the ability to tell what really matters in one’s life. - "Atomism" (1979): Against the idea that individuals and their rights exist prior to and independent of the society that makes them possible. - "The Politics of Recognition" (1992): Misrecognition can be a real injury, and a liberal society has to think about how it recognizes its cultural minorities. Edited volumes: Church and People: Disjunctions in a Secular Age (2012, with José Casanova and George F. McLean), Boundaries of Toleration (2014, with Alfred Stepan), and a number of collections from the Council for Research in Values and Philosophy. Books published only in other languages: Collections of his essays have appeared in German, French and other languages, among them Erklärung und Interpretation in den Wissenschaften vom Menschen (1975), La liberté des modernes (1997), and Wieviel Gemeinschaft braucht die Demokratie? (2002). For further reading: James K. A. Smith, How (Not) to Be Secular: Reading Charles Taylor (Eerdmans, 2014), is the short and friendly guide to A Secular Age; Ruth Abbey, Charles Taylor (Princeton University Press, 2000), is a careful introduction to the whole body of work.
Playlist
Justified True Belief